101. A cobalt(III) coordination compound has the formula \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_4(H_2O)(CO_3)]Cl}\). The carbonato ligand coordinates through one oxygen donor atom, and all other ligands are unidentate. Which name and coordination number are correct?
ⓐ. Tetraammineaquacarbonatocobaltate(III) chloride; coordination number six
ⓑ. Tetraammineaquacarbonatocobalt(II) chloride; coordination number six
ⓒ. Tetraamminecarbonatodiaquacobalt(III) chloride; coordination number seven
ⓓ. Tetraammineaquacarbonatocobalt(III) chloride; coordination number six
Correct Answer: Tetraammineaquacarbonatocobalt(III) chloride; coordination number six
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpretation of the ligands:}\)
The coordination sphere contains four ammonia molecules, one water molecule and one carbonato ligand.
Ammonia is named ammine, water is named aqua and coordinated carbonate is named carbonato.
The prefixes are determined by ligand multiplicities, giving tetraammine for the four ammonia molecules.
The other ligand types occur once each and require no numerical prefix.
\(\textbf{Alphabetical naming order:}\)
The ligand names are arranged alphabetically as ammine, aqua and carbonato.
Therefore, the ligand portion is tetraammineaquacarbonato.
\(\textbf{Charge verification:}\)
Cobalt has oxidation state \(+3\).
Ammonia and water are neutral ligands.
The carbonato ligand carries charge \(-2\).
Therefore:
\[
q=(+3)+4(0)+1(0)+(-2)
\]
\[
q=+1
\]
One chloride counter ion balances the positively charged coordination entity.
This is consistent with the complete compound formula.
\(\textbf{Coordination-number determination:}\)
The four ammonia molecules contribute four nitrogen donor atoms.
The water molecule contributes one oxygen donor atom.
The carbonato ligand is explicitly stated to use one oxygen donor atom.
Therefore:
\[
CN=4(1)+1(1)+1(1)
\]
\[
CN=6
\]
\(\textbf{Metal-name selection:}\)
The complex is a cation, so the metal is named cobalt rather than cobaltate.
Its oxidation state is represented by III.
Thus, the correct systematic name is tetraammineaquacarbonatocobalt(III) chloride.
The coordination number is six, while the carbonato ligand retains its formal charge of \(-2\).
Ligand charge and denticity must not be confused when determining the name and coordination number.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
CN=6
\]
102. A cobalt(III) compound contains two chloride ligands, two ammonia ligands and one en ligand inside its coordination sphere. The en ligand is neutral and didentate. One chloride ion remains outside the sphere. Which statement correctly describes its coordination formula and naming order?
ⓐ. The ligands are named chlorido, ammine and ethane-1,2-diamine, because chloride carries a negative charge.
ⓑ. The compound has formula \(\mathrm{[CoCl_2(en)(NH_3)_2]Cl_2}\), and the coordinated ligands are named in order of decreasing denticity.
ⓒ. The compound has formula \(\mathrm{[CoCl_2(en)(NH_3)_2]Cl}\), and the ligand names appear in the order ammine, chlorido and ethane-1,2-diamine.
ⓓ. The compound has formula \(\mathrm{[CoCl_2(en)(NH_3)_2]Cl}\), but its name must begin with ethane-1,2-diamine because en is didentate.
Correct Answer: The compound has formula \(\mathrm{[CoCl_2(en)(NH_3)_2]Cl}\), and the ligand names appear in the order ammine, chlorido and ethane-1,2-diamine.
Explanation: The coordination entity contains cobalt(III), two coordinated chloride ions, two ammonia molecules and one en molecule.
The coordinated chloride ions contribute a total charge of \(-2\).
Both ammonia and en are electrically neutral.
Consequently, the coordination entity has charge \(+1\).
One external chloride ion is therefore sufficient for electrical neutrality.
The compound is represented as \(\mathrm{[CoCl_2(en)(NH_3)_2]Cl}\).
In writing the coordination formula, the central metal is placed first.
The ligand formulae are then arranged according to the prescribed formula-ordering convention, including the use of the abbreviation en.
However, the systematic name is constructed using alphabetical order of ligand names rather than their charges or denticities.
The ligand names are ammine, chlorido and ethane-1,2-diamine.
Therefore, the naming order begins with ammine, followed by chlorido and ethane-1,2-diamine.
The complete name is diamminedichlorido(ethane-1,2-diamine)cobalt(III) chloride.
The coordination number is six because two chloride ligands and two ammonia molecules contribute four donor atoms, while en contributes two.
The fact that en is didentate does not give it priority over the other ligands in alphabetical naming.
Similarly, the negative charge of chlorido does not require it to be named before neutral ligands.
This example distinguishes formula ordering, nomenclature ordering, charge balance and coordination-number counting.
103. A mononuclear palladium(II) coordination compound contains one ammonia molecule, one bromido ligand, one chlorido ligand and one nitrogen-bonded nitrite ligand. All four ligands are unidentate, and potassium ions provide electrical neutrality. Which complete formula and systematic name are correct?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{K[Pd(NH_3)BrCl(NO_2)]}\); amminebromidochloridonitrito-N-palladium(II)
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{K_2[Pd(NH_3)BrCl(NO_2)]}\); amminebromidochloridonitrito-N-palladate(II)
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{[Pd(NH_3)BrCl(NO_2)]K}\); amminebromidochloridonitrito-O-palladate(II)
ⓓ. \(\mathrm{K[Pd(NH_3)BrCl(NO_2)]}\); potassium amminebromidochloridonitrito-N-palladate(II)
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{K[Pd(NH_3)BrCl(NO_2)]}\); potassium amminebromidochloridonitrito-N-palladate(II)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Coordination-sphere composition:}\)
Palladium has oxidation state \(+2\).
The ammonia ligand is neutral.
The bromido, chlorido and nitrite ligands each carry charge \(-1\).
All four ligands are unidentate, giving coordination number four.
\(\textbf{Entity-charge calculation:}\)
\[
q=(+2)+0+(-1)+(-1)+(-1)
\]
\[
q=-1
\]
The coordination entity is therefore negatively charged.
One potassium ion balances its charge.
The complete formula is:
\[
\mathrm{K[Pd(NH_3)BrCl(NO_2)]}
\]
The nitrite ligand is specified to coordinate through nitrogen.
\(\textbf{Ligand-name construction:}\)
The ligand names are ammine, bromido, chlorido and nitrito-N.
They are placed alphabetically in that order.
Each ligand occurs once, so multiplicative prefixes are unnecessary.
The coordinated nitrite is distinguished from an oxygen-bonded nitrite ligand by its donor-atom designation.
\(\textbf{Metal name and complete compound name:}\)
Because the coordination entity is anionic, palladium takes the ending -ate, giving palladate.
Its oxidation state is shown as II.
The potassium counter ion is named first.
Thus, the systematic name is potassium amminebromidochloridonitrito-N-palladate(II).
Naming the metal palladium without the -ate ending would ignore the negative charge of the complex.
Using nitrito-O would incorrectly specify oxygen coordination rather than the given nitrogen coordination.
The correct name therefore combines ligand identity, donor-specific notation, alphabetical ordering and charge-dependent metal nomenclature.
104. A square-planar platinum(II) coordination entity contains four different unidentate ligands: one ammonia molecule, one water molecule, one bromido ligand and one chlorido ligand. Its formula is \(\mathrm{[Pt(NH_3)(H_2O)BrCl]}\). No information about the relative ligand positions is initially supplied. Which statement is correct?
ⓐ. Its systematic base name specifies one unique geometrical isomer because all four ligands are different.
ⓑ. Its systematic base name identifies the ligand composition, but the four different ligands permit three geometrical arrangements.
ⓒ. The presence of four different ligands makes the entity chiral, so only two optical isomers are possible.
ⓓ. Its coordination formula uniquely identifies the trans arrangement because platinum(II) is square planar.
Correct Answer: Its systematic base name identifies the ligand composition, but the four different ligands permit three geometrical arrangements.
Explanation: The coordination entity contains platinum(II), two neutral ligands and two negatively charged ligands.
Ammonia and water contribute zero charge, while bromido and chlorido contribute \(-1\) each.
Therefore, the complete coordination entity is electrically neutral.
Its coordination number is four because all four ligands are unidentate.
The systematic base name is ammineaquabromidochloridoplatinum(II).
This name identifies the metal oxidation state and the chemical identities of all coordinated ligands.
However, it does not by itself specify their relative positions around the square-planar metal centre.
In a square-planar entity containing four different unidentate ligands, three distinct geometrical arrangements are possible.
For example, ammonia may be opposite water, bromido or chlorido, giving three distinct choices of trans partner.
Once the ligand opposite ammonia is specified, the remaining two positions determine the other trans pair.
Interchanging the two remaining positions does not create an additional geometrical isomer because the resulting arrangement can be related by a suitable spatial symmetry operation.
Consequently, there are three distinct geometrical arrangements rather than six permutations or only one arrangement.
These square-planar arrangements do not exhibit ordinary optical isomerism merely because the four ligand identities are different.
Thus, the base coordination name establishes composition but does not uniquely identify one of the three geometrical arrangements.
An appropriate stereochemical descriptor or unambiguous spatial description is needed to specify a particular form.
105. Two coordination salts contain the same tris(ethane-1,2-diamine)iron coordination framework. In compound P, the metal is iron(III) and chloride is the counter ion. In compound Q, the metal is iron(II) and sulphate is the counter ion. Assume all en ligands are neutral and didentate, and both compounds dissociate ideally without ligand loss. Which statement correctly compares their formulae and ionic-species counts?
ⓐ. P is \(\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3]Cl_3}\), Q is \(\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3]SO_4}\), and P gives twice as many ionic species per formula unit as Q.
ⓑ. P is \(\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3]Cl_2}\), Q is \(\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3]SO_4}\), and both give three ionic species per formula unit.
ⓒ. P is \(\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3]Cl_3}\), Q is \(\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3](SO_4)_2}\), and P gives four ionic species per formula unit.
ⓓ. P is \(\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3]Cl}\), Q is \(\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3]SO_4}\), and Q gives twice as many ionic species per formula unit as P.
Correct Answer: P is \(\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3]Cl_3}\), Q is \(\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3]SO_4}\), and P gives twice as many ionic species per formula unit as Q.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Coordination framework:}\)
Both compounds contain three neutral en ligands.
Each en ligand coordinates through two nitrogen donor atoms.
Therefore:
\[
CN=3(2)=6
\]
The coordination number is the same in both compounds.
\(\textbf{Compound P:}\)
Iron has oxidation state \(+3\).
All three en ligands are neutral.
Hence, the coordination entity carries charge \(+3\).
Three chloride ions are required to balance this charge.
The complete formula is:
\[
\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3]Cl_3}
\]
Its ideal dissociation is:
\[
\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3]Cl_3\longrightarrow[Fe(en)_3]^{3+}+3Cl^-}
\]
Thus:
\[
N_P=1+3=4
\]
\(\textbf{Compound Q:}\)
Iron has oxidation state \(+2\).
The coordination entity therefore carries charge \(+2\).
One sulphate ion, carrying charge \(-2\), balances the complex cation.
The complete formula is:
\[
\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3]SO_4}
\]
Its ideal dissociation is:
\[
\mathrm{[Fe(en)_3]SO_4\longrightarrow[Fe(en)_3]^{2+}+SO_4^{2-}}
\]
Thus:
\[
N_Q=1+1=2
\]
\(\textbf{Comparison:}\)
The number of ionic species produced per formula unit is:
\[
\frac{N_P}{N_Q}=\frac{4}{2}=2
\]
Both compounds retain the same coordination number and ligand multiplicity.
However, their metal oxidation states and counter-ion charges differ.
The names tris(ethane-1,2-diamine)iron(III) chloride and tris(ethane-1,2-diamine)iron(II) sulphate therefore correspond to different ionic formulations.
The multiplicative prefix tris refers to three en ligand molecules in each compound, not to the ionic-species count.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\frac{N_P}{N_Q}=2}
\]
106. Consider the following proposed formula–name–coordination-number combinations.
| Option | Coordination formula | Proposed systematic name | Proposed coordination number |
| A | \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_4(C_2O_4)]Cl}\) | Tetraammineoxalatocobalt(III) chloride | 6 |
| B | \(\mathrm{K_2[Ni(CN)_4]}\) | Potassium tetracyanidonickel(II) | 4 |
| C | \(\mathrm{[Cr(en)_3]Cl_3}\) | Hexa(ethane-1,2-diamine)chromium(III) chloride | 6 |
| D | \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_5Cl]Cl_2}\) | Pentaamminechloridocobalt(II) chloride | 6 |
Which option is fully consistent with the formula, nomenclature and coordination-number rules?
ⓐ. Option A
ⓑ. Option B
ⓒ. Option C
ⓓ. Option D
Correct Answer: Option A
Explanation: In option A, cobalt is in oxidation state \(+3\).
The four ammonia molecules are neutral, while the oxalato ligand carries charge \(-2\).
The coordination entity therefore has charge \(+1\), balanced by one external chloride ion.
The oxalato ligand is didentate, so four ammonia donor atoms and two oxalato donor atoms give coordination number six.
The ligand names are tetraammine and oxalato, arranged alphabetically.
Therefore, tetraammineoxalatocobalt(III) chloride is consistent with the formula.
Option B has the correct coordination number because four cyanido ligands coordinate to nickel.
However, the bracketed entity is negatively charged, so the metal must be named nickelate rather than nickel.
The correct name is potassium tetracyanidonickelate(II).
Option C also has coordination number six, but it contains only three en ligand molecules.
The prefix hexa incorrectly counts the six nitrogen donor atoms as six complete en ligands.
The appropriate name is tris(ethane-1,2-diamine)chromium(III) chloride.
Option D contains one coordinated chloride ligand and two chloride counter ions.
The resulting coordination-entity charge is \(+2\), so cobalt must have oxidation state \(+3\), not \(+2\).
Its correct name is pentaamminechloridocobalt(III) chloride.
Thus, only option A satisfies all three requirements simultaneously.
The exercise illustrates why a correct coordination number alone does not establish that the corresponding systematic name is correct.
107. A metal ion \(\mathrm{M^{3+}}\) forms the coordination entity \(\mathrm{[M(NH_3)_2(C_2O_4)_2]^-}\). A second entity is obtained by replacing one oxalato ligand with two neutral ammonia molecules, while the metal oxidation state remains unchanged and all donor atoms specified remain coordinated. Which statement correctly describes the resulting ligand-name multiplicities, coordination-entity charge and coordination number?
ⓐ. The product contains tetraammine and monooxalato, has charge \(+1\), and coordination number six.
ⓑ. The product contains diammine and oxalato, has charge \(+1\), and coordination number four.
ⓒ. The product contains tetraammine and dioxalato, has charge \(-1\), and coordination number eight.
ⓓ. The product contains tetraammine and oxalato, has charge \(+1\), and coordination number six.
Correct Answer: The product contains tetraammine and oxalato, has charge \(+1\), and coordination number six.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Initial coordination composition:}\)
The original entity contains two neutral ammonia molecules and two didentate oxalato ligands.
The oxalato ligands each carry charge \(-2\).
Therefore:
\[
q_{\mathrm{initial}}=(+3)+2(0)+2(-2)
\]
\[
q_{\mathrm{initial}}=-1
\]
The coordination number is:
\[
CN_{\mathrm{initial}}=2(1)+2(2)=6
\]
\(\textbf{Ligand replacement:}\)
One oxalato ligand is removed and two ammonia molecules enter the coordination sphere.
The removed oxalato ligand contributes two oxygen donor atoms.
The two entering ammonia molecules collectively contribute two nitrogen donor atoms.
Thus, the total number of donor attachments remains unchanged.
\(\textbf{Resulting ligand composition:}\)
The original entity contains two ammonia molecules.
After two additional ammonia molecules enter, the total becomes four.
One oxalato ligand remains coordinated.
The resulting entity is:
\[
\mathrm{[M(NH_3)_4(C_2O_4)]^+}
\]
\(\textbf{Charge calculation:}\)
The metal retains oxidation state \(+3\).
Four ammonia molecules contribute zero formal charge.
One oxalato ligand contributes charge \(-2\).
Therefore:
\[
q_{\mathrm{final}}=(+3)+4(0)+(-2)
\]
\[
q_{\mathrm{final}}=+1
\]
\(\textbf{Coordination-number verification:}\)
Four ammonia molecules contribute four donor attachments.
One didentate oxalato ligand contributes two.
Thus:
\[
CN_{\mathrm{final}}=4(1)+1(2)=6
\]
\(\textbf{Nomenclature consequence:}\)
Four coordinated ammonia molecules require the prefix tetra, giving tetraammine.
One oxalato ligand is named oxalato without an additional multiplicative prefix.
The ligand-name portion is therefore tetraammineoxalato.
The metal name retains its ordinary form because the resulting entity is cationic.
The replacement simultaneously changes ligand multiplicities and reverses the sign of the coordination-entity charge while conserving coordination number.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
q_{\mathrm{final}}=+1,\quad CN_{\mathrm{final}}=6
\]
108. A coordination compound is described by the systematic name potassium diaquadicyanidoferrate(II). Assume each coordinated water and cyanido ligand is unidentate. A student proposes the formula \(\mathrm{K_2[Fe(H_2O)_2(CN)_2]}\). Which statement correctly evaluates the proposed formula and the stated name?
ⓐ. The formula is correct because two coordinated cyanido ligands require two potassium counter ions.
ⓑ. The formula is incorrect because the coordination entity is neutral; the name cannot correctly include potassium as a counter ion.
ⓒ. The formula is incorrect because iron must have oxidation state \(+4\) to balance the two cyanido ligands.
ⓓ. The formula is correct, but the coordination number is six because water contains two hydrogen atoms.
Correct Answer: The formula is incorrect because the coordination entity is neutral; the name cannot correctly include potassium as a counter ion.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpretation of the named coordination entity:}\)
The name specifies iron in oxidation state \(+2\).
Two aqua ligands and two cyanido ligands are directly coordinated.
Each aqua ligand is neutral.
Each cyanido ligand carries charge \(-1\).
\(\textbf{Entity-charge calculation:}\)
\[
q=(+2)+2(0)+2(-1)
\]
\[
q=2-2=0
\]
Therefore, the bracketed coordination entity is electrically neutral.
\(\textbf{Counter-ion consistency:}\)
A neutral coordination entity does not require potassium ions to balance its charge.
The proposed formula includes two potassium ions outside the coordination sphere.
Those ions contribute a total charge of \(+2\).
Because no corresponding anionic component is present, the proposed formula violates electrical neutrality.
Therefore, \(\mathrm{K_2[Fe(H_2O)_2(CN)_2]}\) is not a valid neutral salt formulation under the stated assumptions.
\(\textbf{Correct coordination formulation:}\)
The coordination entity itself may be represented as:
\[
\mathrm{[Fe(H_2O)_2(CN)_2]}
\]
Its systematic base name is diaquadicyanidoiron(II).
The neutral entity uses iron rather than ferrate in its name.
\(\textbf{Coordination-number verification:}\)
Two water molecules contribute two oxygen donor atoms.
Two cyanido ligands contribute two carbon donor atoms.
Hence:
\[
CN=2(1)+2(1)=4
\]
The coordination number is four, not six.
The crucial error is not the number of coordinated ligands but the assumption that any coordination entity containing negatively charged ligands must itself be an anion.
The positive metal oxidation state can exactly balance the ligand charges, producing a neutral coordination entity.
Therefore, both the proposed potassium-containing formula and the corresponding anionic-complex name are inconsistent with the specified composition.
109. Consider the following statements about isomerism in coordination compounds.
Statement I: Structural isomers may differ in the identities of atoms directly bonded to the central metal.
Statement II: Geometrical isomers must differ in the total numbers of coordinated ligand molecules.
Statement III: Optical isomers have the same coordination connectivity but are non-superimposable mirror images.
Statement IV: Two coordination compounds having different overall elemental compositions can be classified as linkage isomers if both contain ambidentate ligands.
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. Statements I, II and III only
ⓑ. Statements I and III only
ⓒ. Statements II, III and IV only
ⓓ. Statements I, III and IV only
Correct Answer: Statements I and III only
Explanation: Statement I is correct because structural isomerism involves a difference in chemical bonding or coordination connectivity while the overall chemical composition remains unchanged.
For example, linkage isomers differ in the donor atom through which an ambidentate ligand attaches to the central metal.
Ionisation and coordination isomerism provide other examples involving changes in the distribution of coordinated groups.
Statement II is incorrect because geometrical isomers retain the same chemical formula and ligand composition.
Their difference concerns the relative spatial positions occupied by ligands around the metal.
The cis and trans forms of a suitable square-planar or octahedral complex illustrate this distinction.
Statement III is correct because optical isomers are non-superimposable mirror images.
They possess the same relevant bonding connectivity but differ in their three-dimensional arrangements.
Such mirror-image stereoisomers are called enantiomers.
Statement IV is incorrect because isomers must have the same overall chemical composition.
The presence of an ambidentate ligand in two unrelated compounds does not make them linkage isomers.
For linkage isomerism, an appropriate change in donor-atom attachment must occur without changing the overall composition.
Thus, Statements I and III correctly distinguish structural isomerism from stereoisomerism.
110. Two cobalt(III) compounds P and Q have the same overall composition, \(\mathrm{Co(NH_3)_5BrSO_4}\). Their coordination formulae are:
P: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_5(SO_4)]Br}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_5Br]SO_4}\)
Assume that under the stated rapid precipitation-test conditions, the coordination spheres remain intact. Which observation and ionic-species comparison are simultaneously correct?
ⓐ. P gives an immediate \(\mathrm{BaSO_4}\) precipitate, Q gives \(\mathrm{AgBr}\), and both produce three ions per formula unit.
ⓑ. P gives an immediate \(\mathrm{AgBr}\) precipitate, Q gives \(\mathrm{BaSO_4}\), and P produces more ions than Q.
ⓒ. P gives an immediate \(\mathrm{AgBr}\) precipitate, Q gives \(\mathrm{BaSO_4}\), and both produce two ions per formula unit.
ⓓ. Neither produces an immediate precipitate with these reagents because both bromide and sulphate are coordinated.
Correct Answer: P gives an immediate \(\mathrm{AgBr}\) precipitate, Q gives \(\mathrm{BaSO_4}\), and both produce two ions per formula unit.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Coordination sphere of P:}\)
P contains five neutral ammonia ligands and one coordinated sulphato ligand.
Cobalt has oxidation state \(+3\), while coordinated sulphate contributes charge \(-2\).
Therefore:
\[
q_P=(+3)+5(0)+(-2)=+1
\]
One bromide ion occurs outside the coordination sphere.
Its ideal dissociation is:
\[
\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_5(SO_4)]Br\longrightarrow[Co(NH_3)_5(SO_4)]^++Br^-}
\]
The free bromide counter ion can produce \(\mathrm{AgBr}\) with silver ions.
The coordinated sulphato ligand is not treated as a freely dissociated sulphate ion under the stated conditions.
\(\textbf{Coordination sphere of Q:}\)
Q contains five ammonia ligands and one coordinated bromido ligand.
Its coordination-entity charge is:
\[
q_Q=(+3)+5(0)+(-1)=+2
\]
One sulphate ion occurs outside the coordination sphere.
The dissociation is:
\[
\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_5Br]SO_4\longrightarrow[Co(NH_3)_5Br]^{2+}+SO_4^{2-}}
\]
The free sulphate counter ion can produce \(\mathrm{BaSO_4}\) with barium ions.
\(\textbf{Isomerism and ionic comparison:}\)
The two compounds have the same overall composition but differ in which anion occurs inside the coordination sphere.
They are therefore ionisation isomers.
P releases bromide as its counter ion, whereas Q releases sulphate.
Each compound nevertheless dissociates into one complex cation and one simple anion.
Thus, both produce two ionic species per formula unit.
Their different precipitation behaviour is more informative than their identical ideal ionic-species counts.
The key distinction is the identity of the external counter ion, not the total number of ions produced.
111. Three hydrated chromium(III) chloride compounds have the same empirical composition, \(\mathrm{CrCl_3\cdot6H_2O}\). An unknown sample X produces one mole of \(\mathrm{AgCl}\) per mole of compound under the usual Werner precipitation conditions. Independent structural information establishes that chromium has coordination number six and that exactly two water molecules occur outside its coordination sphere. Which formula and ideal ionic-species count are consistent with these observations?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_4Cl_2]Cl\cdot2H_2O}\); two ionic species
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_5Cl]Cl_2\cdot H_2O}\); three ionic species
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_6]Cl_3}\); four ionic species
ⓓ. \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_3Cl_3]\cdot3H_2O}\); one molecular species
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_4Cl_2]Cl\cdot2H_2O}\); two ionic species
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpretation of chloride precipitation:}\)
The empirical composition contains three chloride ions per chromium atom.
One mole of \(\mathrm{AgCl}\) per mole of compound indicates one chloride counter ion under the specified conditions.
Therefore, two chloride ions must remain coordinated to chromium.
\(\textbf{Distribution of water molecules:}\)
The empirical formula contains six water molecules.
Two are stated to occur outside the coordination sphere.
The remaining number of coordinated water molecules is:
\[
N_{\mathrm{coordinated\ water}}=6-2
\]
\[
N_{\mathrm{coordinated\ water}}=4
\]
\(\textbf{Construction of the coordination entity:}\)
Four water molecules and two chloride ions are directly coordinated.
All are unidentate in the stated arrangement.
Hence:
\[
CN=4(1)+2(1)=6
\]
This agrees with the specified coordination number.
\(\textbf{Charge verification:}\)
Chromium has oxidation state \(+3\).
The four coordinated water molecules are neutral.
The two coordinated chloride ions contribute charge \(-2\).
Therefore:
\[
q=(+3)+4(0)+2(-1)
\]
\[
q=+1
\]
One external chloride ion is sufficient for electrical neutrality.
The complete formula is:
\[
\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_4Cl_2]Cl\cdot2H_2O}
\]
\(\textbf{Ideal dissociation:}\)
\[
\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_4Cl_2]Cl\longrightarrow[Cr(H_2O)_4Cl_2]^++Cl^-}
\]
One complex cation and one chloride anion are produced.
The two waters of crystallisation are not counted as ionic species.
Therefore, the ideal ionic-species count is two.
The observations collectively identify the third conventional hydrate arrangement of this empirical composition.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{N_{\mathrm{coordinated\ H_2O}}=4,\quad N_{\mathrm{external\ Cl^-}}=1,\quad N_{\mathrm{ions}}=2}
\]
112. The octahedral coordination entity \(\mathrm{[Co(en)_2Cl_2]^+}\) contains two didentate en ligands and two chloride ligands. Both en ligands form their normal chelate rings. If optical enantiomers are counted separately, what are the numbers of geometrical classes and total distinct stereoisomers, respectively?
ⓐ. Two geometrical classes and two stereoisomers
ⓑ. Three geometrical classes and three stereoisomers
ⓒ. Two geometrical classes and four stereoisomers
ⓓ. Two geometrical classes and three stereoisomers
Correct Answer: Two geometrical classes and three stereoisomers
Explanation: \(\textbf{Possible geometrical arrangements:}\)
The two chloride ligands can occupy adjacent or opposite octahedral positions.
Adjacent chloride ligands give the cis arrangement.
Opposite chloride ligands give the trans arrangement.
Therefore, there are two geometrical classes.
\(\textbf{Optical behaviour of the cis form:}\)
The cis arrangement contains two en chelate rings and two adjacent chloride ligands.
Its three-dimensional chelate arrangement can exist in two non-superimposable mirror-image forms.
These forms constitute one enantiomeric pair.
Thus, the cis geometrical class contributes two distinct stereoisomers.
\(\textbf{Optical behaviour of the trans form:}\)
In the trans arrangement, the chloride ligands occupy opposite octahedral positions.
For this standard symmetrical complex, the trans arrangement is achiral.
Its mirror image is superimposable on the original structure.
Therefore, the trans class contributes one stereoisomer.
\(\textbf{Total stereoisomer count:}\)
\[
N_{\mathrm{geometrical\ classes}}=2
\]
\[
N_{\mathrm{stereoisomers}}=2_{\mathrm{cis}}+1_{\mathrm{trans}}
\]
\[
N_{\mathrm{stereoisomers}}=3
\]
The number of geometrical classes is therefore not the same as the total number of stereoisomers.
Counting only cis and trans would omit the optical distinction within the cis class.
Conversely, assigning an enantiomeric pair to the trans form would incorrectly treat an achiral structure as chiral.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
There are two geometrical classes and three distinct stereoisomers.
113. A pure sample of one optical isomer of \(\mathrm{[Co(en)_3]^{3+}}\) rotates plane-polarised light clockwise, while its mirror-image isomer rotates it anticlockwise by the same magnitude under identical measurement conditions. A solution is prepared containing equal amounts of these two enantiomers. Which conclusion is correct?
ⓐ. The solution shows zero net optical rotation even though both constituent coordination entities are chiral.
ⓑ. The solution rotates plane-polarised light clockwise because the cobalt centre has oxidation state \(+3\).
ⓒ. The solution becomes a new achiral coordination entity because the two enantiomers combine chemically.
ⓓ. The solution shows twice the rotation of either pure enantiomer because both contain three chelate rings.
Correct Answer: The solution shows zero net optical rotation even though both constituent coordination entities are chiral.
Explanation: Optical isomers are non-superimposable mirror images called enantiomers.
The two forms of \(\mathrm{[Co(en)_3]^{3+}}\) arise from the three-dimensional arrangement of its three didentate en ligands.
Each en ligand forms a chelate ring, and the complete arrangement can possess opposite handedness.
The two pure enantiomers rotate plane-polarised light in opposite directions under identical conditions.
For equal concentrations and identical optical paths, their specific contributions to the observed rotation have equal magnitudes and opposite signs.
When equal amounts are mixed, these rotations cancel.
The resulting mixture is called a racemic mixture.
A racemic mixture shows zero net optical rotation even though its individual molecular or ionic components remain chiral.
The enantiomers do not need to react chemically with each other for the cancellation to occur.
The oxidation state of cobalt also does not determine the direction of optical rotation.
A zero optical rotation therefore does not necessarily imply that every chemical species in the solution is achiral.
This distinction is essential when interpreting the optical behaviour of coordination compounds and their enantiomeric mixtures.
114. Consider the coordination salts P and Q:
P: \(\mathrm{[Co(en)_3][Cr(C_2O_4)_3]}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Cr(en)_3][Co(C_2O_4)_3]}\)
Both metals are in oxidation state \(+3\). Each en ligand is neutral and didentate, while each oxalato ligand has charge \(-2\) and is didentate. Which statement correctly describes the relationship between P and Q?
ⓐ. They are ionisation isomers because their external counter ions are different.
ⓑ. They are linkage isomers because en coordinates through nitrogen and oxalate through oxygen.
ⓒ. They are coordination isomers because the ligand groups are redistributed between the two metal centres.
ⓓ. They are geometrical isomers because the same metal–ligand bonds have different spatial orientations.
Correct Answer: They are coordination isomers because the ligand groups are redistributed between the two metal centres.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Coordination entities in P:}\)
The first entity contains cobalt(III) coordinated to three neutral en ligands.
Its charge is \(+3\).
The second entity contains chromium(III) coordinated to three oxalato ligands.
Its charge is:
\[
q_{\mathrm{Cr(ox)_3}}=(+3)+3(-2)=-3
\]
Therefore, the two entities combine in a \(1:1\) ratio to give an electrically neutral salt.
\(\textbf{Coordination entities in Q:}\)
In Q, the en ligands are attached to chromium(III) instead of cobalt(III).
The oxalato ligands are attached to cobalt(III) instead of chromium(III).
The charges of the new complex cation and anion remain \(+3\) and \(-3\), respectively.
\(\textbf{Overall composition:}\)
Both compounds contain one cobalt atom, one chromium atom, three en ligands and three oxalato ligands.
Their overall chemical compositions are therefore identical.
\(\textbf{Change in coordination connectivity:}\)
The essential difference is which metal is coordinated by which ligand type.
In P, cobalt is coordinated by en and chromium by oxalate.
In Q, chromium is coordinated by en and cobalt by oxalate.
This redistribution of ligands between complex cationic and anionic entities containing different metal centres is coordination isomerism.
It differs from ionisation isomerism, which involves an interchange between a coordinated ligand and an external counter ion.
It also differs from linkage isomerism, where an ambidentate ligand changes its donor atom.
Both salts retain octahedral coordination numbers of six around each metal.
The isomerism consequently arises from a change in metal–ligand connectivity rather than a change in coordination number or overall composition.
115. Two octahedral entities P and Q each contain three ammonia ligands and three chloride ligands coordinated to a trivalent metal M. All six ligands are unidentate. The following geometrical information is supplied.
| Entity | Number of ammonia–M–ammonia angles equal to \(180^\circ\) | Number of ammonia–M–ammonia angles equal to \(90^\circ\) |
| P | 0 | 3 |
| Q | 1 | 2 |
Which statement correctly identifies the geometrical arrangements?
ⓐ. P is meridional and Q is facial; both entities have charge zero.
ⓑ. Both are meridional because each contains one set of three identical ligands.
ⓒ. Both are facial because each contains three ammonia ligands.
ⓓ. P is facial and Q is meridional; both entities have charge zero.
Correct Answer: P is facial and Q is meridional; both entities have charge zero.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpretation of the octahedral angles:}\)
In an octahedral complex, adjacent coordination positions subtend angles of \(90^\circ\).
Opposite positions subtend angles of \(180^\circ\).
Three ammonia ligands generate three distinct ammonia–metal–ammonia pairs.
Their relative angles can therefore be used to distinguish facial from meridional arrangements.
\(\textbf{Identification of P:}\)
In P, all three ammonia–metal–ammonia angles are \(90^\circ\).
Therefore, every ammonia pair occupies adjacent positions.
The three ammonia donor atoms consequently lie at the corners of one triangular face of the octahedron.
P is the facial isomer.
\(\textbf{Identification of Q:}\)
In Q, one ammonia pair occupies opposite positions, giving an angle of \(180^\circ\).
The remaining two ammonia pairs occupy adjacent positions.
This is characteristic of the meridional arrangement.
Hence, Q is the meridional isomer.
\(\textbf{Charge verification:}\)
The central metal has oxidation state \(+3\).
All ammonia ligands are neutral, while the three coordinated chlorides contribute charge \(-3\).
Therefore:
\[
q=(+3)+3(0)+3(-1)=0
\]
Both coordination entities are neutral.
The facial–meridional distinction therefore does not require any change in metal oxidation state or coordination-entity charge.
The decisive evidence is the distribution of the pairwise angular relationships among the three identical ligands.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
P is facial, Q is meridional, and both coordination entities are neutral.
116. An octahedral cobalt(III) coordination entity has the composition \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_4(NO_2)_2]^+}\). Each nitrite ligand can independently coordinate through nitrogen or oxygen, and both nitrite ligands are unidentate in every arrangement. Assume that all such donor attachments are permitted and count distinct geometrical and linkage arrangements, but not optical isomers. How many distinct structures are possible?
ⓐ. Four
ⓑ. Five
ⓒ. Eight
ⓓ. Six
Correct Answer: Six
Explanation: \(\textbf{Possible donor-atom combinations:}\)
Nitrite is an ambidentate ligand capable of coordinating through nitrogen or oxygen.
The coordination entity contains two nitrite ligands.
Both may coordinate through nitrogen, both may coordinate through oxygen, or one may coordinate through nitrogen while the other coordinates through oxygen.
These give three distinct linkage-composition patterns:
\[
\mathrm{(N,N),\quad(N,O),\quad(O,O)}
\]
The arrangements \(\mathrm{(N,O)}\) and \(\mathrm{(O,N)}\) are not separate linkage-composition patterns because the two nitrite ligands are chemically identical before donor attachment.
\(\textbf{Geometrical possibilities:}\)
Four ammonia ligands occupy four of the six octahedral positions.
The two nitrite ligands occupy the remaining two positions.
For each linkage-composition pattern, the two nitrite donor groups may occupy adjacent or opposite positions.
These correspond to cis and trans geometrical arrangements.
\(\textbf{Counting distinct structures:}\)
For the N,N linkage pattern, there are cis and trans arrangements.
For the O,O linkage pattern, there are also cis and trans arrangements.
For the mixed N,O linkage pattern, the differently bonded nitrite groups can likewise occupy adjacent or opposite positions.
Thus:
\[
N_{\mathrm{structures}}=2+2+2
\]
\[
N_{\mathrm{structures}}=6
\]
\(\textbf{Chemical consistency:}\)
The cobalt oxidation state is \(+3\).
Each nitrite ligand contributes charge \(-1\), regardless of the donor atom used.
All six structures therefore have coordination-entity charge \(+1\).
The coordination number also remains six because every ammonia and nitrite ligand contributes one donor attachment.
The structural differences arise from the independent possibilities of donor-atom selection and geometrical arrangement.
The count excludes additional distinctions that were not requested.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{N_{\mathrm{structures}}=6}
\]
117. Four square-planar arrangements P, Q, R and S contain a central metal M and four different unidentate ligands A, B, C and D. Their positions are specified below, with the coordination positions lying along the positive and negative \(x\) and \(y\) axes.
| Arrangement | \(+x\) | \(+y\) | \(-x\) | \(-y\) |
| P | A | B | C | D |
| Q | D | A | B | C |
| R | A | C | B | D |
| S | A | B | D | C |
Which conclusion is correct after allowing rigid rotations of the complete square-planar entity?
ⓐ. P and Q are equivalent, while R and S represent two other geometrical arrangements.
ⓑ. P and R are equivalent, while Q and S represent two other geometrical arrangements.
ⓒ. Q and S are equivalent, while P and R represent two other geometrical arrangements.
ⓓ. All four are distinct because none has identical ligand labels at corresponding axes.
Correct Answer: P and Q are equivalent, while R and S represent two other geometrical arrangements.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Criterion for geometrical equivalence:}\)
Two spatial descriptions do not necessarily represent different coordination isomers merely because the ligands are assigned different Cartesian directions.
A rigid rotation of the complete coordination entity does not alter its chemical identity.
For square-planar complexes with four different unidentate ligands, the identities of opposite ligand pairs provide a convenient equivalence test.
\(\textbf{Arrangement P:}\)
Ligand A is opposite C.
Ligand B is opposite D.
Therefore, the two trans pairs are A–C and B–D.
\(\textbf{Arrangement Q:}\)
Ligand A occupies \(+y\), while C occupies \(-y\).
Thus, A and C remain opposite.
Similarly, B and D occupy opposite \(x\)-axis positions.
Q has the same two trans pairs as P.
A quarter-turn rotation of P produces Q.
Therefore, P and Q are equivalent.
\(\textbf{Arrangement R:}\)
A and B occupy opposite \(x\)-axis positions.
C and D occupy opposite \(y\)-axis positions.
Its trans pairs are A–B and C–D.
This differs from P and Q.
\(\textbf{Arrangement S:}\)
A and D occupy opposite \(x\)-axis positions.
B and C occupy opposite \(y\)-axis positions.
Its trans pairs are A–D and B–C.
This is different from both previous trans-pair patterns.
\(\textbf{Final comparison:}\)
P and Q describe the same geometrical arrangement.
R and S describe the remaining two geometrical arrangements.
Thus, the four coordinate descriptions represent only three distinct square-planar geometrical structures.
The result illustrates why molecular rotations must be considered before counting isomers.
118. Three isolated chromium(III) compounds P, Q and R all have the empirical composition \(\mathrm{CrCl_3\cdot6H_2O}\). Their structures are specified as follows:
P: cis-\(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_4Cl_2]Cl\cdot2H_2O}\)
Q: trans-\(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_4Cl_2]Cl\cdot2H_2O}\)
R: \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_5Cl]Cl_2\cdot H_2O}\)
Which statement correctly identifies the isomeric relationships?
ⓐ. P and Q are hydrate isomers, whereas P and R are geometrical isomers.
ⓑ. All three are geometrical isomers because chromium has coordination number six in each.
ⓒ. P and Q are geometrical isomers, whereas P and R are hydrate isomers.
ⓓ. All three are linkage isomers because chloride and water have different donor atoms.
Correct Answer: P and Q are geometrical isomers, whereas P and R are hydrate isomers.
Explanation: All three compounds have the same overall empirical composition.
This satisfies the essential compositional requirement for isomerism.
In P and Q, four water molecules and two chloride ions are directly coordinated to chromium.
Both compounds also contain one external chloride counter ion and two waters of crystallisation.
Their coordination connectivity is therefore identical.
However, P has its two coordinated chlorides in adjacent positions, while Q has them in opposite positions.
They consequently represent cis and trans geometrical isomers.
The relationship between P and R is different.
P contains four coordinated water molecules, two coordinated chloride ions and two waters outside the coordination sphere.
R contains five coordinated water molecules, one coordinated chloride ion and one water molecule outside the coordination sphere.
The numbers of directly coordinated water and chloride ligands therefore differ.
This change in the distribution of water between the coordination sphere and the crystal lattice is hydrate isomerism.
Hydrate isomerism is a water-containing form of solvate isomerism and belongs to structural isomerism.
The external chloride counts also differ, giving different ideal ionisation behaviour under ordinary dissolution.
Thus, geometrical and hydrate isomerism can describe different relationships among compounds sharing the same empirical composition.
The appropriate classification depends on whether the difference concerns spatial ligand positions or coordination connectivity.
119. Three cobalt(III) compounds contain the same total numbers of cobalt, ammonia, nitrogen, oxygen and sulphur atoms:
P: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_5(NO_2)]SO_4}\), with nitrite coordinated through nitrogen
Q: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_5(ONO)]SO_4}\), with nitrite coordinated through oxygen
R: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_5(SO_4)]NO_2}\), with sulphate coordinated and nitrite acting as the counter ion
Which statement correctly describes their isomeric relationships?
ⓐ. P and Q are ionisation isomers, while P and R are linkage isomers.
ⓑ. P and Q are linkage isomers, while P and R are ionisation isomers.
ⓒ. All three are linkage isomers because each contains a nitrite ion.
ⓓ. All three are geometrical isomers because each contains six coordinated ligand groups.
Correct Answer: P and Q are linkage isomers, while P and R are ionisation isomers.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Comparison of P and Q:}\)
Both compounds contain five coordinated ammonia molecules and one coordinated nitrite ligand.
The sulphate ion occurs outside the coordination sphere in both cases.
In P, nitrite is attached to cobalt through nitrogen.
In Q, nitrite is attached through oxygen.
Therefore, the two structures differ in the donor atom of the same ambidentate ligand.
P and Q are linkage isomers.
\(\textbf{Comparison of P and R:}\)
In P, nitrite is coordinated and sulphate acts as the external counter ion.
In R, sulphate is coordinated and nitrite acts as the external counter ion.
This involves an interchange between a coordinated ligand and a potential ligand functioning as a counter ion.
The corresponding relationship is ionisation isomerism.
\(\textbf{Charge verification:}\)
For P and Q:
\[
q=(+3)+5(0)+(-1)=+2
\]
The resulting complex cation is balanced by one sulphate ion.
For R:
\[
q=(+3)+5(0)+(-2)=+1
\]
The resulting complex cation is balanced by one nitrite ion.
All three compounds are electrically neutral overall.
\(\textbf{Coordination-number consistency:}\)
The five ammonia molecules contribute five donor atoms.
One nitrite or one coordinated sulphato group contributes the sixth donor attachment in the specified monodentate arrangements.
Thus, each cobalt centre has coordination number six.
The same overall composition therefore supports two different structural-isomer relationships.
The classification depends on whether donor-atom selection changes within a coordinated ligand or an exchange occurs between coordinated and external ions.
120. An octahedral coordination entity \(\mathrm{[Fe(NH_3)_2(CN)_4]^-}\) contains two neutral ammonia ligands and four carbon-bonded cyanido ligands. All ligands are monodentate. Which statement correctly combines its oxidation state, metal-name form and geometrical-isomer possibilities?
ⓐ. Iron(II), ferrate naming and two geometrical isomers
ⓑ. Iron(III), iron naming and one geometrical arrangement
ⓒ. Iron(II), iron naming and one geometrical arrangement
ⓓ. Iron(III), ferrate naming and two geometrical isomers
Correct Answer: Iron(III), ferrate naming and two geometrical isomers
Explanation: \(\textbf{Oxidation-state determination:}\)
The coordination entity carries charge \(-1\).
Each ammonia ligand is neutral.
Each cyanido ligand carries charge \(-1\).
Let the oxidation state of iron be \(x\).
\[
x+2(0)+4(-1)=-1
\]
\[
x-4=-1
\]
\[
x=+3
\]
Thus, iron has oxidation state \(+3\).
\(\textbf{Metal-name selection:}\)
The coordination entity is negatively charged.
Therefore, iron takes the established anionic-complex name ferrate.
The oxidation state is represented by the Roman numeral III.
The corresponding coordination-entity name is diamminetetracyanidoferrate(III).
\(\textbf{Geometrical possibilities:}\)
The entity has coordination number six and octahedral geometry.
Two ammonia ligands occupy two of the six coordination positions.
They may occupy adjacent positions, producing the cis arrangement.
Alternatively, they may occupy opposite positions, producing the trans arrangement.
The four cyanido ligands fill the remaining positions.
Both arrangements retain the same ligand composition and bonding connectivity.
They therefore constitute two geometrical isomers.
\(\textbf{Combined interpretation:}\)
The negative coordination-entity charge does not mean iron has a negative oxidation state.
The -ate ending follows the entity charge, while the Roman numeral follows the metal oxidation state.
The existence of cis–trans isomerism follows from the octahedral arrangement of two ammonia and four cyanido ligands.
Thus, iron(III), ferrate nomenclature and two geometrical isomers are simultaneously consistent.
121. Consider the following statements concerning optical activity in coordination compounds.
Statement I: The two enantiomers of \(\mathrm{[Co(en)_3]^{3+}}\) possess identical elemental compositions and coordination connectivities.
Statement II: A compound must contain a carbon atom bonded to four different substituents to exhibit optical isomerism.
Statement III: An optically active coordination compound can lose its net optical rotation if converted into an equimolar mixture of its two enantiomers.
Statement IV: Every octahedral coordination entity containing a didentate ligand necessarily has an enantiomeric partner.
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. Statements I, II and III only
ⓑ. Statements II and IV only
ⓒ. Statements I and III only
ⓓ. Statements I, III and IV only
Correct Answer: Statements I and III only
Explanation: Statement I is correct because enantiomers are stereoisomers having identical chemical compositions and bonding connectivities.
Their distinguishing feature is the non-superimposable mirror-image relationship of their complete three-dimensional structures.
The two optical forms of \(\mathrm{[Co(en)_3]^{3+}}\) are standard examples.
Statement II is incorrect because a tetrahedral carbon stereogenic centre is not a universal requirement for optical activity.
Coordination compounds may exhibit chirality through the spatial arrangement of ligands around a metal centre.
The tris(en) coordination entity demonstrates this behaviour without requiring a conventional asymmetric carbon atom.
Statement III is correct because enantiomers rotate plane-polarised light equally but in opposite directions under identical conditions.
An equimolar mixture therefore exhibits cancellation of the two rotations and has zero net optical rotation.
Such a mixture is racemic.
Statement IV is incorrect because the presence of a didentate ligand alone does not establish chirality.
The entire three-dimensional structure must lack the symmetry needed for superimposability on its mirror image.
For example, the standard trans form of an octahedral \(\mathrm{[M(en)_2X_2]}\) coordination entity with identical X ligands is achiral.
The corresponding cis form may exhibit optical isomerism.
Thus, chirality depends on the complete coordination arrangement rather than merely the occurrence of chelation.
Only Statements I and III are correct.
122. A cobalt(III) compound of empirical composition \(\mathrm{Co(NH_3)_5ClSO_4}\) is isolated in two forms P and Q. The coordination formulae are:
P: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_5Cl]SO_4}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_5(SO_4)]Cl}\)
A student argues that their identical total compositions and identical numbers of ionic species on ideal dissociation mean that they cannot be structural isomers. Which statement correctly evaluates this argument?
ⓐ. The argument is incorrect because the two forms differ in which anionic group is directly coordinated to cobalt.
ⓑ. The argument is correct because structural isomerism always changes the total number of ionic species.
ⓒ. The argument is correct because both compounds retain cobalt in oxidation state \(+3\).
ⓓ. The argument is incorrect because the two forms have different numbers of ammonia ligands.
Correct Answer: The argument is incorrect because the two forms differ in which anionic group is directly coordinated to cobalt.
Explanation: The two compounds have identical overall chemical compositions.
Both contain cobalt(III), five ammonia molecules, one chloride ion and one sulphate ion.
However, their distributions of coordinated and external anionic groups are different.
In P, chloride is coordinated to cobalt and sulphate is the counter ion.
In Q, sulphate is coordinated and chloride acts as the external counter ion.
The identities of the groups directly attached to the central metal therefore differ.
This establishes a change in coordination connectivity, which is the essential feature of structural isomerism.
More specifically, the two compounds are ionisation isomers.
Both compounds can produce two ionic species per formula unit under the ideal dissociation model.
Nevertheless, the ionic species are not chemically identical in the two solutions.
P produces a complex cation and a free sulphate ion.
Q produces a different complex cation and a free chloride ion.
Thus, identical ideal ionic-species counts do not exclude structural isomerism.
The identical cobalt oxidation state and ammonia count also do not prevent the interchange of coordinated and external anions.
The student's argument fails because ionisation-isomer classification depends on chemical connectivity and counter-ion identity, not merely on the total number of dissolved ions.
123. Two arrangements P and Q of an octahedral coordination entity \(\mathrm{[M(en)_2Cl_2]^+}\) are described below. Both en molecules coordinate through adjacent nitrogen donor positions.
Arrangement P: The two chloride ligands occupy positions separated by \(90^\circ\) at the metal centre. The remaining four positions are occupied by two en ligands, each using a pair of adjacent positions.
Arrangement Q: The two chloride ligands occupy opposite positions separated by \(180^\circ\). The remaining four positions are occupied by two en ligands, each using a pair of adjacent positions.
Which statement correctly describes the geometrical and optical relationships of the two arrangements?
ⓐ. P and Q are both achiral because both contain two identical en ligands.
ⓑ. P and Q are optical isomers of each other because their chloride positions differ.
ⓒ. P is trans and achiral, whereas Q is cis and may occur as an enantiomeric pair.
ⓓ. P is cis and may occur as an enantiomeric pair, whereas Q is trans and is achiral in this standard system.
Correct Answer: P is cis and may occur as an enantiomeric pair, whereas Q is trans and is achiral in this standard system.
Explanation: In an octahedral entity, two adjacent coordination positions subtend an angle of \(90^\circ\).
Two opposite positions subtend an angle of \(180^\circ\).
Therefore, the two chloride ligands in arrangement P are cis to each other.
The chloride ligands in arrangement Q are trans to each other.
Both arrangements contain two didentate en ligands and two unidentate chloride ligands.
Each en ligand must attach through adjacent positions to form its normal chelate ring.
This requirement is compatible with both the specified cis and trans arrangements.
However, the optical behaviour of the two geometrical classes differs.
In the standard cis-\(\mathrm{[M(en)_2Cl_2]^+}\) arrangement, the coordinated chelate rings can produce two non-superimposable mirror-image structures.
The cis class can therefore contain an enantiomeric pair.
The corresponding symmetrical trans class is achiral.
Its mirror image is superimposable on the original structure.
P and Q are consequently geometrical isomers of one another, not optical enantiomers.
Optical enantiomers must have the same geometrical connectivity and differ through non-superimposable mirror-image arrangements.
The distinction demonstrates that a coordination formula may possess one geometrical class with optical isomerism and another without it.
124. Four structural or stereochemical relationships are listed below.
| Pair | First coordination compound | Second coordination compound |
| P | cis-\(\mathrm{[Pt(NH_3)_2Cl_2]}\) | trans-\(\mathrm{[Pt(NH_3)_2Cl_2]}\) |
| Q | \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_5(NO_2)]Cl_2}\), N-bonded | \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_5(ONO)]Cl_2}\), O-bonded |
| R | \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_6]Cl_3}\) | \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_5Cl]Cl_2\cdot H_2O}\) |
| S | \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_6]Cl_3}\) | \(\mathrm{[Co(en)_3]Cl_3}\) |
Which statement correctly identifies the pairs that are isomers and their respective types?
ⓐ. P is geometrical, Q is linkage, R is hydrate, and S is optical.
ⓑ. P is linkage, Q is geometrical, R is hydrate, and S is not an isomeric pair.
ⓒ. P is geometrical, Q is ionisation, R is hydrate, and S is not an isomeric pair.
ⓓ. P is geometrical, Q is linkage, R is hydrate, and S is not an isomeric pair.
Correct Answer: P is geometrical, Q is linkage, R is hydrate, and S is not an isomeric pair.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Pair P:}\)
Both platinum compounds have identical overall compositions and bonding connectivities.
The two chloride ligands occupy adjacent positions in the cis form and opposite positions in the trans form.
Therefore, P represents geometrical isomerism.
\(\textbf{Pair Q:}\)
The cobalt compounds contain the same total numbers of atoms and the same ligand species.
The difference is the donor atom through which nitrite attaches to cobalt.
The first form has nitrogen-bonded nitrite, while the second has oxygen-bonded nitrite.
Consequently, Q represents linkage isomerism.
\(\textbf{Pair R:}\)
Both chromium compounds possess the empirical composition \(\mathrm{CrCl_3\cdot6H_2O}\).
In the first compound, all six water molecules are coordinated.
In the second, five water molecules are coordinated and one occurs outside the coordination sphere.
The coordinated chloride count changes correspondingly.
This is hydrate isomerism, a form of solvate isomerism.
\(\textbf{Pair S:}\)
The first cobalt compound contains six ammonia molecules, whereas the second contains three en molecules.
Ethane-1,2-diamine is not chemically identical to two ammonia molecules.
Although both complexes contain six coordinated nitrogen donor atoms, their overall elemental compositions are different.
Therefore, they cannot be isomers of one another.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The classification must begin by checking overall chemical composition.
Only then should differences in connectivity or spatial arrangement be examined.
P is a geometrical-isomer pair, Q is a linkage-isomer pair and R is a hydrate-isomer pair.
S is not an isomeric pair despite the two compounds having the same metal oxidation state, coordination number and counter-ion type.
125. An octahedral coordination entity \(\mathrm{[M(en)(NH_3)_2Cl_2]^+}\) contains a trivalent metal M. The en ligand forms its normal chelate ring by occupying two adjacent positions. All other ligands are unidentate. Which statement about the relative positions of the two ammonia and two chloride ligands is necessarily correct?
ⓐ. Both ammonia ligands and both chloride ligands may simultaneously occupy trans positions.
ⓑ. If the ammonia ligands are trans, the chloride ligands must also be trans.
ⓒ. If the chloride ligands are trans, the ammonia ligands must be cis.
ⓓ. The ammonia ligands must always be trans because en occupies adjacent positions.
Correct Answer: If the chloride ligands are trans, the ammonia ligands must be cis.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Coordination environment:}\)
The en ligand contributes two nitrogen donor atoms, while two ammonia and two chloride ligands contribute four additional donor atoms.
Thus, the coordination number is six, consistent with octahedral geometry.
The two donor atoms of the short en ligand must occupy adjacent positions to form its normal chelate ring.
\(\textbf{Opposite-position pairs:}\)
An octahedron contains three pairs of mutually opposite coordination positions.
If the two chloride ligands occupy one such pair, they are trans.
The remaining four positions comprise two opposite-position pairs.
Suppose the two ammonia ligands also occupied opposite positions.
They would then use another complete trans pair.
The only positions left for en would constitute the third trans pair.
However, the two donor atoms of en cannot occupy these opposite positions while forming its normal chelate ring.
Therefore, the supposition is incompatible with the stated chelation constraint.
\(\textbf{Allowed arrangement:}\)
When the chloride ligands are trans, the two ammonia ligands must occupy adjacent positions so that the two remaining adjacent positions can accommodate en.
The ammonia ligands are consequently cis.
The reverse implication is not necessary: cis chloride ligands do not force the ammonia ligands to be trans in every permitted arrangement.
\(\textbf{Chemical consistency:}\)
The cobalt-independent metal symbol M does not affect this spatial argument.
The trivalent metal and two coordinated chloride ligands give the entity charge \(+1\), as stated.
The question therefore requires both an octahedral positional analysis and the connectivity restriction imposed by en.
It cannot be answered by coordination-number counting alone.
126. An octahedral coordination entity of composition \(\mathrm{[MA_3B_3]}\) contains three unidentate ligands A and three unidentate ligands B. Define an unlike trans pair as a pair of opposite coordination positions occupied by one A and one B ligand. Which statement correctly compares the facial and meridional arrangements?
ⓐ. The facial arrangement has three unlike trans pairs, whereas the meridional arrangement has one.
ⓑ. The facial arrangement has one unlike trans pair, whereas the meridional arrangement has three.
ⓒ. Both arrangements have three unlike trans pairs because their overall compositions are identical.
ⓓ. Neither arrangement has an unlike trans pair because opposite positions must contain identical ligands.
Correct Answer: The facial arrangement has three unlike trans pairs, whereas the meridional arrangement has one.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Spatial organisation in a facial arrangement:}\)
In an octahedron, each coordination position has exactly one opposite position.
For the facial arrangement of \(\mathrm{MA_3B_3}\), the three A ligands occupy the vertices of one triangular face.
Every pair of A ligands is cis, so no A ligand is opposite another A ligand.
The position opposite each A ligand must therefore contain a B ligand.
Consequently, all three trans pairs consist of unlike ligands.
The facial arrangement has three A–B trans pairs.
\(\textbf{Spatial organisation in a meridional arrangement:}\)
In the meridional arrangement, one pair of A ligands occupies opposite positions.
Therefore, one trans pair is A–A.
The third A ligand occupies a position perpendicular to this pair.
Among the three B ligands, one pair likewise occupies opposite positions.
This gives one B–B trans pair.
The remaining A and B ligands occupy the final opposite positions, producing one A–B trans pair.
\(\textbf{Comparison:}\)
The facial arrangement therefore contains three unlike trans pairs.
The meridional arrangement contains one unlike trans pair, together with one A–A and one B–B trans pair.
Both arrangements have exactly three trans pairs in total, as required by octahedral geometry.
The distinction concerns the identities of the ligands occupying those opposite positions.
Their chemical compositions and coordination numbers remain identical.
This provides a structural test for fac–mer isomerism without relying on differently oriented drawings of the same octahedron.
127. The square-planar coordination compound \(\mathrm{[Pt(NH_3)_2Cl_2]}\) can exist in cis and trans geometrical forms. Cisplatin is used in cancer treatment, whereas the corresponding trans geometrical isomer does not exhibit the same useful antitumour activity. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
ⓐ. The two compounds have different platinum oxidation states because their biological activities differ.
ⓑ. Cisplatin contains coordinated ammonia, whereas its trans isomer contains ammonia only as a counter ion.
ⓒ. The different biological activities prove that the cis compound has coordination number four and the trans compound has coordination number six.
ⓓ. The relative positions of otherwise identical coordinated ligands can substantially affect biological behaviour without changing overall composition or metal oxidation state.
Correct Answer: The relative positions of otherwise identical coordinated ligands can substantially affect biological behaviour without changing overall composition or metal oxidation state.
Explanation: Both compounds have the same molecular formula, \(\mathrm{[Pt(NH_3)_2Cl_2]}\).
Platinum is in oxidation state \(+2\) because the two coordinated chloride ligands contribute a total charge of \(-2\), while ammonia is neutral.
All four ligands are unidentate, so both compounds have coordination number four.
Their geometry is square planar.
In cisplatin, the two coordinated chloride ligands occupy adjacent positions.
In the trans isomer, the chloride ligands occupy opposite positions.
These structures are geometrical isomers because their connectivity and chemical compositions are identical but their spatial ligand arrangements differ.
The relative positions of the coordinated groups influence how the compounds interact with biological targets.
Cisplatin has an important role as an anticancer drug, whereas the corresponding trans isomer does not have equivalent therapeutic activity.
This difference cannot be explained by assigning different oxidation states or coordination numbers.
It arises from the consequences of different three-dimensional ligand arrangements.
The example demonstrates that stereochemistry is not merely a naming distinction; it may strongly influence the chemical and biological properties of coordination compounds.
128. Two purified samples P and Q contain opposite optical isomers of \(\mathrm{[Co(en)_3]Cl_3}\). They are examined separately at identical concentrations, temperatures and solvent conditions. Which observation is consistent with their being a pair of enantiomers?
ⓐ. They have different elemental compositions but identical optical rotations.
ⓑ. They have identical ordinary absorption spectra in an achiral medium but equal and opposite optical rotations.
ⓒ. One sample produces three chloride ions on ideal dissociation, whereas the other produces two.
ⓓ. One sample is paramagnetic and the other diamagnetic because their mirror-image arrangements have opposite handedness.
Correct Answer: They have identical ordinary absorption spectra in an achiral medium but equal and opposite optical rotations.
Explanation: The two samples contain the same coordination compound and differ only in the handedness of their coordination structures.
Each cobalt centre is coordinated by three didentate en ligands, giving coordination number six.
The two structures are non-superimposable mirror images and are therefore enantiomers.
Their elemental compositions, cobalt oxidation states and coordination connectivities are identical.
Each formula unit also contains three external chloride counter ions.
Consequently, both samples have the same ideal ionic dissociation pattern.
In an achiral medium, enantiomers possess identical ordinary chemical and many physical properties, including corresponding ordinary absorption spectra under equivalent conditions.
However, they interact differently with plane-polarised light.
One pure enantiomer rotates the plane of polarisation in one direction, while the other produces an equal rotation in the opposite direction under identical conditions.
Their opposite handedness does not imply different numbers of unpaired electrons.
Thus, it does not make one enantiomer diamagnetic and the other paramagnetic.
The relevant distinguishing observation is optical rotation rather than a change in formula, electrolyte type or magnetic character.
This reasoning separates the optical consequences of chirality from properties controlled by ordinary chemical composition and electronic configuration.
129. A \(0.20\,\mathrm{mol}\) mixture contains only two hydrate isomers of chromium(III) chloride:
P: \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_6]Cl_3}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_5Cl]Cl_2\cdot H_2O}\)
Under suitable precipitation conditions, the mixture gives \(0.52\,\mathrm{mol}\) of \(\mathrm{AgCl}\). Assume only the external chloride ions are precipitated and that both compounds dissociate ideally into intact coordination entities and counter ions. How many moles of ionic species are produced by complete dissolution of the original mixture?
ⓐ. \(0.60\,\mathrm{mol}\)
ⓑ. \(0.68\,\mathrm{mol}\)
ⓒ. \(0.72\,\mathrm{mol}\)
ⓓ. \(0.80\,\mathrm{mol}\)
Correct Answer: \(0.72\,\mathrm{mol}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Ionisation characteristics of the hydrate isomers:}\)
Compound P has three chloride ions outside its coordination sphere.
Therefore, one mole of P gives three moles of precipitable chloride and four moles of ionic species on ideal dissociation.
Compound Q has two external chloride ions and one coordinated chloride ligand.
Thus, one mole of Q gives two moles of precipitable chloride and three moles of ionic species.
The water molecule outside Q's coordination sphere is neutral and is not counted as an ionic species.
\(\textbf{Mixture composition:}\)
Let \(x\) mol be the amount of P.
The amount of Q is:
\[
n_Q=0.20-x
\]
\(\textbf{Silver chloride balance:}\)
P contributes three moles of precipitable chloride per mole of compound.
Q contributes two moles per mole.
Therefore:
\[
3x+2(0.20-x)=0.52
\]
Expanding:
\[
3x+0.40-2x=0.52
\]
\[
x=0.12\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Hence:
\[
n_P=0.12\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\[
n_Q=0.20-0.12=0.08\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Ionic-species calculation:}\)
Each mole of P produces four moles of ionic species.
\[
n_{\mathrm{ions},P}=4(0.12)=0.48\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Each mole of Q produces three moles of ionic species.
\[
n_{\mathrm{ions},Q}=3(0.08)=0.24\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{ions,total}}=0.48+0.24
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{ions,total}}=0.72\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Consistency check:}\)
The mixture produces \(0.52\,\mathrm{mol}\) of external chloride ions.
It also produces \(0.20\,\mathrm{mol}\) of intact complex cations because each formula unit contains one coordination entity.
Their sum is:
\[
0.52+0.20=0.72\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Both methods agree.
The problem illustrates how precipitation evidence can determine the composition of a hydrate-isomer mixture and thereby predict its ideal ionic-species count.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{n_{\mathrm{ionic\ species}}=0.72\,\mathrm{mol}}
\]
130. Two proposed coordination compounds are:
P: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_6]_4[Fe(CN)_6]_3}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Fe(NH_3)_6]_3[Co(CN)_6]_2}\)
Assume cobalt is in oxidation state \(+3\) and iron is in oxidation state \(+2\) in both compounds. All ammonia ligands are neutral, and all cyanido ligands carry charge \(-1\). A student claims that P and Q are coordination isomers because ammonia and cyanido ligands exchange their metal centres. Which statement correctly evaluates the claim?
ⓐ. The claim is correct because ligand redistribution is sufficient even when the overall compositions differ.
ⓑ. The claim is correct because both compounds contain complex cations and complex anions.
ⓒ. The claim is incorrect because coordination isomerism requires one metal centre to have oxidation state zero.
ⓓ. The claim is incorrect because the two charge-balanced formulae have different overall elemental compositions.
Correct Answer: The claim is incorrect because the two charge-balanced formulae have different overall elemental compositions.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Charges in P:}\)
The hexaamminecobalt(III) entity carries charge \(+3\) because ammonia is neutral.
The hexacyanidoferrate(II) entity has charge:
\[
q_{\mathrm{Fe(CN)_6}}=(+2)+6(-1)=-4
\]
Four complex cations and three complex anions therefore give:
\[
4(+3)+3(-4)=0
\]
Thus, P is electrically neutral.
\(\textbf{Charges in Q:}\)
The hexaammineiron(II) entity carries charge \(+2\).
The hexacyanidocobaltate(III) entity has charge:
\[
q_{\mathrm{Co(CN)_6}}=(+3)+6(-1)=-3
\]
Three complex cations and two complex anions give:
\[
3(+2)+2(-3)=0
\]
Thus, Q is also electrically neutral.
\(\textbf{Overall-composition test:}\)
P contains four cobalt atoms and three iron atoms per formula unit.
Q contains two cobalt atoms and three iron atoms per formula unit.
Their metal-atom ratios are therefore different.
They also contain different total numbers of ammonia and cyanido ligands.
Consequently, P and Q do not possess the same overall chemical composition.
\(\textbf{Isomerism conclusion:}\)
Coordination isomerism involves redistribution of ligands between complex cations and complex anions while preserving the overall composition.
Merely exchanging the identities of the metals coordinated by particular ligands is insufficient when charge balance changes the required combining ratios.
The student's proposed transformation fails the essential compositional requirement for isomerism.
Therefore, P and Q are not coordination isomers.
This provides a counterexample to the assumption that every exchange of ligand environments between two metal centres necessarily creates coordination isomerism.
131. Consider the octahedral coordination entities P and Q:
P: \(\mathrm{[Co(en)_3]^{3+}}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_3Cl_3]}\)
Each en ligand forms its normal chelate ring, and all ammonia and chloride ligands are unidentate. Which statement correctly compares their geometrical and optical possibilities?
ⓐ. P has one geometrical class capable of forming an enantiomeric pair; Q has facial and meridional geometrical classes.
ⓑ. P has facial and meridional forms; Q has one geometrical class capable of forming an enantiomeric pair.
ⓒ. Both P and Q have facial and meridional forms because both have coordination number six.
ⓓ. Neither P nor Q can exhibit stereoisomerism because both contain cobalt(III).
Correct Answer: P has one geometrical class capable of forming an enantiomeric pair; Q has facial and meridional geometrical classes.
Explanation: Both coordination entities contain cobalt in oxidation state \(+3\) and have octahedral coordination number six.
However, their ligand connectivities differ.
P contains three didentate en ligands, each of which connects two adjacent coordination positions through a chelate ring.
Its characteristic stereochemical distinction is between two non-superimposable mirror-image arrangements of the three chelate rings.
These arrangements are optical isomers.
The three en ligands are chemically identical, so simply changing the labels assigned to them does not create independent facial or meridional geometrical classes.
Q contains three ammonia ligands and three chloride ligands, each unidentate.
The three ammonia ligands can occupy positions defining one octahedral face.
This produces the facial arrangement.
Alternatively, the three ammonia ligands can lie along a meridian with one ammonia pair trans.
This produces the meridional arrangement.
The familiar facial and meridional forms of this simple \(\mathrm{MA_3B_3}\) entity are distinct geometrical isomers.
Their existence does not depend on the metal oxidation state differing between the forms.
The comparison shows that the same octahedral coordination number may support different stereochemical patterns depending on whether the ligands are linked into chelate rings or independently coordinated.
It is therefore incorrect to apply fac–mer classification mechanically to every octahedral entity containing three ligand molecules.
132. A pure optical isomer of an octahedral tris(ethane-1,2-diamine) coordination compound produces an observed rotation of \(+40^\circ\) under specified conditions. Its enantiomer produces \(-40^\circ\) under the same conditions. A mixture containing only these two enantiomers has the same total concentration and optical path length as the pure samples and produces an observed rotation of \(+12^\circ\). Assuming optical rotations add linearly, what percentage of the mixture consists of the dextrorotatory enantiomer?
ⓐ. \(35\%\)
ⓑ. \(50\%\)
ⓒ. \(65\%\)
ⓓ. \(80\%\)
Correct Answer: \(65\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Optical behaviour of the enantiomers:}\)
The two coordination entities are non-superimposable mirror images.
Their optical rotations have equal magnitudes but opposite signs under identical conditions.
The dextrorotatory enantiomer produces \(+40^\circ\).
The laevorotatory enantiomer produces \(-40^\circ\).
\(\textbf{Composition of the mixture:}\)
Let \(x\) represent the fraction of the dextrorotatory enantiomer.
The fraction of its mirror-image partner is:
\[
1-x
\]
The total concentration and optical path length are unchanged.
Therefore, the contributions to optical rotation are proportional to the corresponding fractions.
\(\textbf{Observed rotation relation:}\)
\[
\alpha_{\mathrm{mixture}}=x\alpha_++(1-x)\alpha_-
\]
Substituting the stated rotations:
\[
12=x(40)+(1-x)(-40)
\]
Expanding:
\[
12=40x-40+40x
\]
\[
12=80x-40
\]
\[
80x=52
\]
\[
x=\frac{52}{80}
\]
\[
x=0.65
\]
\(\textbf{Percentage composition:}\)
\[
\%\text{ dextrorotatory enantiomer}=0.65(100)
\]
\[
=65\%
\]
The other enantiomer therefore constitutes \(35\%\) of the mixture.
\(\textbf{Chemical interpretation:}\)
A racemic mixture would contain equal fractions and produce zero net optical rotation.
The positive observed rotation indicates an excess of the dextrorotatory enantiomer.
The calculation depends on the optical activity of the enantiomers, not on a change in cobalt oxidation state or coordination number.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{65\%}
\]
133. An octahedral coordination entity contains two ligands each of types A, B and C, all unidentate. Spectroscopic evidence establishes that the two A ligands are trans and that the two B ligands are also trans. Which additional conclusion is necessarily correct?
ⓐ. The two C ligands must be cis, and the entity is necessarily chiral.
ⓑ. The two C ligands must be trans, and the stated arrangement possesses a centre of inversion.
ⓒ. The two C ligands may be either cis or trans without changing the A and B relationships.
ⓓ. All six ligands must occupy one plane because two identical-ligand pairs are trans.
Correct Answer: The two C ligands must be trans, and the stated arrangement possesses a centre of inversion.
Explanation: An octahedron has six coordination positions arranged as three pairs of opposite vertices.
The two A ligands are specified to occupy opposite positions.
They therefore use one complete trans pair.
The two B ligands also occupy opposite positions.
Since the A positions are already occupied, the B ligands must occupy a second complete trans pair.
Only one pair of coordination positions remains unoccupied.
These remaining positions are opposite each other.
Consequently, the two C ligands must occupy the third trans pair.
The conclusion follows from the geometry of an octahedron and does not depend on the identities of A, B and C.
The resulting arrangement has identical ligands situated at opposite vertices along each of three perpendicular axes.
An inversion through the metal centre maps each A ligand onto the opposite A ligand.
The same operation maps B onto B and C onto C.
Therefore, the arrangement possesses a centre of inversion.
A structure possessing an inversion centre is achiral.
The entity cannot exhibit optical isomerism through this specified arrangement.
This combines coordination-position counting with a symmetry-based inference about optical activity.
The existence of three different ligand types does not, by itself, imply chirality.
134. Three aqueous samples contain compounds with the same empirical composition, \(\mathrm{CrCl_3\cdot6H_2O}\). Their coordination formulae are:
P: \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_6]Cl_3}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_5Cl]Cl_2\cdot H_2O}\)
R: \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_4Cl_2]Cl\cdot2H_2O}\)
Under conditions in which all coordination spheres remain intact, which sequence correctly gives the number of chloride ions precipitable by silver nitrate per formula unit, the number of coordinated water molecules and the ideal number of ionic species?
ⓐ. P: \((3,6,4)\); Q: \((2,5,3)\); R: \((1,4,2)\)
ⓑ. P: \((3,6,3)\); Q: \((2,5,2)\); R: \((1,4,1)\)
ⓒ. P: \((3,6,4)\); Q: \((2,6,3)\); R: \((1,6,2)\)
ⓓ. P: \((3,6,4)\); Q: \((2,5,4)\); R: \((1,4,4)\)
Correct Answer: P: \((3,6,4)\); Q: \((2,5,3)\); R: \((1,4,2)\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Coordination sphere of P:}\)
P contains six water molecules directly coordinated to chromium.
All three chloride ions occur outside the coordination sphere.
Therefore, three chloride ions are available for immediate precipitation under the stated conditions.
Ideal dissociation produces one complex cation and three chloride counter ions, giving four ionic species.
Thus, P corresponds to \((3,6,4)\).
\(\textbf{Coordination sphere of Q:}\)
Q contains five coordinated water molecules and one coordinated chloride ligand.
One additional water molecule occurs outside the coordination sphere as water of crystallisation.
Two chloride ions remain external counter ions.
Therefore, two chloride ions are precipitable under the stated conditions.
Ideal dissociation produces one complex cation and two chloride ions, giving three ionic species.
Thus, Q corresponds to \((2,5,3)\).
\(\textbf{Coordination sphere of R:}\)
R contains four coordinated water molecules and two coordinated chloride ligands.
Two water molecules occur outside the sphere.
Only one chloride ion remains an external counter ion.
Ideal dissociation consequently gives one complex cation and one chloride ion, producing two ionic species.
Thus, R corresponds to \((1,4,2)\).
\(\textbf{Integrated trend:}\)
Moving from P to Q to R, the number of coordinated water molecules decreases by one at each step.
The number of coordinated chloride ligands increases correspondingly.
The number of external chloride ions and the ideal ionic-species count both decrease.
However, each chromium centre maintains coordination number six.
The water molecules of crystallisation are not counted as ions.
This systematic relationship distinguishes hydrate-isomer structures using coordination-sphere composition, chloride precipitation and ideal dissociation together.
135. Two unknown coordination compounds P and Q have identical elemental compositions, identical oxidation states of the central metal and equal ideal ionic-species counts in water. Experimental analysis further shows that the metal is bonded to nitrogen of a thiocyanate ligand in P but to sulphur of the same ligand in Q. All other metal–ligand attachments are identical. Which inference is justified?
ⓐ. P and Q cannot be isomers because their ionic-species counts are equal.
ⓑ. P and Q are ionisation isomers because the thiocyanate ligand carries a negative charge.
ⓒ. P and Q are geometrical isomers because the ligands occupy different spatial positions.
ⓓ. P and Q are linkage isomers because the donor atom of an ambidentate ligand changes.
Correct Answer: P and Q are linkage isomers because the donor atom of an ambidentate ligand changes.
Explanation: Thiocyanate is an ambidentate ligand because it can coordinate through nitrogen or sulphur.
The problem states that P contains a metal–nitrogen attachment involving thiocyanate.
In Q, the corresponding attachment is through sulphur.
The identity and total charge of the thiocyanate ligand are unchanged.
The overall elemental compositions of P and Q are also identical.
Their central-metal oxidation states and the remaining coordination attachments are unchanged.
Thus, the essential difference is a change in the atom of the ligand directly bonded to the metal.
This is the defining feature of linkage isomerism.
Ionisation isomerism would require an appropriate exchange involving a coordinated ion and an external counter ion.
No such exchange is described.
Geometrical isomerism would involve a change in relative spatial positions while preserving the relevant coordination connectivity.
Here, the connectivity itself changes from metal–nitrogen to metal–sulphur.
Equal ionic-species counts are entirely compatible with linkage isomerism because the number and charges of external counter ions need not change.
Consequently, the spectroscopic evidence concerning donor identity is decisive even though the simple ionic observations are the same.
136. An octahedral coordination compound contains a trivalent metal M, two didentate en ligands and two unidentate chloride ligands. Consider the following proposed changes:
I. A cis arrangement changes into a trans arrangement without changing the identity of any ligand.
II. One en ligand is replaced by two ammonia molecules while the other ligands remain unchanged.
III. One coordinated chloride ion exchanges places with one chloride counter ion outside the coordination sphere.
IV. A cis arrangement is converted into its non-superimposable mirror-image form.
Which changes necessarily produce a different isomer of the original compound rather than merely a different representation or a compound with a changed overall composition?
ⓐ. I and II only
ⓑ. I and IV only
ⓒ. II and III only
ⓓ. III and IV only
Correct Answer: I and IV only
Explanation: The original coordination compound contains two en ligands and two chloride ligands inside its coordination sphere.
The en ligands each coordinate through two nitrogen donor atoms and form chelate rings.
The two chloride ligands occupy the remaining coordination positions.
Change I alters the relative positions of the two coordinated chloride ligands from adjacent to opposite.
This produces a cis–trans geometrical-isomer relationship while preserving the ligand composition and coordination connectivity.
Therefore, I produces a different isomer.
Change II removes one en molecule and introduces two ammonia molecules.
Although two ammonia molecules can replace the two donor attachments originally supplied by one en ligand, ammonia and en are different chemical species.
The overall elemental composition of the resulting coordination compound changes.
Consequently, the new compound is not an isomer of the original.
Change III exchanges a coordinated chloride ion with an external chloride ion of the same chemical identity.
The coordination sphere still contains a coordinated chloride, and the counter-ion region still contains chloride.
No chemically distinguishable connectivity or spatial arrangement is produced merely by interchanging identical chloride ions.
Thus, III does not necessarily give a distinct isomer.
Change IV produces a non-superimposable mirror-image structure of the cis form.
Such a transformation generates an optical isomer without changing chemical composition or relevant coordination connectivity.
Therefore, IV produces a distinct isomer.
The correct changes are I and IV.
The analysis distinguishes genuine structural or stereochemical differences from ligand substitution and the arbitrary relabelling of chemically identical ions.
137. An octahedral coordination entity \(\mathrm{[M(en)_2X_2]}\) is known to have two geometrical classes. The cis class occurs as two non-superimposable mirror images, while the trans class is achiral. A sample contains equal amounts of the two cis enantiomers together with an arbitrary amount of the trans form. Which statement is necessarily true about the optical rotation of the sample, assuming no other optically active substances are present?
ⓐ. The sample shows zero net optical rotation under conditions where the two cis enantiomers contribute equal and opposite rotations.
ⓑ. The sample must be dextrorotatory because the trans form contributes an additional positive rotation.
ⓒ. The sample must be laevorotatory because the cis arrangement contains two chelate rings.
ⓓ. The sample cannot have zero optical rotation unless the amount of trans is exactly equal to the total amount of cis.
Correct Answer: The sample shows zero net optical rotation under conditions where the two cis enantiomers contribute equal and opposite rotations.
Explanation: The cis geometrical class contains two optical isomers that are non-superimposable mirror images.
Under identical optical measurement conditions, the two enantiomers rotate plane-polarised light by equal magnitudes in opposite directions.
The sample is stated to contain equal amounts of these cis enantiomers.
Therefore, their contributions to optical rotation cancel.
The trans form is specified to be achiral.
An achiral coordination entity does not contribute optical rotation through molecular chirality.
Consequently, adding an arbitrary amount of this trans form does not disturb the cancellation between the equal cis enantiomers.
The total sample therefore exhibits zero net optical rotation under the stated conditions.
It is unnecessary for the amount of trans isomer to equal the amount of either cis enantiomer.
The cis components collectively constitute a racemic portion of the sample.
However, the whole sample need not contain only one geometrical class.
This example demonstrates that a solution can be optically inactive while still containing individual chiral coordination entities.
Optical inactivity may arise from cancellation of enantiomeric rotations as well as from the presence of achiral species.
The distinction is important when relating stereoisomer composition to observed optical behaviour.
138. A coordination salt contains two complex ions, one cationic and one anionic. An isomeric form is proposed in which the ligand sets attached to the two different central metals are exchanged. Which condition is indispensable for the proposed forms to qualify as coordination isomers?
ⓐ. Both coordination entities must become neutral after exchanging ligand sets, because charged species cannot be coordination isomers.
ⓑ. The two central metals must have identical oxidation states and coordination numbers, even when their coordinated ligands are exchanged.
ⓒ. The overall elemental composition must be preserved, with a genuine redistribution of ligands between the complex cation and anion.
ⓓ. The number of external simple counter ions must increase after exchanging ligands, independently of the two complex-ion charges.
Correct Answer: The overall elemental composition must be preserved, with a genuine redistribution of ligands between the complex cation and anion.
Explanation: Coordination isomerism is a form of structural isomerism involving salts that contain complex cations and complex anions.
Its characteristic feature is a redistribution of coordinated ligand groups between the two metal centres.
However, redistribution alone does not establish an isomeric relationship.
All isomers must have the same overall chemical composition.
Therefore, the total numbers of metal atoms, ligand atoms and other constituent atoms must remain unchanged.
The two proposed salts must also satisfy electrical neutrality with their actual coordination-entity charges.
It is not necessary for the two central metals to possess identical oxidation states in every possible coordination-isomer system.
Likewise, exchanging ligand environments does not require the coordination entities to become neutral.
A coordination salt may contain a positively charged complex ion and a negatively charged complex ion both before and after redistribution.
The presence or absence of simple external counter ions is not the defining feature of coordination isomerism.
That feature belongs more directly to the analysis of ionisation-isomer relationships.
The essential test is whether the ligand reassignment changes metal–ligand connectivity while preserving the complete chemical composition.
Thus, option C states the indispensable condition without introducing unnecessary restrictions.
139. Two solutions contain equal amounts of the octahedral geometrical isomers fac-\(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_3Cl_3]}\) and mer-\(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_3Cl_3]}\), respectively. Under suitable conditions, a measurement probes only the overall ionic charge of each intact coordination entity, while a structural measurement distinguishes their relative ligand positions. Which result is consistent with these compounds?
ⓐ. The facial entity is positively charged, while the meridional entity is negatively charged.
ⓑ. Both entities are neutral, but the facial form has no pair of ammonia ligands trans to each other whereas the meridional form has one.
ⓒ. Both entities are neutral, but the facial form has one trans ammonia pair whereas the meridional form has none.
ⓓ. The two entities have different coordination numbers because meridional arrangements occupy fewer positions.
Correct Answer: Both entities are neutral, but the facial form has no pair of ammonia ligands trans to each other whereas the meridional form has one.
Explanation: Both coordination entities contain cobalt in oxidation state \(+3\).
Each contains three neutral ammonia ligands and three chloride ligands carrying charge \(-1\).
Therefore, the coordination-entity charge is zero in both geometrical forms.
The charge calculation does not depend on whether the ammonia ligands occupy facial or meridional positions.
Each entity also contains six unidentate ligands, giving coordination number six.
The facial arrangement places the three ammonia ligands on one triangular face of the octahedron.
Every ammonia pair is therefore cis, with no ammonia–cobalt–ammonia angle of \(180^\circ\).
The meridional arrangement places the three ammonia ligands along a meridian of the octahedron.
One ammonia pair occupies opposite positions and is trans.
The remaining ammonia pairs are cis.
These differences in relative ligand positions establish geometrical isomerism.
They do not change the elemental composition, cobalt oxidation state or coordination-entity charge.
Consequently, a measurement sensitive only to the overall ionic charge would not distinguish the two forms.
A suitable structural measurement, however, could distinguish their ammonia–cobalt–ammonia angular relationships.
The example shows why identical electrical behaviour does not imply identical coordination geometry.
140. Two octahedral coordination salts P and Q are represented by:
P: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_6][Cr(CN)_6]}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_5(CN)][Cr(NH_3)(CN)_5]}\)
Assume cobalt and chromium are both in oxidation state \(+3\), ammonia is neutral, and cyanide is a unidentate ligand carrying charge \(-1\). Which statement correctly describes the relationship between P and Q?
ⓐ. They are ionisation isomers because their complex-ion charges are different.
ⓑ. They are coordination isomers because one ammonia and one cyanido ligand have exchanged metal centres while the overall composition is preserved.
ⓒ. They are linkage isomers because cyanide coordinates through different donor atoms.
ⓓ. They are not isomers because the coordination-entity charges must remain identical in every coordination isomer.
Correct Answer: They are coordination isomers because one ammonia and one cyanido ligand have exchanged metal centres while the overall composition is preserved.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Coordination entities in P:}\)
Six neutral ammonia ligands surround cobalt(III), giving the cation \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_6]^{3+}}\).
Six cyanido ligands surround chromium(III), giving the anion \(\mathrm{[Cr(CN)_6]^{3-}}\).
The charges balance in a \(1:1\) ratio, and both metal centres have coordination number six.
\(\textbf{Coordination entities in Q:}\)
In Q, cobalt is coordinated by five ammonia ligands and one cyanido ligand.
Its coordination-entity charge is:
\[
q_{\mathrm{Co}}=(+3)+5(0)+(-1)=+2
\]
Chromium is coordinated by one ammonia ligand and five cyanido ligands.
Its coordination-entity charge is:
\[
q_{\mathrm{Cr}}=(+3)+0+5(-1)=-2
\]
These charges also balance in a \(1:1\) ratio.
\(\textbf{Overall-composition check:}\)
Both salts contain one cobalt atom, one chromium atom, six ammonia molecules and six cyanido ligands.
Their complete elemental compositions are therefore identical.
The difference is that one ammonia ligand and one cyanido ligand have exchanged their respective metal centres.
Thus, the metal–ligand coordination connectivities differ.
\(\textbf{Classification:}\)
This redistribution of ligands between a complex cation and a complex anion is coordination isomerism.
It is not ionisation isomerism because no coordinated ion has exchanged with an external simple counter ion.
It is not linkage isomerism because no change in the donor atom of cyanide has been specified.
The complex-ion charges differ between P and Q, but their overall compositions and electrical neutrality remain intact.
Consequently, the two salts constitute a valid coordination-isomer pair.
141. The coordination entities \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_6]^{3+}}\) and \(\mathrm{[PtCl_4]^{2-}}\) are respectively octahedral and square planar. According to the valence-bond approach, which statement correctly describes the number and spatial arrangement of hybrid orbitals required to accept ligand electron pairs?
ⓐ. The chromium entity requires four tetrahedrally directed hybrid orbitals, while the platinum entity requires six octahedrally directed orbitals.
ⓑ. Both entities require six hybrid orbitals because their metal atoms possess d orbitals.
ⓒ. The chromium entity requires six octahedrally directed hybrid orbitals, while the platinum entity requires four square-planar hybrid orbitals.
ⓓ. Both entities require four hybrid orbitals because ligand electron pairs occupy metal d orbitals only.
Correct Answer: The chromium entity requires six octahedrally directed hybrid orbitals, while the platinum entity requires four square-planar hybrid orbitals.
Explanation: The valence-bond approach describes coordination bonding through donation of electron pairs from ligand donor atoms into suitable hybrid orbitals of the central metal atom or ion.
The number of such hybrid orbitals corresponds to the number of directly coordinated donor atoms.
In \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_6]^{3+}}\), six water molecules coordinate through six oxygen donor atoms.
The coordination number is therefore six.
An octahedral arrangement requires six appropriately directed hybrid orbitals.
For this chromium(III) entity, the valence-bond description can employ \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation using suitable inner d orbitals.
In \(\mathrm{[PtCl_4]^{2-}}\), four chloride ligands coordinate to platinum.
The coordination number is four, and the geometry is specified as square planar.
The corresponding valence-bond description uses four \(dsp^2\) hybrid orbitals.
The presence of d orbitals in both central metal ions does not make their coordination numbers identical.
Nor does coordination number depend on the number of unpaired electrons in the isolated metal ion.
The ligand electron pairs are donated into the directional hybrid orbitals of the metal.
Therefore, the chromium entity requires six octahedrally directed orbitals, whereas the platinum entity requires four square-planar orbitals.
142. Consider the following coordination entities:
P: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_6]^{3+}}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Ni(NH_3)_6]^{2+}}\)
R: \(\mathrm{[Fe(CN)_6]^{3-}}\)
The neutral atoms have the configurations \(\mathrm{Co:[Ar]\,3d^7 4s^2}\), \(\mathrm{Ni:[Ar]\,3d^8 4s^2}\) and \(\mathrm{Fe:[Ar]\,3d^6 4s^2}\). Which sequence gives the correct d-electron counts of the central metal ions in P, Q and R, respectively?
ⓐ. \(d^6,\ d^8,\ d^5\)
ⓑ. \(d^7,\ d^8,\ d^6\)
ⓒ. \(d^6,\ d^6,\ d^5\)
ⓓ. \(d^7,\ d^6,\ d^3\)
Correct Answer: \(d^6,\ d^8,\ d^5\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Oxidation state in P:}\)
Ammonia is neutral, so cobalt has oxidation state \(+3\).
The neutral cobalt atom has configuration:
\[
\mathrm{Co:[Ar]\,3d^7 4s^2}
\]
When cobalt forms \(\mathrm{Co^{3+}}\), the two \(4s\) electrons are removed before the remaining electron is removed from \(3d\).
Therefore:
\[
\mathrm{Co^{3+}:[Ar]\,3d^6}
\]
\(\textbf{Oxidation state in Q:}\)
The six ammonia ligands are neutral.
Nickel consequently has oxidation state \(+2\).
The neutral nickel atom is:
\[
\mathrm{Ni:[Ar]\,3d^8 4s^2}
\]
Removal of the two \(4s\) electrons gives:
\[
\mathrm{Ni^{2+}:[Ar]\,3d^8}
\]
\(\textbf{Oxidation state in R:}\)
Six cyanido ligands contribute a total charge of \(-6\).
The coordination entity carries charge \(-3\).
Therefore, the oxidation state \(x\) of iron satisfies:
\[
x+6(-1)=-3
\]
\[
x=+3
\]
The neutral iron atom has configuration:
\[
\mathrm{Fe:[Ar]\,3d^6 4s^2}
\]
Removal of two \(4s\) electrons and one \(3d\) electron gives:
\[
\mathrm{Fe^{3+}:[Ar]\,3d^5}
\]
\(\textbf{Electronic interpretation:}\)
The correct d-electron counts are six, eight and five, respectively.
These counts must be established before predicting electron pairing, hybridisation or magnetic behaviour.
The fact that P and Q both contain six ammonia ligands does not require their central metal ions to have identical electronic configurations.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
d^6,\ d^8,\ d^5
\]
143. Two octahedral coordination entities contain cobalt(III):
P: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_6]^{3+}}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[CoF_6]^{3-}}\)
In their standard valence-bond descriptions, P is diamagnetic, whereas Q is paramagnetic. Which combination correctly identifies their hybridisation and numbers of unpaired electrons?
ⓐ. P: \(sp^3d^2\), zero; Q: \(d^2sp^3\), four
ⓑ. P: \(d^2sp^3\), zero; Q: \(sp^3d^2\), four
ⓒ. P: \(d^2sp^3\), two; Q: \(sp^3d^2\), two
ⓓ. P: \(sp^3d^2\), four; Q: \(d^2sp^3\), zero
Correct Answer: P: \(d^2sp^3\), zero; Q: \(sp^3d^2\), four
Explanation: \(\textbf{Common metal-ion configuration:}\)
Cobalt has oxidation state \(+3\) in both coordination entities.
Its electronic configuration is:
\[
\mathrm{Co^{3+}:[Ar]\,3d^6}
\]
The two complexes therefore contain the same number of metal d electrons.
Their different magnetic properties arise from different electron-pairing arrangements.
\(\textbf{Entity P — inner-orbital arrangement:}\)
Ammonia produces a sufficiently strong ligand field for the standard cobalt(III) hexaammine complex to undergo electron pairing.
The six \(3d\) electrons occupy three orbitals as pairs.
This leaves two vacant inner \(3d\) orbitals available for hybridisation.
The metal uses two \(3d\), one \(4s\) and three \(4p\) orbitals.
The resulting hybridisation is:
\[
d^2sp^3
\]
All six d electrons are paired.
Therefore:
\[
n_P=0
\]
The complex is diamagnetic.
\(\textbf{Entity Q — outer-orbital arrangement:}\)
Fluoride is a weak-field ligand in this standard cobalt(III) comparison.
The six d electrons retain the high-spin arrangement.
One d orbital contains a pair of electrons, while four others remain singly occupied.
Therefore:
\[
n_Q=4
\]
Two inner \(3d\) orbitals are not available simultaneously for the required octahedral hybridisation.
The valence-bond description therefore uses the outer \(4d\) orbitals, along with \(4s\) and \(4p\).
Its hybridisation is:
\[
sp^3d^2
\]
The complex is paramagnetic.
\(\textbf{Comparison:}\)
Both coordination entities are octahedral and have coordination number six.
Their different magnetic properties are explained by electron pairing and the distinction between inner- and outer-orbital hybridisation.
The ligand identity changes the electronic arrangement without changing the cobalt oxidation state or coordination number.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
P:d^2sp^3,\ n=0;\qquad Q:sp^3d^2,\ n=4
\]
144. Consider the two octahedral iron(III) coordination entities:
P: \(\mathrm{[Fe(CN)_6]^{3-}}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[FeF_6]^{3-}}\)
Which statement correctly compares their magnetic behaviour and valence-bond hybridisation?
ⓐ. P is diamagnetic with \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation, while Q has five unpaired electrons with \(sp^3d^2\) hybridisation.
ⓑ. P has one unpaired electron with \(sp^3d^2\) hybridisation, while Q has five with \(d^2sp^3\).
ⓒ. P has one unpaired electron with \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation, while Q has five with \(sp^3d^2\).
ⓓ. Both have five unpaired electrons because iron is in oxidation state \(+3\) in each.
Correct Answer: P has one unpaired electron with \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation, while Q has five with \(sp^3d^2\).
Explanation: \(\textbf{Metal-ion configuration:}\)
Iron has oxidation state \(+3\) in both complexes.
The corresponding metal-ion configuration is:
\[
\mathrm{Fe^{3+}:[Ar]\,3d^5}
\]
\(\textbf{Strong-field cyanido complex:}\)
Cyanide produces a strong ligand field.
In \(\mathrm{[Fe(CN)_6]^{3-}}\), the five d electrons adopt the low-spin arrangement.
Two d orbitals contain electron pairs, one contains a single electron, and two remain vacant.
Thus:
\[
n_P=1
\]
The two vacant inner d orbitals permit \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation.
Since one electron remains unpaired, the complex is paramagnetic rather than diamagnetic.
\(\textbf{Weak-field fluorido complex:}\)
Fluoride is a weak-field ligand in this standard comparison.
The five d electrons occupy the five d orbitals singly in the high-spin arrangement.
Therefore:
\[
n_Q=5
\]
Two vacant inner d orbitals are unavailable.
The complex consequently uses \(sp^3d^2\) hybridisation involving outer d orbitals.
\(\textbf{Magnetic comparison:}\)
Both complexes are paramagnetic, but their numbers of unpaired electrons differ markedly.
The cyanido complex is weakly paramagnetic relative to the fluorido complex.
The example also demonstrates that a low-spin or inner-orbital complex need not be diamagnetic.
Low spin refers to the extent of electron pairing permitted by the electronic configuration.
For a \(d^5\) ion, the low-spin arrangement still contains one unpaired electron.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
P:d^2sp^3,\ n=1;\qquad Q:sp^3d^2,\ n=5
\]
145. Two four-coordinate nickel(II) entities are compared:
P: \(\mathrm{[NiCl_4]^{2-}}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Ni(CN)_4]^{2-}}\)
Both contain nickel with configuration \(3d^8\), but their observed magnetic properties differ. Which statement correctly relates ligand-field behaviour, hybridisation and geometry?
ⓐ. P is square planar and diamagnetic, whereas Q is tetrahedral and paramagnetic.
ⓑ. P is tetrahedral and paramagnetic, whereas Q is square planar and diamagnetic.
ⓒ. Both are square planar because nickel(II) has a \(d^8\) configuration.
ⓓ. Both are tetrahedral because each contains four unidentate ligands.
Correct Answer: P is tetrahedral and paramagnetic, whereas Q is square planar and diamagnetic.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Common electronic configuration:}\)
Nickel has oxidation state \(+2\) in both entities.
The neutral nickel atom has configuration \(\mathrm{[Ar]\,3d^8 4s^2}\).
The nickel(II) ion therefore has configuration:
\[
\mathrm{Ni^{2+}:[Ar]\,3d^8}
\]
Both complexes have coordination number four.
\(\textbf{Chlorido complex:}\)
Chloride is a weak-field ligand.
In the standard valence-bond description of \(\mathrm{[NiCl_4]^{2-}}\), the electrons do not undergo the pairing required for a square-planar inner-orbital arrangement.
The metal forms four \(sp^3\) hybrid orbitals.
These orbitals are directed tetrahedrally.
Two d electrons remain unpaired, so the complex is paramagnetic.
\(\textbf{Cyanido complex:}\)
Cyanide is a strong-field ligand.
In \(\mathrm{[Ni(CN)_4]^{2-}}\), the d electrons pair sufficiently to leave one inner d orbital vacant.
That orbital combines with one s and two p orbitals to form four \(dsp^2\) hybrid orbitals.
The resulting geometry is square planar.
All eight d electrons are paired, making the complex diamagnetic.
\(\textbf{Comparison:}\)
The nickel oxidation state and coordination number remain unchanged.
Nevertheless, the ligands produce different electron-pairing arrangements and geometries.
Thus, coordination number four alone cannot distinguish square-planar from tetrahedral hybridisation.
The ligand environment and magnetic evidence are both important in making the correct assignment.
146. Both \(\mathrm{[NiCl_4]^{2-}}\) and \(\mathrm{[Ni(CO)_4]}\) are tetrahedral coordination entities. The first is paramagnetic, whereas the second is diamagnetic. Which explanation is correct?
ⓐ. Nickel has oxidation state \(+2\) and configuration \(d^8\) in the first entity, but oxidation state zero and configuration \(d^{10}\) in the second.
ⓑ. Nickel has configuration \(d^8\) in both entities, but carbon monoxide makes the tetrahedral geometry square planar.
ⓒ. Nickel has oxidation state zero in both entities because their coordination numbers are four.
ⓓ. The chloride complex is paramagnetic because it contains four ligands, while the carbonyl complex is diamagnetic because its ligands are neutral.
Correct Answer: Nickel has oxidation state \(+2\) and configuration \(d^8\) in the first entity, but oxidation state zero and configuration \(d^{10}\) in the second.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Nickel in the chlorido complex:}\)
Each chloride ligand carries charge \(-1\).
The overall coordination-entity charge is \(-2\).
Therefore:
\[
x+4(-1)=-2
\]
\[
x=+2
\]
Nickel(II) has the electronic configuration:
\[
\mathrm{Ni^{2+}:[Ar]\,3d^8}
\]
The standard tetrahedral chlorido complex possesses two unpaired d electrons.
It is consequently paramagnetic.
\(\textbf{Nickel in the carbonyl complex:}\)
Carbon monoxide is a neutral ligand.
The complete entity \(\mathrm{[Ni(CO)_4]}\) is also neutral.
Therefore, nickel has oxidation state zero.
The neutral nickel atom has ten electrons available in its \(3d\) and \(4s\) valence orbitals.
In the valence-bond description of tetracarbonylnickel(0), these electrons occupy the \(3d\) orbitals as five pairs.
The resulting configuration is effectively \(3d^{10}\).
No d electron remains unpaired.
Therefore, \(\mathrm{[Ni(CO)_4]}\) is diamagnetic.
\(\textbf{Structural comparison:}\)
Both entities use four metal–ligand donor attachments and are tetrahedral.
Their opposite magnetic behaviours arise from different metal oxidation states and d-electron configurations.
The comparison disproves the idea that tetrahedral geometry alone determines whether a complex is paramagnetic.
It also shows why the neutrality of a ligand must be included when determining oxidation state.
147. The octahedral chromium(III) entity \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_6]^{3+}}\) is paramagnetic and can be described as an inner-orbital complex using \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation. Which statement correctly explains why its inner-orbital description does not require electron pairing in the \(3d\) subshell?
ⓐ. Chromium(III) has configuration \(3d^6\), and all six electrons are already paired.
ⓑ. Chromium(III) has configuration \(3d^5\), leaving no vacant \(3d\) orbitals.
ⓒ. Chromium(III) has configuration \(3d^3\), but its coordination number is only three.
ⓓ. Chromium(III) is \(3d^3\), with two empty 3d orbitals and three unpaired electrons.
Correct Answer: Chromium(III) is \(3d^3\), with two empty 3d orbitals and three unpaired electrons.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Chromium-ion configuration:}\)
The neutral chromium atom has configuration:
\[
\mathrm{Cr:[Ar]\,3d^5 4s^1}
\]
Formation of \(\mathrm{Cr^{3+}}\) removes the \(4s\) electron and two \(3d\) electrons.
Therefore:
\[
\mathrm{Cr^{3+}:[Ar]\,3d^3}
\]
\(\textbf{Distribution among d orbitals:}\)
A d subshell contains five orbitals.
The three electrons occupy three separate orbitals according to Hund's rule.
Their occupancy can be represented as:
\[
3d:\quad [\uparrow]\,[\uparrow]\,[\uparrow]\,[\,]\,[\,]
\]
Two \(3d\) orbitals are already vacant.
No additional pairing is required to make these two orbitals available.
\(\textbf{Hybrid-orbital construction:}\)
The two vacant \(3d\) orbitals combine with one \(4s\) and three \(4p\) orbitals.
This forms six \(d^2sp^3\) hybrid orbitals.
Six water molecules donate electron pairs into these orbitals.
The resulting coordination geometry is octahedral.
\(\textbf{Magnetic consequence:}\)
The three original \(3d\) electrons remain unpaired.
Therefore:
\[
n=3
\]
The complex is paramagnetic despite being an inner-orbital complex.
This demonstrates that inner-orbital hybridisation does not always require prior electron pairing.
The requirement depends on the number of occupied and vacant inner d orbitals available in the metal ion.
For \(d^1\), \(d^2\) and \(d^3\) ions, two vacant inner d orbitals are already available in the elementary valence-bond description.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\mathrm{Cr^{3+}:3d^3},\quad n=3
\]
148. The octahedral coordination entities P and Q contain different metal ions but the same ligand:
P: \(\mathrm{[Co(NH_3)_6]^{3+}}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Ni(NH_3)_6]^{2+}}\)
In their standard valence-bond descriptions, P is an inner-orbital diamagnetic complex, whereas Q is an outer-orbital paramagnetic complex. Which explanation is most appropriate?
ⓐ. Ammonia changes from a strong-field ligand in P to an anionic ligand in Q.
ⓑ. The six ammonia ligands donate twelve pairs of electrons in Q but only six pairs in P.
ⓒ. Different d-electron counts affect whether two inner d orbitals are available for octahedral bonding.
ⓓ. Nickel(II) has a lower coordination number than cobalt(III), requiring outer-orbital hybridisation.
Correct Answer: Different d-electron counts affect whether two inner d orbitals are available for octahedral bonding.
Explanation: The ligand identity is the same in both coordination entities.
Each contains six neutral ammonia molecules and has coordination number six.
Ammonia therefore supplies six nitrogen donor atoms and six electron pairs to each central metal.
The difference cannot be explained by treating ammonia as an anion in only one of the compounds.
\(\textbf{Cobalt(III) arrangement:}\)
Cobalt(III) has the configuration \(3d^6\).
In the standard hexaamminecobalt(III) complex, pairing produces two vacant inner \(3d\) orbitals.
These orbitals participate in \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation.
All six d electrons become paired, and the complex is diamagnetic.
\(\textbf{Nickel(II) arrangement:}\)
Nickel(II) has the configuration \(3d^8\).
Eight electrons cannot be accommodated in only three \(3d\) orbitals because each orbital holds at most two electrons.
Therefore, two simultaneously vacant \(3d\) orbitals cannot be created by pairing the eight electrons.
The required octahedral hybrid orbitals consequently involve outer \(4d\) orbitals.
The corresponding hybridisation is \(sp^3d^2\).
Two d electrons remain unpaired, making the standard nickel(II) hexaammine complex paramagnetic.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The same ligand can produce different valence-bond arrangements when the metal ions possess different d-electron configurations.
Thus, ligand identity alone is insufficient to determine inner- or outer-orbital hybridisation.
The metal oxidation state, resulting d-electron count and availability of orbitals must be considered together.
149. Two octahedral manganese(III) entities are represented by:
P: \(\mathrm{[Mn(CN)_6]^{3-}}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[MnCl_6]^{3-}}\)
The first is a low-spin complex, whereas the second is a high-spin complex. Which statement correctly compares the number of unpaired electrons and the inner-/outer-orbital character of these entities?
ⓐ. P has zero unpaired electrons and is inner orbital; Q has four unpaired electrons and is outer orbital.
ⓑ. P has one unpaired electron and is inner orbital; Q has five unpaired electrons and is outer orbital.
ⓒ. P has two unpaired electrons and is outer orbital; Q has four unpaired electrons and is inner orbital.
ⓓ. P has two unpaired electrons and is inner orbital; Q has four unpaired electrons and is outer orbital.
Correct Answer: P has two unpaired electrons and is inner orbital; Q has four unpaired electrons and is outer orbital.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Metal-ion electronic configuration:}\)
Manganese(III) has the configuration:
\[
\mathrm{Mn^{3+}:[Ar]\,3d^4}
\]
Both complexes therefore contain four metal d electrons.
\(\textbf{Strong-field cyanido complex:}\)
Cyanide produces a strong ligand field.
In the low-spin arrangement, the four d electrons distribute among the lower-energy orbitals so that one orbital contains an electron pair and two others each contain one electron.
The occupancy can be represented schematically as:
\[
3d:\quad [\uparrow\downarrow]\,[\uparrow]\,[\uparrow]\,[\,]\,[\,]
\]
Two inner d orbitals remain vacant.
Therefore, the complex can use \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation.
The number of unpaired electrons is:
\[
n_P=2
\]
\(\textbf{Weak-field chlorido complex:}\)
Chloride is a weak-field ligand.
In the high-spin arrangement, the four d electrons occupy four separate orbitals.
The schematic occupancy is:
\[
3d:\quad [\uparrow]\,[\uparrow]\,[\uparrow]\,[\uparrow]\,[\,]
\]
There is only one vacant inner d orbital.
The octahedral complex consequently uses outer-orbital \(sp^3d^2\) hybridisation in this valence-bond description.
The number of unpaired electrons is:
\[
n_Q=4
\]
\(\textbf{Comparison:}\)
Both complexes are paramagnetic.
However, the cyanido complex contains fewer unpaired electrons because more electron pairing occurs.
The weak-field complex retains the maximum number of unpaired electrons for the \(d^4\) configuration.
The example demonstrates that high spin does not necessarily mean five unpaired electrons.
The number depends on the actual d-electron count of the metal ion.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
P:d^2sp^3,\ n=2;\qquad Q:sp^3d^2,\ n=4
\]
150. Consider the two octahedral iron cyanide coordination entities:
P: \(\mathrm{[Fe(CN)_6]^{4-}}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Fe(CN)_6]^{3-}}\)
Both are treated as low-spin complexes with inner-orbital hybridisation. Which statement correctly explains why one is diamagnetic and the other paramagnetic?
ⓐ. P contains iron(II) with \(d^6\) configuration and no unpaired electrons; Q contains iron(III) with \(d^5\) configuration and one unpaired electron.
ⓑ. P contains iron(III) with \(d^5\) configuration and one unpaired electron; Q contains iron(II) with \(d^6\) configuration and none.
ⓒ. Both contain \(d^6\) metal ions, but their coordination-entity charges cause different magnetic behaviour.
ⓓ. P is tetrahedral and diamagnetic, while Q is octahedral and paramagnetic.
Correct Answer: P contains iron(II) with \(d^6\) configuration and no unpaired electrons; Q contains iron(III) with \(d^5\) configuration and one unpaired electron.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Oxidation state in P:}\)
Each cyanido ligand carries charge \(-1\).
For the entity with charge \(-4\):
\[
x+6(-1)=-4
\]
\[
x=+2
\]
Iron(II) has the electronic configuration:
\[
\mathrm{Fe^{2+}:[Ar]\,3d^6}
\]
In the low-spin arrangement, all six d electrons are paired.
Two inner \(3d\) orbitals are vacant and can participate in \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation.
The number of unpaired electrons is:
\[
n_P=0
\]
Therefore, P is diamagnetic.
\(\textbf{Oxidation state in Q:}\)
For the entity with charge \(-3\):
\[
x+6(-1)=-3
\]
\[
x=+3
\]
Iron(III) has the electronic configuration:
\[
\mathrm{Fe^{3+}:[Ar]\,3d^5}
\]
In the low-spin arrangement, four electrons form two pairs and the fifth remains unpaired.
Two inner d orbitals remain vacant for \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation.
Thus:
\[
n_Q=1
\]
Q is consequently paramagnetic.
\(\textbf{Key inference:}\)
Both complexes contain the same strong-field ligand and have the same octahedral coordination geometry.
Their different magnetic behaviour arises from the oxidation-state difference, which changes the d-electron count.
The low-spin designation does not guarantee the complete absence of unpaired electrons.
For \(d^5\), the low-spin arrangement contains one unpaired electron, whereas low-spin \(d^6\) contains none.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
P:\mathrm{Fe^{2+}},\,d^6,\,n=0;\qquad Q:\mathrm{Fe^{3+}},\,d^5,\,n=1
\]
151. A first-row transition-metal ion has configuration \(3d^6\) and forms a six-coordinate octahedral complex. Two alternative electron arrangements are described.
Arrangement P: The five \(3d\) orbitals contain six electrons distributed as two electrons in each of three orbitals, with the remaining two orbitals empty.
Arrangement Q: The five \(3d\) orbitals contain six electrons distributed as one paired orbital and four singly occupied orbitals.
The complex is assumed to follow the standard valence-bond hybridisation scheme corresponding to the specified arrangement.
Which statement correctly relates the two arrangements to hybridisation and magnetic behaviour?
ⓐ. P requires \(sp^3d^2\) hybridisation and is diamagnetic; Q requires \(d^2sp^3\) and is paramagnetic.
ⓑ. Both require \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation because each contains six d electrons.
ⓒ. P requires \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation and is diamagnetic; Q requires \(sp^3d^2\) and has four unpaired electrons.
ⓓ. P requires \(dsp^2\) hybridisation; Q requires \(sp^3\) hybridisation because four electrons are unpaired.
Correct Answer: P requires \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation and is diamagnetic; Q requires \(sp^3d^2\) and has four unpaired electrons.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Electron occupancy in P:}\)
Arrangement P contains three fully occupied \(3d\) orbitals.
Each contains a pair of electrons.
The remaining two \(3d\) orbitals are vacant.
Therefore, two inner d orbitals are immediately available for octahedral hybridisation.
They combine with one s and three p orbitals.
The resulting hybridisation is:
\[
d^2sp^3
\]
All six d electrons are paired.
Hence:
\[
n_P=0
\]
The corresponding complex is diamagnetic.
\(\textbf{Electron occupancy in Q:}\)
Arrangement Q contains one doubly occupied d orbital and four singly occupied d orbitals.
The total electron count is:
\[
N_d=2+4(1)=6
\]
However, none of the five inner d orbitals is vacant.
Therefore, the two vacant inner d orbitals required for \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation are unavailable.
The valence-bond model consequently uses outer d orbitals.
The corresponding octahedral hybridisation is:
\[
sp^3d^2
\]
The four singly occupied d orbitals give:
\[
n_Q=4
\]
The complex is paramagnetic.
\(\textbf{Comparison:}\)
Both arrangements contain six d electrons and correspond to coordination number six.
They differ in electron pairing and the availability of vacant inner d orbitals.
The number of d electrons alone does not determine hybridisation without considering their occupancy.
The orbital diagram provides the decisive information.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
P:d^2sp^3,\ n=0;\qquad Q:sp^3d^2,\ n=4
\]
152. Match the coordination entities in List I with the appropriate valence-bond descriptions in List II.
| List I — Coordination entity | List II — Description |
| P. \(\mathrm{[Cr(H_2O)_6]^{3+}}\) | 1. \(sp^3\), tetrahedral, two unpaired electrons |
| Q. \(\mathrm{[Co(C_2O_4)_3]^{3-}}\) | 2. \(d^2sp^3\), octahedral, three unpaired electrons |
| R. \(\mathrm{[NiCl_4]^{2-}}\) | 3. \(sp^3d^2\), octahedral, four unpaired electrons |
| S. \(\mathrm{[CoF_6]^{3-}}\) | 4. \(d^2sp^3\), octahedral, zero unpaired electrons |
Which matching is correct for these standard coordination entities?
ⓐ. P–2, Q–4, R–1, S–3
ⓑ. P–4, Q–2, R–1, S–3
ⓒ. P–2, Q–3, R–4, S–1
ⓓ. P–1, Q–4, R–2, S–3
Correct Answer: P–2, Q–4, R–1, S–3
Explanation: The chromium(III) ion in P has configuration \(3d^3\).
Three d orbitals are singly occupied, while two remain vacant.
The six water donor atoms can therefore coordinate through an inner-orbital \(d^2sp^3\) arrangement without requiring prior d-electron pairing.
P has octahedral geometry and three unpaired electrons, so P matches 2.
In Q, cobalt has oxidation state \(+3\), giving configuration \(3d^6\).
The standard tris(oxalato)cobaltate(III) complex is an inner-orbital complex.
Its six d electrons are paired, and the hybridisation is \(d^2sp^3\).
Q is therefore octahedral and diamagnetic, so Q matches 4.
In R, nickel has oxidation state \(+2\) and configuration \(3d^8\).
The weak-field chlorido complex adopts tetrahedral \(sp^3\) hybridisation in the standard valence-bond description.
Two d electrons remain unpaired, so R matches 1.
In S, cobalt again has oxidation state \(+3\) and configuration \(3d^6\).
However, the weak-field fluoride ligands favour the high-spin arrangement.
Four d electrons remain unpaired, and the complex uses outer-orbital \(sp^3d^2\) hybridisation.
S therefore matches 3.
The correct matching is P–2, Q–4, R–1 and S–3.
The comparison demonstrates why hybridisation and magnetic behaviour must be inferred from the metal-ion configuration, ligand environment and coordination geometry together.
153. A nickel(II) ion with configuration \(3d^8\) forms the octahedral coordination entity \(\mathrm{[Ni(NH_3)_6]^{2+}}\). A student argues that sufficiently strong electron pairing should always make two inner \(3d\) orbitals available for \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation. Which response correctly identifies the error?
ⓐ. Nickel(II) has only three d orbitals, so the concept of two vacant d orbitals is inapplicable.
ⓑ. The six ammonia ligands use only four donor atoms, so octahedral hybridisation is unnecessary.
ⓒ. Eight d electrons cannot occupy just three inner d orbitals, so two vacant inner d orbitals are unavailable.
ⓓ. The charge \(+2\) prevents any inner d orbital from participating in metal–ligand bonding.
Correct Answer: Eight d electrons cannot occupy just three inner d orbitals, so two vacant inner d orbitals are unavailable.
Explanation: The nickel(II) ion has eight electrons in its \(3d\) subshell.
A d subshell contains five orbitals.
Each orbital can accommodate at most two electrons of opposite spins.
The inner-orbital octahedral hybridisation \(d^2sp^3\) requires two vacant \(3d\) orbitals.
If two d orbitals were vacant, all eight electrons would have to occupy the remaining three orbitals.
However, three orbitals can hold at most six electrons.
Therefore, eight d electrons cannot be accommodated while leaving two inner d orbitals vacant.
This is an electron-capacity restriction, not merely a question of whether a ligand produces a stronger field.
In the standard valence-bond description, the nickel(II) hexaammine complex consequently uses outer \(4d\) orbitals.
Its hybridisation is \(sp^3d^2\), and its geometry is octahedral.
Two electrons remain unpaired in the \(3d^8\) arrangement, so the complex is paramagnetic.
The coordination number is six because six ammonia molecules donate through six nitrogen atoms.
The charge on the complex is \(+2\) because ammonia is neutral and nickel is in oxidation state \(+2\).
Neither the coordination number nor the entity charge explains the inner-orbital restriction by itself.
The decisive reasoning is the maximum occupancy of the three d orbitals that would remain after reserving two for hybridisation.
154. The coordination entities \(\mathrm{[Ni(CN)_4]^{2-}}\) and \(\mathrm{[Ni(CO)_4]}\) are both diamagnetic. Which statement correctly evaluates whether their common magnetic behaviour establishes a common geometry?
ⓐ. Both must be square planar because the absence of unpaired electrons uniquely requires \(dsp^2\) hybridisation in every four-coordinate nickel complex.
ⓑ. Both must be tetrahedral because four unidentate ligands necessarily require \(sp^3\) hybridisation, regardless of nickel oxidation state.
ⓒ. The cyanido complex is tetrahedral and the carbonyl complex square planar because the signs of their entity charges alone determine geometry.
ⓓ. The cyanido complex is square planar, while the carbonyl complex is tetrahedral; diamagnetism alone does not establish a unique four-coordinate geometry.
Correct Answer: The cyanido complex is square planar, while the carbonyl complex is tetrahedral; diamagnetism alone does not establish a unique four-coordinate geometry.
Explanation: Both coordination entities contain four unidentate ligands and therefore have coordination number four.
However, their central-metal oxidation states differ.
In \(\mathrm{[Ni(CN)_4]^{2-}}\), four cyanido ligands contribute charge \(-4\).
Nickel consequently has oxidation state \(+2\) and electronic configuration \(3d^8\).
Cyanide produces a strong ligand field in this standard nickel(II) complex.
Electron pairing permits the formation of four \(dsp^2\) hybrid orbitals.
The resulting geometry is square planar.
All eight d electrons are paired, making the complex diamagnetic.
In \(\mathrm{[Ni(CO)_4]}\), carbon monoxide is neutral.
Nickel is therefore in oxidation state zero and has an effectively filled \(3d^{10}\) subshell in the valence-bond description.
Four \(sp^3\) hybrid orbitals form the tetrahedral arrangement.
The filled d subshell contains no unpaired electrons, so this complex is also diamagnetic.
Thus, the two entities possess different hybridisation schemes and geometries despite exhibiting the same magnetic classification.
Diamagnetism establishes the absence of unpaired electrons but does not uniquely identify square-planar geometry.
The full ligand and metal-ion context must be considered before drawing a structural conclusion.
155. A chemist studies an octahedral coordination entity before and after replacing some coordinated ligands. The coordination number and central-metal oxidation state remain unchanged, and magnetic measurements suggest the same number of unpaired electrons in both forms. However, the wavelengths of light absorbed by the two forms are different. Which assessment of the bonding models is most appropriate?
ⓐ. The valence-bond approach alone must predict the exact absorption wavelengths because hybridisation determines every spectral property.
ⓑ. Changing ligands can change crystal-field splitting without changing coordination number or electron pairing.
ⓒ. Different absorption wavelengths prove that the central-metal oxidation state has changed despite the given measurements.
ⓓ. Both forms must have identical d-orbital splitting because their coordination numbers and magnetic behaviours are unchanged.
Correct Answer: Changing ligands can change crystal-field splitting without changing coordination number or electron pairing.
Explanation: The valence-bond approach provides a qualitative description of metal–ligand bonding through suitable hybrid orbitals.
It is useful for explaining many coordination geometries and aspects of magnetic behaviour.
However, the elementary valence-bond approach does not satisfactorily explain the colours of coordination compounds or predict their absorption wavelengths.
The crystal-field approach considers the influence of surrounding ligands on the energies of the metal d orbitals.
In an octahedral environment, the ligand field separates the five d orbitals into lower-energy and higher-energy sets.
The magnitude of this splitting depends on the ligand environment, among other factors.
Replacing one type of ligand with another may therefore change the splitting energy.
A suitable electronic transition between the split levels can absorb radiation whose photon energy corresponds to the energy difference.
Consequently, changing the splitting can change the wavelength associated with absorption.
The number of unpaired electrons may remain unchanged if the altered ligand field does not change the relevant electron-pairing arrangement.
The central-metal oxidation state may also remain fixed during ligand replacement.
Thus, identical coordination numbers and magnetic classifications do not require identical absorption spectra.
The observation is consistent with a limitation of the valence-bond approach and a useful application of elementary crystal-field theory.
However, a particular absorption wavelength cannot be inferred from ligand identity alone without sufficient information about the electronic energy levels and allowed transitions.
156. An octahedral metal complex is formed when six ligands approach the central metal ion along the positive and negative directions of the three Cartesian axes. Which statement correctly explains the splitting of the five metal d orbitals according to crystal-field theory?
ⓐ. The \(d_{xy}\), \(d_{yz}\) and \(d_{xz}\) orbitals form the higher-energy \(e_g\) set because they point directly towards the ligands.
ⓑ. The \(d_{z^2}\) and \(d_{x^2-y^2}\) orbitals form the lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) set because their electron densities avoid the coordinate axes.
ⓒ. All five d orbitals remain degenerate because the six ligands are symmetrically arranged around the metal.
ⓓ. The \(d_{z^2}\) and \(d_{x^2-y^2}\) orbitals form the higher-energy \(e_g\) set, while \(d_{xy}\), \(d_{yz}\) and \(d_{xz}\) form the lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) set.
Correct Answer: The \(d_{z^2}\) and \(d_{x^2-y^2}\) orbitals form the higher-energy \(e_g\) set, while \(d_{xy}\), \(d_{yz}\) and \(d_{xz}\) form the lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) set.
Explanation: In an isolated gaseous metal atom or ion, the five d orbitals possess the same energy in the elementary crystal-field description.
This equality of energy is called degeneracy.
When ligands approach the metal in an octahedral arrangement, the field produced by their charges or dipoles is no longer spherically symmetrical.
The different spatial orientations of the d orbitals consequently become important.
The \(d_{z^2}\) and \(d_{x^2-y^2}\) orbitals have electron densities directed substantially along the coordinate axes.
Since the six ligands approach along these axes, electrons occupying these orbitals experience relatively greater electrostatic repulsion.
Their energies increase relative to the average d-orbital energy.
These two orbitals constitute the \(e_g\) set.
The \(d_{xy}\), \(d_{yz}\) and \(d_{xz}\) orbitals have electron densities directed between the coordinate axes.
They consequently experience relatively less repulsion from the approaching ligands.
These three orbitals constitute the lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) set.
Thus, octahedral splitting produces two higher-energy orbitals and three lower-energy orbitals.
The splitting occurs despite the symmetrical arrangement of the six ligands because the ligand field is not spherically symmetrical.
157. In an ideal octahedral crystal field, the three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals are lowered equally in energy, while the two \(e_g\) orbitals are raised equally. The separation between the two sets is \(15\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\). Taking the energy of the unsplit d-orbital level as zero, what are the respective energy shifts of each \(t_{2g}\) orbital and each \(e_g\) orbital?
ⓐ. \(-6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) and \(+9\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\)
ⓑ. \(-9\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) and \(+6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\)
ⓒ. \(-7\,500\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) and \(+7\,500\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\)
ⓓ. \(-5\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) and \(+10\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\)
Correct Answer: \(-6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) and \(+9\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Octahedral splitting relation:}\)
The five initially degenerate d orbitals split into three lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) orbitals and two higher-energy \(e_g\) orbitals.
The separation between their energy levels is denoted by \(\Delta_o\).
The lower set moves down by \(0.4\Delta_o\), while the upper set moves up by \(0.6\Delta_o\).
The reference energy is the average energy of the five unsplit d orbitals.
\(\textbf{Energy shift of the lower set:}\)
\[
E(t_{2g})=-0.4\Delta_o
\]
Substituting the given splitting:
\[
E(t_{2g})=-0.4(15\,000)
\]
\[
E(t_{2g})=-6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Energy shift of the upper set:}\)
\[
E(e_g)=+0.6\Delta_o
\]
\[
E(e_g)=+0.6(15\,000)
\]
\[
E(e_g)=+9\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Separation check:}\)
\[
\Delta_o=9\,000-(-6\,000)
\]
\[
\Delta_o=15\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Barycentre check:}\)
The total energy shift of all five orbitals must be zero in the elementary model.
\[
3(-6\,000)+2(+9\,000)=0
\]
This confirms conservation of the average d-orbital energy.
Equal upward and downward shifts would be incorrect because the two sets contain different numbers of orbitals.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{E(t_{2g})=-6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}},\quad E(e_g)=+9\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}}
\]
158. Two octahedral iron(II) complexes P and Q contain the same \(d^6\) metal-ion configuration. Orbital-occupancy measurements give the following results:
| Complex | \(t_{2g}\) electrons | \(e_g\) electrons |
| P | 6 | 0 |
| Q | 4 | 2 |
Assume the complexes are in their ordinary ground states and follow the elementary octahedral crystal-field model. Which inference is correct?
ⓐ. P has \(\Delta_o\lt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\) and four unpaired electrons; Q has \(\Delta_o\gt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\) and none.
ⓑ. P has \(\Delta_o\gt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\) and no unpaired electrons; Q has \(\Delta_o\lt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\) and four unpaired electrons.
ⓒ. Both have no unpaired electrons because the total d-electron count is six.
ⓓ. Both have four unpaired electrons because occupation of the lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) set does not permit pairing.
Correct Answer: P has \(\Delta_o\gt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\) and no unpaired electrons; Q has \(\Delta_o\lt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\) and four unpaired electrons.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpretation of P:}\)
The metal ion has six d electrons.
All six occupy the lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) set in P.
Since that set contains three orbitals, its complete occupancy requires three electron pairs.
The corresponding configuration is \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\).
This is the low-spin arrangement of an octahedral \(d^6\) ion.
It is favoured when the crystal-field splitting exceeds the relevant pairing energy.
Therefore, \(\Delta_o\gt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\) for P under the stated elementary model.
All electrons are paired, so P is diamagnetic.
\(\textbf{Interpretation of Q:}\)
Q has the arrangement \(t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{2}\).
The four \(t_{2g}\) electrons occupy three orbitals, producing one pair and two singly occupied orbitals.
The two \(e_g\) electrons occupy the two upper orbitals singly.
Consequently, Q contains four unpaired electrons.
This is the high-spin arrangement of a \(d^6\) octahedral ion.
It is favoured when the splitting is insufficient to compensate for additional electron pairing.
Thus, \(\Delta_o\lt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\) for Q.
\(\textbf{Combined inference:}\)
P and Q have identical metal oxidation states and d-electron counts.
Their different electronic occupancies reflect different relationships between splitting energy and pairing energy.
The comparison demonstrates why the \(t_{2g}\) electron count alone must be interpreted together with orbital capacities and spin pairing.
159. A metal ion with configuration \(d^3\) is placed in two octahedral ligand fields, one weak and one strong. A different metal ion with configuration \(d^5\) is also examined in weak and strong octahedral fields. Assume that the weak fields satisfy \(\Delta_o\lt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\), whereas the strong fields satisfy \(\Delta_o\gt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\). Which statement correctly describes the number of unpaired electrons?
ⓐ. The \(d^3\) ion changes from three to one, while the \(d^5\) ion changes from five to three.
ⓑ. Both ions become diamagnetic in the strong field because all electrons occupy \(t_{2g}\).
ⓒ. The \(d^3\) ion changes from three to zero, while the \(d^5\) ion changes from five to one.
ⓓ. The \(d^3\) ion retains three unpaired electrons, while the \(d^5\) ion changes from five to one.
Correct Answer: The \(d^3\) ion retains three unpaired electrons, while the \(d^5\) ion changes from five to one.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Behaviour of the }d^3\textbf{ ion:}\)
In an octahedral field, the three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals lie below the two \(e_g\) orbitals.
The first three d electrons enter the three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals singly according to Hund's rule.
The configuration is therefore \(t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{0}\).
No electron needs to enter \(e_g\), and no electron needs to pair prematurely.
Consequently, the usual weak-field versus strong-field competition does not produce two distinct spin states for the \(d^3\) configuration.
The number of unpaired electrons remains three in both cases.
\(\textbf{Behaviour of the }d^5\textbf{ ion in a weak field:}\)
When \(\Delta_o\lt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\), occupying the upper \(e_g\) orbitals is preferred over additional pairing in \(t_{2g}\).
The high-spin configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{2}
\]
All five electrons are unpaired.
\(\textbf{Behaviour of the }d^5\textbf{ ion in a strong field:}\)
When \(\Delta_o\gt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\), electrons pair within the lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) orbitals.
The low-spin configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{0}
\]
Two \(t_{2g}\) orbitals contain pairs, while the third contains one unpaired electron.
Therefore, the number of unpaired electrons becomes one.
\(\textbf{Conclusion:}\)
High-spin and low-spin alternatives do not occur for every octahedral d-electron count.
The distinction is important for \(d^4\) through \(d^7\) configurations, whereas ordinary \(d^1\) through \(d^3\) filling has no comparable pairing competition.
160. Two hypothetical octahedral complexes of the same \(d^6\) metal ion have the splitting and pairing energies given below. Assume that these quantities adequately determine the spin state in the elementary crystal-field model.
| Complex | \(\Delta_o\) | Pairing energy \(P_{\mathrm{pair}}\) |
| X | \(12\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) | \(16\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) |
| Y | \(22\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) | \(16\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) |
Which combination correctly gives the electron configurations and the decrease in the number of unpaired electrons on going from X to Y?
ⓐ. X: \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\); Y: \(t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{2}\); decrease by four
ⓑ. X: \(t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{2}\); Y: \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\); decrease by two
ⓒ. X: \(t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{2}\); Y: \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\); decrease by four
ⓓ. X: \(t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{3}\); Y: \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\); decrease by six
Correct Answer: X: \(t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{2}\); Y: \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\); decrease by four
Explanation: \(\textbf{Spin-state criterion:}\)
For an octahedral \(d^6\) ion, a competition exists between occupying higher-energy \(e_g\) orbitals and pairing more electrons in the lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) orbitals.
The relative magnitudes of \(\Delta_o\) and \(P_{\mathrm{pair}}\) determine the preferred arrangement.
\(\textbf{Complex X:}\)
\[
\Delta_o=12\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
\[
P_{\mathrm{pair}}=16\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\Delta_o\lt P_{\mathrm{pair}}
\]
X is high spin.
Its configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{2}
\]
There are two unpaired electrons in \(t_{2g}\) and two in \(e_g\).
Hence:
\[
n_X=2+2=4
\]
\(\textbf{Complex Y:}\)
\[
\Delta_o=22\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
Since:
\[
\Delta_o\gt P_{\mathrm{pair}}
\]
Y is low spin.
Its configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}
\]
All six electrons are paired.
Therefore:
\[
n_Y=0
\]
\(\textbf{Change in unpaired-electron count:}\)
\[
\Delta n=n_X-n_Y
\]
\[
\Delta n=4-0=4
\]
The metal-ion d-electron count remains six throughout.
The difference arises entirely from the changed orbital splitting relative to pairing energy.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
n_X=4,\quad n_Y=0,\quad \text{decrease}=4
\]
161. A \(d^7\) metal ion forms two octahedral complexes P and Q. In P, the crystal-field splitting is smaller than the pairing energy; in Q, it is larger. Which pair of electronic configurations and unpaired-electron counts is correct?
ⓐ. P: \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{2}\), three unpaired; Q: \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{1}\), one unpaired
ⓑ. P: \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{2}\), one unpaired; Q: \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{1}\), three unpaired
ⓒ. P: \(t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{3}\), three unpaired; Q: \(t_{2g}^{7}e_g^{0}\), one unpaired
ⓓ. P: \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{1}\), one unpaired; Q: \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{2}\), three unpaired
Correct Answer: P: \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{2}\), three unpaired; Q: \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{1}\), one unpaired
Explanation: \(\textbf{Weak-field arrangement:}\)
The \(d^7\) ion contains seven d electrons.
In an octahedral field, the three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals lie below the two \(e_g\) orbitals.
When \(\Delta_o\lt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\), the complex favours high-spin filling.
The resulting configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{2}
\]
The five \(t_{2g}\) electrons produce two electron pairs and one unpaired electron.
The two \(e_g\) electrons occupy separate orbitals.
Therefore:
\[
n_P=1+2=3
\]
\(\textbf{Strong-field arrangement:}\)
When \(\Delta_o\gt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\), pairing within \(t_{2g}\) is preferred.
Six electrons completely occupy the three lower-energy orbitals.
The seventh electron enters an \(e_g\) orbital.
The configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{1}
\]
Only the \(e_g\) electron remains unpaired.
Thus:
\[
n_Q=1
\]
\(\textbf{Orbital-capacity check:}\)
The \(t_{2g}\) set contains three orbitals and can accommodate at most six electrons.
Therefore, a proposed configuration such as \(t_{2g}^{7}e_g^{0}\) is impossible.
The weak-field configuration also cannot contain three electrons in the two \(e_g\) orbitals while retaining the stated high-spin ground-state distribution.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
P:t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{2},\ n=3;\qquad Q:t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{1},\ n=1
\]
162. Consider idealised octahedral and tetrahedral complexes of the same \(d^4\) metal ion, with identical ligand types and metal–ligand distances. The octahedral splitting is \(18\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\), while the pairing energy is \(12\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\). Assume \(\Delta_t=\frac49\Delta_o\). Which statement correctly compares their spin states and numbers of unpaired electrons?
ⓐ. Both are low spin and have two unpaired electrons because the metal-ion configuration is unchanged.
ⓑ. The octahedral complex is high spin with four unpaired electrons, while the tetrahedral complex is low spin with two.
ⓒ. Both are high spin with four unpaired electrons because tetrahedral splitting reverses the octahedral energy ordering.
ⓓ. The octahedral complex is low spin with two unpaired electrons, while the tetrahedral complex is high spin with four.
Correct Answer: The octahedral complex is low spin with two unpaired electrons, while the tetrahedral complex is high spin with four.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Octahedral splitting criterion:}\)
The octahedral splitting is:
\[
\Delta_o=18\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
The pairing energy is:
\[
P_{\mathrm{pair}}=12\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\Delta_o\gt P_{\mathrm{pair}}
\]
The octahedral \(d^4\) complex favours the low-spin configuration:
\[
t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{0}
\]
Three electrons initially occupy the three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals singly.
The fourth pairs with one of them.
Thus:
\[
n_{\mathrm{oct}}=2
\]
\(\textbf{Tetrahedral splitting magnitude:}\)
For the specified idealised comparison:
\[
\Delta_t=\frac49\Delta_o
\]
Substituting:
\[
\Delta_t=\frac49(18\,000)
\]
\[
\Delta_t=8\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
Comparison with pairing energy gives:
\[
8\,000\lt 12\,000
\]
Therefore:
\[
\Delta_t\lt P_{\mathrm{pair}}
\]
\(\textbf{Tetrahedral electron arrangement:}\)
In a tetrahedral field, the lower-energy set is \(e\), containing two orbitals.
The higher-energy set is \(t_2\), containing three orbitals.
For the high-spin \(d^4\) arrangement:
\[
e^2t_2^2
\]
All four electrons occupy separate orbitals.
Hence:
\[
n_{\mathrm{tet}}=4
\]
\(\textbf{Combined interpretation:}\)
The tetrahedral splitting is smaller than the corresponding octahedral splitting.
It is therefore insufficient to favour additional electron pairing in this example.
The change in geometry reverses the relative order of the two orbital sets and changes their energy separation.
Together, these effects account for the different spin states.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\Delta_t=8\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}},\quad n_{\mathrm{oct}}=2,\quad n_{\mathrm{tet}}=4}
\]
163. A metal ion has a \(d^8\) configuration and forms an octahedral complex. Its ligand field is progressively strengthened without changing the metal oxidation state or octahedral geometry. Assume the ordinary ground-state orbital-filling model throughout. Which statement is correct?
ⓐ. The configuration changes from \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{2}\) to \(t_{2g}^{8}e_g^{0}\), removing both unpaired electrons.
ⓑ. The configuration remains \(t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{4}\) because both sets must contain equal numbers of electrons.
ⓒ. The configuration changes from \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{3}\) to \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{2}\), reducing the unpaired-electron count from four to two.
ⓓ. The configuration remains \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{2}\) with two unpaired electrons because the lower set has a capacity of six electrons.
Correct Answer: The configuration remains \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{2}\) with two unpaired electrons because the lower set has a capacity of six electrons.
Explanation: An octahedral field splits the five d orbitals into three lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) orbitals and two higher-energy \(e_g\) orbitals.
Each orbital can hold at most two electrons.
The \(t_{2g}\) set therefore accommodates a maximum of six electrons.
A \(d^8\) metal ion contains eight d electrons.
Six electrons occupy the three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals completely.
The remaining two must occupy the \(e_g\) set.
Since this set contains two degenerate orbitals in an ideal octahedral field, the two electrons occupy them singly according to Hund's rule.
The ordinary ground-state configuration is consequently \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{2}\).
The number of unpaired electrons is two.
Strengthening the octahedral field increases the energy separation between the orbital sets.
However, it does not increase the electron capacity of the \(t_{2g}\) set.
An arrangement such as \(t_{2g}^{8}e_g^{0}\) would exceed that capacity and is forbidden.
Therefore, the usual high-spin versus low-spin distinction characteristic of \(d^4\) through \(d^7\) octahedral ions does not create an alternative low-spin \(d^8\) occupancy here.
The conclusion applies to the stated ideal octahedral field and should not be transferred automatically to four-coordinate square-planar \(d^8\) complexes.
164. Four octahedral complexes of the same metal ion in the same oxidation state contain only one ligand type each. The ligands are \(\mathrm{F^-}\), \(\mathrm{H_2O}\), en and \(\mathrm{CN^-}\). Assume the complexes have comparable metal–ligand environments so that the NCERT spectrochemical ordering is applicable. Which sequence correctly represents increasing crystal-field splitting?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{CN^-\lt en\lt H_2O\lt F^-}\)
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{H_2O\lt F^-\lt CN^-\lt en}\)
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{F^-\lt H_2O\lt en\lt CN^-}\)
ⓓ. \(\mathrm{F^-\lt en\lt H_2O\lt CN^-}\)
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{F^-\lt H_2O\lt en\lt CN^-}\)
Explanation: The spectrochemical series arranges ligands according to increasing crystal-field splitting strength.
It is an experimentally established ordering rather than a simple ranking by ligand charge.
Fluoride lies towards the weak-field region of the usual series.
Water is a stronger-field ligand than fluoride.
Ethane-1,2-diamine, represented by en, produces a stronger field than water in the standard ordering.
Cyanide lies near the strong-field end of the series.
Therefore, the increasing order is fluoride, water, en and cyanide.
The comparison is meaningful because the question fixes the central metal and its oxidation state.
Changing the metal or oxidation state can also affect the absolute splitting magnitude.
A negatively charged ligand does not necessarily produce a stronger field than a neutral ligand.
For example, cyanide is anionic and strongly splitting, whereas fluoride is also anionic but comparatively weak field.
The ligand's position in the series cannot be predicted solely from its formal electrical charge.
This ordering can be used to anticipate possible changes in electron pairing for metal ions whose d-electron counts permit high-spin and low-spin alternatives.
165. Assertion (A): The elementary crystal-field model is useful for explaining the splitting of d orbitals and the resulting high-spin and low-spin arrangements in suitable coordination compounds.
Reason (R): In this model, ligands are treated as point charges or point dipoles whose electrostatic fields interact with the electrons of the central metal ion.
ⓐ. Both Assertion and Reason are true, and Reason correctly explains Assertion.
ⓑ. Both Assertion and Reason are true, but Reason does not correctly explain Assertion.
ⓒ. Assertion is true, but Reason is false.
ⓓ. Assertion is false, but Reason is true.
Correct Answer: Both Assertion and Reason are true, and Reason correctly explains Assertion.
Explanation: The Assertion is correct because crystal-field theory provides a model for the different energies acquired by metal d orbitals in a ligand environment.
The splitting depends on the spatial arrangement of ligands around the central metal.
For an octahedral complex, the d orbitals separate into lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) and higher-energy \(e_g\) sets.
The separation influences whether certain electrons pair in the lower set or occupy higher-energy orbitals.
For suitable d-electron counts, this explains the distinction between high-spin and low-spin arrangements.
The Reason is also correct because the elementary theory treats metal–ligand interactions as electrostatic.
Anionic ligands are represented as point charges, while neutral polar ligands are represented as point dipoles.
The different orbital orientations cause the metal d electrons to experience unequal repulsive interactions with the surrounding ligand field.
These unequal interactions remove the degeneracy of the d orbitals.
Thus, the electrostatic model described in the Reason provides the basis for the splitting and electron-distribution effects stated in the Assertion.
The model is not a complete description of every aspect of metal–ligand bonding.
In particular, its elementary form does not explicitly account for covalent bonding contributions.
Nevertheless, within its stated assumptions, the Reason correctly explains the Assertion.
166. For a \(d^6\) ion in an ideal octahedral crystal field, the high-spin and low-spin configurations are \(t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{2}\) and \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\), respectively. The splitting is \(\Delta_o=14\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\), and the energy cost of each electron pair is represented by \(P_{\mathrm{pair}}=11\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\). In a simplified energy comparison, take the orbital energies as \(-0.4\Delta_o\) for each \(t_{2g}\) electron and \(+0.6\Delta_o\) for each \(e_g\) electron; add \(P_{\mathrm{pair}}\) for every electron pair. Ignore all other energy contributions. Which statement is correct?
ⓐ. The high-spin arrangement is lower by \(6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\).
ⓑ. Both arrangements have identical energies because they contain the same six d electrons.
ⓒ. The low-spin arrangement is lower by \(28\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\).
ⓓ. The low-spin arrangement is lower by \(6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\).
Correct Answer: The low-spin arrangement is lower by \(6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\).
Explanation: \(\textbf{High-spin orbital energy:}\)
The high-spin \(d^6\) configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{2}
\]
Four electrons occupy the lower level, and two occupy the upper level.
Therefore:
\[
E_{\mathrm{orb,HS}}=4(-0.4\Delta_o)+2(+0.6\Delta_o)
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{orb,HS}}=-1.6\Delta_o+1.2\Delta_o
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{orb,HS}}=-0.4\Delta_o
\]
Substituting:
\[
E_{\mathrm{orb,HS}}=-0.4(14\,000)=-5\,600\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
There is one electron pair in the high-spin arrangement.
Thus:
\[
E_{\mathrm{HS}}=-5\,600+11\,000
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{HS}}=5\,400\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Low-spin orbital energy:}\)
The low-spin configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}
\]
All six electrons occupy the lower level.
Therefore:
\[
E_{\mathrm{orb,LS}}=6(-0.4\Delta_o)
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{orb,LS}}=-2.4\Delta_o
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{orb,LS}}=-2.4(14\,000)=-33\,600\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
The completely filled \(t_{2g}\) set contains three electron pairs.
Hence:
\[
E_{\mathrm{LS}}=-33\,600+3(11\,000)
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{LS}}=-600\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Energy comparison:}\)
\[
E_{\mathrm{LS}}-E_{\mathrm{HS}}=-600-5\,400
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{LS}}-E_{\mathrm{HS}}=-6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
The negative sign means the low-spin arrangement has the lower energy.
This agrees with the supplied inequality \(\Delta_o\gt P_{\mathrm{pair}}\).
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{E_{\mathrm{LS}}-E_{\mathrm{HS}}=-6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}}
\]
167. Three octahedral complexes of the same \(d^5\) metal ion have the following crystal-field splitting values. Assume a pairing energy of \(15\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) and use the elementary \(\Delta_o\)-versus-pairing-energy criterion.
| Complex | \(\Delta_o\) |
| P | \(9\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) |
| Q | \(13\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) |
| R | \(21\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) |
Which conclusion correctly identifies the spin arrangements and a property that remains invariant across all three complexes?
ⓐ. P and Q are low spin, R is high spin, and all three have five unpaired electrons.
ⓑ. P is high spin, Q and R are low spin, and all three have identical \(t_{2g}\) occupancy.
ⓒ. P and Q are high spin, R is low spin, and all three have the same total number of metal d electrons.
ⓓ. All three are high spin because a \(d^5\) ion cannot pair electrons in the \(t_{2g}\) set.
Correct Answer: P and Q are high spin, R is low spin, and all three have the same total number of metal d electrons.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Pairing criterion:}\)
The three complexes contain the same \(d^5\) metal ion.
Therefore, the total number of d electrons is five in every case.
The splitting energy may vary without changing the oxidation state or d-electron count.
The pairing energy is:
\[
P_{\mathrm{pair}}=15\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Complex P:}\)
\[
\Delta_o=9\,000\lt 15\,000
\]
P is high spin.
Its configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{2}
\]
There are five unpaired electrons.
\(\textbf{Complex Q:}\)
\[
\Delta_o=13\,000\lt 15\,000
\]
Q is also high spin.
Its configuration is likewise \(t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{2}\), with five unpaired electrons.
\(\textbf{Complex R:}\)
\[
\Delta_o=21\,000\gt 15\,000
\]
R is low spin.
Its configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{0}
\]
Two electron pairs and one unpaired electron occupy the \(t_{2g}\) set.
Therefore, R has one unpaired electron.
\(\textbf{Invariant and changed properties:}\)
All three complexes contain five metal d electrons.
However, the distribution between \(t_{2g}\) and \(e_g\), and hence the number of unpaired electrons, changes when the splitting exceeds the pairing energy.
The comparison demonstrates that a change in spin state need not involve oxidation or reduction of the central metal ion.
The common electron count is the invariant quantity, while the orbital occupancy is not.
168. Consider four octahedral coordination entities whose central metal ions have the following configurations:
P: \(d^0\)
Q: \(d^1\)
R: \(d^9\)
S: \(d^{10}\)
Which statement correctly identifies the systems in which a crystal-field d–d electronic transition is possible in the elementary orbital-occupancy picture?
ⓐ. P and S only, because their d orbitals are completely empty or completely filled.
ⓑ. Q and R only, because suitable occupied and vacant d-orbital states exist.
ⓒ. P, Q and R only, because a filled d subshell is the sole restriction.
ⓓ. All four, because the presence of octahedral ligands always guarantees a d–d transition.
Correct Answer: Q and R only, because suitable occupied and vacant d-orbital states exist.
Explanation: A d–d transition involves excitation of an electron between metal d-orbital energy levels created by the ligand field.
Such an excitation requires an occupied initial d state and a suitable available final d state.
In a \(d^0\) configuration, no metal d electrons are present.
Consequently, no electron is available for an ordinary d–d excitation.
Thus, P cannot undergo a d–d transition in the elementary description.
In a \(d^1\) configuration, one electron occupies the lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) set of an octahedral field.
A suitable higher-energy \(e_g\) state is available.
Therefore, Q can exhibit a d–d transition.
In a \(d^9\) configuration, nine electrons occupy the five d orbitals.
The d subshell is not completely filled, leaving an available d-orbital state.
Therefore, a suitable d–d excitation is also possible for R.
In a \(d^{10}\) configuration, all five d orbitals are completely filled.
There is no vacant d state within the same set of five metal d orbitals for the ordinary crystal-field excitation.
Thus, S does not exhibit a d–d transition of this type.
The existence of a possible transition does not by itself guarantee that the corresponding absorption lies in the visible region.
Observed colour also depends on the transition energy and other relevant electronic factors.
The correct classification is therefore Q and R only.
169. Two octahedral complexes P and Q contain the same \(d^1\) metal ion in the same oxidation state. Assume their lowest-energy optical absorptions correspond directly to \(t_{2g}\rightarrow e_g\) excitations. P absorbs at \(600\ \mathrm{nm}\), while Q has a crystal-field splitting \(1.25\) times that of P. What is the absorption wavelength of Q?
ⓐ. \(750\ \mathrm{nm}\)
ⓑ. \(600\ \mathrm{nm}\)
ⓒ. \(520\ \mathrm{nm}\)
ⓓ. \(480\ \mathrm{nm}\)
Correct Answer: \(480\ \mathrm{nm}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Energy of the crystal-field transition:}\)
For the stated \(d^1\) octahedral complexes, the transition occurs from the lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) level to the higher-energy \(e_g\) level.
The transition energy is equal to the octahedral splitting energy under the given assumption.
Therefore:
\[
\Delta_o=h\nu
\]
Using \(\nu=c/\lambda\):
\[
\Delta_o=\frac{hc}{\lambda}
\]
Hence, the absorbed wavelength is inversely proportional to the crystal-field splitting.
\(\textbf{Comparison of the two complexes:}\)
The problem states:
\[
\Delta_{o,Q}=1.25\Delta_{o,P}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\frac{\Delta_{o,Q}}{\Delta_{o,P}}=\frac{\lambda_P}{\lambda_Q}
\]
Substitution gives:
\[
1.25=\frac{600}{\lambda_Q}
\]
Rearranging:
\[
\lambda_Q=\frac{600}{1.25}
\]
\[
\lambda_Q=480\ \mathrm{nm}
\]
\(\textbf{Physical interpretation:}\)
Q has the greater octahedral splitting energy.
It must therefore absorb a higher-energy photon for the specified transition.
Since photon energy varies inversely with wavelength, its absorption shifts towards a shorter wavelength.
The result is consistent with \(480\ \mathrm{nm}\lt 600\ \mathrm{nm}\).
The numerical calculation determines the wavelength absorbed, not directly the colour observed by the eye.
The observed colour would require the appropriate complementary-colour interpretation.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\lambda_Q=480\ \mathrm{nm}}
\]
170. A metal ion with configuration \(d^2\) forms an ideal tetrahedral complex. Which statement correctly describes the crystal-field orbital ordering, ground-state occupancy and orbital labels?
ⓐ. The three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals lie below the two \(e_g\) orbitals, giving \(t_{2g}^{2}e_g^{0}\).
ⓑ. The two \(e_g\) orbitals lie below the three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals, giving \(e_g^{2}t_{2g}^{0}\).
ⓒ. The two \(e\) orbitals lie below the three \(t_2\) orbitals, giving \(e^{2}t_2^{0}\) with two unpaired electrons.
ⓓ. The three \(t_2\) orbitals lie below the two \(e\) orbitals, giving \(t_2^{2}e^{0}\) with two unpaired electrons.
Correct Answer: The two \(e\) orbitals lie below the three \(t_2\) orbitals, giving \(e^{2}t_2^{0}\) with two unpaired electrons.
Explanation: The splitting pattern in a tetrahedral crystal field is inverted relative to that in an octahedral field.
In an octahedral field, the three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals lie below the two \(e_g\) orbitals.
In a tetrahedral field, the two-orbital set lies lower in energy.
This lower-energy set is designated \(e\).
The three-orbital upper set is designated \(t_2\).
The labels do not contain the subscript \(g\) because the tetrahedral arrangement does not possess a centre of inversion.
A \(d^2\) metal ion contains two d electrons.
These electrons first occupy the lower-energy \(e\) set.
Since this set contains two orbitals of equal energy, Hund's rule places one electron in each orbital before pairing.
The resulting configuration is \(e^{2}t_2^{0}\).
Both electrons are unpaired, so the complex is paramagnetic.
The occupation does not require promotion to the higher-energy \(t_2\) set.
The different orbital labels and inverted ordering are consequences of tetrahedral symmetry.
Simply reversing the octahedral labels without changing the orbital-energy order would give an incorrect description.
171. Consider the following statements about electron occupancy in ideal octahedral crystal fields.
Statement I: A \(d^2\) ion has the ordinary ground-state configuration \(t_{2g}^{2}e_g^{0}\), with two unpaired electrons.
Statement II: A \(d^3\) ion must place its third electron in \(e_g\) to avoid electron pairing.
Statement III: A high-spin \(d^4\) ion has configuration \(t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{1}\).
Statement IV: A low-spin \(d^5\) ion has configuration \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{0}\), with one unpaired electron.
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. Statements I, III and IV only
ⓑ. Statements I, II and III only
ⓒ. Statements II and IV only
ⓓ. Statements I, II and IV only
Correct Answer: Statements I, III and IV only
Explanation: Statement I is correct because the \(t_{2g}\) set contains three lower-energy orbitals.
Two electrons occupy two separate \(t_{2g}\) orbitals according to Hund's rule.
Therefore, the \(d^2\) configuration contains two unpaired electrons.
Statement II is incorrect because the third electron can occupy the third vacant \(t_{2g}\) orbital.
There is no need to promote it into the higher-energy \(e_g\) set.
Thus, the ordinary \(d^3\) configuration is \(t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{0}\).
All three electrons remain unpaired.
Statement III is correct because a weak octahedral field favours the high-spin arrangement for \(d^4\).
The fourth electron enters an \(e_g\) orbital rather than pairing within \(t_{2g}\).
The resulting configuration is \(t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{1}\).
Statement IV is correct because in a sufficiently strong octahedral field, the five electrons of a \(d^5\) ion occupy the \(t_{2g}\) set.
Two orbitals contain electron pairs, while the third contains one unpaired electron.
Thus, the configuration is \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{0}\), with one unpaired electron.
The distinction between the \(d^3\) and \(d^4\) cases is especially important.
For \(d^3\), an empty lower-energy orbital is still available.
For \(d^4\), the fourth electron must choose between pairing in \(t_{2g}\) and entering the higher-energy \(e_g\) set.
Consequently, Statements I, III and IV are correct.
172. Match the octahedral configurations in List I with the number of unpaired electrons in List II. Assume the stated high-spin or low-spin condition is established by the appropriate crystal-field splitting and pairing energy.
| List I — Configuration | List II — Unpaired electrons |
| P. High-spin \(d^4\) | 1. One |
| Q. Low-spin \(d^5\) | 2. Three |
| R. Low-spin \(d^6\) | 3. Four |
| S. High-spin \(d^7\) | 4. Zero |
Which matching is correct?
ⓐ. P–3, Q–2, R–4, S–1
ⓑ. P–2, Q–1, R–4, S–3
ⓒ. P–3, Q–4, R–1, S–2
ⓓ. P–3, Q–1, R–4, S–2
Correct Answer: P–3, Q–1, R–4, S–2
Explanation: \(\textbf{High-spin }d^4\textbf{:}\)
The weak-field occupancy is \(t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{1}\).
Each of the four electrons occupies a different orbital.
Therefore, P has four unpaired electrons and matches 3.
\(\textbf{Low-spin }d^5\textbf{:}\)
The strong-field occupancy is \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{0}\).
Two of the three lower-energy orbitals contain electron pairs.
The remaining \(t_{2g}\) orbital contains one unpaired electron.
Therefore, Q matches 1.
\(\textbf{Low-spin }d^6\textbf{:}\)
The occupancy is \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\).
The three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals are completely filled by three electron pairs.
No electron remains unpaired.
Thus, R matches 4.
\(\textbf{High-spin }d^7\textbf{:}\)
The occupancy is \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{2}\).
The \(t_{2g}\) set contains one unpaired electron, while the two \(e_g\) orbitals each contain one.
The total number of unpaired electrons is three.
Therefore, S matches 2.
\(\textbf{Combined interpretation:}\)
The four cases demonstrate that the number of unpaired electrons depends on both d-electron count and spin-state preference.
A high-spin complex does not necessarily contain the same number of unpaired electrons as another high-spin complex with a different d count.
Likewise, low-spin behaviour does not guarantee diamagnetism.
The correct matching is P–3, Q–1, R–4 and S–2.
173. A student attempts to explain the NCERT spectrochemical series using only the assumption that ligands behave as point charges or point dipoles. The student predicts that all negatively charged ligands should produce greater d-orbital splitting than neutral ligands. However, the observed series places \(\mathrm{F^-}\) below \(\mathrm{NH_3}\), en and CO in ligand-field strength. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
ⓐ. The experimentally observed order must be rejected because the electrostatic model predicts that all anionic ligands are stronger.
ⓑ. The oxidation state of the metal must become zero whenever a neutral ligand produces stronger splitting than an anionic ligand.
ⓒ. The coordination number must be different in every complex containing these ligands because their field strengths are unequal.
ⓓ. The electrostatic model inadequately describes metal–ligand covalency and the observed ligand-strength order.
Correct Answer: The electrostatic model inadequately describes metal–ligand covalency and the observed ligand-strength order.
Explanation: Elementary crystal-field theory treats metal–ligand interactions as electrostatic.
Anionic ligands are represented as point charges, while suitable neutral ligands are represented as point dipoles.
This approach successfully explains the splitting of d orbitals when ligands approach the central metal in definite geometrical arrangements.
It also helps explain electron pairing, magnetic behaviour and certain optical properties.
However, the model has limitations when used to account for the experimentally observed spectrochemical series.
A purely electrostatic argument might suggest that negatively charged ligands should invariably produce the largest splittings.
The actual ligand ordering does not support such a simple universal rule.
For example, fluoride is an anionic ligand but lies below ammonia, en and carbon monoxide in the standard ligand-field-strength order.
The experimental series is influenced by features of metal–ligand bonding that are not fully represented by the point-charge description.
In particular, the elementary electrostatic treatment does not explicitly include the covalent character of these bonds.
More advanced bonding descriptions can address these limitations, but their detailed treatment is not required for the present elementary analysis.
The discrepancy does not invalidate the usefulness of crystal-field splitting as a model for coordination compounds.
It means that the model's assumptions must not be mistaken for a complete explanation of every observed bonding trend.
Differences in ligand-field strength also do not necessarily change coordination number or force the metal oxidation state to become zero.
Therefore, the scientifically appropriate conclusion is to recognise the explanatory success and the limitations of the basic crystal-field model.
174. Two octahedral coordination entities P and Q contain the same metal ion, the same oxidation state and five identical coordinated ammonia ligands. Their sixth ligand is thiocyanate, but its donor atom differs:
P: \(\mathrm{[M(NH_3)_5(SCN)]^{2+}}\), with thiocyanate bonded through sulphur.
Q: \(\mathrm{[M(NH_3)_5(NCS)]^{2+}}\), with thiocyanate bonded through nitrogen.
The NCERT spectrochemical series places S-bonded \(\mathrm{SCN^-}\) below N-bonded \(\mathrm{NCS^-}\). Assuming the remaining coordination conditions are comparable, which inference is most appropriate?
ⓐ. P and Q must have identical crystal-field splitting because thiocyanate has charge \(-1\) in both.
ⓑ. P must have greater splitting because sulphur has more electrons than nitrogen.
ⓒ. Q is expected to have greater splitting, although this information alone does not establish a change in spin state.
ⓓ. Q must be diamagnetic and P must be paramagnetic, irrespective of the metal's d-electron count.
Correct Answer: Q is expected to have greater splitting, although this information alone does not establish a change in spin state.
Explanation: The two compounds have the same overall composition and differ in the atom through which thiocyanate coordinates.
They therefore represent a linkage-isomer pair.
In P, the donor atom is sulphur, whereas in Q it is nitrogen.
The ligand carries charge \(-1\) in both coordination modes.
Consequently, the metal oxidation state and coordination-entity charge remain unchanged.
The coordination number also remains six because thiocyanate contributes one donor attachment in either mode.
However, identical ligand charge does not imply identical ligand-field strength.
The spectrochemical series distinguishes S-bonded thiocyanate from N-bonded thiocyanate.
The N-bonded form occurs higher in the stated ligand-field-strength order.
Therefore, Q is expected to produce a greater octahedral crystal-field splitting than P in a suitable comparison.
A greater splitting can influence electron pairing when the metal possesses a configuration allowing alternative spin arrangements.
However, the d-electron count and the splitting-to-pairing-energy relationship must be known before predicting a definite spin-state change.
If both splittings lie on the same side of the relevant pairing-energy threshold, the unpaired-electron count may remain unchanged.
Thus, linkage isomerism can influence ligand-field strength without necessarily changing oxidation state, coordination number or magnetic classification.
175. Two hypothetical octahedral metal ions X and Y experience identical crystal-field splitting, \(\Delta_o=15\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\). X has configuration \(d^2\), while Y has configuration \(d^3\). Both follow the ordinary ground-state orbital filling pattern. Neglect electron-pairing contributions and consider only the energy changes produced by crystal-field splitting. By how much is the crystal-field stabilisation of Y greater than that of X?
ⓐ. \(6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\)
ⓑ. \(9\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\)
ⓒ. \(12\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\)
ⓓ. \(15\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\)
Correct Answer: \(6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Octahedral orbital energies:}\)
In an octahedral crystal field, the three lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) orbitals are stabilised by \(0.4\Delta_o\) per electron.
The two higher-energy \(e_g\) orbitals are destabilised by \(0.6\Delta_o\) per electron.
The energy of the unsplit d-orbital level is taken as zero.
\(\textbf{Configuration of X:}\)
X has two d electrons.
Both occupy separate lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) orbitals.
Its configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{2}e_g^{0}
\]
The crystal-field energy is:
\[
E_X=2(-0.4\Delta_o)
\]
\[
E_X=-0.8\Delta_o
\]
Substituting:
\[
E_X=-0.8(15\,000)
\]
\[
E_X=-12\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Configuration of Y:}\)
Y contains three d electrons.
They occupy the three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals singly.
Its configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{0}
\]
The crystal-field energy is:
\[
E_Y=3(-0.4\Delta_o)
\]
\[
E_Y=-1.2\Delta_o
\]
Substituting:
\[
E_Y=-1.2(15\,000)
\]
\[
E_Y=-18\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Comparison of stabilisation magnitudes:}\)
A more negative crystal-field energy represents greater stabilisation relative to the unsplit reference.
Therefore:
\[
\Delta E_{\mathrm{stabilisation}}=|E_Y|-|E_X|
\]
\[
=18\,000-12\,000
\]
\[
=6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
The additional stabilisation arises because Y has one more electron in the lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) set.
Both configurations retain their electrons unpaired, so no additional pairing-energy comparison is required.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\Delta E_{\mathrm{stabilisation}}=6\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}}
\]
176. An octahedral coordination entity contains a metal ion with configuration \(d^{10}\). The six ligands produce a nonzero crystal-field splitting \(\Delta_o\). Which statement correctly describes its orbital occupancy, total crystal-field energy relative to the barycentre and ordinary d–d excitation?
ⓐ. The d orbitals remain unsplit because all ten electrons are paired.
ⓑ. Its total crystal-field energy is negative because six electrons occupy \(t_{2g}\).
ⓒ. Its total crystal-field energy is positive because four electrons occupy \(e_g\).
ⓓ. The d orbitals split, but their full occupancy gives zero net CFSE and prevents ordinary d–d excitation.
Correct Answer: The d orbitals split, but their full occupancy gives zero net CFSE and prevents ordinary d–d excitation.
Explanation: The splitting of metal d orbitals results from the spatial arrangement of surrounding ligands.
It does not require the metal ion to possess partially filled d orbitals.
Therefore, a ligand field can split the d orbitals of a \(d^{10}\) ion even when all ten d electrons are paired.
In an octahedral field, the three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals lie below the barycentre.
The two \(e_g\) orbitals lie above it.
A \(d^{10}\) ion completely fills all five d orbitals.
The occupancy is \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{4}\).
The six \(t_{2g}\) electrons contribute a total energy of \(-2.4\Delta_o\).
The four \(e_g\) electrons contribute \(+2.4\Delta_o\).
These contributions cancel, giving zero net crystal-field energy relative to the unsplit barycentre.
This cancellation does not mean that \(\Delta_o\) itself is zero.
The d orbitals remain separated in energy.
However, every d orbital is fully occupied, leaving no vacant state within the same five-orbital set for an ordinary crystal-field d–d excitation.
The complex is diamagnetic because all d electrons are paired.
The absence of an ordinary d–d transition does not prove that every compound containing such a metal ion must be colourless, since other electronic transitions may occur.
This distinction separates orbital splitting, net stabilisation and the availability of electronic transitions.
177. Two octahedral complexes P and Q contain metal ions with configurations \(d^3\) and \(d^4\), respectively. Both initially experience a weak ligand field. Their ligands are then replaced by stronger-field ligands without changing the respective metal oxidation states or coordination geometries. Assume the final splitting exceeds the relevant pairing energy in both complexes. Which statement correctly predicts the changes in their numbers of unpaired electrons?
ⓐ. P changes from three to one, while Q changes from four to two.
ⓑ. P remains at three, while Q changes from four to two.
ⓒ. P changes from three to zero, while Q changes from four to zero.
ⓓ. Both P and Q retain their initial unpaired-electron counts because the d-electron numbers are unchanged.
Correct Answer: P remains at three, while Q changes from four to two.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Initial electron configurations:}\)
An octahedral \(d^3\) ion has three electrons.
They occupy the three lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) orbitals singly.
Its ground-state configuration is \(t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{0}\).
The number of unpaired electrons is therefore three.
For the weak-field \(d^4\) ion, the fourth electron occupies a higher-energy \(e_g\) orbital rather than pairing in \(t_{2g}\).
The configuration is \(t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{1}\).
It contains four unpaired electrons.
\(\textbf{Response of the }d^3\textbf{ complex:}\)
Increasing the splitting does not require any rearrangement of the three electrons.
All three already occupy different orbitals within the lower-energy set.
Thus, the \(d^3\) ion retains three unpaired electrons.
\(\textbf{Response of the }d^4\textbf{ complex:}\)
In the stronger field, the splitting exceeds the pairing energy.
It becomes energetically preferable for the fourth electron to pair in a \(t_{2g}\) orbital.
The new configuration is \(t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{0}\).
One \(t_{2g}\) orbital contains an electron pair, while two others remain singly occupied.
The number of unpaired electrons consequently decreases from four to two.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The stronger ligand field changes the spin arrangement of Q but not P.
Both complexes retain their original d-electron counts.
The different responses arise from whether the electron configuration presents a competition between occupying \(e_g\) and pairing within \(t_{2g}\).
This explains why the same qualitative ligand-field change need not produce the same magnetic response for different d-electron counts.
178. The same \(d^6\) metal ion is considered in two idealised coordination environments. P is octahedral and has sufficiently large splitting to give the low-spin ground state. Q is tetrahedral and has the usual high-spin ground state. Which comparison is correct?
ⓐ. P has configuration \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\) with no unpaired electrons; Q has configuration \(e^{3}t_2^{3}\) with four unpaired electrons.
ⓑ. P has configuration \(t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{2}\) with four unpaired electrons; Q has configuration \(e^{4}t_2^{2}\) with two unpaired electrons.
ⓒ. P has configuration \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\) with no unpaired electrons; Q has configuration \(e^{4}t_2^{2}\) with two unpaired electrons.
ⓓ. P has configuration \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{1}\) with two unpaired electrons; Q has configuration \(e^{3}t_2^{3}\) with six unpaired electrons.
Correct Answer: P has configuration \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\) with no unpaired electrons; Q has configuration \(e^{3}t_2^{3}\) with four unpaired electrons.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Octahedral field in P:}\)
An octahedral field splits the d orbitals into lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) and higher-energy \(e_g\) sets.
The three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals can accommodate six electrons.
The splitting in P is sufficiently large to favour pairing within these orbitals.
Its low-spin configuration is therefore \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\).
All three \(t_{2g}\) orbitals contain electron pairs.
Consequently, P has no unpaired d electrons.
\(\textbf{Tetrahedral field in Q:}\)
In a tetrahedral field, the two \(e\) orbitals lie below the three \(t_2\) orbitals.
The splitting is ordinarily too small to force additional pairing before the available orbitals have been singly occupied.
The first two electrons enter separate \(e\) orbitals.
The next three electrons occupy the three \(t_2\) orbitals singly.
The sixth electron pairs in one of the lower-energy \(e\) orbitals.
The resulting configuration is:
\[
e^{3}t_2^{3}
\]
One unpaired electron remains in the \(e\) set.
Three unpaired electrons occupy the \(t_2\) set.
Thus:
\[
n_Q=1+3=4
\]
\(\textbf{Comparison:}\)
Both coordination environments contain six metal d electrons.
Their different orbital-energy orderings and splitting magnitudes produce different ground-state arrangements.
The octahedral complex is diamagnetic, whereas the tetrahedral complex is paramagnetic.
This conclusion follows from the specified spin states and is not a universal statement about every octahedral or tetrahedral \(d^6\) complex.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
n_P=0,\quad n_Q=4
\]
179. A \(d^8\) metal ion forms an ideal octahedral complex P and an ordinary high-spin tetrahedral complex Q. Which statement correctly compares their ground-state crystal-field configurations and unpaired-electron counts?
ⓐ. P has \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{2}\) with two unpaired electrons; Q has \(e^{4}t_2^{4}\) with two unpaired electrons.
ⓑ. P has \(t_{2g}^{8}e_g^{0}\) with no unpaired electrons; Q has \(e^{4}t_2^{4}\) with two.
ⓒ. P has \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{2}\) with no unpaired electrons; Q has \(e^{3}t_2^{5}\) with one.
ⓓ. P has \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{3}\) with two unpaired electrons; Q has \(e^{4}t_2^{4}\) with four.
Correct Answer: P has \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{2}\) with two unpaired electrons; Q has \(e^{4}t_2^{4}\) with two unpaired electrons.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Octahedral arrangement:}\)
The three lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) orbitals hold a maximum of six electrons.
For a \(d^8\) ion, these orbitals become completely filled.
The remaining two electrons occupy the two higher-energy \(e_g\) orbitals singly.
Therefore, P has configuration:
\[
t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{2}
\]
Both \(e_g\) electrons remain unpaired.
Thus, P has two unpaired electrons.
\(\textbf{Tetrahedral arrangement:}\)
In a tetrahedral field, the two \(e\) orbitals form the lower-energy set.
The three \(t_2\) orbitals form the higher-energy set.
The eight electrons initially occupy the five available orbitals singly before additional pairing occurs in the high-spin arrangement.
The remaining electrons pair in the occupied orbitals according to their energies.
Four electrons occupy the lower \(e\) set.
The other four occupy the higher \(t_2\) set.
Thus:
\[
e^{4}t_2^{4}
\]
The \(e\) set is completely paired.
Within the three \(t_2\) orbitals, one contains an electron pair and the other two each contain one electron.
Therefore, Q also has two unpaired electrons.
\(\textbf{Structural interpretation:}\)
The two complexes have different geometries and different orbital-energy orderings.
Nevertheless, both possess two unpaired electrons.
Identical magnetic spin counts therefore do not establish identical coordination geometry.
The result also shows why orbital occupancy must be determined separately for octahedral and tetrahedral fields rather than transferring one arrangement directly to the other.
180. Four octahedral coordination entities are described by the following ground-state electron configurations:
| Entity | Ground-state configuration |
| P | \(t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{0}\) |
| Q | \(t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{2}\) |
| R | \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\) |
| S | \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{4}\) |
Which statement correctly compares their crystal-field stabilisation energies relative to the unsplit d-orbital barycentre, excluding pairing-energy contributions?
ⓐ. P and Q have equal stabilisation, while R and S both have zero stabilisation.
ⓑ. P is more stabilised than R, while Q and S have equal stabilisation.
ⓒ. R has the greatest stabilisation magnitude, whereas Q and S both have zero net crystal-field stabilisation.
ⓓ. S has the greatest stabilisation magnitude because all ten d electrons experience the ligand field.
Correct Answer: R has the greatest stabilisation magnitude, whereas Q and S both have zero net crystal-field stabilisation.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Crystal-field energy relation:}\)
For an octahedral complex, each \(t_{2g}\) electron contributes \(-0.4\Delta_o\).
Each \(e_g\) electron contributes \(+0.6\Delta_o\).
The net crystal-field energy depends on the number of electrons occupying each set.
\(\textbf{Entity P:}\)
\[
E_P=3(-0.4\Delta_o)
\]
\[
E_P=-1.2\Delta_o
\]
P is stabilised relative to the unsplit reference.
\(\textbf{Entity Q:}\)
\[
E_Q=3(-0.4\Delta_o)+2(+0.6\Delta_o)
\]
\[
E_Q=-1.2\Delta_o+1.2\Delta_o
\]
\[
E_Q=0
\]
The lower- and higher-level contributions cancel.
\(\textbf{Entity R:}\)
\[
E_R=6(-0.4\Delta_o)
\]
\[
E_R=-2.4\Delta_o
\]
R has the greatest stabilisation magnitude among the four configurations for a common positive \(\Delta_o\).
\(\textbf{Entity S:}\)
\[
E_S=6(-0.4\Delta_o)+4(+0.6\Delta_o)
\]
\[
E_S=-2.4\Delta_o+2.4\Delta_o
\]
\[
E_S=0
\]
The completely filled d subshell has zero net crystal-field energy relative to the barycentre.
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
A larger number of d electrons does not automatically mean greater crystal-field stabilisation.
The relevant quantity is the difference between the stabilising and destabilising contributions.
The actual total energies of different ions also involve other terms, so these values should not be treated as a complete thermodynamic stability ranking of unrelated compounds.
The stated comparison concerns only the crystal-field contributions.
The calculated results establish that R has the greatest stabilisation magnitude, while Q and S have zero net contribution.
181. The following text describes an experimental absorption plot for an octahedral \(d^1\) coordination entity.
The horizontal axis represents photon wavenumber in \(\mathrm{cm^{-1}}\), increasing towards the right. The vertical axis represents relative absorption intensity. A single prominent absorption maximum occurs at \(12\,500\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\). Assume this maximum corresponds directly to excitation from \(t_{2g}\) to \(e_g\). The approximate visible wavelength range is taken as \(400\)–\(700\ \mathrm{nm}\).
Using \(1\ \mathrm{cm}=10^7\ \mathrm{nm}\), which conclusion correctly gives the transition wavelength and its spectral region?
ⓐ. \(800\ \mathrm{nm}\), infrared
ⓑ. \(800\ \mathrm{nm}\), visible
ⓒ. \(625\ \mathrm{nm}\), visible
ⓓ. \(1\,250\ \mathrm{nm}\), infrared
Correct Answer: \(800\ \mathrm{nm}\), infrared
Explanation: \(\textbf{Reading the absorption maximum:}\)
The graph gives the wavenumber associated with the electronic transition.
The absorption maximum occurs at:
\[
\tilde{\nu}=12\,500\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
The transition is explicitly identified as a \(t_{2g}\rightarrow e_g\) excitation.
Therefore, its energy corresponds to the octahedral splitting under the stated approximation.
\(\textbf{Wavenumber–wavelength relation:}\)
Wavenumber is the reciprocal of wavelength when consistent units are used.
\[
\tilde{\nu}=\frac{1}{\lambda}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\lambda=\frac{1}{\tilde{\nu}}
\]
\(\textbf{Substitution in centimetres:}\)
\[
\lambda=\frac{1}{12\,500}\ \mathrm{cm}
\]
\[
\lambda=8.0\times10^{-5}\ \mathrm{cm}
\]
\(\textbf{Conversion to nanometres:}\)
Using:
\[
1\ \mathrm{cm}=10^7\ \mathrm{nm}
\]
\[
\lambda=(8.0\times10^{-5})(10^7)\ \mathrm{nm}
\]
\[
\lambda=800\ \mathrm{nm}
\]
\(\textbf{Spectral-region check:}\)
The supplied visible range ends at approximately \(700\ \mathrm{nm}\).
The calculated wavelength is greater than this limit.
Therefore, the absorption maximum lies in the near-infrared region.
\(\textbf{Chemical interpretation:}\)
The ligand field has produced an electronic energy separation that can support a d–d excitation.
However, that excitation does not fall within the specified visible wavelength interval.
The existence of crystal-field splitting therefore does not guarantee a visible d–d absorption.
Other absorption processes would have to be considered before predicting the complete observed appearance of the substance.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\lambda=800\ \mathrm{nm}
\]
The corresponding spectral region is infrared.
182. In an ideal tetrahedral crystal field, the two \(e\) orbitals lie below the three \(t_2\) orbitals. The separation between these sets is \(\Delta_t\). Assume that the weighted average energy of the five d orbitals is unchanged by splitting. Which statement correctly identifies the energy shifts of the two sets and the crystal-field energy of a high-spin \(d^3\) ion?
ⓐ. \(e\) shifts by \(-0.4\Delta_t\), \(t_2\) by \(+0.6\Delta_t\), and the \(d^3\) crystal-field energy is zero.
ⓑ. \(e\) shifts by \(-0.6\Delta_t\), \(t_2\) by \(+0.4\Delta_t\), and the \(d^3\) crystal-field energy is \(-0.8\Delta_t\).
ⓒ. \(e\) shifts by \(+0.6\Delta_t\), \(t_2\) by \(-0.4\Delta_t\), and the \(d^3\) crystal-field energy is \(-0.8\Delta_t\).
ⓓ. \(e\) shifts by \(-0.6\Delta_t\), \(t_2\) by \(+0.4\Delta_t\), and the \(d^3\) crystal-field energy is \(-1.8\Delta_t\).
Correct Answer: \(e\) shifts by \(-0.6\Delta_t\), \(t_2\) by \(+0.4\Delta_t\), and the \(d^3\) crystal-field energy is \(-0.8\Delta_t\).
Explanation: \(\textbf{Tetrahedral orbital ordering:}\)
The lower-energy set contains two \(e\) orbitals.
The higher-energy set contains three \(t_2\) orbitals.
The energy separation is \(\Delta_t\).
\(\textbf{Barycentre requirement:}\)
Let the lowering of each \(e\) orbital be \(a\Delta_t\).
Let the raising of each \(t_2\) orbital be \(b\Delta_t\).
Because the weighted average orbital energy remains unchanged:
\[
2(-a\Delta_t)+3(b\Delta_t)=0
\]
Cancelling \(\Delta_t\):
\[
-2a+3b=0
\]
The energy separation between the upper and lower sets is:
\[
a\Delta_t+b\Delta_t=\Delta_t
\]
Therefore:
\[
a+b=1
\]
Solving the two relations gives:
\[
a=0.6,\qquad b=0.4
\]
Thus:
\[
E(e)=-0.6\Delta_t
\]
\[
E(t_2)=+0.4\Delta_t
\]
\(\textbf{High-spin }d^3\textbf{ occupancy:}\)
The first two electrons occupy the separate lower-energy \(e\) orbitals.
The third occupies one higher-energy \(t_2\) orbital rather than pairing prematurely.
Therefore, the configuration is:
\[
e^2t_2^1
\]
\(\textbf{Crystal-field energy:}\)
\[
E_{\mathrm{CF}}=2(-0.6\Delta_t)+1(+0.4\Delta_t)
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{CF}}=-1.2\Delta_t+0.4\Delta_t
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{CF}}=-0.8\Delta_t
\]
The three electrons remain unpaired in this high-spin arrangement.
The negative energy indicates stabilisation relative to the unsplit d-orbital reference.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{E(e)=-0.6\Delta_t,\quad E(t_2)=+0.4\Delta_t,\quad E_{\mathrm{CF}}(d^3)=-0.8\Delta_t}
\]
183. A \(d^7\) metal ion forms two complexes, P and Q. P is an ordinary high-spin octahedral complex, while Q is an ordinary high-spin tetrahedral complex. Which statement correctly compares their orbital occupancies and numbers of unpaired electrons?
ⓐ. P has \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{2}\) with three unpaired electrons; Q has \(e^{4}t_2^{3}\) with three unpaired electrons.
ⓑ. P has \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{1}\) with one unpaired electron; Q has \(e^{4}t_2^{3}\) with three.
ⓒ. P has \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{2}\) with three unpaired electrons; Q has \(e^{3}t_2^{4}\) with one.
ⓓ. P has \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{1}\) with one unpaired electron; Q has \(e^{3}t_2^{4}\) with three.
Correct Answer: P has \(t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{2}\) with three unpaired electrons; Q has \(e^{4}t_2^{3}\) with three unpaired electrons.
Explanation: \(\textbf{High-spin octahedral arrangement:}\)
A \(d^7\) metal ion contains seven d electrons.
In an octahedral field, the \(t_{2g}\) orbitals lie below the \(e_g\) orbitals.
For the high-spin arrangement, electrons occupy available orbitals singly before further pairing.
The resulting configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{2}
\]
The \(t_{2g}\) set contains two electron pairs and one unpaired electron.
The two \(e_g\) orbitals each contain one unpaired electron.
Therefore:
\[
n_P=1+2=3
\]
\(\textbf{High-spin tetrahedral arrangement:}\)
The tetrahedral lower-energy \(e\) set contains two orbitals.
The upper \(t_2\) set contains three orbitals.
For seven high-spin electrons, the lower \(e\) set becomes completely filled by four electrons.
The remaining three electrons occupy the three \(t_2\) orbitals singly.
The configuration is:
\[
e^4t_2^3
\]
There are no unpaired electrons in the \(e\) set.
All three electrons in the \(t_2\) set are unpaired.
Therefore:
\[
n_Q=3
\]
\(\textbf{Comparison:}\)
Both complexes contain three unpaired d electrons.
However, their electrons occupy differently ordered orbital sets.
The octahedral and tetrahedral environments also have different coordination numbers and orbital symmetries.
Identical unpaired-electron counts do not imply that the complexes have the same geometry or crystal-field splitting.
The comparison illustrates the importance of distinguishing the magnetic consequences of an electron configuration from the spatial origin of that configuration.
184. Consider the following statements about orbital labels used in crystal-field theory.
Statement I: The octahedral \(t_{2g}\) and \(e_g\) labels include the subscript \(g\) because the relevant orbitals are gerade under inversion through the metal centre.
Statement II: In the elementary tetrahedral splitting diagram, the orbital sets are designated \(e\) and \(t_2\), without the subscript \(g\).
Statement III: The absence of a centre of inversion in a tetrahedral coordination environment necessarily means that every tetrahedral coordination entity is optically active.
Statement IV: The distinction between octahedral and tetrahedral splitting involves both orbital ordering and the symmetry of the coordination environment.
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. Statements I, II and III only
ⓑ. Statements II, III and IV only
ⓒ. Statements I, II and IV only
ⓓ. Statements I, III and IV only
Correct Answer: Statements I, II and IV only
Explanation: Statement I is correct because the symbol \(g\) denotes gerade symmetry, which means even behaviour under inversion through a centre of symmetry.
The ideal octahedral environment possesses an inversion centre.
Its d-orbital sets are consequently labelled \(t_{2g}\) and \(e_g\).
Statement II is correct because an ideal tetrahedral coordination environment lacks a centre of inversion.
Its crystal-field orbital sets are therefore denoted \(e\) and \(t_2\), without the gerade subscript.
This is the notation used in the elementary tetrahedral splitting diagram.
Statement III is incorrect because absence of an inversion centre alone does not establish optical activity.
A molecule or coordination entity can be achiral even if it lacks an inversion centre.
An ideal tetrahedral entity containing four identical ligands is achiral because its mirror image is superimposable.
The conditions for optical isomerism require examination of the complete three-dimensional symmetry of the structure.
Statement IV is correct because tetrahedral and octahedral ligand approaches produce different spatial interactions with the metal d orbitals.
In the octahedral field, \(t_{2g}\) lies below \(e_g\).
In the tetrahedral field, \(e\) lies below \(t_2\).
The splitting magnitudes also differ for otherwise comparable coordination environments.
Thus, Statements I, II and IV are correct.
The question distinguishes the symmetry meaning of orbital labels from the separate structural criterion for molecular chirality.
185. An octahedral complex contains a \(d^1\) metal ion. A stronger ligand is substituted while the metal oxidation state and geometry remain unchanged. The resulting splitting increases from \(14\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\) to \(20\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}\). Assume the observed absorption corresponds to the elementary \(t_{2g}\rightarrow e_g\) transition. Which combination correctly describes the changes?
ⓐ. The number of unpaired electrons decreases from one to zero, and the absorbed photon energy increases.
ⓑ. The number of unpaired electrons remains one, and the absorbed photon energy decreases.
ⓒ. The number of unpaired electrons increases from one to two, and the absorbed photon wavelength decreases.
ⓓ. The number of unpaired electrons remains one, while the absorbed photon energy increases and its wavelength decreases.
Correct Answer: The number of unpaired electrons remains one, while the absorbed photon energy increases and its wavelength decreases.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Electronic configuration:}\)
A \(d^1\) metal ion contains one d electron.
In an octahedral field, this electron occupies a lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) orbital in the ground state.
The configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{1}e_g^{0}
\]
There is only one electron, so no electron-pairing competition occurs.
Consequently, increasing the ligand-field splitting does not change the number of unpaired electrons.
That number remains one.
\(\textbf{Change in splitting:}\)
The initial splitting is:
\[
\Delta_{o,1}=14\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
The final splitting is:
\[
\Delta_{o,2}=20\,000\ \mathrm{cm^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\Delta_{o,2}\gt \Delta_{o,1}
\]
\(\textbf{Absorption-energy relation:}\)
For the specified elementary d–d transition:
\[
E_{\mathrm{photon}}=\Delta_o=\frac{hc}{\lambda}
\]
An increase in \(\Delta_o\) means an increase in the required photon energy.
Because \(h\) and \(c\) are constant:
\[
\lambda\propto\frac{1}{\Delta_o}
\]
Thus, the absorbed wavelength decreases.
\(\textbf{Distinction between optical and magnetic behaviour:}\)
The stronger ligand field changes the electronic excitation energy.
However, it does not create an additional electron or pair the existing single electron.
Therefore, the absorption characteristics may change while the unpaired-electron count remains unchanged.
This is an important qualification to the idea that every increase in crystal-field splitting produces a change in magnetic behaviour.
186. Three idealised octahedral ions P, Q and R have configurations \(d^3\), high-spin \(d^5\) and \(d^{10}\), respectively. For comparison, assume all three experience the same positive splitting \(\Delta_o\), and ignore pairing-energy contributions. Which sequence correctly orders their crystal-field stabilisation energies from most negative to least negative?
ⓐ. P, Q = R
ⓑ. Q, P, R
ⓒ. R, Q, P
ⓓ. P = Q, R
Correct Answer: P, Q = R
Explanation: \(\textbf{Crystal-field energy of P:}\)
A \(d^3\) ion has configuration \(t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{0}\).
Each \(t_{2g}\) electron contributes \(-0.4\Delta_o\).
Therefore:
\[
E_P=3(-0.4\Delta_o)
\]
\[
E_P=-1.2\Delta_o
\]
\(\textbf{Crystal-field energy of Q:}\)
A high-spin \(d^5\) ion has configuration \(t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{2}\).
Its lower-level contribution is:
\[
E_{\mathrm{lower}}=3(-0.4\Delta_o)=-1.2\Delta_o
\]
The upper-level contribution is:
\[
E_{\mathrm{upper}}=2(+0.6\Delta_o)=+1.2\Delta_o
\]
Therefore:
\[
E_Q=-1.2\Delta_o+1.2\Delta_o
\]
\[
E_Q=0
\]
\(\textbf{Crystal-field energy of R:}\)
A \(d^{10}\) ion has configuration \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{4}\).
Its total crystal-field energy is:
\[
E_R=6(-0.4\Delta_o)+4(+0.6\Delta_o)
\]
\[
E_R=-2.4\Delta_o+2.4\Delta_o
\]
\[
E_R=0
\]
\(\textbf{Comparison:}\)
P has a negative crystal-field energy, whereas Q and R have zero net crystal-field energies relative to the barycentre.
Therefore, the order from most negative to least negative is P followed by Q and R jointly.
This is a ranking of crystal-field energy contributions, not a universal ranking of the thermodynamic stabilities of three unrelated coordination compounds.
The distinction matters because pairing energies and other bonding contributions have been deliberately excluded.
It also demonstrates that equal net crystal-field energy does not imply equal electron configurations or magnetic properties.
187. A cobalt(III) complex contains six unidentate ligands and is octahedral. Under one set of conditions, its \(d^6\) electrons occupy \(t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{2}\). Under another set of conditions, the same oxidation state and coordination number are retained, but the ground-state occupancy becomes \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\). Which statement correctly combines crystal-field and valence-bond interpretations?
ⓐ. The first arrangement is low spin and inner orbital, whereas the second is high spin and outer orbital.
ⓑ. Both arrangements require \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation because the metal oxidation state is unchanged.
ⓒ. The first is high-spin, outer-orbital and has four unpaired electrons; the second is low-spin, inner-orbital and diamagnetic.
ⓓ. Both arrangements contain two unpaired electrons because the d-electron count remains six.
Correct Answer: The first is high-spin, outer-orbital and has four unpaired electrons; the second is low-spin, inner-orbital and diamagnetic.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Crystal-field interpretation of the first arrangement:}\)
The initial configuration is \(t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{2}\).
One pair and two unpaired electrons occupy the \(t_{2g}\) set.
Two additional unpaired electrons occupy the \(e_g\) set.
The total number of unpaired electrons is four.
This is the high-spin arrangement of an octahedral \(d^6\) ion.
\(\textbf{Valence-bond interpretation of the first arrangement:}\)
In the corresponding standard valence-bond model, the metal's d electrons retain the high-spin distribution.
Two simultaneously vacant inner d orbitals are unavailable.
The six ligand electron pairs are therefore accommodated using an outer-orbital \(sp^3d^2\) hybridisation scheme.
\(\textbf{Crystal-field interpretation of the second arrangement:}\)
The final configuration is \(t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}\).
All six d electrons occupy the lower-energy orbital set as three pairs.
The complex is low spin and diamagnetic.
This arrangement is favoured when the crystal-field splitting is sufficiently large relative to the pairing energy.
\(\textbf{Valence-bond interpretation of the second arrangement:}\)
In the corresponding standard valence-bond description, the paired d electrons leave two inner d orbitals vacant.
These orbitals can participate in \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation.
The complex is consequently described as an inner-orbital octahedral complex.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The central metal oxidation state, total d-electron count and coordination number remain unchanged.
Nevertheless, electron pairing changes the magnetic behaviour and the hybridisation description.
The comparison links the crystal-field account of spin state with the qualitative valence-bond account of inner- and outer-orbital complexes.
188. A student examines four statements about the interpretation of coordination-compound spectra and magnetism.
Statement I: The existence of crystal-field splitting does not guarantee a visible d–d absorption.
Statement II: Two complexes with identical unpaired-electron counts must necessarily have identical crystal-field splitting energies.
Statement III: A change in ligand identity may change the d-orbital splitting without changing the metal oxidation state.
Statement IV: In elementary crystal-field theory, knowing the orbital splitting alone is sufficient to determine the ground-state spin configuration of every d-electron count without reference to pairing energy.
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. Statements I, II and III only
ⓑ. Statements I and III only
ⓒ. Statements II and IV only
ⓓ. Statements I, III and IV only
Correct Answer: Statements I and III only
Explanation: Statement I is correct because d-orbital splitting establishes an energy separation but does not by itself establish absorption in the visible region.
The transition energy may correspond to ultraviolet or infrared radiation instead.
The electron configuration may also prevent an ordinary d–d transition, as occurs for completely empty or completely filled d subshells in the elementary model.
Statement II is incorrect because the number of unpaired electrons does not uniquely determine the splitting energy.
For example, two octahedral \(d^3\) complexes can have different crystal-field splittings while both retain three unpaired electrons.
They have the same ordinary orbital-filling pattern, but their excitation energies may differ.
Statement III is correct because different ligands produce different ligand fields.
Replacing one ligand type with another can change \(\Delta_o\) without requiring oxidation or reduction of the central metal.
The coordination number and geometry may also remain unchanged during such a substitution.
Statement IV is incorrect because electron pairing involves an energetic cost.
For \(d^4\) through \(d^7\) octahedral configurations, the relative magnitudes of crystal-field splitting and pairing energy influence whether electrons pair in lower-energy orbitals or occupy higher-energy orbitals.
Knowing only \(\Delta_o\), without sufficient pairing-energy information, may therefore be inadequate for selecting the ground-state spin arrangement.
The four statements collectively distinguish orbital splitting, electronic occupation, magnetic behaviour and optical absorption.
These properties are connected, but they are not interchangeable.
Thus, only Statements I and III are correct.
189. Two coordination entities of cobalt(II) are given below:
P: \(\mathrm{[CoCl_4]^{2-}}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Co(H_2O)_6]^{2+}}\)
P is tetrahedral, whereas Q is octahedral. Both are high-spin complexes. Which statement correctly compares their hybridisation and magnetic behaviour in the standard valence-bond description?
ⓐ. P uses \(dsp^2\) hybridisation with one unpaired electron, whereas Q uses \(d^2sp^3\) with three.
ⓑ. P uses \(sp^3\) hybridisation with three unpaired electrons, whereas Q uses \(sp^3d^2\) with three.
ⓒ. P uses \(sp^3\) hybridisation with three unpaired electrons, whereas Q uses \(d^2sp^3\) with one.
ⓓ. P uses \(dsp^2\) hybridisation with no unpaired electrons, whereas Q uses \(sp^3d^2\) with three.
Correct Answer: P uses \(sp^3\) hybridisation with three unpaired electrons, whereas Q uses \(sp^3d^2\) with three.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Metal-ion configuration:}\)
Cobalt has oxidation state \(+2\) in both coordination entities.
The neutral cobalt atom has electronic configuration \(\mathrm{[Ar]\,3d^7 4s^2}\).
Removal of the two \(4s\) electrons gives:
\[
\mathrm{Co^{2+}:[Ar]\,3d^7}
\]
\(\textbf{Tetrahedral entity P:}\)
Four chloride ions coordinate to cobalt through four donor atoms.
The coordination number is four, and the geometry is specified as tetrahedral.
The standard valence-bond description therefore uses four \(sp^3\) hybrid orbitals.
The high-spin \(3d^7\) arrangement contains two electron pairs and three unpaired electrons.
Thus:
\[
n_P=3
\]
\(\textbf{Octahedral entity Q:}\)
Six water molecules coordinate through six oxygen donor atoms.
The coordination number is six.
The high-spin \(3d^7\) arrangement cannot provide two vacant inner \(3d\) orbitals for \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation.
Consequently, the standard outer-orbital description uses \(sp^3d^2\) hybridisation.
Three electrons remain unpaired:
\[
n_Q=3
\]
\(\textbf{Combined inference:}\)
The two entities differ in geometry, coordination number and hybridisation.
Nevertheless, their metal oxidation states, d-electron counts and numbers of unpaired electrons are identical.
Therefore, observing three unpaired electrons would not, by itself, establish whether a cobalt(II) entity is tetrahedral or octahedral.
The full coordination environment is necessary for distinguishing their structures.
190. An octahedral coordination entity contains a first-row transition-metal ion with a \(3d^7\) configuration. A student argues that introducing a sufficiently strong-field ligand must eventually make the entity an inner-orbital \(d^2sp^3\) complex because strong ligands promote electron pairing. Which response correctly evaluates the argument within the elementary valence-bond model?
ⓐ. The argument is correct because seven electrons can occupy three inner d orbitals after pairing.
ⓑ. The argument is correct because one vacant inner d orbital is sufficient for \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation.
ⓒ. The argument is incorrect because seven electrons require at least four d orbitals, leaving at most one vacant inner d orbital.
ⓓ. The argument is incorrect because a \(d^7\) ion cannot form an octahedral coordination entity.
Correct Answer: The argument is incorrect because seven electrons require at least four d orbitals, leaving at most one vacant inner d orbital.
Explanation: The \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation scheme requires two vacant inner d orbitals.
A d subshell contains five orbitals, each capable of accommodating a maximum of two electrons.
If two inner d orbitals are reserved for hybridisation, only three inner d orbitals remain available for the metal's d electrons.
Those three orbitals can hold at most six electrons.
The specified ion contains seven d electrons.
Therefore, seven electrons cannot be accommodated in only three d orbitals, regardless of the strength of the ligand field.
Even under maximum pairing, the seven electrons require four occupied d orbitals.
At most one of the five inner d orbitals can consequently remain vacant.
This is insufficient for the two inner d orbitals required by \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation.
The standard octahedral valence-bond description must therefore employ outer d orbitals, giving \(sp^3d^2\) hybridisation.
The argument incorrectly assumes that stronger-field ligands can overcome the maximum electron capacity imposed by the Pauli exclusion principle.
Strong-field behaviour can alter the number of unpaired electrons without necessarily changing the inner-/outer-orbital classification.
For a \(d^7\) ion, a low-spin octahedral arrangement can have one unpaired electron, but that does not make two inner d orbitals vacant.
The distinction demonstrates why electron capacity must be checked before assigning hybridisation.
191. Consider the four-coordinate entities:
P: \(\mathrm{[NiCl_4]^{2-}}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[PtCl_4]^{2-}}\)
Both contain metal ions with \(d^8\) configurations and four chloride ligands. Experimentally, P is tetrahedral and paramagnetic, whereas Q is square planar and diamagnetic. Which conclusion is justified?
ⓐ. Identical ligand identity, coordination number and d-electron count do not guarantee identical geometry or electron pairing for different central metals.
ⓑ. Both must have \(sp^3\) hybridisation because chloride is a weak-field ligand.
ⓒ. Both must have \(dsp^2\) hybridisation because a \(d^8\) configuration always produces a square-planar complex.
ⓓ. The different geometries prove that nickel has oxidation state \(+2\), whereas platinum has oxidation state \(+4\).
Correct Answer: Identical ligand identity, coordination number and d-electron count do not guarantee identical geometry or electron pairing for different central metals.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Common oxidation-state calculation:}\)
Each coordinated chloride ion carries charge \(-1\).
Both coordination entities have charge \(-2\).
Therefore:
\[
x+4(-1)=-2
\]
\[
x=+2
\]
Both nickel and platinum are in oxidation state \(+2\).
Nickel(II) has a \(3d^8\) configuration, while platinum(II) has a \(5d^8\) configuration.
\(\textbf{Nickel complex:}\)
The standard tetrachloridonickelate(II) entity is tetrahedral.
Its valence-bond description uses \(sp^3\) hybridisation.
Two d electrons remain unpaired, making the complex paramagnetic.
\(\textbf{Platinum complex:}\)
The tetrachloridoplatinate(II) entity is square planar.
Its standard valence-bond description uses \(dsp^2\) hybridisation.
The electrons are paired in the corresponding ground-state arrangement, making the complex diamagnetic.
\(\textbf{Important comparison:}\)
Both entities have coordination number four and contain the same ligand species.
They also have the same formal d-electron count.
However, the central metals belong to different transition series.
Their orbital environments and relative energetic preferences are not necessarily identical.
Therefore, the behaviour of a particular ligand with one metal ion cannot automatically be transferred to a different metal ion.
The observations demonstrate a limitation of predicting four-coordinate geometry solely from ligand charge or d-electron count.
The central-metal identity and experimental structural evidence remain essential.
192. Bonding between a metal and carbon monoxide in a metal carbonyl involves synergic sigma donation and pi back-donation. Which combination correctly describes the directions of these interactions and the effect of increased pi back-donation on the internal C–O bond?
ⓐ. Sigma donation occurs from CO to the metal, pi back-donation enters a bonding orbital of CO, and increased back-donation strengthens the C–O bond.
ⓑ. Sigma donation occurs from the metal to CO, pi back-donation occurs from CO to the metal, and increased back-donation weakens the C–O bond.
ⓒ. Sigma donation occurs from CO to the metal, pi back-donation enters an antibonding orbital of CO, and increased back-donation strengthens the C–O bond.
ⓓ. Sigma donation occurs from CO to the metal, pi back-donation enters an antibonding orbital of CO, and increased back-donation weakens the C–O bond.
Correct Answer: Sigma donation occurs from CO to the metal, pi back-donation enters an antibonding orbital of CO, and increased back-donation weakens the C–O bond.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Sigma donation:}\)
Carbon monoxide acts as a neutral ligand and ordinarily coordinates through its carbon atom.
The carbon end of CO possesses an occupied molecular orbital containing an electron pair suitable for donation.
This electron pair is donated into an appropriate vacant orbital of the metal.
The resulting ligand-to-metal interaction forms the sigma component of the metal–carbon bond.
Thus, the direction of sigma donation is:
\[
\mathrm{CO\rightarrow M}
\]
\(\textbf{Pi back-donation:}\)
The metal can also possess occupied d orbitals of suitable symmetry for interaction with CO.
Electron density from these occupied metal orbitals is donated into vacant antibonding \(\pi^*\) orbitals of CO.
This interaction is called metal-to-ligand pi back-donation.
Its direction is:
\[
\mathrm{M\rightarrow CO}
\]
The two electron-donation processes therefore operate in opposite directions.
\(\textbf{Effect on the metal–carbon bond:}\)
Sigma donation establishes electron-pair donation from CO to the metal.
Pi back-donation provides an additional bonding interaction between the metal and carbon monoxide.
These interactions reinforce the metal–carbon bonding relationship and are described as synergic bonding.
\(\textbf{Effect on the internal C–O bond:}\)
The vacant \(\pi^*\) orbital of CO is antibonding with respect to the carbon–oxygen bond.
Greater occupation of this orbital reduces the effective C–O bond order.
Therefore, enhanced pi back-donation generally weakens and lengthens the internal C–O bond.
It also tends to lower the C–O stretching frequency.
This weakening occurs even though the metal–carbon bonding interaction is strengthened by back-donation.
\(\textbf{Evaluation of the alternatives:}\)
Option A incorrectly assigns the back-donated electrons to a bonding orbital and predicts C–O strengthening.
Option B reverses the actual directions of the two donation processes.
Option C correctly identifies the electron-donation directions but incorrectly predicts strengthening of the internal C–O bond.
Option D correctly identifies both donation directions and the consequence of occupation of the CO antibonding orbital.
\(\textbf{Final conclusion:}\)
In metal carbonyls, CO donates electron density to the metal through sigma bonding, while occupied metal orbitals donate electron density back into CO antibonding orbitals through pi bonding.
Greater pi back-donation generally strengthens the metal–carbon interaction while weakening the internal carbon–oxygen bond.
193. Three neutral homoleptic metal carbonyls are represented by:
P: \(\mathrm{Ni(CO)_4}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{Fe(CO)_5}\)
R: \(\mathrm{Cr(CO)_6}\)
Each CO coordinates through carbon as a unidentate ligand. Which statement correctly compares the coordination numbers, geometries and metal oxidation states in these standard NCERT examples?
ⓐ. P is square planar, Q is trigonal bipyramidal and R is octahedral; all three metals have oxidation state zero.
ⓑ. P is tetrahedral, Q is trigonal bipyramidal and R is octahedral; all three metals have oxidation state zero.
ⓒ. P is tetrahedral, Q is square pyramidal and R is octahedral; their metal oxidation states are \(0,+2,+3\), respectively.
ⓓ. P is tetrahedral, Q is trigonal bipyramidal and R is tetrahedral; their coordination numbers are four, five and four.
Correct Answer: P is tetrahedral, Q is trigonal bipyramidal and R is octahedral; all three metals have oxidation state zero.
Explanation: Each of the three compounds contains only carbon monoxide ligands.
Carbon monoxide is electrically neutral, and all three complete carbonyl molecules are neutral.
Therefore, the oxidation state of the metal is zero in each compound.
Each carbon monoxide molecule contributes one directly attached carbon donor atom.
The coordination number consequently equals the number of CO molecules in these mononuclear examples.
In tetracarbonylnickel(0), four CO ligands coordinate to nickel.
Its coordination number is four, and its geometry is tetrahedral.
In pentacarbonyliron(0), five CO ligands coordinate to iron.
Its coordination number is five, and the molecular geometry is trigonal bipyramidal.
In hexacarbonylchromium(0), six CO ligands coordinate to chromium.
Its coordination number is six, and the geometry is octahedral.
The presence of the same neutral ligand does not force all three complexes to adopt an identical coordination geometry.
Nor does the existence of metal-to-CO pi back-bonding increase the coordination number beyond the number of directly coordinated carbon atoms.
The structures illustrate how different metals can accommodate different numbers of carbonyl ligands while maintaining oxidation state zero.
Their comparison also distinguishes geometry from ligand type and formal metal oxidation state.
194. A chemist investigates two octahedral iron(II) coordination entities:
P: \(\mathrm{[Fe(H_2O)_6]^{2+}}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{[Fe(CN)_6]^{4-}}\)
The first is high spin, while the second is low spin. Which statement correctly combines the metal-ion electronic configuration, hybridisation and magnetic behaviour in their standard valence-bond descriptions?
ⓐ. P: \(d^6,\ sp^3d^2\), four unpaired electrons; Q: \(d^6,\ d^2sp^3\), zero unpaired electrons
ⓑ. P: \(d^6,\ d^2sp^3\), zero unpaired electrons; Q: \(d^6,\ sp^3d^2\), four unpaired electrons
ⓒ. P: \(d^5,\ sp^3d^2\), five unpaired electrons; Q: \(d^6,\ d^2sp^3\), zero unpaired electrons
ⓓ. P: \(d^6,\ sp^3d^2\), two unpaired electrons; Q: \(d^6,\ d^2sp^3\), two unpaired electrons
Correct Answer: P: \(d^6,\ sp^3d^2\), four unpaired electrons; Q: \(d^6,\ d^2sp^3\), zero unpaired electrons
Explanation: \(\textbf{Common metal-ion configuration:}\)
Iron has oxidation state \(+2\) in both entities.
The neutral iron atom has configuration \(\mathrm{[Ar]\,3d^6 4s^2}\).
Removal of the two \(4s\) electrons gives:
\[
\mathrm{Fe^{2+}:[Ar]\,3d^6}
\]
\(\textbf{Aqua complex P:}\)
Water is a weak-field ligand in this standard iron(II) example.
The six d electrons retain the high-spin arrangement.
One d orbital contains an electron pair, while four others remain singly occupied.
Thus:
\[
n_P=4
\]
Two vacant inner \(3d\) orbitals are not available.
Therefore, the six hybrid orbitals are described as \(sp^3d^2\), involving outer d orbitals.
The complex is octahedral and paramagnetic.
\(\textbf{Cyanido complex Q:}\)
Cyanide is a strong-field ligand.
The six d electrons pair within three lower-energy d orbitals.
Two inner d orbitals become vacant and can participate in hybridisation.
The valence-bond description uses \(d^2sp^3\) hybridisation.
All d electrons are paired:
\[
n_Q=0
\]
The complex is octahedral and diamagnetic.
\(\textbf{Comparison:}\)
Both entities have the same metal oxidation state, d-electron count and coordination number.
Their different magnetic behaviours arise from different electron-pairing arrangements.
The ligand change affects the orbitals used in the valence-bond description without changing the basic octahedral geometry.
The example demonstrates why determining the oxidation state alone is insufficient for predicting the magnetic character of a coordination entity.
195. A tetrahedral coordination entity has formula \(\mathrm{[FeCl_4]^-}\). Its experimentally determined spin-only magnetic moment is approximately \(5.92\,\mathrm{BM}\). Using \(\mu=\sqrt{n(n+2)}\,\mathrm{BM}\), which conclusion is consistent with the formula, measurement and standard valence-bond description?
ⓐ. Iron(II), \(d^6\), four unpaired electrons and \(dsp^2\) hybridisation
ⓑ. Iron(III), \(d^5\), one unpaired electron and \(dsp^2\) hybridisation
ⓒ. Iron(III), \(d^5\), five unpaired electrons and \(sp^3\) hybridisation
ⓓ. Iron(II), \(d^6\), five unpaired electrons and \(sp^3\) hybridisation
Correct Answer: Iron(III), \(d^5\), five unpaired electrons and \(sp^3\) hybridisation
Explanation: \(\textbf{Oxidation-state calculation:}\)
The coordination entity contains four chloride ligands, each carrying charge \(-1\).
Its overall charge is \(-1\).
Let the oxidation state of iron be \(x\).
\[
x+4(-1)=-1
\]
\[
x-4=-1
\]
\[
x=+3
\]
\(\textbf{Metal-ion configuration:}\)
The neutral iron atom has configuration \(\mathrm{[Ar]\,3d^6 4s^2}\).
Removal of three electrons gives:
\[
\mathrm{Fe^{3+}:[Ar]\,3d^5}
\]
\(\textbf{Magnetic-moment interpretation:}\)
The spin-only relation is:
\[
\mu=\sqrt{n(n+2)}\,\mathrm{BM}
\]
The measured moment is approximately \(5.92\,\mathrm{BM}\).
Squaring:
\[
n(n+2)\approx(5.92)^2
\]
\[
n(n+2)\approx35
\]
For \(n=5\):
\[
n(n+2)=5(5+2)
\]
\[
=35
\]
Thus, the measurement is consistent with five unpaired electrons.
\(\textbf{Hybridisation and geometry:}\)
The high-spin \(d^5\) arrangement has one electron in each of the five d orbitals.
The four chloride ligands coordinate through four donor atoms.
The tetrahedral valence-bond description uses \(sp^3\) hybridisation.
It does not require the electron pairing associated with a diamagnetic square-planar arrangement.
\(\textbf{Consistency check:}\)
Five unpaired electrons are the maximum possible for a \(d^5\) ion.
The measured magnetic moment is therefore consistent with the stated high-spin tetrahedral structure.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\mathrm{Fe^{3+}:3d^5},\quad n=5,\quad \mu\approx5.92\,\mathrm{BM}
\]
196. The following measurements are reported for two four-coordinate complexes:
P: \(\mathrm{[ZnCl_4]^{2-}}\), diamagnetic
Q: \(\mathrm{[Ni(CN)_4]^{2-}}\), diamagnetic
Both central metal ions belong to the first transition series. Which conclusion is correct?
ⓐ. Both must be square planar because both are diamagnetic.
ⓑ. P is tetrahedral with a \(d^{10}\) central metal ion, whereas Q is square planar with a \(d^8\) central metal ion.
ⓒ. P is square planar with a \(d^{10}\) central metal ion, whereas Q is tetrahedral with a \(d^8\) central metal ion.
ⓓ. Both must be tetrahedral because their coordination numbers are four.
Correct Answer: P is tetrahedral with a \(d^{10}\) central metal ion, whereas Q is square planar with a \(d^8\) central metal ion.
Explanation: Both complexes contain four unidentate ligands and therefore have coordination number four.
However, coordination number four permits more than one geometrical arrangement.
In P, four chloride ions contribute a total charge of \(-4\).
The overall complex charge is \(-2\), so zinc has oxidation state \(+2\).
Zinc(II) has a completely filled \(3d^{10}\) subshell.
All ten d electrons are paired, making the complex diamagnetic.
The standard tetrachloridozincate(II) complex adopts tetrahedral geometry with an \(sp^3\) valence-bond description.
In Q, nickel likewise has oxidation state \(+2\).
Nickel(II) has the configuration \(3d^8\).
The strong-field cyanido ligands favour electron pairing in the standard four-coordinate complex.
The resulting valence-bond description involves \(dsp^2\) hybridisation.
Its geometry is square planar, and all d electrons are paired.
Thus, P and Q are both diamagnetic but differ in metal-ion electron count, hybridisation and coordination geometry.
The absence of unpaired electrons is not a unique signature of square-planar geometry.
The observation must be interpreted together with the identity of the central metal, its electronic configuration and the ligand environment.
197. Two coordination compounds of the same central metal and oxidation state have identical coordination numbers and the same valence-bond hybridisation assignment. However, under identical solution conditions, one undergoes ligand substitution much more rapidly than the other. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
ⓐ. Their different substitution rates prove that one compound has an incorrect coordination number.
ⓑ. Identical hybridisation requires identical substitution rates, so the observations contradict the existence of the compounds.
ⓒ. Their different rates establish that their central metals must possess different numbers of unpaired electrons.
ⓓ. A shared valence-bond hybridisation description does not provide a quantitative prediction of their kinetic stabilities.
Correct Answer: A shared valence-bond hybridisation description does not provide a quantitative prediction of their kinetic stabilities.
Explanation: Valence-bond theory is useful for describing the formation of coordination bonds through suitable hybrid orbitals.
It can explain the geometries and magnetic properties of many standard coordination compounds.
However, the model has important limitations.
One such limitation is its inability to provide a quantitative explanation of the kinetic stabilities of coordination compounds.
Kinetic stability concerns the rates at which processes such as ligand substitution occur.
A complex that undergoes ligand substitution slowly is described as kinetically inert relative to one that reacts rapidly under comparable conditions.
Two complexes may have identical coordination numbers and similar hybridisation descriptions while displaying different substitution rates.
Their ligand identities, bonding environments and reaction pathways may influence those rates.
A hybridisation label alone does not specify the activation-energy barrier for ligand substitution.
Therefore, identical hybridisation does not require identical kinetic behaviour.
The observation also does not, by itself, establish different metal oxidation states or numbers of unpaired electrons.
Kinetic stability must be distinguished from thermodynamic stability.
A thermodynamically stable complex need not always undergo ligand exchange slowly.
The reported difference is consistent with the known limitations of the valence-bond approach rather than evidence that the two coordination compounds cannot exist.
198. Three hypothetical octahedral metal ions P, Q and R have configurations \(d^3\), \(d^5\) and \(d^6\), respectively. Their ligand environments are changed from weak field to sufficiently strong field without changing metal oxidation states or geometries. Which statement correctly describes the possible decreases in the number of unpaired electrons?
ⓐ. P decreases by two, Q decreases by four and R decreases by four.
ⓑ. P shows no decrease, Q decreases by four and R decreases by four.
ⓒ. P shows no decrease, Q decreases by two and R decreases by six.
ⓓ. P decreases by three, Q decreases by four and R decreases by four.
Correct Answer: P shows no decrease, Q decreases by four and R decreases by four.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Behaviour of P — }d^3\textbf{:}\)
The three electrons occupy the three lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) orbitals singly.
The configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{0}
\]
There is no competing need to enter \(e_g\) or pair prematurely in \(t_{2g}\).
Therefore, the ordinary ground-state arrangement remains unchanged when the octahedral field becomes stronger.
The number of unpaired electrons stays at three.
\(\textbf{Behaviour of Q — }d^5\textbf{:}\)
In a weak field, the configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{3}e_g^{2}
\]
All five electrons are unpaired.
In a sufficiently strong field, pairing becomes favourable and the configuration changes to:
\[
t_{2g}^{5}e_g^{0}
\]
Two electron pairs form, leaving one unpaired electron.
The decrease is:
\[
\Delta n_Q=5-1=4
\]
\(\textbf{Behaviour of R — }d^6\textbf{:}\)
In a weak field, the high-spin configuration is:
\[
t_{2g}^{4}e_g^{2}
\]
It contains four unpaired electrons.
In a sufficiently strong field, the configuration becomes:
\[
t_{2g}^{6}e_g^{0}
\]
All six electrons are paired.
Therefore:
\[
\Delta n_R=4-0=4
\]
\(\textbf{Combined conclusion:}\)
The stronger ligand field affects Q and R because their weak-field arrangements involve occupation of higher-energy orbitals to avoid additional pairing.
P already has all three electrons singly occupying the lower-energy orbitals.
Consequently, its spin count does not change.
The same ligand-field change can therefore produce different magnetic responses depending on the metal-ion d-electron count.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\Delta n_P=0,\quad\Delta n_Q=4,\quad\Delta n_R=4}
\]
199. Two coordination compounds contain the same metal ion, the same ligand species and the same number of directly coordinated donor atoms. One is experimentally tetrahedral and the other octahedral. A student applies the relation \(\Delta_t=\frac49\Delta_o\) to compare their observed absorption energies, without examining metal–ligand distances. Which statement correctly evaluates the student's use of the relation?
ⓐ. The relation is always exact for any tetrahedral and octahedral complexes having the same coordination number.
ⓑ. The relation is valid only when the two complexes have different central metals.
ⓒ. The relation is idealised and needs assumptions such as comparable metal–ligand distances for quantitative use.
ⓓ. The relation is invalid because tetrahedral crystal fields never split d orbitals.
Correct Answer: The relation is idealised and needs assumptions such as comparable metal–ligand distances for quantitative use.
Explanation: The crystal-field splitting pattern depends on the geometry of the ligand environment.
In an octahedral complex, the d orbitals split into lower-energy \(t_{2g}\) and higher-energy \(e_g\) sets.
In a tetrahedral complex, the corresponding order is reversed, with the \(e\) set below the \(t_2\) set.
Tetrahedral splitting is generally smaller than octahedral splitting for suitable comparable systems.
The frequently used relation \(\Delta_t=\frac49\Delta_o\) arises from an idealised electrostatic comparison.
It assumes comparable central-metal and ligand conditions, including corresponding metal–ligand distances.
The numerical factor should not be treated as an experimentally universal constant for arbitrary real complexes.
Changing coordination geometry may also change bond lengths and the detailed ligand environment.
Such changes can influence the actual splitting magnitudes.
The question states that the student has not examined the metal–ligand distances.
Therefore, the numerical relation cannot automatically be used to predict an exact ratio of observed absorption energies.
The same metal ion and ligand identity are useful controls but do not independently guarantee all assumptions of the idealised model.
Moreover, an observed optical absorption need not always correspond to a simple single-electron crystal-field transition.
The correct approach is to distinguish the qualitative expectation of smaller tetrahedral splitting from the conditions required for a quantitative \(4/9\) comparison.
200. In the valence-bond description of an octahedral coordination compound, the central metal forms six equivalent hybrid orbitals that accept electron pairs from six unidentate ligands. A student states:
Statement I: Formation of six metal–ligand coordinate bonds necessarily means that the metal ion acquires twelve additional unpaired electrons.
Statement II: The electron pairs supplied by ligands occupy the available metal-centred hybrid orbitals, while the number of unpaired electrons used in the magnetic classification is determined by the complete electronic arrangement of the coordination entity.
Which option is correct?
ⓐ. Both statements are correct.
ⓑ. Statement I is correct, but Statement II is incorrect.
ⓒ. Both statements are incorrect.
ⓓ. Statement I is incorrect, but Statement II is correct.
Correct Answer: Statement I is incorrect, but Statement II is correct.
Explanation: A coordinate bond is formed when a ligand donates an electron pair to a suitable acceptor orbital associated with the central metal.
In the valence-bond description, the central metal forms appropriately directed hybrid orbitals for accepting ligand electron pairs.
Each unidentate ligand contributes one donor attachment in the stated octahedral entity.
Six such ligands therefore provide six electron pairs for six coordination bonds.
However, an electron pair does not constitute two unpaired electrons.
The electrons belonging to a donated pair have opposite spins and are paired in the bonding description.
Consequently, forming six coordinate bonds does not create twelve unpaired electrons.
Statement I is incorrect.
Statement II correctly distinguishes the electron pairs involved in coordinate bonding from the electronic occupancy responsible for the complex's magnetic classification.
The number of unpaired electrons depends on the metal-ion electronic configuration and its ligand-field environment.
For example, octahedral cobalt(III) complexes may be diamagnetic or paramagnetic depending on the ligand environment and electron pairing.
Their six coordinated ligand electron pairs do not make them automatically paramagnetic.
The valence-bond approach describes the bonding interaction using hybrid orbitals, but it does not treat ligand donation as a direct addition to the count of unpaired d electrons.
Thus, Statement II is correct.