201. A \(0.200\,\mathrm{g}\) organic sample contains only one halogen selected from chlorine, bromine and iodine. A quantitative determination produces \(0.376\,\mathrm{g}\) of a pure, dry silver halide, with complete precipitation and no contamination.
The identity of the halogen has not been established by colour or ammonia-solubility testing.
Using \(Ag=108\), \(Cl=35.5\), \(Br=80\) and \(I=127\), which conclusion follows from the gravimetric data alone?
ⓐ. Chlorine and bromine remain possible, but iodine is excluded by the elemental mass balance.
ⓑ. Bromine is uniquely identified because the precipitate mass exceeds the sample mass.
ⓒ. Chlorine is uniquely identified because silver chloride has the lowest molar mass.
ⓓ. All three halogens remain possible because silver-halide mass is always greater than original sample mass.
Correct Answer: Chlorine and bromine remain possible, but iodine is excluded by the elemental mass balance.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Test the chlorine assignment:}\)
If the precipitate were silver chloride:
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgCl}}=143.5\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The chlorine mass would be:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Cl}}=0.376\times\frac{35.5}{143.5}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Cl}}\approx0.0930\,\mathrm{g}
\]
This is less than the \(0.200\,\mathrm{g}\) sample mass, so the chlorine assignment is not excluded by mass conservation.
\(\textbf{Test the bromine assignment:}\)
If the precipitate were silver bromide:
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=188\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The bromine mass would be:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Br}}=0.376\times\frac{80}{188}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Br}}=0.160\,\mathrm{g}
\]
This is also less than the original sample mass, so bromine is not excluded.
\(\textbf{Test the iodine assignment:}\)
If the precipitate were silver iodide:
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgI}}=108+127=235\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The iodine mass would be:
\[
m_{\mathrm I}=0.376\times\frac{127}{235}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm I}=0.2032\,\mathrm{g}
\]
However:
\[
m_{\mathrm I}\gt m_{\mathrm{sample}}
\]
A \(0.200\,\mathrm{g}\) sample cannot contain \(0.2032\,\mathrm{g}\) of iodine.
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The mass balance therefore excludes iodine under the stated assumptions. It does not uniquely distinguish chlorine from bromine because both assignments produce physically possible elemental masses. An independent observation, such as suitable precipitate colour and ammonia-solubility behaviour, would be needed for a unique chemical identification. The result illustrates how gravimetric data can reject an impossible assignment without necessarily determining the remaining identity.
202. An organic compound contains sulphur. Two separate portions are analysed.
Procedure I: The compound undergoes suitable sodium fusion. The aqueous extract gives a violet colour with sodium nitroprusside.
Procedure II: A known mass of the compound is oxidised under the prescribed quantitative conditions so that sulphur is converted into sulphuric acid. The resulting solution is treated with barium chloride, and a white precipitate is collected, dried and weighed.
Which statement correctly identifies the analytical products and the purpose of each procedure?
ⓐ. Procedure I detects sulphate quantitatively, while Procedure II detects sulphide qualitatively.
ⓑ. Procedure I detects sulphide qualitatively; Procedure II determines sulphur from the barium sulphate mass.
ⓒ. Both procedures measure sulphur directly as elemental sulphur separated from the original organic compound.
ⓓ. Procedure II produces barium sulphide, whose mass is used with the sulphide-to-sulphur ratio.
Correct Answer: Procedure I detects sulphide qualitatively; Procedure II determines sulphur from the barium sulphate mass.
Explanation: The two procedures identify or measure sulphur after converting it into different inorganic forms. During suitable sodium fusion, organically bound sulphur is converted into sodium sulphide. The resulting sulphide ions can give a characteristic violet response with sodium nitroprusside. This provides evidence for sulphur but does not by itself establish its mass percentage. The second procedure follows the gravimetric principle used for quantitative sulphur estimation. Sulphur in the organic compound is oxidised into sulphuric acid under the prescribed conditions. Barium chloride supplies barium ions, which react with sulphate ions to produce sparingly soluble barium sulphate. The ionic precipitation reaction is \(\mathrm{Ba^{2+}+SO_4^{2-}\rightarrow BaSO_4(s)}\). The barium sulphate is collected, dried and weighed. Since each mole of barium sulphate contains one mole of sulphur atoms, the sulphur mass can be calculated using its molar-mass fraction. The complete barium sulphate mass is not equal to the original sulphur mass because barium and oxygen also contribute to the precipitate. The correct distinction therefore involves both the different chemical forms generated and the qualitative or quantitative purpose of the observation.
203. A \(0.400\,\mathrm{g}\) organic compound containing sulphur is subjected to quantitative sulphur estimation. All sulphur is converted into sulphate, which is completely precipitated as \(0.699\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure, dry barium sulphate.
Using \(Ba=137\), \(S=32\) and \(O=16\), what is the mass percentage of sulphur in the original compound?
ⓐ. \(18.0\%\)
ⓑ. \(24.0\%\)
ⓒ. \(32.0\%\)
ⓓ. \(40.0\%\)
Correct Answer: \(24.0\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the measured analytical compound:}\)
The recovered precipitate is barium sulphate.
Its mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=0.699\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Each formula unit contains one sulphur atom.
\(\textbf{Calculate the molar mass:}\)
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=137+32+4(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=233\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The mass of sulphur in one mole of barium sulphate is \(32\,\mathrm{g}\).
\(\textbf{Convert precipitate mass into sulphur mass:}\)
\[
m_{\mathrm S}=m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}\times\frac{32}{233}
\]
Substituting:
\[
m_{\mathrm S}=0.699\times\frac{32}{233}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm S}=0.0960\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate sulphur percentage:}\)
The original sample mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{sample}}=0.400\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\%\mathrm S=\frac{0.0960}{0.400}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm S=24.0\%
\]
\(\textbf{Check the stoichiometry:}\)
The barium sulphate precipitate contains barium and oxygen in addition to sulphur. Consequently, its complete mass must not be assigned to sulphur. The correct gravimetric factor is \(32/233\), not \(233/32\). The calculation also assumes complete oxidation to sulphate and quantitative precipitation and recovery of barium sulphate.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{24.0\%}
\]
204. A \(0.400\,\mathrm{g}\) organic compound contains \(20.0\%\) sulphur by mass. A quantitative estimation is performed in which all sulphur is oxidised to sulphate.
During filtration, only \(80.0\%\) of the barium sulphate initially formed is recovered. The recovered precipitate is pure and completely dry, and the loss fraction is independently known.
What sulphur percentage would be calculated if the recovered mass were used without correction, and what is the actual sulphur percentage?
ⓐ. \(16.0\%\) calculated; \(20.0\%\) actual.
ⓑ. \(20.0\%\) calculated; \(16.0\%\) actual.
ⓒ. \(25.0\%\) calculated; \(20.0\%\) actual.
ⓓ. \(20.0\%\) calculated; \(25.0\%\) actual.
Correct Answer: \(16.0\%\) calculated; \(20.0\%\) actual.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the actual sulphur mass:}\)
The original sample weighs:
\[
m_{\mathrm{sample}}=0.400\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Its actual sulphur percentage is \(20.0\%\).
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{S,true}}=0.400\times\frac{20.0}{100}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{S,true}}=0.0800\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate barium sulphate theoretically formed:}\)
Each mole of barium sulphate contains one mole of sulphur.
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4,theoretical}}
=
m_{\mathrm{S,true}}\times\frac{233}{32}
\]
Substituting:
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4,theoretical}}
=
0.0800\times\frac{233}{32}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4,theoretical}}=0.5825\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Apply the recovery loss:}\)
Only \(80.0\%\) of the precipitate is collected.
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4,recovered}}
=
0.5825\times\frac{80.0}{100}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4,recovered}}=0.4660\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Reconstruct the uncorrected calculation:}\)
If the student assumes the recovered precipitate represents all sulphur:
\[
m_{\mathrm{S,apparent}}
=
0.4660\times\frac{32}{233}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{S,apparent}}=0.0640\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Consequently:
\[
\%\mathrm{S,apparent}
=
\frac{0.0640}{0.400}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{S,apparent}=16.0\%
\]
\(\textbf{Interpret the recovery factor:}\)
The apparent sulphur percentage is \(80.0\%\) of the actual percentage because only \(80.0\%\) of the analytical precipitate was recovered. The missing precipitate contains the unaccounted sulphur contribution. Correcting for the known recovery loss restores the true sulphur percentage of \(20.0\%\). This illustrates why a pure precipitate can still give an inaccurate gravimetric result if its recovery is incomplete.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\left(16.0\%,\,20.0\%\right)}
\]
205. A \(0.310\,\mathrm{g}\) pure organic compound is independently known to contain \(20.0\%\) sulphur by mass. All sulphur is converted quantitatively into barium sulphate during the prescribed gravimetric analysis.
A student argues that the final barium sulphate mass cannot exceed the original sample mass because this would violate conservation of mass.
Using \(Ba=137\), \(S=32\) and \(O=16\), which conclusion is correct?
ⓐ. The maximum barium sulphate mass is \(0.0620\,\mathrm{g}\), because this is the original sulphur mass.
ⓑ. The maximum barium sulphate mass is \(0.310\,\mathrm{g}\), because a precipitate cannot be heavier than the sample.
ⓒ. The expected barium sulphate mass is \(0.451\,\mathrm{g}\); the extra mass includes barium and oxygen.
ⓓ. The expected barium sulphate mass is \(2.26\,\mathrm{g}\), because every sulphur atom produces one mole of barium sulphate.
Correct Answer: The expected barium sulphate mass is \(0.451\,\mathrm{g}\); the extra mass includes barium and oxygen.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine sulphur originally present:}\)
The sample mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{sample}}=0.310\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Sulphur constitutes \(20.0\%\) of the sample.
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm S}=0.310\times\frac{20.0}{100}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm S}=0.0620\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Convert sulphur mass into amount:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm S}=\frac{0.0620}{32}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm S}=0.0019375\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine barium sulphate amount:}\)
Each barium sulphate formula unit contains one sulphur atom.
Consequently:
\[
n_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=0.0019375\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
The molar mass is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=137+32+4(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=233\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the expected precipitate:}\)
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=0.0019375\times233
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=0.4514375\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}\approx0.451\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Interpret the mass balance:}\)
The precipitate is heavier than the original organic sample because it contains barium and oxygen in addition to sulphur. These additional atoms originate from the analytical reagents and the preceding chemical transformations. The complete mass of the precipitate therefore need not be supplied by the original sample. Conservation of mass applies to the entire reaction system, not only to the original organic compound and one isolated product. The student's objection is consequently incorrect even though the precipitate is heavier than the starting sample.
206. A sulphur-containing organic compound is oxidised under the prescribed gravimetric conditions so that its sulphur is converted into sulphate. The solution is then treated with barium chloride to obtain barium sulphate.
In one experiment, the final precipitate is contaminated with a small amount of barium carbonate formed from carbonate present in the analytical solution. The contamination is not recognised, and the entire dry precipitate mass is treated as barium sulphate.
Which conclusion is correct?
ⓐ. The calculated sulphur percentage is too high because barium carbonate contributes mass that is incorrectly assigned to barium sulphate.
ⓑ. The calculated sulphur percentage is too low because barium carbonate contains no sulphur.
ⓒ. The result remains accurate because every precipitate containing barium has the same sulphur mass fraction.
ⓓ. The calculated sulphur percentage becomes zero because the presence of carbonate prevents any sulphate from existing.
Correct Answer: The calculated sulphur percentage is too high because barium carbonate contributes mass that is incorrectly assigned to barium sulphate.
Explanation: Gravimetric sulphur estimation requires the weighed precipitate to represent the sulphur-derived barium sulphate quantitatively. The calculation assumes that the measured solid mass corresponds to a known number of moles of barium sulphate. Each mole of barium sulphate contains one mole of sulphur atoms, giving the gravimetric factor \(32/233\). In the described experiment, some barium carbonate is also present in the collected solid. Barium carbonate contains no sulphur, so its mass does not represent any additional sulphur from the organic sample. Nevertheless, treating the entire collected mass as barium sulphate assigns a positive sulphur contribution to the carbonate impurity. The inferred amount of barium sulphate therefore becomes larger than the amount actually produced from the sample's sulphur. The calculated sulphur mass and sulphur percentage are consequently overestimated. The error differs from incomplete precipitation, which would tend to produce a smaller recovered barium sulphate mass. The presence of a barium-containing precipitate does not prove that every portion of it has the required sulphate composition. Correct gravimetry therefore depends not only on collecting and drying a precipitate but also on ensuring its chemical identity and purity.
207. An organic compound containing phosphorus is subjected to quantitative phosphorus estimation. Under the prescribed conditions, its phosphorus is oxidised to phosphoric acid and then precipitated as ammonium phosphomolybdate.
The analytical product is represented as:
\[
\mathrm{(NH_4)_3PO_4\cdot12MoO_3}
\]
Which conclusion about the mass relation is correct?
ⓐ. Each mole of precipitate contains twelve moles of phosphorus because twelve \(\mathrm{MoO_3}\) units are present.
ⓑ. Each mole of precipitate contains three moles of phosphorus because three ammonium groups are present.
ⓒ. The entire precipitate mass represents phosphorus because phosphorus is the element being estimated.
ⓓ. Each mole of precipitate contains one mole of phosphorus, fixing its phosphorus mass fraction.
Correct Answer: Each mole of precipitate contains one mole of phosphorus, fixing its phosphorus mass fraction.
Explanation: The quantitative phosphorus-estimation procedure first converts phosphorus from its original organic environment into phosphoric acid under suitable oxidising conditions. The phosphoric acid is then converted into a compound suitable for gravimetric measurement. One such product is ammonium phosphomolybdate, represented in NCERT by \(\mathrm{(NH_4)_3PO_4\cdot12MoO_3}\). The formula contains a single \(\mathrm{PO_4}\) group and therefore one phosphorus atom per formula unit. The three ammonium groups contribute nitrogen and hydrogen but do not contain phosphorus. The twelve \(\mathrm{MoO_3}\) units contribute molybdenum and oxygen rather than additional phosphorus. Consequently, the precipitate has a large formula mass relative to the mass of phosphorus that it represents. The phosphorus mass is calculated from the weighed precipitate using the ratio of one phosphorus atomic mass to the complete formula mass. Counting either ammonium groups or molybdenum oxide units as phosphorus would produce an incorrect stoichiometric factor. The whole precipitate mass cannot be treated as elemental phosphorus because the other atoms originate from analytical reagents. Correct estimation therefore requires reading the complete chemical formula before applying the gravimetric relation.
208. In an alternative quantitative phosphorus-estimation procedure, phosphorus in an organic compound is converted into phosphoric acid. Suitable treatment with magnesia mixture gives magnesium ammonium phosphate, which is subsequently ignited to form magnesium pyrophosphate, \(\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}\).
Consider the following statements.
Statement I: The precipitate initially obtained and the compound finally weighed are chemically different.
Statement II: One mole of magnesium pyrophosphate contains two moles of phosphorus atoms.
Statement III: The mass of phosphorus can be calculated from the final product using \(2M(P)/M(\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7})\).
Statement IV: Ignition leaves the magnesium ammonium phosphate formula unchanged, so no conversion factor is required.
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. I, II and III only
ⓑ. I, III and IV only
ⓒ. II and IV only
ⓓ. I, II and IV only
Correct Answer: I, II and III only
Explanation: Statement I is correct because magnesium ammonium phosphate is the product obtained before the ignition stage, whereas magnesium pyrophosphate is the compound obtained after ignition. The procedure deliberately converts the initial phosphate precipitate into a stable compound suitable for weighing. Statement II is correct because the formula \(\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}\) contains two phosphorus atoms per formula unit. Consequently, one mole of magnesium pyrophosphate represents two moles of phosphorus atoms. Statement III is correct because the sulphur-free final gravimetric product contains phosphorus together with magnesium and oxygen. The phosphorus mass fraction is therefore the mass of two phosphorus atoms divided by the molar mass of magnesium pyrophosphate. Statement IV is incorrect because ignition changes the identity and composition of the original precipitate. Treating the initial magnesium ammonium phosphate and final magnesium pyrophosphate as having the same formula would ignore this chemical conversion. The correct mass relation must use the compound actually collected and weighed at the end of the procedure. This distinction is important because phosphorus estimation can employ more than one final gravimetric product. Different products have different phosphorus mass fractions even when they represent the same original phosphorus quantity. The correct statements are I, II and III.
209. A \(0.310\,\mathrm{g}\) organic compound containing phosphorus is subjected to quantitative phosphorus estimation through the magnesium pyrophosphate method. Following suitable oxidation, precipitation and ignition, \(0.111\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure, dry \(\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}\) is obtained.
Using \(Mg=24\), \(P=31\) and \(O=16\), what is the percentage of phosphorus in the original compound?
ⓐ. \(5.00\%\)
ⓑ. \(10.0\%\)
ⓒ. \(15.0\%\)
ⓓ. \(20.0\%\)
Correct Answer: \(10.0\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the final weighed product:}\)
The analytical precipitate has been ignited to magnesium pyrophosphate.
Its mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=0.111\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The final formula contains two phosphorus atoms per formula unit.
\(\textbf{Calculate its molar mass:}\)
\[
M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}
=
2(24)+2(31)+7(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}
=
48+62+112
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=222\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the phosphorus mass fraction:}\)
Each mole of magnesium pyrophosphate contains:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P\ per\ mole}}=2(31)
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P\ per\ mole}}=62\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm P}
=
m_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}\times\frac{62}{222}
\]
\(\textbf{Substitute the precipitate mass:}\)
\[
m_{\mathrm P}=0.111\times\frac{62}{222}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm P}=0.0310\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate phosphorus percentage:}\)
The original compound mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{sample}}=0.310\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Hence:
\[
\%\mathrm P=\frac{0.0310}{0.310}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm P=10.0\%
\]
\(\textbf{Check the formula interpretation:}\)
The final weighed product contains two phosphorus atoms per formula unit. Using only one phosphorus atomic mass would underestimate the phosphorus content by a factor of two. The magnesium and oxygen contributions must also remain included in the denominator because the weighed compound is magnesium pyrophosphate, not elemental phosphorus.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{10.0\%}
\]
210. Two portions of the same pure phosphorus-containing organic compound are analysed quantitatively by different prescribed procedures.
In Procedure I, phosphorus is converted into ammonium phosphomolybdate, \(\mathrm{(NH_4)_3PO_4\cdot12MoO_3}\). The recovered mass corresponds to \(0.000500\,\mathrm{mol}\) of this compound.
In Procedure II, the phosphorus is converted through magnesium ammonium phosphate and finally weighed as \(\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}\).
Assume each procedure begins with an equal mass of the same compound and all phosphorus is quantitatively recovered.
Using \(Mg=24\), \(P=31\) and \(O=16\), what mass of magnesium pyrophosphate is expected in Procedure II?
ⓐ. \(0.0278\,\mathrm{g}\)
ⓑ. \(0.0555\,\mathrm{g}\)
ⓒ. \(0.111\,\mathrm{g}\)
ⓓ. \(0.222\,\mathrm{g}\)
Correct Answer: \(0.0555\,\mathrm{g}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine phosphorus from Procedure I:}\)
The amount of ammonium phosphomolybdate obtained is:
\[
n_{\mathrm{phosphomolybdate}}=0.000500\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Its formula is:
\[
\mathrm{(NH_4)_3PO_4\cdot12MoO_3}
\]
Each formula unit contains one phosphorus atom.
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm P}=0.000500\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Translate phosphorus into the alternative product:}\)
Procedure II produces magnesium pyrophosphate:
\[
\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}
\]
Each formula unit contains two phosphorus atoms.
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=\frac{n_{\mathrm P}}{2}
\]
Substituting:
\[
n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=\frac{0.000500}{2}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=0.000250\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the final product mass:}\)
The molar mass is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=2(24)+2(31)+7(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=222\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}
=
n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=0.000250\times222
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=0.0555\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The two procedures use different final gravimetric compounds but must represent the same quantity of elemental phosphorus. One mole of ammonium phosphomolybdate contains one mole of phosphorus atoms, while one mole of magnesium pyrophosphate contains two moles of phosphorus atoms. Therefore, the expected magnesium pyrophosphate amount is half the phosphomolybdate amount in moles. The two precipitate masses are not interchangeable because their formula masses and phosphorus contents differ. The calculation depends on conserving phosphorus atoms across the two analytical pathways rather than treating the two product formulae as equivalent.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{0.0555\,\mathrm{g}}
\]
211. A \(1.205\,\mathrm{g}\) mixture contains only acetamide, \(\mathrm{CH_3CONH_2}\), and nitrobenzene, \(\mathrm{C_6H_5NO_2}\). The nitrogen in acetamide is quantitatively estimated by the ordinary Kjeldahl method, whereas the nitrogen in nitrobenzene is not estimated by this method under the prescribed conditions.
Independent analysis gives the following results:
- Complete Dumas estimation indicates \(0.210\,\mathrm{g}\) of total nitrogen.
- Ordinary Kjeldahl estimation indicates \(0.140\,\mathrm{g}\) of nitrogen.
Assume both results are quantitatively accurate for the forms of nitrogen they measure.
Using \(C=12\), \(H=1\), \(N=14\) and \(O=16\), what is the percentage by mass of nitrobenzene in the mixture?
ⓐ. \(40.8\%\)
ⓑ. \(48.9\%\)
ⓒ. \(58.2\%\)
ⓓ. \(51.0\%\)
Correct Answer: \(51.0\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the nitrogen measured by each method:}\)
Dumas estimation accounts for nitrogen from both components under the stated conditions.
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{N,total}}=0.210\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Ordinary Kjeldahl estimation accounts for nitrogen from acetamide but not from the nitro group of nitrobenzene.
Thus:
\[
m_{\mathrm{N,acetamide}}=0.140\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Isolate nitrogen from nitrobenzene:}\)
\[
m_{\mathrm{N,nitrobenzene}}
=
m_{\mathrm{N,total}}-m_{\mathrm{N,acetamide}}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{N,nitrobenzene}}=0.210-0.140
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{N,nitrobenzene}}=0.0700\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Convert nitrogen into nitrobenzene:}\)
The molecular formula of nitrobenzene is:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5NO_2}
\]
Its molar mass is:
\[
M=6(12)+5(1)+14+2(16)
\]
\[
M=123\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Each molecule contains one nitrogen atom.
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{nitrobenzene}}=\frac{0.0700}{14}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{nitrobenzene}}=0.00500\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
The mass of nitrobenzene is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{nitrobenzene}}=0.00500\times123
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{nitrobenzene}}=0.615\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate percentage composition:}\)
\[
\%\mathrm{nitrobenzene}
=
\frac{0.615}{1.205}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{nitrobenzene}=51.04\ldots\%
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{nitrobenzene}\approx51.0\%
\]
\(\textbf{Independent consistency check:}\)
The remaining mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{acetamide}}=1.205-0.615
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{acetamide}}=0.590\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Acetamide has molar mass \(59\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}\).
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{acetamide}}=\frac{0.590}{59}=0.0100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
It contains one nitrogen atom per molecule, giving:
\[
m_{\mathrm{N,acetamide}}=0.0100\times14
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{N,acetamide}}=0.140\,\mathrm{g}
\]
This agrees with the stated Kjeldahl result. The method comparison is therefore chemically and quantitatively consistent. The difference between the two nitrogen determinations identifies the nitrogen belonging to the Kjeldahl-inapplicable component, permitting its mass to be calculated.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{51.0\%}
\]
212. A \(0.700\,\mathrm{g}\) nitrogen-containing organic compound is completely digested by the Kjeldahl method. The resulting digest is quantitatively transferred to a volumetric flask and diluted to \(100.0\,\mathrm{mL}\).
A \(25.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) aliquot is treated with excess sodium hydroxide. All ammonia liberated from this aliquot is absorbed in \(50.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) of \(0.100\,\mathrm{M}\) hydrochloric acid.
The unreacted hydrochloric acid requires \(20.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) of \(0.100\,\mathrm{M}\) sodium hydroxide for neutralisation.
Assume the digest is homogeneous and all analytical conversions are quantitative.
What is the nitrogen percentage of the original compound?
ⓐ. \(6.00\%\)
ⓑ. \(12.0\%\)
ⓒ. \(24.0\%\)
ⓓ. \(48.0\%\)
Correct Answer: \(24.0\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the original acid quantity:}\)
The receiving flask contains hydrochloric acid:
\[
V_{\mathrm{HCl}}=50.0\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{HCl}}=0.100\,\mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl,initial}}
=
\frac{50.0\times0.100}{1000}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl,initial}}=0.00500\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the unused acid:}\)
The remaining acid is neutralised by sodium hydroxide.
\[
n_{\mathrm{NaOH}}
=
\frac{20.0\times0.100}{1000}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{NaOH}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Because hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide react in a \(1:1\) mole ratio:
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl,unused}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate ammonia from the aliquot:}\)
The acid consumed by ammonia is:
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl,consumed}}
=
0.00500-0.00200
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl,consumed}}=0.00300\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
The relevant reaction is:
\[
\mathrm{NH_3+HCl\rightarrow NH_4Cl}
\]
Thus:
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3,aliquot}}=0.00300\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Restore the full digest quantity:}\)
Only \(25.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) of the \(100.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) digest was analysed.
The dilution factor is:
\[
f=\frac{100.0}{25.0}
\]
\[
f=4
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3,total}}=0.00300\times4
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3,total}}=0.0120\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine nitrogen mass:}\)
Each ammonia molecule contains one nitrogen atom.
\[
m_{\mathrm N}=0.0120\times14
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm N}=0.168\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate nitrogen percentage:}\)
\[
\%\mathrm N=\frac{0.168}{0.700}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm N=24.0\%
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The titration directly measures nitrogen corresponding only to the withdrawn aliquot. Failing to account for the total digest volume would underestimate nitrogen by a factor of four. The use of hydrochloric acid also means that one mole of ammonia consumes one mole of acid. The correct calculation requires acid-base stoichiometry followed by restoration of the original sample quantity.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{24.0\%}
\]
213. Two Dumas nitrogen-estimation experiments are performed on identical portions of a nitrogen-containing organic compound.
| Experimental condition | Trial I | Trial II |
| Atmospheric air initially present | Completely displaced by carbon dioxide | Some air remains |
| Heated copper gauze | Absent | Present and effective |
| Other stated condition | Some sample nitrogen forms \(\mathrm{NO_2}\), which is absorbed by the potassium hydroxide solution before gas-volume measurement | Nitrogen from trapped air reaches the collection tube together with sample-derived \(\mathrm{N_2}\) |
Assume every effect mentioned is quantitatively significant, and no additional error occurs.
Which comparison correctly describes the calculated nitrogen percentages?
ⓐ. Trial I gives an underestimated value, whereas Trial II gives an overestimated value.
ⓑ. Trial I gives an overestimated value, whereas Trial II gives an underestimated value.
ⓒ. Both trials underestimate nitrogen because their final collection tubes contain less nitrogen than the original sample.
ⓓ. Both trials overestimate nitrogen because the potassium hydroxide solution absorbs carbon dioxide.
Correct Answer: Trial I gives an underestimated value, whereas Trial II gives an overestimated value.
Explanation: The Dumas method requires the nitrogen in the organic compound to be represented quantitatively by molecular nitrogen collected for measurement. In Trial I, atmospheric air has been completely displaced, so there is no atmospheric nitrogen contamination. However, the heated copper gauze is absent. The question specifies that some sample nitrogen remains in the form of nitrogen dioxide. That nitrogen dioxide is subsequently absorbed by the potassium hydroxide solution and does not contribute to the measured molecular-nitrogen volume. Consequently, the collected nitrogen represents less than the total nitrogen originally present in the sample. Trial I therefore underestimates nitrogen percentage. In Trial II, the heated copper gauze effectively converts the relevant nitrogen oxides into molecular nitrogen. However, atmospheric air has not been completely displaced. Nitrogen from the trapped air survives the carbon dioxide absorption stage and reaches the graduated collection tube. The measured nitrogen volume consequently includes nitrogen that was never part of the organic compound. Assigning the full gas volume to the sample causes an overestimate. The two trials illustrate opposite errors arising at different stages of the same analytical method. Correct Dumas estimation requires both suitable chemical conversion of sample nitrogen and exclusion of nitrogen from external sources.
214. A nitrogen-containing organic compound is analysed quantitatively by the Dumas method. An equal mass of the same compound is subsequently taken for Kjeldahl estimation.
The Dumas experiment produces \(67.2\,\mathrm{mL}\) of dry molecular nitrogen at STP. Assume the compound is suitable for complete Kjeldahl estimation, so that all its nitrogen will be liberated as ammonia.
Four possible receiving solutions are available for absorbing the ammonia:
| Receiving solution | Volume | Concentration |
| P | \(20.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) | \(0.100\,\mathrm{M}\ \mathrm{H_2SO_4}\) |
| Q | \(30.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) | \(0.100\,\mathrm{M}\ \mathrm{HCl}\) |
| R | \(40.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) | \(0.100\,\mathrm{M}\ \mathrm{HCl}\) |
| S | \(35.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) | \(0.100\,\mathrm{M}\ \mathrm{H_2SO_4}\) |
Which receiving solution has sufficient acid-neutralisation capacity to absorb all the ammonia while retaining excess acid for back-titration?
Take the molar volume at STP as \(22400\,\mathrm{mL\,mol^{-1}}\).
ⓐ. P
ⓑ. Q
ⓒ. R
ⓓ. S
Correct Answer: S
Explanation: \(\textbf{Calculate nitrogen obtained by Dumas estimation:}\)
The dry nitrogen volume is:
\[
V_{\mathrm{N_2}}=67.2\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
At STP:
\[
n_{\mathrm{N_2}}=\frac{67.2}{22400}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{N_2}}=0.00300\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the corresponding ammonia requirement:}\)
Each nitrogen molecule contains two nitrogen atoms, whereas each ammonia molecule contains one.
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3}}=2n_{\mathrm{N_2}}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3}}=2(0.00300)
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3}}=0.00600\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
The receiving solution must neutralise more than \(0.00600\,\mathrm{mol}\) of ammonia to leave excess acid.
\(\textbf{Check receiving solution P:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm{H_2SO_4}}=\frac{20.0\times0.100}{1000}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{H_2SO_4}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Since one mole of sulphuric acid neutralises two moles of ammonia:
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3,capacity}}=2(0.00200)
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3,capacity}}=0.00400\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
This is insufficient.
\(\textbf{Check receiving solution Q:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl}}=\frac{30.0\times0.100}{1000}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl}}=0.00300\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Hydrochloric acid neutralises ammonia in a \(1:1\) ratio.
Therefore, Q is insufficient.
\(\textbf{Check receiving solution R:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl}}=\frac{40.0\times0.100}{1000}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl}}=0.00400\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
This is also insufficient.
\(\textbf{Check receiving solution S:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm{H_2SO_4}}=\frac{35.0\times0.100}{1000}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{H_2SO_4}}=0.00350\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Its ammonia-neutralisation capacity is:
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3,capacity}}=2(0.00350)
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3,capacity}}=0.00700\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
The excess capacity is:
\[
0.00700-0.00600=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
Only S can neutralise the predicted ammonia completely while retaining some unused acid. Merely comparing the volumes of the receiving solutions would be incorrect because hydrochloric acid and sulphuric acid have different neutralisation capacities per mole. The Dumas result establishes the nitrogen quantity, which must then be translated into the corresponding Kjeldahl ammonia amount before selecting a suitable receiving solution.
215. A pure organic compound contains only carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen and oxygen. Separate quantitative analyses of a \(0.300\,\mathrm{g}\) sample give the following results:
- Complete combustion produces \(0.440\,\mathrm{g}\) of carbon dioxide.
- The same combustion produces \(0.180\,\mathrm{g}\) of water.
- Complete Dumas estimation of an equal mass of the compound produces \(44.8\,\mathrm{mL}\) of dry nitrogen at STP.
Assume quantitative measurements, and take the molar volume at STP as \(22400\,\mathrm{mL\,mol^{-1}}\).
What is the percentage of oxygen in the compound?
ⓐ. \(18.7\%\)
ⓑ. \(26.0\%\)
ⓒ. \(34.7\%\)
ⓓ. \(53.3\%\)
Correct Answer: \(34.7\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine carbon from combustion:}\)
The carbon dioxide produced is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{CO_2}}=0.440\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm C}=0.440\times\frac{12}{44}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm C}=0.120\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine hydrogen from combustion:}\)
The water produced is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{H_2O}}=0.180\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Thus:
\[
m_{\mathrm H}=0.180\times\frac{2}{18}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm H}=0.0200\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine nitrogen from Dumas estimation:}\)
The collected nitrogen volume is:
\[
V_{\mathrm{N_2}}=44.8\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
At STP:
\[
n_{\mathrm{N_2}}=\frac{44.8}{22400}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{N_2}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
The mass of molecular nitrogen is:
\[
m_{\mathrm N}=0.00200\times28
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm N}=0.0560\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Apply the four-element mass balance:}\)
The compound is specified to contain only carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen and oxygen.
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm O}
=
m_{\mathrm{sample}}-m_{\mathrm C}-m_{\mathrm H}-m_{\mathrm N}
\]
Substituting:
\[
m_{\mathrm O}
=
0.300-0.120-0.0200-0.0560
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm O}=0.104\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate oxygen percentage:}\)
\[
\%\mathrm O=\frac{0.104}{0.300}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm O=34.666\ldots\%
\]
\[
\%\mathrm O\approx34.7\%
\]
\(\textbf{Consistency check:}\)
The independently estimated elemental percentages are approximately:
\[
\%\mathrm C=40.0\%
\]
\[
\%\mathrm H=6.67\%
\]
\[
\%\mathrm N=18.67\%
\]
The remaining \(34.67\%\) belongs to oxygen.
This deduction is valid because the question excludes sulphur, halogens, phosphorus and other possible constituent elements. The oxygen atoms present in combustion products cannot be used directly to determine the original oxygen content because external oxygen is introduced during combustion. The method therefore combines independent carbon, hydrogen and nitrogen estimations with a justified elemental mass balance.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{34.7\%}
\]
216. Two equal portions of an organic compound suitable for both Dumas and Kjeldahl nitrogen estimation are analysed.
The Dumas experiment produces \(44.8\,\mathrm{mL}\) of dry \(\mathrm{N_2}\) at STP, with complete nitrogen recovery.
In the Kjeldahl experiment, all nitrogen is converted into ammonia, but some ammonia escapes before reaching the receiving flask. The acid consumed by the ammonia actually absorbed is equivalent to \(0.00320\,\mathrm{mol}\) of \(\mathrm{NH_3}\).
Assume the two portions contain equal nitrogen quantities and no other errors occur.
What percentage of the liberated ammonia was successfully absorbed in the Kjeldahl experiment?
ⓐ. \(80.0\%\)
ⓑ. \(60.0\%\)
ⓒ. \(85.7\%\)
ⓓ. \(92.0\%\)
Correct Answer: \(80.0\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the complete nitrogen quantity:}\)
The Dumas experiment is stated to be quantitative.
The dry nitrogen volume is:
\[
V_{\mathrm{N_2}}=44.8\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
At STP:
\[
n_{\mathrm{N_2}}=\frac{44.8}{22400}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{N_2}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Convert the nitrogen quantity into ammonia:}\)
Every \(\mathrm{N_2}\) molecule contains two nitrogen atoms.
Every \(\mathrm{NH_3}\) molecule contains one nitrogen atom.
Therefore, complete Kjeldahl conversion should produce:
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3,theoretical}}=2n_{\mathrm{N_2}}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3,theoretical}}=2(0.00200)
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3,theoretical}}=0.00400\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Identify the absorbed ammonia:}\)
The experimentally determined acid consumption corresponds to:
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3,absorbed}}=0.00320\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
This is smaller than the theoretical ammonia amount.
\(\textbf{Calculate absorption recovery:}\)
\[
\%\mathrm{recovery}
=
\frac{n_{\mathrm{NH_3,absorbed}}}
{n_{\mathrm{NH_3,theoretical}}}\times100
\]
Substituting:
\[
\%\mathrm{recovery}
=
\frac{0.00320}{0.00400}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{recovery}=80.0\%
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The Dumas result establishes the complete amount of nitrogen in the portion. Converting that nitrogen-atom quantity into the expected ammonia amount gives a reference against which the Kjeldahl collection can be assessed. The smaller measured ammonia amount is attributed to transfer loss because complete ammonia formation and all other experimental conditions are specified. The percentage recovered is therefore the absorbed ammonia amount divided by the expected ammonia amount. A valid quantitative comparison requires conservation of nitrogen atoms, not equality of the mole amounts of \(\mathrm{N_2}\) and \(\mathrm{NH_3}\).
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{80.0\%}
\]
217. A \(0.300\,\mathrm{g}\) organic sample contains chlorine and bromine. Complete quantitative treatment produces \(0.475\,\mathrm{g}\) of a dry mixture consisting only of silver chloride and silver bromide.
The mixed precipitate is treated with aqueous ammonia under conditions independently verified to dissolve all silver chloride while leaving silver bromide undissolved. After separation and drying, the insoluble portion weighs \(0.188\,\mathrm{g}\).
Assume no material is lost during either separation and the dissolved silver chloride is accounted for quantitatively.
Using \(Ag=108\), \(Cl=35.5\) and \(Br=80\), which pair gives the percentages of chlorine and bromine, respectively, in the original sample?
ⓐ. \(23.7\%\) and \(26.7\%\)
ⓑ. \(26.7\%\) and \(23.7\%\)
ⓒ. \(35.5\%\) and \(40.0\%\)
ⓓ. \(47.8\%\) and \(62.7\%\)
Correct Answer: \(23.7\%\) and \(26.7\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the separated silver halides:}\)
The total silver-halide precipitate weighs:
\[
m_{\mathrm{total}}=0.475\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Under the specified ammonia-treatment conditions, silver chloride dissolves completely, while silver bromide remains undissolved.
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=0.188\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate silver chloride mass:}\)
\[
m_{\mathrm{AgCl}}=m_{\mathrm{total}}-m_{\mathrm{AgBr}}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{AgCl}}=0.475-0.188
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{AgCl}}=0.287\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine chlorine mass:}\)
The molar mass of silver chloride is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgCl}}=108+35.5
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgCl}}=143.5\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Each mole of silver chloride contains one mole of chlorine atoms.
\[
m_{\mathrm{Cl}}=0.287\times\frac{35.5}{143.5}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Cl}}=0.0710\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine bromine mass:}\)
The molar mass of silver bromide is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=108+80
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=188\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Br}}=0.188\times\frac{80}{188}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Br}}=0.0800\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the individual percentages:}\)
The original sample weighs \(0.300\,\mathrm{g}\).
For chlorine:
\[
\%\mathrm{Cl}=\frac{0.0710}{0.300}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{Cl}=23.666\ldots\%
\]
For bromine:
\[
\%\mathrm{Br}=\frac{0.0800}{0.300}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{Br}=26.666\ldots\%
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The initial precipitate mass cannot be converted using a single silver-halide gravimetric factor because it contains two different compounds. The selective ammonia treatment provides the additional information needed to determine the two masses separately. The chlorine and bromine contributions must then be calculated using their respective silver-halide molar masses. The sample mass is the denominator for both elemental percentages.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\left(\%\mathrm{Cl},\%\mathrm{Br}\right)=(23.7\%,\,26.7\%)}
\]
218. A pure organic compound contains only carbon, hydrogen, bromine and oxygen. Quantitative analysis of a \(0.278\,\mathrm{g}\) sample produces the following results:
| Estimation | Measured analytical product |
| Carbon | \(0.176\,\mathrm{g}\) of \(\mathrm{CO_2}\) |
| Hydrogen | \(0.0540\,\mathrm{g}\) of \(\mathrm{H_2O}\) |
| Bromine | \(0.376\,\mathrm{g}\) of \(\mathrm{AgBr}\) |
Assume all estimations are quantitative and no other elements are present.
Using \(Ag=108\), \(Br=80\), \(C=12\), \(H=1\) and \(O=16\), what is the oxygen percentage of the compound?
ⓐ. \(16.0\%\)
ⓑ. \(20.1\%\)
ⓒ. \(28.8\%\)
ⓓ. \(23.0\%\)
Correct Answer: \(23.0\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine carbon mass:}\)
The carbon dioxide produced is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{CO_2}}=0.176\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm C}=0.176\times\frac{12}{44}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm C}=0.0480\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine hydrogen mass:}\)
The water produced is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{H_2O}}=0.0540\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Hence:
\[
m_{\mathrm H}=0.0540\times\frac{2}{18}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm H}=0.00600\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine bromine mass:}\)
The recovered silver bromide weighs:
\[
m_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=0.376\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Its molar mass is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=108+80
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=188\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The corresponding bromine mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Br}}=0.376\times\frac{80}{188}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Br}}=0.160\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate oxygen by difference:}\)
The sample contains only carbon, hydrogen, bromine and oxygen.
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm O}
=
m_{\mathrm{sample}}-m_{\mathrm C}-m_{\mathrm H}-m_{\mathrm{Br}}
\]
Substituting:
\[
m_{\mathrm O}
=
0.278-0.0480-0.00600-0.160
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm O}=0.0640\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate oxygen percentage:}\)
\[
\%\mathrm O=\frac{0.0640}{0.278}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm O=23.0215\ldots\%
\]
\[
\%\mathrm O\approx23.0\%
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The calculation combines combustion measurements with Carius gravimetry. Carbon and hydrogen are determined from their oxidation products, whereas bromine is determined from the mass of silver bromide. The masses of the analytical products cannot be added directly because they contain atoms supplied by reagents. Each product must first be converted into the mass of the relevant original element. Oxygen can then be calculated by difference because the elemental composition is explicitly restricted to four elements.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{23.0\%}
\]
219. A pure organic compound contains both nitrogen and bromine. Equal masses of the compound are subjected separately to complete Dumas nitrogen estimation and quantitative Carius bromine estimation.
The following results are obtained:
- Dumas estimation gives \(22.4\,\mathrm{mL}\) of dry \(\mathrm{N_2}\) at STP.
- Carius estimation gives \(0.188\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure, dry \(\mathrm{AgBr}\).
Assume quantitative recovery in both methods.
Using \(Ag=108\), \(Br=80\) and the molar volume at STP as \(22400\,\mathrm{mL\,mol^{-1}}\), what is the ratio of the number of nitrogen atoms to bromine atoms in the analysed portion?
ⓐ. \(1:2\)
ⓑ. \(1:1\)
ⓒ. \(4:1\)
ⓓ. \(2:1\)
Correct Answer: \(2:1\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine nitrogen molecules from Dumas data:}\)
The collected molecular nitrogen volume is:
\[
V_{\mathrm{N_2}}=22.4\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
At STP:
\[
n_{\mathrm{N_2}}=\frac{22.4}{22400}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{N_2}}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Convert nitrogen molecules into nitrogen atoms:}\)
Each \(\mathrm{N_2}\) molecule contains two nitrogen atoms.
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{N\ atoms}}=2n_{\mathrm{N_2}}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{N\ atoms}}=2(0.00100)
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{N\ atoms}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine bromine from Carius data:}\)
The silver bromide mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=0.188\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Its molar mass is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=108+80
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=188\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=\frac{0.188}{188}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Each silver bromide formula unit contains one bromine atom.
Thus:
\[
n_{\mathrm{Br\ atoms}}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Compare the elemental atom quantities:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm N}:n_{\mathrm{Br}}
=
0.00200:0.00100
\]
Dividing both terms by \(0.00100\):
\[
n_{\mathrm N}:n_{\mathrm{Br}}=2:1
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
Dumas provides the amount of molecular nitrogen, whereas Carius estimation provides the amount of silver bromide. Their formulae contain different numbers of the elements being estimated. Two nitrogen atoms occur in each \(\mathrm{N_2}\) molecule, but only one bromine atom occurs in each \(\mathrm{AgBr}\) formula unit. The measured molar quantities of the two analytical products happen to be equal, but the atomic quantities are not. The result therefore requires converting both products into amounts of their constituent elements before forming the ratio.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{N:Br=2:1}
\]
220. A pure organic compound contains sulphur and bromine. Equal masses of the compound are analysed separately by quantitative sulphur and bromine estimations.
The sulphur estimation produces \(0.233\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure, dry barium sulphate.
The bromine estimation produces \(0.188\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure, dry silver bromide.
Assume all sulphur and bromine are quantitatively represented by the respective precipitates.
Using \(Ba=137\), \(S=32\), \(Ag=108\), \(Br=80\) and \(O=16\), which statement is correct?
ⓐ. The numbers of sulphur and bromine atoms are equal, but the bromine mass is greater than the sulphur mass.
ⓑ. The numbers of sulphur and bromine atoms are equal, and their masses are also equal.
ⓒ. The sample contains twice as many bromine atoms as sulphur atoms because bromine has a larger atomic mass.
ⓓ. The sulphur mass exceeds the bromine mass because barium sulphate has a larger molar mass than silver bromide.
Correct Answer: The numbers of sulphur and bromine atoms are equal, but the bromine mass is greater than the sulphur mass.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine sulphur amount:}\)
The molar mass of barium sulphate is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=137+32+4(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=233\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The measured precipitate is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=0.233\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=\frac{0.233}{233}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Each barium sulphate formula unit contains one sulphur atom.
Hence:
\[
n_{\mathrm S}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine bromine amount:}\)
The molar mass of silver bromide is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=108+80
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=188\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The precipitate mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=0.188\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=\frac{0.188}{188}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Each silver bromide formula unit contains one bromine atom.
Thus:
\[
n_{\mathrm{Br}}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Compare elemental masses:}\)
The sulphur mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm S}=0.00100\times32
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm S}=0.0320\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The bromine mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Br}}=0.00100\times80
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Br}}=0.0800\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The equal molar quantities of barium sulphate and silver bromide represent equal numbers of sulphur and bromine atoms because both precipitates contain one relevant atom per formula unit. However, bromine atoms are heavier than sulphur atoms. Therefore, the bromine mass is greater even though the atomic amounts are equal. The larger molar mass of barium sulphate does not imply a larger mass of sulphur, because much of the precipitate mass is contributed by barium and oxygen.
221. A pure organic compound contains only carbon, hydrogen, oxygen and sulphur. Separate quantitative analyses of a \(0.460\,\mathrm{g}\) sample give the following results:
- Complete combustion produces \(0.440\,\mathrm{g}\) of carbon dioxide.
- Complete combustion produces \(0.180\,\mathrm{g}\) of water.
- Quantitative sulphur estimation produces \(1.165\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure, dry barium sulphate.
Assume all measurements are accurate and quantitative.
Using \(Ba=137\), \(S=32\), \(C=12\), \(H=1\) and \(O=16\), what is the oxygen percentage of the compound?
ⓐ. \(21.7\%\)
ⓑ. \(27.8\%\)
ⓒ. \(34.8\%\)
ⓓ. \(43.5\%\)
Correct Answer: \(34.8\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Calculate carbon from carbon dioxide:}\)
The carbon dioxide mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{CO_2}}=0.440\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The carbon mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm C}=0.440\times\frac{12}{44}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm C}=0.120\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate hydrogen from water:}\)
The water mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{H_2O}}=0.180\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm H}=0.180\times\frac{2}{18}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm H}=0.0200\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate sulphur from barium sulphate:}\)
The sulphur-estimation product is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=1.165\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The molar mass is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=137+32+4(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=233\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Each mole contains one mole of sulphur atoms.
Hence:
\[
m_{\mathrm S}=1.165\times\frac{32}{233}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm S}=0.160\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine oxygen by difference:}\)
Only carbon, hydrogen, oxygen and sulphur occur in the compound.
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm O}
=
m_{\mathrm{sample}}-m_{\mathrm C}-m_{\mathrm H}-m_{\mathrm S}
\]
Substituting:
\[
m_{\mathrm O}
=
0.460-0.120-0.0200-0.160
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm O}=0.160\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate oxygen percentage:}\)
\[
\%\mathrm O=\frac{0.160}{0.460}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm O=34.7826\ldots\%
\]
\[
\%\mathrm O\approx34.8\%
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The barium sulphate precipitate weighs more than the original organic sample, but this does not make the data inconsistent. The precipitate contains barium and oxygen introduced during the analytical transformations. Only the sulphur fraction of its mass represents sulphur originally present in the sample. The combustion products must similarly be converted into their carbon and hydrogen contributions before the remaining sample mass can be assigned to oxygen. This is an integrated elemental mass-balance calculation involving three different analytical products.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{34.8\%}
\]
222. A \(0.500\,\mathrm{g}\) crude material contains an organic sulphur compound P mixed with \(0.142\,\mathrm{g}\) of anhydrous sodium sulphate. The remaining \(0.358\,\mathrm{g}\) consists entirely of P.
During a quantitative sulphur determination, sulphur from P is completely oxidised to sulphate, and the sulphate originally present as sodium sulphate is also retained quantitatively.
After addition of barium chloride, \(0.699\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure, dry barium sulphate is obtained.
Assume no other sulphur-containing substance is present.
Using \(Na=23\), \(S=32\), \(Ba=137\) and \(O=16\), what is the percentage of sulphur in pure P?
ⓐ. \(12.8\%\)
ⓑ. \(17.9\%\)
ⓒ. \(19.2\%\)
ⓓ. \(28.0\%\)
Correct Answer: \(17.9\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify both sulphur sources:}\)
The recovered barium sulphate contains sulphur derived from:
- Organic compound P after oxidation.
- The sodium sulphate impurity originally present.
The inorganic sulphate contribution must therefore be removed before calculating the sulphur percentage of P.
\(\textbf{Calculate the total sulphur measured:}\)
The molar mass of barium sulphate is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=137+32+4(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=233\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The total precipitate mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=0.699\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=\frac{0.699}{233}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=0.00300\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Each mole of barium sulphate contains one mole of sulphur.
Thus:
\[
n_{\mathrm{S,total}}=0.00300\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine sulphur introduced by sodium sulphate:}\)
The molar mass of sodium sulphate is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{Na_2SO_4}}=2(23)+32+4(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{Na_2SO_4}}=142\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The impurity mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Na_2SO_4}}=0.142\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{Na_2SO_4}}=\frac{0.142}{142}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{Na_2SO_4}}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Each formula unit contains one sulphur atom.
Hence:
\[
n_{\mathrm{S,inorganic}}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Isolate sulphur from P:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm{S,P}}
=
n_{\mathrm{S,total}}-n_{\mathrm{S,inorganic}}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{S,P}}=0.00300-0.00100
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{S,P}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
The corresponding sulphur mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{S,P}}=0.00200\times32
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{S,P}}=0.0640\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate sulphur percentage in pure P:}\)
The mass of P is:
\[
m_{\mathrm P}=0.500-0.142
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm P}=0.358\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\%\mathrm{S\ in\ P}
=
\frac{0.0640}{0.358}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{S\ in\ P}=17.877\ldots\%
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{S\ in\ P}\approx17.9\%
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The analytical precipitate contains sulphur from two chemically different starting sources. Quantitative barium sulphate collection alone does not distinguish organically bound sulphur from sulphate already present as an impurity. The known impurity mass allows its sulphur contribution to be calculated and subtracted. The final percentage must also use the mass of pure P rather than the mass of the entire crude material.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{17.9\%}
\]
223. A \(0.310\,\mathrm{g}\) organic compound containing phosphorus is subjected to quantitative phosphorus estimation. All phosphorus is converted into ammonium phosphomolybdate with the formula:
\[
\mathrm{(NH_4)_3PO_4\cdot12MoO_3}
\]
The recovered precipitate is pure and dry and weighs \(0.9385\,\mathrm{g}\).
Using \(N=14\), \(H=1\), \(P=31\), \(O=16\) and \(Mo=96\), what is the percentage of phosphorus in the compound?
ⓐ. \(2.50\%\)
ⓑ. \(4.13\%\)
ⓒ. \(5.00\%\)
ⓓ. \(10.0\%\)
Correct Answer: \(5.00\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify phosphorus in the product formula:}\)
The analytical product is:
\[
\mathrm{(NH_4)_3PO_4\cdot12MoO_3}
\]
Each formula unit contains one phosphorus atom.
The twelve \(\mathrm{MoO_3}\) units contribute molybdenum and oxygen but no additional phosphorus.
\(\textbf{Calculate the formula mass:}\)
The ammonium contribution is:
\[
3(14+4)=54
\]
The phosphate contribution is:
\[
31+4(16)=95
\]
The molybdenum oxide contribution is:
\[
12[96+3(16)]=12(144)
\]
\[
12(144)=1728
\]
Therefore:
\[
M_{\mathrm{phosphomolybdate}}=54+95+1728
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{phosphomolybdate}}=1877\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Convert precipitate mass into phosphorus mass:}\)
Each mole of precipitate contains \(31\,\mathrm{g}\) of phosphorus.
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm P}
=
m_{\mathrm{precipitate}}\times\frac{31}{1877}
\]
Substituting:
\[
m_{\mathrm P}=0.9385\times\frac{31}{1877}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm P}=0.0155\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate phosphorus percentage:}\)
The original sample weighs:
\[
m_{\mathrm{sample}}=0.310\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Hence:
\[
\%\mathrm P=\frac{0.0155}{0.310}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm P=5.00\%
\]
\(\textbf{Check the analytical relation:}\)
The phosphorus fraction of ammonium phosphomolybdate is relatively small because the precipitate contains substantial amounts of molybdenum and oxygen. Its large mass does not imply that the original organic compound contains a correspondingly large phosphorus mass. Correct gravimetric estimation requires using the complete formula mass and exactly one phosphorus atom per formula unit.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{5.00\%}
\]
224. During quantitative phosphorus estimation, anhydrous magnesium ammonium phosphate, \(\mathrm{MgNH_4PO_4}\), is obtained as an intermediate and subsequently ignited completely to form magnesium pyrophosphate.
For this question, assume the following idealised conversion occurs quantitatively:
\[
\mathrm{2MgNH_4PO_4\rightarrow Mg_2P_2O_7+2NH_3+H_2O}
\]
A sample of the dry intermediate weighs \(0.274\,\mathrm{g}\) before ignition.
Using \(Mg=24\), \(N=14\), \(H=1\), \(P=31\) and \(O=16\), which pair correctly gives the final mass of magnesium pyrophosphate and the total mass lost during ignition, respectively?
ⓐ. \(0.222\,\mathrm{g}\) and \(0.052\,\mathrm{g}\)
ⓑ. \(0.137\,\mathrm{g}\) and \(0.137\,\mathrm{g}\)
ⓒ. \(0.222\,\mathrm{g}\) and \(0.026\,\mathrm{g}\)
ⓓ. \(0.274\,\mathrm{g}\) and \(0.052\,\mathrm{g}\)
Correct Answer: \(0.222\,\mathrm{g}\) and \(0.052\,\mathrm{g}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the molar mass of the initial compound:}\)
The intermediate is anhydrous magnesium ammonium phosphate:
\[
\mathrm{MgNH_4PO_4}
\]
Its molar mass is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{MgNH_4PO_4}}
=
24+14+4(1)+31+4(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{MgNH_4PO_4}}
=
24+14+4+31+64
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{MgNH_4PO_4}}=137\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the initial amount:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm{MgNH_4PO_4}}=\frac{0.274}{137}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{MgNH_4PO_4}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Apply the ignition stoichiometry:}\)
The stated reaction is:
\[
\mathrm{2MgNH_4PO_4\rightarrow Mg_2P_2O_7+2NH_3+H_2O}
\]
Two moles of the initial compound produce one mole of magnesium pyrophosphate.
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}
=
\frac{0.00200}{2}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the final residue mass:}\)
The molar mass of magnesium pyrophosphate is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}
=
2(24)+2(31)+7(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=222\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}
=
0.00100\times222
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=0.222\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the mass lost during ignition:}\)
\[
m_{\mathrm{loss}}=m_{\mathrm{initial}}-m_{\mathrm{final}}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{loss}}=0.274-0.222
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{loss}}=0.0520\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Verify the gaseous products:}\)
The reaction produces two moles of ammonia and one mole of water per mole of magnesium pyrophosphate.
The ammonia mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{NH_3}}=0.00200\times17
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{NH_3}}=0.0340\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The water mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{H_2O}}=0.00100\times18
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{H_2O}}=0.0180\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Their combined mass is:
\[
0.0340+0.0180=0.0520\,\mathrm{g}
\]
This agrees with the mass lost during ignition. The final residue is lighter because ammonia and water leave during the chemical conversion, while phosphorus remains in the magnesium pyrophosphate.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\left(0.222\,\mathrm{g},\,0.0520\,\mathrm{g}\right)}
\]
225. Two equal portions of the same phosphorus-containing organic compound are analysed using alternative quantitative phosphorus-estimation methods.
In Procedure I, all phosphorus is quantitatively recovered as pure, dry magnesium pyrophosphate, \(\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}\), weighing \(0.111\,\mathrm{g}\).
In Procedure II, phosphorus is precipitated as ammonium phosphomolybdate, \(\mathrm{(NH_4)_3PO_4\cdot12MoO_3}\). The collected dry solid weighs \(1.971\,\mathrm{g}\).
Independent evidence establishes that Procedure I is quantitatively accurate, while the solid collected in Procedure II may contain phosphorus-free contamination.
Using \(Mg=24\), \(P=31\), \(Mo=96\), \(N=14\), \(H=1\) and \(O=16\), which conclusion is best supported?
ⓐ. Pure phosphomolybdate should weigh \(1.971\,\mathrm{g}\), so Procedure II contains no contamination.
ⓑ. Pure phosphomolybdate should weigh \(0.938\,\mathrm{g}\), indicating a large excess of collected solid.
ⓒ. Pure phosphomolybdate should weigh \(3.754\,\mathrm{g}\), indicating incomplete precipitation.
ⓓ. Pure phosphomolybdate should weigh \(1.877\,\mathrm{g}\), indicating excess phosphorus-free solid.
Correct Answer: Pure phosphomolybdate should weigh \(1.877\,\mathrm{g}\), indicating excess phosphorus-free solid.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Use the reliable magnesium pyrophosphate result:}\)
Procedure I produces pure, dry magnesium pyrophosphate:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=0.111\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Its molar mass is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}
=
2(24)+2(31)+7(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=222\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=\frac{0.111}{222}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=0.000500\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine elemental phosphorus:}\)
Each magnesium pyrophosphate formula unit contains two phosphorus atoms.
Thus:
\[
n_{\mathrm P}=2n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm P}=2(0.000500)
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm P}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Predict ammonium phosphomolybdate formation:}\)
The alternative product is:
\[
\mathrm{(NH_4)_3PO_4\cdot12MoO_3}
\]
Each formula unit contains one phosphorus atom.
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{phosphomolybdate}}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the alternative product molar mass:}\)
\[
M=3(14+4)+(31+4\times16)+12(96+3\times16)
\]
\[
M=54+95+1728
\]
\[
M=1877\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the expected pure precipitate mass:}\)
\[
m_{\mathrm{expected}}=0.00100\times1877
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{expected}}=1.877\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Compare with the observed mass:}\)
Procedure II reports:
\[
m_{\mathrm{observed}}=1.971\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The difference is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{excess}}=1.971-1.877
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{excess}}=0.0940\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Chemical interpretation:}\)
The original sample portions contain equal quantities of phosphorus, so two valid quantitative methods must represent the same phosphorus amount. The different analytical products naturally have very different masses because they contain different atoms and different numbers of phosphorus atoms per formula unit. However, the reliable magnesium pyrophosphate result establishes a definite expected mass for pure ammonium phosphomolybdate. The observed Procedure II mass exceeds that expectation. Under the given assumptions, this excess is consistent with phosphorus-free contamination of the collected solid. The result must not be interpreted as evidence that the original sample contained more phosphorus in one portion than in the other. The correct comparison conserves elemental phosphorus while accounting for the distinct chemical formulae of the two gravimetric products.
226. In a series of Dumas nitrogen estimations, different masses of the same pure organic compound are analysed. All nitrogen from the compound is converted into molecular nitrogen.
However, a fixed quantity of atmospheric nitrogen remains trapped in the apparatus during every experiment. The reported volumes are converted correctly to dry nitrogen volumes at STP, but the contribution from trapped atmospheric nitrogen is not removed.
A graph is plotted with the mass of organic compound in grams on the horizontal axis and the total measured nitrogen volume at STP in millilitres on the vertical axis. The graph is a straight line passing through the points (0.200 g, 22.4 mL), (0.400 g, 33.6 mL) and (0.600 g, 44.8 mL). Extrapolation to zero sample mass gives a positive vertical intercept.
Assuming the atmospheric nitrogen contribution is constant, what is the actual nitrogen percentage of the organic compound?
Take the molar volume of nitrogen at STP as \(22400\,\mathrm{mL\,mol^{-1}}\).
ⓐ. \(7.00\%\)
ⓑ. \(9.33\%\)
ⓒ. \(14.0\%\)
ⓓ. \(21.0\%\)
Correct Answer: \(7.00\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two contributions to measured nitrogen:}\)
The total volume contains nitrogen derived from the organic compound and a fixed volume of trapped atmospheric nitrogen.
Therefore:
\[
V_{\mathrm{measured}}=V_{\mathrm{sample}}+V_{\mathrm{air}}
\]
Because the compound has a fixed nitrogen percentage, its nitrogen volume is proportional to sample mass.
The constant atmospheric contribution appears as the vertical intercept of the graph.
\(\textbf{Obtain the volume increase due to sample nitrogen:}\)
Two points on the graph are:
\[
(m_1,V_1)=(0.200\,\mathrm{g},22.4\,\mathrm{mL})
\]
\[
(m_2,V_2)=(0.400\,\mathrm{g},33.6\,\mathrm{mL})
\]
The slope is:
\[
\frac{\Delta V}{\Delta m}
=
\frac{33.6-22.4}{0.400-0.200}
\]
\[
\frac{\Delta V}{\Delta m}
=
\frac{11.2}{0.200}
\]
\[
\frac{\Delta V}{\Delta m}
=
56.0\,\mathrm{mL\,g^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Interpret the slope chemically:}\)
The fixed atmospheric contribution cancels when the volume difference is calculated.
Therefore, each gram of the organic compound produces:
\[
V_{\mathrm{N_2,sample}}=56.0\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
at STP.
\(\textbf{Convert nitrogen volume into nitrogen mass:}\)
At STP:
\[
22400\,\mathrm{mL\ of\ N_2}=28\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Consequently:
\[
m_{\mathrm N}
=
56.0\times\frac{28}{22400}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm N}=0.0700\,\mathrm{g}
\]
This nitrogen mass corresponds to \(1.000\,\mathrm{g}\) of compound.
\(\textbf{Calculate the percentage:}\)
\[
\%\mathrm N
=
\frac{0.0700}{1.000}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm N=7.00\%
\]
\(\textbf{Check the atmospheric contribution:}\)
Using the first graph point:
\[
V_{\mathrm{sample}}=0.200\times56.0
\]
\[
V_{\mathrm{sample}}=11.2\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
The trapped atmospheric nitrogen is:
\[
V_{\mathrm{air}}=22.4-11.2
\]
\[
V_{\mathrm{air}}=11.2\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
Thus the positive intercept represents nitrogen unrelated to the sample.
Using the total measured volume directly would overestimate nitrogen percentage.
The slope correctly isolates the quantity that changes with sample mass.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{7.00\%}
\]
227. A \(0.140\,\mathrm{g}\) nitrogen-containing organic compound is analysed by the Dumas method. All its nitrogen is converted into molecular nitrogen.
After passage through the potassium hydroxide absorber, the gas collected at STP has a total volume of \(35.0\,\mathrm{mL}\). Independent gas analysis establishes that \(7.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) of this volume is unabsorbed carbon dioxide, while the remainder is pure nitrogen.
A student incorrectly assumes that the entire \(35.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) represents nitrogen.
Using \(22400\,\mathrm{mL\,mol^{-1}}\) as the molar volume at STP, which pair gives the student's apparent nitrogen percentage and the actual nitrogen percentage, respectively?
ⓐ. \(25.0\%\) and \(31.25\%\)
ⓑ. \(31.25\%\) and \(25.0\%\)
ⓒ. \(35.0\%\) and \(28.0\%\)
ⓓ. \(28.0\%\) and \(22.4\%\)
Correct Answer: \(31.25\%\) and \(25.0\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the error in gas collection:}\)
The total collected gas volume is:
\[
V_{\mathrm{total}}=35.0\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
However, the gas contains:
\[
V_{\mathrm{CO_2}}=7.0\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
The carbon dioxide should have been absorbed by potassium hydroxide before the nitrogen volume was measured.
\(\textbf{Calculate the actual nitrogen volume:}\)
Because both gases are measured at the same temperature and pressure, their volumes are additive under the stated conditions.
\[
V_{\mathrm{N_2}}=V_{\mathrm{total}}-V_{\mathrm{CO_2}}
\]
\[
V_{\mathrm{N_2}}=35.0-7.0
\]
\[
V_{\mathrm{N_2}}=28.0\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the student's apparent nitrogen mass:}\)
The student incorrectly uses the complete collected volume.
\[
m_{\mathrm{N,apparent}}
=
35.0\times\frac{28}{22400}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{N,apparent}}=0.04375\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\%\mathrm{N,apparent}
=
\frac{0.04375}{0.140}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{N,apparent}=31.25\%
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the actual nitrogen mass:}\)
Only \(28.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) is molecular nitrogen.
\[
m_{\mathrm{N,actual}}
=
28.0\times\frac{28}{22400}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{N,actual}}=0.0350\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The correct nitrogen percentage is:
\[
\%\mathrm{N,actual}
=
\frac{0.0350}{0.140}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{N,actual}=25.0\%
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The Dumas calculation assumes that the measured gas consists of nitrogen after removal of carbon dioxide.
Incomplete carbon dioxide absorption violates this assumption.
The residual carbon dioxide contributes volume but contains no nitrogen.
Consequently, assigning its volume to nitrogen produces an excessive nitrogen mass.
The experiment differs from atmospheric nitrogen contamination because the interfering gas is carbon dioxide that should have been removed chemically.
Both errors increase the apparent gas volume, but they arise from different analytical failures.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\left(31.25\%,\,25.0\%\right)}
\]
228. An organic compound is suitable for Kjeldahl nitrogen estimation. After complete digestion with concentrated sulphuric acid, the nitrogen is present as ammonium sulphate in the acidic digestion mixture.
A student adds sodium hydroxide solution and immediately begins distillation. However, the amount of sodium hydroxide added is insufficient to neutralise the remaining sulphuric acid and make the digestion mixture alkaline.
Only a small amount of ammonia reaches the receiving flask containing standard acid.
Which interpretation is most appropriate?
ⓐ. The low ammonia recovery establishes that most nitrogen was destroyed during digestion.
ⓑ. The acidic digestion mixture necessarily converts all ammonium ions into molecular nitrogen.
ⓒ. The Kjeldahl method cannot be used for any compound containing an amide group.
ⓓ. Insufficient alkali may prevent quantitative ammonia liberation and lead to an underestimated nitrogen result.
Correct Answer: Insufficient alkali may prevent quantitative ammonia liberation and lead to an underestimated nitrogen result.
Explanation: Kjeldahl analysis involves two chemically distinct stages before ammonia is measured. During suitable digestion, nitrogen in an applicable organic compound is converted into ammonium sulphate. The digestion mixture contains sulphuric acid because concentrated sulphuric acid is used in the analytical treatment. During the subsequent stage, excess sodium hydroxide must establish sufficiently alkaline conditions to liberate ammonia from the ammonium salt. The relevant reaction is \(\mathrm{(NH_4)_2SO_4+2NaOH\rightarrow Na_2SO_4+2NH_3+2H_2O}\). If the added sodium hydroxide is consumed by the remaining acid, insufficient alkali may be available to convert ammonium ions quantitatively into ammonia. The amount of ammonia reaching the receiving acid will then be smaller than the amount corresponding to the original nitrogen. The back-titration consequently indicates an artificially low acid consumption by ammonia. This leads to an underestimated nitrogen percentage. The observation does not establish that nitrogen was destroyed during the digestion stage. It instead indicates that the subsequent chemical conditions were unsuitable for complete release of the analytical product. Heating an insufficiently alkaline mixture does not replace the need to establish the appropriate acid-base conditions. Correct Kjeldahl estimation requires complete digestion, sufficient alkali and quantitative transfer of the liberated ammonia.
229. In a Kjeldahl nitrogen estimation, an organic sample is digested correctly. Excess sodium hydroxide is then added, and the liberated ammonia is distilled into a known excess of standard hydrochloric acid.
During distillation, vigorous boiling carries fine droplets of sodium hydroxide solution into the receiving acid along with the ammonia. No ammonia escapes, and all other operations are quantitative.
The unused acid is subsequently determined accurately by back-titration.
Which error is expected if the student assumes that the only substance consuming hydrochloric acid was ammonia?
ⓐ. Nitrogen percentage is underestimated because sodium hydroxide increases the unused acid.
ⓑ. Nitrogen percentage is unchanged because sodium hydroxide and ammonia contain different elements.
ⓒ. Nitrogen percentage is overestimated because sodium hydroxide also consumes receiving acid but is incorrectly counted as ammonia.
ⓓ. Nitrogen percentage becomes zero because sodium hydroxide prevents hydrochloric acid from reacting with ammonia.
Correct Answer: Nitrogen percentage is overestimated because sodium hydroxide also consumes receiving acid but is incorrectly counted as ammonia.
Explanation: The quantitative Kjeldahl calculation is based on measuring how much receiving acid is consumed by ammonia. The ammonia liberated from the digestion product reacts with hydrochloric acid to form ammonium chloride. Under normal conditions, the difference between the initial acid quantity and the unused acid quantity gives the acid consumed by ammonia. In the stated experiment, droplets of sodium hydroxide solution are mechanically carried into the receiving flask. Sodium hydroxide also reacts with hydrochloric acid, producing sodium chloride and water. Therefore, the receiving acid is consumed by two different bases rather than by ammonia alone. The subsequent back-titration correctly measures the acid remaining after both reactions. However, the student's calculation incorrectly attributes the entire decrease in acid quantity to ammonia. The calculated ammonia amount consequently exceeds the amount actually liberated from the nitrogen-containing sample. Since the nitrogen mass is inferred from this apparent ammonia amount, nitrogen percentage is overestimated. The fact that sodium hydroxide contains no nitrogen is precisely why its contribution represents an interference. The error differs from loss of ammonia during transfer, which would generally lead to underestimation. Accurate Kjeldahl analysis requires the receiving acid to react quantitatively with ammonia without contamination by mechanically transported alkali.
230. A pure nitrogen-containing organic compound contains \(48.0\%\) carbon and \(4.0\%\) hydrogen by mass. Independent Dumas estimation establishes that the nitrogen percentage is \(11.2\%\).
Structural evidence shows that its nitrogen occurs in a nitro group, making ordinary Kjeldahl estimation unsuitable under the prescribed conditions.
A student nevertheless performs an ordinary Kjeldahl estimation and obtains no measurable ammonia. The student reports \(0\%\) nitrogen and calculates oxygen percentage by subtracting only carbon and hydrogen percentages from \(100\%\).
Assume the compound contains only carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen and oxygen.
Which pair gives the student's apparent oxygen percentage and the actual oxygen percentage, respectively?
ⓐ. \(36.8\%\) and \(48.0\%\)
ⓑ. \(48.0\%\) and \(36.8\%\)
ⓒ. \(52.0\%\) and \(40.8\%\)
ⓓ. \(40.8\%\) and \(36.8\%\)
Correct Answer: \(48.0\%\) and \(36.8\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the analytical limitation:}\)
The ordinary Kjeldahl method requires nitrogen to be converted into ammonium sulphate during digestion.
Nitrogen present in a nitro group does not undergo the required conversion quantitatively under the prescribed conditions.
Therefore, a zero ammonia result cannot be treated as evidence that the original compound contains no nitrogen.
\(\textbf{Reconstruct the student's calculation:}\)
The measured percentages are:
\[
\%\mathrm C=48.0\%
\]
\[
\%\mathrm H=4.0\%
\]
The student incorrectly assumes:
\[
\%\mathrm N=0
\]
Consequently:
\[
\%\mathrm{O,apparent}=100-48.0-4.0
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{O,apparent}=48.0\%
\]
\(\textbf{Use the valid nitrogen determination:}\)
Independent Dumas estimation gives:
\[
\%\mathrm N=11.2\%
\]
Because the compound contains only carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen and oxygen:
\[
\%\mathrm{O,actual}
=
100-\%\mathrm C-\%\mathrm H-\%\mathrm N
\]
Substituting:
\[
\%\mathrm{O,actual}
=
100-48.0-4.0-11.2
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{O,actual}=36.8\%
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the magnitude of the error:}\)
\[
\Delta(\%\mathrm O)=48.0-36.8
\]
\[
\Delta(\%\mathrm O)=11.2
\]
The student overestimates oxygen by \(11.2\) percentage points.
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
Percentage by difference assigns the unaccounted mass to oxygen only after all other constituent elements have been included correctly.
An invalid nitrogen result causes nitrogen mass to be assigned mistakenly to oxygen.
The disagreement is therefore linked directly to the applicability of the nitrogen-estimation method.
It cannot be corrected by repeating the same unsuitable Kjeldahl procedure without addressing the chemical limitation.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\left(48.0\%,\,36.8\%\right)}
\]
231. A pure organic compound contains carbon, hydrogen, oxygen and exactly one halogen selected from chlorine, bromine and iodine.
Quantitative elemental analysis of a \(0.300\,\mathrm{g}\) sample establishes the following masses of elements originally present:
| Element | Mass in original sample |
| Carbon | \(0.120\,\mathrm{g}\) |
| Hydrogen | \(0.010\,\mathrm{g}\) |
| Oxygen | \(0.090\,\mathrm{g}\) |
A quantitative Carius estimation on an equal mass of the compound produces \(0.188\,\mathrm{g}\) of a pure, dry silver halide.
Assume quantitative recovery and no other elements.
Using \(Ag=108\), \(Cl=35.5\), \(Br=80\) and \(I=127\), which halogen is present?
ⓐ. Chlorine
ⓑ. Bromine
ⓒ. Iodine
ⓓ. The data cannot distinguish bromine from iodine.
Correct Answer: Bromine
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the halogen mass by elemental balance:}\)
The sample contains only carbon, hydrogen, oxygen and one halogen.
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm X}
=
m_{\mathrm{sample}}-m_{\mathrm C}-m_{\mathrm H}-m_{\mathrm O}
\]
Substituting:
\[
m_{\mathrm X}
=
0.300-0.120-0.010-0.090
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm X}=0.0800\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Test the silver chloride possibility:}\)
If the precipitate were silver chloride:
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgCl}}=108+35.5=143.5
\]
The chlorine mass represented would be:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Cl}}
=
0.188\times\frac{35.5}{143.5}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Cl}}\approx0.0465\,\mathrm{g}
\]
This is less than the required halogen mass of \(0.0800\,\mathrm{g}\).
\(\textbf{Test the silver bromide possibility:}\)
If the precipitate were silver bromide:
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=108+80=188
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Br}}
=
0.188\times\frac{80}{188}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Br}}=0.0800\,\mathrm{g}
\]
This exactly matches the halogen mass obtained from the original sample.
\(\textbf{Test the silver iodide possibility:}\)
If the precipitate were silver iodide:
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgI}}=108+127=235
\]
The iodine mass would be:
\[
m_{\mathrm I}
=
0.188\times\frac{127}{235}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm I}\approx0.1016\,\mathrm{g}
\]
This exceeds the halogen mass permitted by the independently established sample composition.
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
All three silver halides contain one halogen atom per formula unit, but their gravimetric factors are different.
The known masses of carbon, hydrogen and oxygen provide an independent constraint on the halogen mass.
Only silver bromide converts the observed precipitate mass into the required elemental mass.
The conclusion therefore does not depend on precipitate colour or ammonia-solubility observations.
It results from compatibility between the Carius measurement and the complete elemental mass balance.
232. A pure organic compound contains chlorine and bromine. Both elements are converted quantitatively into silver chloride and silver bromide during a Carius determination.
A \(0.300\,\mathrm{g}\) sample produces \(0.475\,\mathrm{g}\) of a dry mixture of the two silver halides.
An identical experiment using \(0.600\,\mathrm{g}\) of the compound produces \(0.950\,\mathrm{g}\) of the same mixed precipitate.
No independent measurement of either halogen or of the total number of silver-halide formula units is available.
Which conclusion is justified?
ⓐ. The chlorine and bromine percentages can be determined uniquely because the experiment has been repeated using two sample masses.
ⓑ. The compound contains equal masses of chlorine and bromine because the precipitate mass doubles when the sample mass doubles.
ⓒ. Chlorine must be present in a greater atomic amount because silver chloride has the smaller molar mass.
ⓓ. The individual chlorine and bromine percentages cannot be determined uniquely because the second measurement provides no independent composition relation.
Correct Answer: The individual chlorine and bromine percentages cannot be determined uniquely because the second measurement provides no independent composition relation.
Explanation: The first experiment measures the combined mass of silver chloride and silver bromide. These two precipitates contain different halogens and have different molar masses. Let their respective mole amounts in the first experiment be \(n_{\mathrm{AgCl}}\) and \(n_{\mathrm{AgBr}}\). The gravimetric result provides one relation using the usual atomic-mass approximations:
\[
143.5n_{\mathrm{AgCl}}+188n_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=0.475
\] This relation contains two unknown quantities. Therefore, the individual amounts cannot be obtained from that measurement alone. In the second experiment, the mass of organic sample is doubled. Since the compound is pure and the procedure is quantitative, the amounts of both silver halides also double. Consequently, the precipitate mass doubles from \(0.475\,\mathrm{g}\) to \(0.950\,\mathrm{g}\). The second result confirms proportional scaling but does not provide a new independent relation between chlorine and bromine. It therefore cannot resolve the two unknown amounts. An independent measurement of one halogen, the total halide amount or another chemically distinct analytical quantity would be required. Equal scaling of the total precipitate does not imply equal masses or equal mole amounts of its components. The correct conclusion concerns the insufficiency of the supplied analytical information rather than a failure of precipitation.
233. A sulphur-containing organic compound is analysed by a gravimetric procedure in which sulphur is completely oxidised to sulphate and then precipitated as barium sulphate.
Two otherwise identical analytical portions are prepared:
- Portion I is treated with a suitable acid that introduces no sulphate ions, followed by barium chloride solution.
- Portion II is treated with dilute sulphuric acid before barium chloride is added.
In both portions, all sample-derived sulphate forms barium sulphate. The additional sulphate introduced in Portion II also reacts quantitatively with barium chloride.
Which interpretation is correct if the total precipitate is used without correction?
ⓐ. Portion II overestimates sulphur because the acid introduces sulphate that is incorrectly attributed to the organic sample.
ⓑ. Portion II underestimates sulphur because sulphuric acid converts barium sulphate into soluble barium chloride.
ⓒ. Both portions necessarily give the same sulphur percentage because all sulphate ions are chemically identical.
ⓓ. Portion I overestimates sulphur because a sulphate-free acid contributes additional sulphur atoms during precipitation.
Correct Answer: Portion II overestimates sulphur because the acid introduces sulphate that is incorrectly attributed to the organic sample.
Explanation: Quantitative sulphur estimation is based on measuring the amount of sulphur originally present in the organic compound. The prescribed oxidative treatment converts sample-derived sulphur into sulphate. Barium ions then react with sulphate ions to form insoluble barium sulphate. The gravimetric calculation assumes that the recovered barium sulphate corresponds to sulphur originating from the organic sample. In Portion I, the added acid introduces no additional sulphate, so the stated reaction produces barium sulphate from the sample-derived sulphate alone. In Portion II, dilute sulphuric acid supplies additional sulphate ions. These ions are chemically capable of producing barium sulphate when barium chloride is added. The resulting precipitate therefore contains contributions from both sample-derived sulphate and reagent-derived sulphate. If the entire precipitate is treated as originating from the organic compound, the calculated sulphur mass becomes too large. The resulting sulphur percentage is consequently overestimated. Chemical identity of the sulphate ions does not remove the need to trace their sources. The experiment illustrates that a reagent must not introduce the same analyte-derived species that is being measured quantitatively unless its contribution can be determined and corrected. The error is a source-of-material interference rather than an incorrect molar-mass conversion.
234. An organic compound contains phosphorus and is suitable for quantitative estimation through magnesium pyrophosphate.
After the prescribed preparation, \(0.274\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure, anhydrous magnesium ammonium phosphate, \(\mathrm{MgNH_4PO_4}\), is obtained.
During ignition, exactly half of the magnesium ammonium phosphate molecules undergo the reaction:
\[
\mathrm{2MgNH_4PO_4\rightarrow Mg_2P_2O_7+2NH_3+H_2O}
\]
The other half remain as unchanged anhydrous magnesium ammonium phosphate. Both solids remain in the weighed residue, which is completely dry.
A student incorrectly assumes that the entire residue is magnesium pyrophosphate and calculates its phosphorus content using the formula \(\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}\).
Using \(Mg=24\), \(N=14\), \(H=1\), \(P=31\) and \(O=16\), which statement is correct?
ⓐ. The calculated phosphorus mass is less than the actual phosphorus mass because ignition is incomplete.
ⓑ. The calculated phosphorus mass equals the actual phosphorus mass because no phosphorus is lost.
ⓒ. Incomplete ignition leaves a heavier residue than pure magnesium pyrophosphate, so the estimated phosphorus mass is too large.
ⓓ. The residue cannot contain phosphorus because the unreacted magnesium ammonium phosphate remains anhydrous.
Correct Answer: Incomplete ignition leaves a heavier residue than pure magnesium pyrophosphate, so the estimated phosphorus mass is too large.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the initial amount of phosphate:}\)
The molar mass of anhydrous magnesium ammonium phosphate is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{MgNH_4PO_4}}
=
24+14+4+31+4(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{MgNH_4PO_4}}=137\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The initial mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{initial}}=0.274\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{initial}}=\frac{0.274}{137}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{initial}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the unreacted portion:}\)
Half the initial compound remains unchanged.
\[
n_{\mathrm{unreacted}}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Its mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{unreacted}}=0.00100\times137
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{unreacted}}=0.137\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the pyrophosphate formed:}\)
The other half consists of \(0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}\) of magnesium ammonium phosphate.
Two moles form one mole of magnesium pyrophosphate.
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=\frac{0.00100}{2}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=0.000500\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
The molar mass of magnesium pyrophosphate is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=2(24)+2(31)+7(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=222\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Thus:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=0.000500\times222
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=0.111\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the actual residue mass:}\)
\[
m_{\mathrm{residue}}=0.137+0.111
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{residue}}=0.248\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Compare actual and apparent phosphorus:}\)
The original \(0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}\) of magnesium ammonium phosphate contains \(0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}\) of phosphorus atoms.
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,true}}=0.00200\times31
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,true}}=0.0620\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The student incorrectly treats the complete \(0.248\,\mathrm{g}\) residue as magnesium pyrophosphate.
Thus:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,apparent}}=0.248\times\frac{62}{222}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,apparent}}\approx0.0693\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Consequently:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,apparent}}\gt m_{\mathrm{P,true}}
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
Phosphorus has not been lost during ignition, but the final residue is not chemically uniform. Unreacted magnesium ammonium phosphate contains ammonium and other components that would have been removed as gaseous products during complete conversion. Its retention makes the residue heavier than the corresponding fully ignited magnesium pyrophosphate. Treating that extra mass as magnesium pyrophosphate produces an excessive phosphorus estimate. The error arises from an incorrect assumption about the identity of the weighed material, not from a failure to conserve phosphorus.
235. A \(0.300\,\mathrm{g}\) organic sample contains chlorine and bromine. Under suitable quantitative Carius conditions, all halogens are converted into silver chloride and silver bromide.
The combined pure, dry silver-halide precipitate weighs \(0.49725\,\mathrm{g}\). An independent measurement establishes that precisely \(0.00300\,\mathrm{mol}\) of silver(I) ions were consumed in forming these two precipitates.
Assume no competing reaction consumes silver(I).
Using \(Ag=108\), \(Cl=35.5\) and \(Br=80\), what are the individual percentages of chlorine and bromine, respectively?
ⓐ. \(23.7\%\) and \(26.7\%\)
ⓑ. \(17.75\%\) and \(40.0\%\)
ⓒ. \(40.0\%\) and \(17.75\%\)
ⓓ. \(26.7\%\) and \(23.7\%\)
Correct Answer: \(17.75\%\) and \(40.0\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Use the silver-ion consumption data:}\)
The precipitation reactions are:
\[
\mathrm{Ag^++Cl^-\rightarrow AgCl(s)}
\]
\[
\mathrm{Ag^++Br^-\rightarrow AgBr(s)}
\]
Each silver-halide formula unit contains one silver ion.
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{AgCl}}+n_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=0.00300
\]
\(\textbf{Express the total precipitate mass:}\)
The molar masses are:
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgCl}}=108+35.5=143.5
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=108+80=188
\]
Let:
\[
n_{\mathrm{AgCl}}=x
\]
Then:
\[
n_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=0.00300-x
\]
The measured precipitate mass gives:
\[
143.5x+188(0.00300-x)=0.49725
\]
\(\textbf{Solve for silver chloride:}\)
Expanding:
\[
143.5x+0.564-188x=0.49725
\]
\[
44.5x=0.564-0.49725
\]
\[
44.5x=0.06675
\]
\[
x=0.00150\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{AgCl}}=0.00150\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine silver bromide:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=0.00300-0.00150
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=0.00150\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the elemental masses:}\)
Each mole of silver chloride contains one mole of chlorine atoms.
\[
m_{\mathrm{Cl}}=0.00150\times35.5
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Cl}}=0.05325\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Similarly:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Br}}=0.00150\times80
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Br}}=0.120\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the percentages:}\)
For chlorine:
\[
\%\mathrm{Cl}=\frac{0.05325}{0.300}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{Cl}=17.75\%
\]
For bromine:
\[
\%\mathrm{Br}=\frac{0.120}{0.300}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{Br}=40.0\%
\]
\(\textbf{Check the total precipitate mass:}\)
The calculated silver chloride mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{AgCl}}=0.00150\times143.5
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{AgCl}}=0.21525\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The calculated silver bromide mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=0.00150\times188
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{AgBr}}=0.28200\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Their sum is:
\[
0.21525+0.28200=0.49725\,\mathrm{g}
\]
This agrees with the measured precipitate mass.
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The total precipitate mass alone does not uniquely determine the chlorine and bromine quantities. The independent silver-ion consumption measurement supplies a second relation. Together, the total mole amount and total mass determine the individual quantities of the two silver halides. Although the mole amounts of chlorine and bromine are equal, their mass percentages differ because bromine has the larger atomic mass.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\left(\%\mathrm{Cl},\%\mathrm{Br}\right)=(17.75\%,\,40.0\%)}
\]
236. A nitrogen-containing organic compound is analysed by the Dumas method. The collected gas volume is measured at \(27^\circ\mathrm{C}\) and then corrected to STP.
A student uses \(27\) directly as the temperature in the combined gas equation instead of converting \(27^\circ\mathrm{C}\) into the absolute temperature scale.
Assume the dry nitrogen pressure and all other measurements are correct.
Which statement describes the effect of this error on the calculated STP nitrogen volume and nitrogen percentage?
ⓐ. Both are overestimated because the student has used a smaller temperature in the denominator.
ⓑ. Both are underestimated because the incorrect temperature makes the calculated STP volume too small.
ⓒ. The nitrogen percentage is unchanged because the temperature error cancels when the gas mass is calculated.
ⓓ. Only the corrected gas pressure is affected; the nitrogen amount remains correct.
Correct Answer: Both are overestimated because the student has used a smaller temperature in the denominator.
Explanation: The Dumas calculation uses the measured nitrogen gas volume to determine the amount of molecular nitrogen produced. When the gas is collected at a temperature different from STP, its volume must be corrected using an absolute-temperature relation. The relevant gas equation for a fixed amount of ideal gas is:
\[
\frac{PV}{T}=\text{constant}
\] Absolute temperature must therefore be expressed in kelvin. A temperature of \(27^\circ\mathrm{C}\) corresponds to approximately \(300\,\mathrm{K}\).
\[
T=27+273=300\,\mathrm{K}
\] The correct STP-volume relation contains the following temperature factor, together with the appropriate pressure correction:
\[
\frac{T_{\mathrm{STP}}}{T_{\mathrm{sample}}}=\frac{273}{300}
\] If the student substitutes \(27\) in place of \(300\), the temperature factor becomes:
\[
\frac{273}{27}
\] This incorrect factor is much larger than the correct value. Consequently, the student calculates an excessively large STP nitrogen volume from the same observed gas. The inferred number of moles of nitrogen and its mass are correspondingly too large. Since the original sample mass is unchanged, the calculated nitrogen percentage is also overestimated. The error is not corrected by using the proper dry nitrogen pressure because pressure and temperature are separate components of the gas-law conversion. The absolute-temperature requirement is therefore essential to quantitative gas-volume analysis.
237. Two nitrogen-estimation results are obtained for a nitrogen-containing organic compound.
| Method | Reported nitrogen percentage |
| Dumas | \(15.0\%\) |
| Ordinary Kjeldahl | \(12.0\%\) |
The Dumas experiment is known to be quantitatively accurate. The original compound contains nitrogen in a chemical environment for which ordinary Kjeldahl conversion is not guaranteed to be complete.
A student concludes that the Kjeldahl apparatus must have collected exactly \(80.0\%\) of the ammonia actually liberated.
Which statement correctly evaluates this conclusion?
ⓐ. The ratio \(12.0/15.0=0.800\) directly measures ammonia-collection efficiency.
ⓑ. The conclusion is necessarily correct because Kjeldahl always converts every nitrogen environment completely.
ⓒ. The conclusion is incorrect because Dumas and Kjeldahl must produce equal volumes of molecular nitrogen.
ⓓ. Poor Kjeldahl recovery could arise from incomplete organic nitrogen conversion, not solely inefficient ammonia collection.
Correct Answer: Poor Kjeldahl recovery could arise from incomplete organic nitrogen conversion, not solely inefficient ammonia collection.
Explanation: The Dumas result is specified to be quantitatively accurate, so \(15.0\%\) represents the total nitrogen content of the compound. The Kjeldahl result is lower, indicating that the analytical method has not represented all original nitrogen in the final measured ammonia quantity. However, the shortfall can arise at more than one chemical or experimental stage. Ordinary Kjeldahl estimation first requires nitrogen in the original compound to undergo conversion into ammonium sulphate during digestion. The subsequent treatment with excess alkali liberates ammonia from the ammonium salt. The ammonia must then be transferred and absorbed quantitatively in standard acid. The question explicitly states that the original nitrogen environment does not guarantee complete Kjeldahl conversion. Therefore, some nitrogen may fail to enter the ammonia-producing analytical pathway even if every molecule of ammonia actually liberated is collected. Alternatively, incomplete collection could also reduce the measured ammonia amount. The ratio \(12.0/15.0\) describes the fraction of total nitrogen represented by the final reported result, but it does not independently identify which stage caused the shortfall. Assigning the entire difference to ammonia loss is therefore unjustified. A separate assessment of digestion completeness or ammonia collection would be needed to isolate the cause. The correct inference distinguishes total analytical recovery from the efficiency of one particular stage.
238. A pure organic compound contains carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen and oxygen. Quantitative combustion of a \(0.250\,\mathrm{g}\) sample produces \(0.330\,\mathrm{g}\) of carbon dioxide and \(0.135\,\mathrm{g}\) of water.
A separate Dumas estimation establishes that the compound contains \(16.8\%\) nitrogen.
An analyst proposes that the compound contains \(30.0\%\) oxygen and that the remaining mass is accounted for by carbon, hydrogen and nitrogen.
Which statement is correct?
ⓐ. The proposed \(30.0\%\) is too high; the data instead require \(24.4\%\) oxygen.
ⓑ. The proposed \(30.0\%\) is too low; the data instead require \(36.0\%\) oxygen.
ⓒ. The proposed \(30.0\%\) agrees with the separately measured carbon, hydrogen and nitrogen masses.
ⓓ. The proposed \(30.0\%\) is too low; the data instead require \(41.2\%\) oxygen.
Correct Answer: The proposed \(30.0\%\) is too low; the data instead require \(41.2\%\) oxygen.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine carbon from combustion:}\)
The collected carbon dioxide is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{CO_2}}=0.330\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm C}=0.330\times\frac{12}{44}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm C}=0.0900\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine hydrogen from combustion:}\)
The collected water is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{H_2O}}=0.135\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Thus:
\[
m_{\mathrm H}=0.135\times\frac{2}{18}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm H}=0.0150\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine nitrogen mass from its percentage:}\)
The original sample weighs:
\[
m_{\mathrm{sample}}=0.250\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Its nitrogen percentage is \(16.8\%\).
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm N}=0.250\times\frac{16.8}{100}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm N}=0.0420\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Apply elemental mass conservation:}\)
The compound contains only carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen and oxygen.
Hence:
\[
m_{\mathrm O}
=
m_{\mathrm{sample}}-m_{\mathrm C}-m_{\mathrm H}-m_{\mathrm N}
\]
Substituting:
\[
m_{\mathrm O}
=
0.250-0.0900-0.0150-0.0420
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm O}=0.103\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the required oxygen percentage:}\)
\[
\%\mathrm O=\frac{0.103}{0.250}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm O=41.2\%
\]
\(\textbf{Test the proposed composition:}\)
The carbon percentage is:
\[
\%\mathrm C=\frac{0.0900}{0.250}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm C=36.0\%
\]
The hydrogen percentage is:
\[
\%\mathrm H=\frac{0.0150}{0.250}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm H=6.0\%
\]
Combining the measured carbon, hydrogen and nitrogen percentages with the proposed oxygen percentage gives:
\[
36.0+6.0+16.8+30.0=88.8\%
\]
This does not account for the complete mass of a compound containing only the four specified elements.
The oxygen percentage must therefore be \(41.2\%\), not \(30.0\%\).
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The presence of nitrogen does not prevent oxygen estimation by difference when nitrogen has been measured independently and no other elements occur. The combustion-product masses must first be converted into the corresponding carbon and hydrogen masses. Their oxygen contributions cannot be assigned directly to the original organic sample because oxygen is also supplied during combustion.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
41.2\%
\]
239. An organic compound P is present in an aqueous solution. A suitable water-immiscible organic solvent dissolves P, but the distribution of P between the two liquids is such that each ordinary extraction removes only a relatively small fraction of the dissolved compound.
A student proposes using a very large volume of solvent in a single extraction. Another student proposes continuous extraction, in which the aqueous solution is repeatedly contacted with suitable extracting solvent that is recovered and reused.
Which statement best evaluates the two proposals?
ⓐ. Continuous extraction is unsuitable because a compound must transfer completely into the organic solvent during its first contact.
ⓑ. Continuous extraction can improve overall recovery through repeated contact, even though each individual contact transfers only a fraction of P.
ⓒ. Continuous extraction makes P infinitely soluble in the organic solvent, eliminating the distribution of P between the liquids.
ⓓ. A single extraction must give complete recovery whenever the organic solvent is immiscible with water.
Correct Answer: Continuous extraction can improve overall recovery through repeated contact, even though each individual contact transfers only a fraction of P.
Explanation: Differential extraction depends on the unequal distribution of a solute between two suitable immiscible liquids. A favourable extracting solvent need not remove every molecule of the desired compound during one contact. Some solute generally remains in the original liquid because distribution occurs between the two phases. When the fraction transferred during one extraction is small, ordinary extraction may require a considerable quantity of solvent to achieve satisfactory recovery. Continuous extraction provides a useful alternative in such circumstances. Repeated contact with the extracting solvent allows additional quantities of P to transfer from the aqueous phase. Recovering and reusing the solvent can reduce the need for a continuously increasing supply of fresh extracting liquid. However, continuous extraction does not make the solute infinitely soluble or abolish its distribution behaviour. Each contact remains governed by the relevant solubility and partition characteristics. The advantage arises from repeated opportunities for transfer rather than a change in the chemical identity of P. Greater recovery also does not automatically establish that the final extract is completely free from other soluble substances. The correct evaluation therefore distinguishes the limited efficiency of an individual extraction from the potentially greater cumulative recovery of repeated extraction.
240. An aqueous solution contains \(6.00\,\mathrm{g}\) of desired organic compound P and \(4.00\,\mathrm{g}\) of an unwanted organic compound Q.
A suitable extracting solvent is used in successive identical extraction operations. Under the stated conditions, each operation removes \(40.0\%\) of the P and \(10.0\%\) of the Q remaining in the aqueous phase immediately before that operation.
The organic extracts are combined after each operation.
Which statement correctly compares the combined organic extract after two operations with the extract obtained after only one operation?
ⓐ. Both recovery of P and purity of P increase.
ⓑ. Recovery of P decreases, while purity of P increases.
ⓒ. Recovery of P increases, while purity of P decreases.
ⓓ. Both recovery of P and purity of P decrease.
Correct Answer: Recovery of P increases, while purity of P decreases.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the first extraction composition:}\)
Initially:
\[
m_{\mathrm P,0}=6.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm Q,0}=4.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The first extraction removes \(40.0\%\) of P:
\[
m_{\mathrm P,1}=6.00\times0.400
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm P,1}=2.40\,\mathrm{g}
\]
It also removes \(10.0\%\) of Q:
\[
m_{\mathrm Q,1}=4.00\times0.100
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm Q,1}=0.400\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The fraction of P in the recovered solute mixture is:
\[
w_{\mathrm P,1}=\frac{2.40}{2.40+0.400}
\]
\[
w_{\mathrm P,1}=0.85714
\]
The purity of P on a solvent-free solute basis is therefore \(85.7\%\).
Its recovery after one operation is \(40.0\%\).
\(\textbf{Determine the material remaining in water:}\)
After the first extraction:
\[
m_{\mathrm P,remaining}=6.00-2.40
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm P,remaining}=3.60\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Similarly:
\[
m_{\mathrm Q,remaining}=4.00-0.400
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm Q,remaining}=3.60\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the second extraction:}\)
The second extraction removes \(40.0\%\) of the remaining P:
\[
m_{\mathrm P,2}=3.60\times0.400
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm P,2}=1.44\,\mathrm{g}
\]
It removes \(10.0\%\) of the remaining Q:
\[
m_{\mathrm Q,2}=3.60\times0.100
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm Q,2}=0.360\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the combined extract composition:}\)
The total recovered P is:
\[
m_{\mathrm P,total}=2.40+1.44
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm P,total}=3.84\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The total recovered Q is:
\[
m_{\mathrm Q,total}=0.400+0.360
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm Q,total}=0.760\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The new recovery of P is:
\[
\%\mathrm{recovery}=\frac{3.84}{6.00}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{recovery}=64.0\%
\]
The purity of P in the combined recovered solutes is:
\[
\%\mathrm{purity}
=
\frac{3.84}{3.84+0.760}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{purity}=83.48\%
\]
\(\textbf{Compare the two extraction stages:}\)
Recovery increases from \(40.0\%\) to \(64.0\%\). However, purity decreases from approximately \(85.7\%\) to \(83.5\%\). The second extraction recovers additional desired compound but also introduces more impurity into the combined extract. This demonstrates that extraction recovery and extract purity are distinct analytical quantities. Repeated extraction can improve recovery without guaranteeing an increase in selectivity or purity.
241. A mixture contains two organic substances P and Q dissolved in water. P is the desired compound.
Two water-immiscible extraction solvents are available:
| Property | Solvent X | Solvent Y |
| Distribution of P into organic phase | Moderately favourable | Highly favourable |
| Distribution of Q into organic phase | Very unfavourable | Highly favourable |
| Miscibility with water | Immiscible | Immiscible |
| Recovery of extraction solvent | Feasible | Feasible |
The objective is to recover P with minimal contamination by Q. The student can employ repeated or continuous extraction if necessary.
Which strategy is most defensible?
ⓐ. Prefer Y because its high extraction efficiency for P guarantees that Q will not contaminate the extract.
ⓑ. Prefer Y and continue extraction until the remaining aqueous solution is free from both substances.
ⓒ. Reject X because a solvent must remove nearly all P in one contact to be suitable for extraction.
ⓓ. Repeated extraction with X may exploit its better selectivity for P over Q, despite Y's higher single-contact recovery.
Correct Answer: Repeated extraction with X may exploit its better selectivity for P over Q, despite Y's higher single-contact recovery.
Explanation: The most suitable extraction solvent depends on the intended separation, not merely on the amount of desired compound transferred during one contact. Solvent Y extracts P strongly, which is favourable for recovery. However, Y also extracts Q strongly, so the resulting organic phase may contain substantial contamination. High recovery of P therefore does not necessarily imply a high-purity extract. Solvent X transfers P less efficiently during an individual extraction. Nevertheless, Q has very little tendency to enter X, making the solvent more selective for P. Repeated extraction with X can recover additional P through successive contacts. Continuous extraction may also be useful when ordinary extraction would otherwise require a large quantity of solvent. These operations improve cumulative recovery without requiring X to become a stronger solvent for Q. The final choice must consider both the preferential distribution of P relative to Q and the recovery required. Extracting both substances completely into Y would not accomplish their separation from each other. A solvent with moderate recovery but favourable selectivity can consequently be more useful than one with high recovery of both components. The problem illustrates the distinction between extraction efficiency, separation selectivity and final product purity.
242. A crystalline organic compound P is contaminated with two impurities, Q and R.
The following properties are established:
- Q is insoluble in the chosen hot crystallisation solvent.
- R is readily soluble in the solvent at both high and low temperatures.
- P dissolves readily in the hot solvent but has low solubility when cold.
A student dissolves the impure solid in the minimum suitable quantity of hot solvent. Instead of filtering the hot solution, the student cools it immediately and then collects all the deposited solid.
Which outcome is most likely, assuming the insoluble Q remains as suspended solid during cooling?
ⓐ. P may crystallise together with suspended Q, while much of R remains in the mother liquor.
ⓑ. Q becomes soluble as the mixture cools, so hot filtration offers no additional separation.
ⓒ. R must crystallise completely before P because R remains highly soluble in the cold solvent.
ⓓ. Both Q and R are removed automatically when the hot solution is cooled, so filtration before cooling is unnecessary.
Correct Answer: P may crystallise together with suspended Q, while much of R remains in the mother liquor.
Explanation: Crystallisation relies on differences in solubility between the desired compound and its impurities. P is suitable for purification because it dissolves readily in the hot solvent but becomes much less soluble on cooling. R remains soluble at both temperatures, so it tends to remain in the mother liquor when P crystallises. Q behaves differently because it is insoluble even in the hot solvent. A suitable hot-filtration step can therefore remove Q before crystallisation is initiated. If hot filtration is omitted, the suspended Q remains in the mixture as the solution cools. P may then crystallise in the presence of the insoluble particles of Q. Collecting all deposited solid can carry Q into the recovered crystalline fraction. The student has therefore failed to separate an insoluble impurity at the stage where its different solubility should have been used. Cooling alone does not guarantee removal of an impurity that was never dissolved. The soluble R and insoluble Q require different separation decisions within the same crystallisation procedure. The correct sequence exploits the hot-state insolubility of Q and the cold-state low solubility of P without assuming that all impurities behave identically.
243. A mixture contains two substances P and Q that can be separated by paper chromatography under suitable conditions.
In Trial I, chromatography paper contains its normal stationary water phase, and a suitable mobile solvent produces two well-separated spots.
In Trial II, the paper is treated so that the stationary water phase is substantially altered before development with the same mobile solvent. The spots now migrate differently.
A student argues that the changed migration proves P and Q underwent chemical decomposition during Trial II.
Which statement gives the best evaluation?
ⓐ. The argument is correct because changing the stationary phase must break covalent bonds in the sample molecules.
ⓑ. The argument is correct because paper chromatography separates substances only by their boiling points.
ⓒ. Changing the stationary phase can change partitioning and migration without chemically decomposing the compounds.
ⓓ. The argument is not justified because paper chromatography has no stationary phase.
Correct Answer: Changing the stationary phase can change partitioning and migration without chemically decomposing the compounds.
Explanation: Paper chromatography is a form of partition chromatography in the NCERT treatment. The chromatography paper contains water that acts as the stationary phase. The developing solvent serves as the mobile phase. Separation occurs because different substances partition to different extents between the stationary and mobile phases. In Trial I, the specified stationary water phase and mobile solvent produce distinct migration behaviours for P and Q. Trial II changes the stationary-phase conditions while retaining the same mobile solvent. Such a change can alter the relative distribution of the substances between the phases. Consequently, their migration distances may change even if their molecular identities remain unchanged. A different chromatographic pattern therefore does not by itself prove decomposition. The student's argument incorrectly treats a change in separation conditions as evidence of a chemical reaction. It also ignores the role of the stationary phase in determining migration. A valid comparison of chromatographic behaviour must consider both phases and the conditions under which the chromatograms were obtained. The observations are consistent with altered partitioning rather than requiring chemical decomposition.
244. A sodium-fusion extract prepared from an organic compound contains sodium cyanide, sodium sulphide and sodium chloride under the specified fusion conditions.
A student divides the extract into three portions to test for nitrogen, sulphur and chlorine.
The following plan is proposed:
| Portion | Proposed treatment |
| I | Boil with concentrated nitric acid before attempting the prescribed cyanide-based nitrogen test |
| II | Boil with concentrated nitric acid before attempting the prescribed sulphide-based sulphur test |
| III | Boil with concentrated nitric acid before adding silver nitrate for the halogen test |
Assume the nitric-acid treatment successfully decomposes cyanide and sulphide while leaving chloride available for detection.
Which assessment is correct?
ⓐ. The proposed pretreatment is equally appropriate for all three portions because nitric acid enhances every sodium-fusion reaction.
ⓑ. Portions I and II may lose the ions required for their intended tests, whereas Portion III benefits from removing interfering ions.
ⓒ. Portion III becomes unsuitable because nitric acid necessarily converts all chloride ions into molecular chlorine.
ⓓ. All three tests remain unaffected because sodium cyanide, sodium sulphide and sodium chloride undergo identical reactions with nitric acid.
Correct Answer: Portions I and II may lose the ions required for their intended tests, whereas Portion III benefits from removing interfering ions.
Explanation: The sodium-fusion extract contains different inorganic ions that serve as analytical products for different elements. Cyanide provides the basis for the prescribed iron-complex nitrogen test. Sulphide provides the basis for the lead acetate and sodium nitroprusside sulphur tests. Chloride is detected through formation of silver chloride with silver nitrate. The purpose of nitric-acid pretreatment depends on which element is being investigated. When chlorine is being detected, cyanide and sulphide are interfering species because they can react with silver(I) ions. Boiling with concentrated nitric acid removes these interfering effects under the prescribed conditions. Thus Portion III benefits from the treatment. For Portion I, however, cyanide is the species needed to establish the nitrogen-detection pathway. Destroying it before the test would undermine the intended reaction. Similarly, removing sulphide from Portion II would make the subsequent sulphide-based sulphur reactions unreliable. This demonstrates why one pretreatment cannot be applied indiscriminately to every aliquot of the same fusion extract. A reagent used to eliminate interference in one test may eliminate the actual analytical species required by another test.
245. In the nitrogen test following suitable sodium fusion, cyanide ions react with iron(II) ions to form hexacyanidoferrate(II), \(\mathrm{[Fe(CN)_6]^{4-}}\). The characteristic Prussian-blue product is represented, without specifying its hydration, by \(\mathrm{Fe_4[Fe(CN)_6]_3}\).
Consider the following statements.
Statement I: The complex ion \(\mathrm{[Fe(CN)_6]^{4-}}\) contains six cyanide ligands.
Statement II: The iron atom within \(\mathrm{[Fe(CN)_6]^{4-}}\) has oxidation state \(+2\).
Statement III: Three hexacyanidoferrate(II) ions require four iron(III) ions for charge-balanced formation of \(\mathrm{Fe_4[Fe(CN)_6]_3}\).
Statement IV: The formula \(\mathrm{Fe_4[Fe(CN)_6]_3}\) shows that all iron atoms in Prussian blue have oxidation state \(+3\).
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. I, II and IV only
ⓑ. II, III and IV only
ⓒ. I, III and IV only
ⓓ. I, II and III only
Correct Answer: I, II and III only
Explanation: Statement I is correct because the formula \(\mathrm{[Fe(CN)_6]^{4-}}\) explicitly contains six cyanide ligands coordinated to an iron centre. Statement II is correct because each cyanide ligand has charge \(-1\). The six ligands contribute a total charge of \(-6\), while the complete complex has charge \(-4\). Therefore, the oxidation state of the central iron is \(+2\). Statement III is correct because three hexacyanidoferrate(II) ions contribute a total charge of \(-12\). Four iron(III) ions contribute a total charge of \(+12\). These quantities balance the charge in the product represented by \(\mathrm{Fe_4[Fe(CN)_6]_3}\). Statement IV is incorrect because the Prussian-blue product contains iron in more than one oxidation state. The iron atoms within the hexacyanidoferrate(II) units remain associated with the iron(II) description. The additional iron atoms are supplied as iron(III) ions during formation of the characteristic compound. The observed colour therefore arises from a product containing both relevant iron oxidation states rather than from an all-iron(III) cyanide salt. Correct interpretation requires distinguishing the central iron within the complex anion from the iron ions that combine with that anion. Only Statements I, II and III are correct.
246. An organic compound containing sulphur is subjected to suitable sodium fusion, producing a sulphide-containing aqueous extract.
A portion of the extract gives a violet colour after addition of sodium nitroprusside. The violet analytical product is represented by:
\[
\mathrm{[Fe(CN)_5NOS]^{4-}}
\]
A student argues that the nitrogen atoms appearing in this formula prove that the original organic compound also contained nitrogen.
Which conclusion is correct?
ⓐ. The student's argument is invalid because nitrogen-containing ligands are supplied by the sodium nitroprusside reagent.
ⓑ. The student's argument is valid because cyanide ligands in an analytical product must originate from the original organic compound.
ⓒ. The student's argument is valid because sodium fusion always converts sulphur into thiocyanate even when nitrogen is absent.
ⓓ. The student's argument is invalid because the violet product contains neither nitrogen nor sulphur.
Correct Answer: The student's argument is invalid because nitrogen-containing ligands are supplied by the sodium nitroprusside reagent.
Explanation: The sodium nitroprusside test is used to detect sulphide formed from organically bound sulphur during suitable sodium fusion. The fusion extract supplies sulphide ions, which participate in formation of the characteristic violet product. Sodium nitroprusside itself is a complex reagent containing cyanide and nitrosyl groups. These groups contain nitrogen atoms before the reagent is added to the fusion extract. Consequently, the nitrogen appearing in the formula of the final violet product need not originate from the organic sample. The student's argument incorrectly assigns every atom in the analytical product to the original compound. This ignores the chemical contribution made by the detecting reagent. The formula \(\mathrm{[Fe(CN)_5NOS]^{4-}}\) contains sulphur associated with the analytical response as well as nitrogen-containing groups derived from the nitroprusside reagent. The violet observation supports the presence of sulphur through the prescribed sulphide reaction. It does not replace the separate cyanide-based nitrogen test. Establishing nitrogen in the original organic compound would require appropriate independent evidence rather than counting nitrogen atoms in an added reagent. Correct elemental analysis requires tracing which atoms were already present in the analytical reagents and which were supplied by the sample.
247. An aqueous sodium-fusion extract contains cyanide ions but no chloride, bromide, iodide or sulphide ions. The extract is divided into two portions.
Portion I is treated directly with silver nitrate and produces a white precipitate of silver cyanide under the specified conditions.
Portion II is first subjected to the prescribed concentrated nitric-acid treatment, which completely decomposes cyanide. Silver nitrate is then added, and no precipitate forms.
Which interpretation is correct?
ⓐ. The white precipitate in Portion I establishes chlorine because all white silver precipitates are silver chloride.
ⓑ. The absence of a precipitate in Portion II establishes that the original compound contained no nitrogen.
ⓒ. The different results show why cyanide must be removed before interpreting a silver nitrate test for halogens.
ⓓ. The white precipitate in Portion I establishes iodine because silver iodide and silver cyanide have the same colour.
Correct Answer: The different results show why cyanide must be removed before interpreting a silver nitrate test for halogens.
Explanation: Sodium fusion can convert nitrogen in an organic compound into cyanide ions under suitable conditions. Cyanide is useful for the prescribed nitrogen test but can interfere with the silver nitrate test intended for halogens. Silver(I) ions can react with cyanide to produce a silver-containing precipitate. In Portion I, the white precipitate is explicitly identified as silver cyanide. It therefore provides no valid evidence for the presence of chlorine. In Portion II, concentrated nitric-acid pretreatment decomposes the cyanide under the specified conditions. Because the extract contains no chloride, bromide or iodide ions, subsequent addition of silver nitrate produces no silver-halide precipitate. The absence of a precipitate after this pretreatment is consistent with the stated absence of the tested halides. It does not establish that the original compound contained no nitrogen because the nitrogen-derived cyanide was deliberately removed. The comparison demonstrates that a positive silver nitrate observation in an untreated fusion extract can arise from a non-halide ion. Reliable halogen detection therefore depends on preparing the extract so that interfering cyanide and sulphide species do not contribute misleading precipitates.
248. Two identical portions of an organic compound containing nitrogen and sulphur are fused with sodium under different conditions.
In Trial I, sodium thiocyanate is formed predominantly. In Trial II, sufficient excess sodium converts the thiocyanate into sodium cyanide and sodium sulphide according to:
\[
\mathrm{NaSCN+2Na\rightarrow NaCN+Na_2S}
\]
The two extracts are then tested separately with suitable iron(III) reagent and with sodium nitroprusside.
Which statement best explains why the final observations may differ even though the starting organic compound is unchanged?
ⓐ. Trial II necessarily removes sulphur from the organic sample before fusion begins.
ⓑ. Trial II proves that nitrogen and sulphur were originally present as sodium cyanide and sodium sulphide within the organic molecule.
ⓒ. Trial I produces molecular nitrogen, while Trial II converts all nitrogen into nitrate.
ⓓ. Trial I and Trial II generate different inorganic distributions of the same original nitrogen and sulphur atoms.
Correct Answer: Trial I and Trial II generate different inorganic distributions of the same original nitrogen and sulphur atoms.
Explanation: The elemental composition of the original organic compound is the same in both trials. What changes is the chemical distribution of nitrogen and sulphur after sodium fusion. Under suitable conditions, compounds containing both nitrogen and sulphur can produce sodium thiocyanate. Thiocyanate can form a characteristic blood-red complex with iron(III) ions. When excess sodium is used, the stated reaction converts thiocyanate into cyanide and sulphide. The resulting cyanide can participate in the ordinary iron-complex nitrogen-detection sequence, while sulphide can give the characteristic sodium nitroprusside response. The two trials therefore need not show identical colour reactions. This difference does not require nitrogen or sulphur to have disappeared from the sample. Nor does it establish that cyanide or sulphide existed as free ions within the original organic molecule. Sodium fusion is an analytical conversion designed to produce detectable inorganic species. Different fusion conditions can alter which species are predominant. The correct interpretation requires conserving the original elements while recognising the changed reaction products. A change in analytical observation does not automatically imply a change in the elemental composition of the starting compound.
249. An organic compound is suspected to contain phosphorus. Three separately prepared analytical portions are examined.
| Portion | Analytical treatment | Observation |
| I | Prescribed oxidation with sodium peroxide, nitric-acid treatment and ammonium molybdate | Yellow precipitate |
| II | Same prescribed phosphorus procedure, but without the organic sample | Yellow precipitate |
| III | Same prescribed phosphorus procedure using freshly verified uncontaminated reagents and the organic sample | Yellow precipitate |
Further investigation establishes that the reagents used in Portions I and II were contaminated with phosphate, whereas the reagents used in Portion III were phosphate-free before the sample was introduced. Assume no other interfering species produce the stated precipitate.
Which conclusion is most defensible?
ⓐ. Portion I alone conclusively establishes phosphorus because its yellow precipitate is characteristic.
ⓑ. Portion II conclusively establishes that the original organic sample contains no phosphorus.
ⓒ. The phosphate contamination invalidates every phosphorus test, including the independently uncontaminated Portion III.
ⓓ. Portion III is the reliable positive test because its phosphate-free reagents exclude the interference shown in Portion II.
Correct Answer: Portion III is the reliable positive test because its phosphate-free reagents exclude the interference shown in Portion II.
Explanation: The phosphorus test depends on converting organically bound phosphorus into phosphate and then producing a characteristic yellow ammonium phosphomolybdate product. A positive precipitate is meaningful only when the phosphate responsible for its formation can be attributed to the original sample. In Portion I, the detecting reagents already contain phosphate contamination. The yellow observation could therefore arise from reagent-derived phosphate rather than from phosphorus in the organic compound. Portion II is a blank experiment without the organic sample. Its yellow precipitate demonstrates that the contaminated reagents can produce the characteristic observation independently of the sample. Therefore, Portion I cannot by itself provide conclusive evidence for sample-derived phosphorus. Portion III uses reagents verified to be free from phosphate before introducing the organic sample. The prescribed analytical conversion and detection sequence nevertheless produces a yellow precipitate. Under the stated assumptions, this positive result supports the presence of phosphorus in the original organic compound. The contaminated blank does not establish that the sample lacks phosphorus; it establishes that the earlier reagent system was unsuitable for an unambiguous conclusion. The distinction involves identifying the source of phosphate rather than relying solely on the colour of the final product. Proper analytical interpretation requires excluding positive observations generated by the reagents themselves.
250. An organic compound contains nitrogen, sulphur and chlorine. Sodium fusion is performed using sufficient excess sodium to produce cyanide, sulphide and chloride in the aqueous extract.
The extract is divided into three portions, and the following reactions are considered.
Statement I: Cyanide can be detected through the prescribed iron-complex sequence that ultimately produces Prussian blue.
Statement II: Sulphide can be detected through formation of a black lead sulphide precipitate under suitable lead acetate test conditions.
Statement III: The chloride test with silver nitrate may require prior concentrated nitric-acid treatment because cyanide and sulphide can interfere.
Statement IV: The chlorine-detection treatment should be applied to every portion before attempting nitrogen or sulphur detection because it preserves cyanide and sulphide.
Statement V: The final silver chloride precipitate proves that chlorine was present as free chloride ions before sodium fusion.
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. I, II and III only
ⓑ. I, III and V only
ⓒ. II, IV and V only
ⓓ. I, II and IV only
Correct Answer: I, II and III only
Explanation: Statement I is correct because suitable sodium fusion converts organically bound nitrogen into cyanide under the specified conditions. The cyanide participates in the iron(II)-complex formation step, followed by the appropriate iron(III) reaction that produces Prussian blue. Statement II is correct because sulphur gives sulphide during suitable sodium fusion. Sulphide reacts with lead(II) ions to form black lead sulphide under the prescribed lead acetate test conditions. Statement III is correct because cyanide and sulphide can also react with silver(I) ions and interfere with halogen detection. Boiling the appropriate fusion-extract portion with concentrated nitric acid removes these interfering effects before the silver nitrate test. Statement IV is incorrect because the same nitric-acid treatment can destroy the cyanide and sulphide species required for their respective qualitative tests. Consequently, separate portions must be treated according to the analytical species being investigated. Statement V is incorrect because the chloride ions in the fusion extract may have been produced by conversion of covalently bound chlorine during sodium fusion. A positive post-fusion halogen test therefore does not establish that free chloride existed within the original organic molecule. The correct interpretation requires distinguishing elemental conversion, reagent-specific detection and pretreatment for interfering ions. Only Statements I, II and III are correct.
251. An organic compound is known to contain bromine but no chlorine or iodine. It also contains nitrogen and sulphur.
The sodium-fusion extract is tested with silver nitrate under two conditions:
- Trial I: Silver nitrate is added directly to the untreated extract. A dark precipitate forms.
- Trial II: Another portion is boiled with concentrated nitric acid under the prescribed conditions, then treated with silver nitrate. A yellowish precipitate forms and is sparingly soluble in ammonium hydroxide.
Assume that Trial II has removed the cyanide- and sulphide-derived interferences quantitatively.
Which inference is correct?
ⓐ. Trial I establishes iodine because dark silver-containing precipitates always contain iodide.
ⓑ. Trial II establishes chlorine because bromide cannot produce a yellowish precipitate.
ⓒ. Trial II supports bromide detection, while Trial I cannot independently be interpreted as a silver-halide colour test.
ⓓ. Trial I excludes nitrogen because nitrogen-containing fusion products do not interact with silver(I) ions.
Correct Answer: Trial II supports bromide detection, while Trial I cannot independently be interpreted as a silver-halide colour test.
Explanation: The untreated sodium-fusion extract contains several ionic species arising from the different elements in the organic compound. Bromine produces bromide ions under suitable fusion conditions. Nitrogen and sulphur may produce cyanide and sulphide ions, respectively. These species can interfere with silver nitrate testing because silver(I) reacts with ions other than bromide. In Trial I, a dark precipitate therefore cannot safely be interpreted as the characteristic silver bromide observation. The question does not establish that the precipitate consists exclusively of a silver halide. In Trial II, concentrated nitric-acid pretreatment removes the interfering cyanide and sulphide effects under the specified conditions. Bromide remains available for reaction with silver nitrate. Silver bromide produces a yellowish precipitate that is sparingly soluble in ammonium hydroxide in the standard NCERT description. The second observation is consequently consistent with the independently stated presence of bromine. The difference between the two trials reflects the effect of interfering ions rather than a change in the original elemental composition. Reliable interpretation therefore depends on the entire analytical sequence, including pretreatment and final precipitate behaviour.
252. A student investigates an organic compound suspected to contain sulphur and phosphorus.
The student performs the following experiments:
In Experiment I, suitable sodium fusion is carried out. A portion of the aqueous extract produces a violet colour with sodium nitroprusside.
In Experiment II, a fresh portion of the original organic compound undergoes prescribed oxidation with sodium peroxide. After nitric-acid treatment and addition of ammonium molybdate, a yellow precipitate forms.
In Experiment III, the student takes the sulphide-containing fusion extract from Experiment I and adds ammonium molybdate directly, without carrying out the prescribed phosphorus oxidation step. No yellow precipitate forms.
Which interpretation is most appropriate?
ⓐ. Experiment III proves that the original compound contains sulphur but not phosphorus.
ⓑ. I supports sulphur and II supports phosphorus; III omits the conversion needed to detect phosphorus.
ⓒ. Experiment I establishes phosphorus because sodium nitroprusside contains phosphorus in its detecting complex.
ⓓ. Experiment II establishes nitrogen rather than phosphorus because ammonium molybdate contains ammonium ions.
Correct Answer: I supports sulphur and II supports phosphorus; III omits the conversion needed to detect phosphorus.
Explanation: The two elements are detected through different inorganic analytical products. Suitable sodium fusion converts sulphur in the organic compound into sodium sulphide. The sulphide-containing extract can produce a characteristic violet response with sodium nitroprusside. Experiment I therefore supports the presence of sulphur. The prescribed phosphorus test requires conversion of organically bound phosphorus into phosphate by an appropriate oxidising treatment. Sodium peroxide serves this purpose in Experiment II. After suitable nitric-acid treatment, phosphate reacts with ammonium molybdate to produce yellow ammonium phosphomolybdate. Experiment II therefore provides evidence for phosphorus under the stated conditions. Experiment III uses an extract prepared primarily through the sodium-fusion pathway and omits the prescribed oxidation required for the phosphorus test. Consequently, its negative yellow-precipitate result cannot overturn the properly obtained positive observation in Experiment II. The fact that ammonium molybdate contains ammonium ions also does not establish nitrogen in the original sample. Similarly, sodium nitroprusside is not a phosphorus-detection reagent merely because it forms a coloured analytical product. The correct interpretation distinguishes the required chemical form of each element from the final colour observation. A negative result obtained through an incomplete analytical sequence is not equivalent to a valid negative test.
253. An organic compound contains nitrogen and sulphur and may also contain chlorine.
After suitable sodium fusion, the aqueous extract is divided into two portions.
Portion I is treated directly with silver nitrate and produces a white precipitate.
Portion II is boiled with concentrated nitric acid under conditions that completely remove cyanide and sulphide interference. Subsequent addition of silver nitrate produces no precipitate.
An independent nitrogen test on a separately prepared portion is positive.
Assume the prescribed procedures are correctly performed and no other precipitating ions are present.
Which conclusion is best supported?
ⓐ. Chlorine must be present because the direct silver nitrate test produced a white precipitate.
ⓑ. Chlorine must be present because nitric acid can remove silver chloride from the extract before its formation.
ⓒ. The initial precipitate establishes that nitrogen was absent because cyanide cannot react with silver nitrate.
ⓓ. The untreated silver precipitate does not prove chlorine; after interference removal, no positive chlorine evidence remains.
Correct Answer: The untreated silver precipitate does not prove chlorine; after interference removal, no positive chlorine evidence remains.
Explanation: Sodium fusion converts suitable organically bound elements into ionic products that can be investigated through inorganic reactions. Nitrogen can produce cyanide, while sulphur can produce sulphide under appropriate fusion conditions. Chlorine, if present, would be converted into chloride ions. The ordinary halogen test relies on reaction of such halide ions with silver nitrate after suitable preparation. However, cyanide and sulphide can interfere with silver nitrate because they also form silver-containing compounds. Therefore, a precipitate from the untreated extract cannot automatically be assigned to silver chloride. In Portion II, the prescribed nitric-acid treatment removes the cyanide- and sulphide-derived interference. The absence of a precipitate after silver nitrate addition indicates that the treated extract has not produced the characteristic silver-halide observation. This result does not invalidate the independently positive nitrogen test because the nitrogen-derived cyanide was deliberately removed from Portion II. It instead shows why the initial untreated silver nitrate result is insufficient to establish chlorine. The correct reasoning separates the source of the interfering ions, the role of nitric-acid pretreatment and the intended chloride-detection reaction. Under the stated assumptions, the properly treated extract provides no positive evidence for chlorine.
254. A mixture containing \(20.0\,\mathrm{g}\) of desired organic compound P and \(2.00\,\mathrm{g}\) of impurity Q is dissolved completely in \(100\,\mathrm{mL}\) of a suitable hot crystallisation solvent.
At the cooling temperature, the solubilities of P and Q are \(10.0\,\mathrm{g}\) and \(3.00\,\mathrm{g}\), respectively, per \(100\,\mathrm{mL}\) of solvent.
After cooling, the deposited crystals are separated. The mother liquor is then concentrated to \(50.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) without chemical decomposition and returned to the same cooling temperature. All additional solids deposited are collected and combined with the first crystal crop.
Assume equilibrium is attained at each stage, solvent volumes are additive, and the two compounds crystallise separately without occlusion or solid-solution formation.
Which pair gives the final percentage recovery of P and the purity of P in the combined crystals, respectively?
ⓐ. \(75.0\%\) and \(100\%\)
ⓑ. \(50.0\%\) and \(96.8\%\)
ⓒ. \(75.0\%\) and \(96.8\%\)
ⓓ. \(87.5\%\) and \(93.8\%\)
Correct Answer: \(75.0\%\) and \(96.8\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the first crystal crop:}\)
The initial solution contains:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,initial}}=20.0\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,initial}}=2.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
At the cooling temperature, \(100\,\mathrm{mL}\) of solvent can retain \(10.0\,\mathrm{g}\) of P in solution.
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,first\ crop}}=20.0-10.0
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,first\ crop}}=10.0\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The cold solvent can dissolve \(3.00\,\mathrm{g}\) of Q, exceeding the actual \(2.00\,\mathrm{g}\) present.
Thus Q remains completely dissolved during the first crystallisation.
\(\textbf{Determine the mother-liquor composition:}\)
After separating the first crop:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,mother\ liquor}}=10.0\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,mother\ liquor}}=2.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Apply the reduced solvent volume:}\)
The mother liquor is concentrated to \(50.0\,\mathrm{mL}\).
At the same cooling temperature, this volume can retain:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,soluble}}=10.0\times\frac{50.0}{100}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,soluble}}=5.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
For Q:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,soluble}}=3.00\times\frac{50.0}{100}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,soluble}}=1.50\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the second crystal crop:}\)
Additional P deposited:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,second\ crop}}=10.0-5.00
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,second\ crop}}=5.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Additional Q deposited:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,second\ crop}}=2.00-1.50
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,second\ crop}}=0.500\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine overall recovery:}\)
The combined crystals contain:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,recovered}}=10.0+5.00
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,recovered}}=15.0\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\%\mathrm{recovery\ of\ P}=\frac{15.0}{20.0}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{recovery\ of\ P}=75.0\%
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate purity of the combined solids:}\)
The total combined solid mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{combined}}=15.0+0.500
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{combined}}=15.5\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Thus:
\[
\%\mathrm{purity}=\frac{15.0}{15.5}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{purity}=96.774\ldots\%
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{purity}\approx96.8\%
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The first crystal crop is pure P under the stated assumptions because all Q remains dissolved.
Concentrating the mother liquor improves recovery of P but reduces the solvent's capacity to retain Q.
Consequently, part of Q also crystallises during the second operation.
Pooling the two crystal crops therefore increases recovery at the expense of purity.
This demonstrates why mother-liquor concentration must be evaluated using the solubilities of both the desired compound and its impurities.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\left(75.0\%,\,96.8\%\right)}
\]
255. An organic liquid P is immiscible with water and undergoes steam distillation without decomposition.
Its vapour and water vapour are assumed to behave ideally, and the boiling condition is determined by the sum of their individual saturated vapour pressures.
The following data are available:
| Condition | Water vapour pressure | Vapour pressure of P | External pressure |
| I | \(600\,\mathrm{mmHg}\) | \(160\,\mathrm{mmHg}\) | \(760\,\mathrm{mmHg}\) |
| II, at a lower temperature | \(560\,\mathrm{mmHg}\) | \(140\,\mathrm{mmHg}\) | \(700\,\mathrm{mmHg}\) |
Assume both liquids remain present throughout, the vapours are collected without loss, and the condensed distillate separates into two layers.
When the external pressure is reduced from Condition I to Condition II, which conclusion is correct?
ⓐ. The boiling temperature decreases, but the mass ratio of P to water in the distillate remains unchanged.
ⓑ. The boiling temperature decreases, and the mass ratio of P to water in the distillate also decreases.
ⓒ. The boiling temperature increases, while the mass ratio of P to water decreases.
ⓓ. The boiling temperature decreases, while the mass ratio of P to water increases.
Correct Answer: The boiling temperature decreases, and the mass ratio of P to water in the distillate also decreases.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Verify the steam-distillation condition:}\)
For two immiscible liquids under the stated assumptions:
\[
P_{\mathrm{external}}=P_{\mathrm{water}}+P_{\mathrm P}
\]
At Condition I:
\[
P_{\mathrm{total,I}}=600+160
\]
\[
P_{\mathrm{total,I}}=760\,\mathrm{mmHg}
\]
At Condition II:
\[
P_{\mathrm{total,II}}=560+140
\]
\[
P_{\mathrm{total,II}}=700\,\mathrm{mmHg}
\]
Both conditions therefore satisfy the specified boiling relation.
\(\textbf{Determine the temperature change:}\)
The question identifies Condition II as occurring at a lower temperature.
This is consistent with the lower vapour pressures of both components and the reduced external pressure.
Thus the boiling temperature decreases.
\(\textbf{Relate vapour composition to collected masses:}\)
For the immiscible vapours:
\[
\frac{n_{\mathrm P}}{n_{\mathrm{water}}}
=
\frac{P_{\mathrm P}}{P_{\mathrm{water}}}
\]
The corresponding mass ratio is:
\[
\frac{m_{\mathrm P}}{m_{\mathrm{water}}}
=
\frac{P_{\mathrm P}M_{\mathrm P}}
{P_{\mathrm{water}}M_{\mathrm{water}}}
\]
The molar masses of P and water remain unchanged between the two conditions.
Therefore, the direction of change in the mass ratio can be determined from the vapour-pressure ratios.
\(\textbf{Compare Condition I:}\)
\[
\left(\frac{P_{\mathrm P}}{P_{\mathrm{water}}}\right)_{\mathrm I}
=
\frac{160}{600}
\]
\[
\left(\frac{P_{\mathrm P}}{P_{\mathrm{water}}}\right)_{\mathrm I}
=
0.2667
\]
\(\textbf{Compare Condition II:}\)
\[
\left(\frac{P_{\mathrm P}}{P_{\mathrm{water}}}\right)_{\mathrm{II}}
=
\frac{140}{560}
\]
\[
\left(\frac{P_{\mathrm P}}{P_{\mathrm{water}}}\right)_{\mathrm{II}}
=
0.2500
\]
Consequently:
\[
0.2500\lt 0.2667
\]
The organic-liquid-to-water mass ratio decreases.
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
Lowering the external pressure reduces the temperature required for the combined vapour pressures to match that pressure.
However, it does not guarantee that the two component vapour pressures decrease in exactly the same proportion.
Therefore, the composition of the distillate need not remain unchanged.
The supplied data show that P contributes a slightly smaller proportion relative to water at Condition II.
The boiling temperature and distillate composition must therefore be considered separately.
256. Two colourless organic compounds P and Q are suspected to have nearly identical chromatographic behaviour in one solvent system.
On a silica-gel TLC plate developed with solvent system X, authentic samples of P and Q both have \(R_f=0.50\). A mixture containing both substances produces only one apparently compact spot at the same position.
A second silica-gel TLC plate is then developed using solvent system Y. Authentic P gives \(R_f=0.30\), authentic Q gives \(R_f=0.70\), and the mixture produces two resolved spots at these respective positions.
Assume the substances remain chemically unchanged in both solvent systems.
Which conclusion is best supported?
ⓐ. The mixture must contain a third compound because its chromatographic pattern changes with the mobile phase.
ⓑ. P and Q are necessarily the same compound because their \(R_f\) values were equal in solvent system X.
ⓒ. The mixture contains only P because the first chromatogram showed one spot.
ⓓ. P and Q overlap in system X but separate in Y; one spot in X was not proof of purity.
Correct Answer: P and Q overlap in system X but separate in Y; one spot in X was not proof of purity.
Explanation: Thin-layer chromatography separates substances according to their relative interactions with the stationary and mobile phases.
The retardation factor compares the distance travelled by a substance with the distance travelled by the solvent front.
It is meaningful only for the stated chromatographic conditions.
In solvent system X, P and Q have identical reported \(R_f\) values.
Their spots therefore occur at the same position even though the compounds are chemically different.
When a mixture containing both compounds is developed in this system, the two contributions overlap.
An apparently single spot can therefore conceal the presence of more than one component.
Solvent system Y changes the relative migration behaviour.
P now has a smaller \(R_f\), while Q has a substantially larger \(R_f\).
The mixture consequently produces two resolved spots matching the separate reference substances.
This observation establishes that the initial single spot did not represent a uniquely pure compound.
It does not require decomposition or formation of a third substance because the question explicitly excludes chemical change.
The analytical limitation is a lack of resolution under solvent system X.
Chromatographic purity assessment must therefore consider the separation capability of the chosen mobile and stationary phases rather than counting spots without qualification.
257. An aqueous solution contains \(4.00\,\mathrm{g}\) of desired compound P and \(2.00\,\mathrm{g}\) of impurity Q.
A suitable water-immiscible organic solvent is used for repeated differential extraction. Under the specified conditions, P and Q have equal distribution coefficients between the organic and aqueous phases.
The solvent volumes used in each contact may be changed, but both substances remain chemically unchanged, and all separated organic extracts are eventually combined.
Which statement is correct?
ⓐ. Repeated extraction increases recovered P but cannot improve the recovered P:Q ratio when their distribution coefficients are equal.
ⓑ. Repeated extraction must eventually produce pure P because Q has the smaller initial mass.
ⓒ. Increasing the extraction-solvent volume changes the distribution coefficient of P but not that of Q.
ⓓ. The first extraction necessarily contains a greater fraction of P than later extracts because P was initially more abundant.
Correct Answer: Repeated extraction increases recovered P but cannot improve the recovered P:Q ratio when their distribution coefficients are equal.
Explanation: Differential extraction separates dissolved substances by exploiting differences in their distribution between two immiscible liquids.
For a given extraction contact, the fraction transferred depends on the distribution coefficient and the relative solvent volumes.
The question specifies that P and Q have equal distribution coefficients under the same conditions.
Therefore, a particular extraction contact removes the same fraction of the P and Q present immediately before that contact.
Although their absolute masses differ, their fractional extraction behaviours are identical.
Initially, the solute mass ratio is:
\[
m_{\mathrm P}:m_{\mathrm Q}=4.00:2.00
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm P}:m_{\mathrm Q}=2:1
\]
After each contact, the same fraction of both substances is removed.
Consequently, the extracted portions retain the same P:Q mass ratio.
The remaining aqueous material also retains that ratio.
Changing the extraction-solvent volume may change the fraction transferred during an individual contact, but it changes that fraction equally for both substances under the stated assumptions.
Combining successive extracts therefore increases the total amount recovered without improving their relative composition.
The recovered solutes remain \(2:1\) in mass ratio rather than becoming pure P.
The key limitation is the absence of distribution selectivity between P and Q.
Repeated extraction can improve recovery, but selective purification requires different distribution behaviour or an additional separation method.
258. A pure organic liquid P is distilled in an apparatus whose pressure is not held constant.
The liquid is chemically stable and undergoes no decomposition. During the experiment, the pressure gradually decreases, causing the observed boiling temperature to decrease.
A temperature-versus-time graph shows the boiling temperature decreasing smoothly from \(105^\circ\mathrm{C}\) to \(95^\circ\mathrm{C}\) during collection of the distillate. Simultaneous pressure readings establish that the external pressure falls continuously throughout this interval. In a second trial, the same purified liquid is distilled at a carefully maintained constant pressure, and a nearly constant boiling temperature is observed during the principal collection stage.
A student concludes from the first graph that P must be a mixture because its boiling temperature was not constant.
Which evaluation is most appropriate?
ⓐ. The conclusion is correct because pure liquids always boil at one fixed temperature irrespective of pressure.
ⓑ. The conclusion is correct because reducing pressure necessarily changes a pure compound into a mixture.
ⓒ. Different boiling temperatures are compatible with a pure compound because boiling point depends on pressure.
ⓓ. The conclusion is not justified because temperature readings have no relevance to distillation.
Correct Answer: Different boiling temperatures are compatible with a pure compound because boiling point depends on pressure.
Explanation: A pure liquid has a characteristic boiling temperature only when the external pressure is specified.
Boiling occurs when the liquid's vapour pressure becomes equal to the pressure acting on it.
If the external pressure is reduced, this equality can be achieved at a lower temperature.
Therefore, a decreasing boiling temperature does not automatically imply that the distilling material has changing chemical composition.
In the first trial, the pressure is explicitly stated to decrease during distillation.
The observed temperature decrease is therefore compatible with the behaviour of a pure liquid under changing pressure.
The second trial provides an important comparison because the same purified material is distilled at constant pressure.
Its principal boiling temperature remains nearly constant.
This supports the interpretation that the changing pressure caused the earlier temperature drift.
A mixture may also show changing temperatures during distillation, but that possibility cannot be established from the first graph alone.
The experiment must distinguish temperature variation caused by pressure changes from variation caused by composition changes.
The chemically defensible inference is that pressure control is essential when boiling-temperature behaviour is being used to assess a distillation process.
259. A crystalline organic compound P sublimes readily on controlled heating, whereas impurity Q is non-sublimable under the same conditions.
In Trial I, the mixture is heated gently. Pure P deposits on a suitably cooled collecting surface, while Q remains in the original vessel.
In Trial II, the same mixture is heated very vigorously. The condensed P is found to contain tiny solid particles of Q. Independent examination confirms that Q has not sublimed or chemically reacted.
Which explanation best accounts for Trial II?
ⓐ. Q must have acquired a lower sublimation temperature because P was heated more vigorously.
ⓑ. Non-subliming Q could enter the sublimate through mechanical entrainment of particles.
ⓒ. P and Q necessarily formed a new volatile compound because both were present in the collecting region.
ⓓ. The observation proves that sublimation and crystallisation are identical separation processes.
Correct Answer: Non-subliming Q could enter the sublimate through mechanical entrainment of particles.
Explanation: Sublimation involves conversion of a suitable solid directly into vapour, followed by deposition on a cooler surface.
The method can separate a sublimable compound from an impurity that remains nonvolatile under the operating conditions.
In Trial I, P undergoes the desired phase change and is collected separately.
Q remains in the heated vessel because it does not sublime under the specified conditions.
Trial II introduces a different physical effect through very vigorous heating.
Fine particles of a non-sublimable solid can sometimes be carried mechanically into the collecting region when the process is poorly controlled.
Such transport does not require those particles to enter the vapour phase.
The question explicitly establishes that Q has neither sublimed nor reacted chemically.
Its appearance among the deposited P therefore should not be interpreted as evidence of co-sublimation.
Gentler heating and a suitable collecting arrangement can reduce the risk of physical contamination.
The distinction is important because the principle of sublimation may be sound even when the collected material is impure owing to mechanical handling or entrainment.
A successful purification requires both favourable phase-change properties and operating conditions that preserve physical separation.
260. A sodium-fusion extract containing sulphide ions is divided into two portions.
Portion I is treated immediately with the prescribed acetic-acid and lead acetate reagents. A black precipitate forms.
Portion II is first made strongly acidic and heated in an open vessel under conditions that convert essentially all sulphide into hydrogen sulphide and allow this gas to escape. The resulting liquid is then tested with lead acetate, and no black precipitate appears.
Assume no other sulphur-containing analytical species are present in Portion II after the treatment.
Which inference is correct?
ⓐ. Portion II proves that the original organic compound contained no sulphur because lead acetate is more sensitive after strong acidification.
ⓑ. Portion I proves that the black precipitate is elemental sulphur rather than lead sulphide.
ⓒ. Portion II proves that lead acetate cannot react with sulphide ions under any acidic conditions.
ⓓ. Portion II gives a negative result because the sulphide-derived analytical species was removed before testing, not because the original compound lacked sulphur.
Correct Answer: Portion II gives a negative result because the sulphide-derived analytical species was removed before testing, not because the original compound lacked sulphur.
Explanation: Suitable sodium fusion converts sulphur in an organic compound into a sulphide-containing inorganic product.
The resulting extract can be tested using lead acetate under the prescribed conditions.
Lead(II) ions react with sulphide ions to form black lead sulphide.
Portion I gives this characteristic observation and therefore supports the presence of sulphur in the original sample.
Portion II undergoes an additional treatment before lead acetate is added.
Strong acidification converts sulphide into hydrogen sulphide according to the acid-base relation \(\mathrm{S^{2-}+2H^+\rightarrow H_2S}\).
The question further specifies that heating allows essentially all hydrogen sulphide to escape from the open vessel.
Consequently, the liquid no longer contains the sulphide quantity needed to form the characteristic black precipitate.
The negative lead acetate test therefore reflects removal of the analytical species.
It does not reverse the elemental evidence obtained from Portion I.
The result illustrates why a reagent treatment that changes or removes the species being detected can cause a false-negative analytical observation.
The original sample's elemental composition remains unchanged by how the subsequent fusion extract is handled.
261. A student tests a sodium-fusion extract for nitrogen using the prescribed iron-complex pathway.
The extract contains cyanide ions and is strongly alkaline. Instead of carrying out the appropriate iron(II) treatment followed by the prescribed acidification and iron(III) reaction, the student adds iron(III) chloride directly to the strongly alkaline extract.
A brown precipitate of iron(III) hydroxide forms, and the characteristic Prussian-blue observation is not obtained.
Which interpretation is most appropriate?
ⓐ. The brown precipitate establishes that cyanide was absent from the extract.
ⓑ. A failed colour test does not exclude nitrogen when strongly alkaline conditions precipitate iron(III) hydroxide.
ⓒ. The brown precipitate proves that the original compound contained iron rather than nitrogen.
ⓓ. The direct addition of iron(III) establishes that the prescribed iron(II)-cyanide complex must already have formed quantitatively.
Correct Answer: A failed colour test does not exclude nitrogen when strongly alkaline conditions precipitate iron(III) hydroxide.
Explanation: The prescribed nitrogen test depends on a definite sequence of chemical transformations after sodium fusion.
Nitrogen present in the organic compound is converted into cyanide under suitable conditions.
The cyanide then participates in formation of hexacyanidoferrate(II) using an appropriate iron(II) reagent.
The subsequent iron(III) reaction produces the characteristic Prussian-blue product.
In the altered experiment, the student adds iron(III) directly to a strongly alkaline solution.
Iron(III) ions react with hydroxide ions to form the poorly soluble brown precipitate iron(III) hydroxide.
This competing reaction changes the availability and chemical form of the iron reagent.
Moreover, the student has omitted the prescribed formation of the iron(II)-cyanide complex.
The absence of Prussian blue therefore cannot be interpreted as proof that cyanide or nitrogen was absent.
The observed brown precipitate is consistent with the stated strongly alkaline conditions.
The result demonstrates that analytical reagents must be introduced under conditions that favour the intended detection pathway.
A correct elemental conclusion depends on both the presence of the relevant fusion product and the successful execution of the required complex-forming reactions.
262. A white silver chloride precipitate is obtained from a suitably prepared sodium-fusion extract.
The precipitate dissolves in aqueous ammonia through formation of a soluble silver-ammonia complex.
The resulting clear solution is divided into two portions:
- Portion I is retained under the same ammoniacal conditions.
- Portion II is treated with sufficient nitric acid to remove the complexing effect of ammonia, while keeping chloride ions in the solution. A white precipitate reappears.
Assume no other silver-containing species participate and the stated complexation and decomplexation processes are effectively complete.
Which explanation is correct?
ⓐ. Nitric acid creates chlorine atoms from the nitrogen originally present in ammonia.
ⓑ. The original silver chloride has undergone an irreversible change into metallic silver.
ⓒ. Removal of ammonia destabilises its silver complex, allowing silver chloride to precipitate again.
ⓓ. The reappearing white precipitate proves that iodide rather than chloride was present originally.
Correct Answer: Removal of ammonia destabilises its silver complex, allowing silver chloride to precipitate again.
Explanation: Silver chloride gives a characteristic white precipitate in the appropriate halogen-detection procedure.
Its dissolution in aqueous ammonia is associated with formation of a soluble silver-ammonia complex.
The dissolved silver(I) remains chemically present; it has not been converted into metallic silver.
Ammonia acts as a ligand and lowers the concentration of uncomplexed silver(I) ions under suitable conditions.
This favours dissolution of silver chloride while the complex is maintained.
The question specifies that nitric acid removes the complexing effect of ammonia in Portion II.
Under these changed conditions, the concentration of the soluble silver-ammonia complex decreases.
Silver(I) is again available to combine with chloride ions.
The chloride ions are explicitly stated to remain present in the solution.
Silver chloride can therefore precipitate again when its solubility condition is exceeded.
The reappearance of the white solid does not require new chlorine to be introduced.
It instead reflects a change in the chemical equilibrium governing the dissolved and precipitated silver species.
This reasoning connects the familiar ammonia-solubility observation of silver chloride with the reversible nature of complex formation.
263. An organic compound containing sulphur undergoes suitable sodium fusion, giving an aqueous sulphide-containing extract.
The extract is divided into two portions:
- Portion I gives a violet colour with sodium nitroprusside.
- Portion II is treated under controlled oxidising conditions that convert all sulphide ions into sulphate ions without losing sulphur. A subsequent sodium nitroprusside test is negative, but addition of a suitable barium salt produces white barium sulphate.
Assume all transformations and observations are complete and unambiguous.
Which statement correctly reconciles the results?
ⓐ. Sulphur remains conserved but changes from sulphide to sulphate, requiring a different detecting reaction.
ⓑ. The negative nitroprusside test establishes that sulphur was destroyed during oxidation.
ⓒ. The white barium sulphate precipitate establishes that the original compound contained barium atoms.
ⓓ. The positive violet test must have been caused by phosphate because sulphide cannot undergo oxidation.
Correct Answer: Sulphur remains conserved but changes from sulphide to sulphate, requiring a different detecting reaction.
Explanation: The sodium nitroprusside test is based on the reaction of the prescribed reagent with sulphide ions.
Portion I contains sulphide derived from the organic compound through sodium fusion.
Its violet observation therefore supports the presence of sulphur in the sample.
Portion II undergoes an additional oxidation step before the same colour test is attempted.
The question specifies that all sulphide is converted into sulphate without losing sulphur.
Therefore, sulphur remains present but is no longer available in the sulphide form required for the nitroprusside reaction.
A negative result with this reagent is consequently expected after complete oxidation.
The sulphate ions can instead react with barium ions to form white barium sulphate.
The barium atoms originate from the added reagent and do not have to be present in the original organic compound.
The two results are therefore compatible rather than contradictory.
They illustrate that a qualitative test detects an element through a particular chemical form, not through direct recognition of every possible form of that element.
Changing the oxidation state and ionic identity of the analytical species may change the required detecting reagent while conserving the element itself.
264. Equal masses of the same phosphorus- and sulphur-containing organic compound are analysed separately.
In the first experiment, all phosphorus is converted quantitatively into magnesium pyrophosphate, \(\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}\), producing \(0.111\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure, dry precipitate.
In the second experiment, all sulphur is converted quantitatively into barium sulphate, \(\mathrm{BaSO_4}\), producing \(0.466\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure, dry precipitate.
Using \(Mg=24\), \(P=31\), \(Ba=137\), \(S=32\) and \(O=16\), what is the atomic ratio of phosphorus to sulphur in the compound?
ⓐ. \(1:1\)
ⓑ. \(2:1\)
ⓒ. \(1:4\)
ⓓ. \(1:2\)
Correct Answer: \(1:2\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the phosphorus-containing product amount:}\)
The molar mass of magnesium pyrophosphate is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=2(24)+2(31)+7(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=222\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The measured mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=0.111\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=\frac{0.111}{222}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}=0.000500\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Convert pyrophosphate into phosphorus atoms:}\)
Each magnesium pyrophosphate formula unit contains two phosphorus atoms.
Thus:
\[
n_{\mathrm P}=2n_{\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm P}=2(0.000500)
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm P}=0.00100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the sulphur-containing product amount:}\)
The molar mass of barium sulphate is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=137+32+4(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=233\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The measured precipitate mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=0.466\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=\frac{0.466}{233}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Convert barium sulphate into sulphur atoms:}\)
Each barium sulphate formula unit contains one sulphur atom.
Consequently:
\[
n_{\mathrm S}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the elemental atom ratio:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm P}:n_{\mathrm S}
=
0.00100:0.00200
\]
Dividing both terms by \(0.00100\):
\[
n_{\mathrm P}:n_{\mathrm S}=1:2
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
Equal sample masses ensure that both measurements refer to the same quantity of the original compound.
The two gravimetric products contain different numbers of the elements being estimated per formula unit.
Magnesium pyrophosphate contributes two phosphorus atoms, whereas barium sulphate contributes one sulphur atom.
Consequently, the ratio of precipitate mole amounts cannot be used directly as the phosphorus-to-sulphur atom ratio.
The correct comparison requires converting each analytical product into the amount of its corresponding element.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{P:S=1:2}
\]
265. A pure organic molecule contains exactly two nitrogen atoms: one in an amide group suitable for ordinary Kjeldahl conversion and one in a nitro group that is not quantitatively converted by the ordinary Kjeldahl procedure.
A complete Dumas determination measures all nitrogen atoms in the molecule. The ordinary Kjeldahl procedure quantitatively recovers only the amide nitrogen as ammonia.
Assume both methods use equal masses of the same pure compound, and all analytically accessible nitrogen is recovered without loss.
Which relationship between the nitrogen percentages reported by the two methods is expected?
ⓐ. The Kjeldahl percentage is one-quarter of the Dumas percentage because Dumas collects nitrogen as \(\mathrm{N_2}\).
ⓑ. The Kjeldahl percentage is twice the Dumas percentage because ammonia contains three hydrogen atoms.
ⓒ. The Kjeldahl percentage equals the Dumas percentage because both nitrogen atoms belong to the same organic molecule.
ⓓ. The Kjeldahl percentage is one-half of the Dumas percentage because only one of the two nitrogen atoms per molecule is measured.
Correct Answer: The Kjeldahl percentage is one-half of the Dumas percentage because only one of the two nitrogen atoms per molecule is measured.
Explanation: The Dumas method determines nitrogen by converting the nitrogen in the sample into molecular nitrogen under suitable analytical conditions.
The question specifies complete recovery of both nitrogen atoms per organic molecule by this method.
Therefore, the Dumas result represents the total nitrogen mass in the original sample.
The ordinary Kjeldahl method uses a different analytical transformation.
It requires the relevant nitrogen to be converted into an ammonium-containing product during digestion and subsequently liberated as ammonia.
One nitrogen atom in each original molecule is present in an amide group and is specified to undergo this conversion quantitatively.
The second nitrogen atom occurs in a nitro group and is explicitly stated not to be recovered quantitatively by the ordinary Kjeldahl procedure.
Consequently, only one of the two original nitrogen atoms contributes to the Kjeldahl measurement.
Because both atoms have the same atomic mass, the Kjeldahl-detectable nitrogen represents one-half of the total nitrogen mass.
The sample mass used as the percentage denominator is the same in both analyses.
Therefore, the reported Kjeldahl nitrogen percentage is half the valid Dumas percentage.
The fact that Dumas collects \(\mathrm{N_2}\) while Kjeldahl collects ammonia does not introduce another factor of two into the elemental mass percentage.
Both products must be interpreted according to the number of original nitrogen atoms they represent.
The difference here arises from incomplete applicability of the Kjeldahl conversion to one specific nitrogen environment.
266. During quantitative phosphorus estimation, a sample is converted into magnesium ammonium phosphate, which is then intended to be ignited completely to magnesium pyrophosphate, \(\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}\).
Instead, a student stops the heating prematurely. Independent analysis establishes that the residue contains magnesium pyrophosphate together with some unchanged magnesium ammonium phosphate hexahydrate, \(\mathrm{MgNH_4PO_4\cdot6H_2O}\).
The student treats the entire residue mass as pure magnesium pyrophosphate when calculating phosphorus percentage.
Assume no phosphorus-containing material is lost.
Which statement is correct?
ⓐ. The calculated phosphorus percentage is necessarily correct because the total phosphorus atoms are conserved.
ⓑ. The calculated phosphorus percentage is necessarily too low because the hydrated material contains water.
ⓒ. Incomplete ignition leaves extra residue mass that is wrongly counted as magnesium pyrophosphate, overestimating phosphorus.
ⓓ. The phosphorus percentage becomes zero because magnesium ammonium phosphate hexahydrate contains no phosphorus.
Correct Answer: Incomplete ignition leaves extra residue mass that is wrongly counted as magnesium pyrophosphate, overestimating phosphorus.
Explanation: The intended analytical method requires the final weighed compound to be magnesium pyrophosphate.
Its formula is \(\mathrm{Mg_2P_2O_7}\), containing two phosphorus atoms per formula unit.
The mass-to-phosphorus conversion factor is valid only when the weighed material actually has this specified composition.
During complete ignition, magnesium ammonium phosphate is converted into magnesium pyrophosphate with elimination of volatile products.
The question states that some magnesium ammonium phosphate hexahydrate remains unchanged.
This material contains ammonium and water of crystallisation in addition to magnesium, phosphorus and oxygen.
Consequently, the partially ignited residue retains material that should not be present in the final magnesium pyrophosphate product.
The student nevertheless applies the magnesium pyrophosphate gravimetric factor to the entire residue.
This assigns phosphorus to excess residue mass that is not genuinely present as magnesium pyrophosphate.
The calculated phosphorus mass therefore becomes too large.
Conservation of phosphorus atoms does not guarantee the correctness of a gravimetric calculation when the assumed identity of the final weighed substance is wrong.
The mistake is caused by incomplete conversion and incorrect interpretation of the residue composition.
The result illustrates why quantitative gravimetry requires a definite, stable and correctly identified final analytical product.
267. A pure organic compound suitable for Kjeldahl nitrogen estimation is completely digested. All liberated ammonia is absorbed in \(40.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) of \(0.100\,\mathrm{M}\) hydrochloric acid.
The unused acid is back-titrated with \(0.100\,\mathrm{M}\) sodium hydroxide.
The student should have stopped the back-titration after \(15.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) of sodium hydroxide, but accidentally adds \(16.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) and records this incorrect endpoint volume.
The original organic sample weighs \(0.280\,\mathrm{g}\).
Assume the ammonia absorption and all other stages are quantitative.
By how many percentage points is the calculated nitrogen percentage lower than the correct value?
ⓐ. \(0.25\) percentage points
ⓑ. \(2.00\) percentage points
ⓒ. \(1.00\) percentage point
ⓓ. \(0.50\) percentage points
Correct Answer: \(0.50\) percentage points
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the endpoint error:}\)
The correct sodium hydroxide volume is:
\[
V_{\mathrm{correct}}=15.0\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
The incorrectly recorded volume is:
\[
V_{\mathrm{recorded}}=16.0\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\Delta V=16.0-15.0
\]
\[
\Delta V=1.00\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
\(\textbf{Convert the excess alkali into an apparent acid difference:}\)
The sodium hydroxide concentration is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{NaOH}}=0.100\,\mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}
\]
The excess amount recorded is:
\[
\Delta n_{\mathrm{NaOH}}
=
\frac{1.00\times0.100}{1000}
\]
\[
\Delta n_{\mathrm{NaOH}}=0.000100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide react in a \(1:1\) mole ratio.
Therefore, the student overestimates the unused hydrochloric acid by:
\[
\Delta n_{\mathrm{HCl}}=0.000100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the nitrogen error:}\)
The acid consumed by ammonia is found by subtracting unused acid from initial acid.
Overestimating unused acid therefore underestimates the ammonia amount by:
\[
\Delta n_{\mathrm{NH_3}}=0.000100\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Each ammonia molecule contains one nitrogen atom.
Thus the underestimated nitrogen mass is:
\[
\Delta m_{\mathrm N}
=
0.000100\times14
\]
\[
\Delta m_{\mathrm N}=0.00140\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the percentage-point error:}\)
The sample mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{sample}}=0.280\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\Delta(\%\mathrm N)
=
\frac{0.00140}{0.280}\times100
\]
\[
\Delta(\%\mathrm N)=0.500
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The endpoint overshoot makes the recorded amount of unused acid too large.
As a result, the acid apparently consumed by ammonia becomes too small.
The calculated nitrogen content is therefore underestimated.
The requested quantity is the difference between two reported percentages, expressed in percentage points, rather than a relative percentage error.
The size of the error depends on the titrant concentration, endpoint-volume difference and original sample mass.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{0.50\ \text{percentage points lower}}
\]
268. Equal portions of a phosphorus-containing organic compound undergo quantitative phosphorus estimation using ammonium phosphomolybdate, \(\mathrm{(NH_4)_3PO_4\cdot12MoO_3}\).
In Trial I, the precipitate is collected, washed properly and dried to give the expected pure analytical product.
In Trial II, the precipitate is collected but not washed adequately. Independent examination establishes that a small quantity of excess ammonium molybdate reagent remains associated with the dried solid.
The student calculates phosphorus percentage in both cases by treating the entire recovered mass as pure ammonium phosphomolybdate.
Which conclusion is correct?
ⓐ. Trial II necessarily underestimates phosphorus because excess ammonium molybdate contains molybdenum.
ⓑ. Trial II remains accurate because excess reagent is expected to stay exclusively in the filtrate.
ⓒ. Trial II necessarily gives a zero phosphorus percentage because the precipitate has not been washed completely.
ⓓ. Phosphorus-free reagent contaminates the precipitate in Trial II, producing an overestimated phosphorus result.
Correct Answer: Phosphorus-free reagent contaminates the precipitate in Trial II, producing an overestimated phosphorus result.
Explanation: Quantitative phosphorus estimation using ammonium phosphomolybdate depends on weighing a definite phosphorus-containing analytical product.
The formula \(\mathrm{(NH_4)_3PO_4\cdot12MoO_3}\) contains one phosphorus atom per formula unit.
The prescribed calculation uses the ratio of one phosphorus atomic mass to the complete formula mass of this precipitate.
That relation assumes the recovered solid consists of pure ammonium phosphomolybdate.
In Trial I, the analytical product is properly washed and dried, so the stated assumption is satisfied.
In Trial II, excess ammonium molybdate reagent remains with the collected precipitate.
The additional reagent contains no phosphorus originating from the organic sample.
Nevertheless, the student includes its mass in the amount assigned to ammonium phosphomolybdate.
The apparent precipitate mass is therefore larger than the mass corresponding to the sample's phosphorus alone.
Applying the same positive gravimetric factor to this inflated mass produces an excessively large calculated phosphorus mass.
Since the organic sample mass is unchanged, the calculated phosphorus percentage also becomes too high.
The error is distinct from incomplete precipitation, which would generally reduce the recovered mass of the intended product.
Accurate gravimetric estimation requires not only formation and recovery of the analytical compound but also removal of adhering reagents and other contaminants before weighing.
269. A crude sample containing \(12.0\,\mathrm{g}\) of desired organic compound P undergoes crystallisation. After cooling and filtration, the filter cake contains \(10.0\,\mathrm{g}\) of crystalline P together with \(2.00\,\mathrm{mL}\) of adhering mother liquor.
Each millilitre of this mother liquor contains \(0.0500\,\mathrm{g}\) of dissolved P and \(0.100\,\mathrm{g}\) of impurity Q.
The cake is washed with a suitable cold solvent. The washing operation removes \(90.0\%\) of the adhering mother liquor but also dissolves \(0.500\,\mathrm{g}\) of crystalline P. Assume the remaining mother liquor retains its original composition and no other material is lost.
Which pair gives the percentage recovery of P and the purity of P in the final dried solid, respectively?
ⓐ. \(79.3\%\) and \(99.8\%\)
ⓑ. \(83.3\%\) and \(98.0\%\)
ⓒ. \(79.3\%\) and \(97.9\%\)
ⓓ. \(83.4\%\) and \(99.8\%\)
Correct Answer: \(79.3\%\) and \(99.8\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the original material in the filter cake:}\)
The cake initially contains \(10.0\,\mathrm{g}\) of crystalline P.
It also retains \(2.00\,\mathrm{mL}\) of mother liquor containing dissolved P and Q.
The dissolved P originally adhering to the crystals is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,adhering}}=2.00\times0.0500
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,adhering}}=0.100\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The corresponding impurity mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,adhering}}=2.00\times0.100
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,adhering}}=0.200\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the mother liquor remaining after washing:}\)
The washing removes \(90.0\%\) of the adhering liquor.
Therefore, the remaining fraction is:
\[
f_{\mathrm{remaining}}=1-0.900
\]
\[
f_{\mathrm{remaining}}=0.100
\]
The remaining mother-liquor volume is:
\[
V_{\mathrm{remaining}}=2.00\times0.100
\]
\[
V_{\mathrm{remaining}}=0.200\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the solutes remaining from the mother liquor:}\)
The remaining dissolved P is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,liquor}}=0.200\times0.0500
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,liquor}}=0.0100\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The remaining Q is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,final}}=0.200\times0.100
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,final}}=0.0200\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Account for dissolution of crystalline P:}\)
The washing solvent dissolves \(0.500\,\mathrm{g}\) of crystalline P.
The crystalline P remaining is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,crystalline}}=10.0-0.500
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,crystalline}}=9.50\,\mathrm{g}
\]
After drying, the dissolved P remaining in the adhering liquor also contributes to the solid.
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,final}}=9.50+0.0100
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,final}}=9.51\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate recovery:}\)
The original crude sample contained \(12.0\,\mathrm{g}\) of P.
Hence:
\[
\%\mathrm{recovery}=\frac{9.51}{12.0}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{recovery}=79.25\%
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate purity:}\)
The final dried solid contains P and the remaining Q.
\[
m_{\mathrm{final\ solid}}=9.51+0.0200
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{final\ solid}}=9.53\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\%\mathrm{purity}=\frac{9.51}{9.53}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{purity}=99.79\%
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
Washing removes most of the impurity-containing mother liquor but also dissolves some desired crystals.
The purification therefore involves competing effects on recovery and purity.
A high final purity does not imply complete recovery of P.
The dissolved P and Q remaining in the adhering liquor must both be included when calculating the composition of the dried solid.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\left(79.3\%,\,99.8\%\right)}
\]
270. A mixture contains \(12.0\,\mathrm{g}\) of desired crystalline organic compound P and \(1.50\,\mathrm{g}\) of impurity Q.
Two solvents are being considered for crystallisation. Their solubilities are:
| Substance and condition | Solvent A | Solvent B |
| P in hot solvent | \(20.0\,\mathrm{g}/100\,\mathrm{mL}\) | \(12.0\,\mathrm{g}/100\,\mathrm{mL}\) |
| P in cold solvent | \(4.00\,\mathrm{g}/100\,\mathrm{mL}\) | \(3.00\,\mathrm{g}/100\,\mathrm{mL}\) |
| Q in cold solvent | \(2.00\,\mathrm{g}/100\,\mathrm{mL}\) | \(3.00\,\mathrm{g}/100\,\mathrm{mL}\) |
Both components dissolve completely in the minimum hot-solvent volume needed to dissolve P. On cooling, each independently reaches its stated solubility limit, and the deposited solids are collected together without occlusion.
The primary objective is to obtain the highest possible purity of P in a single crystallisation.
Which conclusion is correct?
ⓐ. Solvent A is preferred because it gives \(9.60\,\mathrm{g}\) of completely pure P.
ⓑ. B gives \(9.00\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure P, while A also crystallises some Q.
ⓒ. Both solvents give pure P, but Solvent A has the greater recovery.
ⓓ. Solvent B is unsuitable because its hot solubility for P is lower than that of Solvent A.
Correct Answer: B gives \(9.00\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure P, while A also crystallises some Q.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Calculate the minimum volume of Solvent A:}\)
Solvent A dissolves \(20.0\,\mathrm{g}\) of P per \(100\,\mathrm{mL}\) when hot.
To dissolve \(12.0\,\mathrm{g}\):
\[
V_{\mathrm A}=\frac{12.0\times100}{20.0}
\]
\[
V_{\mathrm A}=60.0\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the cold-state P recovery in A:}\)
At the cooling temperature:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,dissolved,A}}=\frac{4.00\times60.0}{100}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,dissolved,A}}=2.40\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,crystals,A}}=12.0-2.40
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,crystals,A}}=9.60\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Check impurity crystallisation in A:}\)
The cold solution can dissolve:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,capacity,A}}=\frac{2.00\times60.0}{100}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,capacity,A}}=1.20\,\mathrm{g}
\]
However, the mixture contains \(1.50\,\mathrm{g}\) of Q.
Consequently:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,crystals,A}}=1.50-1.20
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,crystals,A}}=0.300\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The collected solid from A therefore contains both P and Q.
Its P purity is:
\[
\%\mathrm{purity_A}=\frac{9.60}{9.60+0.300}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{purity_A}=96.97\%
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the minimum volume of Solvent B:}\)
\[
V_{\mathrm B}=\frac{12.0\times100}{12.0}
\]
\[
V_{\mathrm B}=100\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
At the cooling temperature:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,dissolved,B}}=3.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Thus:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,crystals,B}}=12.0-3.00
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,crystals,B}}=9.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Check impurity behaviour in B:}\)
The \(100\,\mathrm{mL}\) cold solution can dissolve \(3.00\,\mathrm{g}\) of Q.
Since only \(1.50\,\mathrm{g}\) is present, all Q remains dissolved.
Therefore, the crystals obtained from B contain only P under the stated assumptions.
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
Solvent A provides a greater mass of recovered P but allows a portion of Q to crystallise.
Solvent B gives slightly lower recovery but complete separation from Q in one crystallisation.
Because maximum purity is the stated priority, Solvent B is preferred.
This illustrates why solvent selection must consider impurity solubility as well as desired-compound recovery.
271. A liquid mixture contains organic compounds P and Q with boiling points of \(180^\circ\mathrm{C}\) and \(184^\circ\mathrm{C}\), respectively, at atmospheric pressure.
Both compounds begin to undergo significant decomposition if maintained at temperatures above \(150^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
At a suitably reduced pressure, P and Q boil at \(118^\circ\mathrm{C}\) and \(122^\circ\mathrm{C}\), respectively, without decomposition.
Assume an appropriately designed fractionating column can operate at the reduced pressure and that the components do not form an azeotrope.
Which method is most appropriate for obtaining separate purified fractions of P and Q?
ⓐ. Simple distillation at atmospheric pressure because the compounds have different boiling points.
ⓑ. Steam distillation because any mixture of two organic liquids can be separated in the presence of steam.
ⓒ. Fractional distillation at reduced pressure because both thermal stability and the small boiling-point difference must be considered.
ⓓ. Simple distillation at reduced pressure because preventing decomposition automatically makes close-boiling liquids easy to separate.
Correct Answer: Fractional distillation at reduced pressure because both thermal stability and the small boiling-point difference must be considered.
Explanation: The separation involves two independent physical-property constraints.
First, P and Q have boiling points that differ by only \(4^\circ\mathrm{C}\) at atmospheric pressure.
Liquids with such closely spaced boiling points are not generally separated efficiently by ordinary simple distillation.
Fractional distillation provides repeated vaporisation and condensation processes that improve separation of close-boiling components.
Second, the compounds begin decomposing above \(150^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
At atmospheric pressure, both boiling temperatures exceed this stability limit.
Therefore, atmospheric-pressure distillation would expose the substances to conditions under which decomposition becomes significant.
Reducing the pressure lowers their boiling temperatures to \(118^\circ\mathrm{C}\) and \(122^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
These temperatures are below the stated decomposition threshold.
However, reduced pressure does not eliminate the small difference between their boiling points.
Consequently, simple distillation at reduced pressure would address thermal decomposition without necessarily providing sufficient separation.
Combining reduced-pressure operation with an appropriate fractionating column addresses both difficulties.
Steam distillation cannot be selected merely because the substances are organic liquids; its suitability depends on the specified behaviour with water.
The scientifically defensible choice must therefore satisfy both the thermal-stability requirement and the close-boiling separation requirement.
272. A TLC plate is used to compare two colourless substances P and Q. The bottom edge of the plate is assigned a ruler coordinate of \(0\,\mathrm{cm}\), but the actual spotting baseline is located at \(1.50\,\mathrm{cm}\).
After development, the solvent front reaches the ruler coordinate \(9.50\,\mathrm{cm}\). The centres of spots P and Q are at ruler coordinates \(4.30\,\mathrm{cm}\) and \(6.70\,\mathrm{cm}\), respectively.
The same plate is developed on silica gel under conditions where greater adsorption produces smaller relative migration.
Which option correctly gives the \(R_f\) values of P and Q and identifies the more strongly adsorbed substance?
ⓐ. \(R_f(P)=0.45,\ R_f(Q)=0.65\); P is more strongly adsorbed.
ⓑ. \(R_f(P)=0.35,\ R_f(Q)=0.65\); Q is more strongly adsorbed.
ⓒ. \(R_f(P)=0.35,\ R_f(Q)=0.65\); P is more strongly adsorbed.
ⓓ. \(R_f(P)=0.35,\ R_f(Q)=0.55\); P is more strongly adsorbed.
Correct Answer: \(R_f(P)=0.35,\ R_f(Q)=0.65\); P is more strongly adsorbed.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the correct reference position:}\)
The \(R_f\) value uses distances measured from the spotting baseline.
The ruler coordinate of the baseline is:
\[
x_{\mathrm{baseline}}=1.50\,\mathrm{cm}
\]
The solvent-front coordinate is:
\[
x_{\mathrm{front}}=9.50\,\mathrm{cm}
\]
Therefore:
\[
d_{\mathrm{front}}=9.50-1.50
\]
\[
d_{\mathrm{front}}=8.00\,\mathrm{cm}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the movement of P:}\)
The P spot occurs at \(4.30\,\mathrm{cm}\).
Its distance from the baseline is:
\[
d_{\mathrm P}=4.30-1.50
\]
\[
d_{\mathrm P}=2.80\,\mathrm{cm}
\]
Using the chromatographic relation:
\[
R_f(P)=\frac{d_{\mathrm P}}{d_{\mathrm{front}}}
\]
\[
R_f(P)=\frac{2.80}{8.00}
\]
\[
R_f(P)=0.35
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the movement of Q:}\)
The Q spot occurs at \(6.70\,\mathrm{cm}\).
Therefore:
\[
d_{\mathrm Q}=6.70-1.50
\]
\[
d_{\mathrm Q}=5.20\,\mathrm{cm}
\]
Its retardation factor is:
\[
R_f(Q)=\frac{5.20}{8.00}
\]
\[
R_f(Q)=0.65
\]
\(\textbf{Interpret adsorption behaviour:}\)
P has the smaller \(R_f\) value.
Under the stated silica-gel conditions, stronger adsorption produces smaller relative migration.
Therefore, P is more strongly adsorbed than Q.
The ruler coordinates cannot be substituted directly into the \(R_f\) formula because the baseline is not at the zero coordinate.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
The retardation factors are \(R_f(P)=0.35\) and \(R_f(Q)=0.65\). Since P has the smaller \(R_f\) value, P is more strongly adsorbed on silica gel.
273. An organic mixture contains three colourless compounds P, Q and R. Their individual behaviour under a particular TLC solvent system is established:
- P is an amino acid that produces a coloured spot after treatment with ninhydrin.
- Q is a colourless organic compound detected under the selected ultraviolet conditions but does not give the stated ninhydrin response.
- R is not detected by either of these revealing methods under the specified experimental conditions, although it is present and separates chromatographically.
A student develops a sample containing all three compounds and observes two spots under ultraviolet light. After ninhydrin treatment, a third, separately positioned spot becomes visible.
Assume the observed spots do not overlap and all stated detection behaviours are reproducible.
Which conclusion is justified?
ⓐ. The chromatogram must contain only two components because ultraviolet examination gave two visible spots.
ⓑ. The ninhydrin spot supports P, but the absence of a visible response cannot establish the absence of R.
ⓒ. The third spot proves that ninhydrin chemically created a new amino acid during chromatographic development.
ⓓ. All three components must be amino acids because they were separated on the same TLC plate.
Correct Answer: The ninhydrin spot supports P, but the absence of a visible response cannot establish the absence of R.
Explanation: Chromatographic separation and detection of separated substances are distinct operations.
The stationary and mobile phases determine the positions to which different components migrate.
However, a separated substance need not be visible without an appropriate detecting procedure.
The question specifies that P is an amino acid giving a ninhydrin response.
Ninhydrin is a suitable revealing reagent for amino acids in the NCERT chromatographic treatment.
A spot appearing after ninhydrin treatment is therefore consistent with P under the stated assumptions.
Q can be detected under the chosen ultraviolet conditions.
R, however, is specified not to respond to either of the two revealing methods.
Consequently, absence of a visible R spot under these conditions does not mean R is chemically absent.
The student must distinguish the number of visible spots from the number of components actually present.
It would also be incorrect to infer that ninhydrin created a new component merely because an additional spot became observable after treatment.
The compound may already have occupied that position on the developed plate.
The appropriate conclusion is that the revealing method affects which separated substances can be observed.
Chromatographic evidence of purity or composition must therefore be interpreted with the limitations of the detection method in mind.
274. Two organic substances P and Q are separated by adsorption chromatography on silica gel. Under the selected conditions, P is more strongly adsorbed than Q and therefore migrates more slowly.
The same mixture is then examined by paper chromatography. In the paper-chromatography system, P is more favourably distributed into the mobile phase than Q, and P migrates farther.
A student claims that one of the experiments must be incorrect because the migration order has reversed.
Which interpretation is most appropriate?
ⓐ. The student is correct because every substance must have the same migration order in every chromatographic method.
ⓑ. The student is correct because paper chromatography has no stationary phase.
ⓒ. Both results may be valid because adsorption and partition chromatography can reverse relative retention.
ⓓ. Both results can be correct only if P and Q chemically decompose into new substances during paper chromatography.
Correct Answer: Both results may be valid because adsorption and partition chromatography can reverse relative retention.
Explanation: Chromatographic separation depends on the relative distribution or retention of substances between stationary and mobile phases.
However, different chromatographic methods can employ different governing interactions.
In adsorption chromatography, separation depends importantly on the relative adsorption of components on the stationary adsorbent.
The question specifies that P is more strongly adsorbed on silica gel than Q.
Therefore, P migrates less readily in the stated adsorption system.
Paper chromatography, as described in NCERT, is a form of partition chromatography.
Water retained by the paper acts as the stationary phase, while a suitable developing solvent forms the mobile phase.
The question specifies that P is more favourably distributed into the mobile phase than Q in this second system.
Consequently, P can travel farther than Q during paper-chromatographic development.
The reversal in migration order is therefore not chemically contradictory.
It reflects the fact that the two chromatographic systems do not impose identical relative retention conditions.
One cannot assume that a compound more strongly retained in one stationary phase must also be more strongly retained in every other phase.
The observations do not require chemical decomposition of either compound.
They illustrate why migration order and chromatographic identity must be interpreted under the particular stationary-phase and mobile-phase conditions used.
275. An aqueous mixture contains \(1.00\,\mathrm{g}\) each of desired compound P and impurity Q. A \(100\,\mathrm{mL}\) aqueous portion is extracted once with \(100\,\mathrm{mL}\) of a suitable immiscible organic solvent.
Two possible extracting solvents have the following distribution coefficients:
| Distribution coefficient \(K=C_{\mathrm{organic}}/C_{\mathrm{aqueous}}\) | Solvent X | Solvent Y |
| P | \(4.00\) | \(2.50\) |
| Q | \(1.00\) | \(0.100\) |
Assume equilibrium distribution, constant solvent volumes and no reactions or solubility-limit complications.
The chosen solvent must recover at least \(70.0\%\) of P in one extraction. Among solvents satisfying this condition, the one producing the higher P purity in the extracted solutes is preferred.
Which conclusion is correct?
ⓐ. Solvent X is preferred because it has the larger distribution coefficient for P, regardless of Q.
ⓑ. Solvent Y is preferred because it recovers approximately \(71.4\%\) of P while extracting much less Q.
ⓒ. Solvent X is preferred because it recovers \(80.0\%\) of P as a completely pure fraction.
ⓓ. Neither solvent meets the required P recovery.
Correct Answer: Solvent Y is preferred because it recovers approximately \(71.4\%\) of P while extracting much less Q.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Establish the extraction relation:}\)
The distribution coefficient is:
\[
K=\frac{C_{\mathrm{organic}}}{C_{\mathrm{aqueous}}}
\]
With equal organic and aqueous volumes, the fraction of a solute transferred into the organic phase is:
\[
f_{\mathrm{extracted}}=\frac{K}{1+K}
\]
The initial mass of each compound is \(1.00\,\mathrm{g}\).
\(\textbf{Calculate P recovered with Solvent X:}\)
For P:
\[
K_{\mathrm{P,X}}=4.00
\]
Therefore:
\[
f_{\mathrm{P,X}}=\frac{4.00}{1+4.00}
\]
\[
f_{\mathrm{P,X}}=0.800
\]
The recovered mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,X}}=1.00\times0.800
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,X}}=0.800\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate Q contamination with X:}\)
\[
f_{\mathrm{Q,X}}=\frac{1.00}{1+1.00}
\]
\[
f_{\mathrm{Q,X}}=0.500
\]
Thus:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,X}}=0.500\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The purity of P in the extracted solutes is:
\[
\%\mathrm{purity_X}=\frac{0.800}{0.800+0.500}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{purity_X}=61.54\%
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate P recovered with Solvent Y:}\)
\[
f_{\mathrm{P,Y}}=\frac{2.50}{1+2.50}
\]
\[
f_{\mathrm{P,Y}}=0.714286
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,Y}}=0.714286\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The P recovery is approximately \(71.4\%\).
\(\textbf{Calculate Q contamination with Y:}\)
\[
f_{\mathrm{Q,Y}}=\frac{0.100}{1+0.100}
\]
\[
f_{\mathrm{Q,Y}}=0.090909
\]
Hence:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,Y}}=0.090909\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The purity of P is:
\[
\%\mathrm{purity_Y}=
\frac{0.714286}{0.714286+0.090909}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{purity_Y}=88.71\%
\]
\(\textbf{Apply the selection condition:}\)
Both solvents recover at least \(70.0\%\) of P.
However, Solvent Y produces a substantially purer extracted solute mixture.
The larger distribution coefficient of P in Solvent X gives greater recovery, but Q is also extracted relatively strongly.
Solvent Y provides the more selective separation under the stated conditions.
Therefore, Y is preferred despite its slightly lower P recovery.
276. A solid mixture contains \(8.00\,\mathrm{g}\) of sublimable compound P and \(3.00\,\mathrm{g}\) of non-sublimable impurity Q.
During controlled sublimation, \(75.0\%\) of P enters the vapour phase. Of the P that sublimes, \(80.0\%\) deposits on the intended cooled collecting surface, while the remainder deposits on other surfaces and is not recovered.
Assume Q remains completely in the original vessel and no mechanical entrainment or chemical decomposition occurs.
Which pair correctly gives the percentage recovery of P in the collected sublimate and the mass of P remaining in the original vessel, respectively?
ⓐ. \(75.0\%\) and \(2.00\,\mathrm{g}\)
ⓑ. \(60.0\%\) and \(2.00\,\mathrm{g}\)
ⓒ. \(60.0\%\) and \(3.20\,\mathrm{g}\)
ⓓ. \(80.0\%\) and \(2.00\,\mathrm{g}\)
Correct Answer: \(60.0\%\) and \(2.00\,\mathrm{g}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine P entering the vapour phase:}\)
Initially:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,initial}}=8.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The sublimed fraction is:
\[
f_{\mathrm{sublimed}}=0.750
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,sublimed}}=8.00\times0.750
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,sublimed}}=6.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate deposition on the collecting surface:}\)
Only \(80.0\%\) of the sublimed P reaches the intended collector.
Thus:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,collected}}=6.00\times0.800
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,collected}}=4.80\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine overall recovery:}\)
The recovery must be compared with the initial P mass.
\[
\%\mathrm{recovery}=\frac{4.80}{8.00}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{recovery}=60.0\%
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the original-vessel residue:}\)
The amount of P that did not sublime is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,residue}}=8.00-6.00
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,residue}}=2.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The original vessel also contains the non-sublimable Q:
\[
m_{\mathrm{Q,residue}}=3.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Thus the total original-vessel residue weighs:
\[
m_{\mathrm{residue,total}}=2.00+3.00
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{residue,total}}=5.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Account for P deposited elsewhere:}\)
The P that sublimed but was not collected is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,other\ surfaces}}=6.00-4.80
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{P,other\ surfaces}}=1.20\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Mass-balance check:}\)
The original mixture weighed:
\[
m_{\mathrm{initial,total}}=8.00+3.00
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{initial,total}}=11.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The final material distribution is:
\[
4.80+5.00+1.20=11.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The balance is satisfied.
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The fraction sublimed and the fraction collected are not identical.
Material that sublimes but deposits on unintended surfaces contributes to recovery loss.
The non-sublimable Q remains in the original vessel, while some unsublimed P remains with it.
The intended collected fraction is pure P under the stated assumptions, but its recovery is only \(60.0\%\).
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\left(60.0\%,\,2.00\,\mathrm{g}\right)}
\]
277. Three organic liquids P, Q and R have the following properties:
| Liquid | Boiling point at atmospheric pressure | Behaviour on prolonged heating | Miscibility with water |
| P | \(95^\circ\mathrm{C}\) | Stable | Completely miscible |
| Q | \(99^\circ\mathrm{C}\) | Stable | Completely miscible |
| R | \(210^\circ\mathrm{C}\) | Decomposes significantly above \(170^\circ\mathrm{C}\) | Immiscible |
P and Q form one homogeneous liquid mixture, whereas R is available separately in pure form.
A student proposes using steam distillation to separate P from Q and ordinary atmospheric distillation to collect R.
Which alternative is scientifically more appropriate?
ⓐ. Use simple distillation for P and Q, and atmospheric distillation for R.
ⓑ. Use steam distillation for P and Q, and fractional distillation at atmospheric pressure for R.
ⓒ. Use fractional distillation for P and Q, and reduced-pressure distillation for R.
ⓓ. Use crystallisation for P and Q, and steam distillation for R without considering its volatility with water.
Correct Answer: Use fractional distillation for P and Q, and reduced-pressure distillation for R.
Explanation: The problem requires selecting different purification methods for two different physical situations.
P and Q form a homogeneous mixture of liquids with boiling points separated by only \(4^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
Such close boiling points make ordinary simple distillation relatively ineffective for obtaining well-separated fractions.
Fractional distillation is the more appropriate method because repeated vaporisation and condensation improve separation.
The complete miscibility of P and Q with water also prevents their automatic classification as suitable candidates for the ordinary immiscible-liquid steam-distillation procedure.
The separate liquid R presents a different problem.
Its atmospheric boiling point is \(210^\circ\mathrm{C}\), whereas significant decomposition begins above \(170^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
Heating R to its ordinary atmospheric boiling point would therefore expose it to damaging conditions.
Distillation under reduced pressure lowers the boiling temperature required for vaporisation.
This permits suitable thermally sensitive liquids to be distilled at temperatures below those required at atmospheric pressure.
The question does not require R to be fractionated from another close-boiling liquid.
Therefore, reduced-pressure distillation addresses its relevant purification constraint.
The choice for P and Q depends mainly on their close boiling points, while the choice for R depends mainly on thermal stability.
One general method cannot be selected correctly for all three liquids without considering their different properties.
278. A column chromatography experiment is performed using a silica-gel stationary phase. The sample contains compounds P, Q and R.
The following observations are recorded during development with a suitable mobile phase:
| Component | Position after equal development time | Independent adsorption assessment |
| P | Nearest the column outlet | Weakest adsorption |
| Q | Intermediate position | Intermediate adsorption |
| R | Nearest the top of the column | Strongest adsorption |
The experiment is repeated with the same stationary phase but a different mobile solvent. The second solvent increases the movement of all three compounds, although their relative adsorption order remains unchanged.
Which conclusion is justified?
ⓐ. R must elute before P because R has the strongest interaction with the stationary phase.
ⓑ. P may still elute first, but the absolute migration rates can change when the mobile solvent changes.
ⓒ. All components must move identical distances because the stationary phase remains unchanged.
ⓓ. The increased movement proves that adsorption chromatography has become partition chromatography.
Correct Answer: P may still elute first, but the absolute migration rates can change when the mobile solvent changes.
Explanation: Column chromatography depends on differences in the retention of components by the stationary phase.
The question specifies that silica gel serves as the stationary adsorbent.
P is the weakest-adsorbed component and has migrated closest to the column outlet.
R is the strongest-adsorbed component and remains closest to the top.
These observations are consistent with greater stationary-phase retention producing slower migration under the stated conditions.
Q has intermediate adsorption and occupies an intermediate position.
Changing the mobile solvent can alter the effectiveness with which compounds are carried through the column.
The second solvent is specified to increase the movement of all three components.
However, their relative adsorption order remains unchanged.
Therefore, the increased absolute migration does not require reversal of their relative elution order.
P can still reach the outlet before Q and R.
The stationary phase remains silica gel, so a faster migration rate does not by itself convert the method into partition chromatography.
The observations show that migration rate and relative elution order are related but distinct properties.
A change in mobile-phase conditions can alter the speed of separation without necessarily reversing which component is retained most strongly.
279. An aqueous sodium-fusion extract is suspected to contain chloride and sulphide ions. Two portions are examined.
In Portion I, silver nitrate is added directly and a dark precipitate forms.
In Portion II, the prescribed concentrated nitric-acid treatment removes sulphide interference. Addition of silver nitrate then produces a white precipitate that dissolves in aqueous ammonia.
A separately prepared portion gives a positive sulphide test with sodium nitroprusside.
Which conclusion is most defensible?
ⓐ. Only sulphur is present because the untreated silver nitrate test produced a dark precipitate.
ⓑ. Only chlorine is present because the treated extract produced a white precipitate.
ⓒ. The results support sulphur and chlorine, but interfering ions make the untreated silver nitrate test unreliable.
ⓓ. Neither sulphur nor chlorine is supported because nitric acid changes the colour of silver precipitates.
Correct Answer: The results support sulphur and chlorine, but interfering ions make the untreated silver nitrate test unreliable.
Explanation: The qualitative sulphur test relies on the sulphide-containing species produced during suitable sodium fusion.
The separate sodium nitroprusside observation supports the presence of sulphur under the stated conditions.
However, sulphide can also react with silver(I) ions and interfere with the halogen-detection procedure.
Therefore, the dark precipitate observed when silver nitrate is added directly to Portion I cannot be treated as a pure silver-halide observation.
The relevant halogen test should be interpreted after removal of interfering species.
Portion II undergoes the prescribed concentrated nitric-acid treatment.
The question specifies that this treatment removes the sulphide-derived interference.
Silver nitrate subsequently produces a white precipitate.
Its dissolution in aqueous ammonia is characteristic of silver chloride in the NCERT treatment.
This provides evidence for chloride in the appropriately prepared fusion extract.
The two positive observations correspond to different analytical species arising from sulphur and chlorine.
The untreated dark precipitate does not invalidate the later chloride result.
Correct interpretation requires separating interference removal from the final characteristic detection reaction.
The evidence therefore supports both elements rather than forcing a choice between them.
280. An organic compound containing nitrogen and bromine is subjected to suitable sodium fusion. Its aqueous extract is divided into two equal portions.
Portion I is treated through the prescribed iron(II)-cyanide complex formation and subsequent iron(III) reaction, producing Prussian blue.
Portion II is boiled with concentrated nitric acid to remove cyanide interference. Addition of silver nitrate produces a yellowish precipitate that is sparingly soluble in aqueous ammonia.
A student proposes that the nitrogen result from Portion I must be false because the nitric-acid-treated Portion II no longer contains cyanide.
Which statement correctly evaluates the proposal?
ⓐ. The proposal is correct because cyanide must remain unchanged in every portion of the fusion extract.
ⓑ. The proposal is incorrect because Prussian blue is formed directly from molecular nitrogen without involvement of cyanide.
ⓒ. The proposal is correct because silver bromide formation prevents nitrogen from occurring in the original compound.
ⓓ. The separately treated portions test different species; destroying cyanide in Portion II does not invalidate its detection in Portion I.
Correct Answer: The separately treated portions test different species; destroying cyanide in Portion II does not invalidate its detection in Portion I.
Explanation: The starting fusion extract contains inorganic products corresponding to elements in the original organic compound.
Suitable sodium fusion can convert organically bound nitrogen into cyanide and bromine into bromide.
Portion I follows the prescribed nitrogen-detection sequence.
Cyanide participates in forming an iron(II)-cyanide complex, followed by the iron(III) reaction producing Prussian blue.
This positive result supports nitrogen in the original sample.
Portion II is subjected to a different analytical treatment because bromide is to be detected with silver nitrate.
Cyanide would interfere with that silver nitrate reaction if left in the extract.
Consequently, concentrated nitric-acid treatment is used to remove cyanide interference under the prescribed conditions.
The absence of cyanide after this treatment is expected and does not contradict its earlier presence.
The yellowish silver precipitate with limited ammonia solubility supports bromide detection.
The two tests therefore provide compatible information about different elements.
The student's mistake is to assume that the chemical form of the analytical species must remain unchanged after different reagent treatments.
Separate aliquots permit the original elements to be tested using procedures that would be incompatible if applied sequentially to the same untreated portion.
281. An organic compound contains nitrogen and sulphur. Quantitative elemental analysis gives the following results from equal masses of the compound:
- Complete Dumas estimation produces \(44.8\,\mathrm{mL}\) of dry nitrogen at STP.
- Complete sulphur estimation produces \(0.466\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure, dry barium sulphate.
Assume quantitative conversion and recovery.
Using \(Ba=137\), \(S=32\), \(O=16\) and \(22400\,\mathrm{mL\,mol^{-1}}\) as the molar volume at STP, what is the atomic ratio of nitrogen to sulphur in the compound?
ⓐ. \(1:2\)
ⓑ. \(2:1\)
ⓒ. \(1:1\)
ⓓ. \(4:1\)
Correct Answer: \(2:1\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine nitrogen from the Dumas measurement:}\)
The collected nitrogen is molecular nitrogen:
\[
V_{\mathrm{N_2}}=44.8\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
At STP:
\[
n_{\mathrm{N_2}}=\frac{44.8}{22400}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{N_2}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Each molecule contains two nitrogen atoms.
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm N}=2n_{\mathrm{N_2}}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm N}=2(0.00200)
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm N}=0.00400\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine sulphur from the gravimetric product:}\)
The barium sulphate mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=0.466\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Its molar mass is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=137+32+4(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=233\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The amount of barium sulphate is:
\[
n_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=\frac{0.466}{233}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Each formula unit of barium sulphate contains one sulphur atom.
Thus:
\[
n_{\mathrm S}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the atomic ratio:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm N}:n_{\mathrm S}
=
0.00400:0.00200
\]
Dividing by the smaller amount:
\[
n_{\mathrm N}:n_{\mathrm S}=2:1
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
Equal sample masses allow the two elemental quantities to be compared directly.
Dumas estimation measures nitrogen as diatomic molecules.
The barium sulphate method measures sulphur through a formula unit containing one sulphur atom.
Therefore, equal mole amounts of these two analytical products do not represent equal mole amounts of nitrogen and sulphur atoms.
The nitrogen amount must be doubled before the elemental ratio is formed.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{N:S=2:1}
\]
282. A nitrogen-containing organic compound is analysed by the Kjeldahl method. After complete digestion and quantitative liberation of ammonia, the gas is absorbed in excess standard hydrochloric acid.
The receiving solution is diluted to \(200\,\mathrm{mL}\). A \(50.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) aliquot of this solution requires \(15.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) of \(0.100\,\mathrm{M}\) sodium hydroxide to neutralise the unused acid.
The original receiving flask contained \(40.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) of \(0.200\,\mathrm{M}\) hydrochloric acid.
The organic sample mass was \(0.700\,\mathrm{g}\).
Assume quantitative absorption, homogeneous dilution and accurate titration.
What is the nitrogen percentage of the compound?
ⓐ. \(2.00\%\)
ⓑ. \(4.00\%\)
ⓒ. \(6.00\%\)
ⓓ. \(8.00\%\)
Correct Answer: \(4.00\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Calculate the initial hydrochloric acid:}\)
The receiving acid volume is:
\[
V_{\mathrm{HCl}}=40.0\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
Its concentration is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{HCl}}=0.200\,\mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl,initial}}
=
\frac{40.0\times0.200}{1000}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl,initial}}=0.00800\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine unused acid in the aliquot:}\)
The \(50.0\,\mathrm{mL}\) aliquot requires:
\[
V_{\mathrm{NaOH}}=15.0\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{NaOH}}=0.100\,\mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}
\]
Thus:
\[
n_{\mathrm{NaOH}}
=
\frac{15.0\times0.100}{1000}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{NaOH}}=0.00150\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
Hydrochloric acid reacts with sodium hydroxide in a \(1:1\) mole ratio.
Therefore, the aliquot contains:
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl,aliquot}}=0.00150\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Restore the unused acid in the complete receiving solution:}\)
The complete diluted solution has volume \(200\,\mathrm{mL}\).
The aliquot represents \(50.0\,\mathrm{mL}\).
Therefore:
\[
f=\frac{200}{50.0}
\]
\[
f=4
\]
The unused acid amount is:
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl,unused}}=0.00150\times4
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl,unused}}=0.00600\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine acid consumed by ammonia:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl,consumed}}
=
0.00800-0.00600
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{HCl,consumed}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
The reaction is:
\[
\mathrm{NH_3+HCl\rightarrow NH_4Cl}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n_{\mathrm{NH_3}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate nitrogen mass:}\)
Each mole of ammonia contains one mole of nitrogen atoms.
\[
m_{\mathrm N}=0.00200\times14
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm N}=0.0280\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate nitrogen percentage:}\)
\[
\%\mathrm N=\frac{0.0280}{0.700}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm N=4.00\%
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The back-titration measures only a fraction of the unused receiving acid.
That quantity must first be multiplied by the dilution factor before subtraction from the initially added acid.
The resulting acid consumption is attributed to ammonia.
The calculated ammonia amount then gives the nitrogen mass.
Failure to restore the full receiving-solution volume would overestimate the acid consumed by ammonia and therefore overestimate nitrogen.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{4.00\%}
\]
283. A pure organic compound contains carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, sulphur and oxygen, with no other elements.
A \(0.500\,\mathrm{g}\) sample undergoes separate quantitative elemental analyses. The following analytical products are obtained:
| Elemental determination | Result |
| Carbon | \(0.660\,\mathrm{g}\) of \(\mathrm{CO_2}\) |
| Hydrogen | \(0.270\,\mathrm{g}\) of \(\mathrm{H_2O}\) |
| Nitrogen | \(44.8\,\mathrm{mL}\) of dry \(\mathrm{N_2}\) at STP |
| Sulphur | \(0.466\,\mathrm{g}\) of pure, dry \(\mathrm{BaSO_4}\) |
Take \(C=12\), \(H=1\), \(N=14\), \(S=32\), \(O=16\), \(Ba=137\) and the molar volume at STP as \(22400\,\mathrm{mL\,mol^{-1}}\).
Assume complete conversion and collection of all analytical products.
What is the oxygen percentage of the compound?
ⓐ. \(34.0\%\)
ⓑ. \(39.0\%\)
ⓒ. \(31.0\%\)
ⓓ. \(28.0\%\)
Correct Answer: \(34.0\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine carbon mass:}\)
The carbon dioxide obtained is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{CO_2}}=0.660\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm C}=0.660\times\frac{12}{44}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm C}=0.180\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine hydrogen mass:}\)
The water obtained is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{H_2O}}=0.270\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm H}=0.270\times\frac{2}{18}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm H}=0.0300\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine nitrogen mass:}\)
The measured nitrogen volume is:
\[
V_{\mathrm{N_2}}=44.8\,\mathrm{mL}
\]
At STP:
\[
n_{\mathrm{N_2}}=\frac{44.8}{22400}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{N_2}}=0.00200\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
The mass of nitrogen is:
\[
m_{\mathrm N}=0.00200\times28
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm N}=0.0560\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine sulphur mass:}\)
The barium sulphate precipitate weighs:
\[
m_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=0.466\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The molar mass is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=137+32+4(16)
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{BaSO_4}}=233\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm S}=0.466\times\frac{32}{233}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm S}=0.0640\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Apply the complete elemental mass balance:}\)
The compound contains only carbon, hydrogen, nitrogen, sulphur and oxygen.
Therefore:
\[
m_{\mathrm O}
=
m_{\mathrm{sample}}-m_{\mathrm C}-m_{\mathrm H}-m_{\mathrm N}-m_{\mathrm S}
\]
Substituting:
\[
m_{\mathrm O}
=
0.500-0.180-0.0300-0.0560-0.0640
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm O}=0.170\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate oxygen percentage:}\)
\[
\%\mathrm O=\frac{0.170}{0.500}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm O=34.0\%
\]
\(\textbf{Check the percentage distribution:}\)
The separately determined elemental percentages are:
\[
\%\mathrm C=36.0\%
\]
\[
\%\mathrm H=6.0\%
\]
\[
\%\mathrm N=11.2\%
\]
\[
\%\mathrm S=12.8\%
\]
Combining them with the oxygen percentage:
\[
36.0+6.0+11.2+12.8+34.0=100.0\%
\]
The elemental mass balance is therefore satisfied.
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
The analytical products contain atoms supplied by reagents, so their complete masses cannot be added to determine the original sample composition.
Each product must first be converted into the mass of its corresponding original element.
Because the elemental composition is explicitly restricted to five elements, oxygen can then be determined by difference.
Omitting either nitrogen or sulphur from the balance would incorrectly assign its mass to oxygen.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{34.0\%}
\]
284. A crude solid contains desired compound P together with impurities Q and R. The following properties are established:
- P is readily soluble in hot ethanol but poorly soluble in cold water.
- Q is insoluble in hot ethanol.
- R is soluble in hot ethanol and remains readily soluble in the intended cold ethanol–water solvent mixture.
- Ethanol and water are mutually miscible, and P can be crystallised by carefully adding water to its ethanolic solution followed by cooling.
A student dissolves the crude sample in hot ethanol and proposes adding water immediately, allowing crystallisation, and then collecting all solid material by filtration.
Which modification gives the most defensible purification sequence?
ⓐ. Add water before filtering Q so that P precipitates while the original insoluble material separates later.
ⓑ. Cool the hot ethanolic suspension before filtration because Q must become soluble as the temperature decreases.
ⓒ. Evaporate all ethanol and water to dryness because this must leave P without Q or R.
ⓓ. Filter out Q while hot, crystallise P using the specified solvent mixture, and leave soluble R in the mother liquor.
Correct Answer: Filter out Q while hot, crystallise P using the specified solvent mixture, and leave soluble R in the mother liquor.
Explanation: The purification requires two distinct separation decisions because Q and R have different solubility behaviours. Q is insoluble even in hot ethanol, so it can be removed while P and R remain dissolved. Hot filtration provides the appropriate separation between the insoluble Q and the ethanolic solution. If this step is omitted, Q remains suspended and may contaminate the subsequently collected crystals. The filtrate contains P together with dissolved R. The question specifies that careful addition of water to this ethanolic solution, followed by cooling, provides suitable conditions for crystallisation of P. P consequently separates from the solvent mixture as its solubility decreases. R remains readily soluble under the final conditions and is therefore retained principally in the mother liquor. Filtration then separates crystalline P from the liquid containing R. Evaporating the complete solution to dryness would not selectively remove the dissolved impurity. The mixed-solvent procedure is useful only when the desired compound and its impurities respond differently to the changed solvent composition. The correct sequence therefore combines hot filtration with controlled crystallisation rather than assuming that one cooling operation removes every impurity.
285. A mixture of two miscible organic liquids P and Q has boiling points of \(78^\circ\mathrm{C}\) and \(82^\circ\mathrm{C}\), respectively, at the operating pressure. Both are chemically stable, and they do not form an azeotrope.
The mixture is subjected to fractional distillation using an appropriate fractionating column. Three successive collected fractions are analysed:
| Fraction | Mass percentage of P | Mass percentage of Q |
| I | \(96\%\) | \(4\%\) |
| II | \(55\%\) | \(45\%\) |
| III | \(6\%\) | \(94\%\) |
The objective is to obtain separate fractions enriched as strongly as possible in P and Q without unnecessarily contaminating either collected product.
Which strategy is most appropriate?
ⓐ. Combine Fractions I and III because their compositions are complementary, and discard Fraction II.
ⓑ. Add Fraction II entirely to Fraction I because its P percentage exceeds its Q percentage.
ⓒ. Add Fraction II entirely to Fraction III because it was collected between the other two fractions.
ⓓ. Keep the P-rich and Q-rich fractions separate; refractionate the intermediate mixed fraction.
Correct Answer: Keep the P-rich and Q-rich fractions separate; refractionate the intermediate mixed fraction.
Explanation: Fractional distillation is appropriate because P and Q have closely spaced boiling points. The fractionating column provides repeated condensation and vaporisation, allowing partial enrichment of different components. However, the collected fractions need not all possess the same degree of purity. Fraction I contains a high percentage of P and is therefore the P-rich fraction. Fraction III contains a high percentage of Q and is therefore the Q-rich fraction. Fraction II contains substantial quantities of both compounds and represents a comparatively poorly separated portion of the distillate. Adding Fraction II to the P-rich fraction would increase the contamination of that fraction by Q. Adding it to the Q-rich fraction would similarly increase contamination by P. Combining Fractions I and III would largely undo the separation already achieved. The intermediate fraction may instead be subjected to further fractional distillation if additional separation is worthwhile. Its treatment should be determined by the required purity and recovery rather than by collection order alone. The experiment illustrates that obtaining a distillate is not identical to obtaining a pure component. Fraction collection and subsequent handling are both important parts of a successful fractional-distillation procedure.
286. An organic liquid P is immiscible with water and can be purified by steam distillation without decomposition. At the boiling temperature of the water–P system, the saturated vapour pressures are:
\[
P_{\mathrm{water}}=520\,\mathrm{mmHg}
\]
\[
P_{\mathrm P}=240\,\mathrm{mmHg}
\]
The external pressure is \(760\,\mathrm{mmHg}\). The molar mass of P is \(120\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}\), and the molar mass of water is \(18\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}\).
Assume ideal vapour behaviour, both liquid phases remain present, and the vapours condense quantitatively.
What is the mass ratio of P to water in the distillate?
ⓐ. \(0.462:1\)
ⓑ. \(3.08:1\)
ⓒ. \(2.17:1\)
ⓓ. \(1.85:1\)
Correct Answer: \(3.08:1\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Verify the boiling condition:}\)
For immiscible liquids under the stated conditions, the total vapour pressure is the sum of their individual saturated vapour pressures.
\[
P_{\mathrm{total}}=P_{\mathrm{water}}+P_{\mathrm P}
\]
Substituting:
\[
P_{\mathrm{total}}=520+240
\]
\[
P_{\mathrm{total}}=760\,\mathrm{mmHg}
\]
The total vapour pressure equals the external pressure, so the stated condition is consistent with boiling.
\(\textbf{Determine the vapour mole ratio:}\)
For ideal vapours collected at the same temperature and pressure:
\[
\frac{n_{\mathrm P}}{n_{\mathrm{water}}}
=
\frac{P_{\mathrm P}}{P_{\mathrm{water}}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\frac{n_{\mathrm P}}{n_{\mathrm{water}}}
=
\frac{240}{520}
\]
\[
\frac{n_{\mathrm P}}{n_{\mathrm{water}}}
=
\frac{6}{13}
\]
\(\textbf{Convert mole ratio into mass ratio:}\)
The mass of each component depends on its mole amount and molar mass.
\[
\frac{m_{\mathrm P}}{m_{\mathrm{water}}}
=
\frac{n_{\mathrm P}M_{\mathrm P}}{n_{\mathrm{water}}M_{\mathrm{water}}}
\]
Substituting the vapour-pressure relation:
\[
\frac{m_{\mathrm P}}{m_{\mathrm{water}}}
=
\frac{P_{\mathrm P}M_{\mathrm P}}
{P_{\mathrm{water}}M_{\mathrm{water}}}
\]
Using the supplied values:
\[
\frac{m_{\mathrm P}}{m_{\mathrm{water}}}
=
\frac{240\times120}{520\times18}
\]
\[
\frac{m_{\mathrm P}}{m_{\mathrm{water}}}
=
\frac{28800}{9360}
\]
\[
\frac{m_{\mathrm P}}{m_{\mathrm{water}}}
=
3.0769\ldots
\]
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
Water contributes the larger vapour pressure and therefore the larger number of vapour molecules. Nevertheless, P has a much larger molar mass than water. Consequently, the mass of P in the condensed distillate can exceed the mass of water. The vapour-pressure ratio alone is a mole ratio, not a mass ratio. Both the individual vapour pressures and molar masses are needed to determine the relative masses of the condensed components.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{m_{\mathrm P}:m_{\mathrm{water}}=3.08:1}
\]
287. A mixture of three organic compounds P, Q and R is introduced into an adsorption chromatography column containing silica gel.
Under the initial mobile-phase conditions:
- P is weakly adsorbed and leaves the column readily.
- Q is moderately adsorbed and can be separated from P.
- R is strongly adsorbed and remains near the top of the column even after P and Q have been collected.
A different suitable mobile solvent is available that reduces the retention of R sufficiently for it to move through the column.
Which strategy is most defensible for recovering all three components separately?
ⓐ. Collect P and Q using the original mobile phase, then use the second suitable mobile phase to elute R without combining it with the earlier fractions.
ⓑ. Continue using the original mobile phase indefinitely because the stationary phase cannot retain R once P and Q have left.
ⓒ. Add the second mobile phase before collecting P so that all three substances necessarily emerge in a single pure fraction.
ⓓ. Replace the silica gel with paper after Q leaves the column because changing the mobile solvent cannot affect adsorption chromatography.
Correct Answer: Collect P and Q using the original mobile phase, then use the second suitable mobile phase to elute R without combining it with the earlier fractions.
Explanation: Adsorption chromatography separates compounds because they interact to different extents with the stationary adsorbent. The silica gel in this experiment retains R more strongly than Q and P under the original mobile-phase conditions. P consequently moves through the column most readily. Q moves more slowly but can still be collected separately. R remains strongly retained and does not migrate sufficiently for satisfactory recovery with the original mobile solvent. The question specifies that a second suitable mobile solvent reduces R's retention. Once the earlier fractions have been collected, changing the mobile solvent can permit R to move through the column. This allows the strongly retained component to be recovered without deliberately mixing it with P or Q. The method does not require changing the stationary phase halfway through the experiment. Nor is there a guarantee that adding the stronger mobile solvent from the beginning would preserve the useful separation of P and Q. The choice of mobile solvent affects migration and separation, so the development conditions may be selected to recover components at different stages. The correct strategy combines controlled elution with separate fraction collection. It recognises that strong adsorption can delay recovery without making the retained substance chemically absent from the sample.
288. A crude solid mixture contains desired organic compound P and impurity Q. Both P and Q sublime appreciably under the same heating conditions, and their vapours deposit together on a cooled surface.
Additional observations establish that P is highly soluble in a suitable hot solvent and poorly soluble in that solvent when cold, whereas Q remains highly soluble at both temperatures.
Which conclusion is most defensible?
ⓐ. Crystallisation can selectively recover P from Q, whereas their similar sublimation behaviour offers little separation.
ⓑ. Neither sublimation nor crystallisation can separate the compounds because both are organic solids.
ⓒ. Sublimation is necessarily the superior purification method because both compounds enter the vapour phase.
ⓓ. Sublimation must give pure P because the first solid to deposit is always the desired compound.
Correct Answer: Crystallisation can selectively recover P from Q, whereas their similar sublimation behaviour offers little separation.
Explanation: The usefulness of a purification method depends on differences between the physical properties of the desired substance and its impurities. Sublimation can separate a suitable sublimable solid from material that does not sublime appreciably under the same conditions. In the stated mixture, however, both P and Q sublime. Their vapours also deposit together on the collecting surface. Therefore, the stated sublimation operation lacks the selectivity required to obtain pure P. Crystallisation offers a different basis for separation. P dissolves well in the selected hot solvent but has low solubility when the solvent is cold. This makes it possible for P to crystallise as the solution cools. Q remains highly soluble under the cooling conditions and can remain in the mother liquor. The contrasting solubility behaviours therefore provide a plausible route to separating the two compounds. The answer does not depend simply on whether P can sublime or dissolve. It depends on whether the selected method distinguishes P from Q sufficiently. Two compounds can each exhibit the physical property used by a purification method without necessarily being separable by that method. A better purification choice must exploit a useful difference in their actual behaviours.
289. A mixture of two stable, miscible organic liquids with nearby boiling points is separated by fractional distillation.
A suitable fractionating column is used in two trials with otherwise identical conditions:
- Trial I permits repeated condensation and vaporisation within the column.
- Trial II has an incorrectly arranged column in which most condensed liquid bypasses the intended repeated vapour–liquid contacts and rapidly drains back into the distillation flask.
Assume the compounds do not react or form an azeotrope.
Which outcome is most consistent with the principles of fractional distillation?
ⓐ. Trial II must produce purer fractions because rapid return of condensed liquid always improves separation.
ⓑ. Trial II may give poorer separation because the repeated vapour–liquid contacts responsible for enrichment have been reduced.
ⓒ. Trial I cannot separate the mixture because condensation inside the column prevents any vapour from reaching the condenser.
ⓓ. Both trials must have identical separation efficiencies because only the original boiling points determine the distillate compositions.
Correct Answer: Trial II may give poorer separation because the repeated vapour–liquid contacts responsible for enrichment have been reduced.
Explanation: Fractional distillation is particularly useful for separating miscible liquids whose boiling points are close. A fractionating column provides opportunities for repeated condensation and vaporisation. These repeated processes help establish vapour and liquid compositions that differ from the original mixture. The vapour reaching the upper part of the column can become enriched in the more volatile component. Efficient interaction between rising vapour and returning condensed liquid is therefore an important feature of the separation. In Trial I, the intended repeated contacts occur within the column. In Trial II, much of the condensed material bypasses these contacts. The question specifies that the arrangement consequently reduces the repeated vapour–liquid interactions. Under these conditions, the column may perform less effectively even though the substances and their boiling points are unchanged. Merely providing a long column or allowing condensed liquid to drain back does not guarantee the desired degree of fractionation. Condensation inside the column is not inherently undesirable; it is part of the process by which separation improves. The important issue is whether condensation and subsequent vaporisation contribute to effective fractionation. The likely consequence of the defective arrangement is therefore poorer separation of the close-boiling components.
290. A solution contains an organic compound P dissolved in water. A water-immiscible extracting solvent S has a density of \(1.20\,\mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}\), while the aqueous solution has a density of \(1.00\,\mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}\).
At equilibrium, P preferentially dissolves in S. The two liquids are shaken together in a separating funnel and allowed to form clear layers without emulsion.
The student assumes that the organic solvent must be the upper layer and opens the stopcock to discard the lower layer.
Which interpretation is correct?
ⓐ. The lower layer is necessarily aqueous because water has a smaller molar mass than an organic solvent.
ⓑ. Preferential dissolution of P in S requires S to form the upper layer regardless of density.
ⓒ. The position of the layers cannot be predicted because the distribution coefficient and density are always numerically equal.
ⓓ. The lower layer is solvent S under the stated density conditions, so discarding it would remove the phase enriched in P.
Correct Answer: The lower layer is solvent S under the stated density conditions, so discarding it would remove the phase enriched in P.
Explanation: Differential extraction involves distributing a dissolved compound between two suitable immiscible liquids. The relative amount of P in the organic and aqueous phases is governed by its distribution behaviour under the extraction conditions. The question states that P preferentially dissolves in solvent S. Therefore, the solvent-S phase becomes enriched in the desired compound. However, preferential solubility does not determine whether a liquid occupies the upper or lower layer. Layer position depends primarily on the densities of the immiscible liquids under the stated conditions. Solvent S has a density of \(1.20\,\mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}\), which is greater than the aqueous solution's density of \(1.00\,\mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}\). The denser solvent consequently forms the lower layer after the liquids settle. The student incorrectly assumes that every organic solvent forms the upper layer. Opening the stopcock and discarding the lower layer would therefore discard the solvent phase enriched in P. The distribution coefficient and density describe different physical properties and should not be confused. A separating funnel can be used successfully only when the collected layer is identified correctly. The appropriate decision must consider both where the desired compound partitions and which liquid occupies each layer.
291. A coloured organic impurity Q is present in a sample of crystalline compound P. Activated charcoal is known to adsorb Q, but it also adsorbs P to a smaller extent.
Two treatments are compared:
| Property | Treatment I | Treatment II |
| Activated charcoal added | Small suitable quantity | Large excess |
| Removal of Q | Almost complete | Complete |
| Loss of P through adsorption | Small | Substantial |
| Subsequent crystallisation | Successful | Successful |
The aim is to obtain sufficiently pure P while avoiding unnecessary loss of the desired compound.
Which interpretation is most appropriate?
ⓐ. Treatment II is always superior because using more adsorbent cannot reduce recovery of P.
ⓑ. Treatment I is necessarily unsuitable because charcoal must remove every molecule of Q before crystallisation.
ⓒ. Excess charcoal provides little further impurity removal but causes a substantial loss of P.
ⓓ. Neither treatment can work because adsorption and crystallisation cannot be used in the same purification sequence.
Correct Answer: Excess charcoal provides little further impurity removal but causes a substantial loss of P.
Explanation: Activated charcoal can help remove suitable coloured impurities through adsorption during purification by crystallisation. It is not the substance that causes P to crystallise. Instead, it selectively retains some dissolved material on its surface under the appropriate conditions. In this experiment, Q is strongly adsorbed, but P is also adsorbed to a smaller extent. The amount of charcoal therefore influences both impurity removal and loss of the desired compound. Treatment I removes almost all Q while retaining most of P for crystallisation. Treatment II removes the remaining small amount of Q but causes substantial additional loss of P. Because the stated objective includes adequate purity and satisfactory recovery, the greater charcoal quantity is not automatically advantageous. A purification treatment must be evaluated in terms of both the composition and amount of the recovered material. The final crystallisation stage remains useful after the charcoal treatment because it separates P through its solubility behaviour. Adsorption and crystallisation can consequently serve different purposes within one purification sequence. Increasing the extent of one purification operation does not necessarily improve the overall outcome. The appropriate amount of adsorbent should achieve the required impurity removal without unnecessary loss of P.
292. A student compares the separation of the same organic compounds P and Q by paper chromatography using two different mobile solvents while maintaining the same type of paper as the stationary support.
The measured distances from the starting line are:
| Run | Solvent front | Spot P | Spot Q |
| I | \(10.0\,\mathrm{cm}\) | \(6.0\,\mathrm{cm}\) | \(3.0\,\mathrm{cm}\) |
| II | \(12.0\,\mathrm{cm}\) | \(4.8\,\mathrm{cm}\) | \(7.2\,\mathrm{cm}\) |
Assume the spots are well resolved, the migration distances are measured from the same starting line in each run, and the compounds remain chemically unchanged.
Which comparison of relative chromatographic migration is correct?
ⓐ. P has the greater \(R_f\) in both runs.
ⓑ. P has the greater \(R_f\) in Run I, whereas Q has the greater \(R_f\) in Run II.
ⓒ. Q has the greater \(R_f\) in Run I, whereas P has the greater \(R_f\) in Run II.
ⓓ. Neither run permits comparison because the two solvent fronts moved different distances.
Correct Answer: P has the greater \(R_f\) in Run I, whereas Q has the greater \(R_f\) in Run II.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the relevant chromatographic relation:}\)
The retardation factor measures the distance travelled by a spot relative to the distance travelled by the solvent front from the same starting line.
\[
R_f=\frac{\text{distance moved by substance}}{\text{distance moved by solvent front}}
\]
The solvent front need not travel the same absolute distance in different runs for a within-run comparison of the two \(R_f\) values.
\(\textbf{Calculate the values in Run I:}\)
\[
R_f(P)=\frac{6.0}{10.0}=0.60
\]
\[
R_f(Q)=\frac{3.0}{10.0}=0.30
\]
Therefore, P moves farther relative to the solvent front than Q in Run I.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the changed mobile solvent in Run II:}\)
\[
R_f(P)=\frac{4.8}{12.0}=0.40
\]
\[
R_f(Q)=\frac{7.2}{12.0}=0.60
\]
The ordering is now reversed: Q has the larger \(R_f\) and P has the smaller \(R_f\).
The different mobile solvent can change the relative interactions responsible for migration without chemically changing either compound.
\(\textbf{Interpret the comparison:}\)
It would be incorrect to transfer an \(R_f\) value from one solvent system to the other as though it were an intrinsic constant of a compound.
It would also be incorrect to compare spot distances alone without normalising by the solvent-front distance.
Both runs resolve P from Q, but they give opposite relative migration orders.
The correct choice reflects the ordering in each specified mobile-solvent system.
293. A suitable organic compound P is soluble in water and can be extracted using a water-immiscible organic solvent. The extraction is performed twice using equal fresh portions of solvent under identical conditions.
After the first extraction, some P remains in the aqueous phase. After the second extraction, the total amount of P recovered in the combined organic extracts is larger.
A student concludes that the second extraction must have increased the distribution coefficient of P because more P has been recovered overall.
Which evaluation is correct?
ⓐ. The conclusion is correct because the distribution coefficient increases automatically after every extraction.
ⓑ. The conclusion is correct because the second solvent portion changes the molecular formula of P.
ⓒ. Fresh solvent contacts can increase cumulative recovery even with a constant distribution coefficient.
ⓓ. The conclusion is not justified because a second extraction must return all previously extracted P to the aqueous phase.
Correct Answer: Fresh solvent contacts can increase cumulative recovery even with a constant distribution coefficient.
Explanation: A distribution coefficient describes the equilibrium distribution of a solute between two immiscible liquids under specified conditions. It is not simply the percentage of the original sample recovered during an entire sequence of extraction operations. In the first extraction, some P transfers into the organic solvent while some remains in water. The two phases are then separated. A fresh portion of organic solvent is introduced during the second extraction. The P remaining in water again distributes between the fresh organic solvent and the aqueous phase. Consequently, additional P can enter the new organic portion. Combining the two organic extracts gives a greater recovered amount than the first extraction alone. This improvement does not require the intrinsic distribution coefficient to change. It arises because previously unextracted P receives another opportunity to transfer into a fresh solvent phase. The fraction recovered in a particular contact depends on the distribution coefficient and the phase volumes. The cumulative recovery depends additionally on how many extraction contacts are performed. Therefore, the student's conclusion confuses an equilibrium property with the overall result of a multistage separation process.
294. A student wants to separate the following three materials:
- P: a solid organic compound that sublimes readily without decomposition.
- Q: a non-sublimable solid impurity mixed with P.
- R: an independently collected liquid organic compound that decomposes near its atmospheric boiling point but can be distilled safely at reduced pressure.
The student proposes using reduced-pressure distillation to separate P from Q and sublimation to purify R.
Which alternative is most appropriate?
ⓐ. Separate P from Q by sublimation, and purify R by distillation under reduced pressure.
ⓑ. Separate P from Q by fractional distillation, and purify R by crystallisation.
ⓒ. Separate P from Q by steam distillation, and purify R by ordinary atmospheric distillation.
ⓓ. Separate P from Q by differential extraction, and purify R by adsorption chromatography without considering its physical properties.
Correct Answer: Separate P from Q by sublimation, and purify R by distillation under reduced pressure.
Explanation: The two purification problems involve different physical forms and different limiting properties. P is a solid that sublimes readily under the specified conditions. Q is a non-sublimable solid impurity mixed with P. Sublimation can therefore separate P by transferring it into the vapour phase while Q remains in the original vessel. Cooling the vapour permits collection of P. R, however, is a liquid organic compound that decomposes near its atmospheric boiling point. Ordinary distillation at atmospheric pressure would expose R to temperatures at which its stability is inadequate. Reducing the external pressure lowers the boiling temperature needed for distillation. This can permit R to vaporise under conditions where decomposition is avoided. The student has incorrectly interchanged methods that solve different purification problems. Reduced-pressure distillation is not the natural choice for separating the stated sublimable solid from a non-sublimable solid. Sublimation is likewise not the appropriate description of purifying the stated liquid R through pressure-controlled boiling. The correct choices arise from combining the physical state of each material with the relevant phase-change and thermal-stability behaviour.
295. A solution contains organic compound P and impurity Q. During crystallisation, both substances can enter the deposited solid when the solvent is cooled sufficiently.
The following results are observed:
| Cooling condition | P crystallised | Q crystallised |
| Condition I | \(8.00\,\mathrm{g}\) | \(0.100\,\mathrm{g}\) |
| Condition II, lower final temperature | \(9.00\,\mathrm{g}\) | \(0.500\,\mathrm{g}\) |
Assume the recovered crystals contain only P and Q, and both experiments begin with identical samples.
Which conclusion correctly compares the two crystallisation conditions?
ⓐ. Condition II gives both greater recovery of P and greater purity of P.
ⓑ. Condition I gives greater recovery of P, whereas Condition II gives greater purity.
ⓒ. Condition II gives greater recovery of P but lower purity of P.
ⓓ. Both conditions give equal purity because the same two compounds crystallise.
Correct Answer: Condition II gives greater recovery of P but lower purity of P.
Explanation: \(\textbf{Calculate the purity under Condition I:}\)
The collected solid contains:
\[
m_{\mathrm P,I}=8.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm Q,I}=0.100\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The total crystalline mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{total,I}}=8.00+0.100
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{total,I}}=8.10\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\%\mathrm{purity_I}=\frac{8.00}{8.10}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{purity_I}=98.77\%
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the purity under Condition II:}\)
The collected masses are:
\[
m_{\mathrm P,II}=9.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm Q,II}=0.500\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The combined crystalline mass is:
\[
m_{\mathrm{total,II}}=9.00+0.500
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{total,II}}=9.50\,\mathrm{g}
\]
Thus:
\[
\%\mathrm{purity_{II}}=\frac{9.00}{9.50}\times100
\]
\[
\%\mathrm{purity_{II}}=94.74\%
\]
\(\textbf{Compare recovery of P:}\)
Both experiments begin with identical amounts of P.
Condition II recovers \(9.00\,\mathrm{g}\), whereas Condition I recovers \(8.00\,\mathrm{g}\).
Therefore, recovery of P is greater under Condition II.
\(\textbf{Compare the impurity contribution:}\)
Condition I crystallises only \(0.100\,\mathrm{g}\) of Q.
Condition II crystallises \(0.500\,\mathrm{g}\) of Q.
The additional impurity entering the collected solid more than offsets the purity benefit of collecting additional P.
Consequently, Condition II gives lower purity despite higher recovery.
\(\textbf{Interpretation:}\)
Cooling more strongly may reduce the solubility of the desired compound and increase its recovery. However, the impurity may also become less soluble and crystallise. Therefore, obtaining the largest crystalline mass does not necessarily mean obtaining the purest product. The preferred cooling condition depends on the required balance between purity and recovery rather than on crystal yield alone.
296. A liquid mixture contains an organic compound P together with a small amount of nonvolatile impurity Q. P is stable at its atmospheric boiling point, and Q does not vaporise appreciably under the operating conditions.
During simple distillation, the student collects the principal distillate containing P. Near the end of the experiment, almost all liquid P has distilled, but the student continues heating until the original flask approaches dryness.
Which statement provides the best evaluation?
ⓐ. Continuing to dryness is essential because the nonvolatile Q must eventually vaporise before P can be considered purified.
ⓑ. Vaporising P while leaving Q behind provides separation; heating the residue close to dryness is unnecessary.
ⓒ. The distillate must contain only Q because the least volatile component always reaches the condenser first.
ⓓ. Simple distillation is unsuitable because it can separate only two liquids with nearly equal boiling points.
Correct Answer: Vaporising P while leaving Q behind provides separation; heating the residue close to dryness is unnecessary.
Explanation: Simple distillation can be used to separate a suitable volatile liquid from nonvolatile impurities. In this experiment, P is the volatile desired component. Q is specified not to vaporise appreciably under the operating conditions. Heating produces vapour enriched in P, which passes into the condenser and is collected as distillate. Q remains principally in the distillation flask. This separation does not require Q itself to vaporise. Once most P has been recovered, continued heating can leave an increasingly concentrated residue of Q. Driving the original flask toward dryness does not improve the fundamental volatility difference responsible for the separation. It may instead create unnecessary difficulties associated with heating a nearly dry residue. The student should therefore distinguish the recovery of the volatile desired material from an attempt to eliminate all material from the original flask. Fractional distillation is primarily used when suitable miscible volatile liquids have closely spaced boiling points. It is not required merely because a nonvolatile impurity is present. The chemically relevant reason for selecting simple distillation here is the substantial difference in volatility between P and Q. The principal purified fraction can be collected without demanding complete evaporation of the original mixture.
297. A chromatographic experiment is conducted on a silica-gel TLC plate. Two compounds P and Q are developed under identical conditions with the same mobile solvent.
In Trial I, a small quantity of the sample is applied at the origin, and two compact spots are resolved clearly.
In Trial II, a much larger quantity of the same mixture is applied to a very small region of the origin. The developed zones become broad and partially overlap, although no chemical reaction has occurred.
A student concludes that the mixture contains fewer components in Trial II because fewer separate spots can be distinguished visually.
Which interpretation is most appropriate?
ⓐ. Excessive sample loading can hide separation without changing the number of chemical components.
ⓑ. The conclusion is correct because chromatography identifies the number of substances solely from the total mass loaded.
ⓒ. The conclusion is correct because applying more sample converts two components into one.
ⓓ. The conclusion is not justified because two substances always produce exactly the same \(R_f\) value when silica gel is used.
Correct Answer: Excessive sample loading can hide separation without changing the number of chemical components.
Explanation: Thin-layer chromatography separates substances according to their relative interactions with the stationary and mobile phases. Under suitable conditions, components with different migration behaviours can form distinct spots. Trial I uses a small sample quantity and produces two clearly resolved spots. This establishes that the chosen chromatographic system can distinguish P and Q under those loading conditions. Trial II uses a much larger quantity of the same mixture in a small region. The question states that the resulting zones become broad and overlap. Such broadening reduces the ability to distinguish separate components visually. The loss of visible separation does not require a change in the molecular identities of P and Q. The problem is therefore one of chromatographic resolution rather than evidence of chemical conversion. Counting an apparently merged region as one component would ignore the result obtained under more suitable conditions. The amount and manner of sample application can influence the quality of a chromatographic separation. A reliable conclusion about the number of components requires a separation procedure that produces sufficiently distinct zones. The improved result in Trial I is therefore more informative than the overloaded and poorly resolved chromatogram in Trial II.
298. A mixture contains two organic compounds P and Q. The compounds have very similar boiling points but markedly different adsorption tendencies on silica gel.
P is weakly adsorbed, whereas Q is strongly adsorbed in a suitable chromatographic solvent system. Both compounds are stable, nonreactive and recoverable from that solvent.
A student proposes simple distillation because P and Q are both liquids at room temperature. Another student proposes adsorption chromatography.
Which conclusion is best supported by the supplied properties?
ⓐ. Simple distillation must provide better separation because every liquid mixture is most effectively separated by boiling.
ⓑ. Adsorption chromatography exploits the compounds' differing silica-gel interactions, unlike simple distillation of close-boiling liquids.
ⓒ. Neither method can work because compounds with similar boiling points must have identical adsorption behaviour.
ⓓ. Adsorption chromatography cannot be used because its stationary phase interacts only with solids, not with dissolved organic compounds.
Correct Answer: Adsorption chromatography exploits the compounds' differing silica-gel interactions, unlike simple distillation of close-boiling liquids.
Explanation: Purification methods should be chosen by identifying a physical property that distinguishes the components effectively. Simple distillation depends on differences in volatility and is particularly suitable when such differences are sufficiently large. The question states that P and Q have very similar boiling points. Therefore, simple distillation may provide poor separation because both liquids can contribute appreciably to the vapour. Adsorption chromatography employs a different separation principle. Components interact to different extents with the stationary adsorbent. Under the specified conditions, P is weakly adsorbed by silica gel, whereas Q is strongly adsorbed. Consequently, P can migrate through the chromatographic system more readily than Q. The difference in adsorption provides a basis for separating the compounds even when their boiling points are close. The method does not require the original substances to be solids. Dissolved organic compounds can undergo chromatographic separation through their interactions with stationary and mobile phases. The stability and solvent compatibility assumptions further support the proposed chromatographic procedure. The student's reliance solely on physical state overlooks the more important issue of separation selectivity. The defensible choice is the method that exploits the useful difference actually established between P and Q.
299. Two pure molecular compounds P and Q have the formulae \(\mathrm{C_2H_4O_2}\) and \(\mathrm{C_3H_6O_3}\), respectively. Their molar masses are different, but their elemental mass percentages are identical.
Consider the following statements.
Statement I: P and Q have the same empirical formula.
Statement II: Their molecular formulae must be identical because their elemental percentages are identical.
Statement III: An empirical formula specifies the simplest whole-number ratio of constituent atoms rather than the actual number of atoms in every molecule.
Statement IV: Independent molecular-mass information can distinguish molecular formulae that share the same empirical formula.
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. I, II and III only
ⓑ. II and IV only
ⓒ. I, III and IV only
ⓓ. I, II and IV only
Correct Answer: I, III and IV only
Explanation: Statement I is correct because the subscripts in both molecular formulae have a common factor. Dividing the subscripts of \(\mathrm{C_2H_4O_2}\) by two gives \(\mathrm{CH_2O}\). Dividing those of \(\mathrm{C_3H_6O_3}\) by three also gives \(\mathrm{CH_2O}\). Therefore, both compounds have the same simplest whole-number atomic ratio. Statement II is incorrect because identical elemental percentages do not uniquely establish the actual number of atoms in a molecule. Different positive integer multiples of an empirical formula retain the same elemental mass fractions. Statement III is correct because an empirical formula expresses relative atomic proportions, not necessarily the complete molecular composition. Statement IV is correct because the molecular molar mass establishes how many empirical-formula units occur in one molecule. For example, the two compounds here have molecular molar masses of \(60\) and \(90\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}\), respectively. The empirical-formula mass of \(\mathrm{CH_2O}\) is \(30\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}\). Consequently, their molecular formulae correspond to different integer multiples of the same empirical unit. The correct distinction is between composition ratios and actual molecular size. Only Statements I, III and IV are correct.
300. An organic compound contains only carbon, hydrogen and oxygen. Quantitative elemental analysis gives approximately \(40.00\%\) carbon, \(6.67\%\) hydrogen and \(53.33\%\) oxygen by mass.
Using \(C=12\), \(H=1\) and \(O=16\), which empirical formula is consistent with these data?
ⓐ. \(\mathrm{CH_2O}\)
ⓑ. \(\mathrm{C_2H_2O}\)
ⓒ. \(\mathrm{CH_4O}\)
ⓓ. \(\mathrm{C_2H_4O}\)
Correct Answer: \(\mathrm{CH_2O}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Choose a convenient composition basis:}\)
For a hypothetical \(100\,\mathrm{g}\) sample:
\[
m_{\mathrm C}=40.00\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm H}=6.67\,\mathrm{g}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm O}=53.33\,\mathrm{g}
\]
The percentages can be treated as gram masses only because the chosen sample basis is \(100\,\mathrm{g}\).
\(\textbf{Convert masses into atomic mole amounts:}\)
For carbon:
\[
n_{\mathrm C}=\frac{40.00}{12}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm C}=3.3333\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
For hydrogen:
\[
n_{\mathrm H}=\frac{6.67}{1}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm H}=6.67\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
For oxygen:
\[
n_{\mathrm O}=\frac{53.33}{16}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm O}=3.3331\,\mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Obtain the simplest ratio:}\)
Divide the three values by their smallest approximate value:
\[
C:H:O
=
\frac{3.3333}{3.3331}:
\frac{6.67}{3.3331}:
\frac{3.3331}{3.3331}
\]
\[
C:H:O\approx1:2:1
\]
\(\textbf{Construct the empirical formula:}\)
The simplest whole-number ratio contains one carbon atom, two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom.
Therefore, the empirical formula is \(\mathrm{CH_2O}\).
\(\textbf{Verify its composition:}\)
Its empirical-formula mass is:
\[
M_{\mathrm{emp}}=12+2(1)+16
\]
\[
M_{\mathrm{emp}}=30\,\mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
The carbon fraction is:
\[
\%\mathrm C=\frac{12}{30}\times100=40.00\%
\]
The hydrogen fraction is:
\[
\%\mathrm H=\frac{2}{30}\times100=6.67\%
\]
The oxygen fraction is:
\[
\%\mathrm O=\frac{16}{30}\times100=53.33\%
\]
These agree with the supplied rounded values.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\mathrm{CH_2O}}
\]