1. An element X has the ground-state electronic configuration \([\mathrm{Ne}]\,3s^2 3p^1\). Which identification correctly combines its position in the periodic table and the number of electrons in its outermost shell?
ⓐ. Group 13, Period 3, three valence electrons
ⓑ. Group 13, Period 2, three valence electrons
ⓒ. Group 3, Period 3, three valence electrons
ⓓ. Group 13, Period 3, one valence electron
Correct Answer: Group 13, Period 3, three valence electrons
Explanation: The configuration \([\mathrm{Ne}]\,3s^2 3p^1\) represents aluminium, which has atomic number \(13\).
The highest principal quantum number in the configuration is \(n=3\), so the element belongs to Period 3.
For a p-block element, the outermost \(s\) and \(p\) electrons are counted together to determine the number of valence electrons.
Here, the \(3s\) subshell contains two electrons and the \(3p\) subshell contains one electron.
Thus, the total number of valence electrons is \(2+1=3\).
The general valence-shell configuration of Group 13 elements is \(ns^2np^1\).
The group number is \(13\), not \(3\), even though the atom has three valence electrons.
Counting only the single \(3p\) electron would incorrectly ignore the two outermost \(3s\) electrons.
Hence, aluminium belongs to Group 13 and Period 3 and possesses three valence electrons.
2. An element M belongs to Group 13 and has the general valence-shell configuration \(ns^2np^1\). Which statement correctly combines its valence-electron count with the oxidation-state trend observed down the group?
ⓐ. Three valence electrons; the +1 oxidation state is most characteristic of boron and aluminium.
ⓑ. Three valence electrons; the +1 oxidation state gains relative stability towards heavier members.
ⓒ. One valence electron; the +1 oxidation state gains relative stability towards heavier members.
ⓓ. Three valence electrons; the +3 oxidation state becomes increasingly more stable than +1 down the group.
Correct Answer: Three valence electrons; the +1 oxidation state gains relative stability towards heavier members.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the valence-electron count:}\)
The general valence-shell configuration of Group 13 elements is \(ns^2np^1\).
The outermost \(s\) subshell contains two electrons, while the \(p\) subshell contains one electron.
Therefore, each neutral Group 13 atom possesses three valence electrons.
The number of valence electrons must not be confused with the number of electrons occupying only the \(np\) subshell.
\(\textbf{Examine the possible oxidation states:}\)
The +3 oxidation state involves formal participation of all three valence electrons.
It is particularly important for lighter Group 13 elements such as boron and aluminium.
The +1 oxidation state corresponds formally to participation of the \(np^1\) electron while the \(ns^2\) pair remains occupied.
Both oxidation states are possible for certain members, but their relative stabilities change down the group.
\(\textbf{Apply the inert-pair effect:}\)
Among heavier Group 13 elements, participation of the outermost \(ns^2\) electron pair becomes increasingly unfavourable.
This behaviour is associated with the inert-pair effect.
Consequently, the +1 oxidation state becomes relatively more stable towards the heavier members.
Thallium provides a characteristic example because Tl(I) is generally more stable than Tl(III).
The inert-pair effect does not imply that the +3 oxidation state becomes completely impossible.
It describes a change in relative energetic stability rather than a change in the number of valence electrons.
\(\textbf{Eliminate the incorrect interpretations:}\)
Option A incorrectly associates the greatest importance of the +1 state with the lighter members.
Option C incorrectly counts only the \(np^1\) electron as a valence electron.
Option D reverses the general trend in relative oxidation-state stability.
Therefore, Group 13 elements possess three valence electrons, while the +1 state becomes increasingly important towards the heavier members.
3. Boron and aluminium belong to the same group and possess the same general valence-shell configuration. Nevertheless, boron is not a typical metal, whereas aluminium is metallic. Which explanation best accounts for this difference?
ⓐ. Boron has fewer valence electrons than aluminium.
ⓑ. Aluminium belongs to the s-block, whereas boron belongs to the p-block.
ⓒ. Increasing atomic size and electropositive character favour metallic behaviour in aluminium.
ⓓ. Boron has a completely filled valence shell, whereas aluminium has an incomplete valence shell.
Correct Answer: Increasing atomic size and electropositive character favour metallic behaviour in aluminium.
Explanation: Boron and aluminium are both Group 13 elements with the general valence-shell configuration \(ns^2np^1\).
Consequently, both possess three valence electrons, so a difference in valence-electron count cannot explain their contrasting metallic characters.
Boron is considerably smaller and has a stronger attraction for its valence electrons.
Its relatively high ionization enthalpy makes the formation of a simple \(\mathrm{B^{3+}}\) ion energetically unfavourable.
Boron therefore shows predominantly covalent bonding and non-metallic or metalloid-like behaviour.
Aluminium has a larger atomic size and greater electropositive character.
Its valence electrons are less strongly attracted than those of boron, contributing to its metallic behaviour.
Both elements remain members of the p-block despite this difference.
The broad increase in metallic character down Group 13 is therefore compatible with an unchanged general valence-shell configuration.
This illustrates why membership of the same group does not imply identical physical or bonding behaviour.
4. A heavier Group 13 element M can exhibit both +1 and +3 oxidation states. Consider the outermost electron arrangement of the neutral atom, \(ns^2np^1\), and the formal removal of electrons to form these oxidation states. Which statement correctly connects the electron arrangement with the increasing importance of the +1 state?
ⓐ. The +1 state retains the \(np^1\) electron and removes both \(ns\) electrons.
ⓑ. The +3 state retains the \(ns^2\) pair and removes only the \(np^1\) electron.
ⓒ. The +1 state requires the addition of two electrons to the outermost shell.
ⓓ. The +1 state can retain the \(ns^2\) pair, whose participation becomes less favourable.
Correct Answer: The +1 state can retain the \(ns^2\) pair, whose participation becomes less favourable.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Electronic starting point:}\)
The neutral Group 13 atom has the outermost configuration \(ns^2np^1\).
The \(np^1\) electron is the first outer-shell electron considered for removal in a simplified electron-counting description.
Removal of this electron gives the formal +1 state while leaving the \(ns^2\) pair occupied.
Removal of all three outer-shell electrons corresponds formally to the +3 state.
\(\textbf{Why the lower state becomes important:}\)
In heavier Group 13 elements, the \(ns^2\) electron pair increasingly resists participation in bonding.
This is described by the inert-pair effect.
Consequently, the +1 oxidation state can become more stable relative to the +3 state as one moves towards the heavier members.
The effect does not mean that the \(ns^2\) electrons have disappeared or that they are absolutely incapable of participating in bonding.
It means that their participation becomes energetically less favourable in comparison with the lower oxidation state.
Thallium illustrates this behaviour because Tl(I) is generally more stable than Tl(III).
The decisive distinction is therefore between the number of available valence electrons and the number that participate in producing a particular oxidation state.
5. Consider the following Assertion and Reason.
Assertion (A): Thallium commonly shows greater stability in the +1 oxidation state than in the +3 oxidation state.
Reason (R): In heavier Group 13 elements, participation of the outermost \(ns^2\) electron pair in bonding becomes increasingly unfavourable.
Choose the correct option.
ⓐ. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
ⓑ. Both A and R are true, but R does not correctly explain A.
ⓒ. A is true, but R is false.
ⓓ. A is false, but R is true.
Correct Answer: Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
Explanation: The assertion is correct because Tl(I) is generally more stable than Tl(III).
Thallium belongs to Group 13 and has three outermost electrons, represented by the general arrangement \(ns^2np^1\).
The +3 oxidation state formally involves participation of all three valence electrons.
The +1 state corresponds to participation of only the \(np^1\) electron while the \(ns^2\) pair remains occupied.
The reason is also correct because the inert-pair effect becomes important among heavier p-block elements.
In thallium, the reluctance of the \(6s^2\) electron pair to participate in bonding favours the lower oxidation state.
This gives a direct chemical explanation for the relatively greater stability of Tl(I).
The +3 state is not impossible, but its stability is reduced relative to that of the +1 state.
It would therefore be incorrect to assume that the highest accessible oxidation state must always be the most stable.
Since the reason identifies the underlying cause of the observation stated in the assertion, both statements are true and R correctly explains A.
6. Three Group 13 elements P, Q and R show the following behaviour.
| Element | Supplied observation |
| P | Non-metallic or metalloid-like character; +3 is characteristic |
| Q | Metallic character; +3 is an important stable oxidation state |
| R | Metallic character; +1 is relatively more stable than +3 |
Considering boron, aluminium and thallium, which assignment is consistent with both their chemical character and oxidation-state stability?
ⓐ. P = aluminium, Q = boron, R = thallium
ⓑ. P = boron, Q = aluminium, R = thallium
ⓒ. P = boron, Q = thallium, R = aluminium
ⓓ. P = thallium, Q = aluminium, R = boron
Correct Answer: P = boron, Q = aluminium, R = thallium
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify P from its chemical character:}\)
Boron is the first member of Group 13 and differs significantly from the more metallic members.
Its small atomic size and high ionization enthalpy favour covalent bonding rather than ordinary metallic behaviour.
Boron commonly exhibits the +3 oxidation state, so P is boron.
\(\textbf{Distinguish Q from R:}\)
Aluminium is metallic and commonly forms compounds in the +3 oxidation state.
Although it has the same number of valence electrons as boron and thallium, the relative stability of its oxidation states is different.
For aluminium, the +3 oxidation state is particularly important.
Thallium is also metallic, but the inert-pair effect strongly favours its +1 oxidation state relative to +3.
Thus, R corresponds to thallium and Q corresponds to aluminium.
This assignment simultaneously satisfies the chemical-character evidence and the oxidation-state evidence.
Assigning thallium to Q would neglect the important stability difference between Tl(I) and Tl(III).
The correct sequence is therefore boron, aluminium and thallium for P, Q and R, respectively.
7. In a chemical change, thallium in oxidation state +3 is converted into thallium in oxidation state +1. Which conclusion correctly combines the electron-transfer requirement with the significance of this change?
ⓐ. Tl(III) loses two electrons and behaves as a reducing agent.
ⓑ. Tl(III) gains one electron and reaches the more stable +1 state.
ⓒ. Tl(III) gains two electrons and can behave as an oxidizing agent.
ⓓ. Tl(III) loses one electron and produces the more stable +1 state.
Correct Answer: Tl(III) gains two electrons and can behave as an oxidizing agent.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the oxidation-state change:}\)
Thallium changes from oxidation state +3 to oxidation state +1.
A decrease in oxidation state indicates reduction rather than oxidation.
The change is represented by the following formal electron-transfer relation:
\[
\mathrm{Tl^{3+}+2e^-\longrightarrow Tl^+}
\]
The oxidation state decreases by two units, so two electrons are gained.
\(\textbf{Interpret the chemical role:}\)
A species that gains electrons undergoes reduction.
When it accepts electrons from another species, it acts as an oxidizing agent.
Therefore, thallium(III) can behave as an oxidizing agent while being reduced to thallium(I).
The greater relative stability of Tl(I) is consistent with the tendency of Tl(III) compounds to undergo reduction under suitable conditions.
This behaviour is related to the inert-pair effect, which favours retention of the outermost \(6s^2\) pair.
The reverse conversion, Tl(I) to Tl(III), would require oxidation and participation of two additional valence electrons.
Hence, electron-transfer direction, oxidizing behaviour and oxidation-state stability all support the same conclusion.
8. Consider the following statements concerning the oxides of Group 13 elements. Assume oxygen has oxidation state \(-2\) in each oxide.
Statement I: An oxide containing a Group 13 element in oxidation state +1 can have the formula \(\mathrm{M_2O}\).
Statement II: An oxide containing the element in oxidation state +3 can have the formula \(\mathrm{M_2O_3}\).
Statement III: A Group 13 element forming \(\mathrm{M_2O_3}\) must have the +3 oxidation state as its most stable state under all conditions.
Statement IV: The relative stability of \(\mathrm{Tl_2O}\) compared with a corresponding Tl(III) oxide is consistent with the inert-pair effect.
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. Statements I, II and IV only
ⓑ. Statements I, III and IV only
ⓒ. Statements II, III and IV only
ⓓ. Statements I, II and III only
Correct Answer: Statements I, II and IV only
Explanation: \(\textbf{Evaluate the oxide formulas:}\)
For an element M in oxidation state +1, two M atoms are required to balance one oxide ion carrying charge \(-2\).
Thus, the neutral formula \(\mathrm{M_2O}\) is consistent with oxidation state +1, making Statement I correct.
For oxidation state +3, two M atoms contribute a total formal oxidation-state sum of +6.
Three oxygen atoms contribute \(-6\), giving the neutral formula \(\mathrm{M_2O_3}\).
Therefore, Statement II is also correct.
Statement III is incorrect because a chemically possible oxidation state need not be the most stable oxidation state.
A compound containing Tl(III) can exist even though Tl(I) is generally more stable.
Statement IV is correct because the inert-pair effect favours retention of the \(ns^2\) pair in heavier Group 13 elements.
In thallium, this favours the +1 state relative to +3.
The formula \(\mathrm{Tl_2O}\) corresponds to Tl(I), whereas a Tl(III) oxide has the formula \(\mathrm{Tl_2O_3}\).
The crucial distinction is between satisfying oxidation-state charge balance and predicting relative chemical stability.
Thus, Statements I, II and IV are correct.
9. Boron commonly forms covalent compounds even when its formal oxidation state is +3. Which explanation correctly reconciles these observations?
ⓐ. Boron forms covalent compounds only when its oxidation state is zero.
ⓑ. Boron's +3 oxidation state requires three completely ionic B–X bonds.
ⓒ. Boron possesses only one valence electron, which is shared three times.
ⓓ. Boron's small size makes formation of a free \(\mathrm{B^{3+}}\) ion energetically unfavourable.
Correct Answer: Boron's small size makes formation of a free \(\mathrm{B^{3+}}\) ion energetically unfavourable.
Explanation: Boron has three valence electrons and commonly exhibits the formal oxidation state +3 in its compounds.
However, the oxidation state is an electron-accounting quantity and is not necessarily the actual charge on an atom.
Formation of an isolated \(\mathrm{B^{3+}}\) ion would require removal of three electrons from a very small atom.
The exceptionally high energy requirement makes such simple ionic behaviour unfavourable under ordinary conditions.
Consequently, boron generally forms compounds involving shared electron pairs.
For example, boron trichloride contains covalent B–Cl bonds while boron has the formal oxidation state +3.
The oxidation state is assigned using electronegativity-based electron counting, rather than by claiming complete physical transfer of electrons.
Thus, covalent bonding and a positive formal oxidation state are chemically compatible.
This is particularly important when comparing boron with more electropositive Group 13 members.
The misconception is to interpret an oxidation-state number as proof that a corresponding free cation must exist.
The correct explanation is therefore based on boron's small size, high ionization enthalpy and preference for covalent bonding.
10. A neutral molecule \(\mathrm{BCl_3}\) contains three B–Cl single bonds around its central boron atom. Under suitable conditions, it can accept an electron pair from a Lewis base. Which interpretation correctly relates these observations?
ⓐ. Boron possesses a complete octet and donates an electron pair to the base.
ⓑ. Boron has six electrons around it and can accept a lone pair into an available orbital.
ⓒ. Boron has eight electrons around it but loses two electrons before accepting the base.
ⓓ. Boron possesses two electrons around it and must first form an ionic \(\mathrm{B^{3+}}\) species.
Correct Answer: Boron has six electrons around it and can accept a lone pair into an available orbital.
Explanation: Boron has three valence electrons and ordinarily forms three covalent bonds in \(\mathrm{BCl_3}\).
Each B–Cl single bond contributes a shared electron pair around the central boron atom.
The three bonding pairs therefore account for six electrons around boron.
Thus, the central atom does not possess a complete octet in the usual Lewis structure of \(\mathrm{BCl_3}\).
Boron has an available orbital that can accept electron density from a suitable donor.
A Lewis base possesses an electron pair that can be donated to an electron-pair acceptor.
Consequently, \(\mathrm{BCl_3}\) can behave as a Lewis acid.
Electron-pair acceptance can increase the coordination number of boron from three to four.
This behaviour does not require formation of a free \(\mathrm{B^{3+}}\) ion.
It also does not mean that boron initially possesses eight electrons around it.
The key reasoning is that three covalent bonds satisfy boron's usual trivalent bonding pattern without necessarily satisfying the octet rule.
11. Boron trifluoride and ammonia combine to form a Lewis acid–base adduct, represented schematically by \(\mathrm{F_3B\leftarrow NH_3}\), where the arrow indicates donation of the nitrogen lone pair to boron. Which statement correctly describes the change at boron?
ⓐ. Boron changes from +3 to +1 and retains three-coordinate bonding.
ⓑ. Boron changes from +3 to 0 and forms a free ionic intermediate.
ⓒ. Boron stays at +3 while its coordination increases from three to four.
ⓓ. Boron remains in oxidation state +3 while its coordination number decreases from three to two.
Correct Answer: Boron stays at +3 while its coordination increases from three to four.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Examine the initial molecule:}\)
In \(\mathrm{BF_3}\), boron is bonded to three fluorine atoms.
Boron has the formal oxidation state +3 because each fluorine is assigned oxidation state \(-1\).
Three B–F bonds provide six electrons around the central boron atom in the ordinary Lewis structure.
Thus, boron is electron-deficient and can accept a lone pair from a donor.
\(\textbf{Interpret adduct formation:}\)
Ammonia has a lone pair on nitrogen that can be donated to the electron-deficient boron centre.
The resulting coordinate bond increases the number of atoms directly bonded to boron from three to four.
Therefore, boron's coordination number increases from three to four, and its immediate electron-counting environment becomes octet-complete.
This is a Lewis acid–base interaction rather than a redox reaction.
The formal oxidation state of boron remains +3 because electron-pair donation does not produce the electron transfer characteristic of reduction to +1 or to zero.
In the adduct, oxidation-state assignments remain consistent with boron at +3 and nitrogen at \(-3\).
The essential distinction is that coordination number and oxidation state describe different chemical properties.
Formation of an additional coordinate bond does not, by itself, prove that an atom's oxidation state has changed.
12. Consider the oxides \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\) and \(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\). A student argues that both must behave identically towards acids and bases because boron and aluminium belong to Group 13 and exhibit oxidation state +3 in these oxides. Which response is chemically correct?
ⓐ. Both oxides are necessarily basic because the elements belong to Group 13.
ⓑ. Both oxides are necessarily neutral because their central elements have equal oxidation states.
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\) is amphoteric, whereas \(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\) is exclusively acidic.
ⓓ. \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\) is acidic, whereas \(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\) is amphoteric.
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\) is acidic, whereas \(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\) is amphoteric.
Explanation: Boron and aluminium both belong to Group 13 and commonly show the +3 oxidation state.
Consequently, their ordinary oxides can have the same general stoichiometric formula, \(\mathrm{M_2O_3}\).
However, identical stoichiometry does not imply identical acid–base behaviour.
Boron is a small, relatively non-metallic element whose compounds commonly show pronounced covalent character.
Its oxide, \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\), is acidic and can react with suitable bases.
Aluminium has greater metallic character, but its oxide is not simply a strongly basic oxide.
\(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\) is amphoteric, meaning that it can react with both acids and bases under appropriate conditions.
Amphoterism must not be confused with chemical neutrality.
The distinction reflects the different chemical characters of boron and aluminium despite their common group membership.
Their oxidation states establish an electron-accounting similarity, whereas their bonding and acid–base properties reveal an important difference.
The student's conclusion is therefore incorrect because group membership and oxidation-state equality are insufficient to predict identical oxide behaviour.
13. Two white solid oxides P and Q are known to be the normal oxides of boron and aluminium, respectively, but their identities are initially concealed. Their qualitative acid–base behaviour under suitable reaction conditions is supplied below.
| Test | Oxide P | Oxide Q |
| Reaction with a suitable acid | No characteristic acid–base reaction | Reacts |
| Reaction with a suitable strong base | Reacts | Reacts |
Which assignment and explanation are consistent with these observations?
ⓐ. P = \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\), Q = \(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\); acidic and amphoteric behaviour, respectively
ⓑ. P = \(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\), Q = \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\); acidic and amphoteric behaviour, respectively
ⓒ. P = \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\), Q = \(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\); amphoteric and basic behaviour, respectively
ⓓ. P = \(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\), Q = \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\); basic and neutral behaviour, respectively
Correct Answer: P = \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\), Q = \(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\); acidic and amphoteric behaviour, respectively
Explanation: \(\textbf{Classify the first oxide:}\)
Oxide P reacts with a suitable strong base but does not show the characteristic acid–base reaction of a basic or amphoteric oxide with the supplied acid.
This behaviour is consistent with an acidic oxide.
Among the two specified Group 13 oxides, \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\) is acidic.
Therefore, P is identified as \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\).
\(\textbf{Classify the second oxide:}\)
Oxide Q reacts with both a suitable acid and a suitable strong base.
Such dual acid–base behaviour is the defining feature of an amphoteric oxide.
Aluminium oxide, \(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\), is amphoteric, so Q is identified as \(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\).
The two observations for Q must be considered together; reaction with an acid alone would not establish amphoterism.
\(\textbf{Connect the observations to periodic character:}\)
Boron is more non-metallic and its oxide shows acidic character.
Aluminium is more metallic, but its oxide retains amphoteric behaviour rather than behaving as an exclusively basic oxide.
The identical +3 oxidation state of the two elements does not determine the oxide classification by itself.
Thus, the response pattern supports P as boron oxide and Q as aluminium oxide.
14. A student compares the following three observations for Group 13.
Statement I: Boron trichloride has predominantly covalent bonding even though boron exhibits oxidation state +3.
Statement II: Aluminium oxide reacts with both suitable acids and bases, although aluminium is metallic.
Statement III: Thallium(I) can be more stable than thallium(III), although thallium possesses three valence electrons.
Which interpretation correctly reconciles these observations?
ⓐ. Statements I and II are valid, but Statement III contradicts the Group 13 valence configuration.
ⓑ. All three hold: valence-electron count alone fixes neither bonding, oxide character nor oxidation-state stability.
ⓒ. Statements II and III are valid, but covalent bonding prevents boron from exhibiting oxidation state +3.
ⓓ. Only Statement I is valid because metallic Group 13 elements must form basic oxides and favour oxidation state +3.
Correct Answer: All three hold: valence-electron count alone fixes neither bonding, oxide character nor oxidation-state stability.
Explanation: All three observations are chemically valid, but they describe different consequences of electronic structure.
Statement I is correct because boron commonly forms covalent compounds owing to its small size and high ionization enthalpy.
In \(\mathrm{BCl_3}\), boron's formal oxidation state is +3 without requiring the compound to contain free \(\mathrm{B^{3+}}\) ions.
The oxidation-state number therefore cannot be used as a direct measurement of ionic bonding character.
Statement II is correct because aluminium oxide is amphoteric.
Aluminium's metallic character does not require every aluminium compound to behave exclusively as a basic substance.
Oxide acid–base behaviour depends on more than the broad metal/non-metal classification of the parent element.
Statement III is also correct because Tl(I) is relatively more stable than Tl(III).
The inert-pair effect increasingly favours non-participation of the outermost \(ns^2\) electrons in heavier Group 13 elements.
Thus, three valence electrons do not guarantee that +3 will always be the preferred oxidation state.
The three observations are linked by a central principle: electronic configuration provides a starting framework, but atomic size, bonding and relative energetic stability determine actual chemical behaviour.
A successful prediction must therefore distinguish oxidation state from bonding character and chemical stability.
15. Two Group 13 elements X and Y form chlorides in which their oxidation states are +3 and +1, respectively. X represents a lighter member for which the +3 state is particularly important, whereas Y represents a heavier member for which the +1 state is generally preferred. Which prediction is most consistent with the electron-pair participation responsible for this difference?
ⓐ. X and Y both favour complete retention of their outermost \(ns^2\) pairs in bonding.
ⓑ. Y favours participation of all three valence electrons more strongly than X.
ⓒ. X is more likely to form stable +3 compounds, whereas Y shows greater relative stability in +1 compounds.
ⓓ. Y must possess fewer than three valence electrons because its preferred oxidation state is +1.
Correct Answer: X is more likely to form stable +3 compounds, whereas Y shows greater relative stability in +1 compounds.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Establish the common valence framework:}\)
Both X and Y belong to Group 13, so their general valence-shell configuration is \(ns^2np^1\).
Each neutral atom therefore has three outermost electrons.
The observation that X exhibits a particularly important +3 state is consistent with substantial participation of these three electrons in bonding.
For a lighter member such as aluminium, the +3 oxidation state is commonly favoured.
\(\textbf{Interpret the heavier member:}\)
The +1 oxidation state corresponds formally to participation of the \(np^1\) electron while the \(ns^2\) pair remains occupied.
In heavier Group 13 members, the inert-pair effect makes participation of that pair less favourable.
Consequently, the lower oxidation state becomes relatively more stable.
Thallium provides an important example because Tl(I) is generally more stable than Tl(III).
This difference does not arise because thallium has fewer valence electrons than aluminium.
It arises from the changing relative tendency of the available electrons to participate in chemical bonding.
The correct prediction must therefore preserve the common valence-electron count while allowing oxidation-state stability to change.
This is why X can favour +3 compounds while Y exhibits greater relative stability in +1 compounds.
16. Three unknown elements X, Y and Z belong to Group 13. The following independent observations are made under suitable chemical conditions.
Element X forms a trihalide with an electron-deficient central atom that can accept a lone pair from ammonia. Its normal oxide is acidic.
Element Y forms a normal oxide with formula \(\mathrm{Y_2O_3}\) that reacts with both acids and strong bases.
Element Z forms compounds in both +1 and +3 oxidation states, but its +1 state is generally more stable.
The three elements are to be selected from boron, aluminium and thallium.
Which assignment simultaneously satisfies the electron-pair, oxide and oxidation-state evidence?
ⓐ. X = aluminium, Y = boron, Z = thallium
ⓑ. X = boron, Y = thallium, Z = aluminium
ⓒ. X = thallium, Y = aluminium, Z = boron
ⓓ. X = boron, Y = aluminium, Z = thallium
Correct Answer: X = boron, Y = aluminium, Z = thallium
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify X using two related properties:}\)
An electron-deficient trihalide capable of accepting an electron pair is characteristic of boron trihalide behaviour.
In a molecule such as \(\mathrm{BCl_3}\), the central boron atom has six electrons around it in the ordinary Lewis structure.
It can accept a suitable donor lone pair and thereby act as a Lewis acid.
Boron also forms the acidic oxide \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\).
Both the electron-deficiency evidence and the oxide evidence therefore identify X as boron.
\(\textbf{Identify Y from amphoterism:}\)
The oxide of Y reacts with both acids and strong bases.
This establishes amphoteric behaviour rather than exclusively acidic or basic behaviour.
Aluminium oxide, \(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\), is amphoteric.
Therefore, Y is aluminium.
\(\textbf{Identify Z through oxidation-state stability:}\)
The remaining element is thallium, but its assignment must also agree with the independent oxidation-state evidence.
Thallium can exhibit +1 and +3 oxidation states, with Tl(I) generally more stable.
The inert-pair effect helps explain this preference for the lower oxidation state.
Thus, Z is thallium.
The three identifications are mutually consistent with the common Group 13 valence configuration \(ns^2np^1\).
Their differences arise from changes in atomic size, chemical character, bonding and the relative stability of oxidation states.
The correct assignment is therefore X = boron, Y = aluminium and Z = thallium.
17. Aluminium and gallium belong to Group 13 and have the valence-shell configuration \(ns^2np^1\). Their covalent radii are approximately \(143\,\mathrm{pm}\) and \(135\,\mathrm{pm}\), respectively. Gallium therefore does not follow the simple expectation of a larger radius on moving down the group. Which explanation is consistent with its electronic configuration and the observed size?
ⓐ. The filled \(3d\) subshell in gallium screens nuclear charge so effectively that the \(4p\) electron experiences negligible attraction.
ⓑ. Gallium has a smaller principal quantum number than aluminium, causing its outermost electrons to occupy a lower shell.
ⓒ. Gallium contains an additional filled \(3d\) subshell whose relatively poor shielding increases the attraction experienced by its outer electrons.
ⓓ. Gallium has fewer valence electrons than aluminium, allowing the remaining valence electrons to approach the nucleus more closely.
Correct Answer: Gallium contains an additional filled \(3d\) subshell whose relatively poor shielding increases the attraction experienced by its outer electrons.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Compare the electronic configurations:}\)
Aluminium has the configuration \([\mathrm{Ne}]\,3s^23p^1\), whereas gallium has \([\mathrm{Ar}]\,3d^{10}4s^24p^1\).
Both elements possess three valence electrons and belong to Group 13.
Gallium has an additional principal shell, so a simple shell-number argument would predict a larger atomic radius.
However, the supplied radii show that gallium is slightly smaller than aluminium.
\(\textbf{Account for the shielding difference:}\)
The ten \(3d\) electrons in gallium do not shield the increasing nuclear charge as effectively as an equivalent number of electrons in more penetrating inner orbitals.
Consequently, the outer electrons experience a relatively strong effective nuclear attraction.
This increased attraction offsets the size increase expected from the additional principal shell.
The result is a contraction sufficient to make gallium's covalent radius slightly smaller than aluminium's.
The observation cannot be explained by claiming that gallium has fewer valence electrons or belongs to a lower period.
It illustrates why increasing principal quantum number does not guarantee a perfectly regular increase in atomic radius down every p-block group.
Thus, poor shielding by the filled \(3d\) subshell explains the observed exception.
18. Aluminium and gallium are metallic Group 13 elements, yet their melting points are approximately \(660^\circ\mathrm{C}\) and \(29.8^\circ\mathrm{C}\), respectively. Consider pure samples of both elements in equilibrium at \(30^\circ\mathrm{C}\) under ordinary pressure. Which conclusion correctly combines their physical states with the limitation of predicting melting points from group membership?
ⓐ. Aluminium is solid and gallium is liquid; their different solid-state bonding arrangements influence their melting points.
ⓑ. Aluminium is liquid and gallium is solid; the element farther down the group necessarily has a higher melting point.
ⓒ. Both are solid; equal numbers of valence electrons require similar melting behaviour.
ⓓ. Both are liquid; metallic character alone determines whether a Group 13 element melts near room temperature.
Correct Answer: Aluminium is solid and gallium is liquid; their different solid-state bonding arrangements influence their melting points.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the physical states:}\)
A pure substance is normally solid below its equilibrium melting point and liquid above it, provided no unusual metastable condition is maintained.
The stated temperature of \(30^\circ\mathrm{C}\) is far below aluminium's melting point of approximately \(660^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
Therefore, aluminium remains solid under the specified conditions.
Gallium melts at approximately \(29.8^\circ\mathrm{C}\), which is slightly below the stated temperature.
Consequently, gallium is liquid at equilibrium at \(30^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
\(\textbf{Explain the physical-property difference:}\)
Both elements possess three valence electrons and are metallic, but this does not imply identical cohesive forces in their solids.
Melting depends on the bonding and structural arrangement of atoms in the condensed phase.
Gallium has unusual solid-state bonding and packing characteristics that contribute to its low melting point.
Aluminium has a different metallic crystal structure and substantially greater resistance to melting.
Atomic size alone cannot provide a reliable quantitative prediction of these melting points.
Likewise, the melting points of all Group 13 elements cannot be assumed to decrease uniformly with increasing atomic number.
The correct conclusion follows from interpreting the supplied temperatures and recognising the influence of solid-state structure.
19. Boron and indium belong to Group 13. Their normal oxides can both be represented by the general formula \(\mathrm{M_2O_3}\), but their acid–base tendencies are different. Which prediction is consistent with their relative metallic characters and the meaning of the oxide formula?
ⓐ. Both oxides must be equally acidic because their parent elements have three valence electrons.
ⓑ. Indium oxide must be neutral because indium is metallic and exhibits the +3 oxidation state.
ⓒ. Boron oxide must be more basic because boron has the smaller atomic radius.
ⓓ. Indium(III) oxide is more basic than boron(III) oxide despite their common +3 oxidation state.
Correct Answer: Indium(III) oxide is more basic than boron(III) oxide despite their common +3 oxidation state.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret the common oxide formula:}\)
In \(\mathrm{M_2O_3}\), each oxygen atom is assigned oxidation state \(-2\).
The three oxygen atoms contribute a total oxidation-state sum of \(-6\).
Therefore, the two atoms of M must together contribute +6, giving M an oxidation state of +3.
This electron-accounting result applies to both \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\) and \(\mathrm{In_2O_3}\).
However, identical oxidation states do not require identical oxide acid–base behaviour.
\(\textbf{Compare the parent elements:}\)
Boron is much less metallic than indium and forms predominantly covalent compounds.
Its oxide, \(\mathrm{B_2O_3}\), is acidic.
Indium is a metallic member of Group 13 and forms an oxide with appreciably greater basic character.
\(\mathrm{In_2O_3}\) can also exhibit amphoteric behaviour under suitable conditions, so its increased basic tendency should not be interpreted as proof that it is exclusively basic.
The trend is consistent with the broad increase in metallic character down the group.
The essential distinction is that oxidation-state equality determines formal electron balance, whereas oxide acid–base behaviour depends strongly on chemical bonding and the character of the parent element.
Hence, indium oxide has a greater basic tendency than boron oxide without requiring a different oxidation state.
20. Two elements X and Y have the electronic configurations \([\mathrm{Ar}]\,3d^{10}4s^24p^2\) and \([\mathrm{Kr}]\,4d^{10}5s^25p^2\), respectively. Which conclusion correctly identifies the elements and relates their electronic similarity to their chemical character?
ⓐ. X is germanium and Y is tin; both are non-metals because their outermost configurations are identical in form.
ⓑ. X is germanium and Y is tin; both have four valence electrons, but Y is more metallic.
ⓒ. X is gallium and Y is indium; both have four valence electrons and show predominantly covalent bonding.
ⓓ. X is silicon and Y is germanium; both have four valence electrons, but X is more metallic.
Correct Answer: X is germanium and Y is tin; both have four valence electrons, but Y is more metallic.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the elements:}\)
The configuration of X contains two electrons in the \(4s\) subshell and two electrons in the \(4p\) subshell.
Its complete ground-state configuration corresponds to atomic number \(32\), identifying X as germanium.
The highest principal quantum number is four, placing germanium in Period 4.
The configuration of Y corresponds to atomic number \(50\), identifying Y as tin.
Its outermost electrons occupy the \(5s\) and \(5p\) subshells, placing it in Period 5.
\(\textbf{Connect configuration with character:}\)
Both configurations end in \(ns^2np^2\), the characteristic pattern of Group 14.
Each element therefore has four valence electrons.
However, identical general valence configurations do not imply identical metallic character.
Germanium is commonly classified as a metalloid, whereas tin is metallic.
Moving down Group 14, increasing atomic size and changes in electron attraction generally favour increasing metallic character.
Tin consequently shows more pronounced metallic behaviour than germanium.
The filled inner \(d\) subshells do not convert either element into a d-block element because the differentiating electron enters a \(p\) subshell.
Thus, the correct identification must combine electronic configuration, periodic position and the down-group change in chemical character.
21. Methane and silane have the formulas \(\mathrm{CH_4}\) and \(\mathrm{SiH_4}\), respectively. On the Pauling scale, the electronegativities of carbon, hydrogen and silicon are approximately \(2.55\), \(2.20\) and \(1.90\), respectively. Which pair of formal oxidation states is correct for the central atoms?
ⓐ. Carbon = +4; Silicon = +4
ⓑ. Carbon = \(-4\); Silicon = \(-4\)
ⓒ. Carbon = +4; Silicon = \(-4\)
ⓓ. Carbon = \(-4\); Silicon = +4
Correct Answer: Carbon = \(-4\); Silicon = +4
Explanation: \(\textbf{Apply the electronegativity rule:}\)
In formal oxidation-state assignment, bonding electrons are assigned to the more electronegative atom.
Hydrogen generally has oxidation state +1 when bonded to an element more electronegative than itself.
It has oxidation state \(-1\) when bonded to an element less electronegative than itself.
Carbon is more electronegative than hydrogen because \(2.55\) is greater than \(2.20\).
Therefore, hydrogen is assigned +1 in \(\mathrm{CH_4}\).
The molecule is neutral, so:
\[
x+4(+1)=0
\]
\[
x=-4
\]
Thus, carbon has oxidation state \(-4\) in methane.
\(\textbf{Repeat the assignment for silane:}\)
Silicon is less electronegative than hydrogen because \(1.90\) is less than \(2.20\).
Consequently, hydrogen is assigned oxidation state \(-1\) in \(\mathrm{SiH_4}\).
For the neutral molecule:
\[
y+4(-1)=0
\]
\[
y=+4
\]
Silicon therefore has oxidation state +4 in silane.
The two hydrides have the same general molecular formula and both contain four bonds to hydrogen.
Nevertheless, their central atoms have opposite formal oxidation states because the relative electronegativities differ.
This demonstrates why molecular formula and covalency alone cannot determine oxidation state.
The required pair is carbon \(-4\) and silicon +4.
22. Tin and lead are Group 14 elements exhibiting both +2 and +4 oxidation states. Under suitable reaction conditions, \(\mathrm{Sn^{2+}}\) can be converted to \(\mathrm{Sn^{4+}}\), whereas Pb(IV) can be converted to Pb(II). Which statement correctly combines the electron-transfer directions with the relative stability of these states?
ⓐ. Sn(II) acts as an oxidizing agent, whereas Pb(IV) acts as a reducing agent.
ⓑ. Both Sn(II) and Pb(IV) act as reducing agents because they belong to Group 14.
ⓒ. Sn(II) can act as a reducing agent, whereas Pb(IV) can act as an oxidizing agent.
ⓓ. Neither species undergoes electron transfer because both elements possess four valence electrons.
Correct Answer: Sn(II) can act as a reducing agent, whereas Pb(IV) can act as an oxidizing agent.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Examine the tin conversion:}\)
Tin changes from oxidation state +2 to +4.
An increase in oxidation state represents oxidation.
The corresponding electron-transfer relation is:
\[
\mathrm{Sn^{2+}\longrightarrow Sn^{4+}+2e^-}
\]
Tin(II) loses two electrons and can therefore behave as a reducing agent.
This is consistent with the importance of the +4 oxidation state for tin.
\(\textbf{Examine the lead conversion:}\)
Lead changes from oxidation state +4 to +2.
A decrease in oxidation state represents reduction.
The corresponding relation is:
\[
\mathrm{Pb^{4+}+2e^-\longrightarrow Pb^{2+}}
\]
Here, Pb(IV) gains two electrons and can behave as an oxidizing agent.
The +2 oxidation state is generally more stable than +4 for lead because the inert-pair effect is especially significant in this heavier Group 14 member.
This does not imply that every Sn(II) or Pb(IV) compound reacts instantaneously under all conditions.
The actual reaction still depends on the other reactant and the surrounding chemical conditions.
Nevertheless, the relative oxidation-state stabilities help explain the contrasting redox tendencies.
The correct interpretation is that Sn(II) can donate electrons, whereas Pb(IV) can accept electrons.
23. Carbon dioxide and silicon dioxide both contain the Group 14 element in oxidation state +4. However, carbon dioxide exists as discrete molecules, whereas ordinary crystalline silicon dioxide has an extended covalent network. Which explanation best accounts for this difference?
ⓐ. Carbon forms effective \(p\pi\)-\(p\pi\) bonds with oxygen, whereas silicon dioxide favours a network of Si–O bonds with bridging oxygen atoms.
ⓑ. Carbon dioxide is molecular because carbon has only two valence electrons, whereas silicon has four.
ⓒ. Silicon dioxide forms a network because silicon is assigned oxidation state +2, unlike carbon in carbon dioxide.
ⓓ. Carbon dioxide is molecular because its bonds are ionic, whereas silicon dioxide contains only metallic bonding.
Correct Answer: Carbon forms effective \(p\pi\)-\(p\pi\) bonds with oxygen, whereas silicon dioxide favours a network of Si–O bonds with bridging oxygen atoms.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the common chemical feature:}\)
Both carbon and silicon belong to Group 14 and possess four valence electrons.
With oxygen assigned oxidation state \(-2\), the central element has oxidation state +4 in both dioxides.
Therefore, oxidation-state equality cannot explain the structural difference.
\(\textbf{Compare orbital overlap:}\)
Carbon possesses compact \(2p\) orbitals that can overlap effectively with oxygen \(2p\) orbitals.
This favours strong carbon–oxygen multiple bonding.
An ordinary carbon dioxide molecule can consequently be represented as \(\mathrm{O=C=O}\).
Silicon has larger and more diffuse \(3p\) orbitals.
Effective sideways overlap with oxygen \(2p\) orbitals is substantially less favourable than the corresponding carbon–oxygen overlap.
Silicon dioxide therefore favours an extended structure containing Si–O–Si linkages.
In crystalline silica, silicon is generally bonded tetrahedrally to four oxygen atoms, while oxygen atoms connect neighbouring silicon centres.
Thus, \(\mathrm{SiO_2}\) represents the atomic ratio in a network solid rather than a discrete three-atom molecule analogous to \(\mathrm{CO_2}\).
The different bonding arrangements also account for major differences in their bulk physical properties.
The correct reasoning connects orbital size, multiple-bonding ability and the resulting molecular or network structure.
24. The approximate single-bond enthalpies of C–C and Si–Si bonds are \(348\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) and \(226\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\), respectively. Carbon and silicon both belong to Group 14. Which inference most appropriately combines these data with their catenation behaviour?
ⓐ. Silicon should show greater catenation because its larger atomic radius allows stronger Si–Si bonds.
ⓑ. Carbon catenates more strongly than silicon, although silicon can also form element–element chains.
ⓒ. Carbon cannot form extended chains because its C–C bond enthalpy is greater than the Si–Si bond enthalpy.
ⓓ. Carbon and silicon must show identical catenation tendencies because both have four valence electrons.
Correct Answer: Carbon catenates more strongly than silicon, although silicon can also form element–element chains.
Explanation: Catenation is the ability of an element to form bonds with atoms of the same element, producing chains, rings or extended frameworks.
Carbon and silicon both have four valence electrons, so both can form covalent bonds with atoms of their own kind.
However, the strength of those bonds influences the persistence and stability of the resulting structures.
The supplied C–C bond enthalpy is considerably greater than the Si–Si bond enthalpy.
A larger bond dissociation enthalpy generally indicates that more energy is required to break that particular bond.
Carbon's relatively small atomic size permits effective orbital overlap and strong C–C bonding.
This contributes to its exceptional ability to form stable chains and rings.
Silicon atoms are larger, and their more diffuse valence orbitals generally produce weaker Si–Si bonds.
Consequently, silicon's tendency towards extensive catenation is less pronounced than carbon's.
This does not mean that silicon is completely incapable of bonding to itself.
It also does not mean that bond enthalpy is the only factor determining the stability of every possible compound.
The comparison must distinguish the existence of catenation from its relative extent and chemical favourability.
Thus, the bond-strength evidence supports carbon's greater catenation tendency while allowing some self-bonding in silicon.
25. Lead dioxide can oxidize iodide ions in acidic medium while Pb(IV) is reduced to Pb(II). Which equation correctly represents the overall reaction, with both atoms and charge balanced?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{PbO_2+2H^++2I^-\rightarrow Pb^{2+}+I_2+H_2O}\)
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{PbO_2+4H^++4I^-\rightarrow Pb^{2+}+2I_2+2H_2O}\)
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{PbO_2+4H^++2I^-\rightarrow Pb^{4+}+I_2+2H_2O}\)
ⓓ. \(\mathrm{PbO_2+4H^++2I^-\rightarrow Pb^{2+}+I_2+2H_2O}\)
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{PbO_2+4H^++2I^-\rightarrow Pb^{2+}+I_2+2H_2O}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the oxidation-state changes:}\)
In \(\mathrm{PbO_2}\), oxygen has oxidation state \(-2\), so lead has oxidation state +4.
Lead is reduced from +4 to +2, requiring a gain of two electrons.
Iodine changes from oxidation state \(-1\) in iodide to zero in molecular iodine.
Therefore, two iodide ions collectively lose two electrons.
\(\textbf{Write the reduction half-reaction:}\)
In acidic medium, oxygen atoms can be balanced by forming water, and hydrogen atoms can be balanced using hydrogen ions.
\[
\mathrm{PbO_2+4H^++2e^-\rightarrow Pb^{2+}+2H_2O}
\]
\(\textbf{Write the oxidation half-reaction:}\)
\[
\mathrm{2I^-\rightarrow I_2+2e^-}
\]
Both half-reactions involve two electrons, so no additional multiplication is necessary.
Adding them and cancelling electrons gives:
\[
\mathrm{PbO_2+4H^++2I^-\rightarrow Pb^{2+}+I_2+2H_2O}
\]
\(\textbf{Verify the balance:}\)
There is one lead atom, two oxygen atoms, four hydrogen atoms and two iodine atoms on each side.
The net charge on the left is \(+4-2=+2\).
The net charge on the right is also +2.
Thus, both atomic and charge conservation are satisfied.
This reaction illustrates the oxidizing behaviour possible for Pb(IV), whose reduction to the generally more stable +2 state is consistent with the inert-pair effect.
The correct equation must satisfy the electron-transfer requirement as well as conservation of atoms and charge.
26. Consider the ordinary oxides \(\mathrm{CO_2}\) and \(\mathrm{SnO_2}\). Both have the Group 14 element in oxidation state +4, but their acid–base behaviour differs. Which statement correctly relates the difference to the periodic change in metallic character?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{CO_2}\) is acidic, while \(\mathrm{SnO_2}\) is amphoteric; tin is more metallic than carbon.
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{CO_2}\) is amphoteric, while \(\mathrm{SnO_2}\) is acidic; carbon is more metallic than tin.
ⓒ. Both oxides are neutral because their central atoms have the same oxidation state.
ⓓ. Both oxides are exclusively basic because they belong to the same group.
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{CO_2}\) is acidic, while \(\mathrm{SnO_2}\) is amphoteric; tin is more metallic than carbon.
Explanation: Carbon and tin are members of Group 14 but occupy widely separated positions within the group.
Carbon is a non-metal, whereas tin is metallic.
The broad increase in metallic character down the group affects the bonding and acid–base properties of their oxides.
Carbon dioxide is an acidic oxide and reacts with suitable bases to form carbonate or hydrogencarbonate species.
Tin(IV) oxide, \(\mathrm{SnO_2}\), exhibits amphoteric behaviour under appropriate conditions.
An amphoteric oxide can react with both suitable acids and strong bases.
It is therefore incorrect to classify \(\mathrm{SnO_2}\) as neutral simply because it can exhibit both acid-like and base-like behaviour.
\(\textbf{Check the oxidation states:}\)
Two oxygen atoms contribute a total oxidation-state sum of \(-4\) in each dioxide.
Consequently, both carbon in \(\mathrm{CO_2}\) and tin in \(\mathrm{SnO_2}\) have oxidation state +4.
This similarity concerns formal electron accounting and does not impose identical chemical properties.
The bonding character of the element and its position within the group must also be considered.
Thus, the change from acidic carbon dioxide to amphoteric tin dioxide is consistent with the increased metallic character of the heavier element.
The correct explanation distinguishes oxidation-state similarity from acid–base similarity.
27. The average X–H bond enthalpies of the Group 14 hydrides \(\mathrm{CH_4}\), \(\mathrm{SiH_4}\) and \(\mathrm{GeH_4}\) decrease in the order \(\mathrm{C-H\gt Si-H\gt Ge-H}\). Which interpretation correctly relates this trend to bond stability and the prediction of thermal decomposition rates?
ⓐ. The bonds weaken towards germane; decomposition activation barriers must increase in the same order.
ⓑ. The bonds strengthen towards germane; decomposition activation barriers require separate evaluation.
ⓒ. The bonds weaken towards germane; decomposition activation barriers require separate evaluation.
ⓓ. The bonds strengthen towards germane; decomposition activation barriers must decrease in the same order.
Correct Answer: The bonds weaken towards germane; decomposition activation barriers require separate evaluation.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret the supplied bond-enthalpy order:}\)
The three hydrides contain central Group 14 atoms bonded to four hydrogen atoms.
Their common general formula reflects the four valence electrons of the central atoms.
However, their X–H bonds do not possess identical strengths.
The supplied order indicates that C–H bonds are stronger than Si–H bonds, which are stronger than Ge–H bonds.
Bond dissociation enthalpy measures the energy required for the specified bond-breaking process in the gaseous state.
A higher bond dissociation enthalpy indicates a stronger bond under the stated comparison.
Therefore, methane has the strongest X–H bonds, whereas germane has the weakest among the three hydrides.
\(\textbf{Explain the down-group trend:}\)
Atomic size generally increases from carbon to silicon to germanium.
The valence orbitals become larger and more diffuse.
This generally reduces the effectiveness of orbital overlap between the central atom and hydrogen.
Consequently, the X–H bond strength decreases down the group.
The decrease contributes to the broad trend of decreasing thermal stability among these hydrides.
\(\textbf{Distinguish bond strength from reaction rate:}\)
Thermal decomposition may require the breaking of existing bonds and the formation of new bonds.
The overall energy change depends on the energetics of both reactants and products.
The rate of decomposition additionally depends on the activation-energy barrier and the available reaction pathway.
Therefore, the X–H bond-enthalpy order alone cannot establish the exact decomposition rates.
A weaker bond does not necessarily imply a smaller activation barrier for every possible decomposition mechanism.
Similarly, the order of bond enthalpies does not prove a corresponding numerical order of reaction rates under all experimental conditions.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the alternatives:}\)
Options B and D reverse the supplied bond-strength trend.
Option A correctly recognises weakening bonds but incorrectly assumes a compulsory activation-barrier trend.
Option C preserves the observed bond-strength order while recognising that kinetic barriers require independent evaluation.
Thus, bond strength generally decreases towards germane, but decomposition kinetics cannot be determined from bond enthalpy alone.
28. Three Group 14 elements P, Q and R have the following characteristics.
| Element | General character | Representative oxidation-state behaviour |
| P | Non-metal; strong multiple-bonding tendency | +4 is particularly important in its oxides |
| Q | Metalloid; predominantly covalent chemistry | +4 is an important oxidation state |
| R | Metal; pronounced inert-pair effect | +2 is generally more stable than +4 |
Which assignment is consistent with all the information, considering carbon, germanium and lead?
ⓐ. P = germanium, Q = carbon, R = lead
ⓑ. P = carbon, Q = germanium, R = lead
ⓒ. P = carbon, Q = lead, R = germanium
ⓓ. P = lead, Q = germanium, R = carbon
Correct Answer: P = carbon, Q = germanium, R = lead
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify P from bonding behaviour:}\)
Carbon is a non-metal and the first member of Group 14.
Its compact \(2p\) orbitals enable effective multiple bonding with suitable atoms, including oxygen.
Carbon commonly exhibits oxidation state +4 in compounds such as \(\mathrm{CO_2}\).
Therefore, the combination of non-metallic character and strong multiple-bonding tendency identifies P as carbon.
\(\textbf{Identify Q from intermediate character:}\)
Germanium lies between silicon and tin in Group 14.
It is commonly classified as a metalloid and exhibits substantial covalent bonding.
The +4 oxidation state is important in its chemistry.
Thus, Q corresponds to germanium.
\(\textbf{Identify R through oxidation-state stability:}\)
Lead is a metallic member near the bottom of Group 14.
Its outermost configuration follows the general pattern \(ns^2np^2\).
The inert-pair effect makes participation of the \(6s^2\) pair less favourable.
Consequently, the +2 oxidation state is generally more stable than the +4 state.
This identifies R as lead.
The three assignments also follow the broad change from non-metallic to metalloid and metallic character down Group 14.
The important distinction is that all three elements possess four valence electrons, but their bonding characteristics and preferred oxidation states differ.
Thus, P, Q and R correspond to carbon, germanium and lead, respectively.
29. Tin has the ground-state electronic configuration \([\mathrm{Kr}]\,4d^{10}5s^25p^2\). Consider the formal electron configurations of \(\mathrm{Sn^{2+}}\) and \(\mathrm{Sn^{4+}}\). Which statement correctly identifies the retained valence-electron pair and the direction of electron transfer when \(\mathrm{Sn^{2+}}\) is oxidized to \(\mathrm{Sn^{4+}}\)?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{Sn^{2+}}\) retains \(5p^2\), and oxidation removes the filled \(4d^{10}\) subshell.
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{Sn^{4+}}\) retains \(5s^2\), and oxidation requires addition of two electrons.
ⓒ. Both ions retain \(5s^2\), and oxidation changes only the number of inner \(d\) electrons.
ⓓ. \(\mathrm{Sn^{2+}}\) retains \(5s^2\), and oxidation removes these two electrons to form \(\mathrm{Sn^{4+}}\).
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{Sn^{2+}}\) retains \(5s^2\), and oxidation removes these two electrons to form \(\mathrm{Sn^{4+}}\).
Explanation: \(\textbf{Establish the neutral configuration:}\)
Tin belongs to Group 14 and possesses four valence electrons.
Its outermost configuration is \(5s^25p^2\).
When forming a positive ion, electrons are removed from the outer occupied orbitals.
The two \(5p\) electrons are removed in forming the formal \(\mathrm{Sn^{2+}}\) ion.
This gives:
\[
\mathrm{Sn^{2+}:[Kr]\,4d^{10}5s^2}
\]
The \(5s^2\) pair remains occupied in this state.
\(\textbf{Consider oxidation to the +4 state:}\)
Formation of \(\mathrm{Sn^{4+}}\) requires removal of two additional electrons.
These are the remaining \(5s\) electrons in the simplified ionic electron-counting description.
Thus:
\[
\mathrm{Sn^{4+}:[Kr]\,4d^{10}}
\]
The corresponding electron-transfer relation is:
\[
\mathrm{Sn^{2+}\longrightarrow Sn^{4+}+2e^-}
\]
The oxidation state increases by two units, and two electrons are released.
Therefore, \(\mathrm{Sn^{2+}}\) can function as a reducing agent when this conversion occurs.
The filled \(4d^{10}\) subshell is not the source of the two electrons involved in this oxidation-state change.
This analysis also demonstrates the meaning of the inert-pair effect: retaining the \(ns^2\) pair favours a lower oxidation state, but does not make oxidation to a higher state absolutely impossible.
Hence, the +2 ion retains the \(5s^2\) pair, which is removed in the formal conversion to the +4 ion.
30. Carbon and tin possess the same general Group 14 valence-shell configuration, but their elemental solids exhibit markedly different bonding characteristics. Which explanation is consistent with the broad change in chemical character down the group?
ⓐ. Carbon forms extended covalent solids; metallic tin instead has metallic bonding despite also having four valence electrons.
ⓑ. Carbon and tin must both form molecular solids because their outer shells contain four electrons.
ⓒ. Carbon exhibits metallic bonding exclusively, whereas tin is necessarily a covalent network solid.
ⓓ. Both elements must have identical crystal structures because their general electronic configurations are \(ns^2np^2\).
Correct Answer: Carbon forms extended covalent solids; metallic tin instead has metallic bonding despite also having four valence electrons.
Explanation: Carbon and tin are both Group 14 elements with four valence electrons.
However, carbon is non-metallic, whereas tin exhibits metallic character.
Carbon's small atomic size and strong directional covalent bonding permit extended structures such as diamond.
In diamond, each carbon atom is covalently bonded to four neighbouring carbon atoms in a three-dimensional network.
Such a structure is not an assembly of separate small molecules.
Tin, by contrast, exhibits metallic forms in which metallic bonding and a corresponding crystal structure are important.
The commonly encountered metallic form is white tin, which is stable above its transition temperature near \(13^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
Tin also possesses a non-metallic grey allotrope at lower temperatures, showing why the chemical form and conditions must be specified.
The broad comparison nevertheless illustrates the increasing importance of metallic behaviour down Group 14.
The presence of four valence electrons does not force those electrons to participate in identical types of bonding in every element.
Bulk physical properties depend on the actual structure and interatomic forces rather than the valence-electron count alone.
This is why carbon and metallic tin can show very different solid-state behaviour despite belonging to the same group.
31. Thallium and lead are consecutive elements with atomic numbers \(81\) and \(82\), respectively. Their ground-state configurations end in \(6s^26p^1\) and \(6s^26p^2\), with the same filled inner subshells. Consider the ions \(\mathrm{Tl^+}\) and \(\mathrm{Pb^{2+}}\). Which conclusion correctly combines their electronic configurations, the inert-pair effect and their expected relative ionic sizes?
ⓐ. The ions have different outer-shell electron counts, and \(\mathrm{Pb^{2+}}\) should be larger because lead has the higher atomic number.
ⓑ. Both ions retain \(6s^2\), and \(\mathrm{Pb^{2+}}\) should be smaller because it has the greater nuclear charge in an isoelectronic pair.
ⓒ. Both ions have the same electron configuration, but \(\mathrm{Tl^+}\) should be smaller because it has the lower positive charge.
ⓓ. Both ions retain \(6p\) electrons, and \(\mathrm{Pb^{2+}}\) should be larger because it has lost more electrons.
Correct Answer: Both ions retain \(6s^2\), and \(\mathrm{Pb^{2+}}\) should be smaller because it has the greater nuclear charge in an isoelectronic pair.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the ionic electron configurations:}\)
Thallium belongs to Group 13 and has the configuration \([\mathrm{Xe}]\,4f^{14}5d^{10}6s^26p^1\).
Formation of \(\mathrm{Tl^+}\) removes the single \(6p\) electron.
Thus:
\[
\mathrm{Tl^+:[Xe]\,4f^{14}5d^{10}6s^2}
\]
Lead belongs to Group 14 and has the configuration \([\mathrm{Xe}]\,4f^{14}5d^{10}6s^26p^2\).
Formation of \(\mathrm{Pb^{2+}}\) removes the two \(6p\) electrons.
Therefore:
\[
\mathrm{Pb^{2+}:[Xe]\,4f^{14}5d^{10}6s^2}
\]
Both ions contain \(80\) electrons and are isoelectronic.
\(\textbf{Apply the nuclear-charge comparison:}\)
Thallium has \(81\) protons, whereas lead has \(82\) protons.
For species with the same electron count and corresponding configurations, greater nuclear charge generally produces stronger attraction and a smaller ionic radius.
Therefore, \(\mathrm{Pb^{2+}}\) is expected to be smaller than \(\mathrm{Tl^+}\) in the comparable ionic-radius description.
\(\textbf{Connect the result with oxidation-state stability:}\)
Both ions retain the outermost \(6s^2\) electron pair.
Retention of this pair is consistent with the inert-pair effect in the heavier p-block elements.
It helps explain the importance of Tl(I) in Group 13 and Pb(II) in Group 14.
The ions need not have the same charge to be isoelectronic.
The conclusion therefore requires three distinct ideas: electron removal from the neutral configurations, identification of the retained \(6s^2\) pair, and ionic-size comparison using nuclear charge.
Hence, both ions have the same electronic configuration, but \(\mathrm{Pb^{2+}}\) is expected to be smaller.
32. An element X has the ground-state electronic configuration \([\mathrm{Ar}]\,3d^{10}4s^24p^3\). Under suitable conditions, it forms a covalent trihydride \(\mathrm{XH_3}\) and compounds containing X in positive oxidation states. Which conclusion correctly combines its electronic configuration, periodic position and valence behaviour?
ⓐ. X is germanium; it has four valence electrons and belongs to Group 14.
ⓑ. X is selenium; it has six valence electrons and belongs to Group 16.
ⓒ. X is arsenic; it has five valence electrons and belongs to Group 15.
ⓓ. X is phosphorus; it has five valence electrons and belongs to Period 3.
Correct Answer: X is arsenic; it has five valence electrons and belongs to Group 15.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the element from its configuration:}\)
The configuration contains the argon core, a completely filled \(3d\) subshell, and the outermost arrangement \(4s^24p^3\).
The total electron count identifies the element as arsenic, with atomic number \(33\).
The highest occupied principal shell is \(n=4\), so arsenic belongs to Period 4.
Its outermost shell contains two \(4s\) electrons and three \(4p\) electrons.
Therefore, it possesses five valence electrons.
\(\textbf{Connect orbital occupancy with group behaviour:}\)
The general valence-shell configuration \(ns^2np^3\) identifies Group 15.
According to Hund's rule, the three \(p\) electrons initially occupy the three degenerate \(p\) orbitals singly.
The atom consequently has three unpaired \(p\) electrons in its ground-state configuration.
Formation of a trihydride is consistent with three bonds involving the central Group 15 atom.
The remaining valence-electron pair is important in explaining the bonding and electron-pair-donor behaviour of many Group 15 compounds.
However, the presence of five valence electrons does not require oxidation state +5 in every compound.
Arsenic can exhibit different oxidation states depending on its bonding partners.
Hence, the correct identification must satisfy the atomic-number, group, period and valence-electron evidence simultaneously.
33. Nitrogen forms \(\mathrm{NH_3}\), \(\mathrm{NF_3}\) and \(\mathrm{N_2O_5}\). Given that fluorine is more electronegative than nitrogen, whereas nitrogen is more electronegative than hydrogen, which sequence gives the oxidation states of nitrogen in these compounds, respectively?
ⓐ. \(-3,+3,+5\)
ⓑ. \(+3,-3,+5\)
ⓒ. \(-3,+5,+3\)
ⓓ. \(+3,+3,+5\)
Correct Answer: \(-3,+3,+5\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Assign the oxidation state in ammonia:}\)
Nitrogen is more electronegative than hydrogen, so hydrogen is assigned oxidation state +1 in \(\mathrm{NH_3}\).
Let the oxidation state of nitrogen be \(x\).
For a neutral molecule, the algebraic sum of oxidation states is zero.
\[
x+3(+1)=0
\]
\[
x=-3
\]
Thus, nitrogen has oxidation state \(-3\) in ammonia.
\(\textbf{Examine nitrogen trifluoride:}\)
Fluorine is more electronegative than nitrogen and is assigned oxidation state \(-1\).
For \(\mathrm{NF_3}\):
\[
x+3(-1)=0
\]
\[
x=+3
\]
Nitrogen therefore exhibits oxidation state +3 in nitrogen trifluoride.
\(\textbf{Determine the highest state in the oxide:}\)
Oxygen is assigned oxidation state \(-2\) in \(\mathrm{N_2O_5}\).
\[
2x+5(-2)=0
\]
\[
2x=10
\]
\[
x=+5
\]
The three compounds demonstrate that nitrogen can exhibit negative and positive oxidation states.
The number of bonds around an atom does not independently determine its oxidation state.
The identities and electronegativities of the bonding partners must also be considered.
The required sequence is therefore \(-3,+3,+5\).
34. Phosphorus and bismuth are Group 15 elements. Phosphorus(V) is important in its compounds, whereas bismuth(III) is generally more stable than bismuth(V). A student concludes that bismuth must possess only three valence electrons. Which alternative interpretation correctly accounts for the observation?
ⓐ. Bismuth has three valence electrons because its outermost \(p\) subshell contains three electrons.
ⓑ. Bismuth has five valence electrons, but its +5 oxidation state is impossible in every compound.
ⓒ. Bismuth retains the \(6p^3\) electrons in its +3 state because the \(6s^2\) pair is removed first.
ⓓ. Bismuth has five valence electrons, but retention of its \(6s^2\) pair favours the +3 state.
Correct Answer: Bismuth has five valence electrons, but retention of its \(6s^2\) pair favours the +3 state.
Explanation: Phosphorus and bismuth both belong to Group 15 and follow the general valence-shell configuration \(ns^2np^3\).
They therefore possess five valence electrons despite their different chemical behaviour.
Bismuth has the outermost configuration \(6s^26p^3\).
The +3 oxidation state corresponds formally to participation of the three \(6p\) electrons while the \(6s^2\) pair remains occupied.
The +5 state involves participation of the \(6s^2\) pair in addition to the three \(6p\) electrons.
\(\textbf{Explain the preference for the lower state:}\)
In heavier p-block elements, the outermost \(ns^2\) electron pair increasingly resists participation in bonding.
This phenomenon is described as the inert-pair effect.
It contributes to the greater stability of Bi(III) relative to Bi(V).
The effect is considerably less dominant for phosphorus, so the +5 state remains important in phosphorus chemistry.
A preferred oxidation state cannot be used to determine the total number of valence electrons directly.
Furthermore, the inert-pair effect is a relative stability effect, not an absolute prohibition against the higher oxidation state.
Bismuth(V) compounds can exist under suitable chemical conditions.
Thus, the correct explanation preserves the five-electron valence configuration while accounting for the increasing preference for the lower positive oxidation state.
35. Bismuth(V) fluoride, \(\mathrm{BiF_5}\), can exist, whereas the corresponding pentachloride is not comparably stable under ordinary conditions. This observation must be reconciled with the greater stability of the +3 oxidation state of bismuth. Which explanation is most appropriate?
ⓐ. Fluorine changes the ground-state valence configuration of bismuth from \(6s^26p^3\) to \(6s^26p^5\).
ⓑ. The inert-pair effect disappears completely when bismuth forms a compound with fluorine.
ⓒ. Strong bonding to highly electronegative fluorine can favour Bi(V), although the +3 state is generally more stable.
ⓓ. Bismuth possesses five valence electrons in its fluorides but only three valence electrons in its chlorides.
Correct Answer: Strong bonding to highly electronegative fluorine can favour Bi(V), although the +3 state is generally more stable.
Explanation: Bismuth has five valence electrons and can formally exhibit oxidation states +3 and +5.
The inert-pair effect favours retention of the \(6s^2\) pair, making the +3 state generally more stable.
However, the relative stability of an oxidation state also depends on the bonding environment.
Fluorine is highly electronegative and forms strong bonds with suitable elements in high oxidation states.
Formation of strong Bi–F bonds can provide sufficient stabilization for a Bi(V) compound such as \(\mathrm{BiF_5}\).
Consequently, the existence of \(\mathrm{BiF_5}\) does not contradict the inert-pair effect.
\(\textbf{Distinguish general preference from compound stability:}\)
The inert-pair effect describes a tendency for the lower oxidation state to become relatively more favourable.
It does not establish that every compound containing the higher oxidation state must be unstable.
Different bonding partners can alter the relative energies of compounds containing the same central element.
The stability of the resulting compound therefore depends on both the central atom and the atoms attached to it.
Fluorine does not change the number of valence electrons in the neutral bismuth atom.
Nor does compound formation abolish the underlying electronic tendency associated with the \(6s^2\) pair.
The observation illustrates why oxidation-state stability cannot be predicted from group position alone without considering the chemical environment.
36. Nitrogen exhibits oxidation state +5 in the nitrate ion, \(\mathrm{NO_3^-}\), but does not form an ordinary stable pentachloride analogous to \(\mathrm{PCl_5}\). Which statement correctly distinguishes formal oxidation state from covalent bonding capacity?
ⓐ. Nitrogen cannot have oxidation state +5 because its valence shell contains only five electrons.
ⓑ. Nitrogen can attain oxidation state +5 without forming five ordinary covalent bonds or expanding its octet.
ⓒ. Nitrogen forms \(\mathrm{NCl_5}\) readily because an oxidation state of +5 always requires five bonds.
ⓓ. Phosphorus forms \(\mathrm{PCl_5}\) because it has a smaller valence shell than nitrogen.
Correct Answer: Nitrogen can attain oxidation state +5 without forming five ordinary covalent bonds or expanding its octet.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret nitrogen's oxidation state:}\)
Nitrogen belongs to Group 15 and possesses five valence electrons.
In nitrate, oxygen is assigned oxidation state \(-2\).
For the nitrate ion:
\[
x+3(-2)=-1
\]
\[
x=+5
\]
Thus, nitrogen has the formal oxidation state +5 in \(\mathrm{NO_3^-}\).
However, the oxidation-state number does not specify the number of atoms directly bonded to nitrogen.
In nitrate, nitrogen is bonded to three oxygen atoms, with electron delocalization represented by resonance structures.
The nitrogen atom does not require five ordinary two-electron covalent bonds to exhibit oxidation state +5.
\(\textbf{Apply the second-period restriction:}\)
Nitrogen has a compact valence shell containing \(2s\) and \(2p\) orbitals.
It cannot accommodate ten valence-shell electrons around itself in an ordinary expanded-octet Lewis structure.
Therefore, a conventional pentacoordinate pentachloride of nitrogen is not analogous to phosphorus pentachloride.
Phosphorus belongs to Period 3 and can form hypervalent compounds such as \(\mathrm{PCl_5}\).
This difference must not be explained simply by assuming that phosphorus has more valence electrons than nitrogen.
Both elements possess five valence electrons.
The decisive distinction is between formal oxidation-state assignment and the bonding arrangements accessible to the atoms.
Thus, nitrogen's +5 oxidation state is compatible with its inability to form an ordinary stable \(\mathrm{NCl_5}\) molecule.
37. Nitrogen exists predominantly as \(\mathrm{N_2}\) under ordinary conditions, whereas phosphorus commonly exists as molecular \(\mathrm{P_4}\) in its white allotrope. Nitrogen molecules are comparatively unreactive at room temperature, whereas white phosphorus is much more reactive. Which explanation best reconciles these observations?
ⓐ. The strong \(\mathrm{N\equiv N}\) bond and the strained P–P bonding arrangement in \(\mathrm{P_4}\) contribute to their different reactivities.
ⓑ. Nitrogen is comparatively unreactive because the \(\mathrm{N_2}\) molecule contains no covalent bonds.
ⓒ. White phosphorus is more reactive because every P–P bond is a stronger multiple bond than the \(\mathrm{N\equiv N}\) bond.
ⓓ. Nitrogen is comparatively unreactive because its atoms have complete outer shells before forming \(\mathrm{N_2}\).
Correct Answer: The strong \(\mathrm{N\equiv N}\) bond and the strained P–P bonding arrangement in \(\mathrm{P_4}\) contribute to their different reactivities.
Explanation: Nitrogen and phosphorus belong to Group 15 and each has five valence electrons.
However, identical valence-electron counts do not require identical structures for their elemental forms.
Nitrogen atoms can form an exceptionally strong triple bond through effective orbital overlap.
The \(\mathrm{N_2}\) molecule therefore contains a strong \(\mathrm{N\equiv N}\) bond.
Breaking this bond requires substantial energy, contributing to the large activation barriers of many reactions involving molecular nitrogen.
Consequently, nitrogen is relatively unreactive under ordinary conditions.
\(\textbf{Examine the phosphorus structure:}\)
White phosphorus contains discrete tetrahedral \(\mathrm{P_4}\) molecules.
Each phosphorus atom is bonded to three other phosphorus atoms through single bonds.
The tetrahedral arrangement imposes P–P–P bond angles of approximately \(60^\circ\).
Such an arrangement is strained compared with the bonding geometry preferred for many phosphorus compounds.
The P–P single bonds are also much weaker than the nitrogen–nitrogen triple bond.
These factors contribute to the relatively high reactivity of white phosphorus.
The difference is therefore not caused by a different number of valence electrons.
It arises from the different bonding patterns, bond strengths and molecular structures of the two elemental forms.
38. The approximate bond dissociation enthalpies of N–N, P–P and \(\mathrm{N\equiv N}\) bonds are supplied below.
| Bond | Bond dissociation enthalpy |
| \(\mathrm{N-N}\) | \(163\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) |
| \(\mathrm{P-P}\) | \(201\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) |
| \(\mathrm{N\equiv N}\) | \(945\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) |
A student argues that nitrogen must show a greater tendency than phosphorus to form long chains through ordinary single bonds because the \(\mathrm{N_2}\) molecule is exceptionally stable. Which assessment correctly uses the bond-energy evidence?
ⓐ. The argument is valid because triple-bond strength directly determines the strength of all N–N single bonds.
ⓑ. The argument is valid because nitrogen has fewer non-bonding electrons than phosphorus.
ⓒ. The argument is invalid because phosphorus has no tendency to bond with other phosphorus atoms.
ⓓ. Strong N≡N bonds do not imply strong N–N single bonds; the latter are weaker than P–P single bonds.
Correct Answer: Strong N≡N bonds do not imply strong N–N single bonds; the latter are weaker than P–P single bonds.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the bond relevant to catenation:}\)
Catenation involves formation of bonds between atoms of the same element, often producing chains or rings.
For ordinary single-bonded chains, the strength of the X–X single bond is especially relevant.
The supplied N–N single-bond enthalpy is \(163\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\).
The corresponding P–P single-bond enthalpy is \(201\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\).
Therefore, the supplied data indicate that a P–P single bond is stronger than an N–N single bond.
\(\textbf{Resolve the apparent contradiction:}\)
The \(\mathrm{N\equiv N}\) triple bond is exceptionally strong because of effective multiple bonding between compact nitrogen orbitals.
That strong triple bond cannot be treated as evidence that the ordinary N–N single bond is equally strong.
Nitrogen atoms also contain lone pairs, and their relatively small size can produce significant repulsion between non-bonding electron pairs on adjacent nitrogen atoms.
Such repulsion contributes to the relative weakness of N–N single bonds.
Phosphorus has larger atoms, and ordinary P–P single bonds are less affected by the same degree of adjacent lone-pair repulsion.
Consequently, phosphorus can show a greater tendency towards formation of certain single-bonded chains and frameworks than nitrogen.
The comparison must therefore distinguish multiple-bond strength from single-bond catenation.
The exceptional stability of molecular nitrogen does not establish exceptional stability for every nitrogen–nitrogen bonding arrangement.
39. The normal boiling points of four Group 15 hydrides are supplied in the table.
| Hydride | Normal boiling point |
| \(\mathrm{NH_3}\) | \(-33^\circ\mathrm{C}\) |
| \(\mathrm{PH_3}\) | \(-88^\circ\mathrm{C}\) |
| \(\mathrm{AsH_3}\) | \(-63^\circ\mathrm{C}\) |
| \(\mathrm{SbH_3}\) | \(-17^\circ\mathrm{C}\) |
Which conclusion correctly reconciles the boiling-point sequence with molecular interactions?
ⓐ. Ammonia has the highest boiling point of the four because hydrogen bonding always dominates dispersion forces.
ⓑ. Phosphine has the lowest boiling point because its molecules are smaller than ammonia molecules.
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{NH_3}\) boils above \(\mathrm{AsH_3}\) through hydrogen bonding, but heavier \(\mathrm{SbH_3}\) benefits from dispersion.
ⓓ. The boiling points must increase regularly from ammonia to stibine because all four hydrides have the same general formula.
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{NH_3}\) boils above \(\mathrm{AsH_3}\) through hydrogen bonding, but heavier \(\mathrm{SbH_3}\) benefits from dispersion.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret the supplied temperatures:}\)
The boiling point of ammonia is \(-33^\circ\mathrm{C}\), whereas that of arsine is \(-63^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
Since \(-33^\circ\mathrm{C}\) is higher than \(-63^\circ\mathrm{C}\), ammonia has the higher boiling point.
This is notable because ammonia has a much lower molar mass than arsine.
A prediction based only on increasing molar mass would therefore fail for this comparison.
\(\textbf{Identify the exceptional interaction:}\)
Nitrogen is small and highly electronegative.
Ammonia molecules can form appreciable intermolecular hydrogen bonds.
These interactions increase the energy required to separate ammonia molecules during boiling.
Phosphine and arsine do not exhibit comparable strong hydrogen bonding between their molecules.
Their boiling points are consequently influenced predominantly by weaker intermolecular interactions, including dispersion forces.
\(\textbf{Explain the heavier-member comparison:}\)
Stibine has a larger, more polarizable electron cloud than the lighter Group 15 hydrides.
Its stronger dispersion interactions contribute to its boiling point of \(-17^\circ\mathrm{C}\), which is higher than ammonia's.
Therefore, hydrogen bonding does not guarantee that ammonia must boil above every heavier hydride.
The actual supplied order is:
\[
\mathrm{PH_3\lt AsH_3\lt NH_3\lt SbH_3}
\]
The correct interpretation requires considering both hydrogen bonding and the increasing strength of dispersion forces down the group.
This illustrates why molecular formula or molar mass alone cannot establish the complete boiling-point trend.
40. Ammonia is a substantially stronger Lewis base than phosphine under ordinary comparable conditions. Both molecules contain a central Group 15 atom bonded to three hydrogen atoms and possess a lone pair. Which explanation best accounts for their different basic strengths?
ⓐ. Phosphine must be the stronger base because it contains the same number of hydrogen atoms as ammonia.
ⓑ. Phosphine is the stronger base because phosphorus has a larger atomic radius and therefore a more exposed lone pair.
ⓒ. Ammonia has no lone pair in its ground-state Lewis structure, but acquires one during protonation.
ⓓ. Ammonia can donate its nitrogen lone pair more effectively, whereas the phosphorus lone pair in phosphine is a much poorer donor.
Correct Answer: Ammonia can donate its nitrogen lone pair more effectively, whereas the phosphorus lone pair in phosphine is a much poorer donor.
Explanation: Nitrogen and phosphorus belong to Group 15 and have the general valence configuration \(ns^2np^3\).
In their simple trihydrides, each central atom forms three bonds with hydrogen and retains a non-bonding electron pair.
Therefore, both ammonia and phosphine have the basic structural requirement for Lewis-base behaviour.
However, possession of a lone pair does not guarantee equal electron-pair-donor strength.
Ammonia is an effective Lewis base because its nitrogen lone pair is relatively accessible for donation to a suitable electron-pair acceptor.
Phosphine is a considerably weaker base under ordinary comparable conditions.
Its bonding involves valence orbitals with different sizes, energies and mixing characteristics from those of nitrogen in ammonia.
The phosphorus lone pair consequently does not show the same tendency towards donation and protonation.
\(\textbf{Separate basicity from intermolecular attraction:}\)
Ammonia also exhibits intermolecular hydrogen bonding, but hydrogen bonding is not by itself a complete explanation of its greater Lewis basicity.
Basicity concerns the tendency to donate an electron pair or accept a proton under specified conditions.
Boiling point, by contrast, depends on the intermolecular forces that must be overcome during vaporization.
Two hydrides can therefore have similar general formulas while differing in both basicity and physical properties.
The important conclusion is that valence-electron count establishes the presence of the lone pair, but its chemical availability determines how effectively it behaves as a Lewis base.
41. The H–N–H bond angle in ammonia is approximately \(107^\circ\), whereas the H–P–H bond angle in phosphine is approximately \(93.5^\circ\). Both molecules are trigonal pyramidal and contain one lone pair on the central atom. Which interpretation best explains the substantial difference?
ⓐ. Phosphine is planar because its bond angle is closer to \(90^\circ\).
ⓑ. Ammonia contains four bonding pairs, whereas phosphine contains three bonding pairs.
ⓒ. The phosphorus atom has no lone pair, so phosphine must have a bond angle of exactly \(90^\circ\).
ⓓ. Nitrogen uses more hybridization; P–H bonding has more nearly pure \(p\)-orbital character.
Correct Answer: Nitrogen uses more hybridization; P–H bonding has more nearly pure \(p\)-orbital character.
Explanation: Ammonia and phosphine are both Group 15 hydrides with the general formula \(\mathrm{EH_3}\).
Each central atom possesses five valence electrons.
Three electrons participate in the formation of three bonds, while the remaining two form a lone pair.
Both molecules therefore have trigonal-pyramidal molecular structures.
However, the presence of the same number of bonding and non-bonding electron pairs does not require identical bond angles.
\(\textbf{Explain ammonia's geometry:}\)
In ammonia, the nitrogen valence orbitals show appreciable hybridization.
The electron-pair arrangement is approximately tetrahedral.
Lone-pair–bond-pair repulsion compresses the H–N–H bond angle below the ideal tetrahedral value of approximately \(109.5^\circ\).
The observed bond angle is therefore close to \(107^\circ\).
\(\textbf{Explain phosphine's smaller angle:}\)
In phosphine, the contribution of hybridization is much smaller.
The P–H bonds possess a greater degree of nearly pure \(p\)-orbital character.
Since the three mutually perpendicular \(p\) orbitals have an angular relationship close to \(90^\circ\), the H–P–H angle approaches this value.
The actual angle of approximately \(93.5^\circ\) is consistent with this description.
Phosphine remains pyramidal rather than planar.
Thus, the difference arises from the changing orbital character of bonding in the two hydrides, not from a difference in the number of valence electrons or lone pairs.
42. Three oxides belong to elements of Group 15. Under suitable chemical conditions, their acid–base responses are described below.
| Oxide | Reaction with suitable acid | Reaction with suitable strong base |
| P | No characteristic acid–base reaction | Reacts |
| Q | Reacts | Reacts |
| R | Reacts | No characteristic acid–base reaction |
The oxides are \(\mathrm{N_2O_3}\), \(\mathrm{Sb_2O_3}\) and \(\mathrm{Bi_2O_3}\), but their identities are concealed. Which assignment correctly combines their acid–base behaviour with the changing metallic character down Group 15?
ⓐ. P = \(\mathrm{Bi_2O_3}\), Q = \(\mathrm{Sb_2O_3}\), R = \(\mathrm{N_2O_3}\)
ⓑ. P = \(\mathrm{N_2O_3}\), Q = \(\mathrm{Sb_2O_3}\), R = \(\mathrm{Bi_2O_3}\)
ⓒ. P = \(\mathrm{N_2O_3}\), Q = \(\mathrm{Bi_2O_3}\), R = \(\mathrm{Sb_2O_3}\)
ⓓ. P = \(\mathrm{Sb_2O_3}\), Q = \(\mathrm{N_2O_3}\), R = \(\mathrm{Bi_2O_3}\)
Correct Answer: P = \(\mathrm{N_2O_3}\), Q = \(\mathrm{Sb_2O_3}\), R = \(\mathrm{Bi_2O_3}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Classify the three observed responses:}\)
An oxide showing characteristic reaction with a base but not with a suitable acid is consistent with acidic behaviour.
An oxide reacting with both suitable acids and strong bases is amphoteric.
An oxide reacting with acids but not showing characteristic acidic-oxide behaviour towards bases is consistent with basic character.
The supplied observations therefore classify P as acidic, Q as amphoteric and R as basic.
\(\textbf{Relate the responses to group position:}\)
Nitrogen is a non-metal and the first member of Group 15.
Its oxide \(\mathrm{N_2O_3}\) is acidic and corresponds to nitrogen in oxidation state +3.
Thus, P is \(\mathrm{N_2O_3}\).
Antimony lies lower in Group 15 and has appreciable metalloid character.
Its oxide \(\mathrm{Sb_2O_3}\) exhibits amphoteric behaviour, identifying Q.
Bismuth is metallic and lies below antimony in the group.
Its oxide \(\mathrm{Bi_2O_3}\) is predominantly basic, identifying R.
The assigned oxidation state of the Group 15 element is +3 in all three oxides.
Consequently, the difference in acid–base behaviour cannot be attributed to different formal oxidation states.
Instead, it reflects the broad increase in metallic character and associated bonding changes down the group.
The correct assignment is therefore P = \(\mathrm{N_2O_3}\), Q = \(\mathrm{Sb_2O_3}\) and R = \(\mathrm{Bi_2O_3}\).
43. The first ionization enthalpies of selected Group 15 elements are approximately:
| Element | First ionization enthalpy \((\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}})\) |
| N | 1402 |
| P | 1012 |
| As | 947 |
| Sb | 834 |
| Bi | 703 |
A student argues that because bismuth has the lowest first ionization enthalpy in this list, the +5 oxidation state must be more stable for bismuth than for phosphorus. Which assessment is correct?
ⓐ. The conclusion is valid because first ionization enthalpy directly measures the stability of the +5 oxidation state.
ⓑ. The conclusion is valid because increasing metallic character removes the inert-pair effect completely.
ⓒ. The conclusion is invalid because the values show that bismuth has a smaller atomic number than phosphorus.
ⓓ. Easier first-electron removal does not ensure all five valence electrons participate in bonding.
Correct Answer: Easier first-electron removal does not ensure all five valence electrons participate in bonding.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret the supplied ionization data:}\)
First ionization enthalpy is the energy required to remove one electron from an isolated gaseous atom in its ground state.
The values show a broad decrease from nitrogen to bismuth.
This trend is consistent with increasing atomic size and changes in shielding down Group 15.
The outermost electrons generally experience less effective attraction as the principal shell number increases.
Consequently, removal of the first electron becomes energetically easier down the group.
However, first ionization enthalpy concerns removal of only one electron.
It does not measure the total energy required to remove all five valence electrons or their energetic participation in chemical bonding.
\(\textbf{Apply the oxidation-state stability principle:}\)
Group 15 atoms possess the outermost configuration \(ns^2np^3\).
The +3 oxidation state can retain the \(ns^2\) electron pair.
The +5 state involves participation of this pair along with the three \(np\) electrons.
In heavier Group 15 members, the inert-pair effect increasingly favours retention of the \(ns^2\) pair.
Therefore, bismuth generally favours the +3 state relative to +5.
Phosphorus, by contrast, commonly forms stable compounds containing phosphorus in oxidation state +5.
The student incorrectly uses the energy of the first ionization process as though it determined the stability of every oxidation state.
Actual oxidation-state stability depends on the full energetic consequences of electron participation and compound formation.
Thus, decreasing first ionization enthalpy and increasing relative stability of the lower positive oxidation state can occur together without contradiction.
44. Match the Group 15 substances in List I with the most appropriate chemical characteristic in List II.
| List I | List II |
| (P) \(\mathrm{N_2}\) | (1) Amphoteric oxide of a metalloid |
| (Q) \(\mathrm{PH_3}\) | (2) Strong intramolecular triple bonding |
| (R) \(\mathrm{Sb_2O_3}\) | (3) Weak Lewis-base behaviour compared with ammonia |
| (S) \(\mathrm{BiF_5}\) | (4) Higher oxidation state stabilized by fluorine bonding |
Choose the correct matching.
ⓐ. P–2, Q–3, R–1, S–4
ⓑ. P–2, Q–1, R–3, S–4
ⓒ. P–3, Q–2, R–1, S–4
ⓓ. P–2, Q–3, R–4, S–1
Correct Answer: P–2, Q–3, R–1, S–4
Explanation: \(\textbf{Match the elemental molecule:}\)
Molecular nitrogen contains an exceptionally strong \(\mathrm{N\equiv N}\) triple bond.
Effective overlap between compact nitrogen orbitals produces strong multiple bonding.
Thus, P is matched with characteristic 2.
\(\textbf{Identify the hydride property:}\)
Phosphine contains a lone pair on phosphorus and can behave as a Lewis base.
However, it is a considerably weaker Lewis base than ammonia under ordinary comparable conditions.
The difference reflects the distinct electronic character and donor availability of the lone pairs on phosphorus and nitrogen.
Therefore, Q matches characteristic 3.
\(\textbf{Classify the oxide:}\)
Antimony lies in the metalloid region of Group 15.
Its oxide, \(\mathrm{Sb_2O_3}\), can exhibit both acidic and basic behaviour under suitable reaction conditions.
This is characteristic of an amphoteric oxide.
Hence, R matches characteristic 1.
\(\textbf{Interpret the bismuth compound:}\)
Bismuth is a heavier Group 15 element for which the +3 oxidation state is generally more stable.
Nevertheless, strong bonding with highly electronegative fluorine can stabilize a compound containing Bi(V).
In \(\mathrm{BiF_5}\), fluorine has oxidation state \(-1\), giving bismuth oxidation state +5.
Therefore, S matches characteristic 4.
The four associations represent different consequences of Group 15 electronic structure: multiple bonding, lone-pair donation, oxide acid–base behaviour and oxidation-state stabilization.
The correct matching is P–2, Q–3, R–1 and S–4.
45. Consider the following statements about Group 15 hydrides and elemental bonding.
Statement I: The boiling point of ammonia is higher than that of phosphine partly because ammonia exhibits appreciable intermolecular hydrogen bonding.
Statement II: The H–P–H bond angle in phosphine is closer to \(90^\circ\) than the H–N–H bond angle in ammonia.
Statement III: Nitrogen's exceptionally strong \(\mathrm{N\equiv N}\) bond means that ordinary N–N single-bonded chains must be more stable than corresponding P–P single-bonded chains.
Statement IV: Phosphine is a weaker Lewis base than ammonia, although both molecules contain a lone pair on their central atom.
Which combination of statements is correct?
ⓐ. Statements I, II and III only
ⓑ. Statements I, III and IV only
ⓒ. Statements I, II and IV only
ⓓ. Statements II, III and IV only
Correct Answer: Statements I, II and IV only
Explanation: Statement I is correct because ammonia molecules can form intermolecular hydrogen bonds.
Nitrogen's small size and high electronegativity make these interactions appreciable.
Phosphine does not exhibit comparable strong intermolecular hydrogen bonding.
Therefore, ammonia has a substantially higher boiling point than phosphine despite its lower molar mass.
Statement II is also correct.
The H–N–H bond angle in ammonia is approximately \(107^\circ\), whereas the H–P–H angle in phosphine is approximately \(93.5^\circ\).
Bonding in phosphine involves relatively little hybridization, so its bond angle approaches the \(90^\circ\) relationship associated with nearly pure \(p\)-orbital bonding.
Statement III is incorrect because multiple-bond strength cannot be used directly to predict single-bond strength.
Nitrogen forms an exceptionally strong triple bond in \(\mathrm{N_2}\), but the ordinary N–N single bond is relatively weak.
Repulsion between lone pairs on adjacent small nitrogen atoms contributes to this weakness.
P–P single bonds can consequently support catenation more effectively in suitable structures.
Statement IV is correct because both ammonia and phosphine contain lone pairs, but those lone pairs differ in their chemical availability.
Ammonia is the substantially stronger Lewis base under ordinary comparable conditions.
The four statements illustrate three different aspects of Group 15 chemistry: intermolecular attraction, molecular geometry and electron-pair/bonding behaviour.
The correct combination is therefore Statements I, II and IV.
46. Lead and bismuth are consecutive heavy p-block elements. Lead has the valence configuration \(6s^26p^2\), while bismuth has \(6s^26p^3\). Their lower positive oxidation states, +2 and +3 respectively, are generally favoured relative to their higher states. Which conclusion explains both the different numerical oxidation states and their common underlying cause?
ⓐ. Both atoms lose the \(6s^2\) electrons first, leaving different numbers of \(6p\) electrons.
ⓑ. Both atoms can retain the \(6s^2\) pair, while participation of two or three \(6p\) electrons gives their respective lower positive oxidation states.
ⓒ. Lead retains the \(6p^2\) electrons, whereas bismuth retains the \(6p^3\) electrons in their lower positive states.
ⓓ. Lead and bismuth have identical valence-electron counts, so their different oxidation states arise only from their atomic masses.
Correct Answer: Both atoms can retain the \(6s^2\) pair, while participation of two or three \(6p\) electrons gives their respective lower positive oxidation states.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Compare the valence configurations:}\)
Lead belongs to Group 14 and possesses the outermost configuration \(6s^26p^2\).
It therefore has four valence electrons.
Bismuth belongs to Group 15 and possesses the configuration \(6s^26p^3\).
It consequently has five valence electrons.
The two elements have the same occupied outermost \(s\) subshell but differ in the number of \(p\) electrons.
\(\textbf{Interpret the lower oxidation states:}\)
For lead, formal participation of the two \(6p\) electrons corresponds to oxidation state +2 while the \(6s^2\) pair remains occupied.
For bismuth, participation of the three \(6p\) electrons corresponds to oxidation state +3 while retaining the same type of \(6s^2\) pair.
Thus, the different numerical oxidation states follow from the different \(p\)-electron counts.
\(\textbf{Identify the shared stabilizing effect:}\)
Both elements are sufficiently heavy for the inert-pair effect to be important.
This effect makes participation of the \(6s^2\) pair relatively unfavourable.
Consequently, Pb(II) is generally more stable than Pb(IV), while Bi(III) is generally more stable than Bi(V).
The lower positive states therefore arise from the same electronic tendency but involve different numbers of \(p\) electrons.
This does not mean that higher oxidation states are impossible for either element.
It means that their relative stability decreases when participation of the outermost \(s\)-electron pair becomes energetically less favourable.
The correct conclusion must therefore combine group-specific \(p\)-electron occupancy with the common inert-pair effect.
Hence, retention of \(6s^2\) accounts for both the preferred +2 state of lead and the preferred +3 state of bismuth.
47. An element X has the ground-state electronic configuration \([\mathrm{Ar}]\,3d^{10}4s^24p^4\). It forms a simple monatomic anion by acquiring sufficient electrons to complete its outermost shell. Which conclusion correctly identifies X and the electronic configuration of its anion?
ⓐ. X is bromine, and \(\mathrm{X^-}\) is isoelectronic with krypton.
ⓑ. X is selenium, and \(\mathrm{X^-}\) is isoelectronic with krypton.
ⓒ. X is arsenic, and \(\mathrm{X^{2-}}\) is isoelectronic with krypton.
ⓓ. X is selenium, and \(\mathrm{X^{2-}}\) is isoelectronic with krypton.
Correct Answer: X is selenium, and \(\mathrm{X^{2-}}\) is isoelectronic with krypton.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the neutral atom:}\)
The supplied electronic configuration contains an argon core, ten \(3d\) electrons, two \(4s\) electrons and four \(4p\) electrons.
The total number of electrons is:
\[
Z=18+10+2+4=34
\]
An atom with atomic number \(34\) is selenium.
Its highest occupied principal shell is \(n=4\), placing it in Period 4.
Its outermost configuration is \(4s^24p^4\), which contains six valence electrons and identifies Group 16.
\(\textbf{Determine the anion configuration:}\)
The \(4p\) subshell requires two additional electrons to become completely filled.
Acquisition of two electrons produces the formal selenide ion, \(\mathrm{Se^{2-}}\).
The total electron count becomes:
\[
N_e=34+2=36
\]
Krypton has atomic number \(36\) and the configuration \([\mathrm{Ar}]\,3d^{10}4s^24p^6\).
Thus, \(\mathrm{Se^{2-}}\) and krypton are isoelectronic.
The negative charge indicates acquisition of electrons rather than their removal.
However, the ability to assign a closed-shell configuration to \(\mathrm{Se^{2-}}\) does not mean selenium must form free monatomic ions in every compound.
Selenium can also participate in covalent bonding and exhibit other oxidation states.
The correct conclusion therefore combines group identification, valence-shell completion and electron counting.
48. Consider the compounds \(\mathrm{Na_2O}\), \(\mathrm{Na_2O_2}\) and \(\mathrm{OF_2}\). Sodium has oxidation state +1 and fluorine has oxidation state \(-1\) in these compounds. Which sequence gives the oxidation states of oxygen in the three compounds, respectively?
ⓐ. \(-2,-2,+2\)
ⓑ. \(-2,-1,-2\)
ⓒ. \(-2,-1,+2\)
ⓓ. \(-1,-2,+2\)
Correct Answer: \(-2,-1,+2\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine oxygen's state in the normal oxide:}\)
In \(\mathrm{Na_2O}\), each sodium atom has oxidation state +1.
Since the compound is neutral, the sum of oxidation states must be zero.
Let the oxidation state of oxygen be \(x\).
\[
2(+1)+x=0
\]
\[
x=-2
\]
Thus, oxygen has its common oxidation state \(-2\) in sodium oxide.
\(\textbf{Examine the peroxide:}\)
Sodium peroxide has the formula \(\mathrm{Na_2O_2}\), containing a peroxide unit with an O–O bond.
For its two oxygen atoms:
\[
2(+1)+2x=0
\]
\[
2x=-2
\]
\[
x=-1
\]
The oxygen oxidation state is therefore \(-1\), not \(-2\).
\(\textbf{Apply the electronegativity condition:}\)
In \(\mathrm{OF_2}\), fluorine has oxidation state \(-1\) because it is more electronegative than oxygen.
For the neutral molecule:
\[
x+2(-1)=0
\]
\[
x=+2
\]
The positive oxidation state of oxygen in \(\mathrm{OF_2}\) is an important exception to its usual negative oxidation state.
The peroxide exception arises from the O–O bonding arrangement, whereas the positive state in \(\mathrm{OF_2}\) follows from fluorine's greater electronegativity.
Therefore, oxygen's oxidation state cannot be assigned solely from its Group 16 membership.
The required sequence is \(-2,-1,+2\).
49. Sodium sulphide, \(\mathrm{Na_2S}\), and hydrogen sulphide, \(\mathrm{H_2S}\), both contain sulphur in oxidation state \(-2\). However, their bonding characters are different. Which statement correctly reconciles these observations?
ⓐ. Sulphur has oxidation state \(-2\) only in ionic compounds, so \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) must be ionic.
ⓑ. Both compounds must contain free \(\mathrm{S^{2-}}\) ions because the oxidation state is identical.
ⓒ. Sulphur has oxidation state +2 in \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) because hydrogen forms covalent bonds.
ⓓ. The oxidation state can be \(-2\) in both compounds even though \(\mathrm{Na_2S}\) is ionic and \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) is covalent.
Correct Answer: The oxidation state can be \(-2\) in both compounds even though \(\mathrm{Na_2S}\) is ionic and \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) is covalent.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Establish the oxidation states:}\)
Sodium is a highly electropositive metal and has oxidation state +1 in sodium sulphide.
Two sodium ions contribute a total charge of +2, so the sulphide ion carries charge \(-2\).
Hence, \(\mathrm{Na_2S}\) can be represented as an ionic compound containing sodium and sulphide ions.
Hydrogen sulphide is a molecular compound containing covalent S–H bonds.
Hydrogen is assigned oxidation state +1 because sulphur is more electronegative than hydrogen.
For the neutral molecule:
\[
2(+1)+x=0
\]
\[
x=-2
\]
Thus, sulphur has the same formal oxidation state in both substances.
\(\textbf{Distinguish oxidation state from actual ionic charge:}\)
In sodium sulphide, sulphur occurs as a sulphide ion in an ionic lattice.
In hydrogen sulphide, sulphur is part of a covalently bonded molecule.
The oxidation state in a covalent compound is assigned by a formal electron-accounting convention.
It does not demonstrate complete physical transfer of two electrons to the sulphur atom.
Therefore, identical oxidation states do not require identical bonding arrangements.
This distinction is especially important for Group 16 elements because both electron acquisition and electron sharing contribute to their chemistry.
The correct conclusion is that formal oxidation-state equality is compatible with different actual bonding characters.
50. Consider the following Assertion and Reason.
Assertion (A): Oxygen can exhibit oxidation state +2 in \(\mathrm{OF_2}\), but it does not form an ordinary stable hexafluoride analogous to \(\mathrm{SF_6}\).
Reason (R): Fluorine is more electronegative than oxygen, while the second-period valence shell of oxygen cannot accommodate the twelve electrons of a conventional six-single-bond Lewis arrangement.
Choose the correct option.
ⓐ. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
ⓑ. Both A and R are true, but R does not correctly explain A.
ⓒ. A is true, but R is false.
ⓓ. A is false, but R is true.
Correct Answer: Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
Explanation: The assertion contains two observations that must be examined separately.
In \(\mathrm{OF_2}\), fluorine is assigned oxidation state \(-1\).
Charge balance therefore assigns oxygen oxidation state +2.
Thus, oxygen is not restricted to negative oxidation states in all its compounds.
However, oxygen does not form an ordinary stable hexafluoride corresponding to \(\mathrm{SF_6}\).
\(\textbf{Examine the electronic restriction:}\)
Oxygen belongs to Period 2 and has the outermost configuration \(2s^22p^4\).
Its valence-shell orbitals cannot accommodate an expanded-octet arrangement involving six ordinary two-electron single bonds around oxygen.
Such an arrangement would place twelve electrons around the central oxygen atom.
Sulphur belongs to Period 3 and can form hypervalent compounds such as \(\mathrm{SF_6}\).
The bonding in hypervalent compounds need not be interpreted as requiring extensive occupation of sulphur \(d\) orbitals.
The relevant distinction is that oxygen lacks the bonding capacity needed for an analogous ordinary six-coordinate fluoride.
The reason correctly identifies fluorine's role in producing a positive oxygen oxidation state and the valence-shell limitation preventing the proposed hexafluoride.
Both statements are therefore true, and the reason correctly explains the assertion.
51. The normal boiling points and approximate E–H bond dissociation enthalpies of four Group 16 hydrides are supplied below.
| Hydride | Boiling point \((^\circ\mathrm{C})\) | E–H bond enthalpy \((\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}})\) |
| \(\mathrm{H_2O}\) | 100 | 463 |
| \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) | -60 | 347 |
| \(\mathrm{H_2Se}\) | -41 | 276 |
| \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) | -2 | 238 |
Which conclusion correctly explains the simultaneous trends?
ⓐ. Boiling points increase strictly with E–H bond enthalpy because vaporization breaks covalent E–H bonds.
ⓑ. Hydrogen bonding elevates water's boiling point; increasing dispersion raises \(\mathrm{H_2S}\)-to-\(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) values.
ⓒ. Hydrogen telluride has the weakest E–H bond and therefore must possess the lowest boiling point.
ⓓ. Hydrogen sulphide has the lowest boiling point because it contains fewer hydrogen atoms than the other hydrides.
Correct Answer: Hydrogen bonding elevates water's boiling point; increasing dispersion raises \(\mathrm{H_2S}\)-to-\(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) values.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Separate intramolecular and intermolecular properties:}\)
E–H bond dissociation enthalpy measures the energy associated with breaking a specified covalent bond in the gas phase.
Boiling, in contrast, involves separating molecules from one another without ordinarily breaking their internal covalent bonds.
Therefore, a high E–H bond enthalpy does not by itself establish a high boiling point.
The supplied bond enthalpies decrease consistently from O–H to Te–H.
However, the boiling points do not follow the same numerical ordering.
\(\textbf{Explain the water exception:}\)
Water molecules exhibit strong intermolecular hydrogen bonding because oxygen is small and highly electronegative.
A substantial amount of energy is required to disrupt enough of this intermolecular network for vaporization.
This produces water's unusually high boiling point.
\(\textbf{Explain the heavier-hydride trend:}\)
Hydrogen sulphide, hydrogen selenide and hydrogen telluride do not exhibit comparable strong hydrogen bonding.
Down this sequence, molecular size and polarizability increase.
Consequently, London dispersion interactions become stronger.
Their boiling points therefore rise from approximately \(-60^\circ\mathrm{C}\) to \(-2^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
Hydrogen telluride has the weakest E–H bond of the four but a higher boiling point than hydrogen sulphide and hydrogen selenide.
This confirms that the two supplied properties describe different aspects of molecular behaviour.
The correct conclusion requires distinguishing covalent bond strength from intermolecular attraction and accounting for water's exceptional hydrogen bonding.
52. Consider the general Group 16 hydride series \(\mathrm{H_2O}\), \(\mathrm{H_2S}\), \(\mathrm{H_2Se}\) and \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\). Which pair of trends is consistent with their ordinary comparative chemical behaviour?
ⓐ. Acidic strength decreases down the group; E–H bond strength also decreases.
ⓑ. Acidic strength decreases down the group; E–H bond strength increases.
ⓒ. Acidic strength increases down the group; E–H bond strength also increases.
ⓓ. Acidic strength increases down the group; E–H bond strength decreases.
Correct Answer: Acidic strength increases down the group; E–H bond strength decreases.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the bond-strength trend:}\)
The central Group 16 atom becomes larger on moving from oxygen to tellurium.
The E–H bond length generally increases because the valence orbitals of the central atom become larger and more diffuse.
Orbital overlap with hydrogen becomes less effective.
Consequently, the E–H bond generally becomes weaker down the group.
The thermal stability of the hydrides broadly decreases in the same direction.
\(\textbf{Connect bond strength with acidity:}\)
Acidic behaviour involves the ability of the hydride to release a proton under suitable conditions.
Down Group 16, weakening E–H bonds contributes to easier proton release.
The overall aqueous acid-strength trend is:
\[
\mathrm{H_2O\lt H_2S\lt H_2Se\lt H_2Te}
\]
Here, the ordering represents increasing tendency towards acidic dissociation under comparable conditions.
Although oxygen is more electronegative than sulphur, selenium and tellurium, water is much less acidic than the heavier hydrides.
This demonstrates that electronegativity alone does not determine the acidity of all hydrides down a group.
Bond strength and the energetic stability of the species formed after proton release must also be considered.
The hydrides therefore become generally more acidic while their E–H bonds become weaker.
The opposite directions of these two properties are chemically related rather than contradictory.
The correct option must preserve both trends simultaneously.
53. Two Group 16 hydrides, \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) and \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\), are compared under otherwise similar conditions. Hydrogen telluride has a weaker E–H bond and is generally less thermally stable than hydrogen sulphide. Which additional prediction is consistent with these observations?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) generally shows stronger acidic and reducing character than \(\mathrm{H_2S}\).
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) generally shows weaker acidic and reducing character than \(\mathrm{H_2S}\).
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) is more acidic but cannot act as a reducing agent because tellurium has oxidation state \(-2\).
ⓓ. \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) is less acidic but more thermally stable because tellurium is less electronegative.
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) generally shows stronger acidic and reducing character than \(\mathrm{H_2S}\).
Explanation: Both hydrides contain a Group 16 element bonded to two hydrogen atoms.
Hydrogen has oxidation state +1, so sulphur and tellurium are assigned oxidation state \(-2\) in their respective hydrides.
\(\textbf{Assess the acidity trend:}\)
Tellurium has a larger atomic radius than sulphur.
The H–Te bond is generally longer and weaker than the H–S bond.
This contributes to the greater acidic strength of hydrogen telluride.
Therefore, \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) is more acidic than \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) under ordinary comparative conditions.
\(\textbf{Assess the reducing tendency:}\)
A reducing agent undergoes oxidation while causing another species to undergo reduction.
The Group 16 atom in either hydride can undergo oxidation from oxidation state \(-2\) to a higher oxidation state.
The weakening E–H bonds and decreasing stability of the hydrides down the group are consistent with an increasing tendency towards oxidation under suitable conditions.
Consequently, reducing character generally increases from the lighter to the heavier Group 16 hydrides.
Hydrogen telluride is therefore a stronger reducing agent than hydrogen sulphide under appropriate comparable conditions.
A negative oxidation state does not prevent a substance from acting as a reducing agent.
Indeed, an element at a low oxidation state may have considerable scope for undergoing oxidation.
However, this trend does not specify the speed of every possible redox reaction.
Reaction rate and the identity of the oxidizing partner remain separate considerations.
Thus, \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) shows greater acidic and reducing tendencies while being less thermally stable.
54. Oxygen commonly exists as diatomic \(\mathrm{O_2}\), whereas ordinary rhombic sulphur contains cyclic \(\mathrm{S_8}\) molecules. Both oxygen and sulphur have six valence electrons. Which explanation correctly reconciles their different elemental structures?
ⓐ. Sulphur has fewer valence electrons and therefore forms only single bonds.
ⓑ. Oxygen cannot form multiple bonds because its atoms are smaller than sulphur atoms.
ⓒ. Oxygen forms effective multiple bonds; sulphur more readily makes stable S–S chains and rings.
ⓓ. Sulphur must exist as \(\mathrm{S_8}\) because each sulphur atom requires eight direct covalent bonds.
Correct Answer: Oxygen forms effective multiple bonds; sulphur more readily makes stable S–S chains and rings.
Explanation: Oxygen and sulphur belong to Group 16 and have the general outermost configuration \(ns^2np^4\).
Each neutral atom possesses six valence electrons.
The difference between their elemental molecular structures therefore cannot be attributed to different valence-electron counts.
\(\textbf{Examine oxygen's bonding preference:}\)
Oxygen has compact \(2p\) orbitals that can overlap effectively with orbitals on another oxygen atom.
Effective sideways overlap permits strong \(\pi\) bonding.
Molecular oxygen consequently contains an O–O bond with substantial double-bond character.
The relatively weak O–O single bond also makes extensive ordinary single-bonded oxygen chains less favourable.
\(\textbf{Examine sulphur's bonding preference:}\)
Sulphur has larger, more diffuse \(3p\) orbitals.
Effective multiple bonding between two sulphur atoms is generally less favourable than the corresponding multiple bonding between two oxygen atoms.
However, S–S single bonds can support chains and cyclic structures.
Ordinary rhombic sulphur contains puckered eight-membered \(\mathrm{S_8}\) rings.
Each sulphur atom in such a ring is directly bonded to two neighbouring sulphur atoms.
The remaining valence electrons are represented by lone pairs.
Therefore, the existence of an \(\mathrm{S_8}\) ring does not require each sulphur atom to form eight covalent bonds.
The contrasting elemental structures reflect differences in single-bonding and multiple-bonding tendencies.
The correct explanation connects atomic-orbital size, orbital overlap and the relative stability of different bonding arrangements.
55. Two Group 16 elements X and Y occupy different positions in the group. X forms an acidic dioxide \(\mathrm{XO_2}\), whereas Y forms an amphoteric dioxide \(\mathrm{YO_2}\). Both central elements have oxidation state +4 in their respective oxides. If X is sulphur and Y is tellurium, which additional comparison is consistent with their group positions?
ⓐ. Tellurium is more non-metallic, and \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) is less acidic than \(\mathrm{H_2S}\).
ⓑ. Tellurium is more metallic, and \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) has a weaker E–H bond than \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\).
ⓒ. Sulphur is more metallic, and \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) is more acidic than \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\).
ⓓ. Sulphur is more non-metallic, and \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) is more acidic than \(\mathrm{H_2S}\).
Correct Answer: Sulphur is more non-metallic, and \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) is more acidic than \(\mathrm{H_2S}\).
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret the oxide evidence:}\)
Sulphur and tellurium both belong to Group 16, but tellurium lies below sulphur.
Metallic character generally increases down the group.
Sulphur is a non-metal, whereas tellurium has appreciable metalloid character.
Sulphur dioxide, \(\mathrm{SO_2}\), behaves as an acidic oxide.
Tellurium dioxide, \(\mathrm{TeO_2}\), exhibits amphoteric behaviour under suitable conditions.
This difference is consistent with increasing metallic character and changing bonding properties down the group.
The central element has oxidation state +4 in both oxides, so their different acid–base behaviour cannot be explained by oxidation-state difference.
\(\textbf{Apply the independent hydride trend:}\)
The corresponding hydrides are \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) and \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\).
The E–H bond becomes longer and generally weaker down Group 16.
The weaker H–Te bond contributes to the greater acidic strength of hydrogen telluride.
Thus, \(\mathrm{H_2Te}\) is more acidic than \(\mathrm{H_2S}\).
There is no contradiction between tellurium exhibiting greater metallic character in its elemental and oxide chemistry and its hydride exhibiting stronger acidic behaviour.
The oxide comparison depends on the chemical character of the parent element and the bonding environment.
The hydride-acidity comparison additionally depends on E–H bonding and the energetics of proton release.
These different relationships must not be collapsed into a single rule that every property becomes either more acidic or more basic down a group.
Therefore, sulphur is more non-metallic, while hydrogen telluride is the stronger acid.
56. The sulphur oxides \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) and \(\mathrm{SO_3}\) are both acidic, although sulphur has different oxidation states in them. Which statement correctly combines their oxidation states with a possible redox change?
ⓐ. Sulphur has oxidation states +2 and +3, and conversion of \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) to \(\mathrm{SO_3}\) is reduction.
ⓑ. Sulphur has oxidation states +4 and +6, and conversion of \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) to \(\mathrm{SO_3}\) is reduction.
ⓒ. Sulphur has oxidation states +4 and +6, and conversion of \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) to \(\mathrm{SO_3}\) involves oxidation of sulphur.
ⓓ. Sulphur has oxidation states +6 and +4, and conversion of \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) to \(\mathrm{SO_3}\) involves oxidation of oxygen.
Correct Answer: Sulphur has oxidation states +4 and +6, and conversion of \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) to \(\mathrm{SO_3}\) involves oxidation of sulphur.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Assign oxidation states:}\)
Oxygen ordinarily has oxidation state \(-2\) in both oxides.
For sulphur dioxide:
\[
x+2(-2)=0
\]
\[
x=+4
\]
Thus, sulphur has oxidation state +4 in \(\mathrm{SO_2}\).
For sulphur trioxide:
\[
y+3(-2)=0
\]
\[
y=+6
\]
Thus, sulphur has oxidation state +6 in \(\mathrm{SO_3}\).
\(\textbf{Interpret the oxidation-state change:}\)
Conversion from sulphur dioxide to sulphur trioxide increases the oxidation state of sulphur from +4 to +6.
An increase in oxidation state indicates oxidation.
Therefore, sulphur dioxide can act as a reducing agent when it is oxidized to sulphur trioxide under suitable conditions.
An illustrative balanced reaction is:
\[
\mathrm{2SO_2+O_2\longrightarrow 2SO_3}
\]
In this reaction, oxygen from molecular oxygen is reduced from oxidation state zero to \(-2\).
Sulphur is oxidized, while molecular oxygen acts as the oxidizing agent.
\(\textbf{Relate the result to oxide behaviour:}\)
Both \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) and \(\mathrm{SO_3}\) are acidic oxides.
A change in the oxidation state of the central element does not necessarily change an acidic oxide into a basic oxide.
Oxide acid–base classification and oxidation-state assignment describe different chemical properties.
Therefore, the correct interpretation combines oxidation of sulphur with retention of acidic oxide character.
57. Hydrogen sulphide and sulphur dioxide react under suitable conditions according to:
\[
\mathrm{2H_2S+SO_2\longrightarrow 3S+2H_2O}
\]
Which statement correctly identifies the redox roles of the two sulphur-containing reactants?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) acts as the reducing agent, while \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) acts as the oxidizing agent.
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) acts as the oxidizing agent, while \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) acts as the reducing agent.
ⓒ. Both \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) and \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) act as reducing agents because both contain sulphur.
ⓓ. Neither reactant undergoes oxidation-state change because elemental sulphur is the product.
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) acts as the reducing agent, while \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) acts as the oxidizing agent.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify sulphur's initial oxidation states:}\)
In hydrogen sulphide, hydrogen has oxidation state +1.
The oxidation state of sulphur is therefore:
\[
2(+1)+x=0
\]
\[
x=-2
\]
In sulphur dioxide, oxygen has oxidation state \(-2\).
Therefore:
\[
y+2(-2)=0
\]
\[
y=+4
\]
Elemental sulphur in the product has oxidation state zero.
\(\textbf{Follow the two oxidation-state changes:}\)
Sulphur in \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) changes from \(-2\) to zero.
This is an increase in oxidation state and therefore represents oxidation.
Each sulphur atom from \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) loses two electrons in formal oxidation-state accounting.
There are two \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) molecules, so the total number of electrons lost is:
\[
2\times[0-(-2)]=4
\]
Sulphur in \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) changes from +4 to zero.
This represents reduction involving a formal gain of four electrons:
\[
(+4)-0=4
\]
\(\textbf{Check electron conservation:}\)
The two sulphur atoms initially present in hydrogen sulphide collectively lose four electrons.
The sulphur atom initially present in sulphur dioxide gains four electrons.
Thus, total electron loss equals total electron gain.
Hydrogen sulphide undergoes oxidation and acts as the reducing agent.
Sulphur dioxide undergoes reduction and acts as the oxidizing agent.
This illustrates an important feature of variable oxidation states: a Group 16 element at an intermediate oxidation state can participate in redox reactions differently depending on its reaction partner.
The balanced equation simultaneously satisfies atomic conservation and electron-transfer consistency.
Hence, \(\mathrm{H_2S}\) is the reducing agent and \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) is the oxidizing agent.
58. The first electron-gain enthalpies of oxygen and sulphur are approximately \(-141\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) and \(-200\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\), respectively. Sulphur is larger than oxygen. Which explanation correctly reconciles these observations?
ⓐ. Oxygen has a less negative electron-gain enthalpy because its nuclear charge is smaller than that of sulphur.
ⓑ. Sulphur has a more negative electron-gain enthalpy because its larger \(3p\) orbitals eliminate all electron–electron repulsion.
ⓒ. Oxygen must have a more negative electron-gain enthalpy because it is more electronegative than sulphur.
ⓓ. Compact oxygen \(2p\) orbitals repel an added electron strongly, reducing exothermicity of electron gain.
Correct Answer: Compact oxygen \(2p\) orbitals repel an added electron strongly, reducing exothermicity of electron gain.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret the sign of electron-gain enthalpy:}\)
A negative electron-gain enthalpy indicates that energy is released when an isolated gaseous atom accepts an electron in the specified process.
The value for sulphur is more negative than that for oxygen.
Therefore, electron attachment to gaseous sulphur releases more energy than electron attachment to gaseous oxygen under the defined conditions.
This may appear surprising because oxygen is smaller and more electronegative.
\(\textbf{Compare the receiving orbitals:}\)
The electronic configuration of oxygen ends in \(2p^4\).
An incoming electron must enter the compact \(2p\) subshell.
Because this subshell occupies a relatively small spatial region, the additional electron experiences appreciable repulsion from electrons already present.
Sulphur has the outermost configuration \(3s^23p^4\).
Its \(3p\) orbitals are larger and more diffuse than oxygen's \(2p\) orbitals.
The incoming electron consequently experiences less severe electron–electron repulsion in the receiving subshell.
Although the attractive nuclear effects also matter, the repulsion difference is sufficient to make sulphur's first electron-gain enthalpy more negative.
This is an important exception to applying a simple down-group trend without qualification.
The more negative value for sulphur does not mean sulphur is necessarily more electronegative or a stronger oxidizing agent than oxygen in every chemical environment.
Electron-gain enthalpy describes a specific gas-phase atomic process, whereas chemical reactivity can depend on additional energetic factors.
The correct explanation must therefore consider both attraction and electron–electron repulsion rather than relying only on atomic size.
59. Consider two Group 16 elements X and Y. X is sulphur, while Y is tellurium. The following statements are proposed.
Statement I: Both possess the general outermost configuration \(ns^2np^4\).
Statement II: The \(-2\) oxidation state is possible for both under suitable bonding conditions.
Statement III: The metallic character of Y is greater than that of X.
Statement IV: The E–H bond in the simple hydride of Y is generally stronger than the corresponding bond in the hydride of X.
Statement V: The +6 oxidation state is impossible for Y because it lies below sulphur.
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. Statements I, II and IV only
ⓑ. Statements I, II and III only
ⓒ. Statements II, III and V only
ⓓ. Statements I, III and V only
Correct Answer: Statements I, II and III only
Explanation: Statement I is correct because sulphur and tellurium are both members of Group 16.
Their valence-shell configurations have the general form \(ns^2np^4\).
Consequently, both possess six valence electrons.
Statement II is correct because both elements can exhibit oxidation state \(-2\) in suitable compounds.
For example, their simple hydrides contain the Group 16 element in oxidation state \(-2\).
However, the existence of this oxidation state does not require identical bonding character in every compound.
Statement III is correct because metallic character generally increases down Group 16.
Sulphur is non-metallic, whereas tellurium exhibits appreciable metalloid character.
Statement IV is incorrect because E–H bond strength generally decreases down the group.
Tellurium has a larger atomic radius than sulphur, leading to longer and generally weaker bonds with hydrogen.
Therefore, the H–Te bond is weaker than the H–S bond.
Statement V is also incorrect.
Tellurium can exhibit positive oxidation states, including +6, in suitable compounds such as \(\mathrm{TeF_6}\).
The relative stability of an oxidation state may change down the group, but such a trend does not mean that the higher oxidation state becomes universally impossible.
The statements together test electronic similarity, oxidation-state accessibility, metallic character and bonding changes.
Only Statements I, II and III are correct.
60. A compound containing aluminium and sulphur is treated as predominantly ionic for the purpose of deriving its simplest formula. Aluminium forms \(\mathrm{Al^{3+}}\), while sulphur forms \(\mathrm{S^{2-}}\). Which conclusion correctly combines electrical neutrality with the electronic configuration of the sulphide ion?
ⓐ. Formula \(\mathrm{Al_3S_2}\); sulphide has the electron configuration of argon.
ⓑ. Formula \(\mathrm{Al_2S_3}\); sulphide has the electron configuration of neon.
ⓒ. Formula \(\mathrm{Al_2S_3}\); sulphide has the electron configuration of argon.
ⓓ. Formula \(\mathrm{Al_3S_2}\); sulphide has the electron configuration of krypton.
Correct Answer: Formula \(\mathrm{Al_2S_3}\); sulphide has the electron configuration of argon.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the formula from charge balance:}\)
The aluminium ion carries charge +3, while the sulphide ion carries charge \(-2\).
A neutral formula unit must contain a combination of ions whose total positive and negative charges cancel.
The least common multiple of the charge magnitudes three and two is six.
Two aluminium ions contribute:
\[
2(+3)=+6
\]
Three sulphide ions contribute:
\[
3(-2)=-6
\]
The net charge becomes:
\[
(+6)+(-6)=0
\]
Therefore, the simplest charge-balanced formula is:
\[
\mathrm{Al_2S_3}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the sulphide electron count:}\)
A neutral sulphur atom has atomic number \(16\) and therefore contains sixteen electrons.
Formation of the sulphide ion involves acquisition of two electrons.
The resulting electron count is:
\[
N_e=16+2=18
\]
Argon has eighteen electrons and the electronic configuration \(1s^22s^22p^63s^23p^6\).
Consequently, \(\mathrm{S^{2-}}\) is isoelectronic with argon.
\(\textbf{Check the chemical interpretation:}\)
The Group 16 valence configuration \(ns^2np^4\) explains why acquisition of two electrons can complete the valence shell.
The formula follows from charge balance, not simply from exchanging group numbers without considering ionic charges.
This ionic model is appropriate for deriving the simplest formula of aluminium sulphide.
The conclusions also demonstrate how Group 13 and Group 16 electronic configurations can be integrated into one chemically consistent prediction.
Thus, \(\mathrm{Al_2S_3}\) has the required charge balance, and its sulphide ions possess an argon-like electron configuration.
61. The H–O–H bond angle in water is approximately \(104.5^\circ\), while the H–S–H bond angle in hydrogen sulphide is approximately \(92^\circ\). Both molecules are bent and contain two lone pairs on the central atom. Which explanation best accounts for their differing bond angles?
ⓐ. Water has appreciable orbital hybridization, whereas H–S–H bonding has greater nearly pure \(p\)-orbital character.
ⓑ. Water contains one lone pair on oxygen, whereas hydrogen sulphide contains two lone pairs on sulphur.
ⓒ. Hydrogen sulphide is nearly linear because sulphur has a larger atomic radius than oxygen.
ⓓ. Water forms four covalent O–H bonds, whereas hydrogen sulphide forms two covalent S–H bonds.
Correct Answer: Water has appreciable orbital hybridization, whereas H–S–H bonding has greater nearly pure \(p\)-orbital character.
Explanation: Oxygen and sulphur both belong to Group 16 and possess six valence electrons.
In their simple hydrides, each central atom forms two covalent bonds with hydrogen.
The remaining four valence electrons form two lone pairs.
Consequently, both molecules have two bonding pairs and two lone pairs in the usual Lewis description.
Their molecular geometries are bent rather than linear.
\(\textbf{Explain water's bond angle:}\)
Water has an approximately tetrahedral electron-pair arrangement around oxygen.
Its valence bonding exhibits appreciable hybridized-orbital character.
Lone-pair–lone-pair and lone-pair–bond-pair repulsions influence the positions of the O–H bonds.
The H–O–H bond angle is therefore smaller than the ideal tetrahedral angle of approximately \(109.5^\circ\).
Its observed value is approximately \(104.5^\circ\).
\(\textbf{Explain hydrogen sulphide's angle:}\)
Hydrogen sulphide exhibits much less hybridization than water.
Its S–H bonding possesses greater nearly pure \(p\)-orbital character.
The angular relationship between nearly perpendicular \(p\) orbitals produces a bond angle close to \(90^\circ\).
The observed H–S–H angle of approximately \(92^\circ\) is consistent with this bonding description.
Hydrogen sulphide therefore remains bent despite having a smaller bond angle than water.
The difference cannot be explained by assigning different numbers of lone pairs to the central atoms.
It reflects differences in valence-orbital participation and bonding characteristics between the first and heavier Group 16 members.
62. Ammonia and water belong to the simple hydrides of adjacent p-block groups. Their normal boiling points are approximately \(-33^\circ\mathrm{C}\) and \(100^\circ\mathrm{C}\), respectively. Which interpretation correctly combines their central-atom electron arrangements with their intermolecular behaviour?
ⓐ. Ammonia and water each contain two central-atom lone pairs, but water has stronger dispersion forces.
ⓑ. Ammonia contains two central-atom lone pairs, while water contains one; both are non-polar molecules.
ⓒ. Ammonia and water have identical molecular geometries, but water has the larger molar mass.
ⓓ. Ammonia has one central-atom lone pair, while water has two; water forms a more extensive hydrogen-bonding network.
Correct Answer: Ammonia has one central-atom lone pair, while water has two; water forms a more extensive hydrogen-bonding network.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Compare the central-atom valence electrons:}\)
Nitrogen belongs to Group 15 and has five valence electrons.
In ammonia, nitrogen forms three N–H covalent bonds and retains one lone pair.
This gives ammonia a trigonal-pyramidal molecular geometry.
Oxygen belongs to Group 16 and has six valence electrons.
In water, oxygen forms two O–H covalent bonds and retains two lone pairs.
This gives water a bent molecular geometry.
Therefore, the two molecules differ in both the number of central-atom lone pairs and molecular geometry.
\(\textbf{Connect structure with hydrogen bonding:}\)
Both ammonia and water can form intermolecular hydrogen bonds.
However, water has two hydrogen atoms available as hydrogen-bond donors and two lone pairs that can participate as hydrogen-bond acceptors.
This enables an extensive intermolecular hydrogen-bonding network.
Ammonia also participates in hydrogen bonding, but its hydrogen-bonding arrangement is less extensive and its intermolecular interactions are generally weaker.
Water consequently requires substantially more energy to separate its molecules during boiling.
\(\textbf{Reject the molar-mass explanation:}\)
Ammonia has a molar mass of approximately \(17\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}\), while water has a molar mass of approximately \(18\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}\).
Such a small molar-mass difference cannot by itself explain their approximately \(133^\circ\mathrm{C}\) difference in boiling points.
Furthermore, hydrogen bonding depends on molecular polarity and the availability of suitable donors and acceptors, not merely on molar mass.
The comparison therefore requires both valence-electron reasoning and an understanding of intermolecular interactions.
Water's two lone pairs and extensive hydrogen-bonding network provide the chemically appropriate explanation for its much higher boiling point.
63. An element X has the ground-state electronic configuration \([\mathrm{Ar}]\,3d^{10}4s^24p^5\). It forms a diatomic elemental molecule and can acquire one electron to form a closed-shell monatomic anion. Which statement correctly combines the identity of X, its ground-state orbital occupancy and the configuration of its anion?
ⓐ. X is selenium; its neutral atom has two unpaired \(4p\) electrons, and \(\mathrm{X^{2-}}\) is isoelectronic with krypton.
ⓑ. X is bromine; its neutral atom has two unpaired \(4p\) electrons, and \(\mathrm{X^-}\) is isoelectronic with argon.
ⓒ. X is bromine; its neutral atom has one unpaired \(4p\) electron, and \(\mathrm{X^-}\) is isoelectronic with krypton.
ⓓ. X is iodine; its neutral atom has one unpaired \(5p\) electron, and \(\mathrm{X^-}\) is isoelectronic with krypton.
Correct Answer: X is bromine; its neutral atom has one unpaired \(4p\) electron, and \(\mathrm{X^-}\) is isoelectronic with krypton.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the neutral element:}\)
The supplied electronic configuration contains an argon core, ten \(3d\) electrons, two \(4s\) electrons and five \(4p\) electrons.
The total electron count is:
\[
Z=18+10+2+5=35
\]
Atomic number \(35\) corresponds to bromine.
Its highest occupied principal shell is \(n=4\), so bromine belongs to Period 4.
The outermost configuration \(4s^24p^5\) identifies Group 17 and seven valence electrons.
\(\textbf{Determine the unpaired-electron count:}\)
A \(p\) subshell contains three orbitals.
According to Hund's rule, the three orbitals are occupied singly before electron pairing occurs.
For the \(4p^5\) arrangement, two orbitals contain electron pairs and the remaining orbital contains one electron.
Consequently, the neutral bromine atom has one unpaired \(4p\) electron.
\(\textbf{Determine the anion configuration:}\)
Acquisition of one electron completes the \(4p\) subshell.
The resulting bromide ion has:
\[
N_e=35+1=36
\]
Its electronic configuration is \([\mathrm{Ar}]\,3d^{10}4s^24p^6\), identical to that of krypton.
This closed-shell arrangement helps explain the characteristic \(-1\) oxidation state of bromine in compounds with sufficiently electropositive elements.
However, the number of unpaired electrons in an isolated bromine atom should not be confused with the electron arrangement in molecular \(\mathrm{Br_2}\) or in \(\mathrm{Br^-}\).
The identification requires atomic-number determination, orbital occupancy and the electron-gain consequence to agree simultaneously.
64. The first electron-gain enthalpies of fluorine and chlorine are approximately \(-328\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) and \(-349\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\), respectively. Nevertheless, fluorine is the stronger oxidizing agent under standard aqueous conditions. Which explanation correctly reconciles these observations?
ⓐ. Fluorine's smaller \(2p\) subshell increases incoming-electron repulsion, while its aqueous oxidizing strength depends on additional energetic factors, including fluoride hydration.
ⓑ. Chlorine's more negative electron-gain enthalpy proves that chlorine is the stronger aqueous oxidizing agent, regardless of hydration.
ⓒ. Fluorine's electron-gain enthalpy must be positive because its compact \(2p\) subshell cannot accept another electron.
ⓓ. Chlorine's larger atomic radius makes its electron-gain enthalpy more negative and its aqueous reduction potential necessarily higher than fluorine's.
Correct Answer: Fluorine's smaller \(2p\) subshell increases incoming-electron repulsion, while its aqueous oxidizing strength depends on additional energetic factors, including fluoride hydration.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret the electron-gain-enthalpy data:}\)
A negative first electron-gain enthalpy indicates that energy is released when an isolated gaseous atom gains an electron.
The value for chlorine is more negative than that for fluorine.
Therefore, electron attachment to gaseous chlorine releases more energy than electron attachment to gaseous fluorine under the specified conditions.
This does not contradict fluorine's greater electronegativity.
\(\textbf{Explain the atomic exception:}\)
Fluorine has the outermost configuration \(2s^22p^5\).
The incoming electron must enter its compact \(2p\) subshell.
Electron–electron repulsion is appreciable because the receiving subshell occupies a small spatial region.
Chlorine has a larger and more diffuse \(3p\) subshell, where the incoming electron experiences less severe repulsion.
This difference helps make chlorine's first electron-gain enthalpy more negative.
\(\textbf{Connect the atomic property with aqueous oxidation:}\)
Oxidizing strength in aqueous solution concerns the overall tendency of a species to accept electrons under specified solution conditions.
For molecular halogens, reduction involves breaking the X–X bond, forming gaseous halide ions conceptually, and stabilizing the resulting ions in water.
The fluoride ion is very strongly hydrated because of its small size and high charge density.
The relatively low F–F bond dissociation enthalpy also contributes favourably to the reduction process.
These energetic contributions help make fluorine the strongest oxidizing halogen under standard aqueous conditions.
Aqueous electrode potentials depend on Gibbs energy changes rather than electron-gain enthalpy alone.
Thus, the halogen with the most negative isolated-atom electron-gain enthalpy need not possess the greatest aqueous oxidizing strength.
65. For a simplified thermochemical comparison, the following approximate enthalpy data are supplied.
| Quantity | Fluorine | Chlorine |
| X–X bond dissociation enthalpy \((\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}})\) | 159 | 243 |
| First electron-gain enthalpy \((\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}})\) | -328 | -349 |
| Hydration enthalpy of \(\mathrm{X^-}\) \((\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}})\) | -506 | -381 |
Assume these values apply to the specified standard thermochemical steps. Using Hess's law, estimate the enthalpy change for \(\mathrm{X_2(g)+2e^-\rightarrow 2X^-(aq)}\), taking the electron energy as the same reference for both halogens. Which conclusion is correct?
ⓐ. Fluorine: \(-497\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\); chlorine: \(-455\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\); fluorine is more exothermic.
ⓑ. Fluorine: \(-1509\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\); chlorine: \(-1217\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\); fluorine is more exothermic.
ⓒ. Fluorine: \(-117\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\); chlorine: \(-455\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\); chlorine is more exothermic.
ⓓ. Fluorine: \(-1509\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\); chlorine: \(-1217\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\); chlorine is more exothermic.
Correct Answer: Fluorine: \(-1509\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\); chlorine: \(-1217\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\); fluorine is more exothermic.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Construct the thermochemical pathway:}\)
The required transformation involves converting one mole of gaseous diatomic halogen into two moles of hydrated halide ions.
The first stage is dissociation of the X–X bond.
This process absorbs energy.
\[
\mathrm{X_2(g)\rightarrow 2X(g)}
\]
The second stage involves attachment of one electron to each gaseous halogen atom.
\[
\mathrm{2X(g)+2e^-\rightarrow 2X^-(g)}
\]
The third stage involves hydration of the two gaseous halide ions.
\[
\mathrm{2X^-(g)\rightarrow 2X^-(aq)}
\]
By Hess's law, the total enthalpy change is the sum of these three contributions.
\(\textbf{Governing enthalpy relation:}\)
\[
\Delta H=D(\mathrm{X-X})+2\Delta_{\mathrm{eg}}H+2\Delta_{\mathrm{hyd}}H
\]
The factor of two is essential because one \(\mathrm{X_2}\) molecule produces two halide ions.
\(\textbf{Calculate the fluorine value:}\)
\[
\Delta H_{\mathrm{F_2}}=159+2(-328)+2(-506)
\]
\[
=159-656-1012
\]
\[
\Delta H_{\mathrm{F_2}}=-1509\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the chlorine value:}\)
\[
\Delta H_{\mathrm{Cl_2}}=243+2(-349)+2(-381)
\]
\[
=243-698-762
\]
\[
\Delta H_{\mathrm{Cl_2}}=-1217\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Compare the results:}\)
The fluorine process has the more negative enthalpy change.
Its stronger hydration contribution more than compensates for its less negative atomic electron-gain enthalpy.
The lower F–F bond dissociation enthalpy also favours the fluorine reduction process.
These data therefore support the conclusion that the specified reduction pathway is more exothermic for fluorine.
The calculation must not be mistaken for a complete electrode-potential calculation because electrode potentials depend on Gibbs energy, including entropy contributions.
Nevertheless, the supplied thermochemical cycle demonstrates why comparing isolated-atom electron-gain enthalpies alone is insufficient to determine aqueous oxidizing behaviour.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\Delta H_{\mathrm{F_2}}=-1509\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\lt \Delta H_{\mathrm{Cl_2}}=-1217\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}}
\]
The modeled reduction of fluorine is more exothermic.
66. Under ordinary standard aqueous conditions, halogen oxidizing strength decreases in the order \(\mathrm{F_2\gt Cl_2\gt Br_2\gt I_2}\). Which pair of reactions is thermodynamically favourable in the indicated forward directions?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{Br_2+2Cl^-\rightarrow 2Br^-+Cl_2}\) and \(\mathrm{Cl_2+2I^-\rightarrow 2Cl^-+I_2}\)
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{Cl_2+2Br^-\rightarrow 2Cl^-+Br_2}\) and \(\mathrm{I_2+2Br^-\rightarrow 2I^-+Br_2}\)
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{I_2+2Cl^-\rightarrow 2I^-+Cl_2}\) and \(\mathrm{Br_2+2F^-\rightarrow 2Br^-+F_2}\)
ⓓ. \(\mathrm{Cl_2+2Br^-\rightarrow 2Cl^-+Br_2}\) and \(\mathrm{Br_2+2I^-\rightarrow 2Br^-+I_2}\)
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{Cl_2+2Br^-\rightarrow 2Cl^-+Br_2}\) and \(\mathrm{Br_2+2I^-\rightarrow 2Br^-+I_2}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the electron-transfer requirement:}\)
A molecular halogen acts as an oxidizing agent when it gains electrons to form halide ions.
The general reduction half-reaction is:
\[
\mathrm{X_2+2e^-\rightarrow 2X^-}
\]
A halide ion acts as a reducing agent when it loses electrons to form the corresponding elemental halogen.
The corresponding oxidation half-reaction is:
\[
\mathrm{2Y^-\rightarrow Y_2+2e^-}
\]
A favourable displacement reaction occurs when the molecular halogen is a stronger oxidizing agent than the halogen represented by the halide ion.
\(\textbf{Apply the supplied oxidizing-strength order:}\)
Chlorine is a stronger oxidizing agent than bromine under standard aqueous conditions.
Therefore, chlorine can oxidize bromide ions to bromine.
\[
\mathrm{Cl_2+2Br^-\rightarrow 2Cl^-+Br_2}
\]
Bromine is a stronger oxidizing agent than iodine.
Consequently, bromine can oxidize iodide ions to iodine.
\[
\mathrm{Br_2+2I^-\rightarrow 2Br^-+I_2}
\]
Both reactions are consistent with electron transfer from the weaker halogen's halide ion to the stronger molecular oxidizing agent.
The reverse reactions are not thermodynamically favourable under the specified standard conditions.
For example, molecular iodine cannot ordinarily oxidize chloride ions to chlorine under these conditions.
\(\textbf{Connect oxidizing and reducing tendencies:}\)
The oxidizing tendency of the molecular halogens decreases down Group 17.
Conversely, the tendency of their halide ions to act as reducing agents generally increases down the group.
Thus, iodide is more readily oxidized than bromide, while fluoride is particularly resistant to oxidation by the other halogens.
This reciprocal relationship explains the displacement pattern.
The correct pair contains two reactions proceeding in the direction favoured by the relative standard oxidizing strengths.
67. Chlorine forms the binary compounds \(\mathrm{ClF}\) and \(\mathrm{ICl}\). Fluorine is more electronegative than chlorine, while chlorine is more electronegative than iodine. Which conclusion correctly compares the oxidation states of chlorine in these two compounds?
ⓐ. Chlorine is +1 in \(\mathrm{ClF}\) and -1 in \(\mathrm{ICl}\).
ⓑ. Chlorine is -1 in \(\mathrm{ClF}\) and +1 in \(\mathrm{ICl}\).
ⓒ. Chlorine is +1 in both compounds because it belongs to Group 17.
ⓓ. Chlorine is -1 in both compounds because all halogens prefer the -1 state.
Correct Answer: Chlorine is +1 in \(\mathrm{ClF}\) and -1 in \(\mathrm{ICl}\).
Explanation: \(\textbf{Apply the electronegativity convention:}\)
In formal oxidation-state assignment, bonding electrons are assigned to the more electronegative atom.
The oxidation state is therefore dependent on the identity of the bonding partner.
It is not fixed solely by the periodic group of the element.
\(\textbf{Examine chlorine monofluoride:}\)
Fluorine is the most electronegative element.
It is assigned oxidation state \(-1\) in \(\mathrm{ClF}\).
Since the molecule is neutral, chlorine must have oxidation state +1.
\[
x+(-1)=0
\]
\[
x=+1
\]
\(\textbf{Examine iodine monochloride:}\)
Chlorine is more electronegative than iodine.
Consequently, chlorine is assigned oxidation state \(-1\) in \(\mathrm{ICl}\).
Iodine therefore has oxidation state +1.
\[
y+(-1)=0
\]
\[
y=+1
\]
The positive oxidation state in the second calculation belongs to iodine, not chlorine.
Thus, chlorine changes its formal oxidation-state assignment depending on whether it is bonded to a more or a less electronegative halogen.
This illustrates an important distinction within Group 17.
Fluorine is assigned oxidation state \(-1\) in its compounds, whereas chlorine, bromine and iodine can exhibit positive oxidation states with suitable bonding partners.
The result cannot be predicted from the group number or the common halide oxidation state alone.
The decisive information is the relative electronegativity of the two bonded atoms.
68. A chlorine-containing oxyanion, \(\mathrm{ClO_4^-}\), is considered under acidic conditions. Chlorine is reduced completely to chloride, \(\mathrm{Cl^-}\), without changing the number of chlorine atoms. Which half-reaction correctly represents the reduction, with both atoms and charge balanced?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{ClO_4^-+8H^++6e^-\rightarrow Cl^-+4H_2O}\)
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{ClO_4^-+6H^++8e^-\rightarrow Cl^-+4H_2O}\)
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{ClO_4^-+8H^++8e^-\rightarrow Cl^-+4H_2O}\)
ⓓ. \(\mathrm{ClO_4^-+8H^++4e^-\rightarrow Cl^-+4H_2O}\)
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{ClO_4^-+8H^++8e^-\rightarrow Cl^-+4H_2O}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the initial oxidation state:}\)
In the perchlorate ion, oxygen is assigned oxidation state \(-2\).
Let the oxidation state of chlorine be \(x\).
The algebraic sum must equal the ionic charge of \(-1\).
\[
x+4(-2)=-1
\]
\[
x-8=-1
\]
\[
x=+7
\]
Thus, chlorine initially has oxidation state +7.
In chloride, chlorine has oxidation state \(-1\).
\(\textbf{Calculate the electron requirement:}\)
The oxidation state decreases from +7 to \(-1\).
This corresponds to a formal gain of eight electrons per chlorine atom.
\[
(+7)-(-1)=8
\]
Therefore, eight electrons must appear on the reactant side of the reduction half-reaction.
\(\textbf{Balance oxygen and hydrogen:}\)
The reactant contains four oxygen atoms.
Four water molecules are placed on the product side to balance oxygen.
These four water molecules contain eight hydrogen atoms.
Because the medium is acidic, eight hydrogen ions are introduced on the reactant side.
The resulting relation is:
\[
\mathrm{ClO_4^-+8H^++8e^-\rightarrow Cl^-+4H_2O}
\]
\(\textbf{Verify charge conservation:}\)
The total charge on the reactant side is:
\[
-1+8-8=-1
\]
The total charge on the product side is \(-1\).
There is one chlorine atom, four oxygen atoms and eight hydrogen atoms on each side.
Thus, both atomic and charge conservation are satisfied.
The balanced half-reaction illustrates that chlorine can exhibit oxidation states extending from +7 in suitable oxygen-containing species to \(-1\) in chloride.
It represents formal electron-transfer accounting and does not, by itself, specify the reaction mechanism or establish that the reduction is rapid under every acidic condition.
The correct equation must satisfy oxidation-state change, hydrogen–oxygen balance and charge conservation simultaneously.
69. The approximate bond dissociation enthalpies of the halogen molecules are shown below.
| Bond | Bond dissociation enthalpy \((\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}})\) |
| F–F | 159 |
| Cl–Cl | 243 |
| Br–Br | 193 |
| I–I | 151 |
Fluorine has the smallest atomic size and highest electronegativity among the halogens. Why is its F–F bond nevertheless substantially weaker than the Cl–Cl bond?
ⓐ. Fluorine cannot form covalent bonds because it has seven valence electrons.
ⓑ. The compact fluorine atoms experience substantial repulsion between non-bonding electron pairs on adjacent atoms, weakening the F–F bond.
ⓒ. The F–F bond is weaker because fluorine molecules have stronger intermolecular dispersion forces than chlorine molecules.
ⓓ. The F–F bond is weaker because the fluorine atom possesses no unpaired valence electron before bonding.
Correct Answer: The compact fluorine atoms experience substantial repulsion between non-bonding electron pairs on adjacent atoms, weakening the F–F bond.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret the bond-energy comparison:}\)
A larger bond dissociation enthalpy means that more energy is required to break a specified covalent bond in the gas phase.
The supplied Cl–Cl bond enthalpy is greater than the F–F bond enthalpy.
Therefore, the chlorine–chlorine single bond is stronger than the fluorine–fluorine single bond.
This is an exception to the oversimplified expectation that the smallest atoms must always form the strongest single bonds.
\(\textbf{Examine electron-pair repulsion:}\)
Each fluorine atom has seven valence electrons and forms one ordinary covalent bond in \(\mathrm{F_2}\).
The remaining six valence electrons on each fluorine atom are represented by three lone pairs.
Fluorine atoms are exceptionally small.
When two such atoms approach one another to form the F–F bond, their non-bonding electron pairs occupy closely spaced regions.
The resulting lone-pair–lone-pair repulsion is substantial.
This repulsion reduces the net stability of the F–F bond.
Chlorine atoms are larger, so the corresponding non-bonding electron pairs are more spatially separated.
The Cl–Cl bond consequently experiences less severe crowding from adjacent lone pairs.
Although Cl–Cl orbital overlap differs from F–F overlap, the reduced lone-pair repulsion contributes significantly to its greater bond strength.
\(\textbf{Distinguish bonding strength from oxidation behaviour:}\)
Fluorine remains a very powerful oxidizing agent despite the comparatively weak F–F bond.
Its aqueous oxidizing tendency depends on the complete reduction process, including bond dissociation, electron attachment and hydration.
Furthermore, bond dissociation enthalpy describes intramolecular bonding rather than the intermolecular forces responsible for boiling.
The comparison therefore illustrates why electronegativity, covalent bond strength and oxidizing power must not be treated as interchangeable properties.
70. The approximate melting and boiling points of four elemental halogens at \(1\,\mathrm{atm}\) are supplied below.
| Halogen | Melting point \((^\circ\mathrm{C})\) | Boiling point \((^\circ\mathrm{C})\) |
| \(\mathrm{F_2}\) | -220 | -188 |
| \(\mathrm{Cl_2}\) | -101 | -34 |
| \(\mathrm{Br_2}\) | -7 | 59 |
| \(\mathrm{I_2}\) | 114 | 184 |
At \(50^\circ\mathrm{C}\) and \(1\,\mathrm{atm}\), pure samples are allowed to attain phase equilibrium. Which statement correctly predicts their physical states and identifies the main down-group cause of the increasing phase-transition temperatures?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{F_2}\) and \(\mathrm{Cl_2}\) are gases, \(\mathrm{Br_2}\) is liquid and \(\mathrm{I_2}\) is solid; increasing molecular polarizability strengthens dispersion forces.
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{F_2}\) and \(\mathrm{Cl_2}\) are gases, \(\mathrm{Br_2}\) is solid and \(\mathrm{I_2}\) is liquid; increasing covalent bond strength determines the states.
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{F_2}\) is liquid, \(\mathrm{Cl_2}\) is gas, \(\mathrm{Br_2}\) is liquid and \(\mathrm{I_2}\) is solid; decreasing polarizability strengthens dispersion forces.
ⓓ. \(\mathrm{F_2}\) and \(\mathrm{Cl_2}\) are gases, \(\mathrm{Br_2}\) is liquid and \(\mathrm{I_2}\) is solid; increasing X–X bond dissociation enthalpy determines the states.
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{F_2}\) and \(\mathrm{Cl_2}\) are gases, \(\mathrm{Br_2}\) is liquid and \(\mathrm{I_2}\) is solid; increasing molecular polarizability strengthens dispersion forces.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret the temperature limits:}\)
At the stated pressure, a pure substance is normally solid below its melting point and gaseous above its boiling point.
Between the melting and boiling points, its equilibrium phase is liquid.
The specified temperature is \(50^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
\(\textbf{Classify fluorine and chlorine:}\)
Fluorine boils at approximately \(-188^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
Since \(50^\circ\mathrm{C}\) is well above this value, fluorine is gaseous.
Chlorine boils at approximately \(-34^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
Therefore, chlorine is also gaseous.
\(\textbf{Classify bromine and iodine:}\)
Bromine melts at approximately \(-7^\circ\mathrm{C}\) and boils at approximately \(59^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
The specified temperature lies between these values.
Hence, bromine is liquid.
Iodine melts at approximately \(114^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
Since the specified temperature is below its melting point, iodine remains solid at equilibrium.
\(\textbf{Explain the increasing transition temperatures:}\)
Elemental halogen molecules are homonuclear diatomic molecules and possess no permanent electric dipole moment.
Their intermolecular attractions are dominated by London dispersion forces.
Down Group 17, the number of electrons and the spatial extent of the electron cloud generally increase.
The electron clouds become more polarizable, strengthening intermolecular dispersion attractions.
More energy is therefore required to separate the molecules during melting or boiling.
This accounts for the general increase in melting and boiling points from fluorine to iodine.
The trend must not be explained by increasing X–X covalent bond strength because these covalent bonds are not ordinarily broken during melting or boiling.
Thus, the physical-state predictions and the intermolecular-force explanation are mutually consistent.
71. The normal boiling points of the hydrogen halides are approximately \(19.5^\circ\mathrm{C}\), \(-85^\circ\mathrm{C}\), \(-67^\circ\mathrm{C}\) and \(-35^\circ\mathrm{C}\) for HF, HCl, HBr and HI, respectively. In dilute aqueous solution, HF is a weak acid, whereas HCl, HBr and HI behave as strong acids. Which explanation correctly reconciles these observations?
ⓐ. HF has the highest boiling point because its H–F bond is the easiest to break; this also makes HF the weakest aqueous acid.
ⓑ. HF has the highest boiling point because its molecules are the most polarizable; its weak acidity results only from the low molar mass of fluorine.
ⓒ. HF has a high boiling point because of intermolecular hydrogen bonding, while its relatively strong H–F bond contributes to its incomplete ionization in dilute water.
ⓓ. HF has a high boiling point because it forms an ionic solid at ordinary temperatures, while HCl, HBr and HI remain covalent gases.
Correct Answer: HF has a high boiling point because of intermolecular hydrogen bonding, while its relatively strong H–F bond contributes to its incomplete ionization in dilute water.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Separate boiling behaviour from acid strength:}\)
Boiling point concerns the intermolecular attractions that must be overcome to separate molecules.
Aqueous acid strength concerns the equilibrium tendency of a dissolved acid to transfer a proton to water.
These are different chemical properties and need not follow the same trend.
\(\textbf{Explain the exceptional boiling point of HF:}\)
Fluorine is exceptionally small and highly electronegative.
The H–F bond is strongly polar.
HF molecules form substantial intermolecular hydrogen bonds, producing associated molecular arrangements in the liquid phase.
These interactions raise HF's boiling point considerably above the values expected from dispersion forces alone.
HCl, HBr and HI do not exhibit comparably strong intermolecular hydrogen bonding.
Their boiling points generally increase from HCl to HI as molecular size and polarizability increase.
\(\textbf{Explain the acidity difference:}\)
The H–F bond is considerably stronger than the H–Cl, H–Br and H–I bonds.
The energetics of breaking the H–F bond and solvating the resulting species contribute to HF's incomplete ionization in dilute aqueous solution.
For HCl, HBr and HI, the overall proton-transfer equilibria in dilute water lie much farther towards ionized products.
Thus, HF is weak relative to the other common hydrogen halides despite fluorine's greater electronegativity.
The acid-strength comparison cannot be explained solely by the polarity of the H–X bond.
Bond strength, solvation and the overall free-energy change of proton transfer must also be considered.
This is why HF can exhibit the highest normal boiling point among the four hydrogen halides while behaving as the weakest aqueous acid of the series.
72. Sodium chloride and sodium iodide contain the same monovalent metal cation. Consider their idealized ionic-lattice attraction and the reducing tendencies of their halide ions under standard aqueous conditions. Which pair of comparisons is consistent with both trends?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{NaI}\) has stronger ionic attraction than \(\mathrm{NaCl}\), while \(\mathrm{I^-}\) is more resistant to oxidation than \(\mathrm{Cl^-}\).
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{NaCl}\) has stronger ionic attraction than \(\mathrm{NaI}\), while \(\mathrm{I^-}\) is more readily oxidized than \(\mathrm{Cl^-}\).
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{NaCl}\) has weaker ionic attraction than \(\mathrm{NaI}\), while \(\mathrm{Cl^-}\) is more readily oxidized than \(\mathrm{I^-}\).
ⓓ. \(\mathrm{NaI}\) has stronger ionic attraction than \(\mathrm{NaCl}\), while \(\mathrm{Cl^-}\) is more readily oxidized than \(\mathrm{I^-}\).
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{NaCl}\) has stronger ionic attraction than \(\mathrm{NaI}\), while \(\mathrm{I^-}\) is more readily oxidized than \(\mathrm{Cl^-}\).
Explanation: \(\textbf{Compare ionic-lattice attraction:}\)
Both sodium chloride and sodium iodide contain \(\mathrm{Na^+}\) ions.
Their anions, \(\mathrm{Cl^-}\) and \(\mathrm{I^-}\), carry the same magnitude of negative charge.
Consequently, a first comparison of idealized electrostatic lattice attraction can focus on ionic size.
Chloride is smaller than iodide because chlorine occupies a higher position in Group 17.
For a given cation and equal ionic charges, a smaller anion generally permits shorter cation–anion separations.
Shorter separations strengthen Coulombic attraction.
Therefore, the electrostatic lattice attraction is stronger in sodium chloride than in sodium iodide.
This comparison concerns the lattice contribution and should not automatically be treated as a complete prediction of aqueous solubility.
\(\textbf{Compare the reducing tendencies:}\)
The reducing tendency of a halide ion concerns its ability to lose electrons.
The general oxidation half-reaction is:
\[
\mathrm{2X^-\rightarrow X_2+2e^-}
\]
Under standard aqueous conditions, iodide is more readily oxidized than chloride.
This corresponds to the fact that iodine is a much weaker oxidizing agent than chlorine.
The reducing strength of the halide ions therefore broadly increases down Group 17.
\(\textbf{Reconcile the two comparisons:}\)
Lattice attraction depends strongly on ionic charge and separation.
Aqueous reducing tendency depends on the overall free-energy change of electron transfer, including the chemical environment.
Thus, a larger iodide ion can participate in a less strongly attracted sodium-halide lattice while simultaneously being more readily oxidized in aqueous solution.
The correct conclusion requires applying two different principles rather than using ionic size as a universal explanation for every property.
73. Four monatomic ions are known to possess eighteen electrons each: \(\mathrm{S^{2-}}\), \(\mathrm{Cl^-}\), \(\mathrm{K^+}\) and \(\mathrm{Ca^{2+}}\). Consider their relative ionic radii using a consistent ionic-radius convention. Which decreasing order is expected?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{Ca^{2+}\gt K^+\gt Cl^-\gt S^{2-}}\)
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{Cl^-\gt S^{2-}\gt K^+\gt Ca^{2+}}\)
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{S^{2-}\gt K^+\gt Cl^-\gt Ca^{2+}}\)
ⓓ. \(\mathrm{S^{2-}\gt Cl^-\gt K^+\gt Ca^{2+}}\)
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{S^{2-}\gt Cl^-\gt K^+\gt Ca^{2+}}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Verify the electron counts:}\)
Sulphur has atomic number \(16\).
The sulphide ion gains two electrons, giving eighteen electrons.
Chlorine has atomic number \(17\).
The chloride ion gains one electron, also giving eighteen electrons.
Potassium has atomic number \(19\).
The potassium ion loses one electron, leaving eighteen electrons.
Calcium has atomic number \(20\).
The calcium ion loses two electrons, again leaving eighteen electrons.
Thus, all four ions possess the argon electronic configuration.
\(\textbf{Identify the controlling variable:}\)
An isoelectronic series contains species with the same number of electrons.
Their electron configurations are comparable, but their nuclear charges are different.
The number of protons increases in the sequence sulphur, chlorine, potassium and calcium.
For an isoelectronic series, increasing nuclear charge generally pulls the same number of electrons closer to the nucleus.
Consequently, ionic radius decreases with increasing nuclear charge.
\(\textbf{Apply the comparison:}\)
Sulphide has sixteen protons attracting eighteen electrons and is the largest ion in the series.
Chloride has seventeen protons and is smaller than sulphide.
Potassium ion has nineteen protons and is smaller than chloride.
Calcium ion has twenty protons and is the smallest.
The resulting decreasing order is:
\[
\mathrm{S^{2-}\gt Cl^-\gt K^+\gt Ca^{2+}}
\]
It would be incorrect to rank these ions simply according to the atomic radii of their neutral parent elements.
Ion formation changes the electron count and may change the occupied outer shell.
The valid comparison here is possible because the four specified ions are isoelectronic.
This also shows why a Group 17 anion such as chloride can be compared meaningfully with ions from neighbouring groups when their electron configurations are first established.
74. The standard reduction potentials for selected halogen couples are supplied below.
| Reduction half-reaction | \(E^\circ_{\mathrm{red}}\) (V) |
| \(\mathrm{Cl_2+2e^-\rightarrow 2Cl^-}\) | +1.36 |
| \(\mathrm{Br_2+2e^-\rightarrow 2Br^-}\) | +1.07 |
| \(\mathrm{I_2+2e^-\rightarrow 2I^-}\) | +0.54 |
At standard conditions, chlorine is separately brought into contact with iodide ions, and bromine is separately brought into contact with chloride ions. Which conclusion correctly identifies the thermodynamically favourable reaction and its standard cell potential?
ⓐ. Chlorine oxidizes iodide, with \(E^\circ_{\mathrm{cell}}=+0.82\,\mathrm{V}\); bromine cannot favourably oxidize chloride.
ⓑ. Bromine oxidizes chloride, with \(E^\circ_{\mathrm{cell}}=+0.29\,\mathrm{V}\); chlorine cannot favourably oxidize iodide.
ⓒ. Chlorine oxidizes iodide, with \(E^\circ_{\mathrm{cell}}=+1.90\,\mathrm{V}\); bromine cannot favourably oxidize chloride.
ⓓ. Both reactions are favourable; their standard cell potentials are \(+0.82\,\mathrm{V}\) and \(+0.29\,\mathrm{V}\), respectively.
Correct Answer: Chlorine oxidizes iodide, with \(E^\circ_{\mathrm{cell}}=+0.82\,\mathrm{V}\); bromine cannot favourably oxidize chloride.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the competing redox processes:}\)
A molecular halogen undergoes reduction when it gains electrons.
A halide ion undergoes oxidation when it loses electrons.
For a proposed displacement reaction, the standard cell potential is obtained from the reduction potentials:
\[
E^\circ_{\mathrm{cell}}=E^\circ_{\mathrm{red,cathode}}-E^\circ_{\mathrm{red,anode}}
\]
The anode value is written as its reduction potential in this formula.
\(\textbf{Evaluate chlorine with iodide:}\)
Chlorine undergoes reduction:
\[
\mathrm{Cl_2+2e^-\rightarrow 2Cl^-}
\]
Iodide undergoes oxidation:
\[
\mathrm{2I^-\rightarrow I_2+2e^-}
\]
The overall reaction is:
\[
\mathrm{Cl_2+2I^-\rightarrow 2Cl^-+I_2}
\]
Substitution gives:
\[
E^\circ_{\mathrm{cell}}=1.36-0.54
\]
\[
E^\circ_{\mathrm{cell}}=+0.82\,\mathrm{V}
\]
The positive potential indicates that the reaction is thermodynamically favourable under standard conditions.
\(\textbf{Evaluate bromine with chloride:}\)
For the proposed reaction:
\[
\mathrm{Br_2+2Cl^-\rightarrow 2Br^-+Cl_2}
\]
Bromine is the species being reduced and chloride is the species being oxidized.
Therefore:
\[
E^\circ_{\mathrm{cell}}=1.07-1.36
\]
\[
E^\circ_{\mathrm{cell}}=-0.29\,\mathrm{V}
\]
The negative potential indicates that this proposed forward reaction is not thermodynamically favourable under standard conditions.
\(\textbf{Interpret the chemistry:}\)
Chlorine is a stronger oxidizing agent than both bromine and iodine.
It can therefore oxidize iodide under suitable conditions.
Bromine is weaker than chlorine as an oxidizing agent and cannot ordinarily oxidize chloride to chlorine under the stated standard conditions.
The comparison illustrates how the general Group 17 oxidizing-strength trend is represented quantitatively by standard reduction potentials.
A favourable potential does not independently establish the speed of a reaction.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{E^\circ_{\mathrm{cell}}(\mathrm{Cl_2/2I^-})=+0.82\,\mathrm{V}}
\]
Only the chlorine–iodide reaction is thermodynamically favourable in the indicated forward direction.
75. Molecular bromine, \(\mathrm{Br_2}\), is non-polar and has a normal boiling point of approximately \(59^\circ\mathrm{C}\). Hydrogen chloride, \(\mathrm{HCl}\), is polar but has a normal boiling point near \(-85^\circ\mathrm{C}\). At \(25^\circ\mathrm{C}\) and \(1\,\mathrm{atm}\), bromine is liquid while hydrogen chloride is gaseous. Which conclusion correctly explains this difference?
ⓐ. A polar molecule must always have a higher boiling point than any non-polar molecule.
ⓑ. Bromine is liquid because Br–Br covalent bonds are broken during condensation, whereas H–Cl bonds remain intact.
ⓒ. Bromine's highly polarizable cloud gives stronger dispersion interactions than those in HCl.
ⓓ. Hydrogen chloride has a lower boiling point because the H–Cl bond is non-polar and its molecules have no intermolecular attraction.
Correct Answer: Bromine's highly polarizable cloud gives stronger dispersion interactions than those in HCl.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Distinguish molecular polarity:}\)
Bromine is a homonuclear diatomic molecule.
Its two atoms have equal electronegativity, so the molecule has no permanent dipole moment.
Hydrogen chloride is a heteronuclear diatomic molecule with a significant electronegativity difference between hydrogen and chlorine.
Therefore, HCl possesses a permanent molecular dipole.
However, molecular polarity is not the only factor affecting boiling point.
\(\textbf{Examine the bromine molecule:}\)
A bromine molecule contains many more electrons than an HCl molecule.
Its electron cloud is relatively large and highly polarizable.
Temporary fluctuations in the electron distribution produce instantaneous dipoles.
These induce corresponding dipoles in neighbouring molecules, generating London dispersion attractions.
The dispersion interactions between bromine molecules are sufficiently strong to give bromine a much higher boiling point than HCl.
\(\textbf{Examine hydrogen chloride:}\)
HCl molecules experience dipole–dipole attractions as well as dispersion forces.
Nevertheless, the smaller and less polarizable HCl molecules experience weaker overall intermolecular cohesion than bromine molecules under comparable conditions.
Consequently, HCl has a much lower boiling point.
At \(25^\circ\mathrm{C}\), the temperature lies below bromine's boiling point but far above HCl's boiling point.
This explains why bromine can be liquid while HCl is gaseous.
Neither ordinary condensation nor boiling requires breaking the Br–Br or H–Cl covalent bonds.
The observation demonstrates that a non-polar molecule can have a higher boiling point than a polar molecule when its dispersion interactions are sufficiently strong.
Thus, intermolecular-force magnitude must be evaluated rather than inferred from molecular polarity alone.
76. Sodium chloride and anhydrous aluminium chloride both contain chlorine formally in oxidation state \(-1\). However, ordinary crystalline sodium chloride is predominantly ionic, while anhydrous aluminium chloride exhibits considerable covalent character. Which explanation correctly accounts for this difference?
ⓐ. Chlorine has seven valence electrons in sodium chloride but only five valence electrons in aluminium chloride.
ⓑ. Small, highly charged \(\mathrm{Al^{3+}}\) polarizes chloride more strongly than sodium does.
ⓒ. Sodium chloride is ionic because chlorine has oxidation state \(-1\), whereas aluminium chloride must contain chlorine in oxidation state +1.
ⓓ. Aluminium chloride is covalent because aluminium belongs to the d-block, whereas sodium belongs to the s-block.
Correct Answer: Small, highly charged \(\mathrm{Al^{3+}}\) polarizes chloride more strongly than sodium does.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Establish the common chlorine feature:}\)
Chlorine belongs to Group 17 and possesses seven valence electrons in its neutral atom.
It commonly exhibits oxidation state \(-1\) when combined with sufficiently electropositive elements.
This formal oxidation state applies to chlorine in both sodium chloride and aluminium chloride.
However, an oxidation-state assignment does not by itself determine the actual bonding character.
\(\textbf{Compare the positive centres:}\)
Sodium commonly forms a monovalent \(\mathrm{Na^+}\) ion.
Its relatively low positive charge and larger ionic size give it a lower polarizing influence on chloride electron density.
Ordinary sodium chloride therefore forms a predominantly ionic lattice.
Aluminium commonly exhibits oxidation state +3.
The aluminium(III) centre has a higher positive charge and a relatively small ionic radius.
This produces a high polarizing power.
The electron cloud associated with a chloride ion can consequently be distorted strongly in the presence of an aluminium(III) centre.
Such polarization favours increased covalent character in the bonding.
\(\textbf{Connect the reasoning with the observed substances:}\)
Anhydrous aluminium chloride exhibits considerable covalent character and can form molecular species under appropriate conditions.
Sodium chloride retains predominantly ionic lattice character under ordinary conditions.
The difference does not require chlorine to possess different numbers of valence electrons in the two compounds.
Nor does it require a positive oxidation state for chlorine in aluminium chloride.
The comparison illustrates why the chemical behaviour of a Group 17 element depends on the nature and polarizing power of its bonding partner.
It also shows why oxidation state, ionic charge and covalent character must be treated as related but distinct concepts.
77. A neutral chlorine atom readily accepts one electron in the gas phase with release of energy, but the hypothetical addition of a second electron to gaseous \(\mathrm{Cl^-}\) is highly unfavourable. Which explanation best connects these observations with the characteristic oxidation state of Group 17 elements?
ⓐ. The first addition completes \(3p\), while a second electron enters a higher shell against anionic repulsion.
ⓑ. The first electron enters the \(3d\) subshell, while the second enters the \(3p\) subshell and destroys the chlorine octet.
ⓒ. The first electron removes the outermost \(3s^2\) pair, while the second restores the original neutral chlorine configuration.
ⓓ. Both electron additions are equally favourable because chlorine possesses seven electrons in its outermost shell.
Correct Answer: The first addition completes \(3p\), while a second electron enters a higher shell against anionic repulsion.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Examine the neutral atomic configuration:}\)
Chlorine has atomic number \(17\) and the electronic configuration \([\mathrm{Ne}]\,3s^23p^5\).
It possesses seven electrons in its outermost shell.
The \(3p\) subshell contains five electrons and can accommodate a maximum of six.
Therefore, one additional electron can complete this subshell.
The first electron-attachment process is:
\[
\mathrm{Cl(g)+e^-\rightarrow Cl^-(g)}
\]
The first electron-gain enthalpy of chlorine is negative, so energy is released in this process.
\(\textbf{Determine the configuration after electron gain:}\)
The chloride ion possesses eighteen electrons and has the argon electronic configuration.
Its outermost shell is now complete:
\[
\mathrm{Cl^-:[Ne]\,3s^23p^6}
\]
The \(3s\) and \(3p\) subshells can accommodate no additional electrons.
\(\textbf{Consider the second electron attachment:}\)
The hypothetical second electron would have to occupy a higher-energy available orbital beyond the filled \(n=3\) valence shell.
It would also approach an ion that already carries a negative charge.
Strong electrostatic repulsion would oppose its addition.
Consequently, formation of an isolated gaseous \(\mathrm{Cl^{2-}}\) ion through this process is energetically very unfavourable.
This helps explain why the mononegative oxidation state is characteristic of halogens.
The favourable first electron-gain process is associated with completion of an outer electron shell, whereas the second does not provide the same closed-shell advantage.
However, the characteristic \(-1\) oxidation state does not mean halogens are restricted to ionic bonding in every compound.
Chlorine can also form covalent compounds and exhibit positive oxidation states with suitable more electronegative partners.
Thus, the first and second electron-attachment processes must be distinguished both electronically and energetically.
78. Helium has the electronic configuration \(1s^2\), while beryllium has the outermost configuration \(2s^2\) and neon has \(2s^22p^6\). Although helium and beryllium both possess two outermost electrons, helium is placed in Group 18 rather than Group 2. Which explanation correctly accounts for this classification?
ⓐ. Helium and beryllium both possess complete valence shells, but helium has the smaller atomic radius.
ⓑ. Helium is placed in Group 18 because its outermost electrons occupy a \(p\) subshell, as in neon.
ⓒ. Helium belongs to Group 18 because all elements with two valence electrons are chemically inert.
ⓓ. Helium possesses a completely filled first shell, whereas beryllium has an incomplete second shell with available \(2p\) orbitals.
Correct Answer: Helium possesses a completely filled first shell, whereas beryllium has an incomplete second shell with available \(2p\) orbitals.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Compare the electronic configurations:}\)
Helium has only two electrons, both occupying the \(1s\) orbital.
The first principal shell contains only the \(1s\) orbital and can accommodate a maximum of two electrons.
Therefore, helium has a completely filled valence shell.
Beryllium has the configuration \(1s^22s^2\).
Although its outermost \(2s\) subshell is filled, the \(2p\) subshell belonging to the same principal shell remains vacant.
Hence, beryllium does not possess a completely filled second principal shell.
\(\textbf{Connect configuration with chemical behaviour:}\)
Helium has an exceptionally high first ionization enthalpy and very little tendency to participate in ordinary chemical bonding.
Its chemical behaviour is characteristic of the noble gases.
Beryllium, by contrast, forms compounds and exhibits the characteristic chemistry of Group 2 elements.
Neon has the closed-shell configuration \(1s^22s^22p^6\), which is also associated with very low chemical reactivity.
The similarity between helium and neon therefore arises from complete valence-shell occupancy rather than identical subshell configurations.
Helium is the exceptional Group 18 member with a \(1s^2\) configuration instead of the usual \(ns^2np^6\) arrangement.
Thus, periodic classification must consider electronic-shell completion and chemical behaviour rather than the number of outermost electrons alone.
79. Chlorine and argon are consecutive Period 3 elements with ground-state configurations \([\mathrm{Ne}]\,3s^23p^5\) and \([\mathrm{Ne}]\,3s^23p^6\), respectively. Electron attachment to an isolated gaseous chlorine atom is strongly exothermic, whereas electron attachment to an isolated gaseous argon atom is energetically unfavourable. Which explanation best reconciles these observations?
ⓐ. Argon has fewer valence electrons than chlorine, so its electron-gain enthalpy is necessarily more positive.
ⓑ. Chlorine gains an electron into its \(3d\) subshell, whereas argon gains an electron into its \(3p\) subshell.
ⓒ. Electron gain completes chlorine's \(3p\) shell; argon would place an electron beyond its closed shell.
ⓓ. Argon cannot accept an electron because an atom with a completely filled shell has no vacant orbital at any higher energy.
Correct Answer: Electron gain completes chlorine's \(3p\) shell; argon would place an electron beyond its closed shell.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Examine the chlorine configuration:}\)
Chlorine belongs to Group 17 and has seven valence electrons.
Its outermost configuration is \(3s^23p^5\).
The \(3p\) subshell can accommodate six electrons, so chlorine has space for one additional electron within its valence shell.
Electron attachment produces:
\[
\mathrm{Cl(g)+e^-\rightarrow Cl^-(g)}
\]
The chloride ion has the configuration \([\mathrm{Ne}]\,3s^23p^6\).
Formation of this closed-shell arrangement is energetically favourable, giving chlorine a strongly negative first electron-gain enthalpy.
\(\textbf{Examine the argon configuration:}\)
Argon already possesses the completely filled configuration \(3s^23p^6\).
An additional electron cannot enter the filled \(3s\) or \(3p\) subshell.
It would have to occupy a higher-energy available orbital, beginning with the next principal shell.
The electron would not gain the stabilization associated with completing an initially incomplete valence shell.
Consequently, ordinary electron attachment to isolated gaseous argon is energetically unfavourable.
This difference does not mean that argon has no available orbitals whatsoever.
It means that the available orbitals are energetically unsuitable for favourable ordinary electron attachment.
Thus, two consecutive elements can have markedly different electron-gain tendencies because one is approaching a closed shell while the other already possesses one.
80. The following approximate atomic-radius data have been collected using different measurement conventions.
| Element | Reported radius | Radius definition |
| Chlorine | \(99\,\mathrm{pm}\) | Covalent radius |
| Argon | \(188\,\mathrm{pm}\) | van der Waals radius |
| Krypton | \(202\,\mathrm{pm}\) | van der Waals radius |
| Xenon | \(216\,\mathrm{pm}\) | van der Waals radius |
A student concludes that argon must have an intrinsically larger atomic size than chlorine by the factor \(188/99\), and that the noble-gas radii increase down Group 18. Which assessment is scientifically justified?
ⓐ. The chlorine–argon comparison is not directly valid, whereas the increasing Group 18 trend is supported by radii defined consistently.
ⓑ. The chlorine–argon comparison is valid, but the Group 18 comparison is invalid because noble gases are monatomic.
ⓒ. Both conclusions are valid because covalent and van der Waals radii use identical atomic boundaries.
ⓓ. Neither conclusion is valid because atoms without ordinary covalent bonds cannot be assigned any atomic radius.
Correct Answer: The chlorine–argon comparison is not directly valid, whereas the increasing Group 18 trend is supported by radii defined consistently.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the measurement distinction:}\)
A covalent radius is generally derived from the distance between nuclei of covalently bonded atoms.
For two identical bonded atoms, the covalent radius is approximately half the corresponding internuclear bond distance.
A van der Waals radius is associated with the closest characteristic approach of non-bonded atoms.
The two radii are therefore determined using different physical situations.
The reported chlorine value is a covalent radius, whereas the reported argon value is a van der Waals radius.
Consequently, the numerical ratio \(188/99\) cannot be interpreted directly as the ratio of two identically defined atomic sizes.
Such a comparison confuses a change in measurement convention with a genuine periodic-property difference.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the down-group trend:}\)
The radii of argon, krypton and xenon have all been reported using the van der Waals convention.
These values are therefore suitable for a consistent comparison.
The supplied radii increase from argon to krypton to xenon.
This is consistent with the occupation of successively higher principal shells down Group 18.
Increasing electron-cloud extent and shielding generally contribute to larger atomic size.
Noble gases can be assigned van der Waals radii despite their weak tendency to form ordinary covalent bonds.
The correct interpretation accepts the consistently measured down-group trend while rejecting the direct comparison of unlike radius definitions.
81. The first ionization enthalpies of four noble gases are given below.
| Element | First ionization enthalpy \((\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}})\) |
| Ne | 2081 |
| Ar | 1521 |
| Kr | 1351 |
| Xe | 1170 |
Xenon forms certain stable compounds under suitable conditions, whereas neon is exceptionally unreactive. Which conclusion best connects these observations with the data?
ⓐ. Xenon has fewer valence electrons than neon, making electron removal easier.
ⓑ. Xenon's larger and less strongly bound electron cloud allows greater chemical participation.
ⓒ. Neon possesses a partially filled \(2p\) subshell, whereas xenon has a completely filled \(5p\) subshell.
ⓓ. A lower first ionization enthalpy guarantees that xenon forms compounds with every element under ordinary conditions.
Correct Answer: Xenon's larger and less strongly bound electron cloud allows greater chemical participation.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Establish the common electronic feature:}\)
Neon, argon, krypton and xenon belong to Group 18.
Their general outermost configuration is \(ns^2np^6\).
Therefore, all four possess complete valence shells with eight outermost electrons.
The difference in their chemical behaviour cannot be attributed to xenon having fewer valence electrons.
\(\textbf{Interpret the ionization-enthalpy trend:}\)
The supplied values decrease from neon to xenon.
Down the group, the outermost electrons occupy successively higher principal shells.
Atomic size and shielding generally increase, reducing the effective attraction experienced by the outermost electrons.
Consequently, removal of an electron becomes energetically less demanding.
Xenon's first ionization enthalpy is substantially lower than neon's.
\(\textbf{Connect the trend with chemical reactivity:}\)
Xenon also has a larger and more polarizable electron cloud.
Under suitable conditions, strong bonding with highly electronegative elements can stabilize compounds containing xenon in positive oxidation states.
Neon's much higher ionization enthalpy and smaller, less polarizable electron cloud make comparable chemical interactions considerably less favourable.
Nevertheless, xenon's lower ionization enthalpy does not imply unrestricted reactivity.
Compound formation depends on the complete energetic balance of bond formation and bond disruption.
Thus, noble-gas chemical inertness is a strong general tendency, not an absolute prohibition against compound formation.
82. The approximate normal melting and boiling points of four noble gases at \(1\,\mathrm{atm}\) are supplied below.
| Noble gas | Melting point (K) | Boiling point (K) |
| Ne | 24.6 | 27.1 |
| Ar | 83.8 | 87.3 |
| Kr | 115.8 | 119.9 |
| Xe | 161.4 | 165.0 |
Pure samples are maintained at \(100\,\mathrm{K}\) and \(1\,\mathrm{atm}\) until equilibrium is established. Which option correctly predicts their physical states and identifies the principal cause of the transition-temperature trend?
ⓐ. Ne and Ar are gases; Kr and Xe are solids; increasing polarizability strengthens dispersion attractions.
ⓑ. Ne and Ar are liquids; Kr and Xe are solids; decreasing ionization enthalpy directly forms metallic bonds.
ⓒ. Ne and Kr are gases; Ar and Xe are solids; increasing electronegativity strengthens permanent dipoles.
ⓓ. Ne and Ar are gases; Kr and Xe are liquids; increasing atomic size produces stronger covalent bonds.
Correct Answer: Ne and Ar are gases; Kr and Xe are solids; increasing polarizability strengthens dispersion attractions.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the equilibrium states:}\)
At the stated pressure, a pure substance is normally gaseous above its boiling point.
It is solid below its melting point and liquid between its melting and boiling points.
The specified temperature is \(100\,\mathrm{K}\).
Neon boils at approximately \(27.1\,\mathrm{K}\), which is far below the specified temperature.
Therefore, neon is gaseous.
Argon boils at approximately \(87.3\,\mathrm{K}\), so it is also gaseous at \(100\,\mathrm{K}\).
Krypton melts at approximately \(115.8\,\mathrm{K}\), which is above the specified temperature.
Consequently, krypton remains solid.
Xenon melts at approximately \(161.4\,\mathrm{K}\), so it also remains solid.
\(\textbf{Explain the trend in phase-transition temperatures:}\)
Noble gases exist as monatomic substances under ordinary conditions.
Their atoms do not possess permanent molecular dipole moments.
The principal attractive interactions between neutral noble-gas atoms are London dispersion forces.
Down Group 18, atomic electron clouds become larger and more polarizable.
Temporary fluctuations in these electron clouds produce increasingly strong induced-dipole attractions.
More energy is therefore required to separate the atoms in the condensed phases.
This explains the broad increase in melting and boiling points down the group.
The trend does not require noble-gas atoms to form ordinary covalent or metallic bonds with one another.
Thus, the phase predictions and their intermolecular-force explanation are consistent with the supplied data.
83. A sealed vessel contains pure argon at a temperature well above its normal boiling point. The vessel is cooled sufficiently for some argon to condense into a liquid, without introducing any other substance. Which statement correctly distinguishes the physical change from argon's chemical behaviour?
ⓐ. Argon must form covalent \(\mathrm{Ar_2}\) molecules during condensation because a liquid requires chemical bonds.
ⓑ. Argon changes its outermost configuration from \(3s^23p^6\) to \(3s^23p^5\) during liquefaction.
ⓒ. Argon can condense only after acquiring an electron because the liquid phase requires negatively charged atoms.
ⓓ. Argon remains monatomic; at low temperature, dispersion attractions allow condensation.
Correct Answer: Argon remains monatomic; at low temperature, dispersion attractions allow condensation.
Explanation: Argon has the electronic configuration \([\mathrm{Ne}]\,3s^23p^6\).
Its outermost shell is completely filled, contributing to its very low ordinary chemical reactivity.
However, chemical unreactivity does not mean that the atoms experience no attractive forces.
Even a neutral atom with a spherically symmetric average electron distribution has an electron cloud that can fluctuate.
Such fluctuations produce temporary dipoles that can induce dipoles in neighbouring atoms.
The resulting London dispersion forces provide weak attractions between argon atoms.
\(\textbf{Interpret the cooling process:}\)
At sufficiently high temperatures, thermal motion prevents these attractions from maintaining a condensed phase at the specified pressure.
On cooling, the tendency of the atoms to remain associated becomes more important.
Argon can consequently condense into a liquid without forming ordinary covalent molecules.
The atoms remain individually identifiable within the condensed substance.
The electronic configuration of the neutral argon atom does not change simply because its physical state changes.
No electron transfer or oxidation-state change is required.
This is why a substance can be chemically unreactive yet possess definite melting and boiling temperatures.
The essential distinction is between weak interatomic attraction responsible for condensation and chemical bond formation that changes the identity of the species.
84. Xenon forms compounds such as \(\mathrm{XeF_2}\) and \(\mathrm{XeF_4}\) under suitable conditions. Fluorine has oxidation state \(-1\) in both compounds. Which conclusion correctly compares xenon's oxidation states with its ground-state electronic configuration?
ⓐ. Xenon is +1 in \(\mathrm{XeF_2}\) and +2 in \(\mathrm{XeF_4}\); it possesses an incomplete \(5p\) subshell.
ⓑ. Xenon is -2 in \(\mathrm{XeF_2}\) and -4 in \(\mathrm{XeF_4}\); it gains electrons from fluorine.
ⓒ. Xenon is +2 in \(\mathrm{XeF_2}\) and +4 in \(\mathrm{XeF_4}\), although its neutral atom initially has a closed valence shell.
ⓓ. Xenon is +2 in both compounds because a noble gas cannot exhibit more than one positive oxidation state.
Correct Answer: Xenon is +2 in \(\mathrm{XeF_2}\) and +4 in \(\mathrm{XeF_4}\), although its neutral atom initially has a closed valence shell.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Establish xenon's neutral configuration:}\)
Xenon belongs to Group 18 and has atomic number \(54\).
Its outermost electronic configuration is \(5s^25p^6\).
Therefore, the neutral xenon atom possesses eight valence electrons and a complete outer shell.
However, a closed-shell configuration does not make all chemical interactions energetically impossible.
\(\textbf{Determine the formal oxidation states:}\)
Fluorine is more electronegative than xenon and is assigned oxidation state \(-1\) in its compounds.
For \(\mathrm{XeF_2}\), the oxidation-state balance is:
\[
x+2(-1)=0
\]
\[
x=+2
\]
Thus, xenon has oxidation state +2.
For \(\mathrm{XeF_4}\):
\[
y+4(-1)=0
\]
\[
y=+4
\]
Xenon therefore has oxidation state +4 in the second compound.
\(\textbf{Explain the apparent exception to inertness:}\)
Xenon has a lower ionization enthalpy and greater polarizability than the lighter noble gases.
Strong bonding with fluorine can stabilize compounds containing xenon in positive formal oxidation states.
These oxidation-state values do not imply that the neutral xenon atom originally possessed vacancies in its \(5p\) subshell.
Nor do they require the existence of free \(\mathrm{Xe^{2+}}\) or \(\mathrm{Xe^{4+}}\) ions in the molecular compounds.
The oxidation states are formal electron-accounting assignments based on bonding.
Their existence demonstrates that Group 18 elements are generally unreactive rather than universally incapable of forming compounds.
The correct comparison is xenon +2 in \(\mathrm{XeF_2}\) and +4 in \(\mathrm{XeF_4}\).
85. Argon and xenon are treated as ideal monatomic gases at the same temperature and pressure. Their molar masses are approximately \(40.0\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}\) and \(131.3\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}\), respectively. What is the approximate ratio of the mass density of xenon to that of argon under these conditions?
ⓐ. \(0.305\)
ⓑ. \(3.28\)
ⓒ. \(1.81\)
ⓓ. \(10.8\)
Correct Answer: \(3.28\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the common physical conditions:}\)
Both argon and xenon are Group 18 elements.
Under ordinary gas-phase conditions, they exist as monatomic gases.
The problem specifies the same temperature and pressure for both samples.
It also specifies ideal-gas behaviour, so the ideal-gas relation can be applied consistently.
\(\textbf{Relate density to molar mass:}\)
The ideal-gas equation is:
\[
PV=nRT
\]
The number of moles is related to mass by:
\[
n=\frac{m}{M}
\]
Substituting this relation:
\[
PV=\frac{m}{M}RT
\]
Rearranging:
\[
\frac{m}{V}=\frac{PM}{RT}
\]
Since mass density is \(\rho=m/V\):
\[
\rho=\frac{PM}{RT}
\]
\(\textbf{Compare the two gases:}\)
At identical pressure and temperature, the factor \(P/(RT)\) is the same.
Therefore, the density ratio equals the molar-mass ratio.
\[
\frac{\rho_{\mathrm{Xe}}}{\rho_{\mathrm{Ar}}}
=\frac{M_{\mathrm{Xe}}}{M_{\mathrm{Ar}}}
\]
Substitution gives:
\[
\frac{\rho_{\mathrm{Xe}}}{\rho_{\mathrm{Ar}}}
=\frac{131.3}{40.0}
\]
\[
=3.2825
\]
\(\textbf{Check the interpretation:}\)
Xenon has the greater molar mass, so it should have the greater mass density under identical ideal-gas conditions.
The calculated ratio is dimensionless because the molar-mass units cancel.
The result concerns the mass of gas occupying a specified volume, not the intrinsic size of a single atom.
A larger molar mass also does not directly establish a proportionally larger atomic radius.
The two gases can have different densities while sharing the same general closed-shell electronic configuration.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\frac{\rho_{\mathrm{Xe}}}{\rho_{\mathrm{Ar}}}\approx3.28}
\]
86. Consider the following Assertion and Reason.
Assertion (A): Xenon is more readily polarized by an external electric field than neon, despite both atoms having completely filled valence shells.
Reason (R): Xenon has a larger and more diffuse electron cloud, making its electron distribution more readily distorted.
Choose the correct option.
ⓐ. Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
ⓑ. Both A and R are true, but R does not correctly explain A.
ⓒ. A is true, but R is false.
ⓓ. A is false, but R is true.
Correct Answer: Both A and R are true, and R correctly explains A.
Explanation: The assertion is correct because atomic polarizability generally increases down Group 18.
Polarizability describes how readily the electron distribution of an atom can be distorted by an external electric field or a neighbouring charge distribution.
Neon has a relatively compact electron cloud.
Its electrons experience strong nuclear attraction and are comparatively resistant to distortion.
Xenon contains many more electrons distributed through additional principal shells.
Its outer electron cloud extends farther from the nucleus.
The electron distribution is therefore more readily distorted.
\(\textbf{Connect the effect with closed-shell character:}\)
Both neon and xenon possess the outermost configuration \(ns^2np^6\).
A complete valence shell does not imply that the atom's electron cloud is perfectly rigid.
Neutral noble-gas atoms can develop induced dipole moments without undergoing electron transfer or ordinary chemical bonding.
The greater polarizability of xenon contributes to stronger dispersion attractions between xenon atoms.
This is consistent with xenon's much higher boiling point compared with neon.
The same increasing electron-cloud flexibility can also influence interactions with strongly electronegative bonding partners.
However, polarizability alone does not establish that every chemical reaction will occur.
The reason correctly identifies the physical cause of xenon's greater polarizability.
Therefore, both statements are true, and the reason correctly explains the assertion.
87. The following data are available for three consecutive elements near the end of Period 3 and the beginning of Period 4.
| Element | Atomic number | First ionization enthalpy \((\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}})\) |
| Cl | 17 | 1251 |
| Ar | 18 | 1521 |
| K | 19 | 419 |
Which explanation correctly accounts for the sharp decrease in first ionization enthalpy from argon to potassium, despite the increase in atomic number?
ⓐ. Potassium has fewer total electrons than argon, so its outermost electron experiences weaker nuclear attraction.
ⓑ. Argon's \(3p\) subshell is partially occupied, whereas potassium completes the same subshell by losing an electron.
ⓒ. Potassium's differentiating electron enters an inner shell, producing greater shielding than argon.
ⓓ. Potassium begins a new principal shell with a \(4s^1\) electron, whereas argon has a completed \(3s^23p^6\) valence shell.
Correct Answer: Potassium begins a new principal shell with a \(4s^1\) electron, whereas argon has a completed \(3s^23p^6\) valence shell.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the relevant electronic configurations:}\)
Chlorine has the outermost configuration \(3s^23p^5\).
Argon has the completed valence-shell configuration \(3s^23p^6\).
Potassium has the configuration \([\mathrm{Ar}]\,4s^1\).
Therefore, the differentiating electron in potassium occupies the fourth principal shell rather than continuing to occupy the third shell.
\(\textbf{Explain argon's high ionization enthalpy:}\)
Argon's valence shell is completely filled.
Its outer electrons experience relatively strong effective nuclear attraction within the compact third principal shell.
Removal of an electron would disrupt this closed-shell arrangement.
Consequently, argon has a high first ionization enthalpy.
\(\textbf{Explain the decrease at potassium:}\)
The outermost electron of potassium occupies the \(4s\) orbital.
This electron is farther from the nucleus and is shielded by the completed inner argon-like core.
Although potassium has one additional proton, the increased shell distance and shielding substantially reduce the attraction experienced by its outermost electron.
As a result, removing the \(4s\) electron requires much less energy.
Electron loss produces \(\mathrm{K^+}\), which possesses the argon electronic configuration.
Thus, the decrease in ionization enthalpy does not contradict the increase in atomic number.
It reflects the beginning of a new period and a new principal shell.
The comparison illustrates why ionization enthalpy generally rises towards the noble gas at the end of a period and falls sharply on entering the next period.
88. A noble gas X forms a stable fluoride under suitable conditions, while another noble gas Y shows extremely little ordinary chemical reactivity. Their first ionization enthalpies are approximately \(1170\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) and \(2081\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\), respectively. If X and Y are selected from xenon and neon, which conclusion is consistent with their configurations and chemical behaviour?
ⓐ. X is neon and Y is xenon because the larger first ionization enthalpy favours fluoride formation.
ⓑ. X is xenon and Y is neon because xenon's lower ionization enthalpy and greater polarizability permit stronger interactions with fluorine.
ⓒ. X is xenon and Y is neon because xenon has a partially filled \(5p\) subshell while neon has a complete \(2p\) subshell.
ⓓ. X is neon and Y is xenon because neon has a larger atomic size and more readily distorted electron cloud.
Correct Answer: X is xenon and Y is neon because xenon's lower ionization enthalpy and greater polarizability permit stronger interactions with fluorine.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the elements from the data:}\)
The first ionization enthalpy of neon is approximately \(2081\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\).
Xenon's corresponding value is approximately \(1170\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\).
Therefore, X corresponds to xenon and Y corresponds to neon.
Both elements belong to Group 18 and have completely filled outermost shells.
Neon's configuration is \(2s^22p^6\), whereas xenon's outermost configuration is \(5s^25p^6\).
\(\textbf{Interpret the chemical difference:}\)
Neon is smaller and its valence electrons are strongly attracted to the nucleus.
Its very high ionization enthalpy makes ordinary electron participation energetically difficult.
Xenon's outermost electrons occupy a higher principal shell.
Its electron cloud is larger and more polarizable.
The lower first ionization enthalpy makes electron participation less demanding than in neon.
Strong bonding with fluorine can stabilize certain xenon compounds.
This explains why xenon can exhibit chemical reactivity that is not characteristic of neon.
\(\textbf{Qualify the prediction:}\)
The existence of xenon fluorides does not mean that xenon behaves like a typical reactive non-metal.
Nor does it mean that a filled \(5p\) subshell must contain an unpaired electron before compound formation.
The initial electronic configuration remains closed-shell.
Chemical bonding becomes possible when the overall energetic consequences of the interaction are favourable.
Thus, xenon is X and neon is Y, with their differing reactivity linked to ionization enthalpy, atomic size and polarizability.
89. A neutral xenon atom is subjected to a sufficiently energetic process that removes one electron, producing \(\mathrm{Xe^+}\). Separately, a neutral caesium atom loses its single outermost \(6s\) electron to form \(\mathrm{Cs^+}\). Which statement correctly compares the electronic configurations of the resulting ions?
ⓐ. Both \(\mathrm{Xe^+}\) and \(\mathrm{Cs^+}\) have the xenon configuration because both parent atoms belong to Period 6.
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{Xe^+}\) has a complete \(5p^6\) subshell, whereas \(\mathrm{Cs^+}\) has a partially filled \(6s\) subshell.
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{Xe^+}\) has the outermost arrangement \(5s^25p^5\), whereas \(\mathrm{Cs^+}\) has the closed-shell xenon configuration.
ⓓ. Both ions have the outermost arrangement \(5s^25p^5\) because one electron is removed from each neutral atom.
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{Xe^+}\) has the outermost arrangement \(5s^25p^5\), whereas \(\mathrm{Cs^+}\) has the closed-shell xenon configuration.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Establish the neutral configurations:}\)
Xenon has atomic number \(54\).
Its outermost configuration is \(5s^25p^6\), corresponding to a complete valence shell.
Caesium has atomic number \(55\) and the configuration \([\mathrm{Xe}]\,6s^1\).
Thus, caesium contains a xenon-like inner core and one additional outermost electron.
\(\textbf{Follow electron removal from xenon:}\)
Formation of \(\mathrm{Xe^+}\) requires removal of an electron from the highest occupied valence subshell.
The resulting ion has the outermost configuration \(5s^25p^5\).
It therefore no longer possesses the completely filled \(5p^6\) subshell of neutral xenon.
The ionization process is energetically demanding because xenon initially has a closed valence shell.
\(\textbf{Follow electron removal from caesium:}\)
The outermost electron of caesium occupies the \(6s\) orbital.
Removal of this electron leaves the configuration \([\mathrm{Xe}]\).
Therefore, \(\mathrm{Cs^+}\) possesses the complete xenon electron configuration.
\(\textbf{Connect the result with ionization behaviour:}\)
Electron removal from xenon disrupts a closed shell.
Electron removal from caesium produces a closed-shell configuration.
This difference helps explain why caesium has a much lower first ionization enthalpy than xenon.
The comparison also demonstrates that removing one electron from neighbouring neutral atoms can produce ions with very different valence-shell occupancy.
Thus, the charge on an ion alone is insufficient to establish whether the ion possesses a noble-gas configuration.
90. A text-described graph compares the normal boiling points of helium, neon, argon, krypton and xenon.
The horizontal axis represents increasing atomic number from helium to xenon. The vertical axis represents normal boiling point in kelvin. Five plotted points rise monotonically from helium to xenon. The increase becomes progressively less uniform, but no point reverses the overall upward trend. The graph describes pure noble gases at the same external pressure.
Which interpretation correctly connects the graph with the atomic properties of the elements?
ⓐ. Increasing boiling point proves that noble gases progressively develop permanent molecular dipoles down the group.
ⓑ. Increasing boiling point proves that the covalent bond between two noble-gas atoms becomes stronger down the group.
ⓒ. Increasing boiling point must imply increasing first ionization enthalpy because both properties measure electron attraction by the nucleus.
ⓓ. Increasing boiling point is consistent with stronger dispersion interactions, even though first ionization enthalpy generally decreases down the group.
Correct Answer: Increasing boiling point is consistent with stronger dispersion interactions, even though first ionization enthalpy generally decreases down the group.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret the graph:}\)
The graph shows that the normal boiling points of noble gases generally increase from helium to xenon.
Because the substances are being compared at the same external pressure, their boiling temperatures provide a meaningful measure of their relative resistance to vaporization.
Noble gases exist as monatomic substances under ordinary conditions.
They do not consist of stable diatomic molecules held together by ordinary covalent bonds.
Their atoms also possess no permanent molecular dipole moments.
Therefore, the increasing boiling points cannot be explained by the formation of permanent dipoles or progressively stronger ordinary covalent bonds.
\(\textbf{Identify the relevant attractive interactions:}\)
The electron clouds of noble-gas atoms can undergo temporary fluctuations.
These fluctuations generate instantaneous dipoles that induce dipoles in neighbouring atoms.
Down Group 18, atomic size and polarizability generally increase.
Consequently, London dispersion interactions become stronger.
This raises the temperatures required for vaporization.
\(\textbf{Compare the independent atomic trend:}\)
First ionization enthalpy concerns the energy required to remove an electron from an isolated gaseous atom.
Down Group 18, increased principal-shell number and shielding generally reduce the attraction experienced by the outermost electrons.
The first ionization enthalpy therefore decreases.
There is no contradiction between increasing boiling point and decreasing ionization enthalpy because the two properties describe different processes.
Boiling involves separation of neutral atoms from a condensed phase, whereas ionization involves removal of an electron.
The graph is therefore consistent with increasing dispersion interactions and decreasing first ionization enthalpy down Group 18.
91. A discharge tube containing neon emits visible light when an appropriate electrical discharge is maintained. After the discharge stops, the gas returns to its ordinary electronic state without forming a new stable compound. Which interpretation correctly distinguishes electronic excitation from chemical reactivity?
ⓐ. Neon atoms can undergo electronic excitation and emit photons without forming ordinary chemical bonds or losing their noble-gas identity.
ⓑ. The visible emission proves that neon has permanently lost its closed-shell configuration and become chemically reactive.
ⓒ. The light must arise from the formation of \(\mathrm{Ne_2}\) molecules because isolated atoms cannot emit radiation.
ⓓ. The discharge converts neon into fluorine because both have electrons occupying the second principal shell.
Correct Answer: Neon atoms can undergo electronic excitation and emit photons without forming ordinary chemical bonds or losing their noble-gas identity.
Explanation: Neon has the ground-state electronic configuration \(1s^22s^22p^6\).
Its valence shell is completely filled, contributing to its extremely low ordinary chemical reactivity.
However, a closed-shell atom can absorb energy when the required energy is supplied.
During an electrical discharge, collisions involving energetic electrons can transfer energy to neon atoms.
Some neon atoms are thereby promoted into electronically excited states.
These excited states are not necessarily chemically stable species or new compounds.
When the excited electrons return to lower-energy states, the atoms can emit photons.
The emitted photon energies correspond to differences between allowed atomic energy levels.
\(\textbf{Distinguish excitation from compound formation:}\)
Electronic excitation changes the energy state of an atom.
Chemical compound formation involves a different process in which atoms become associated through chemical bonding.
Emission of characteristic radiation does not establish that neon has formed stable covalent molecules.
Nor does it mean that the element has been transformed into a different element.
Following relaxation, the atom can return to its original ground-state electronic configuration.
Thus, low chemical reactivity is compatible with excitation, de-excitation and light emission.
The observation illustrates why chemical inertness should not be confused with an inability to participate in physical energy-transfer processes.
92. The thallium(I) ion and the helium atom both contain an occupied outermost \(s^2\) subshell. Helium is exceptionally unreactive, whereas thallium(I) forms numerous chemical compounds. Which explanation correctly distinguishes the two electronic situations?
ⓐ. Helium's \(1s^2\) configuration is equivalent to thallium(I)'s \(6s^2\) configuration because both contain two electrons.
ⓑ. The \(6s^2\) pair in thallium(I) means that its entire sixth principal shell is completely filled, exactly as in helium.
ⓒ. Helium fills its first shell; the retained \(6s^2\) pair of Tl(I) does not make its full electronic structure helium-like.
ⓓ. Thallium(I) contains no inner-shell electrons, so its occupied \(6s\) subshell cannot contribute to electronic stability.
Correct Answer: Helium fills its first shell; the retained \(6s^2\) pair of Tl(I) does not make its full electronic structure helium-like.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Compare the occupied subshells:}\)
Helium contains only two electrons, both occupying the \(1s\) orbital.
The first principal shell has no \(p\) subshell and is complete when the \(1s\) orbital contains two electrons.
Therefore, helium possesses a genuinely closed first shell.
Thallium belongs to Group 13 and has the neutral-atom outermost configuration \(6s^26p^1\).
Formation of thallium(I) corresponds formally to removal of the \(6p\) electron.
The resulting ion retains the \(6s^2\) pair.
However, the sixth principal shell contains additional available orbitals beyond the occupied \(6s\) subshell.
Therefore, the thallium(I) configuration is not electronically identical to the closed first shell of helium.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the underlying stability concepts:}\)
Helium's exceptional stability arises from the complete occupation of its only electron shell together with strong nuclear attraction.
The relative stability of thallium(I) is associated with the inert-pair effect.
That effect makes participation of the \(6s^2\) electron pair relatively unfavourable.
It does not make the entire thallium(I) ion incapable of chemical interactions.
Thallium(I) can form compounds with suitable anions and participate in chemical reactions.
Thus, retention of an \(ns^2\) pair and possession of a completely filled valence shell are not interchangeable descriptions.
The comparison illustrates why the term inert pair must not be interpreted as giving a heavy p-block ion all the chemical properties of helium.
93. Three unknown noble gases P, Q and R have the following approximate properties.
| Property | P | Q | R |
| First ionization enthalpy \((\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}})\) | 2372 | 1521 | 1170 |
| Normal boiling point (K) | 4.2 | 87.3 | 165.0 |
| Ordinary chemical behaviour | Exceptionally unreactive | Very low reactivity | Can form certain stable compounds |
If P, Q and R are selected from helium, argon and xenon, which assignment and explanation are consistent with all three properties?
ⓐ. P = xenon, Q = argon, R = helium; ionization enthalpy increases with atomic size.
ⓑ. P = helium, Q = xenon, R = argon; polarizability decreases down Group 18.
ⓒ. P = argon, Q = helium, R = xenon; boiling point decreases as dispersion forces strengthen.
ⓓ. P, Q, R are He, Ar, Xe; ionization enthalpy falls but dispersion attractions rise with size.
Correct Answer: P, Q, R are He, Ar, Xe; ionization enthalpy falls but dispersion attractions rise with size.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify P from its exceptional properties:}\)
The first ionization enthalpy of approximately \(2372\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) is characteristic of helium.
Helium also has an exceptionally low normal boiling point near \(4.2\,\mathrm{K}\).
Its compact \(1s^2\) electronic configuration accounts for its very high resistance to electron removal.
Therefore, P is helium.
\(\textbf{Identify Q and R from the supplied trends:}\)
Argon has a first ionization enthalpy near \(1521\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) and a normal boiling point near \(87.3\,\mathrm{K}\).
Thus, Q corresponds to argon.
Xenon has a considerably lower first ionization enthalpy near \(1170\,\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\).
Its normal boiling point is substantially higher, near \(165\,\mathrm{K}\).
Therefore, R is xenon.
\(\textbf{Explain the opposing property trends:}\)
Down Group 18, the principal quantum number of the outermost occupied shell increases.
Atomic size and shielding generally increase.
Consequently, the outermost electrons become easier to remove, and first ionization enthalpy decreases.
At the same time, the electron clouds become larger and more polarizable.
This strengthens London dispersion attractions between neutral atoms.
Hence, normal boiling points increase down the group.
\(\textbf{Connect the chemical behaviour:}\)
Helium's small size and exceptionally high ionization enthalpy are associated with its extreme chemical unreactivity.
Argon is also very unreactive under ordinary conditions.
Xenon's lower ionization enthalpy and greater polarizability make compound formation possible with suitable strongly electronegative elements.
The existence of xenon compounds does not eliminate the general chemical stability associated with noble-gas closed shells.
The correct assignment therefore requires the ionization-enthalpy trend, boiling-point trend and qualified chemical-reactivity trend to be satisfied simultaneously.
Thus, P is helium, Q is argon and R is xenon.
94. The first ionization enthalpies of selected Group 13 elements are approximately as follows.
| Element | First ionization enthalpy \((\mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}})\) |
| B | 801 |
| Al | 578 |
| Ga | 579 |
| In | 558 |
| Tl | 589 |
Consider the following statements.
Statement I: The slight increase from aluminium to gallium is consistent with the relatively poor shielding provided by the filled \(3d\) subshell of gallium.
Statement II: The increase from indium to thallium shows that the effect of increasing principal quantum number can be opposed by changes in shielding and effective nuclear attraction.
Statement III: Thallium's higher first ionization enthalpy than indium proves that the +3 oxidation state is more stable than +1 in thallium.
Statement IV: Boron's small size and relatively strong attraction for its outermost electrons contribute to its high first ionization enthalpy.
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. Statements I, II and III only
ⓑ. Statements I, III and IV only
ⓒ. Statements II, III and IV only
ⓓ. Statements I, II and IV only
Correct Answer: Statements I, II and IV only
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret the numerical trend:}\)
The supplied values do not decrease uniformly down Group 13.
Boron has the highest first ionization enthalpy among the listed elements, consistent with its small atomic size and relatively strong effective nuclear attraction.
Statement IV is therefore correct.
The first ionization enthalpy decreases substantially from boron to aluminium, but the aluminium-to-gallium comparison shows a slight reversal.
\(\textbf{Explain the aluminium–gallium exception:}\)
Aluminium has the ground-state configuration \([\mathrm{Ne}]\,3s^23p^1\).
Gallium has the configuration \([\mathrm{Ar}]\,3d^{10}4s^24p^1\).
The intervening \(3d^{10}\) electrons shield the increasing nuclear charge relatively poorly.
Consequently, gallium's outermost electron experiences an attraction strong enough to offset the expected decrease associated with occupation of the fourth principal shell.
This makes Statement I correct.
\(\textbf{Examine the indium–thallium comparison:}\)
Indium has the outermost arrangement \(5s^25p^1\), while thallium has \(6s^26p^1\).
The filled inner \(4f\) and \(5d\) subshells in thallium do not completely shield the increasing nuclear charge.
Their poor shielding, together with other electronic effects, contributes to the relatively strong attraction experienced by thallium's outermost electrons.
Therefore, the first ionization enthalpy can increase despite the additional principal shell.
Statement II is correct.
\(\textbf{Separate ionization from oxidation-state stability:}\)
The first ionization enthalpy concerns removal of one electron from an isolated gaseous atom.
The relative stability of +1 and +3 oxidation states depends on the energetic consequences of participation of additional electrons and formation of particular compounds.
In thallium, the inert-pair effect generally favours retention of the \(6s^2\) pair and therefore the +1 state.
A higher first ionization enthalpy than indium does not prove preferential stability of Tl(III).
Statement III is incorrect.
Thus, Statements I, II and IV correctly interpret the supplied data.
95. The following approximate radii are supplied for aluminium and gallium. The ionic radii refer to six-coordinate trivalent ions.
| Element | Neutral-atom covalent radius (pm) | Trivalent ionic radius (pm) |
| Al | 143 | 54 |
| Ga | 135 | 62 |
A student predicts that because neutral gallium has a smaller covalent radius than aluminium, \(\mathrm{Ga^{3+}}\) must also be smaller than \(\mathrm{Al^{3+}}\). Which assessment correctly combines the supplied observations with electronic structure?
ⓐ. The prediction is valid because ionic radii must preserve the order of neutral-atom covalent radii.
ⓑ. Different retained shells and subshells mean the neutral-atom radius order need not persist for their ions.
ⓒ. The prediction is valid because gallium loses its filled \(3d^{10}\) subshell when forming \(\mathrm{Ga^{3+}}\).
ⓓ. The prediction is invalid because aluminium and gallium have different numbers of valence electrons in their neutral atoms.
Correct Answer: Different retained shells and subshells mean the neutral-atom radius order need not persist for their ions.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Compare the neutral electronic configurations:}\)
Aluminium has the configuration \([\mathrm{Ne}]\,3s^23p^1\).
Gallium has the configuration \([\mathrm{Ar}]\,3d^{10}4s^24p^1\).
Both belong to Group 13 and possess three valence electrons.
The filled \(3d^{10}\) subshell in gallium provides relatively poor shielding of the increased nuclear charge.
This contributes to the unexpectedly small covalent radius of neutral gallium.
Thus, the neutral-atom data correctly show gallium to be slightly smaller than aluminium under the stated radius convention.
\(\textbf{Examine electron removal:}\)
Formation of \(\mathrm{Al^{3+}}\) removes the \(3p^1\) electron and both \(3s\) electrons.
The resulting ion has the neon configuration.
For gallium, the corresponding removal involves the \(4p^1\) electron and two \(4s\) electrons.
The resulting gallium(III) ion retains the \([\mathrm{Ar}]\,3d^{10}\) configuration.
Therefore, the two trivalent ions do not have identical electron configurations.
\(\textbf{Interpret the ionic-radius reversal:}\)
The supplied six-coordinate ionic radii show that \(\mathrm{Ga^{3+}}\) is larger than \(\mathrm{Al^{3+}}\).
This is compatible with the different electronic structures of the ions and the changed balance of nuclear attraction and electron distribution after ion formation.
It does not contradict the smaller neutral-atom covalent radius of gallium.
A neutral covalent radius and a crystal-derived ionic radius describe different electronic and bonding environments.
The correct comparison must therefore use the specified ionic data rather than transferring the neutral-atom order automatically to the ions.
The student has incorrectly assumed that losing three electrons preserves the same size relationship for both elements.
96. The ground-state configurations of four Group 13 elements are given below.
| Element | Electronic configuration |
| B | \([\mathrm{He}]\,2s^22p^1\) |
| Al | \([\mathrm{Ne}]\,3s^23p^1\) |
| Ga | \([\mathrm{Ar}]\,3d^{10}4s^24p^1\) |
| In | \([\mathrm{Kr}]\,4d^{10}5s^25p^1\) |
Consider the formal ground-state electronic configurations of the isolated gaseous tripositive ions obtained by removing the three outermost valence electrons. Which conclusion is correct?
ⓐ. All four tripositive ions acquire the electronic configurations of noble-gas atoms.
ⓑ. Only boron and gallium form tripositive ions with noble-gas configurations.
ⓒ. Boron and aluminium form noble-gas-core cations; gallium and indium cations additionally retain filled inner \(d\) subshells.
ⓓ. Aluminium and indium acquire noble-gas configurations, while boron and gallium retain partially filled \(p\) subshells.
Correct Answer: Boron and aluminium form noble-gas-core cations; gallium and indium cations additionally retain filled inner \(d\) subshells.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the electrons removed:}\)
Every neutral atom in the table has the general Group 13 valence-shell configuration \(ns^2np^1\).
Formation of a tripositive ion formally involves removing the \(np^1\) electron and the two outermost \(ns\) electrons.
The three-electron removal must be applied separately to each complete electronic configuration.
\(\textbf{Examine boron and aluminium:}\)
Boron loses its three second-shell valence electrons.
The remaining configuration is:
\[
\mathrm{B^{3+}:1s^2=[He]}
\]
Aluminium loses its \(3s^23p^1\) electrons.
The remaining configuration is:
\[
\mathrm{Al^{3+}:[Ne]}
\]
Thus, these two ions possess noble-gas electronic configurations.
\(\textbf{Examine gallium and indium:}\)
Gallium loses the \(4s^24p^1\) electrons, but its filled \(3d^{10}\) subshell remains occupied.
\[
\mathrm{Ga^{3+}:[Ar]\,3d^{10}}
\]
Similarly, indium loses its \(5s^25p^1\) electrons while retaining the filled \(4d^{10}\) subshell.
\[
\mathrm{In^{3+}:[Kr]\,4d^{10}}
\]
Neither resulting configuration is identical to the configuration of a neutral noble-gas atom.
\(\textbf{Interpret the chemical significance:}\)
The existence of a +3 oxidation state does not require that every Group 13 element acquire an exact noble-gas electronic configuration.
The filled inner \(d\) subshells become important when considering the heavier members.
Moreover, these formal ionic configurations should not be interpreted as proof that every Group 13 compound consists of free \(\mathrm{M^{3+}}\) ions.
For example, boron's very high ionization enthalpies make formation of an isolated \(\mathrm{B^{3+}}\) ion extremely unfavourable under ordinary chemical conditions.
The exercise concerns electron counting and electronic structure, not the practical stability of every isolated ion.
Therefore, only boron and aluminium yield the stated noble-gas configurations.
97. Carbon monoxide, \(\mathrm{CO}\), and lead(II) oxide, \(\mathrm{PbO}\), both contain a Group 14 element in oxidation state +2. Carbon monoxide is classified as a neutral oxide, while lead(II) oxide exhibits appreciable basic and amphoteric behaviour under suitable conditions. Which explanation correctly accounts for this contrast?
ⓐ. The common +2 oxidation state does not determine oxide acid–base behaviour; Pb(II) stability is also influenced by the inert-pair effect.
ⓑ. Both oxides must be neutral because the Group 14 element has oxidation state +2 in each compound.
ⓒ. Carbon monoxide must be basic because carbon has a positive oxidation state, while lead(II) oxide must be acidic because lead is heavier.
ⓓ. The +2 state in carbon monoxide and lead(II) oxide must arise from an equally strong inert-pair effect in both elements.
Correct Answer: The common +2 oxidation state does not determine oxide acid–base behaviour; Pb(II) stability is also influenced by the inert-pair effect.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Establish the common oxidation state:}\)
Oxygen has oxidation state \(-2\) in both compounds.
Since each oxide is electrically neutral, the Group 14 element must have oxidation state +2.
Thus, carbon has oxidation state +2 in carbon monoxide, and lead has oxidation state +2 in lead(II) oxide.
However, oxidation state is a formal electron-accounting quantity.
It does not independently determine whether a compound behaves as an acidic, basic, amphoteric or neutral oxide.
\(\textbf{Examine carbon monoxide:}\)
Carbon monoxide is a covalently bonded molecular substance.
It does not show the characteristic acid–base reactions of ordinary acidic or basic oxides and is therefore classified as a neutral oxide.
Carbon is a small non-metallic element capable of effective multiple bonding.
The occurrence of carbon in oxidation state +2 does not require invoking the inert-pair effect.
\(\textbf{Examine lead(II) oxide:}\)
Lead is a heavy metallic member of Group 14.
Its oxide exhibits appreciable basic character and can also show amphoteric behaviour under suitable conditions.
Lead has the outermost electronic configuration \(6s^26p^2\).
The inert-pair effect favours retention of the \(6s^2\) pair, contributing to the greater stability of Pb(II) relative to Pb(IV).
Thus, the importance of the +2 state in lead chemistry has an electronic explanation that does not apply in the same way to carbon monoxide.
\(\textbf{Connect the observations:}\)
The two oxides illustrate why identical oxidation states need not correspond to identical bonding, acid–base behaviour or preferred oxidation-state stability.
Group position, metallic character and the chemical environment must be considered alongside formal electron counting.
The correct explanation therefore preserves the shared +2 state without assuming identical chemical properties.
98. Carbon tetrachloride, \(\mathrm{CCl_4}\), and carbon dioxide, \(\mathrm{CO_2}\), both contain carbon in oxidation state +4. In the usual molecular structures, carbon is directly bonded to four chlorine atoms in the first compound and two oxygen atoms in the second. Which conclusion correctly reconciles their oxidation states and bonding arrangements?
ⓐ. Carbon has oxidation state +4 in \(\mathrm{CCl_4}\), but +2 in \(\mathrm{CO_2}\) because only two oxygen atoms are bonded to it.
ⓑ. Carbon has oxidation state +4 in both compounds, but its coordination number is four in \(\mathrm{CCl_4}\) and two in \(\mathrm{CO_2}\).
ⓒ. Carbon has coordination number four in both compounds because a double bond counts as two directly bonded atoms.
ⓓ. Carbon has oxidation state zero in both compounds because the bonds are covalent rather than ionic.
Correct Answer: Carbon has oxidation state +4 in both compounds, but its coordination number is four in \(\mathrm{CCl_4}\) and two in \(\mathrm{CO_2}\).
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine oxidation states:}\)
Carbon is less electronegative than both chlorine and oxygen.
In carbon tetrachloride, chlorine is assigned oxidation state \(-1\).
The neutral-molecule condition gives:
\[
x+4(-1)=0
\]
\[
x=+4
\]
In carbon dioxide, oxygen has oxidation state \(-2\).
Therefore:
\[
y+2(-2)=0
\]
\[
y=+4
\]
Both compounds consequently contain carbon in formal oxidation state +4.
\(\textbf{Examine the bonding arrangements:}\)
In \(\mathrm{CCl_4}\), the carbon atom forms four ordinary C–Cl single bonds.
Four chlorine atoms are directly attached to carbon.
The coordination number of carbon is therefore four.
In \(\mathrm{CO_2}\), carbon forms two C=O double bonds in the usual molecular structure.
Only two oxygen atoms are directly attached to the carbon atom.
The coordination number of carbon is consequently two.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the concepts:}\)
A double bond contains more than one shared electron pair, but it does not create two separately bonded neighbouring atoms.
Coordination number counts directly attached atoms, not bonding electron pairs.
Oxidation state is assigned using the formal distribution of bonding electrons according to electronegativity.
These quantities can therefore differ without contradiction.
The comparison demonstrates that an oxidation state of +4 does not require a coordination number of four.
It also shows why covalent bonding does not imply oxidation state zero.
The correct conclusion must distinguish formal electron accounting from actual molecular connectivity.
99. Consider the hypothetical redox transformation:
\[
\mathrm{CO+PbO_2\longrightarrow CO_2+PbO}
\]
Assume that the transformation is considered only for formal oxidation-state and electron-balance analysis, without requiring a prediction of its reaction rate. Which statement correctly describes the electron transfer?
ⓐ. Carbon gains two electrons, while lead loses two electrons.
ⓑ. Carbon gains four electrons, while lead loses four electrons.
ⓒ. Carbon loses four electrons, while lead gains two electrons.
ⓓ. Carbon loses two electrons, while lead gains two electrons.
Correct Answer: Carbon loses two electrons, while lead gains two electrons.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the initial oxidation states:}\)
Oxygen is assigned oxidation state \(-2\) in each oxide.
In carbon monoxide:
\[
x+(-2)=0
\]
\[
x=+2
\]
Carbon therefore begins in oxidation state +2.
In lead dioxide:
\[
y+2(-2)=0
\]
\[
y=+4
\]
Lead initially has oxidation state +4.
\(\textbf{Determine the product oxidation states:}\)
In carbon dioxide:
\[
x+2(-2)=0
\]
\[
x=+4
\]
In lead(II) oxide:
\[
y+(-2)=0
\]
\[
y=+2
\]
\(\textbf{Identify the oxidation and reduction processes:}\)
Carbon changes from +2 in \(\mathrm{CO}\) to +4 in \(\mathrm{CO_2}\).
Its oxidation state increases by two units.
This corresponds to formal loss of two electrons:
\[
\mathrm{C(+II)\longrightarrow C(+IV)+2e^-}
\]
Lead changes from +4 in \(\mathrm{PbO_2}\) to +2 in \(\mathrm{PbO}\).
Its oxidation state decreases by two units.
This corresponds to formal gain of two electrons:
\[
\mathrm{Pb(+IV)+2e^-\longrightarrow Pb(+II)}
\]
\(\textbf{Verify conservation:}\)
There is one carbon atom and one lead atom on each side.
The reactants contain three oxygen atoms, as do the products.
The total formal electron loss is two electrons, equal to the total formal electron gain.
Therefore, the proposed transformation is atomically and electronically balanced.
Carbon monoxide acts as the reducing agent in the formal redox description, while lead dioxide acts as the oxidizing agent.
The lowering of lead's oxidation state is consistent with the relative importance of Pb(II) in heavy Group 14 chemistry.
The balanced equation does not independently establish the conditions or kinetics of an actual reaction.
The required electron-transfer conclusion is that carbon loses two electrons and lead gains two electrons.
100. The simple hydrides of Group 15 include \(\mathrm{NH_3}\), \(\mathrm{PH_3}\), \(\mathrm{AsH_3}\), \(\mathrm{SbH_3}\) and \(\mathrm{BiH_3}\). Consider their general thermal stability, Lewis basicity and reducing behaviour under appropriate comparable conditions. Which combination of trends is correct on moving down the group?
ⓐ. Thermal stability decreases, reducing character increases, and Lewis basicity generally decreases.
ⓑ. Thermal stability increases, reducing character decreases, and Lewis basicity generally decreases.
ⓒ. Thermal stability decreases, reducing character decreases, and Lewis basicity generally increases.
ⓓ. Thermal stability increases, reducing character increases, and Lewis basicity generally increases.
Correct Answer: Thermal stability decreases, reducing character increases, and Lewis basicity generally decreases.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the common valence pattern:}\)
All five central elements belong to Group 15 and possess five valence electrons.
Their simple trihydrides follow the general formula \(\mathrm{EH_3}\).
The central atom ordinarily forms three E–H bonds and retains a lone pair in the usual Lewis description.
Nevertheless, similar formulas do not require identical chemical stability or reactivity.
\(\textbf{Examine thermal stability:}\)
Atomic size increases down Group 15.
The E–H bonds generally become longer because the valence orbitals of the central atom become more diffuse.
Effective overlap with hydrogen decreases, and E–H bond strength generally decreases.
This contributes to decreasing thermal stability down the hydride series.
\(\textbf{Connect the trend with reducing behaviour:}\)
In these hydrides, the Group 15 element has a low formal oxidation state.
Under suitable conditions, it can be oxidized while reducing another species.
The decrease in hydride stability and weakening of E–H bonds are consistent with increasing reducing character towards the heavier hydrides.
Consequently, the heavier hydrides generally behave as stronger reducing agents.
\(\textbf{Examine Lewis basicity:}\)
All five hydrides possess a non-bonding electron pair on the central atom.
However, the effectiveness of lone-pair donation changes down the group.
Ammonia is a much stronger Lewis base than phosphine under ordinary comparable conditions.
The basic tendency generally decreases further among the heavier simple hydrides.
Thus, possession of a lone pair is necessary for this kind of Lewis-base behaviour but does not establish equal basicity.
\(\textbf{Reconcile the three trends:}\)
Reducing behaviour involves a tendency to undergo oxidation, whereas Lewis basicity involves electron-pair donation to an acceptor.
These are different chemical processes.
Therefore, increasing reducing character and decreasing Lewis basicity can occur simultaneously.
The correct combination is decreasing thermal stability, increasing reducing character and generally decreasing Lewis basicity down Group 15.