401. A sample of 2-bromo-2-methylpropane is solvolysed in a mixture containing isotopically labelled water, \(\mathrm{H_2{}^{18}O}\), and ordinary methanol, \(\mathrm{CH_3{}^{16}OH}\).
Assume that the substrate undergoes ionisation to a tert-butyl carbocation, followed by nucleophilic capture by either water or methanol.
The two organic products are isolated before any subsequent oxygen-isotope exchange.
Which observation would be consistent with the stated mechanism?
ⓐ. Both tert-butanol and methyl tert-butyl ether must contain \(\mathrm{^{18}O}\) because water is present in the solvent mixture
ⓑ. Only methyl tert-butyl ether can contain \(\mathrm{^{18}O}\), because the ether contains two carbon–oxygen bonds
ⓒ. Neither product can contain \(\mathrm{^{18}O}\), because oxygen is not present in the original alkyl bromide
ⓓ. Tert-butanol formed by water capture contains \(\mathrm{^{18}O}\), while methyl tert-butyl ether formed by methanol capture retains \(\mathrm{^{16}O}\)
Correct Answer: Tert-butanol formed by water capture contains \(\mathrm{^{18}O}\), while methyl tert-butyl ether formed by methanol capture retains \(\mathrm{^{16}O}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the common intermediate:}\)
2-Bromo-2-methylpropane contains bromine bonded to a tertiary carbon.
Under the stipulated ionising conditions, the carbon–bromine bond undergoes heterolytic cleavage:
\[
\mathrm{(CH_3)_3CBr\rightarrow (CH_3)_3C^++Br^-}
\]
The resulting carbocation can be trapped by either oxygen-containing solvent molecule.
\(\textbf{Track oxygen during water capture:}\)
Labelled water supplies the nucleophilic oxygen atom:
\[
\mathrm{(CH_3)_3C^++H_2{}^{18}O
\rightarrow (CH_3)_3C{}^{18}OH_2^+}
\]
Loss of a proton gives labelled tert-butanol:
\[
\mathrm{(CH_3)_3C{}^{18}OH}
\]
The product's oxygen atom therefore originates from the labelled water.
\(\textbf{Track oxygen during methanol capture:}\)
Ordinary methanol also contains an oxygen lone pair capable of attacking the carbocation.
Methanol capture followed by deprotonation produces:
\[
\mathrm{(CH_3)_3C{}^{16}OCH_3}
\]
The ether oxygen originates from methanol, not from the water present elsewhere in the mixture.
\(\textbf{Distinguish proton transfer from oxygen transfer:}\)
The reactions involve proton-transfer steps after formation of carbon–oxygen bonds.
A proton transfer does not automatically exchange the oxygen atom that has become covalently attached to carbon.
The question also explicitly excludes subsequent oxygen-isotope exchange.
\(\textbf{Interpret the two products:}\)
Both products arise from the same tertiary carbocation.
However, they preserve information about which solvent molecule supplied the nucleophilic oxygen.
The isotope label can therefore distinguish the two capture pathways even though they share the same initial ionisation event.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Product isotope composition depends on atom origin rather than simply on which labelled substance is present in the reaction vessel.
Labelled water gives labelled tert-butanol, while ordinary methanol gives an ether containing ordinary oxygen.
402. Two \(\alpha,\omega\)-dibromoalkanes are treated separately with sodium in dry ether under highly dilute conditions selected to favour intramolecular Wurtz-type coupling.
P: 1,4-Dibromobutane, \(\mathrm{Br(CH_2)_4Br}\).
Q: 1,5-Dibromopentane, \(\mathrm{Br(CH_2)_5Br}\).
Assume complete intramolecular coupling without competing intermolecular reactions or elimination.
Which statement correctly compares the products and their ring strain?
ⓐ. P gives cyclobutane and Q gives cyclopentane; the four-membered ring has greater angle strain
ⓑ. P gives cyclopentane and Q gives cyclohexane because coupling always adds one carbon atom from sodium
ⓒ. P and Q give but-1-ene and pent-1-ene, respectively, because removal of two bromine atoms necessarily forms a double bond
ⓓ. Both give cyclobutane because the terminal bromine atoms are equivalent in each substrate
Correct Answer: P gives cyclobutane and Q gives cyclopentane; the four-membered ring has greater angle strain
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two reactive carbon termini:}\)
Each starting compound contains two saturated terminal carbons bonded to bromine.
The problem specifies intramolecular formation of a carbon–carbon bond between those terminal carbons.
Sodium participates in the reductive coupling, but it does not become a carbon atom in the organic product.
\(\textbf{Determine the product from P:}\)
P contains four carbon atoms in a single chain.
Joining its two terminal carbons closes a four-membered ring:
\[
\mathrm{Br(CH_2)_4Br+2Na
\xrightarrow{dry\ ether}
C_4H_8+2NaBr}
\]
The cyclic product is cyclobutane.
\(\textbf{Determine the product from Q:}\)
Q contains five carbon atoms.
Joining its terminal carbons produces a five-membered ring:
\[
\mathrm{Br(CH_2)_5Br+2Na
\xrightarrow{dry\ ether}
C_5H_{10}+2NaBr}
\]
The cyclic product is cyclopentane.
\(\textbf{Check carbon and halogen conservation:}\)
The number of carbon atoms remains unchanged during ring closure.
Both bromine atoms leave the organic molecule and are accounted for in sodium bromide.
The product contains two fewer halogen substituents and one additional carbon–carbon bond between previously unconnected chain ends.
\(\textbf{Compare the ring geometries:}\)
Saturated carbon atoms favour approximately tetrahedral bond angles.
A four-membered ring has much greater deviation from the preferred bond-angle geometry than a five-membered ring.
Cyclobutane therefore experiences substantial angle strain.
Cyclopentane can adopt nonplanar conformations that reduce its overall strain.
\(\textbf{Interpret the reaction-condition qualification:}\)
The question explicitly selects highly dilute, intramolecular coupling conditions.
Without that restriction, intermolecular coupling and other reactions could complicate the product mixture.
The ring identities follow from the specified intramolecular connectivity rather than a claim that these reactions must always proceed quantitatively in practice.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Terminal dihalides can form cyclic hydrocarbons through intramolecular coupling.
The length of the carbon chain determines the ring size, while the ring geometry influences its strain.
403. But-2-ene undergoes bromine addition to form a vicinal dibromide.
The dibromide is then subjected to controlled removal of one molecule of HBr to isolate 2-bromobut-2-ene as the specified principal intermediate.
This intermediate is subsequently treated with excess sodium amide in liquid ammonia under conditions suitable for removing the remaining HBr.
Assume complete intended conversion without rearrangement.
Which statement correctly identifies the final product and explains why the second elimination requires a stronger base than ordinary dehydrohalogenation of a saturated alkyl bromide?
ⓐ. Butane; the second elimination involves replacement of bromine by hydrogen without changing bond order
ⓑ. But-1-yne; the original internal double bond necessarily migrates to a terminal position
ⓒ. But-2-yne; the second elimination must remove HBr from a vinylic bromide, which resists ordinary elimination conditions
ⓓ. Buta-1,3-diene; the second elimination forms another double bond on a different pair of carbon atoms
Correct Answer: But-2-yne; the second elimination must remove HBr from a vinylic bromide, which resists ordinary elimination conditions
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the initial addition reaction:}\)
But-2-ene contains a double bond between carbons 2 and 3:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH{=}CHCH_3}
\]
Bromine adds across this double bond, producing 2,3-dibromobutane:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH{=}CHCH_3+Br_2
\rightarrow CH_3CHBrCHBrCH_3}
\]
Both bromine atoms are initially bonded to saturated carbon atoms.
\(\textbf{Follow the stipulated first elimination:}\)
Removal of one molecule of HBr generates the specified brominated alkene:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CHBrCHBrCH_3
\rightarrow CH_3C(Br){=}CHCH_3+HBr}
\]
The intermediate is 2-bromobut-2-ene.
Its remaining bromine atom is now attached directly to a double-bonded carbon.
\(\textbf{Recognise the changed bonding environment:}\)
The original vicinal dibromide has bromine bonded to \(sp^3\)-hybridised carbon.
The intermediate has a vinylic carbon–bromine bond involving an \(sp^2\)-hybridised carbon.
The remaining hydrogen that must be removed is also attached to the neighbouring double-bonded carbon.
\(\textbf{Apply the second elimination:}\)
A sufficiently strong base, such as sodium amide under the specified conditions, removes the remaining HBr:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3C(Br){=}CHCH_3
\xrightarrow{NaNH_2/NH_3(l)}
CH_3C{\equiv}CCH_3}
\]
The new carbon–carbon bond order is three.
The product is but-2-yne.
\(\textbf{Connect the two stages:}\)
The first elimination changes an alkyl carbon–halogen environment into a vinylic carbon–halogen environment.
The second elimination is therefore not merely an identical repetition of the first step.
Its reaction centre and energetic requirements are different.
\(\textbf{Verify carbon connectivity:}\)
The chain retains four carbon atoms throughout the sequence.
The triple bond forms between the same two central carbons that originally constituted the alkene double bond.
It does not migrate to a terminal position.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Preparing an alkyne from a vicinal dibromide requires two dehydrohalogenations.
The vinylic halide formed after the first step explains why suitably strong conditions are needed for the second.
404. The allylic bromide \(\mathrm{BrCH_2CH{=}CHCH_3}\) is divided into two portions.
P: Treatment with alcoholic KCN under conditions verified to give direct \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) displacement at the primary bromine-bearing carbon, without substitution at either other carbon.
Q: Solvolysis in water under conditions verified to form a delocalised allylic carbocation that can be captured at either of its two terminal positions.
Assume that the carbon–carbon double bond is not hydrogenated and that elimination is absent.
Which comparison correctly identifies the products?
ⓐ. P gives pent-3-enenitrile; Q gives only but-2-en-1-ol because allylic resonance cannot change the site of nucleophilic capture
ⓑ. P gives but-2-enenitrile; Q gives only but-3-en-2-ol because cyanide does not introduce an additional carbon
ⓒ. P gives pent-3-enenitrile; Q can give both but-2-en-1-ol and but-3-en-2-ol because the two reaction pathways differ
ⓓ. P gives pent-2-enenitrile; Q gives butan-1-ol and butan-2-ol because solvolysis necessarily saturates the double bond
Correct Answer: P gives pent-3-enenitrile; Q can give both but-2-en-1-ol and but-3-en-2-ol because the two reaction pathways differ
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the allylic substrate:}\)
Bromine is bonded to a saturated terminal carbon adjacent to a carbon–carbon double bond.
The substrate is therefore an allylic bromide rather than a vinylic bromide.
Its reaction products depend on whether the mechanism is direct substitution or carbocation capture.
\(\textbf{Analyse the direct substitution in P:}\)
The question specifies \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) attack by the carbon end of cyanide at the original bromine-bearing carbon.
The intended conversion is:
\[
\mathrm{BrCH_2CH{=}CHCH_3+KCN
\rightarrow NCCH_2CH{=}CHCH_3+KBr}
\]
The new carbon–carbon bond introduces the nitrile carbon as an additional carbon atom.
Numbering the principal chain from the nitrile carbon gives a five-carbon nitrile with a double bond between carbons 3 and 4.
Thus, P gives pent-3-enenitrile.
No allylic rearrangement has been stipulated for this direct displacement.
\(\textbf{Analyse carbocation formation in Q:}\)
Ionisation of the carbon–bromine bond permits delocalisation of the positive charge:
\[
\mathrm{{}^{+}CH_2CH{=}CHCH_3
\leftrightarrow CH_2{=}CHCH^{+}CH_3}
\]
The two resonance contributors place the electrophilic position at different carbons.
Water can therefore capture the cation at either terminal position of the allylic system.
\(\textbf{Identify the alcohols:}\)
Capture at the carbon that originally bore bromine gives:
\[
\mathrm{HOCH_2CH{=}CHCH_3}
\]
This is but-2-en-1-ol.
Capture at the other allylic terminus gives:
\[
\mathrm{CH_2{=}CHCH(OH)CH_3}
\]
This is but-3-en-2-ol.
The two alcohols retain the original four-carbon skeleton, unlike the cyanide product.
\(\textbf{Integrate mechanism and carbon tracking:}\)
A resonance-stabilised carbocation can allow more than one site of attack, whereas the stipulated direct \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) reaction fixes the bond-forming site.
Only the cyanide pathway adds a carbon atom.
The combined observations identify pent-3-enenitrile for P and two allylic alcohols for Q.
405. Chlorobenzene is subjected to an idealised selective catalytic hydrogenation that completely saturates its aromatic carbon ring while preserving its original carbon–chlorine bond.
The isolated organic product is then compared with the original chlorobenzene for possible reactions with hydroxide.
Assume that the comparison concerns suitable ordinary nucleophilic substitution conditions rather than aromatic substitution under extreme conditions.
Which statement correctly describes the changed carbon–halogen bonding environment?
ⓐ. Hydrogenation gives benzyl chloride with a primary \(sp^3\) carbon–chlorine centre
ⓑ. Hydrogenation gives cyclohexyl chloride with an \(sp^3\) carbon–chlorine centre capable of substitution or elimination
ⓒ. Hydrogenation gives chloromethane with a primary \(sp^3\) carbon–chlorine centre
ⓓ. Hydrogenation gives cyclohexane because its carbon–chlorine bond is cleaved
Correct Answer: Hydrogenation gives cyclohexyl chloride with an \(sp^3\) carbon–chlorine centre capable of substitution or elimination
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the original carbon–chlorine bond:}\)
In chlorobenzene, chlorine is bonded directly to an aromatic ring carbon.
That carbon is \(sp^2\)-hybridised.
Lone-pair resonance involving chlorine and the aromatic ring contributes partial double-bond character to the carbon–chlorine bond.
\(\textbf{Apply the specified hydrogenation:}\)
Complete saturation of the ring adds hydrogen across the aromatic pi system.
The problem explicitly requires retention of the carbon–chlorine bond:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5Cl+3H_2
\xrightarrow{selective\ catalyst}
C_6H_{11}Cl}
\]
The product is chlorocyclohexane, also called cyclohexyl chloride.
\(\textbf{Identify the new carbon environment:}\)
The chlorine-bearing carbon now belongs to a saturated cyclohexane ring.
It is \(sp^3\)-hybridised and attached to two neighbouring carbon atoms.
The product is therefore a secondary alkyl chloride rather than an aryl chloride.
\(\textbf{Explain the bonding change:}\)
Saturating the benzene ring removes the original aromatic pi-electron system.
The chlorine lone pair no longer interacts with that aromatic system in the same way.
The carbon–chlorine bond consequently has the ordinary saturated-carbon bonding environment instead of the original aryl environment.
\(\textbf{Compare substitution behaviour:}\)
Chlorobenzene resists ordinary saturated-carbon \(S_\mathrm{N}1\) and \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) pathways.
Cyclohexyl chloride, by contrast, can undergo appropriate alkyl-halide reactions under suitable conditions.
However, its secondary reaction centre is sterically less accessible than that of a simple primary chloride.
Elimination may also compete, depending on the reagent and conditions.
\(\textbf{Recognise the experimental restriction:}\)
Catalytic hydrogenation of aromatic halides can involve competing transformations under some practical conditions.
The question avoids this ambiguity by expressly stipulating selective ring hydrogenation without carbon–chlorine bond cleavage.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
A molecule can retain the same halogen and carbon skeleton while acquiring a different carbon–halogen reaction environment.
Changing the hybridisation and resonance context alters the possible reaction pathways.
406. An unconstrained mixture containing all stereoisomers of 2-bromo-3-methylpentane, \(\mathrm{CH_3CH(Br)CH(CH_3)CH_2CH_3}\), undergoes beta-elimination.
Assume that elimination can occur towards either adjacent beta carbon, that all stereochemically accessible products are represented, and that no rearrangement occurs.
When constitutional and configurational stereoisomers are counted separately, how many distinct alkene structures are possible?
ⓐ. Two, because there are only two different beta carbons
ⓑ. Three, because only the internal alkene can exhibit stereoisomerism
ⓒ. Six, because each constitutional alkene must have three stereoisomers
ⓓ. Four: two configurations of the terminal alkene and E/Z configurations of the internal alkene
Correct Answer: Four: two configurations of the terminal alkene and E/Z configurations of the internal alkene
Explanation: \(\textbf{Locate the elimination centre:}\)
The starting bromide has bromine attached to carbon 2.
Its adjacent beta carbons are carbon 1 and carbon 3.
Both possess hydrogen atoms.
Elimination can therefore form a double bond at either of two positions.
\(\textbf{Identify the terminal alkene:}\)
Removal of a beta-hydrogen from carbon 1 gives:
\[
\mathrm{CH_2{=}CHCH(CH_3)CH_2CH_3}
\]
The constitutional product is 3-methylpent-1-ene.
Its terminal double-bond carbon carries two hydrogen atoms, so it cannot exhibit E/Z isomerism.
\(\textbf{Examine stereogenicity in the terminal alkene:}\)
Carbon 3 remains saturated and is bonded to hydrogen, methyl, ethyl and vinyl groups.
These four substituents are different.
Therefore, 3-methylpent-1-ene contains a stereogenic centre and can exist as two enantiomers.
The starting mixture includes the stereochemical possibilities required to obtain both configurations.
\(\textbf{Identify the internal alkene:}\)
Elimination towards carbon 3 gives:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH{=}C(CH_3)CH_2CH_3}
\]
The constitutional product is 3-methylpent-2-ene.
Each double-bonded carbon carries two different substituents.
Consequently, E and Z geometrical isomers are possible.
\(\textbf{Check whether the internal alkene has another stereogenic centre:}\)
Carbon 3 becomes \(sp^2\)-hybridised during this elimination.
The original saturated stereogenic environment at that carbon no longer exists.
Therefore, this alkene contributes two E/Z isomers rather than an additional pair of independently chiral products.
\(\textbf{Count all structures:}\)
The terminal alkene contributes two enantiomers.
The internal alkene contributes two geometrical isomers.
Thus:
\[
N_{\mathrm{total}}=2+2
\]
\[
N_{\mathrm{total}}=4
\]
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The two elimination directions create different constitutional alkenes.
One retains a stereogenic saturated carbon, while the other introduces a geometrically isomeric double bond.
Both kinds of stereochemistry must be included in the total count.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
N_{\mathrm{distinct\ alkene\ structures}}=4
\]
407. An enantiomerically pure sample of \((R)\)-2-bromobutane undergoes substitution to butan-2-ol through two simultaneous pathways.
The \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) pathway produces only \((S)\)-butan-2-ol.
The \(S_\mathrm{N}1\) pathway produces an exactly racemic alcohol mixture.
The measured specific rotation of the final alcohol mixture is \(+8.0^\circ\), while optically pure \((S)\)-butan-2-ol has a specific rotation of \(+20.0^\circ\) under identical conditions.
Assume quantitative substitution, no elimination and no other optically active products.
What percentages of the alcohol were formed through the \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) and \(S_\mathrm{N}1\) pathways, respectively?
ⓐ. \(40\%\) and \(60\%\)
ⓑ. \(60\%\) and \(40\%\)
ⓒ. \(70\%\) and \(30\%\)
ⓓ. \(20\%\) and \(80\%\)
Correct Answer: \(40\%\) and \(60\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify what the rotation measures:}\)
The two enantiomers of butan-2-ol have equal and opposite specific rotations under identical conditions.
An equimolar enantiomeric mixture therefore has zero net rotation.
The observed rotation of a mixture can be used to determine its enantiomeric excess.
\(\textbf{Calculate the observed enantiomeric excess:}\)
The pure \((S)\) alcohol has:
\[
[\alpha]_{\mathrm{pure}\ S}=+20.0^\circ
\]
The mixture has:
\[
[\alpha]_{\mathrm{mixture}}=+8.0^\circ
\]
Using:
\[
ee=\frac{[\alpha]_{\mathrm{mixture}}}{[\alpha]_{\mathrm{pure}\ S}}
\]
\[
ee=\frac{8.0}{20.0}
\]
\[
ee=0.400
\]
The mixture has a \(40.0\%\) enantiomeric excess in favour of \((S)\)-butan-2-ol.
\(\textbf{Connect the excess to the two pathways:}\)
Let \(f\) be the fraction of product formed through \(S_\mathrm{N}2\).
That pathway produces only the \((S)\) enantiomer.
The remaining fraction, \(1-f\), forms through \(S_\mathrm{N}1\) and contributes equal amounts of both enantiomers.
\(\textbf{Express the individual enantiomer fractions:}\)
The total \((S)\) fraction is:
\[
x_S=f+\frac{1-f}{2}
\]
The total \((R)\) fraction is:
\[
x_R=\frac{1-f}{2}
\]
Subtracting gives:
\[
x_S-x_R=f
\]
Therefore, the enantiomeric excess equals the fraction formed through the stereospecific \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) pathway in this model.
\(\textbf{Calculate the mechanism fractions:}\)
\[
f_{S_\mathrm{N}2}=0.400
\]
\[
f_{S_\mathrm{N}1}=1-0.400
\]
\[
f_{S_\mathrm{N}1}=0.600
\]
\(\textbf{Verify the predicted product mixture:}\)
The \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) pathway contributes \(40\%\) of pure \((S)\) alcohol.
The \(60\%\) racemic contribution supplies \(30\%\) of each enantiomer.
The final mixture therefore contains \(70\%\) \((S)\) and \(30\%\) \((R)\) alcohol.
Its enantiomeric excess is:
\[
70\%-30\%=40\%
\]
This agrees with the measured rotation.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The measured rotation reveals an excess of one enantiomer, not the percentage of that enantiomer directly.
Under the specified mixture of stereospecific and racemising pathways, the enantiomeric excess provides the \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) contribution.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{S_\mathrm{N}2=40\%,\qquad S_\mathrm{N}1=60\%}
\]
408. Two isomeric aromatic fluorides are treated separately with sodium methoxide under conditions intended for activated nucleophilic aromatic substitution:
P: 1-Fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene.
Q: 1-Fluoro-3,5-dinitrobenzene.
In both compounds, methoxide is intended to replace fluorine, and both nitro groups are to remain attached to their original aromatic carbons.
Which assessment is most appropriate?
ⓐ. P and Q have identical substitution tendencies because each contains one carbon–fluorine bond and two nitro groups
ⓑ. Q is substantially more activated because two meta nitro groups stabilise the substitution intermediate more effectively than ortho and para nitro groups
ⓒ. P is substantially more activated because its ortho and para nitro groups can stabilise the anionic addition intermediate through resonance, unlike the corresponding meta arrangement in Q
ⓓ. Neither can undergo activated aromatic substitution because a carbon–fluorine bond is always too strong to be displaced
Correct Answer: P is substantially more activated because its ortho and para nitro groups can stabilise the anionic addition intermediate through resonance, unlike the corresponding meta arrangement in Q
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the common features:}\)
Both substrates are aromatic fluorides containing two strongly electron-withdrawing nitro groups.
The carbon–fluorine bonds are attached to \(sp^2\)-hybridised aromatic carbons.
The intended reaction is not ordinary saturated-carbon \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) displacement.
\(\textbf{Identify the required aromatic mechanism:}\)
Suitable nucleophilic aromatic substitution can proceed through nucleophilic addition followed by leaving-group elimination.
Methoxide initially attacks the aromatic carbon bearing fluorine.
The resulting anionic addition intermediate requires appropriate stabilisation.
Elimination of fluoride subsequently restores aromaticity.
\(\textbf{Analyse the nitro positions in P:}\)
P contains nitro groups ortho and para to the carbon bearing fluorine.
These groups can participate in stabilising the negatively charged addition intermediate through resonance.
The presence of two appropriately placed withdrawing groups provides particularly favourable electronic activation.
\(\textbf{Analyse the nitro positions in Q:}\)
Q contains nitro groups at the two meta positions relative to fluorine.
The nitro groups still exert electron-withdrawing inductive effects.
However, they do not provide the same direct resonance stabilisation of the characteristic addition intermediate produced by attack at the fluorine-bearing carbon.
\(\textbf{Distinguish number from location:}\)
P and Q contain equal numbers of nitro and fluorine substituents.
They also possess the same molecular formula.
Nevertheless, their different substitution patterns change the electronic stabilisation available to the reaction intermediate.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the carbon–fluorine bond argument:}\)
A strong carbon–fluorine bond does not prevent every aromatic nucleophilic substitution.
In a suitably activated aromatic addition–elimination pathway, fluorine can be displaced.
The reaction conditions and intermediate stabilisation must be considered together.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Electron-withdrawing substituents cannot be evaluated merely by counting them.
Their positions relative to the leaving group determine how effectively they stabilise the required aromatic intermediate.
P is consequently the more strongly activated substrate.
409. Two different bromopentanes undergo beta elimination with alcoholic KOH under suitable conditions:
P: 3-Bromopentane, \(\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH(Br)CH_2CH_3}\)
Q: 2-Bromopentane, \(\mathrm{CH_3CH(Br)CH_2CH_2CH_3}\)
Ignore E/Z stereoisomers and count only distinct constitutional alkene products obtainable by removal of a beta hydrogen. Which comparison is correct?
ⓐ. P forms two constitutional alkenes; Q forms one because Q is less symmetrical
ⓑ. Both P and Q form only pent-1-ene because the terminal alkene is always preferred
ⓒ. P forms one constitutional alkene; Q can form two, with pent-2-ene favoured by the usual Zaitsev tendency
ⓓ. Both P and Q form two constitutional alkenes because each contains two beta carbons
Correct Answer: P forms one constitutional alkene; Q can form two, with pent-2-ene favoured by the usual Zaitsev tendency
Explanation: \(\textbf{Locate beta carbons in P:}\)
3-Bromopentane has bromine on the middle carbon of a symmetric five-carbon chain. Carbon 2 and carbon 4 each provide beta hydrogens. Elimination towards either side forms the same constitutional alkene after correct numbering:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH{=}CHCH_2CH_3}
\]
This is pent-2-ene. Its E/Z stereoisomers are excluded by the question, so P gives one constitutional alkene.
\(\textbf{Locate beta carbons in Q:}\)
In 2-bromopentane, the beta carbons are carbon 1 and carbon 3. Removal of a hydrogen from carbon 1 produces pent-1-ene:
\[
\mathrm{CH_2{=}CHCH_2CH_2CH_3}
\]
Removal of a hydrogen from carbon 3 produces pent-2-ene:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH{=}CHCH_2CH_3}
\]
These are constitutionally distinct alkenes.
\(\textbf{Use the correct selectivity criterion:}\)
Under the stated usual Zaitsev conditions, pent-2-ene is favoured over pent-1-ene because its double bond is more substituted. That preference affects the product proportions, not the number of constitutionally possible products.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The number of beta carbons alone is not the answer. Molecular symmetry makes the two elimination directions equivalent in P, whereas they produce different alkene structures in Q. Thus, P gives one constitutional alkene and Q can give two.
410. Two substituted aromatic chlorides give the following experimental results during hydrolysis:
| Property | P: Chlorobenzene | Q: 4-Nitrochlorobenzene |
| Measured aromatic C–Cl bond length | \(169\ \mathrm{pm}\) | \(166\ \mathrm{pm}\) |
| Behaviour towards aqueous hydroxide | Requires severe conditions | Undergoes nitro-activated aromatic substitution under less severe conditions |
Treat the bond lengths as experimentally supplied values for these particular samples.
A student concludes that Q cannot react faster because its shorter carbon–chlorine bond must be harder to break.
Which assessment is most defensible?
ⓐ. The conclusion is correct because carbon–halogen bond length alone determines the rate of every substitution reaction
ⓑ. The conclusion is correct because a nitro group at the para position cannot influence the aromatic carbon bearing chlorine
ⓒ. The conclusion is incorrect because Q undergoes ordinary backside \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) displacement at an aromatic \(sp^2\) carbon
ⓓ. The nitro-activated addition intermediate can lower the substitution barrier despite Q's shorter carbon–chlorine bond
Correct Answer: The nitro-activated addition intermediate can lower the substitution barrier despite Q's shorter carbon–chlorine bond
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify what the structural measurement shows:}\)
The supplied measurements describe carbon–chlorine bond lengths in the original reactant molecules.
Q has the shorter measured bond.
However, a ground-state bond length is not a complete measurement of the activation barrier for a chemical reaction.
\(\textbf{Examine chlorobenzene:}\)
Chlorobenzene contains chlorine bonded directly to an aromatic carbon.
The carbon–chlorine bond has partial double-bond character through resonance.
Ordinary nucleophilic displacement is consequently difficult under mild conditions.
\(\textbf{Identify the structural difference in Q:}\)
Q contains a strongly electron-withdrawing nitro group para to the carbon bearing chlorine.
This group changes the electronic behaviour of the aromatic ring.
Its effect is particularly important when an anionic intermediate can be stabilised through resonance.
\(\textbf{Follow the activated substitution pathway:}\)
Hydroxide can attack the aromatic carbon bearing chlorine under suitable conditions.
The resulting addition intermediate has negative-charge character distributed through the aromatic system.
A para nitro group can stabilise this intermediate.
Elimination of chloride subsequently restores aromaticity.
\(\textbf{Distinguish ground-state stability from transition-state accessibility:}\)
The substitution rate depends on the free-energy barrier between reactants and the relevant transition state.
Stabilisation of intermediates and transition states can make a pathway more favourable even when a bond in the original substrate is relatively short.
Therefore, comparing reactant bond lengths alone is insufficient.
\(\textbf{Reject the ordinary }S_\mathrm{N}2\textbf{ interpretation:}\)
Both substrates contain chlorine bonded to aromatic \(sp^2\)-hybridised carbon atoms.
The nitro group does not convert that carbon into an ordinary primary alkyl-halide centre.
The appropriate explanation involves activated aromatic addition–elimination substitution.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Chemical reactivity cannot be predicted exclusively from the strength or length of one bond in the starting molecule.
Electronic stabilisation along a particular reaction pathway can outweigh a simplistic bond-length argument.
Q is more reactive under the specified comparison because its nitro group activates the aromatic substitution mechanism.
411. A chemist wishes to distinguish between two chlorinated compounds:
P: 4-Nitrochlorobenzene, \(\mathrm{4\!-\!O_2NC_6H_4Cl}\).
Q: 4-Nitrobenzyl chloride, \(\mathrm{4\!-\!O_2NC_6H_4CH_2Cl}\).
Each is treated separately with aqueous hydroxide under conditions suitable for its intended nucleophilic substitution, followed by acidification.
Assume complete intended replacement of chlorine and no reduction or displacement of the nitro group.
Which statement correctly identifies the products and the essential mechanistic distinction?
ⓐ. Both give 4-nitrophenol because a para nitro group always forces hydroxyl substitution directly onto the aromatic ring
ⓑ. P gives 4-nitrophenol through activated aromatic substitution, whereas Q gives 4-nitrobenzyl alcohol through substitution at a saturated benzylic carbon
ⓒ. P gives 4-nitrobenzyl alcohol, whereas Q gives 4-nitrophenol because the two compounds contain the same functional groups
ⓓ. Neither undergoes substitution because a nitro group withdraws electrons and therefore deactivates every nucleophilic reaction centre
Correct Answer: P gives 4-nitrophenol through activated aromatic substitution, whereas Q gives 4-nitrobenzyl alcohol through substitution at a saturated benzylic carbon
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the chlorine-bearing carbons:}\)
In P, chlorine is attached directly to an aromatic \(sp^2\)-hybridised carbon.
In Q, chlorine is attached to a saturated methylene carbon adjacent to an aromatic ring.
These are chemically different carbon–chlorine bonding environments.
\(\textbf{Examine the electronic activation in P:}\)
The nitro group is para to the aromatic carbon bearing chlorine.
It strongly withdraws electron density and can stabilise the anionic addition intermediate of suitable nucleophilic aromatic substitution.
Under appropriately selected conditions, hydroxide replaces aromatic chlorine through the addition–elimination pathway.
\(\textbf{Identify P's neutral product:}\)
The initial reaction produces the corresponding phenoxide species in basic solution.
Acidification gives:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!O_2NC_6H_4OH}
\]
The product is 4-nitrophenol.
The hydroxyl group is bonded directly to the aromatic ring.
\(\textbf{Examine the reaction centre in Q:}\)
The chlorine-bearing carbon is primary and benzylic.
It is accessible to direct nucleophilic attack.
The benzylic environment can also stabilise developing charge in suitable substitution pathways.
Therefore, hydroxide can replace chlorine at the methylene carbon without replacing a ring substituent.
\(\textbf{Identify Q's product:}\)
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!O_2NC_6H_4CH_2Cl+OH^-
\rightarrow4\!-\!O_2NC_6H_4CH_2OH+Cl^-}
\]
The product is 4-nitrobenzyl alcohol.
The hydroxyl group remains separated from the benzene ring by a methylene carbon.
\(\textbf{Distinguish phenolic and alcoholic hydroxyl:}\)
Although both products contain a hydroxyl group and a para nitro substituent, their hydroxyl-bearing carbons differ.
P gives a phenol.
Q gives a primary benzylic alcohol.
These compounds are not interchangeable in classification or subsequent reaction behaviour.
\(\textbf{Integrate the mechanistic evidence:}\)
P reacts through an electronically activated aromatic substitution mechanism.
Q reacts at an accessible saturated benzylic carbon.
A common nitro group and common chlorine leaving atom do not establish an identical substitution pathway.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The precise position of the carbon–chlorine bond determines the relevant reaction mechanism and product functional group.
P gives 4-nitrophenol, whereas Q gives 4-nitrobenzyl alcohol.
412. A secondary alkyl bromide undergoes two parallel nucleophilic substitution pathways in a fixed solvent at constant temperature.
Pathway P is an \(S_\mathrm{N}1\) reaction with rate constant \(k_1\).
Pathway Q is an \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) reaction with rate constant \(k_2\).
The total initial disappearance rate is:
\[
r=[\mathrm{RX}]\left(k_1+k_2[\mathrm{Nu^-}]\right)
\]
The following measurements are obtained:
| Experiment | \([\mathrm{RX}]\) (mol L\(^{-1}\)) | \([\mathrm{Nu^-}]\) (mol L\(^{-1}\)) | Initial rate (mol L\(^{-1}\) min\(^{-1}\)) |
| I | 0.100 | 0 | 0.00200 |
| II | 0.100 | 0.200 | 0.00800 |
Assume no elimination, rearrangement or other reactions. At \([\mathrm{Nu^-}]=0.300\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\) and the same substrate concentration, what fraction of substrate disappearance occurs through the \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) pathway?
ⓐ. \(75.0\%\)
ⓑ. \(66.7\%\)
ⓒ. \(90.0\%\)
ⓓ. \(81.8\%\)
Correct Answer: \(81.8\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Separate the two kinetic contributions:}\)
The overall disappearance rate is the sum of the rates of two independent substitution pathways.
The \(S_\mathrm{N}1\) contribution depends only on substrate concentration.
The \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) contribution depends on both substrate and nucleophile concentrations.
Therefore:
\[
r_{S_\mathrm{N}1}=k_1[\mathrm{RX}]
\]
\[
r_{S_\mathrm{N}2}=k_2[\mathrm{RX}][\mathrm{Nu^-}]
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the first-order rate constant:}\)
In Experiment I, the added nucleophile concentration is zero.
Under the stipulated model, only the \(S_\mathrm{N}1\) contribution remains.
\[
k_1=\frac{r_I}{[\mathrm{RX}]}
\]
\[
k_1=\frac{0.00200}{0.100}
\]
\[
k_1=0.0200\ \mathrm{min^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Isolate the bimolecular contribution:}\)
At the same substrate concentration, Experiment II has the same \(S_\mathrm{N}1\) contribution as Experiment I.
The additional rate is attributed to \(S_\mathrm{N}2\).
\[
r_{S_\mathrm{N}2,II}=0.00800-0.00200
\]
\[
r_{S_\mathrm{N}2,II}=0.00600\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}\,min^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
k_2=\frac{0.00600}{(0.100)(0.200)}
\]
\[
k_2=0.300\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}\,min^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Apply the new nucleophile concentration:}\)
At \([\mathrm{Nu^-}]=0.300\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\):
\[
r_{S_\mathrm{N}1}=(0.0200)(0.100)
\]
\[
r_{S_\mathrm{N}1}=0.00200\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}\,min^{-1}}
\]
\[
r_{S_\mathrm{N}2}=(0.300)(0.100)(0.300)
\]
\[
r_{S_\mathrm{N}2}=0.00900\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}\,min^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the pathway fraction:}\)
\[
f_{S_\mathrm{N}2}=
\frac{r_{S_\mathrm{N}2}}{r_{S_\mathrm{N}1}+r_{S_\mathrm{N}2}}
\]
\[
f_{S_\mathrm{N}2}=\frac{0.00900}{0.00200+0.00900}
\]
\[
f_{S_\mathrm{N}2}=\frac9{11}=0.81818
\]
\(\textbf{Interpret the mechanistic change:}\)
Increasing nucleophile concentration increases the bimolecular contribution without directly changing the stipulated unimolecular contribution.
Consequently, the fraction undergoing \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) increases even though the substrate, solvent and temperature remain unchanged.
This demonstrates why an overall substitution rate need not follow one elementary rate law when parallel mechanisms operate.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{f_{S_\mathrm{N}2}=81.8\%}
\]
413. Two secondary and tertiary alkyl bromides are treated separately with a suitable strong base under conditions favouring ordinary beta elimination:
P: \(\mathrm{CH_3C(Br)(CH_3)CH_2CH_3}\)
Q: \(\mathrm{CH_3CH(Br)C(CH_3)_3}\)
Assume elimination occurs without rearrangement. Which statement correctly compares their accessible major alkene structures?
ⓐ. P preferentially gives 2-methylbut-2-ene; Q can give 3,3-dimethylbut-1-ene because its quaternary beta carbon has no hydrogen
ⓑ. P preferentially gives 2-methylbut-1-ene; Q must form an internal alkene towards its quaternary beta carbon
ⓒ. P cannot eliminate because the bromine-bearing carbon is tertiary; Q cannot eliminate because it is secondary
ⓓ. Both must give only the more substituted internal alkene, regardless of whether the relevant beta carbon bears hydrogen
Correct Answer: P preferentially gives 2-methylbut-2-ene; Q can give 3,3-dimethylbut-1-ene because its quaternary beta carbon has no hydrogen
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the elimination requirement:}\)
Ordinary beta elimination requires a hydrogen on a carbon adjacent to the carbon bearing bromine. The base removes such a hydrogen while bromide departs, creating a carbon–carbon double bond. The most substituted potential alkene cannot form if the necessary beta hydrogen is absent.
\(\textbf{Analyse substrate P:}\)
The bromine-bearing carbon is attached to two methyl groups and an ethyl group. A beta hydrogen can be removed from the ethyl group's adjacent \(\mathrm{CH_2}\), producing:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3C(CH_3){=}CHCH_3}
\]
This is 2-methylbut-2-ene, a trisubstituted alkene. Removing a beta hydrogen from one of the methyl groups gives the less substituted 2-methylbut-1-ene. Under the usual Zaitsev preference, 2-methylbut-2-ene predominates.
\(\textbf{Analyse substrate Q:}\)
The carbon immediately next to the bromine-bearing carbon on the branched side is quaternary: \(\mathrm{C(CH_3)_3}\). It has no hydrogen, so an alkene cannot be formed towards that carbon by ordinary beta elimination. The methyl group on the other side does supply beta hydrogens. Elimination there gives:
\[
\mathrm{CH_2{=}CHC(CH_3)_3}
\]
This product is 3,3-dimethylbut-1-ene.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
P can form a more substituted internal alkene; Q is structurally prevented from eliminating towards its quaternary beta carbon. Beta-hydrogen availability must be checked before applying an alkene-substitution preference.
414. Two primary bromohydrins are separately treated with a suitable base in dry solvent under dilute conditions chosen to favour intramolecular nucleophilic substitution.
P: 4-Bromobutan-1-ol, \(\mathrm{HO(CH_2)_4Br}\).
Q: 5-Bromopentan-1-ol, \(\mathrm{HO(CH_2)_5Br}\).
Assume that the hydroxyl groups are converted into alkoxide nucleophiles and that each alkoxide attacks the carbon bearing bromine within its own molecule.
Which statement correctly identifies the products?
ⓐ. P forms a five-membered cyclic ether, tetrahydrofuran, while Q forms a six-membered cyclic ether, tetrahydropyran
ⓑ. P forms butan-1-ol and Q forms pentan-1-ol because an alkoxide cannot attack a carbon within the same molecule
ⓒ. P forms a four-membered cyclic ether and Q forms a five-membered cyclic ether because the oxygen atom is excluded from ring-size counting
ⓓ. P and Q both produce ethylene oxide because all terminal bromohydrins cyclise to the smallest possible ring
Correct Answer: P forms a five-membered cyclic ether, tetrahydrofuran, while Q forms a six-membered cyclic ether, tetrahydropyran
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two reactive ends:}\)
Both substrates contain a hydroxyl group at one end of a carbon chain and a primary carbon–bromine bond at the other.
Conversion of the hydroxyl group into an alkoxide generates an oxygen-centred nucleophile.
The bromine-bearing carbon remains accessible to backside attack.
\(\textbf{Recognise the intramolecular substitution:}\)
The alkoxide oxygen and electrophilic carbon belong to the same molecule.
The oxygen can therefore form a new carbon–oxygen bond while bromide leaves.
This is an intramolecular Williamson-type ether formation.
\(\textbf{Count the atoms in the ring from P:}\)
P contains four methylene groups between oxygen and the bromine-bearing end.
The new oxygen–carbon bond closes a ring containing those four carbon atoms and one oxygen atom.
Therefore, the ring has five atoms.
\[
\mathrm{HO(CH_2)_4Br
\xrightarrow{base}
(CH_2)_4O}
\]
The product is tetrahydrofuran, also called oxolane.
\(\textbf{Count the atoms in the ring from Q:}\)
Q contains five methylene groups.
Closing the chain produces a ring containing five carbon atoms and one oxygen atom.
Therefore, the ring has six atoms.
\[
\mathrm{HO(CH_2)_5Br
\xrightarrow{base}
(CH_2)_5O}
\]
The product is tetrahydropyran, also called oxane.
\(\textbf{Distinguish ring formation from chain shortening:}\)
Neither reaction removes a carbon atom.
The oxygen atom becomes part of the ring rather than remaining in an external hydroxyl group.
The number of ring atoms therefore exceeds the number of methylene groups by one.
\(\textbf{Interpret the selected reaction conditions:}\)
Dilute conditions can favour appropriate intramolecular reactions relative to collisions between different molecules.
However, ring size and substrate structure also influence the competition between possible pathways.
The question explicitly specifies intramolecular closure as the intended reaction.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Correct product prediction requires recognising alkoxide formation, locating the primary carbon–bromine bond and counting every atom in the newly formed ring.
The products are five-membered tetrahydrofuran and six-membered tetrahydropyran.
415. 1,6-Dibromohexane, \(\mathrm{Br(CH_2)_6Br}\), is subjected to two idealised synthetic routes.
Route P: Treatment with sodium in dry ether under conditions giving exclusive intramolecular reductive coupling between the terminal carbons.
Route Q: Complete conversion of both carbon–bromine bonds into carbon–magnesium bonds using excess magnesium in dry ether, followed by treatment with excess dry carbon dioxide and acidic hydrolysis.
Assume that no competing cyclisation occurs during Route Q and no intermolecular coupling occurs during Route P.
Which pair correctly identifies the organic products?
ⓐ. P: Cyclohexane; Q: octanedioic acid
ⓑ. P: Cyclopentane; Q: heptanedioic acid
ⓒ. P: Hex-1-ene; Q: hexanedioic acid
ⓓ. P: Cyclohexane; Q: hexanedioic acid
Correct Answer: P: Cyclohexane; Q: octanedioic acid
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the starting carbon skeleton:}\)
1,6-Dibromohexane contains six carbon atoms in an unbranched chain.
Each terminal carbon bears one bromine atom.
The two routes transform these carbon–bromine bonds in different ways.
\(\textbf{Route P — Join the terminal carbons:}\)
The stipulated intramolecular sodium coupling forms a carbon–carbon bond between the two terminal methylene carbons.
\[
\mathrm{Br(CH_2)_6Br+2Na
\rightarrow (CH_2)_6+2NaBr}
\]
Here, \(\mathrm{(CH_2)_6}\) represents a six-membered carbon ring.
The product is cyclohexane.
\(\textbf{Check carbon conservation in P:}\)
The ring contains the original six carbon atoms.
Sodium does not introduce any additional carbon.
The two bromine atoms are removed as bromide-containing inorganic products.
\(\textbf{Route Q — Form the difunctional organomagnesium reagent:}\)
The question specifies complete magnesium insertion at both termini:
\[
\mathrm{Br(CH_2)_6Br+2Mg
\xrightarrow{dry\ ether}
BrMg(CH_2)_6MgBr}
\]
The resulting compound contains two carbon–magnesium bonds.
Each carbon–magnesium centre can react with carbon dioxide.
\(\textbf{Carboxylate both reactive termini:}\)
\[
\mathrm{BrMg(CH_2)_6MgBr+2CO_2
\rightarrow BrMgOOC(CH_2)_6COOMgBr}
\]
Acidic hydrolysis produces:
\[
\mathrm{HOOC(CH_2)_6COOH}
\]
The product is octanedioic acid.
\(\textbf{Count the carbon atoms in Q:}\)
The original chain contains six carbon atoms.
Each carbon dioxide molecule contributes one new carboxyl carbon.
Therefore:
\[
N_C=6+2
\]
\[
N_C=8
\]
The compound is an eight-carbon dicarboxylic acid.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the synthetic strategies:}\)
Route P creates an internal carbon–carbon bond and preserves the original carbon count.
Route Q forms two new carbon–carbon bonds with carbon dioxide and increases the carbon count by two.
Both transformations involve the terminal carbon–bromine positions, but they produce very different carbon frameworks.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Tracking the fate of both carbon–bromine bonds establishes the product structures.
Intramolecular coupling gives cyclohexane, whereas double carboxylation gives octanedioic acid.
416. Two substitution series are investigated using the same nucleophile under suitable conditions for the specified mechanisms.
Series I: Hydroxide substitution of fluoromethane and chloromethane through ordinary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) pathways.
Series II: Methoxide substitution of 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene and 1-chloro-2,4-dinitrobenzene through activated aromatic addition–elimination pathways.
Assume comparable conditions within each series.
Which qualitative comparison is most appropriate?
ⓐ. The carbon–fluorine substrate must be faster in both series because fluorine is more electronegative than chlorine
ⓑ. The carbon–chlorine substrate must be faster in both series because chloride is always the better leaving group in every substitution mechanism
ⓒ. Both halogens must show identical reactivity in Series II because the two nitro groups completely determine the rate
ⓓ. Chloromethane is favoured in ordinary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\); activated aromatic fluoride can exceed chloride in addition–elimination
Correct Answer: Chloromethane is favoured in ordinary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\); activated aromatic fluoride can exceed chloride in addition–elimination
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two reaction mechanisms:}\)
Series I involves nucleophilic substitution at saturated methyl carbon.
Series II involves nucleophilic aromatic substitution at an \(sp^2\)-hybridised aromatic carbon.
The corresponding reaction pathways have different electronic requirements.
\(\textbf{Examine the methyl-halide comparison:}\)
Both methyl substrates are sterically accessible.
However, the carbon–fluorine bond is particularly strong.
Fluoride is generally a poor leaving group in ordinary alkyl-halide substitution.
Chloromethane is therefore more suitable than fluoromethane for the stated \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) reaction.
\(\textbf{Identify the electronic activation in Series II:}\)
Both aromatic substrates contain nitro groups ortho and para to the aromatic carbon bearing halogen.
These electron-withdrawing groups stabilise the negatively charged addition intermediate formed during suitable nucleophilic attack.
The reaction proceeds through addition followed by elimination and restoration of aromaticity.
\(\textbf{Explain the distinct role of fluorine:}\)
In activated aromatic addition–elimination reactions, the addition step can strongly influence the overall rate.
The powerful electron-withdrawing inductive effect of fluorine can favour nucleophilic addition to the aromatic carbon.
Consequently, suitably activated aromatic fluorides can be more reactive than analogous aromatic chlorides.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the two leaving-group arguments:}\)
Ordinary methyl-halide \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) substitution depends on the concerted displacement of the leaving group.
Activated aromatic substitution instead involves a distinct addition intermediate.
The rate cannot be inferred from the carbon–halogen homolytic bond enthalpy alone.
\(\textbf{Reject a universal halogen order:}\)
The reactivity order associated with one mechanism cannot be transferred automatically to another.
A stronger carbon–halogen bond does not necessarily imply a slower reaction under every possible substitution pathway.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Substrate class, electronic activation and mechanism must be considered together.
The qualitative fluoride–chloride preference can reverse between ordinary alkyl substitution and nitro-activated aromatic substitution.
417. A chemist wishes to prepare 4-bromonitrobenzene as the principal positional isomer from benzene.
Two strategies are proposed.
Route P: Bromination of benzene using \(\mathrm{Br_2/FeBr_3}\), isolation of bromobenzene, followed by controlled mononitration.
Route Q: Mononitration of benzene, isolation of nitrobenzene, followed by bromination using \(\mathrm{Br_2/FeBr_3}\) under suitable conditions.
Assume that the reactions occur and that the usual directing influences govern the substitution patterns.
Which assessment is most appropriate?
ⓐ. Route P favours ortho/para bromonitrobenzene formation and can provide the required para isomer after separation, whereas Route Q favours the meta isomer
ⓑ. Route Q is preferred because a nitro group activates benzene towards para-directed bromination
ⓒ. Both routes favour the same para product because electrophilic aromatic substitution is independent of the order in which substituents are introduced
ⓓ. Neither route can form bromonitrobenzene because bromine and nitro groups cannot coexist on an aromatic ring
Correct Answer: Route P favours ortho/para bromonitrobenzene formation and can provide the required para isomer after separation, whereas Route Q favours the meta isomer
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the effect of introducing bromine first:}\)
Bromination of benzene using bromine and a suitable Lewis-acid catalyst produces bromobenzene:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_6+Br_2\xrightarrow{FeBr_3}C_6H_5Br+HBr}
\]
The bromine atom remains attached directly to an aromatic carbon.
It subsequently influences the orientation of further electrophilic substitution.
\(\textbf{Determine bromine's directing effect:}\)
Bromine withdraws electron density through its inductive effect.
It therefore deactivates the aromatic ring relative to benzene.
However, lone-pair resonance donation gives bromine an ortho/para-directing influence.
\(\textbf{Predict Route-P nitration:}\)
Controlled nitration of bromobenzene gives principally ortho- and para-bromonitrobenzene.
The para isomer is commonly favoured over the ortho isomer by reduced steric crowding.
Nevertheless, the reaction should not be assumed to give a single pure para product without separation.
\(\textbf{Identify the effect of introducing nitro first:}\)
Nitration of benzene produces nitrobenzene:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_6\xrightarrow{HNO_3/H_2SO_4}C_6H_5NO_2}
\]
The nitro group strongly withdraws electron density by inductive and resonance effects.
It deactivates the ring and is meta directing towards ordinary electrophilic substitution.
\(\textbf{Predict Route-Q bromination:}\)
Subsequent bromination of nitrobenzene therefore favours meta-bromonitrobenzene under conditions allowing the reaction.
This is not the required para isomer.
The directing effect arises from the substituent already present when the second electrophile is introduced.
\(\textbf{Compare the synthetic strategies:}\)
Both routes ultimately introduce one bromine and one nitro group.
However, introducing these substituents in different orders changes the directing group present during the second substitution.
The relative positions in the final products consequently differ.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Aromatic synthesis planning requires controlling substitution order as well as reagent identity.
Bromination followed by nitration is the more appropriate route for obtaining the para isomer after suitable separation.
418. Two secondary alkyl chlorides are heated separately with alcoholic KOH under conditions favouring beta-elimination.
P: 3-Chloro-2,2-dimethylpentane, \(\mathrm{(CH_3)_3CCH(Cl)CH_2CH_3}\).
Q: 3-Chloro-2-methylpentane, \(\mathrm{CH_3CH(CH_3)CH(Cl)CH_2CH_3}\).
Assume no rearrangement and that all stereochemically accessible elimination products are considered.
Which statement correctly compares the available elimination directions?
ⓐ. P cannot eliminate because its carbon skeleton contains a quaternary carbon, whereas Q forms only one constitutional alkene
ⓑ. Both form exclusively the same internal alkene because the chlorine-bearing carbon is secondary in each
ⓒ. P eliminates only towards the ethyl side to give 4,4-dimethylpent-2-ene; Q can eliminate in two directions
ⓓ. P and Q each form only a terminal alkene because branching always prevents internal double-bond formation
Correct Answer: P eliminates only towards the ethyl side to give 4,4-dimethylpent-2-ene; Q can eliminate in two directions
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the E2 structural requirement:}\)
Beta-elimination involves removal of a hydrogen from a carbon adjacent to the carbon bearing chlorine.
The required beta-hydrogen must also possess suitable stereoelectronic alignment with the leaving group.
The presence or absence of such hydrogens determines the available elimination directions.
\(\textbf{Examine the chlorine-bearing carbon in P:}\)
P has the structure:
\[
\mathrm{(CH_3)_3CCH(Cl)CH_2CH_3}
\]
The chlorine-bearing carbon is attached to a quaternary carbon on one side and a methylene carbon on the other.
Both are formally adjacent beta carbons.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the quaternary side of P:}\)
The quaternary carbon has four carbon–carbon bonds.
It bears no hydrogen.
Therefore, no ordinary beta-elimination can form a double bond between that carbon and the chlorine-bearing carbon.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the other side of P:}\)
The adjacent methylene carbon contains beta-hydrogens.
Elimination can therefore occur towards that side:
\[
\mathrm{(CH_3)_3CCH(Cl)CH_2CH_3
\rightarrow (CH_3)_3CCH{=}CHCH_3+HCl}
\]
The product is 4,4-dimethylpent-2-ene.
Because each double-bond carbon bears two different substituents, E/Z configurations are possible when the required conformations are available.
\(\textbf{Examine the chlorine-bearing carbon in Q:}\)
Q has the structure:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH(CH_3)CH(Cl)CH_2CH_3}
\]
The beta carbon on the branched side contains one hydrogen.
The beta carbon on the ethyl side contains two hydrogens.
Both directions are therefore available.
\(\textbf{Identify the constitutional products from Q:}\)
Elimination towards the branched side gives 2-methylpent-2-ene.
Elimination towards the ethyl side gives 4-methylpent-2-ene.
The product ratio depends on alkene stability, steric effects and reaction conditions.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Two secondary alkyl chlorides can have different elimination possibilities because their adjacent carbon environments differ.
A quaternary beta carbon blocks one elimination direction, whereas a beta carbon bearing hydrogen permits it.
419. Three hydrocarbons have the same molecular formula, \(\mathrm{C_5H_{10}}\):
P: Cyclopentane.
Q: Methylcyclobutane.
R: Pent-1-ene.
They are subjected separately to two experiments.
Experiment I: Treatment with bromine in a suitable inert solvent in the dark, under conditions that permit ordinary alkene addition but not photochemical alkane substitution.
Experiment II: Controlled free-radical monochlorination with \(\mathrm{Cl_2/h\nu}\), with only constitutionally distinct monochloro products counted.
Which statement correctly identifies the hydrocarbon that does not undergo the ordinary dark bromine-addition reaction and also gives only one constitutional monochloro product?
ⓐ. R, because a terminal carbon–carbon double bond is equivalent to a saturated cycloalkane bond
ⓑ. Q, because its methyl group makes every hydrogen atom equivalent
ⓒ. Both P and Q, because their molecular formulas are identical
ⓓ. P, because it lacks an alkene double bond and all its ring hydrogen positions are constitutionally equivalent
Correct Answer: P, because it lacks an alkene double bond and all its ring hydrogen positions are constitutionally equivalent
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret the molecular formula:}\)
The formula \(\mathrm{C_5H_{10}}\) is compatible with both an acyclic alkene and a saturated monocyclic hydrocarbon.
Therefore, the molecular formula alone does not distinguish the three structures.
The reactions must be interpreted using their bonding arrangements.
\(\textbf{Analyse Experiment I for P:}\)
Cyclopentane contains only carbon–carbon single bonds.
It lacks the carbon–carbon double bond required for ordinary bromine addition under the specified conditions.
Therefore, it does not undergo the intended dark alkene-addition reaction.
\(\textbf{Analyse Experiment I for Q:}\)
Methylcyclobutane is also a saturated cycloalkane.
It likewise lacks an alkene double bond.
Under the stated dark conditions, it does not undergo the ordinary alkene-addition reaction.
\(\textbf{Analyse Experiment I for R:}\)
Pent-1-ene contains a carbon–carbon double bond.
Bromine can add across that double bond under suitable conditions:
\[
\mathrm{CH_2{=}CHCH_2CH_2CH_3+Br_2
\rightarrow BrCH_2CHBrCH_2CH_2CH_3}
\]
Thus, R behaves differently from the two saturated cyclic structures.
\(\textbf{Compare monochlorination of P:}\)
Cyclopentane has five equivalent ring carbon positions for constitutional substitution.
Replacing one hydrogen by chlorine at any ring position produces chlorocyclopentane.
Only one constitutional monochloro product is therefore possible.
\(\textbf{Compare monochlorination of Q:}\)
Methylcyclobutane contains several nonequivalent hydrogen environments.
They include the methyl group, the substituted ring carbon and different ring methylene positions.
Consequently, free-radical monochlorination can produce more than one constitutional product.
\(\textbf{Integrate the observations:}\)
Both P and Q satisfy the first observation involving the absence of ordinary dark bromine addition.
Only P satisfies the second observation involving one constitutional monochloro product.
The combination therefore identifies cyclopentane.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Reaction-class recognition and molecular symmetry provide independent structural information.
Using both observations distinguishes positional or skeletal isomers that share the same molecular formula.
420. Ethanol is converted into bromoethane using phosphorus tribromide prepared in situ from phosphorus and bromine.
The idealised reactions are:
\[
\mathrm{P_4+6Br_2\rightarrow4PBr_3}
\]
\[
\mathrm{3C_2H_5OH+PBr_3\rightarrow3C_2H_5Br+H_3PO_3}
\]
Initially, the laboratory has \(0.0500\ \mathrm{mol}\) of \(\mathrm{P_4}\), \(0.240\ \mathrm{mol}\) of \(\mathrm{Br_2}\) and \(0.600\ \mathrm{mol}\) of ethanol.
Assume complete intended reactions without side products.
Which pair gives the maximum amount of phosphorus tribromide formed and the corresponding maximum amount of bromoethane?
ⓐ. \(0.200\ \mathrm{mol}\) and \(0.600\ \mathrm{mol}\)
ⓑ. \(0.160\ \mathrm{mol}\) and \(0.480\ \mathrm{mol}\)
ⓒ. \(0.0400\ \mathrm{mol}\) and \(0.120\ \mathrm{mol}\)
ⓓ. \(0.160\ \mathrm{mol}\) and \(0.160\ \mathrm{mol}\)
Correct Answer: \(0.160\ \mathrm{mol}\) and \(0.480\ \mathrm{mol}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two reaction stages:}\)
Phosphorus tribromide is first prepared from elemental phosphorus and bromine.
The resulting reagent then converts ethanol into bromoethane.
The limiting reagent must be determined in the first stage before calculating the second-stage product.
\(\textbf{Determine the phosphorus requirement:}\)
The first balanced equation is:
\[
\mathrm{P_4+6Br_2\rightarrow4PBr_3}
\]
Complete consumption of \(0.0500\ \mathrm{mol}\) \(\mathrm{P_4}\) would require:
\[
n_{\mathrm{required}}(\mathrm{Br_2})=6(0.0500)
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{required}}(\mathrm{Br_2})=0.300\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
Only \(0.240\ \mathrm{mol}\) bromine is available.
Therefore, bromine is the limiting reagent.
\(\textbf{Calculate the phosphorus tribromide amount:}\)
Six moles of bromine produce four moles of phosphorus tribromide:
\[
n(\mathrm{PBr_3})=\frac46n(\mathrm{Br_2})
\]
\[
n(\mathrm{PBr_3})=\frac46(0.240)
\]
\[
n(\mathrm{PBr_3})=0.160\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine ethanol consumption in the second stage:}\)
One mole of phosphorus tribromide reacts with three moles of ethanol:
\[
\mathrm{3C_2H_5OH+PBr_3\rightarrow3C_2H_5Br+H_3PO_3}
\]
The ethanol required is:
\[
n_{\mathrm{required}}(\mathrm{C_2H_5OH})=3(0.160)
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{required}}(\mathrm{C_2H_5OH})=0.480\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
Since \(0.600\ \mathrm{mol}\) ethanol is available, ethanol is in excess.
\(\textbf{Calculate bromoethane formation:}\)
The phosphorus tribromide-to-bromoethane mole ratio is \(1:3\):
\[
n(\mathrm{C_2H_5Br})=3n(\mathrm{PBr_3})
\]
\[
n(\mathrm{C_2H_5Br})=3(0.160)
\]
\[
n(\mathrm{C_2H_5Br})=0.480\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Check the sequential limitation:}\)
Although the initially available phosphorus could theoretically produce \(0.200\ \mathrm{mol}\) phosphorus tribromide, bromine limits actual formation to \(0.160\ \mathrm{mol}\).
The bromoethane amount must therefore be calculated from the actual first-stage product.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{n(\mathrm{PBr_3})=0.160\ \mathrm{mol},\quad
n(\mathrm{C_2H_5Br})=0.480\ \mathrm{mol}}
\]
421. 1-Bromobutane is treated with magnesium turnings in dry ether to form an organomagnesium compound P. In a separate experiment, the freshly prepared P is deliberately exposed to water before it can react with another reagent. Which pair correctly identifies P and the organic product of its reaction with water?
ⓐ. P is butylmagnesium bromide; water converts it into butane
ⓑ. P is butylmagnesium bromide; water converts it into butan-1-ol
ⓒ. P is butane; water converts it into butylmagnesium bromide
ⓓ. P is butan-1-ol; water converts it into 1-bromobutane
Correct Answer: P is butylmagnesium bromide; water converts it into butane
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the metal-insertion reaction:}\)
A suitable alkyl bromide reacts with magnesium in anhydrous ether to form a Grignard reagent. Magnesium becomes bonded to the carbon group and to the halogen:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH_2CH_2Br+Mg\xrightarrow{dry\ ether}CH_3CH_2CH_2CH_2MgBr}
\]
The product P is butylmagnesium bromide. Its carbon–magnesium bond is strongly polar and the carbon end has pronounced basic character.
\(\textbf{Predict the reaction with water:}\)
Water supplies an acidic proton to the carbon attached to magnesium. The organic fragment becomes the corresponding alkane:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH_2CH_2MgBr+H_2O\rightarrow CH_3CH_2CH_2CH_3+Mg(OH)Br}
\]
The organic product is butane, not butan-1-ol.
\(\textbf{Explain the role of dry ether:}\)
The Grignard reagent must be prepared and handled under dry conditions because even small amounts of moisture can consume it through proton transfer. This destroys the organomagnesium reagent before it can take part in a planned reaction.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The first stage creates a reactive C–Mg bond from a C–Br bond. The second stage breaks that organomagnesium functionality through reaction with water, yielding a hydrocarbon with the same four-carbon skeleton.
422. A chemist wishes to convert chlorobenzene into 4-nitroanisole while retaining the aromatic ring.
Two sequences are considered.
Route P: Controlled nitration of chlorobenzene, separation of the para-nitrochlorobenzene isomer, followed by treatment with sodium methoxide under conditions favouring activated nucleophilic aromatic substitution.
Route Q: Treatment of chlorobenzene with sodium methoxide under ordinary mild substitution conditions, followed by nitration of whatever aromatic compound remains.
Which assessment correctly identifies the more suitable sequence?
ⓐ. Route P is suitable because para-nitro substitution activates the aromatic carbon–chlorine bond towards methoxide displacement; Route Q lacks that activation during its first step
ⓑ. Route Q is suitable because methoxide readily displaces chlorine from unactivated chlorobenzene before nitration
ⓒ. Both routes necessarily give 4-nitroanisole because substituent introduction order never affects aromatic substitution
ⓓ. Neither route is suitable because an aromatic carbon–chlorine bond cannot undergo nucleophilic substitution under any conditions
Correct Answer: Route P is suitable because para-nitro substitution activates the aromatic carbon–chlorine bond towards methoxide displacement; Route Q lacks that activation during its first step
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the desired product:}\)
4-Nitroanisole contains a methoxy group and a nitro group at para positions on a benzene ring.
The starting chlorobenzene contains the aromatic carbon–chlorine bond that must eventually be replaced by methoxy.
The synthetic problem is therefore concerned with the order in which electronic activation and nucleophilic replacement are introduced.
\(\textbf{Examine the nitration step in P:}\)
Chlorine is deactivating but ortho/para directing in electrophilic aromatic substitution.
Controlled nitration of chlorobenzene therefore produces ortho- and para-nitrochlorobenzene.
The question explicitly requires separation of the para isomer.
This provides a substrate with a nitro group para to the aromatic chlorine.
\(\textbf{Identify the electronic advantage:}\)
A para nitro group strongly withdraws electron density.
It can stabilise the anionic addition intermediate formed during suitable nucleophilic aromatic substitution.
Consequently, the aromatic carbon–chlorine bond becomes more susceptible to methoxide attack through the addition–elimination pathway.
\(\textbf{Complete Route P:}\)
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!O_2NC_6H_4Cl+CH_3O^-
\rightarrow 4\!-\!O_2NC_6H_4OCH_3+Cl^-}
\]
The intended organic product is 4-nitroanisole.
The nitro group remains attached to the ring throughout this substitution.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the first step in Q:}\)
Route Q attempts methoxide displacement on chlorobenzene before introducing an activating nitro group.
Unactivated chlorobenzene resists ordinary mild aromatic nucleophilic substitution.
Therefore, the first step does not provide an efficient route to anisole under the stipulated conditions.
\(\textbf{Consider the subsequent nitration:}\)
Nitration cannot retroactively cause the earlier unsuccessful methoxide substitution.
If chlorobenzene remains unchanged, subsequent nitration primarily introduces a nitro group into a chlorinated aromatic ring.
It does not automatically produce the required methoxy-containing product.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Reaction order can determine whether a later transformation is electronically feasible.
Installing the para nitro group first creates the activation needed for nucleophilic replacement of aromatic chlorine.
Route P is therefore the more suitable sequence.
423. A primary alkyl bromide X has the structure \(\mathrm{BrCH_2CH(CH_3)CH_2CH_3}\).
It undergoes two independent reaction sequences.
Route P: Heating with alcoholic KOH to obtain the corresponding alkene, followed by addition of HBr in the absence of peroxides.
Route Q: Symmetrical Wurtz coupling of two molecules of X using sodium in dry ether.
Assume the expected regioselectivity in Route P, no rearrangement and quantitative intended coupling in Route Q.
Which pair correctly identifies the principal products?
ⓐ. P: 1-Bromo-2-methylbutane; Q: n-decane
ⓑ. P: 2-Bromo-3-methylbutane; Q: 2,7-dimethyloctane
ⓒ. P: 1-Bromo-2-methylbutane; Q: 3,6-dimethyloctane
ⓓ. P: 2-Bromo-2-methylbutane; Q: 3,6-dimethyloctane
Correct Answer: P: 2-Bromo-2-methylbutane; Q: 3,6-dimethyloctane
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the starting carbon skeleton:}\)
X is 1-bromo-2-methylbutane.
It contains five carbon atoms and has bromine attached to a terminal primary carbon.
The carbon skeleton is branched, but the bromine-bearing carbon remains suitable for the stipulated transformations.
\(\textbf{Route P — Locate the available beta-hydrogen:}\)
The beta carbon adjacent to the bromine-bearing carbon is carbon 2.
It possesses one hydrogen atom.
Elimination of this hydrogen together with bromide forms:
\[
\mathrm{BrCH_2CH(CH_3)CH_2CH_3
\xrightarrow{alc.\ KOH,\ \Delta}
CH_2{=}C(CH_3)CH_2CH_3}
\]
The alkene is 2-methylbut-1-ene.
\(\textbf{Apply ordinary HBr addition:}\)
The alkene has an unsymmetrical terminal double bond.
In the absence of peroxides, HBr follows the usual Markovnikov orientation.
Bromine becomes attached to the more substituted double-bond carbon:
\[
\mathrm{CH_2{=}C(CH_3)CH_2CH_3+HBr
\rightarrow CH_3C(Br)(CH_3)CH_2CH_3}
\]
The product is 2-bromo-2-methylbutane.
\(\textbf{Route Q — Identify the coupling carbon:}\)
Wurtz coupling joins two alkyl fragments at the carbons originally bonded to bromine.
Each starting fragment has the structure:
\[
\mathrm{{-}CH_2CH(CH_3)CH_2CH_3}
\]
Joining two such fragments gives:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH(CH_3)CH_2CH_2CH(CH_3)CH_2CH_3}
\]
\(\textbf{Name the coupled product:}\)
The longest continuous chain contains eight carbon atoms.
The two methyl substituents are positioned at carbons 3 and 6.
Therefore, the product is 3,6-dimethyloctane.
\(\textbf{Check carbon conservation:}\)
The initial bromide contains five carbon atoms.
Elimination followed by hydrohalogenation retains those five carbon atoms.
Symmetrical Wurtz coupling combines two five-carbon fragments into one ten-carbon molecule.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the two structural changes:}\)
Route P moves the bromine-bearing reaction centre through elimination and subsequent addition.
Route Q creates a new carbon–carbon bond without changing the internal branching pattern of each starting fragment.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The same primary alkyl bromide can generate a tertiary alkyl bromide through elimination and Markovnikov addition, or a larger branched alkane through symmetrical coupling.
Correctly tracking the reacting carbon is essential in both routes.
424. Two alkenes undergo bromine addition in an achiral solvent under conditions favouring the usual electrophilic addition pathway:
P: 2-Methylbut-2-ene, \(\mathrm{(CH_3)_2C{=}CHCH_3}\).
Q: 2,3-Dimethylbut-2-ene, \(\mathrm{(CH_3)_2C{=}C(CH_3)_2}\).
Assume complete addition of exactly one molecule of bromine per alkene molecule, without rearrangement.
Which statement correctly compares the configurational stereoisomers of the dibromide products?
ⓐ. P gives one achiral dibromide, whereas Q gives an enantiomeric pair
ⓑ. Both give racemic products because every bromine addition creates two stereogenic centres
ⓒ. P forms an enantiomeric pair of dibromides; Q forms an achiral dibromide
ⓓ. Both give one meso dibromide because each starting alkene contains two methyl groups
Correct Answer: P forms an enantiomeric pair of dibromides; Q forms an achiral dibromide
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the common reaction:}\)
Molecular bromine adds across a suitable carbon–carbon double bond.
Each original double-bond carbon acquires one bromine atom.
The resulting carbons become saturated.
Whether the product is chiral depends on the identities of the four substituents attached to each newly saturated carbon.
\(\textbf{Determine the product from P:}\)
Addition to 2-methylbut-2-ene gives:
\[
\mathrm{(CH_3)_2C{=}CHCH_3+Br_2
\rightarrow (CH_3)_2C(Br)CH(Br)CH_3}
\]
The product is 2,3-dibromo-2-methylbutane.
\(\textbf{Examine the first bromine-bearing carbon:}\)
One carbon is attached to bromine, the adjacent brominated carbon and two identical methyl groups.
It is not stereogenic because two substituents are identical.
\(\textbf{Examine the second bromine-bearing carbon:}\)
The other carbon is attached to bromine, hydrogen, methyl and the neighbouring substituted carbon.
These four substituents are different.
It is therefore stereogenic.
Under achiral conditions, formation of both enantiomeric configurations is possible.
\(\textbf{Determine the product from Q:}\)
Addition to 2,3-dimethylbut-2-ene gives:
\[
\mathrm{(CH_3)_2C{=}C(CH_3)_2+Br_2
\rightarrow (CH_3)_2C(Br)C(Br)(CH_3)_2}
\]
The product is 2,3-dibromo-2,3-dimethylbutane.
\(\textbf{Examine Q's two bromine-bearing carbons:}\)
Each is bonded to bromine, the adjacent carbon and two identical methyl groups.
Neither carbon has four different substituents.
Therefore, neither is stereogenic.
The product is achiral.
\(\textbf{Distinguish bromine addition from automatic chirality:}\)
Addition to a double bond does not always generate a stereogenic centre.
The substituent identities around each newly saturated carbon must be checked.
The number of bromine atoms in the product is not sufficient for predicting optical isomerism.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
P produces a dibromide capable of existing as an enantiomeric pair.
Q produces an achiral dibromide because identical methyl substituents prevent stereogenicity at either bromine-bearing carbon.
425. 1-Bromo-3-nitrobenzene is subjected to controlled electrophilic mononitration.
The benzene ring contains bromine at carbon 1 and a nitro group at carbon 3. The available positions are 2, 4, 5 and 6. Bromine ordinarily directs incoming electrophiles towards positions 2, 4 and 6. The nitro group ordinarily directs incoming electrophiles towards positions 1 and 5, but position 1 is already occupied by bromine.
A student argues that both substituents must direct nitration to the same vacant carbon because bromine and nitro groups are both deactivating.
Which assessment is correct?
ⓐ. The student is correct because the shared deactivating effect makes position 2 uniquely favoured
ⓑ. The student is incorrect: the substituents favour different vacant sites, and simple directing rules do not assign an exclusive major isomer
ⓒ. The student is correct because the nitro group becomes ortho/para directing when bromine is present
ⓓ. The student is incorrect because electrophilic nitration must replace the existing bromine atom rather than an aromatic hydrogen
Correct Answer: The student is incorrect: the substituents favour different vacant sites, and simple directing rules do not assign an exclusive major isomer
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the effect of aromatic bromine:}\)
Bromine withdraws electron density through its inductive effect.
It therefore deactivates the aromatic ring towards electrophilic substitution.
However, lone-pair resonance donation makes bromine ortho/para directing.
\(\textbf{Locate the bromine-directed positions:}\)
With bromine at carbon 1, its ortho positions are 2 and 6.
Its para position is 4.
All three positions are vacant in the stated starting structure.
\(\textbf{Identify the effect of the nitro group:}\)
The nitro group strongly withdraws electron density through inductive and resonance effects.
It deactivates the aromatic ring and is meta directing in ordinary electrophilic substitution.
This directing behaviour differs from that of bromine.
\(\textbf{Locate the nitro-directed positions:}\)
With the nitro group at carbon 3, its meta positions are 1 and 5.
Carbon 1 is already occupied by bromine.
Therefore, the only vacant position favoured by the nitro group's simple meta-directing rule is carbon 5.
\(\textbf{Compare the position sets:}\)
Bromine favours positions 2, 4 and 6.
The nitro group favours position 5.
There is no vacant position common to the two preferred sets.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the student's explanation:}\)
Two substituents can both deactivate an aromatic ring while directing incoming electrophiles towards different positions.
Overall activation or deactivation and positional directing effect are not identical concepts.
Consequently, the student's inference from shared deactivation is incorrect.
\(\textbf{Recognise the limitation of simple directing rules:}\)
A real product distribution depends on the combined electronic effects, steric crowding and reaction conditions.
The absence of a commonly favoured position does not mean that nitration is impossible.
It means that the simple directing rules alone do not establish one exclusive principal isomer.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
When directing influences conflict, an unjustified single-product prediction should be avoided.
The correct analysis identifies the competing positional preferences before making any claim about the product mixture.
426. Cyclobutylmethyl chloride is subjected to two separate hydrolysis experiments.
The starting compound is a four-membered cyclobutane ring bearing an external \(\mathrm{-CH_2Cl}\) group on one ring carbon. The carbon bearing chlorine is primary. In Experiment P, hydroxide replaces chlorine through direct backside substitution without carbon-skeleton rearrangement. In Experiment Q, the carbon–chlorine bond first ionises, and the resulting cyclobutylmethyl carbocation undergoes a specified ring-expansion rearrangement to a cyclopentyl carbocation before water capture.
Assume complete intended substitution in both experiments and no competing elimination.
Which pair correctly identifies the final alcohols?
ⓐ. P: Cyclopentanol; Q: cyclobutylmethanol
ⓑ. P and Q: Cyclobutylmethanol, because rearrangement does not affect the number of carbon atoms
ⓒ. P: Cyclobutanol; Q: cyclopentanol
ⓓ. P: Cyclobutylmethanol; Q: cyclopentanol
Correct Answer: P: Cyclobutylmethanol; Q: cyclopentanol
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the starting carbon framework:}\)
Cyclobutylmethyl chloride contains a cyclobutane ring with a chloromethyl substituent.
Its total carbon count is five.
The chlorine-bearing carbon lies outside the four-membered ring.
The two experiments differ in whether the carbon framework is preserved or rearranged.
\(\textbf{Experiment P — Direct substitution:}\)
The question specifies an ordinary backside substitution at the external primary carbon.
Hydroxide replaces chlorine without breaking or forming any carbon–carbon sigma bond.
The four-membered ring therefore remains intact.
\(\textbf{Identify P's product:}\)
The external group changes from \(\mathrm{-CH_2Cl}\) to \(\mathrm{-CH_2OH}\).
The product is cyclobutylmethanol.
It retains the original cyclobutane ring and five-carbon skeleton.
\(\textbf{Experiment Q — Form the initial carbocation:}\)
Ionisation of the external carbon–chlorine bond gives a cyclobutylmethyl carbocation.
The positive charge is initially associated with the carbon outside the ring.
This intermediate can undergo the specified skeletal rearrangement before water attacks.
\(\textbf{Apply ring expansion:}\)
Migration of an adjacent carbon–carbon bonding electron pair changes the connectivity between the external carbon and the original ring.
The four-membered ring expands into a five-membered ring.
A cyclopentyl carbocation is formed.
This transformation also relieves strain associated with the smaller ring.
\(\textbf{Capture the rearranged carbocation:}\)
Water attacks the cyclopentyl carbocation and subsequently loses a proton.
The product is cyclopentanol.
Its hydroxyl-bearing carbon now belongs to a five-membered ring.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the products by connectivity:}\)
Both products contain five carbon atoms and one hydroxyl group.
However, cyclobutylmethanol contains a four-membered ring with an external hydroxymethyl group.
Cyclopentanol contains a five-membered ring with hydroxyl directly attached to a ring carbon.
They are constitutional isomers.
\(\textbf{Interpret the mechanistic significance:}\)
A direct \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) pathway preserves the carbon skeleton.
A carbocation-containing pathway can permit skeletal rearrangement when an energetically favourable route is available.
The presence of a rearranged product can therefore provide evidence for an intermediate capable of carbon–carbon bond migration.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The two experiments produce different alcohols because only Q includes a ring-expansion step.
The correct products are cyclobutylmethanol and cyclopentanol.
427. 1-Bromopropane is divided into two equal portions and subjected to separate nucleophilic substitutions.
Portion P is treated with sodium ethoxide, \(\mathrm{C_2H_5ONa}\).
Portion Q is treated with sodium ethanethiolate, \(\mathrm{C_2H_5SNa}\).
Both reactions proceed through ordinary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) displacement under suitable conditions.
The resulting organic products are then compared for boiling-point behaviour.
Which statement correctly identifies the products and provides the more appropriate physical explanation?
ⓐ. P gives ethyl propyl sulfide and Q gives ethyl propyl ether; P should have stronger hydrogen bonding because sulphur is heavier
ⓑ. Both give ethyl propyl ether because oxygen and sulphur nucleophiles become chemically identical after substitution
ⓒ. P gives ethyl propyl ether and Q gives ethyl propyl sulfide; the sulphur-containing product can have stronger dispersion attractions because sulphur is larger and more polarizable
ⓓ. P gives propan-1-ol and Q gives propan-1-thiol; both products necessarily form extensive intermolecular O–H hydrogen bonds
Correct Answer: P gives ethyl propyl ether and Q gives ethyl propyl sulfide; the sulphur-containing product can have stronger dispersion attractions because sulphur is larger and more polarizable
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the common electrophilic substrate:}\)
1-Bromopropane contains bromine attached to a terminal saturated carbon.
The carbon is primary and accessible to backside nucleophilic attack.
Both supplied reagents contain negatively charged heteroatoms capable of donating an electron pair.
\(\textbf{Follow the oxygen-centred substitution:}\)
Ethoxide attacks through oxygen:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH_2Br+C_2H_5O^-
\rightarrow CH_3CH_2CH_2OC_2H_5+Br^-}
\]
The product is 1-ethoxypropane, also called ethyl propyl ether.
This is a Williamson-type ether synthesis.
\(\textbf{Follow the sulphur-centred substitution:}\)
Ethanethiolate attacks through sulphur:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH_2Br+C_2H_5S^-
\rightarrow CH_3CH_2CH_2SC_2H_5+Br^-}
\]
The product is ethyl propyl sulfide, a thioether.
The carbon skeleton is unchanged relative to the ether product, but sulphur replaces oxygen as the linking atom.
\(\textbf{Compare their intermolecular interactions:}\)
Both products contain polarizable electron clouds and exhibit dispersion attractions.
Sulphur is larger and contains more electrons than oxygen.
The sulphur-containing product consequently has greater molecular mass and generally stronger polarizability-related dispersion interactions.
This can favour a higher boiling point than that of the corresponding oxygen ether.
\(\textbf{Check the hydrogen-bonding claim:}\)
Neither product contains an O–H or S–H bond.
It would therefore be incorrect to explain their boiling-point difference by claiming that one possesses an extensive network of ordinary O–H hydrogen bonds.
The identity and polarizability of the heteroatom provide a more relevant distinction.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Changing the nucleophilic atom from oxygen to sulphur changes the linkage and intermolecular properties without changing the alkyl fragments.
The products are an ether and a thioether, respectively.
428. 1-Bromobutane is subjected to two alternative sequences.
Route P: Substitution with alcoholic KCN, followed by complete acidic hydrolysis of the isolated carbon-linked nitrile.
Route Q: Substitution with AgCN under conditions favouring nitrogen-linked isocyanide formation, followed by complete acidic hydrolysis of the isolated isocyanide.
Assume that no rearrangement or competing substitution occurs.
Which statement correctly identifies the principal organic hydrolysis products?
ⓐ. P gives butanoic acid, whereas Q gives pentan-1-amine
ⓑ. P gives pentanoic acid, whereas Q gives butan-1-amine together with methanoic acid
ⓒ. P gives pentan-1-amine, whereas Q gives pentanoic acid
ⓓ. Both routes give pentanoic acid because nitriles and isocyanides contain the same number of carbon atoms
Correct Answer: P gives pentanoic acid, whereas Q gives butan-1-amine together with methanoic acid
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the ambident cyanide system:}\)
The cyanide group can become connected to an organic fragment through carbon or nitrogen.
Under the stipulated conditions, KCN favours carbon-linked nitrile formation, whereas AgCN favours nitrogen-linked isocyanide formation.
The products have different atom connectivity despite containing the same elemental types.
\(\textbf{Route P — Form the nitrile:}\)
Carbon-linked cyanide substitution produces:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH_2CH_2Br+KCN
\rightarrow CH_3CH_2CH_2CH_2CN+KBr}
\]
The nitrile is pentanenitrile.
Its nitrile carbon is the fifth carbon of the organic chain.
\(\textbf{Hydrolyse the nitrile:}\)
Under suitable complete acidic hydrolysis, the nitrile group becomes a carboxylic acid group:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH_2CH_2CN
\xrightarrow{H_2O/H^+,\ \Delta}
CH_3CH_2CH_2CH_2COOH}
\]
The principal organic product is pentanoic acid.
All five carbon atoms remain in one organic molecule.
\(\textbf{Route Q — Form the isocyanide:}\)
Silver cyanide favours attachment through nitrogen:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH_2CH_2Br+AgCN
\rightarrow CH_3CH_2CH_2CH_2NC+AgBr}
\]
The product is butyl isocyanide.
Its original four-carbon butyl group is attached to nitrogen rather than to the cyanide carbon.
\(\textbf{Hydrolyse the isocyanide:}\)
Suitable acidic hydrolysis of an isocyanide produces the corresponding primary amine, present as an ammonium salt in sufficiently acidic solution, together with methanoic acid:
\[
\mathrm{RNC+2H_2O\rightarrow RNH_2+HCOOH}
\]
After appropriate neutralisation, the amine is butan-1-amine.
The additional carbon originally present in the isocyanide group becomes the carbon of methanoic acid.
\(\textbf{Check carbon conservation:}\)
Route P gives one five-carbon carboxylic acid.
Route Q gives a four-carbon amine and a one-carbon acid.
Both routes conserve the total five carbon atoms present after cyanide incorporation.
However, their hydrolysis reactions distribute those carbon atoms differently.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Ambident nucleophile linkage selectivity can determine not only the immediate substitution product but also the connectivity and carbon distribution of later hydrolysis products.
The two routes cannot be treated as equivalent cyanide introductions.
429. Two stereoisomers of 1-bromo-4-methylcyclohexane are subjected to hydrolysis under conditions verified to produce one exclusive backside \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) substitution at carbon 1.
P initially has bromine and methyl on the same face of the cyclohexane ring.
Q initially has bromine and methyl on opposite faces.
Assume that the methyl-bearing carbon does not undergo any change in bonding, and that no ionisation, rearrangement or elimination occurs.
Which statement correctly identifies the relative stereochemistry of the alcohol products?
ⓐ. P gives trans-4-methylcyclohexan-1-ol, whereas Q gives cis-4-methylcyclohexan-1-ol
ⓑ. P gives cis-4-methylcyclohexan-1-ol, whereas Q gives trans-4-methylcyclohexan-1-ol
ⓒ. Both give the cis alcohol because hydroxyl is more strongly hydrogen bonding than bromine
ⓓ. Both give the trans alcohol because an \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) reaction removes all ring stereochemistry
Correct Answer: P gives trans-4-methylcyclohexan-1-ol, whereas Q gives cis-4-methylcyclohexan-1-ol
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the relevant stereochemical feature:}\)
Cis and trans relationships in substituted cyclohexanes describe whether substituents occupy the same or opposite faces of the ring.
These relationships are not determined by whether a substituent is axial or equatorial in one particular chair conformer.
A chair inversion changes axial and equatorial positions but does not change the up-or-down face occupied by a substituent.
\(\textbf{Examine the initial arrangement in P:}\)
P has bromine and methyl on the same face.
Its relative configuration is therefore cis.
The methyl group at carbon 4 is not altered during the stipulated substitution.
\(\textbf{Apply backside substitution to P:}\)
Hydroxide attacks carbon 1 from the face opposite the departing bromine.
The local tetrahedral arrangement at the reacting carbon is inverted.
The newly attached hydroxyl group consequently occupies the face opposite the original bromine.
Because methyl remains on its original face, hydroxyl and methyl become trans.
\(\textbf{Examine the initial arrangement in Q:}\)
Q has bromine and methyl on opposite ring faces.
Its starting relative configuration is trans.
Again, the methyl group's face remains unchanged during the specified reaction.
\(\textbf{Apply backside substitution to Q:}\)
The carbon bearing bromine undergoes inversion.
The entering hydroxyl group occupies the face opposite the departing bromine.
This places hydroxyl on the same face as the unchanged methyl substituent.
The product is therefore cis-4-methylcyclohexan-1-ol.
\(\textbf{Distinguish geometrical inversion from ring inversion:}\)
An \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) inversion changes the configuration at the reaction centre.
A cyclohexane chair inversion changes conformational positions while retaining configurational relationships.
These are different processes and must not be confused.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The substitution changes the relative ring-face relationship because only one of the two substituted carbons undergoes inversion.
P gives the trans alcohol, whereas Q gives the cis alcohol.
430. 4-Chloroaniline is converted into its diazonium salt using sodium nitrite and hydrochloric acid at \(273–278\ \mathrm{K}\).
The diazonium salt is divided into two portions.
P: Treatment with hypophosphorous acid, \(\mathrm{H_3PO_2}\), under conditions favouring reductive removal of the diazonium group.
Q: Treatment with a suitable cuprous bromide reagent under Sandmeyer conditions.
Assume that the original aromatic carbon–chlorine bond remains intact in both portions and that no further substitution occurs.
Which pair correctly identifies the organic products?
ⓐ. P: Benzene; Q: bromobenzene
ⓑ. P: Chlorobenzene; Q: 1-chloro-4-bromobenzene
ⓒ. P: 1,4-Dichlorobenzene; Q: chlorobenzene
ⓓ. P: 4-Chlorophenol; Q: 1,4-dibromobenzene
Correct Answer: P: Chlorobenzene; Q: 1-chloro-4-bromobenzene
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two original substituents:}\)
4-Chloroaniline contains chlorine directly attached to an aromatic carbon and an amino group at the para position.
The first stage converts the aromatic amino group into a diazonium group.
The pre-existing aromatic chlorine is not involved in that transformation.
\(\textbf{Form the diazonium intermediate:}\)
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!ClC_6H_4NH_2
\xrightarrow[\ 273-278\,K\ ]{NaNO_2/HCl}
4\!-\!ClC_6H_4N_2^+Cl^-}
\]
The diazonium group now occupies the aromatic position previously bearing the amino group.
\(\textbf{Determine the transformation in P:}\)
Hypophosphorous acid can reduce a suitable aromatic diazonium group to hydrogen.
Therefore, the diazonium substituent is removed:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!ClC_6H_4N_2^+
\xrightarrow{H_3PO_2/H_2O}
C_6H_5Cl+N_2}
\]
The organic product is chlorobenzene.
The original ring chlorine remains attached.
\(\textbf{Determine the transformation in Q:}\)
Under suitable Sandmeyer conditions, cuprous bromide replaces the diazonium group by bromine:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!ClC_6H_4N_2^+
\xrightarrow{CuBr}
4\!-\!ClC_6H_4Br+N_2}
\]
The organic product is 1-chloro-4-bromobenzene.
Its two halogens occupy para positions.
\(\textbf{Compare the fate of the diazonium carbon:}\)
The aromatic carbon initially bonded to nitrogen receives hydrogen in P.
The same carbon receives bromine in Q.
Neither reaction requires replacement of the chlorine already present elsewhere on the ring.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the synthetic purposes:}\)
Reductive removal of an amino-derived diazonium group is useful when a substituent has served its purpose during an earlier synthetic stage.
Sandmeyer substitution is useful for introducing a halogen at the diazonium-bearing position.
The two reactions therefore provide different aromatic substitution patterns from the same intermediate.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Following which aromatic carbon bears the diazonium group prevents confusion between replacement of the original chlorine and replacement of the nitrogen-containing group.
P yields chlorobenzene, whereas Q yields 1-chloro-4-bromobenzene.
431. A secondary alkyl bromide has the structure:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH(Br)CH(CH_3)CH_3}
\]
It undergoes two separate hydrolysis experiments.
P: Direct substitution of bromine by hydroxyl under conditions that prevent formation of a discrete carbocation.
Q: Ionisation to a secondary carbocation, followed by a favourable 1,2-hydride shift from the adjacent tertiary carbon and then capture by water.
Assume that the specified transformations are exclusive.
Which pair correctly identifies the principal alcohol products?
ⓐ. P: 2-Methylbutan-2-ol; Q: 3-methylbutan-2-ol
ⓑ. P: 3-Methylbutan-1-ol; Q: 2-methylbutan-2-ol
ⓒ. P: 3-Methylbutan-2-ol; Q: 2-methylbutan-2-ol
ⓓ. Both give 3-methylbutan-2-ol because hydride migration cannot change the position of a carbocation
Correct Answer: P: 3-Methylbutan-2-ol; Q: 2-methylbutan-2-ol
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the original bromine-bearing carbon:}\)
The starting compound is 2-bromo-3-methylbutane.
Its bromine-bearing carbon is secondary.
An adjacent carbon carries two methyl groups and one hydrogen and can provide a hydride during a suitable carbocation rearrangement.
\(\textbf{Evaluate direct substitution in P:}\)
The stipulated pathway replaces bromine without carbon–carbon bond rearrangement:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH(Br)CH(CH_3)CH_3
\rightarrow CH_3CH(OH)CH(CH_3)CH_3}
\]
The resulting alcohol is 3-methylbutan-2-ol.
Its hydroxyl-bearing carbon remains secondary.
\(\textbf{Identify the initial carbocation in Q:}\)
Ionisation removes bromide:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH^+CH(CH_3)CH_3}
\]
The positive charge is on the carbon that originally bore bromine.
The initially formed carbocation is secondary.
\(\textbf{Identify the migrating group:}\)
The adjacent branched carbon possesses a hydrogen atom.
Migration of that hydrogen together with its bonding electron pair can shift the positive charge to the neighbouring carbon.
This is a 1,2-hydride shift.
\(\textbf{Follow the carbocation rearrangement:}\)
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH^+CH(CH_3)CH_3
\rightarrow CH_3CH_2C^+(CH_3)CH_3}
\]
The rearranged carbocation is tertiary.
It is more stabilised than the initially formed secondary carbocation under the stipulated comparison.
\(\textbf{Capture the rearranged intermediate:}\)
Water attacks the tertiary carbocation.
After deprotonation, the product is:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2C(OH)(CH_3)CH_3}
\]
This is 2-methylbutan-2-ol.
\(\textbf{Check carbon connectivity:}\)
A hydride shift transfers hydrogen and its bonding electron pair.
It does not move a carbon atom or change the total carbon skeleton.
The carbon count remains five in both routes.
However, the position at which the hydroxyl group is introduced changes.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Direct substitution preserves the original site of the carbon–bromine bond.
The stipulated carbocation pathway allows the positive charge to relocate through hydride migration before water capture.
The products are therefore different constitutional alcohols.
432. An equilibrium model is proposed for halogen exchange between a primary alkyl bromide and iodide:
\[
\mathrm{RBr+I^-\rightleftharpoons RI+Br^-}
\]
Two experiments use the same concentrations of dissolved organic substrate and initially dissolved iodide.
In Experiment P, the solvent selectively causes the bromide-containing inorganic salt to precipitate while retaining the iodide reagent in solution.
In Experiment Q, both inorganic salts remain dissolved, and the homogeneous reaction has a finite equilibrium constant.
Assume that the precipitate does not participate in further reactions and that the substrates remain chemically stable.
Which conclusion is most appropriate?
ⓐ. P can favour iodide formation by bromide precipitation; no larger intrinsic substitution rate constant follows
ⓑ. P must have a lower extent of iodide formation because removing bromide shifts the equilibrium towards RBr
ⓒ. Q must proceed to complete iodide formation because soluble salts always drive halogen exchange irreversibly
ⓓ. The two experiments must have identical equilibrium compositions and intrinsic rate constants because the same carbon–halogen bonds are involved
Correct Answer: P can favour iodide formation by bromide precipitation; no larger intrinsic substitution rate constant follows
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the halogen-exchange process:}\)
A suitable primary alkyl bromide can undergo nucleophilic displacement by iodide.
The organic product is the corresponding alkyl iodide.
Bromide becomes the leaving-group ion.
\(\textbf{Distinguish dissolved species from a precipitate:}\)
In Experiment P, the bromide-containing inorganic salt precipitates.
This reduces the amount of dissolved bromide available to participate in the reverse reaction.
The solid is excluded from further chemical participation by the stated assumption.
\(\textbf{Apply the equilibrium argument:}\)
The reversible model can be expressed as:
\[
\mathrm{RBr+I^-\rightleftharpoons RI+Br^-}
\]
Removal of a dissolved product favours further formation of products.
Therefore, selective precipitation of the bromide salt can increase the equilibrium extent of organic iodide formation.
\(\textbf{Relate the situation to Finkelstein chemistry:}\)
In the conventional Finkelstein reaction, sodium iodide is used in dry acetone for suitable alkyl chlorides or bromides.
Sodium chloride or sodium bromide precipitates under appropriate conditions.
This removal of an inorganic product helps drive halogen exchange.
\(\textbf{Evaluate Experiment Q:}\)
When both inorganic salts remain dissolved, the stated finite homogeneous equilibrium can retain appreciable concentrations of reactants and products.
There is no corresponding precipitation-driven removal of bromide.
The organic iodide yield therefore need not match that of P.
\(\textbf{Distinguish equilibrium extent from reaction rate:}\)
The position of an equilibrium describes the relative amounts present when equilibrium is reached.
An intrinsic reaction rate constant describes the kinetics of an elementary or specified reaction pathway.
Changing solvent can affect both, but a precipitation argument alone cannot establish which solvent has the larger intrinsic substitution rate constant.
\(\textbf{Recognise the inference limit:}\)
The question does not supply activation barriers or measured initial rates.
Therefore, the kinetic constants cannot be ranked numerically from the equilibrium observations.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Precipitation can enhance conversion without proving a faster elementary substitution step.
This distinction is essential when interpreting solvent-driven halogen exchange.
433. A chemist wishes to prepare 1-phenoxy-2-methylbutane from an optically active sample of 2-methylbutan-1-ol.
Two strategies are considered.
Route P: Convert the primary hydroxyl group into bromide under conditions preserving the configuration at carbon 2, then react the resulting alkyl bromide with sodium phenoxide under conditions favouring substitution at carbon 1.
Route Q: Convert the original alcohol into its sodium alkoxide, then treat it with bromobenzene under ordinary Williamson ether synthesis conditions.
Assume that no rearrangement occurs.
Which statement best evaluates the strategies and the stereogenic centre?
ⓐ. Route Q is preferred because bromobenzene undergoes ordinary backside substitution more readily than a primary alkyl bromide
ⓑ. Both routes necessarily racemise carbon 2 because every Williamson ether synthesis destroys all stereogenic centres in the alkyl fragment
ⓒ. Route P gives phenol as the only organic product because sodium phenoxide cannot form a carbon–oxygen bond with a primary alkyl bromide
ⓓ. Route P is suitable; the ether bond forms at the primary carbon while the spatial arrangement at the separate stereogenic carbon 2 is retained
Correct Answer: Route P is suitable; the ether bond forms at the primary carbon while the spatial arrangement at the separate stereogenic carbon 2 is retained
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the required ether linkage:}\)
The target contains a phenyl group joined through oxygen to a branched four-carbon chain.
Its structure is:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5OCH_2CH(CH_3)CH_2CH_3}
\]
The desired carbon–oxygen bond involves the primary carbon at the end of the alkyl chain.
\(\textbf{Follow the substrate preparation in P:}\)
The initial alcohol is:
\[
\mathrm{HOCH_2CH(CH_3)CH_2CH_3}
\]
Conversion of its terminal hydroxyl group into bromide produces:
\[
\mathrm{BrCH_2CH(CH_3)CH_2CH_3}
\]
The question specifies that carbon 2 retains its original spatial configuration during this step.
\(\textbf{Apply Williamson ether formation:}\)
Sodium phenoxide provides a nucleophilic oxygen atom.
The prepared primary alkyl bromide presents an accessible saturated reaction centre:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5O^-+BrCH_2CH(CH_3)CH_2CH_3
\rightarrow C_6H_5OCH_2CH(CH_3)CH_2CH_3+Br^-}
\]
The desired ether is obtained.
\(\textbf{Track the stereogenic carbon:}\)
Carbon 2 is bonded to hydrogen, methyl, ethyl and the terminal carbon-containing group.
The substitution occurs at carbon 1 rather than carbon 2.
No bond directly attached to the stereogenic carbon is changed under the stated conditions.
Therefore, its spatial arrangement is retained.
\(\textbf{Evaluate Route Q:}\)
The sodium alkoxide derived from the original alcohol is a suitable nucleophile.
However, bromobenzene contains bromine attached directly to an aromatic carbon.
Unactivated bromobenzene does not undergo the ordinary saturated-carbon backside displacement required by a conventional Williamson synthesis.
Therefore, Route Q is not an appropriate ordinary Williamson approach.
\(\textbf{Distinguish ring-bound and side-chain halogens:}\)
Bromine in the Route-P alkyl bromide is attached to a primary \(sp^3\)-hybridised carbon.
Bromine in Route Q is attached directly to an aromatic \(sp^2\)-hybridised carbon.
The same leaving halogen consequently appears in chemically different reaction environments.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The preferred ether synthesis places the leaving group on an accessible alkyl carbon and the nucleophilic oxygen on phenoxide.
Route P forms the desired ether without requiring substitution at the separate stereogenic carbon.
434. 1-Bromo-2-fluoroethane, \(\mathrm{BrCH_2CH_2F}\), undergoes two alternative carbon-chain extension sequences.
Route P: Substitution with alcoholic KCN, followed by complete acidic hydrolysis of the resulting nitrile.
Route Q: Selective magnesium insertion into the carbon–bromine bond using dry ether, followed by carbon dioxide and acidic hydrolysis.
Assume that the carbon–fluorine bond remains intact throughout both sequences and that no competing reactions occur.
Which statement correctly identifies the products?
ⓐ. P gives 3-fluoropropanoic acid, whereas Q gives 2-fluoropropanoic acid
ⓑ. Both give 2-fluoropropanoic acid because fluorine determines the carboxyl-group position
ⓒ. P gives 3-fluoropropanoic acid, whereas Q gives 2-fluoroethanoic acid
ⓓ. Both routes form 3-fluoropropanoic acid; its carboxyl carbon comes from cyanide in P and carbon dioxide in Q
Correct Answer: Both routes form 3-fluoropropanoic acid; its carboxyl carbon comes from cyanide in P and carbon dioxide in Q
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two carbon–halogen bonds:}\)
The substrate contains bromine and fluorine attached to separate saturated carbon atoms.
The question specifies selective transformation at the carbon–bromine bond.
The carbon–fluorine bond remains attached to the original terminal carbon.
\(\textbf{Route P — Introduce a nitrile carbon:}\)
Carbon-linked cyanide replaces bromide:
\[
\mathrm{BrCH_2CH_2F+CN^-
\rightarrow NCCH_2CH_2F+Br^-}
\]
The nitrile is 3-fluoropropanenitrile.
It contains the two original carbon atoms and one new carbon from cyanide.
\(\textbf{Hydrolyse the nitrile:}\)
Complete acidic hydrolysis converts the nitrile carbon into a carboxyl carbon:
\[
\mathrm{NCCH_2CH_2F
\xrightarrow{H_2O/H^+,\ \Delta}
HOOCCH_2CH_2F}
\]
The product is 3-fluoropropanoic acid.
Fluorine remains on carbon 3 when numbering begins at the carboxyl carbon.
\(\textbf{Route Q — Form the organomagnesium reagent:}\)
Selective magnesium insertion replaces the carbon–bromine bond by the corresponding carbon–magnesium bond:
\[
\mathrm{BrCH_2CH_2F+Mg
\xrightarrow{dry\ ether}
BrMgCH_2CH_2F}
\]
The carbon originally bearing bromine becomes the organomagnesium reaction centre.
\(\textbf{Introduce carbon dioxide:}\)
The reagent reacts with the electrophilic carbon of carbon dioxide:
\[
\mathrm{BrMgCH_2CH_2F+CO_2
\rightarrow BrMgOOCCH_2CH_2F}
\]
Acidic hydrolysis gives:
\[
\mathrm{HOOCCH_2CH_2F}
\]
This is again 3-fluoropropanoic acid.
\(\textbf{Compare the carbon sources:}\)
In P, the new carbon comes from the cyanide nucleophile and becomes the carboxyl carbon during nitrile hydrolysis.
In Q, the new carbon enters directly from carbon dioxide.
Both pathways preserve the original two-carbon fragment and terminal fluorine.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Different carbon–carbon bond-forming methods can converge on the same carboxylic acid.
Correct product prediction requires tracking the reaction centre, the source of the added carbon and the position of the retained halogen.
435. 1,4-Dibromobutane, \(\mathrm{Br(CH_2)_4Br}\), is treated separately with two nucleophilic reagent systems.
P: One equivalent of sodium sulphide, \(\mathrm{Na_2S}\), under controlled conditions favouring formation of one intramolecularly closed sulphur-containing product.
Q: Two equivalents of sodium ethoxide under conditions ensuring complete substitution of both carbon–bromine bonds without cyclisation.
Assume that the stated pathways are exclusive.
Which statement correctly compares the organic products?
ⓐ. P gives a five-membered cyclic sulphide containing four carbon atoms, whereas Q gives 1,4-diethoxybutane containing eight carbon atoms
ⓑ. P gives a four-membered cyclic sulphide, whereas Q gives tetrahydrofuran
ⓒ. P gives butane, whereas Q gives but-2-ene because both reagents remove the terminal bromine atoms
ⓓ. P and Q give the same five-membered cyclic ether because sulphur and oxygen become interchangeable during substitution
Correct Answer: P gives a five-membered cyclic sulphide containing four carbon atoms, whereas Q gives 1,4-diethoxybutane containing eight carbon atoms
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the bifunctional substrate:}\)
1,4-Dibromobutane contains a four-carbon chain with a primary carbon–bromine bond at each end.
Both terminal carbons are suitable electrophilic centres for appropriate nucleophilic displacement.
The products depend on the nucleophile's structure and the number of nucleophilic sites it provides.
\(\textbf{Analyse the sulphide reagent:}\)
Sulphide contains one sulphur atom capable of forming two carbon–sulphur bonds.
Under the specified conditions, it first becomes attached to one end of the carbon chain.
The sulphur-containing intermediate can then react with the remaining terminal carbon–bromine bond.
\(\textbf{Follow ring closure in P:}\)
The overall transformation is:
\[
\mathrm{Br(CH_2)_4Br+Na_2S
\rightarrow (CH_2)_4S+2NaBr}
\]
The product contains four carbon atoms and one sulphur atom in a ring.
Therefore, the ring has five members.
The compound is tetrahydrothiophene, also called thiolane.
\(\textbf{Analyse the ethoxide reagent:}\)
Each ethoxide ion contains one oxygen nucleophilic centre joined to an ethyl group.
It can replace one bromide at a terminal carbon.
Two equivalents are required for complete replacement of both bromine atoms under the stated pathway.
\(\textbf{Follow double substitution in Q:}\)
\[
\mathrm{Br(CH_2)_4Br+2C_2H_5O^-
\rightarrow C_2H_5O(CH_2)_4OC_2H_5+2Br^-}
\]
The product is 1,4-diethoxybutane.
It is an acyclic diether rather than a cyclic ether.
\(\textbf{Compare the carbon counts:}\)
P retains the four carbon atoms of the starting chain and introduces one sulphur atom.
Q retains the four starting carbons and introduces two ethyl groups.
Each ethyl group contributes two carbons, giving eight carbon atoms in the final diether.
\(\textbf{Identify the connectivity principle:}\)
A sulphide ion can connect two electrophilic sites through the same sulphur atom.
Two separate ethoxide ions introduce two independently attached alkoxy groups.
The difference in nucleophile connectivity, not merely its elemental identity, determines whether the product is cyclic or acyclic.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Both reactions replace the terminal bromine atoms, but their products differ in ring formation, heteroatom identity and carbon count.
The sulphide route gives a five-membered cyclic sulphide, while the ethoxide route gives an eight-carbon acyclic diether.
436. Equal-concentration samples of pure \((R)\)-2-bromobutane and pure \((S)\)-2-bromobutane are separately treated with the same achiral hydroxide reagent in the same achiral solvent at the same temperature.
Each reaction is experimentally verified to follow an exclusive \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) pathway, with no elimination or racemisation.
Which statement correctly compares the two experiments?
ⓐ. The \((R)\) substrate must react faster because its optical rotation has the opposite sign to that of the \((S)\) substrate
ⓑ. The enantiomers have equal intrinsic rate constants in the stated achiral environment and form alcohol products of opposite absolute configurations
ⓒ. The \((S)\) substrate must react faster because backside attack is possible only on the \((S)\) configuration
ⓓ. Both substrates produce the same absolute configuration of butan-2-ol because hydroxide replaces the same leaving group in each
Correct Answer: The enantiomers have equal intrinsic rate constants in the stated achiral environment and form alcohol products of opposite absolute configurations
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the relationship between the substrates:}\)
The two samples contain enantiomers of 2-bromobutane.
They are non-superimposable mirror images with the same molecular formula and connectivity.
Their corresponding ordinary physical properties are identical in an achiral environment.
\(\textbf{Identify the reaction mechanism:}\)
The stipulated substitution is \(S_\mathrm{N}2\).
Hydroxide attacks the carbon bearing bromine from the side opposite the leaving group.
Each event produces geometrical inversion at the stereogenic centre.
\(\textbf{Compare the relevant energy pathways:}\)
An achiral reagent and achiral solvent do not distinguish the two mirror-image substrates through a chiral interaction.
The corresponding transition-state arrangements are related as mirror images.
Their energies are therefore equal under the specified conditions.
\(\textbf{Predict the intrinsic rate constants:}\)
Equal activation barriers under identical temperature and medium conditions give equal intrinsic rate constants for the two enantiomeric reactions.
At equal substrate and hydroxide concentrations, their initial substitution rates are therefore equal.
A difference in optical-rotation sign does not create a kinetic preference.
\(\textbf{Follow the stereochemical outcome from the }(R)\textbf{ substrate:}\)
The \((R)\)-bromide undergoes backside substitution.
Its product has the inverted spatial arrangement.
For this bromide-to-alcohol transformation, the CIP priority ordering remains corresponding, so the product is \((S)\)-butan-2-ol.
\(\textbf{Follow the outcome from the }(S)\textbf{ substrate:}\)
The \((S)\)-bromide undergoes the mirror-image substitution pathway.
Inversion produces \((R)\)-butan-2-ol.
The two product molecules are enantiomers.
\(\textbf{Distinguish kinetics from stereochemical outcome:}\)
Equal reaction rates do not imply identical absolute product configurations.
Conversely, different product configurations do not require different activation barriers.
The two experiments remain mirror-related because every specified reagent and environmental factor is achiral.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Enantiomeric substrates react at equal rates with an achiral reagent in an achiral environment under corresponding pathways.
Their stereospecific substitution products nevertheless have opposite absolute configurations.
437. Cyclohexene undergoes two independent bromination reactions.
P: Addition of one molecule of bromine in a suitable inert solvent under conditions producing anti addition across the double bond.
Q: Addition of HBr under ordinary ionic conditions, giving the expected saturated monobromide.
Assume achiral starting materials and reagents, and no competing reactions.
Which statement correctly compares the stereochemical nature of the products?
ⓐ. P forms only cis-1,2-dibromocyclohexane, whereas Q forms an enantiomeric pair of bromocyclohexane
ⓑ. Both produce an enantiomeric pair because every carbon–bromine bond creates a stereogenic centre
ⓒ. P can form a racemic pair of trans-1,2-dibromocyclohexane, whereas Q gives achiral bromocyclohexane
ⓓ. P forms only meso-trans-1,2-dibromocyclohexane, whereas Q gives optically pure bromocyclohexane
Correct Answer: P can form a racemic pair of trans-1,2-dibromocyclohexane, whereas Q gives achiral bromocyclohexane
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the unsaturated starting ring:}\)
Cyclohexene contains a double bond between two adjacent ring carbons.
Its starting structure is achiral under the stated conditions.
Both reaction pathways convert the double bond into a saturated carbon–carbon single bond.
However, they introduce different substituent arrangements.
\(\textbf{Analyse bromine addition in P:}\)
Electrophilic bromination proceeds through an appropriate bromonium-ion pathway.
Backside attack opens the intermediate, producing anti addition.
The two bromine atoms become attached to opposite faces of the original double-bonded carbons.
\(\textbf{Determine the relative ring configuration:}\)
The product contains bromine atoms at carbons 1 and 2.
Because they lie on opposite faces of the cyclohexane ring, the substitution pattern is trans.
Therefore, P produces trans-1,2-dibromocyclohexane.
\(\textbf{Examine absolute stereochemistry:}\)
The two bromine-bearing carbons are stereogenic.
The trans product has mirror-image configurations that are not superimposable.
Under achiral conditions, addition can occur from either enantiotopic face of the original alkene.
The enantiomeric products can therefore form in equal amounts, producing a racemic mixture.
\(\textbf{Analyse HBr addition in Q:}\)
Cyclohexene has equivalent double-bonded positions before addition.
Ordinary HBr addition introduces one bromine atom and one additional hydrogen atom.
The product is bromocyclohexane.
\(\textbf{Check bromocyclohexane for chirality:}\)
The bromine-bearing ring carbon is attached to bromine, hydrogen and two ring paths.
In otherwise unsubstituted bromocyclohexane, the two ring paths are equivalent.
That carbon therefore lacks four different substituents.
The product is achiral.
\(\textbf{Distinguish addition stereochemistry from product stereogenicity:}\)
Anti addition determines the relative faces occupied by the two bromine atoms in P.
Introduction of only one bromine atom in Q does not create an equivalent pair of stereogenic centres.
The stereochemical properties depend on the complete product structure rather than on the presence of bromine alone.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The same alkene can produce a racemic vicinal dibromide through anti addition or an achiral monobromide through hydrohalogenation.
The different stereochemical outcomes follow from the substituents introduced and the symmetry of the resulting ring.
438. 4-Bromobutan-1-ol, \(\mathrm{HO(CH_2)_4Br}\), is treated with a suitable base that converts its hydroxyl group into an alkoxide.
Two competing pathways are considered:
P: Intramolecular displacement of bromide by the alkoxide group of the same molecule, forming tetrahydrofuran.
Q: Intermolecular displacement in which the alkoxide of one molecule attacks the bromine-bearing carbon of a second molecule, initiating formation of a longer-chain ether.
Assume that the relative intrinsic rate constants do not change when the reaction mixture is diluted, and that both pathways remain kinetically accessible.
Which statement correctly predicts the effect of dilution on the relative importance of the two pathways?
ⓐ. Dilution must favour Q because intermolecular substitution becomes faster when fewer molecules are present
ⓑ. Dilution must suppress P because intramolecular substitution requires the simultaneous collision of two substrate molecules
ⓒ. Dilution cannot affect the relative pathways because both use the same type of carbon–bromine bond
ⓓ. Dilution favours unimolecular intramolecular closure P over intermolecular ether formation Q
Correct Answer: Dilution favours unimolecular intramolecular closure P over intermolecular ether formation Q
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the bifunctional substrate:}\)
4-Bromobutan-1-ol contains a hydroxyl group and a primary carbon–bromine bond within the same molecule.
Formation of an alkoxide makes the oxygen atom nucleophilic.
The molecule can therefore participate in either intramolecular or intermolecular ether formation.
\(\textbf{Examine the intramolecular pathway:}\)
The alkoxide oxygen can attack the terminal carbon bearing bromine within its own carbon chain.
This closes a five-membered ring containing four carbon atoms and one oxygen atom.
The product is tetrahydrofuran.
Once the appropriate reactive molecule is formed, no second organic molecule is required for the bond-forming event.
\(\textbf{Represent the intramolecular rate dependence:}\)
Under the simplified kinetic model, the ring-closure contribution can be expressed as:
\[
r_P=k_P[\mathrm{M}]
\]
Here, \([\mathrm{M}]\) represents the concentration of the reactive bifunctional alkoxide-containing molecules.
\(\textbf{Examine the intermolecular pathway:}\)
The alkoxide of one molecule can attack the carbon–bromine bond of another molecule.
This forms a carbon–oxygen bond between two originally separate organic molecules.
Further reactions can produce longer ether-containing chains.
\(\textbf{Represent the intermolecular rate dependence:}\)
For the stipulated elementary bimolecular encounter:
\[
r_Q=k_Q[\mathrm{M}]^2
\]
This simplified expression captures the dependence on the concentrations of two reacting organic molecules.
\(\textbf{Compare the pathways under dilution:}\)
The rate ratio is:
\[
\frac{r_P}{r_Q}
=\frac{k_P[\mathrm{M}]}{k_Q[\mathrm{M}]^2}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\frac{r_P}{r_Q}
=\frac{k_P}{k_Q[\mathrm{M}]}
\]
As \([\mathrm{M}]\) decreases, the ratio of intramolecular to intermolecular reaction increases, provided the stated rate constants remain unchanged.
\(\textbf{Interpret the practical consequence:}\)
Dilute conditions can therefore make intramolecular ring closure relatively more competitive than intermolecular chain extension.
This does not prove that cyclisation is quantitative or that all competing processes disappear.
Ring strain, conformational accessibility and reaction conditions also affect the actual outcome.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The distinction between a one-molecule bond-forming event and a two-molecule encounter explains the concentration effect.
Dilution can favour tetrahydrofuran formation relative to intermolecular ether formation.
439. An optically active sample of \((R)\)-2-bromobutane is divided into two portions.
P: Reaction with silver ethanoate, \(\mathrm{CH_3COOAg}\), under conditions favouring nucleophilic substitution.
Q: Reaction with sodium ethoxide under conditions favouring nucleophilic substitution rather than elimination.
The products are subsequently subjected to ordinary alkaline hydrolysis conditions suitable for cleaving an ester.
Assume that the initial substitutions occur at carbon 2 and that no rearrangement or racemisation occurs.
Which statement correctly distinguishes the organic products and their subsequent behaviour?
ⓐ. P gives an ether that is readily hydrolysed to butan-2-ol, whereas Q gives an ester that resists hydrolysis
ⓑ. Both initially give ethoxybutane because ethanoate and ethoxide form identical carbon–oxygen linkages
ⓒ. P initially gives butan-2-ol, whereas Q initially gives butyl ethanoate
ⓓ. P gives butan-2-yl ethanoate, hydrolysable to butan-2-ol; Q gives 2-ethoxybutane, not subject to ordinary ester hydrolysis
Correct Answer: P gives butan-2-yl ethanoate, hydrolysable to butan-2-ol; Q gives 2-ethoxybutane, not subject to ordinary ester hydrolysis
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the substrate and two nucleophiles:}\)
2-Bromobutane contains bromine attached to a secondary saturated carbon.
Both ethanoate and ethoxide can act as oxygen-centred nucleophiles under suitable conditions.
However, the structures of the groups they introduce are different.
\(\textbf{Determine the product in P:}\)
Ethanoate contains the group \(\mathrm{CH_3COO^-}\).
Substitution introduces an ethanoate ester linkage:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH(Br)CH_2CH_3+CH_3COO^-
\rightarrow CH_3COOCH(CH_3)CH_2CH_3+Br^-}
\]
The product is butan-2-yl ethanoate.
Its oxygen-containing group includes a carbonyl carbon.
\(\textbf{Determine the product in Q:}\)
Ethoxide contains the group \(\mathrm{C_2H_5O^-}\).
Its substitution gives:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH(Br)CH_2CH_3+C_2H_5O^-
\rightarrow CH_3CH(OC_2H_5)CH_2CH_3+Br^-}
\]
The product is 2-ethoxybutane.
It is an ether rather than an ester.
\(\textbf{Evaluate subsequent hydrolysis of P:}\)
An ester can undergo alkaline hydrolysis to form an alcohol and a carboxylate salt.
For the ester produced in P:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3COOCH(CH_3)CH_2CH_3+OH^-
\rightarrow CH_3COO^-+CH_3CH(OH)CH_2CH_3}
\]
The alcohol formed is butan-2-ol.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the ether from Q:}\)
2-Ethoxybutane contains an ether linkage but no ester carbonyl group.
It does not undergo the ordinary alkaline ester-hydrolysis reaction described for P.
Therefore, the same subsequent treatment does not provide an equivalent conversion to butan-2-ol.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the initial stereochemistry from functional-group behaviour:}\)
The original stereogenic carbon remains identifiable in both initial substitution products.
The question specifies conditions excluding racemisation and other competing pathways.
However, the crucial difference in the requested comparison is whether the introduced group is an ester or an ether.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Two oxygen-centred nucleophiles can substitute the same carbon–bromine bond while introducing functional groups with different subsequent reactions.
The ethanoate product is hydrolysable as an ester, whereas the ethoxide product is an ether.
440. An initially pure meso sample of 2,3-dibromobutane is subjected to two controlled nucleophilic-substitution experiments.
P: Exactly one bromine atom is replaced by hydroxyl through an exclusive backside \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) event.
Q: Both bromine atoms are replaced by hydroxyl, each through an exclusive backside \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) event at its own stereogenic carbon.
Assume achiral reaction conditions, equal accessibility of symmetry-related sites, no elimination and no subsequent configurational change.
Which statement correctly compares the stereochemical possibilities?
ⓐ. P can give an enantiomeric pair of bromohydrins, whereas Q gives meso-butane-2,3-diol through inversion at both original stereogenic centres
ⓑ. P gives only an achiral bromohydrin, whereas Q necessarily gives an enantiomeric pair of diols
ⓒ. Both give only meso products because the starting material possesses an internal plane of symmetry
ⓓ. P and Q necessarily give the same constitutional product because substitution does not alter the carbon skeleton
Correct Answer: P can give an enantiomeric pair of bromohydrins, whereas Q gives meso-butane-2,3-diol through inversion at both original stereogenic centres
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the starting stereochemistry:}\)
Meso-2,3-dibromobutane contains two stereogenic carbons.
Their opposite configurations give a molecule with internal symmetry.
Consequently, the starting material is achiral despite possessing stereogenic centres.
\(\textbf{Follow single substitution in P:}\)
Hydroxide can replace bromine at either of the two symmetry-related positions.
The attacking nucleophile approaches from the side opposite the leaving bromide.
Only the attacked stereogenic centre undergoes geometrical inversion.
\(\textbf{Identify the product connectivity in P:}\)
The substitution product has the structure:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH(OH)CH(Br)CH_3}
\]
It is 3-bromobutan-2-ol.
The original symmetry is lost because the two adjacent substituted carbons now bear different functional groups.
\(\textbf{Determine the stereochemical possibilities in P:}\)
Attack at one original bromine-bearing centre produces one chiral bromohydrin configuration.
Attack at the symmetry-related centre produces its mirror image after consistent numbering.
Under the stipulated achiral conditions, the two products can form in equal amounts.
Therefore, P can give a racemic pair.
\(\textbf{Follow double substitution in Q:}\)
Both bromine-bearing carbons undergo backside displacement.
Each centre experiences one geometrical inversion.
The product has the structure:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH(OH)CH(OH)CH_3}
\]
This is butane-2,3-diol.
\(\textbf{Determine the relative configurations after double inversion:}\)
Inverting both original stereogenic centres preserves their opposite relationship.
The resulting diol possesses an internal symmetry relationship corresponding to its meso configuration.
It is therefore achiral.
\(\textbf{Distinguish one-centre and two-centre transformations:}\)
In P, inversion at only one of the original symmetry-related centres removes the internal symmetry.
In Q, inversion at both centres restores a relationship permitting internal compensation.
The stereochemical result depends on which centres react, not simply on the chirality of the starting molecule.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
A meso substrate can produce a racemic mixture after selective reaction at one of two equivalent stereogenic centres.
Appropriate stereospecific substitution at both centres can instead yield another meso compound.
441. An alkene has the structure \(\mathrm{CH_3CH{=}C(Br)Cl}\).
It is subjected to selective catalytic hydrogenation under conditions that saturate only the carbon–carbon double bond while retaining both carbon–halogen bonds.
Assume the alkene and catalyst are achiral and hydrogen can be delivered to either face of the double bond without an enantioselective preference.
Which statement correctly compares the starting compound and the hydrogenation product?
ⓐ. The starting alkene is necessarily achiral and has no geometrical isomers; the product is also achiral
ⓑ. The starting alkene can exhibit E/Z isomerism, while the product is 1-bromo-1-chloropropane containing a stereogenic carbon and can form as a racemic mixture
ⓒ. The starting alkene can exhibit E/Z isomerism, but hydrogenation necessarily converts both halogens into hydrogen atoms
ⓓ. The hydrogenation product is 1-bromo-2-chloropropane because bromine and chlorine must migrate to different carbons
Correct Answer: The starting alkene can exhibit E/Z isomerism, while the product is 1-bromo-1-chloropropane containing a stereogenic carbon and can form as a racemic mixture
Explanation: \(\textbf{Examine the starting double bond:}\)
The left double-bond carbon is attached to hydrogen and methyl.
The right double-bond carbon is attached to bromine and chlorine.
Each double-bond carbon therefore has two different substituents.
Consequently, the starting alkene can possess E/Z geometrical isomers.
\(\textbf{Apply the stipulated hydrogenation:}\)
Hydrogen is added across the carbon–carbon double bond.
The original double-bond carbons become saturated.
The carbon–bromine and carbon–chlorine bonds are explicitly retained.
\(\textbf{Determine the product structure:}\)
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH{=}C(Br)Cl+H_2
\rightarrow CH_3CH_2CH(Br)Cl}
\]
The organic product is 1-bromo-1-chloropropane.
Both halogens remain attached to the same terminal carbon.
\(\textbf{Check the terminal carbon for stereogenicity:}\)
After hydrogenation, the carbon bearing the halogens is bonded to bromine, chlorine, hydrogen and ethyl.
All four substituents are different.
Therefore, that saturated carbon is stereogenic.
\(\textbf{Identify the change in stereochemical classification:}\)
The original molecule can have E/Z isomerism around its carbon–carbon double bond.
Hydrogenation removes that double bond.
The product no longer has the same E/Z stereochemical feature but can possess optical isomers through its newly formed stereogenic carbon.
\(\textbf{Consider the achiral reaction environment:}\)
The question specifies no enantioselective preference.
Addition leading to opposite configurations of the product can therefore occur.
The product can consequently form as a racemic mixture.
\(\textbf{Distinguish hydrogenation from dehalogenation:}\)
Saturating a carbon–carbon double bond does not logically require cleavage of every carbon–halogen bond.
The specified selective conditions exclude such cleavage.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
A reaction may remove one source of stereoisomerism while creating another.
Here, double-bond hydrogenation converts a geometrically isomeric haloalkene into a potentially optically active saturated geminal dihalide.
442. Toluene is subjected to two controlled photochemical chlorination experiments.
P: Exactly one benzylic hydrogen is replaced by chlorine.
Q: Exactly two benzylic hydrogens on the same methyl group are replaced successively by chlorine.
The isolated products are separately hydrolysed under conditions appropriate for their carbon–chlorine bonding environments.
Assume that no aromatic-ring chlorination, oxidation or competing reaction occurs.
Which pair correctly identifies the principal hydrolysis products?
ⓐ. P: Phenol; Q: benzoic acid
ⓑ. P: Benzaldehyde; Q: benzyl alcohol
ⓒ. P: Benzyl alcohol; Q: benzaldehyde
ⓓ. P: Benzyl alcohol; Q: benzoic acid
Correct Answer: P: Benzyl alcohol; Q: benzaldehyde
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the reaction site during photochemical chlorination:}\)
Toluene contains a methyl group attached to an aromatic ring.
Under suitable ultraviolet irradiation, free-radical chlorination can replace hydrogen atoms at the benzylic carbon.
The problem specifies that no chlorine is introduced directly onto the aromatic ring.
\(\textbf{Follow the first chlorination in P:}\)
Replacement of one benzylic hydrogen gives:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH_3+Cl_2
\xrightarrow{h\nu}
C_6H_5CH_2Cl+HCl}
\]
The organic product is benzyl chloride.
Its chlorine-bearing carbon remains a saturated primary benzylic carbon.
\(\textbf{Hydrolyse the product from P:}\)
Suitable nucleophilic substitution replaces chlorine with hydroxyl:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH_2Cl+OH^-
\rightarrow C_6H_5CH_2OH+Cl^-}
\]
The product is benzyl alcohol.
The hydroxyl group is attached to a saturated carbon adjacent to the benzene ring.
\(\textbf{Follow double chlorination in Q:}\)
Successive replacement of two benzylic hydrogen atoms gives:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH_3+2Cl_2
\xrightarrow{h\nu}
C_6H_5CHCl_2+2HCl}
\]
The product is benzal chloride.
Both chlorine atoms are attached to the same benzylic carbon.
\(\textbf{Determine the hydrolysis consequence:}\)
Hydrolysis of the two carbon–chlorine bonds formally introduces two hydroxyl groups at that carbon.
The corresponding geminal diol is:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH(OH)_2}
\]
It is associated with the stable carbonyl compound benzaldehyde.
Therefore, the intended final product is:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CHO}
\]
\(\textbf{Distinguish the oxidation states of the final products:}\)
Benzyl alcohol contains the group \(\mathrm{-CH_2OH}\).
Benzaldehyde contains the group \(\mathrm{-CHO}\).
The number of chlorine substitutions at the benzylic carbon determines which oxygen-containing functional group is obtained after the stipulated hydrolysis.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Controlled monochlorination gives a benzylic monohalide that hydrolyses to an alcohol.
Controlled dichlorination gives a geminal dihalide that hydrolyses to an aldehyde.
443. Two primary alkyl bromides, P and Q, react independently with the same nucleophile in one solution under conditions where both follow elementary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) substitution.
The experimentally determined rate constants are:
\[
k_P=0.120\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}\,min^{-1}}
\]
\[
k_Q=0.0400\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}\,min^{-1}}
\]
Initially:
\[
[P]=0.0200\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}
\]
\[
[Q]=0.100\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}
\]
The nucleophile concentration is the same for both reactions.
Which statement correctly identifies the faster initial product-forming pathway and the concentration of P that would make both initial reaction rates equal, with Q unchanged?
ⓐ. P is initially faster; equality requires \([P]=0.0333\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\)
ⓑ. Q is initially faster; equality requires \([P]=0.0333\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\)
ⓒ. Q is initially faster; equality requires \([P]=0.300\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\)
ⓓ. P is initially faster; equality requires \([P]=0.300\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\)
Correct Answer: Q is initially faster; equality requires \([P]=0.0333\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the competition between intrinsic and concentration effects:}\)
The rate constant for P is three times the rate constant for Q.
However, Q is initially present at a concentration five times that of P.
A larger rate constant does not automatically imply the greater observed reaction rate when reactant concentrations differ.
\(\textbf{Write the two elementary rate laws:}\)
\[
r_P=k_P[P][\mathrm{Nu^-}]
\]
\[
r_Q=k_Q[Q][\mathrm{Nu^-}]
\]
Because both reactions occur in the same solution, the nucleophile concentration is common to the comparison.
\(\textbf{Calculate the initial rate contributions:}\)
For P:
\[
\frac{r_P}{[\mathrm{Nu^-}]}=k_P[P]
\]
\[
\frac{r_P}{[\mathrm{Nu^-}]}=(0.120)(0.0200)
\]
\[
\frac{r_P}{[\mathrm{Nu^-}]}=0.00240\ \mathrm{min^{-1}}
\]
For Q:
\[
\frac{r_Q}{[\mathrm{Nu^-}]}=k_Q[Q]
\]
\[
\frac{r_Q}{[\mathrm{Nu^-}]}=(0.0400)(0.100)
\]
\[
\frac{r_Q}{[\mathrm{Nu^-}]}=0.00400\ \mathrm{min^{-1}}
\]
Therefore, Q has the greater initial rate of product formation.
\(\textbf{Determine the equality condition:}\)
For equal initial rates:
\[
k_P[P]_{\mathrm{equal}}[\mathrm{Nu^-}]
=k_Q[Q][\mathrm{Nu^-}]
\]
Cancel the common nucleophile concentration:
\[
k_P[P]_{\mathrm{equal}}=k_Q[Q]
\]
\[
[P]_{\mathrm{equal}}=\frac{k_Q[Q]}{k_P}
\]
Substitute:
\[
[P]_{\mathrm{equal}}=\frac{(0.0400)(0.100)}{0.120}
\]
\[
[P]_{\mathrm{equal}}=0.03333\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Interpret the result:}\)
Increasing P from \(0.0200\) to approximately \(0.0333\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\) compensates for its smaller initial concentration.
The rate constants remain unchanged because the reaction conditions are stipulated to be identical.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Intrinsic reactivity and actual reaction rate are related but different quantities.
The initially more concentrated substrate Q reacts faster overall, even though P has the larger elementary rate constant.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\text{Initially Q is faster};\quad
[P]_{\mathrm{equal}}=0.0333\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}
\]
444. Two positional isomers of trichlorobenzene are compared:
P: 1,3,5-Trichlorobenzene.
Q: 1,2,3-Trichlorobenzene.
Assume planar benzene rings and use a simplified bond-dipole model in which each aromatic carbon–chlorine bond contributes an equal vector directed radially towards chlorine.
Each isomer is also subjected to controlled electrophilic mononitration.
Only constitutionally distinct mononitro products are counted, irrespective of their relative yields.
Which statement correctly combines the molecular-dipole and product-count comparisons?
ⓐ. P has a zero resultant bond-dipole vector and one constitutional mononitro product; Q has a non-zero resultant and two constitutional mononitro products
ⓑ. Both have zero resultant bond-dipole vectors and one mononitro product because each contains three chlorine atoms
ⓒ. P has a non-zero resultant and two mononitro products; Q has a zero resultant and one
ⓓ. Both have non-zero resultant bond-dipole vectors and three constitutional mononitro products because three hydrogens remain in each molecule
Correct Answer: P has a zero resultant bond-dipole vector and one constitutional mononitro product; Q has a non-zero resultant and two constitutional mononitro products
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two substitution patterns:}\)
Both compounds have the formula \(\mathrm{C_6H_3Cl_3}\).
They contain equal numbers of aromatic carbon–chlorine bonds.
However, the positions of those bonds around the ring differ.
\(\textbf{Examine the bond-dipole arrangement in P:}\)
The chlorine atoms occupy alternating ring positions 1, 3 and 5.
In the supplied radial-vector model, their bond-dipole contributions are separated by equal angular intervals of \(120^\circ\).
Three equal planar vectors arranged in this way cancel.
Therefore, P has zero resultant molecular dipole moment in the stipulated model.
\(\textbf{Examine the bond-dipole arrangement in Q:}\)
The chlorine atoms occupy adjacent positions 1, 2 and 3.
Their dipole directions are not spaced symmetrically around the complete ring.
The vector contributions do not cancel.
Therefore, Q has a non-zero resultant in the specified approximation.
\(\textbf{Count available nitration positions in P:}\)
The unsubstituted ring positions in P are 2, 4 and 6.
These positions are equivalent by the symmetry of 1,3,5-trichlorobenzene.
Substitution of any one hydrogen by a nitro group therefore gives the same constitutional mononitro product.
P contributes one product.
\(\textbf{Count available nitration positions in Q:}\)
The vacant ring positions in Q are 4, 5 and 6.
Positions 4 and 6 are equivalent through the symmetry relating the two ends of the 1,2,3-trichloro substitution pattern.
Position 5 is not equivalent to either.
Therefore, Q permits two constitutionally distinct mononitro products.
\(\textbf{Distinguish counting from selectivity:}\)
The number of constitutionally possible products depends on symmetry.
The relative quantities formed additionally depend on electronic directing effects and steric factors.
The question does not require their experimental proportions.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The same substitution pattern that produces a symmetric cancellation of bond-dipole vectors in P also makes its available aromatic hydrogen positions equivalent.
Q has less symmetry, a non-zero dipole resultant and two distinct mononitration positions.
445. 1-Bromo-2-chloroethane, \(\mathrm{BrCH_2CH_2Cl}\), undergoes complete halogen exchange using an excess of suitable silver fluoride under conditions that replace both original halogens by fluorine.
Each displaced bromine atom precipitates as AgBr, and each displaced chlorine atom precipitates as AgCl.
A \(0.0800\ \mathrm{mol}\) sample is treated quantitatively.
Use:
\[
M(\mathrm{AgBr})=187.8\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\[
M(\mathrm{AgCl})=143.5\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Which statement correctly identifies the organic product and the combined mass of silver halide precipitates?
ⓐ. 1-Bromo-2-fluoroethane; \(11.48\ \mathrm{g}\)
ⓑ. 1,2-Difluoroethane; \(11.48\ \mathrm{g}\)
ⓒ. 1,2-Difluoroethane; \(26.50\ \mathrm{g}\)
ⓓ. 1,2-Dichloroethane; \(26.50\ \mathrm{g}\)
Correct Answer: 1,2-Difluoroethane; \(26.50\ \mathrm{g}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify both leaving halogens:}\)
Each starting molecule contains one bromine and one chlorine atom attached to separate saturated carbon atoms.
The question specifies complete exchange of both halogens.
Therefore, the final organic product contains neither bromine nor chlorine.
\(\textbf{Write the idealised double exchange:}\)
\[
\mathrm{BrCH_2CH_2Cl+2AgF
\rightarrow FCH_2CH_2F+AgBr+AgCl}
\]
The organic product is 1,2-difluoroethane.
Two equivalents of silver fluoride are required per mole of starting compound.
\(\textbf{Establish precipitate stoichiometry:}\)
One mole of starting compound releases one mole of bromide and one mole of chloride.
Therefore:
\[
n(\mathrm{AgBr})=n(\mathrm{substrate})
\]
\[
n(\mathrm{AgCl})=n(\mathrm{substrate})
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the AgBr amount and mass:}\)
\[
n(\mathrm{AgBr})=0.0800\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\[
m(\mathrm{AgBr})=nM
\]
\[
m(\mathrm{AgBr})=(0.0800)(187.8)
\]
\[
m(\mathrm{AgBr})=15.024\ \mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the AgCl amount and mass:}\)
\[
n(\mathrm{AgCl})=0.0800\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\[
m(\mathrm{AgCl})=(0.0800)(143.5)
\]
\[
m(\mathrm{AgCl})=11.480\ \mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Combine both precipitate masses:}\)
\[
m_{\mathrm{total}}=15.024+11.480
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{total}}=26.504\ \mathrm{g}
\]
\[
m_{\mathrm{total}}\approx26.50\ \mathrm{g}
\]
\(\textbf{Check the atom accounting:}\)
Each starting molecule gives one formula unit of each silver halide.
Counting only AgCl would overlook the displacement of bromine.
Counting two moles of one silver halide would incorrectly treat the original halogens as identical.
\(\textbf{Interpret the preparation:}\)
The transformation is a Swarts-type fluorination because fluorine replaces other halogens in suitable organic substrates.
It differs from Finkelstein exchange, which ordinarily introduces iodine using an iodide reagent.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\mathrm{FCH_2CH_2F};\quad m_{\mathrm{AgBr+AgCl}}=26.50\ \mathrm{g}}
\]
446. Cyclohexyl chloride is subjected to two separate experiments.
P: Hydrolysis under conditions favouring substitution of chlorine by hydroxyl.
Q: Dehydrohalogenation with alcoholic KOH, followed by addition of bromine to the isolated unsaturated product in an inert solvent.
Assume complete intended transformations and no rearrangement.
Which statement correctly identifies the final organic products?
ⓐ. P gives phenol, while Q gives bromobenzene
ⓑ. P gives cyclohexanol, while Q gives 1,2-dibromocyclohexane
ⓒ. P gives cyclohexene, while Q gives chlorocyclohexanol
ⓓ. P gives cyclohexanol, while Q gives 1,1-dibromocyclohexane
Correct Answer: P gives cyclohexanol, while Q gives 1,2-dibromocyclohexane
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the substrate class:}\)
Cyclohexyl chloride contains chlorine bonded to a saturated ring carbon.
That carbon is secondary because it is attached to two neighbouring carbon atoms.
It is an alkyl chloride rather than an aryl chloride.
\(\textbf{Follow substitution in P:}\)
The specified hydrolysis replaces chlorine with hydroxyl:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_{11}Cl+OH^-
\rightarrow C_6H_{11}OH+Cl^-}
\]
The six-membered carbon ring remains saturated.
The product is cyclohexanol.
\(\textbf{Follow elimination in Q:}\)
Alcoholic KOH can promote beta-elimination under the stated conditions.
Loss of a beta-hydrogen and chloride forms a carbon–carbon double bond within the ring:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_{11}Cl
\xrightarrow{alc.\ KOH,\ \Delta}
C_6H_{10}}
\]
The product is cyclohexene.
\(\textbf{Identify the next reagent's reaction site:}\)
Cyclohexene contains a carbon–carbon double bond.
Molecular bromine can add across it under suitable conditions.
One bromine atom becomes attached to each original double-bond carbon.
\(\textbf{Predict the dibromide:}\)
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_{10}+Br_2
\rightarrow C_6H_{10}Br_2}
\]
The two bromine atoms occupy adjacent ring carbons.
The constitutional product is 1,2-dibromocyclohexane.
Under the usual bromonium-ion pathway, anti addition determines the relative stereochemical arrangement.
\(\textbf{Distinguish vicinal from geminal addition products:}\)
A geminal dibromide would have both bromine atoms attached to the same carbon.
Ordinary addition of bromine across an alkene double bond instead introduces one bromine atom at each carbon.
Therefore, the stated product is vicinal rather than geminal.
\(\textbf{Integrate the routes:}\)
P replaces a carbon–chlorine bond with a carbon–oxygen bond.
Q first creates a double bond by elimination and then converts that double bond into two carbon–bromine bonds.
The two routes therefore produce different functional-group arrangements from the same starting haloalkane.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Substitution and elimination are alternative reactions of a suitable secondary haloalkane.
The subsequent bromination step provides a structural test for the unsaturation produced in Q.
447. A student dissolves pure bromoethane in two different media.
P: A dry, chemically inert, non-conducting organic solvent in which bromoethane dissolves but does not undergo a chemical reaction.
Q: An aqueous medium containing hydroxide ions under conditions that produce complete substitution to ethanol.
The student then adds aqueous silver nitrate to suitably prepared samples from both experiments and records whether bromide ions are present.
Assume that no other bromide-containing reagents are used and that the analytical conditions prevent interference.
Which interpretation is most appropriate?
ⓐ. P must contain a high concentration of bromide ions because bromoethane has a polar carbon–bromine bond
ⓑ. Both samples must contain equal bromide-ion concentrations because both initially contain the same number of bromine atoms
ⓒ. P contains no molecular bromoethane because all covalent organic halides completely dissociate when dissolved
ⓓ. P need not contain free bromide ions, whereas Q can contain bromide released by chemical substitution; molecular bond polarity and ion formation must be distinguished
Correct Answer: P need not contain free bromide ions, whereas Q can contain bromide released by chemical substitution; molecular bond polarity and ion formation must be distinguished
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the bonding in bromoethane:}\)
Bromoethane contains a polar covalent carbon–bromine bond.
Carbon has partial positive charge, and bromine has partial negative charge.
These are partial charges associated with electron sharing rather than complete separation into free ions.
\(\textbf{Interpret dissolution in P:}\)
The question specifies that bromoethane dissolves without chemical reaction.
Ordinary dissolution of a covalent organic molecule in an inert solvent does not necessarily cleave its carbon–bromine bond.
Therefore, the presence of dissolved bromoethane does not establish a concentration of free bromide ions.
\(\textbf{Identify the chemical reaction in Q:}\)
Hydroxide attacks the saturated carbon bearing bromine:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2Br+OH^-
\rightarrow CH_3CH_2OH+Br^-}
\]
Bromine departs as bromide ion during the substitution.
The organic product is ethanol.
\(\textbf{Connect substitution to analytical evidence:}\)
Silver ions can react with bromide ions:
\[
\mathrm{Ag^++Br^-\rightarrow AgBr\downarrow}
\]
A silver bromide precipitate provides evidence of bromide ion under the specified analytical conditions.
The precipitate is associated with the halide released from the carbon–bromine bond.
\(\textbf{Distinguish atom conservation from ionic speciation:}\)
Both original samples contain bromine atoms in the same starting organic compound.
However, the chemical form of bromine changes in Q.
Atom conservation does not imply that bromine exists as free bromide ions in both samples.
\(\textbf{Interpret the mechanistic distinction:}\)
The reactive carbon centre of bromoethane is electrophilic because the carbon–bromine bond is polar.
A suitable nucleophile can displace bromide.
Nevertheless, electrophilic character does not mean that complete ionisation occurs before the nucleophile approaches.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
A polar covalent bond and a solution containing freely mobile ions are not equivalent.
P contains dissolved molecular bromoethane, while Q can contain bromide ions generated through nucleophilic substitution.
448. 1,1,2-Tribromopropane has the structure \(\mathrm{CHBr_2CHBrCH_3}\).
It undergoes two consecutive controlled reactions.
Stage I: Both bromine atoms on carbon 1 are hydrolysed under conditions favouring formation of the corresponding stable carbonyl compound, while the bromine attached to carbon 2 remains intact.
Stage II: The Stage-I product is treated with sodium iodide in dry acetone under conditions favouring exchange of its remaining saturated carbon–bromine bond.
Assume no competing reactions.
Which statement correctly identifies the Stage-I and Stage-II products?
ⓐ. Stage I gives 2-bromopropanal, and Stage II gives 2-iodopropanal
ⓑ. Stage I gives 1-bromopropan-2-one, and Stage II gives 1-iodopropan-2-one
ⓒ. Stage I gives 2-bromopropan-1-ol, and Stage II gives 2-iodopropan-1-ol
ⓓ. Stage I gives propanone, and Stage II gives 1-iodopropan-2-one
Correct Answer: Stage I gives 2-bromopropanal, and Stage II gives 2-iodopropanal
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two halogen-bearing environments:}\)
The starting compound has two bromine atoms attached to carbon 1.
This is a geminal dibromide arrangement.
The third bromine atom is attached to the adjacent carbon 2.
The question specifies selective hydrolysis of the geminal dibromide group first.
\(\textbf{Examine the geminal dibromide carbon:}\)
Carbon 1 bears two bromine atoms and one hydrogen.
Replacing both bromine atoms by hydroxyl formally produces:
\[
\mathrm{CH(OH)_2CHBrCH_3}
\]
This is a geminal diol at the terminal carbon.
\(\textbf{Identify the stable carbonyl product:}\)
A geminal diol derived from a terminal \(\mathrm{-CHBr_2}\) group corresponds to an aldehyde.
The stable carbonyl structure is:
\[
\mathrm{OHCCHBrCH_3}
\]
The product is 2-bromopropanal.
The remaining bromine is attached to carbon 2, adjacent to the aldehyde group.
\(\textbf{Follow the second-stage halogen exchange:}\)
Sodium iodide in dry acetone is suitable for halogen exchange at an accessible saturated carbon.
The remaining carbon–bromine bond can undergo the stipulated substitution:
\[
\mathrm{OHCCHBrCH_3+I^-
\rightarrow OHCCHICH_3+Br^-}
\]
The aldehyde functional group remains intact.
\(\textbf{Name the final product:}\)
The aldehyde carbon is carbon 1.
Iodine is attached to the adjacent carbon 2.
Therefore, the Stage-II product is 2-iodopropanal.
\(\textbf{Distinguish carbonyl formation from halogen exchange:}\)
Stage I changes the functional group at carbon 1 from a geminal dihalide to an aldehyde.
Stage II changes the halogen identity at carbon 2 without altering the carbonyl group.
These are different transformations occurring at different carbons.
\(\textbf{Check carbon conservation:}\)
The starting tribromide and both final organic products contain three carbon atoms.
No carbon–carbon bond is formed or broken.
The sequence changes functional groups and halogen identities while preserving the original chain.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Tracking the two geminal bromine atoms separately from the adjacent bromine identifies the carbonyl position correctly.
The products are 2-bromopropanal and 2-iodopropanal.
449. A compound contains an aromatic nitro group and a primary benzylic chlorine atom:
\[
\mathrm{3\!-\!O_2NC_6H_4CH_2Cl}
\]
Two sequences are considered.
P: Benzylic substitution using aqueous hydroxide under suitable conditions, followed by selective reduction of the aromatic nitro group to amino using an appropriate reducing reagent.
Q: Selective reduction of the nitro group to amino first, followed by nucleophilic substitution of the benzylic chlorine using aqueous hydroxide.
Assume that every stipulated transformation proceeds selectively and completely, and that no additional reactions occur.
Which statement correctly predicts the final organic products?
ⓐ. P gives 3-aminobenzyl alcohol, whereas Q gives 3-chloroaniline
ⓑ. P gives 3-nitrophenol, whereas Q gives 3-aminophenol
ⓒ. Both give 3-aminobenzyl alcohol because the two transformations act at different functional groups
ⓓ. Both give 3-aminophenol because benzylic substitution necessarily transfers hydroxyl directly onto the aromatic ring
Correct Answer: Both give 3-aminobenzyl alcohol because the two transformations act at different functional groups
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two functional-group locations:}\)
The nitro group is attached directly to the aromatic ring.
The chlorine atom is attached to a saturated benzylic methylene carbon.
The two functional groups occupy different reaction centres.
\(\textbf{Follow the first step in P:}\)
Hydroxide replaces chlorine at the benzylic carbon:
\[
\mathrm{3\!-\!O_2NC_6H_4CH_2Cl+OH^-
\rightarrow3\!-\!O_2NC_6H_4CH_2OH+Cl^-}
\]
The product is 3-nitrobenzyl alcohol.
The nitro group remains attached to the aromatic ring.
\(\textbf{Follow reduction in P:}\)
The stipulated selective reduction converts the aromatic nitro group into an amino group.
The benzylic hydroxyl group remains unchanged.
The final product is:
\[
\mathrm{3\!-\!H_2NC_6H_4CH_2OH}
\]
This is 3-aminobenzyl alcohol.
\(\textbf{Follow the first step in Q:}\)
Reducing the original nitro group gives:
\[
\mathrm{3\!-\!H_2NC_6H_4CH_2Cl}
\]
The compound is 3-aminobenzyl chloride.
The carbon–chlorine bond remains attached to the saturated benzylic carbon.
\(\textbf{Follow hydroxide substitution in Q:}\)
The subsequently added hydroxide replaces benzylic chlorine:
\[
\mathrm{3\!-\!H_2NC_6H_4CH_2Cl+OH^-
\rightarrow3\!-\!H_2NC_6H_4CH_2OH+Cl^-}
\]
The same 3-aminobenzyl alcohol product results.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the benzylic substitution from aromatic substitution:}\)
The hydroxyl group is introduced onto the external methylene carbon.
It does not become directly attached to the aromatic ring.
Consequently, the product is a benzylic alcohol rather than an aminophenol.
\(\textbf{Interpret the sequence independence:}\)
The question explicitly stipulates complete selectivity.
Under those assumptions, nitro reduction and benzylic chlorine substitution can be performed in either order.
The transformations do not require the same reactive site.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Reaction order can sometimes determine the outcome of multistep organic synthesis.
In this controlled example, however, two selective transformations at different functional groups converge on the same product.
450. Two unsaturated organic halides are compared:
P: Vinyl fluoride, \(\mathrm{CH_2{=}CHF}\).
Q: 4-Nitrofluorobenzene, \(\mathrm{4\!-\!O_2NC_6H_4F}\).
Each is treated separately with sodium methoxide under conditions suitable for aromatic nucleophilic substitution where activation is present.
Assume that addition across the carbon–carbon double bond of P is excluded and that no photochemical or radical reactions occur.
Which statement best explains their differing behaviour towards replacement of fluorine?
ⓐ. P must react faster because its carbon–fluorine bond is attached to a smaller molecular skeleton
ⓑ. Q permits nitro-activated aromatic addition–elimination; P lacks both this activation and a saturated \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) reaction centre
ⓒ. Both must undergo ordinary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) substitution because their carbon–fluorine bonds are polar
ⓓ. Neither can react because a carbon–fluorine bond is always incapable of nucleophilic replacement
Correct Answer: Q permits nitro-activated aromatic addition–elimination; P lacks both this activation and a saturated \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) reaction centre
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the shared structural feature:}\)
Both compounds contain fluorine bonded directly to an \(sp^2\)-hybridised carbon.
Therefore, neither is an ordinary alkyl fluoride with fluorine attached to a saturated \(sp^3\)-hybridised carbon.
However, the surrounding carbon frameworks differ.
\(\textbf{Examine P:}\)
Vinyl fluoride contains fluorine attached directly to a carbon–carbon double bond.
Its carbon–fluorine bond has a vinylic bonding environment.
Ordinary backside nucleophilic displacement at that carbon is highly unfavourable.
\(\textbf{Identify the missing activation in P:}\)
P contains no aromatic ring.
It also lacks the nitro-substituted aromatic system needed for the activated addition–elimination pathway described for Q.
The problem excludes alternative double-bond addition and radical chemistry.
Therefore, the intended substitution is not favoured for P.
\(\textbf{Examine Q:}\)
4-Nitrofluorobenzene contains fluorine directly attached to an aromatic ring.
The nitro group is para to the fluorine-bearing carbon.
Its strongly electron-withdrawing effect can stabilise the negatively charged addition intermediate formed during suitable nucleophilic aromatic substitution.
\(\textbf{Follow the activated pathway in Q:}\)
Methoxide attacks the aromatic carbon bearing fluorine.
The nitro group stabilises the relevant addition intermediate.
Subsequent fluoride departure restores aromaticity:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!O_2NC_6H_4F+CH_3O^-
\rightarrow4\!-\!O_2NC_6H_4OCH_3+F^-}
\]
The product is 4-nitroanisole.
\(\textbf{Distinguish two kinds of }sp^2\textbf{ carbon:}\)
A vinylic carbon belongs to a nonaromatic alkene double bond.
An aromatic carbon belongs to an aromatic pi-electron system.
The nitro group can activate the latter towards a particular substitution mechanism.
The shared \(sp^2\) hybridisation does not imply identical nucleophilic-substitution behaviour.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
A strong polar carbon–fluorine bond is not, by itself, sufficient for predicting substitution reactivity.
The relevant mechanism and stabilisation available to its intermediates must also be considered.
Q is suited to the stipulated activated aromatic displacement, whereas P is not.
451. An optically active sample of 1-bromo-2-chloropropane, \(\mathrm{BrCH_2CH(Cl)CH_3}\), undergoes two successive controlled substitutions.
Stage I: Treatment with one equivalent of sodium iodide in dry acetone under conditions favouring substitution at the less hindered carbon bearing the better leaving group.
Stage II: Treatment of the isolated Stage-I product with aqueous hydroxide under conditions giving selective displacement of iodide while retaining the secondary carbon–chlorine bond.
Assume complete intended substitution, no elimination or rearrangement, and no bond-breaking event at the stereogenic carbon during either stage.
Which statement correctly identifies the intermediates and final product?
ⓐ. Stage I gives 1-iodo-2-chloropropane; Stage II gives 2-chloropropan-1-ol with retention of the spatial arrangement at carbon 2
ⓑ. Stage I gives 2-iodo-1-chloropropane; Stage II gives propane-1,2-diol with inversion at carbon 2
ⓒ. Stage I gives 1-iodo-2-chloropropane; Stage II gives propan-2-ol because hydroxide replaces both halogens
ⓓ. Stage I gives 1-chloro-2-iodopropane; Stage II gives 1-chloropropan-2-ol with racemisation
Correct Answer: Stage I gives 1-iodo-2-chloropropane; Stage II gives 2-chloropropan-1-ol with retention of the spatial arrangement at carbon 2
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two reaction centres:}\)
The starting compound contains bromine attached to a primary carbon and chlorine attached to an adjacent secondary carbon.
The secondary carbon is stereogenic because it carries hydrogen, methyl, chlorine and bromomethyl substituents.
The two carbon–halogen bonds therefore differ in both leaving-group identity and steric environment.
\(\textbf{Select the first substitution site:}\)
Iodide is an effective nucleophile for ordinary halogen exchange in suitable primary haloalkanes.
The terminal carbon bearing bromine is less hindered than the secondary carbon bearing chlorine.
Bromide is also generally a better leaving group than chloride.
Both factors favour the specified displacement at carbon 1.
\(\textbf{Follow Stage I:}\)
\[
\mathrm{BrCH_2CH(Cl)CH_3+I^-
\rightarrow ICH_2CH(Cl)CH_3+Br^-}
\]
The intermediate is 1-iodo-2-chloropropane.
The chlorine-bearing stereogenic carbon has not undergone substitution.
\(\textbf{Apply Stage II:}\)
Hydroxide replaces the terminal iodide under the selected conditions:
\[
\mathrm{ICH_2CH(Cl)CH_3+OH^-
\rightarrow HOCH_2CH(Cl)CH_3+I^-}
\]
The product is 2-chloropropan-1-ol.
Its carbon skeleton and secondary carbon–chlorine bond remain intact.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the stereochemical outcome:}\)
Both substitutions occur at the primary carbon.
No bond directly attached to the neighbouring stereogenic carbon is broken or newly formed.
Consequently, the spatial arrangement at carbon 2 is retained.
This does not require the two compounds to have identical optical-rotation values.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The preferred site of substitution depends on leaving-group ability and steric accessibility.
Following the reaction centre through both stages shows that the terminal halogen is exchanged twice while the original stereogenic centre retains its arrangement.
452. 1-Bromopropane undergoes two simultaneous, independent \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) substitutions in a solution containing hydroxide and methoxide ions.
Pathway P produces propan-1-ol by hydroxide attack.
Pathway Q produces 1-methoxypropane by methoxide attack.
The elementary rate laws are:
\[
r_P=k_P[\mathrm{RBr}][\mathrm{OH^-}]
\]
\[
r_Q=k_Q[\mathrm{RBr}][\mathrm{CH_3O^-}]
\]
At constant temperature:
\[
k_P=0.0600\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}\,min^{-1}}
\]
\[
k_Q=0.120\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}\,min^{-1}}
\]
Initially, \([\mathrm{OH^-}]=0.300\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\) and \([\mathrm{CH_3O^-}]=0.100\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\).
Methoxide concentration is then increased to \(0.250\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\), while hydroxide concentration remains unchanged.
Assume that both nucleophile concentrations remain effectively constant during each measurement and that no elimination occurs.
What are the fractions of substitution product formed as propan-1-ol before and after the methoxide concentration change?
ⓐ. \(60.0\%\) and \(37.5\%\)
ⓑ. \(66.7\%\) and \(54.5\%\)
ⓒ. \(40.0\%\) and \(62.5\%\)
ⓓ. \(75.0\%\) and \(50.0\%\)
Correct Answer: \(60.0\%\) and \(37.5\%\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the competing chemical reactions:}\)
Both nucleophiles attack the same primary alkyl bromide.
Hydroxide forms an alcohol, whereas methoxide forms an ether.
The substrate concentration appears in both elementary rate laws.
Therefore, it cancels when the relative pathway fractions are calculated.
\(\textbf{Derive the alcohol-product fraction:}\)
The fraction reacting through hydroxide substitution is:
\[
f_P=\frac{r_P}{r_P+r_Q}
\]
Substitute the two rate laws:
\[
f_P=
\frac{k_P[\mathrm{RBr}][\mathrm{OH^-}]}
{k_P[\mathrm{RBr}][\mathrm{OH^-}]+
k_Q[\mathrm{RBr}][\mathrm{CH_3O^-}]}
\]
Cancel the common substrate concentration:
\[
f_P=
\frac{k_P[\mathrm{OH^-}]}
{k_P[\mathrm{OH^-}]+k_Q[\mathrm{CH_3O^-}]}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the initial pathway contributions:}\)
For hydroxide:
\[
k_P[\mathrm{OH^-}]=(0.0600)(0.300)
\]
\[
k_P[\mathrm{OH^-}]=0.0180\ \mathrm{min^{-1}}
\]
For methoxide:
\[
k_Q[\mathrm{CH_3O^-}]=(0.120)(0.100)
\]
\[
k_Q[\mathrm{CH_3O^-}]=0.0120\ \mathrm{min^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
f_{P,1}=\frac{0.0180}{0.0180+0.0120}
\]
\[
f_{P,1}=0.600
\]
\(\textbf{Recalculate after increasing methoxide:}\)
The hydroxide contribution remains:
\[
0.0180\ \mathrm{min^{-1}}
\]
The methoxide contribution becomes:
\[
k_Q[\mathrm{CH_3O^-}]=(0.120)(0.250)
\]
\[
k_Q[\mathrm{CH_3O^-}]=0.0300\ \mathrm{min^{-1}}
\]
Thus:
\[
f_{P,2}=\frac{0.0180}{0.0180+0.0300}
\]
\[
f_{P,2}=0.375
\]
\(\textbf{Interpret the change in selectivity:}\)
Methoxide has the larger intrinsic rate constant throughout the comparison.
Initially, however, hydroxide's greater concentration makes its product pathway dominant.
Increasing methoxide concentration reverses the relative importance of the two pathways.
No change in the underlying \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) mechanism is required.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{f_{P,\mathrm{initial}}=60.0\%,\qquad
f_{P,\mathrm{final}}=37.5\%}
\]
453. The three positional isomers of dichlorobenzene are compared using the following simplified molecular-dipole model.
A regular planar benzene hexagon has two chlorine atoms attached radially at ring positions 1 and 2 for the ortho isomer, positions 1 and 3 for the meta isomer, and positions 1 and 4 for the para isomer. Each aromatic carbon–chlorine bond contributes an equal dipole vector of magnitude \(1.50\ \mathrm{D}\), directed outward towards chlorine. The angles between these bond-dipole directions are \(60^\circ\), \(120^\circ\), and \(180^\circ\), respectively. Ignore all other contributions to the molecular dipole.
Which option gives the resultant dipole-moment magnitudes of the ortho, meta and para isomers, respectively?
ⓐ. \(1.50,\ 2.60,\ 0\ \mathrm{D}\)
ⓑ. \(2.60,\ 0,\ 1.50\ \mathrm{D}\)
ⓒ. \(3.00,\ 1.50,\ 0\ \mathrm{D}\)
ⓓ. \(2.60,\ 1.50,\ 0\ \mathrm{D}\)
Correct Answer: \(2.60,\ 1.50,\ 0\ \mathrm{D}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the vector-addition requirement:}\)
Each chlorine substituent contributes a bond-dipole vector of equal magnitude.
The resultant molecular dipole is determined by vector addition rather than ordinary arithmetic addition of magnitudes.
The relative angle between the vectors therefore matters.
\(\textbf{Use the equal-vector resultant relation:}\)
For two vectors of equal magnitude \(\mu_0\), separated by angle \(\theta\):
\[
\mu_R^2=\mu_0^2+\mu_0^2+2\mu_0^2\cos\theta
\]
Therefore:
\[
\mu_R=2\mu_0\cos\left(\frac{\theta}{2}\right)
\]
The magnitude is non-negative for the supplied angular range.
\(\textbf{Calculate the ortho-isomer resultant:}\)
For ortho-dichlorobenzene:
\[
\theta=60^\circ
\]
\[
\mu_o=2(1.50)\cos30^\circ
\]
\[
\mu_o=3.00\left(\frac{\sqrt3}{2}\right)
\]
\[
\mu_o=2.598\ \mathrm{D}
\]
\[
\mu_o\approx2.60\ \mathrm{D}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the meta-isomer resultant:}\)
For meta-dichlorobenzene:
\[
\theta=120^\circ
\]
\[
\mu_m=2(1.50)\cos60^\circ
\]
\[
\mu_m=3.00(0.500)
\]
\[
\mu_m=1.50\ \mathrm{D}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the para-isomer resultant:}\)
For para-dichlorobenzene:
\[
\theta=180^\circ
\]
\[
\mu_p=2(1.50)\cos90^\circ
\]
\[
\mu_p=0
\]
\(\textbf{Interpret the positional dependence:}\)
The ortho bond dipoles reinforce one another most strongly.
The meta bond dipoles partially cancel.
The para bond dipoles cancel completely in the stipulated symmetric model.
All three molecules contain two polar carbon–chlorine bonds, yet their resultant dipoles differ.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\mu_o=2.60\ \mathrm{D},\quad
\mu_m=1.50\ \mathrm{D},\quad
\mu_p=0}
\]
454. Styrene, \(\mathrm{C_6H_5CH{=}CH_2}\), undergoes HBr addition under two sets of conditions.
P: HBr in the absence of peroxides, favouring the ordinary ionic addition mechanism.
Q: HBr in the presence of a suitable peroxide initiator, favouring radical-chain addition.
The products are isolated under achiral conditions without further reaction.
Which statement correctly compares their constitutional structures and stereochemical possibilities?
ⓐ. P gives 1-bromo-1-phenylethane, which can form as an enantiomeric pair; Q gives 2-bromoethylbenzene, which is achiral
ⓑ. P gives achiral 2-bromoethylbenzene; Q gives an enantiomeric pair of 1-bromo-1-phenylethane
ⓒ. Both give 1-bromo-1-phenylethane because benzylic resonance stabilisation enforces the same regioselectivity in ionic and radical addition
ⓓ. Both give optically active bromides because the original alkene contains an aromatic ring
Correct Answer: P gives 1-bromo-1-phenylethane, which can form as an enantiomeric pair; Q gives 2-bromoethylbenzene, which is achiral
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two alkene carbons:}\)
Styrene contains a terminal carbon–carbon double bond adjacent to a phenyl ring.
One double-bond carbon is directly attached to the aromatic group.
The other is terminal and bears two hydrogen atoms.
The two addition mechanisms are influenced by different reactive intermediates.
\(\textbf{Examine the ionic pathway in P:}\)
Ordinary HBr addition involves protonation of the alkene followed by bromide capture.
The favoured protonation direction generates a resonance-stabilised benzylic carbocation:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH^+CH_3}
\]
Bromide attacks this carbocation.
\(\textbf{Identify P's product:}\)
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH{=}CH_2+HBr
\rightarrow C_6H_5CH(Br)CH_3}
\]
The product is 1-bromo-1-phenylethane.
The bromine-bearing carbon is attached to bromine, hydrogen, methyl and phenyl groups.
Therefore, it is stereogenic.
\(\textbf{Determine P's stereochemical possibility:}\)
The benzylic carbocation is approximately planar.
In an achiral environment, bromide can approach from either face.
The two product configurations can therefore form as an enantiomeric pair.
\(\textbf{Examine the radical pathway in Q:}\)
Under suitable peroxide conditions, bromine radicals add to the double bond.
Addition of bromine at the terminal carbon generates the more favourable benzylic carbon radical.
That radical subsequently abstracts hydrogen from HBr.
\(\textbf{Identify Q's product:}\)
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH{=}CH_2+HBr
\xrightarrow{peroxide}
C_6H_5CH_2CH_2Br}
\]
The product is 2-bromoethylbenzene.
Its bromine-bearing carbon carries two identical hydrogen atoms, so it is not stereogenic.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the roles of resonance:}\)
Benzylic resonance stabilisation influences both mechanisms.
In P, it favours formation of a benzylic carbocation.
In Q, it favours formation of a benzylic radical after bromine adds at the opposite double-bond carbon.
The resulting positions of bromine therefore differ.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The same electronic stabilisation principle can favour different addition orientations when the intermediate type changes.
The ionic route gives a potentially chiral benzylic bromide, whereas the radical route gives an achiral primary bromide.
455. Two tertiary alkyl bromides P and Q undergo separate first-order solvolysis reactions at the same temperature.
The measured half-lives are:
\[
t_{1/2,P}=10.0\ \mathrm{min}
\]
\[
t_{1/2,Q}=20.0\ \mathrm{min}
\]
Initially, each solution contains \(0.100\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\) substrate.
Assume complete conversion of disappeared substrate into one substitution product, constant solution volume, no elimination, and ideal first-order kinetics.
After \(20.0\ \mathrm{min}\), what is the ratio of the concentrations of substitution products formed from P and Q?
ⓐ. \(1:1\)
ⓑ. \(4:3\)
ⓒ. \(3:2\)
ⓓ. \(2:1\)
Correct Answer: \(3:2\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the kinetic model:}\)
Each reaction follows first-order substrate disappearance.
For such a process, an equal fraction of the substrate remaining is consumed during every successive half-life.
The two solutions begin with the same substrate concentration.
Therefore, the relative product concentrations depend on the fractions converted after the specified time.
\(\textbf{Determine the number of half-lives for P:}\)
\[
n_P=\frac{t}{t_{1/2,P}}
\]
\[
n_P=\frac{20.0}{10.0}
\]
\[
n_P=2
\]
After two half-lives, the remaining substrate fraction is:
\[
f_{\mathrm{remaining},P}=\left(\frac12\right)^2
\]
\[
f_{\mathrm{remaining},P}=\frac14
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate P's product concentration:}\)
The converted fraction is:
\[
f_{\mathrm{converted},P}=1-\frac14
\]
\[
f_{\mathrm{converted},P}=\frac34
\]
Therefore:
\[
[\mathrm{Product}]_P=(0.100)\left(\frac34\right)
\]
\[
[\mathrm{Product}]_P=0.0750\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the number of half-lives for Q:}\)
\[
n_Q=\frac{20.0}{20.0}=1
\]
After one half-life:
\[
f_{\mathrm{remaining},Q}=\frac12
\]
The converted fraction is also:
\[
f_{\mathrm{converted},Q}=\frac12
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate Q's product concentration:}\)
\[
[\mathrm{Product}]_Q=(0.100)\left(\frac12\right)
\]
\[
[\mathrm{Product}]_Q=0.0500\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Compare the product concentrations:}\)
\[
\frac{[\mathrm{Product}]_P}{[\mathrm{Product}]_Q}
=\frac{0.0750}{0.0500}
\]
\[
\frac{[\mathrm{Product}]_P}{[\mathrm{Product}]_Q}=1.50
\]
Therefore:
\[
[\mathrm{Product}]_P:[\mathrm{Product}]_Q=3:2
\]
\(\textbf{Interpret the kinetic difference:}\)
P has the shorter half-life and consequently the larger fraction converted after the same elapsed time.
The product ratio is not simply the inverse ratio of the half-lives.
Actual integrated first-order conversion must be considered.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{[\mathrm{Product}]_P:[\mathrm{Product}]_Q=3:2}
\]
456. 1,2-Dibromopropane, \(\mathrm{CH_3CHBrCH_2Br}\), undergoes two alternative transformations.
P: Treatment with zinc under suitable reductive dehalogenation conditions.
Q: Treatment with sufficient sodium amide in liquid ammonia under conditions selected for complete double dehydrohalogenation.
Assume that the intended reactions proceed without skeletal rearrangement or competing substitution.
Which pair correctly identifies the principal hydrocarbon products?
ⓐ. P gives propane; Q gives propene
ⓑ. P gives propene; Q gives propyne
ⓒ. P gives propyne; Q gives propene
ⓓ. Both give propyne because removal of two bromine atoms always forms a carbon–carbon triple bond
Correct Answer: P gives propene; Q gives propyne
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the starting halogen arrangement:}\)
1,2-Dibromopropane contains bromine atoms on adjacent carbon atoms.
It is therefore a vicinal dibromide.
The two reactions differ in whether they remove the halogens reductively or remove hydrogen bromide through elimination.
\(\textbf{Analyse zinc dehalogenation in P:}\)
Zinc can remove both bromine atoms from a suitable vicinal dibromide.
A carbon–carbon double bond is formed between the two original bromine-bearing carbons.
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CHBrCH_2Br+Zn
\rightarrow CH_3CH{=}CH_2+ZnBr_2}
\]
The hydrocarbon product is propene.
\(\textbf{Check the hydrogen balance in P:}\)
Zinc removes the two bromine atoms without removing hydrogen from the organic skeleton.
The starting formula is \(\mathrm{C_3H_6Br_2}\).
Removing bromine as zinc bromide leaves the alkene formula \(\mathrm{C_3H_6}\).
\(\textbf{Analyse double dehydrohalogenation in Q:}\)
The stipulated strong-base conditions remove two molecules of HBr from the vicinal dibromide.
The first elimination forms a suitable bromoalkene.
The second elimination removes hydrogen bromide from the remaining vinylic bromide environment.
\(\textbf{Identify Q's final product:}\)
The net carbon skeleton becomes:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3C{\equiv}CH}
\]
The product is propyne.
The carbon–carbon triple bond forms between the two carbons that originally carried bromine.
\(\textbf{Check the formula change in Q:}\)
Two dehydrohalogenation steps remove two bromine atoms and two hydrogen atoms.
Consequently:
\[
\mathrm{C_3H_6Br_2\rightarrow C_3H_4+2HBr}
\]
The hydrocarbon formula \(\mathrm{C_3H_4}\) is consistent with propyne.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the chemical transformations:}\)
Zinc dehalogenation removes halogen atoms and forms an alkene.
Double dehydrohalogenation removes hydrogen halide twice and forms an alkyne under the stipulated conditions.
The same vicinal dibromide therefore gives different degrees of unsaturation.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
A reaction described merely as removal of bromine is insufficient to predict the product.
The reagent and the atoms removed determine whether an alkene or alkyne forms.
457. Two different bromoalkenes undergo selective catalytic hydrogenation of their carbon–carbon double bonds.
P: 3-Bromopent-2-ene, \(\mathrm{CH_3CH{=}C(Br)CH_2CH_3}\).
Q: 2-Bromopent-2-ene, \(\mathrm{CH_3C(Br){=}CHCH_2CH_3}\).
Assume that hydrogenation leaves both carbon–bromine bonds intact, and that each alkene is reduced completely under achiral conditions.
Which statement correctly identifies the products and their stereochemical possibilities?
ⓐ. P gives 2-bromopentane, which is achiral; Q gives 3-bromopentane, which is chiral
ⓑ. Both give 2-bromopentane because hydrogenation causes migration of bromine towards the nearest terminal carbon
ⓒ. P gives 3-bromopentane, which is achiral; Q gives 2-bromopentane, which can exist as an enantiomeric pair
ⓓ. Both give 3-bromopentane, which is optically active because each original alkene can possess E/Z isomerism
Correct Answer: P gives 3-bromopentane, which is achiral; Q gives 2-bromopentane, which can exist as an enantiomeric pair
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the selective reaction:}\)
The question specifies addition of hydrogen across the carbon–carbon double bond.
The carbon–bromine bonds must remain intact.
Therefore, the bromine-bearing carbon remains the same carbon within each original skeleton.
\(\textbf{Follow hydrogenation of P:}\)
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH{=}C(Br)CH_2CH_3+H_2
\rightarrow CH_3CH_2CH(Br)CH_2CH_3}
\]
The product is 3-bromopentane.
Bromine is attached to the central carbon of the five-carbon chain.
\(\textbf{Check stereogenicity in P's product:}\)
The bromine-bearing carbon is attached to bromine, hydrogen and two ethyl groups.
The two ethyl groups are identical.
Therefore, this carbon is not stereogenic.
3-Bromopentane is achiral.
\(\textbf{Follow hydrogenation of Q:}\)
\[
\mathrm{CH_3C(Br){=}CHCH_2CH_3+H_2
\rightarrow CH_3CH(Br)CH_2CH_2CH_3}
\]
The product is 2-bromopentane.
Bromine remains attached to carbon 2.
\(\textbf{Check stereogenicity in Q's product:}\)
Carbon 2 is bonded to bromine, hydrogen, methyl and n-propyl groups.
All four substituents are different.
The carbon is therefore stereogenic.
Under the stated achiral conditions, the product can form as an enantiomeric pair.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the starting and final stereochemistry:}\)
Both starting alkenes can exhibit E/Z isomerism because each double-bonded carbon bears two different substituents.
Hydrogenation removes the double bond and eliminates that geometrical-isomerism feature.
However, the saturated products differ in whether a stereogenic carbon remains.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Selective reduction can eliminate E/Z stereochemistry without necessarily producing an achiral compound.
The decisive test for the final product is whether the bromine-bearing saturated carbon has four distinguishable substituents.
458. A hypothetical exhaustive ammonolysis experiment begins with \(0.0500\ \mathrm{mol}\) ammonia and an excess of bromoethane.
The reaction is controlled so that every ammonia-derived nitrogen atom ultimately becomes the nitrogen of a tetraethylammonium ion, \(\mathrm{(C_2H_5)_4N^+}\).
The three hydrogen atoms initially attached to each nitrogen are removed by a suitable base during successive alkylations.
Assume quantitative formation of tetraethylammonium bromide and no competing reactions.
What amounts of bromoethane are consumed and tetraethylammonium bromide formed, respectively?
ⓐ. \(0.150\ \mathrm{mol}\) and \(0.0500\ \mathrm{mol}\)
ⓑ. \(0.200\ \mathrm{mol}\) and \(0.0500\ \mathrm{mol}\)
ⓒ. \(0.200\ \mathrm{mol}\) and \(0.200\ \mathrm{mol}\)
ⓓ. \(0.0500\ \mathrm{mol}\) and \(0.0500\ \mathrm{mol}\)
Correct Answer: \(0.200\ \mathrm{mol}\) and \(0.0500\ \mathrm{mol}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify successive amine alkylation:}\)
Ammonia possesses a nitrogen lone pair and can attack suitable primary alkyl bromides.
The initially formed primary amine can undergo further alkylation.
Successive introduction of additional ethyl groups can ultimately produce a quaternary ammonium ion.
\(\textbf{Count the original nitrogen atoms:}\)
Each ammonia molecule contains one nitrogen atom.
Each tetraethylammonium ion also contains one nitrogen atom.
Therefore, nitrogen-atom conservation gives:
\[
n(\mathrm{(C_2H_5)_4N^+})=n(\mathrm{NH_3})
\]
\[
n(\mathrm{(C_2H_5)_4N^+})=0.0500\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the number of ethyl groups introduced:}\)
Ammonia initially has no ethyl groups.
A tetraethylammonium ion has four ethyl groups attached to nitrogen.
Each bromoethane molecule supplies one ethyl group during the stipulated substitution sequence.
Therefore, four molecules of bromoethane are required per nitrogen atom converted.
\(\textbf{Calculate bromoethane consumption:}\)
\[
n(\mathrm{C_2H_5Br})=4n(\mathrm{NH_3})
\]
\[
n(\mathrm{C_2H_5Br})=4(0.0500)
\]
\[
n(\mathrm{C_2H_5Br})=0.200\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the quaternary salt amount:}\)
One tetraethylammonium ion combines with one bromide counterion to form tetraethylammonium bromide:
\[
\mathrm{[(C_2H_5)_4N]^+Br^-}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n(\mathrm{tetraethylammonium\ bromide})=0.0500\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Check the bromine accounting:}\)
Four bromoethane molecules supply four bromine atoms for every final tetraethylammonium unit.
One bromide becomes the counterion of the quaternary salt.
The remaining bromide ions are accounted for in the inorganic products associated with removal of the original nitrogen-bound hydrogens.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the final product from a tertiary amine:}\)
A tertiary amine has three carbon-containing groups attached to nitrogen and retains a lone pair.
A quaternary ammonium ion has four such groups and bears a positive charge.
It is therefore not simply another neutral amine.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Product stoichiometry follows nitrogen conservation and the number of carbon groups introduced.
Four equivalents of bromoethane are needed per ammonia-derived nitrogen under the stipulated exhaustive alkylation.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{n(\mathrm{C_2H_5Br})=0.200\ \mathrm{mol},\quad
n(\mathrm{quaternary\ salt})=0.0500\ \mathrm{mol}}
\]
459. Two closed experimental chambers initially contain the same small amount of Freon-12, \(\mathrm{CCl_2F_2}\), and ozone. Both chambers are otherwise set up to compare only the chlorine-radical-mediated ozone-destruction pathway.
Chamber P is exposed only to light that is insufficient to cleave the C–Cl bonds of Freon-12.
Chamber Q is exposed to sufficiently energetic ultraviolet radiation to initiate C–Cl bond cleavage in Freon-12.
Assume no chlorine radicals are present initially and that competing direct photolysis reactions are excluded from the comparison. Which conclusion is most appropriate?
ⓐ. P initiates more chlorine-radical cycling because intact Freon-12 is itself a free radical
ⓑ. Both initiate identical chlorine-radical cycles because Freon-12 contains two chlorine atoms per molecule
ⓒ. Neither can initiate a chlorine-radical cycle because a carbon–chlorine bond can never break under ultraviolet light
ⓓ. Q can generate chlorine radicals for catalytic ozone loss, while P lacks the specified photochemical initiation step
Correct Answer: Q can generate chlorine radicals for catalytic ozone loss, while P lacks the specified photochemical initiation step
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the required initiation event:}\)
Freon-12 contains chlorine atoms attached to carbon, but those chlorine atoms are not automatically free radicals. The relevant catalytic pathway begins when sufficiently energetic radiation cleaves a carbon–chlorine bond and releases reactive chlorine.
\(\textbf{Assess chamber P:}\)
The light in P is explicitly insufficient to initiate the specified C–Cl bond photolysis. Therefore, with no radicals initially present and other initiation routes excluded, P does not start the chlorine-radical-mediated cycle merely because its molecules contain chlorine.
\(\textbf{Assess chamber Q:}\)
Higher-energy ultraviolet photons can break an appropriate C–Cl bond in a CFC, producing a chlorine radical. Once formed, active chlorine can participate in ozone-depleting reactions and may be regenerated in catalytic steps. The main difference between P and Q is whether this radical source is activated.
\(\textbf{Interpret the environmental relevance:}\)
Relative stability in the lower atmosphere does not imply that a CFC is completely resistant to higher-energy stratospheric radiation. The real atmospheric mechanism involves many additional reactions; the question isolates the initiation of chlorine-radical chemistry rather than asking for a numerical ozone-loss estimate.
\(\textbf{Conclusion:}\)
The presence of carbon-bound chlorine is not enough on its own to start a radical chain. Under the defined conditions, Q supplies the required photochemical initiation, whereas P does not.
460. Two alkyl bromides are separately converted into their Grignard reagents using magnesium in dry ether:
P: Bromobenzene, \(\mathrm{C_6H_5Br}\).
Q: Benzyl bromide, \(\mathrm{C_6H_5CH_2Br}\).
Each Grignard reagent is treated with isotopically labelled carbon dioxide, \(\mathrm{^{13}CO_2}\), followed by acidic hydrolysis.
Assume complete conversion, no rearrangement and no carbon-isotope exchange.
Which statement correctly identifies where the labelled carbon appears?
ⓐ. P produces benzoic acid with the label at its carboxyl carbon; Q produces phenylacetic acid with the label at its carboxyl carbon
ⓑ. P produces phenylacetic acid with the label on the benzylic methylene; Q produces benzoic acid with the label on the aromatic ring
ⓒ. Both produce labelled benzoic acid because Grignard carboxylation removes any carbon between the aromatic ring and magnesium
ⓓ. Both produce labelled phenylacetic acid because carbon dioxide always inserts one methylene group between the ring and carboxyl group
Correct Answer: P produces benzoic acid with the label at its carboxyl carbon; Q produces phenylacetic acid with the label at its carboxyl carbon
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two carbon–bromine environments:}\)
Bromobenzene contains bromine directly attached to an aromatic carbon.
Benzyl bromide contains bromine attached to a saturated methylene carbon adjacent to the aromatic ring.
Although both compounds contain a phenyl group and bromine, magnesium insertion generates organomagnesium bonds at different carbon positions.
\(\textbf{Form the reagent from P:}\)
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5Br+Mg
\xrightarrow{dry\ ether}
C_6H_5MgBr}
\]
The organic carbon bonded to magnesium is an aromatic ring carbon.
\(\textbf{Carboxylate the reagent from P:}\)
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5MgBr+{}^{13}CO_2
\rightarrow C_6H_5{}^{13}COOMgBr}
\]
Acidic hydrolysis gives:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5{}^{13}COOH}
\]
The product is benzoic acid with the labelled carbon at the carboxyl group.
\(\textbf{Form the reagent from Q:}\)
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH_2Br+Mg
\xrightarrow{dry\ ether}
C_6H_5CH_2MgBr}
\]
The reactive organomagnesium carbon is now the benzylic methylene carbon.
\(\textbf{Carboxylate the reagent from Q:}\)
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH_2MgBr+{}^{13}CO_2
\rightarrow C_6H_5CH_2{}^{13}COOMgBr}
\]
Acidic hydrolysis produces:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH_2{}^{13}COOH}
\]
The product is phenylacetic acid with the label at its carboxyl carbon.
\(\textbf{Track the original methylene group:}\)
Q already contains one carbon between the benzene ring and bromine.
That original carbon becomes the methylene group between the ring and the newly formed carboxyl group.
The labelled carbon comes from carbon dioxide rather than from the starting benzyl group.
\(\textbf{Integrate connectivity with isotope tracing:}\)
Both reactions incorporate the labelled carbon as the carbon of a carboxyl group.
However, the position of the original organomagnesium carbon determines whether that carboxyl group is directly attached to the benzene ring or separated by a methylene unit.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Isotope tracing distinguishes the origin of the newly introduced carbon from the original carbon skeleton.
P gives labelled benzoic acid, whereas Q gives labelled phenylacetic acid.
461. A sample of 4-bromoaniline contains ordinary nitrogen, \(\mathrm{^{14}N}\), in its amino group.
It is diazotised using sodium nitrite enriched entirely in \(\mathrm{^{15}N}\) under suitable acidic conditions at \(273–278\ \mathrm{K}\).
The resulting diazonium salt is treated with cuprous chloride under Sandmeyer conditions.
Assume that:
The amino nitrogen and nitrite nitrogen become the two nitrogen atoms of the diazonium group.
There is no nitrogen-isotope exchange.
The original aromatic bromine remains attached to the ring.
Complete substitution releases the two diazonium nitrogen atoms as molecular nitrogen.
Which pair correctly identifies the principal organic product and the isotope composition of the nitrogen gas?
ⓐ. 1-Bromo-4-fluorobenzene and \(\mathrm{^{14}N{}^{15}N}\)
ⓑ. 1,4-Dichlorobenzene and \(\mathrm{^{15}N_2}\)
ⓒ. Chlorobenzene and \(\mathrm{^{14}N_2}\)
ⓓ. 1-Bromo-4-chlorobenzene and \(\mathrm{^{14}N{}^{15}N}\)
Correct Answer: 1-Bromo-4-chlorobenzene and \(\mathrm{^{14}N{}^{15}N}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the original substituents:}\)
4-Bromoaniline has an amino group and a bromine atom attached at para positions on a benzene ring.
The amino group contains ordinary \(\mathrm{^{14}N}\).
The aromatic carbon–bromine bond is stipulated to remain unchanged throughout the sequence.
\(\textbf{Identify the source of the second nitrogen atom:}\)
The diazotisation reagent is sodium nitrite enriched in \(\mathrm{^{15}N}\).
In the stipulated atom-tracing model, one nitrogen atom of the diazonium group comes from the original amino group.
The other comes from the nitrite reagent.
The resulting diazonium group therefore contains both nitrogen isotopes.
\(\textbf{Follow diazonium formation:}\)
Under the specified acidic and low-temperature conditions, 4-bromoaniline is converted into a diazonium salt.
The aromatic carbon originally bonded to the amino nitrogen now bears the diazonium group.
The para bromine substituent remains in its original position.
\(\textbf{Apply the Sandmeyer reaction:}\)
Cuprous chloride replaces the diazonium group with chlorine:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4N_2^+
\xrightarrow{CuCl}
4\!-\!BrC_6H_4Cl+N_2}
\]
The principal organic product is 1-bromo-4-chlorobenzene.
Its two halogen atoms occupy para positions.
\(\textbf{Determine the nitrogen-gas isotopes:}\)
The diazonium group contains one \(\mathrm{^{14}N}\) atom and one \(\mathrm{^{15}N}\) atom.
The question excludes isotope exchange.
Both atoms leave together as molecular nitrogen during the intended substitution.
Therefore, the released nitrogen gas is:
\[
\mathrm{^{14}N{}^{15}N}
\]
\(\textbf{Distinguish nitrogen removal from halogen substitution:}\)
The reaction introduces chlorine at the carbon previously attached to the amino-derived diazonium group.
It does not replace the original aromatic bromine.
The nitrogen atoms are expelled as nitrogen gas rather than incorporated into the organic product.
\(\textbf{Check atom conservation:}\)
Each diazonium group contains two nitrogen atoms.
One originates from the starting aniline and one from the labelled nitrite.
Formation of one mixed-isotope nitrogen molecule conserves both atoms without requiring formation of \(\mathrm{^{14}N_2}\) or \(\mathrm{^{15}N_2}\).
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The product identity follows the Sandmeyer substitution site.
The nitrogen-gas isotope composition follows the separate origins of the two diazonium nitrogen atoms.
Together, these give 1-bromo-4-chlorobenzene and \(\mathrm{^{14}N{}^{15}N}\).
462. The three positional isomers of dichlorobenzene have the following approximate physical properties:
| Isomer | Melting point (°C) | Boiling point (°C) |
| 1,2-Dichlorobenzene | −17 | 180 |
| 1,3-Dichlorobenzene | −25 | 173 |
| 1,4-Dichlorobenzene | 53 | 174 |
An equimolar mixture of the three isomers is maintained at \(25^\circ\mathrm{C}\). Assume that each component retains its pure-substance phase behaviour for this idealised comparison and that all three compounds remain chemically unchanged.
Which interpretation correctly compares their phase behaviour and relative volatility?
ⓐ. The para isomer is solid at \(25^\circ\mathrm{C}\), while the ortho and meta isomers are liquids; the meta isomer has the lowest boiling point
ⓑ. The ortho isomer is solid at \(25^\circ\mathrm{C}\), while the meta and para isomers are liquids; the para isomer has the lowest boiling point
ⓒ. All three are liquids at \(25^\circ\mathrm{C}\), and the para isomer has the highest boiling point because it has the most symmetrical structure
ⓓ. The para isomer is solid at \(25^\circ\mathrm{C}\), and the ortho isomer has the lowest boiling point because adjacent chlorine atoms always reduce intermolecular attraction
Correct Answer: The para isomer is solid at \(25^\circ\mathrm{C}\), while the ortho and meta isomers are liquids; the meta isomer has the lowest boiling point
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two distinct physical transitions:}\)
Melting involves conversion of a crystalline solid into a liquid.
Boiling involves conversion of a liquid into a vapour.
The molecular interactions relevant to crystal packing and liquid volatility are related but not identical.
Therefore, the isomer with the highest melting point need not have the highest boiling point.
\(\textbf{Interpret the melting-point data:}\)
At \(25^\circ\mathrm{C}\), the para isomer lies below its melting point of \(53^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
It is therefore solid under the stipulated idealised phase comparison.
The ortho and meta isomers have melting points below \(25^\circ\mathrm{C}\).
Both are liquids at this temperature.
\(\textbf{Explain the unusual para-isomer melting point:}\)
1,4-Dichlorobenzene has a relatively symmetrical molecular structure.
This arrangement permits comparatively efficient packing in its crystal.
The resulting crystal stability contributes to its substantially higher melting point than those of the other two isomers.
\(\textbf{Compare the boiling points separately:}\)
The supplied boiling-point order is:
\[
\mathrm{1,3\!-\!dichlorobenzene
\lt
1,4\!-\!dichlorobenzene
\lt
1,2\!-\!dichlorobenzene}
\]
The meta isomer has the lowest boiling point.
The ortho isomer has the highest boiling point.
\(\textbf{Connect volatility with the data:}\)
At a common temperature where all three are liquids, the lower-boiling isomer will generally be more volatile.
The table therefore does not support assigning greatest volatility to the para isomer merely because it crystallises most readily.
\(\textbf{Recognise the phase-assumption limitation:}\)
A real mixture can exhibit melting-point depression and solid–liquid equilibria.
The question explicitly supplies a pure-substance phase approximation to avoid those complications.
The correct interpretation must use the stated approximation rather than infer an unprovided mixture phase diagram.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The para isomer illustrates how efficient crystal packing can produce a high melting point without producing the highest boiling point.
Melting behaviour and volatility must be assessed using their respective data.
463. Three halogenated methane derivatives have the following approximate properties:
| Compound | Boiling point (°C) | Permanent molecular dipole |
| P: \(\mathrm{CF_4}\) | −128 | Zero |
| Q: \(\mathrm{CHCl_3}\) | 61 | Non-zero |
| R: \(\mathrm{CCl_4}\) | 77 | Zero |
A student argues that Q must have the highest boiling point because it is the only polar molecule in the table.
Which explanation correctly resolves the contradiction with the measured data?
ⓐ. Carbon–chlorine bonds in R are nonpolar, so R has no intermolecular forces and should boil below P
ⓑ. P and R have identical boiling points because tetrahedral symmetry gives both zero permanent dipole moment
ⓒ. Q is necessarily more volatile than P because polar molecules always require less energy to enter the vapour phase
ⓓ. R can have stronger dispersion attractions than polar Q; P has a much smaller and less polarizable electron cloud
Correct Answer: R can have stronger dispersion attractions than polar Q; P has a much smaller and less polarizable electron cloud
Explanation: \(\textbf{Distinguish bond polarity from molecular polarity:}\)
All three compounds contain polar carbon–halogen bonds.
However, the complete molecular dipole depends on the vector sum of bond-dipole contributions.
A molecule can contain several polar bonds yet have zero permanent dipole moment.
\(\textbf{Examine P and R:}\)
Tetrafluoromethane and tetrachloromethane each have four equivalent carbon–halogen bonds arranged tetrahedrally.
Their individual bond-dipole contributions cancel.
Therefore, both molecules have zero permanent dipole moment.
This does not mean that their intermolecular attractive forces vanish.
\(\textbf{Examine Q:}\)
Chloroform has three chlorine substituents and one hydrogen substituent.
Its tetrahedral bond-dipole contributions do not cancel completely.
It therefore has a permanent molecular dipole.
Permanent dipole–dipole interactions can contribute to its intermolecular attraction.
\(\textbf{Identify the additional intermolecular force:}\)
London dispersion forces occur in both polar and nonpolar molecules.
Their importance generally increases with electron-cloud size and polarizability.
Chlorine-containing molecules can exhibit substantial dispersion attractions because chlorine atoms are comparatively large and polarizable.
\(\textbf{Explain the behaviour of R:}\)
Tetrachloromethane contains four chlorine atoms.
Its large, polarizable molecular electron cloud can support stronger dispersion attractions than those present in chloroform.
Consequently, R can have a higher boiling point than Q despite lacking a permanent molecular dipole.
\(\textbf{Explain the behaviour of P:}\)
Tetrafluoromethane contains comparatively small fluorine atoms.
Its molecular electron cloud is less polarizable than that of tetrachloromethane.
The much weaker overall attractions help explain its exceptionally low boiling point.
\(\textbf{Integrate the physical evidence:}\)
The measured order is:
\[
T_b(\mathrm{CF_4})\lt T_b(\mathrm{CHCl_3})\lt T_b(\mathrm{CCl_4})
\]
This order cannot be predicted solely by asking whether a molecule possesses a permanent dipole.
Molecular mass, electron-cloud polarizability and the complete set of intermolecular forces also matter.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Molecular polarity and boiling point are not interchangeable measures of intermolecular attraction.
The high boiling point of tetrachloromethane is compatible with its symmetrical, nonpolar structure.
464. Two idealised gaseous hydrolysis reactions are considered:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3F+H_2O\rightarrow CH_3OH+HF}
\]
\[
\mathrm{CH_3I+H_2O\rightarrow CH_3OH+HI}
\]
The following average bond enthalpies are supplied:
| Bond | Bond enthalpy (kJ mol\(^{-1}\)) |
| C–F | 452 |
| C–I | 234 |
| O–H | 463 |
| C–O | 358 |
| H–F | 565 |
| H–I | 299 |
Treat all species as gaseous and use the bond-enthalpy approximation. Separately, consider ordinary aqueous nucleophilic substitution using hydroxide under conditions suitable for comparing the methyl halides.
Which statement is correct?
ⓐ. Fluoromethane hydrolysis is approximately \(40\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) endothermic, while iodomethane hydrolysis is approximately \(8\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) exothermic
ⓑ. Both reactions are exothermic, and fluoromethane must react faster because its carbon–fluorine bond is more polar
ⓒ. Fluoromethane hydrolysis is about \(8\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) exothermic and iodomethane hydrolysis about \(40\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) endothermic, despite the faster ordinary substitution of iodomethane
ⓓ. The gaseous hydrolysis of iodomethane is more exothermic, so its ordinary substitution rate must also be higher
Correct Answer: Fluoromethane hydrolysis is about \(8\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) exothermic and iodomethane hydrolysis about \(40\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\) endothermic, despite the faster ordinary substitution of iodomethane
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the bonds changed during hydrolysis:}\)
Each reaction breaks one carbon–halogen bond.
Conversion of water into the alcohol and hydrogen halide involves breaking one O–H bond.
One new carbon–oxygen bond and one hydrogen–halogen bond are formed.
\(\textbf{Apply the bond-enthalpy approximation:}\)
\[
\Delta H\approx
\sum D(\text{bonds broken})-\sum D(\text{bonds formed})
\]
For the general reaction:
\[
\Delta H\approx D(\mathrm{C-X})+D(\mathrm{O-H})
-D(\mathrm{C-O})-D(\mathrm{H-X})
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate fluoromethane hydrolysis:}\)
\[
E_{\mathrm{broken,F}}=452+463
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{broken,F}}=915\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{formed,F}}=358+565
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{formed,F}}=923\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\Delta H_F=915-923
\]
\[
\Delta H_F=-8\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate iodomethane hydrolysis:}\)
\[
E_{\mathrm{broken,I}}=234+463
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{broken,I}}=697\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{formed,I}}=358+299
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{formed,I}}=657\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\Delta H_I=697-657
\]
\[
\Delta H_I=+40\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Distinguish enthalpy change from activation barrier:}\)
The calculated enthalpy describes the difference between the energies of reactants and products in the stipulated gaseous model.
It does not provide the activation barrier for nucleophilic substitution.
A more exothermic overall reaction need not be kinetically faster.
\(\textbf{Connect with ordinary substitution behaviour:}\)
Iodide is generally a better leaving group than fluoride in ordinary alkyl-halide substitution.
The carbon–iodine bond is substantially weaker than the carbon–fluorine bond.
Consequently, iodomethane is ordinarily much more reactive towards suitable nucleophilic displacement than fluoromethane.
The aqueous kinetic comparison also involves solvation effects not represented by the idealised gaseous bond-enthalpy calculation.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Thermodynamic energy difference, elementary activation barrier and leaving-group ability are distinct chemical quantities.
The supplied enthalpies do not overturn the ordinary methyl-halide substitution trend.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{\Delta H_F\approx-8\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}},\qquad
\Delta H_I\approx+40\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}}
\]
465. Two historical halogen-containing compounds are examined:
P: Iodoform, \(\mathrm{CHI_3}\), with a sample mass of \(0.394\ \mathrm{g}\).
Q: Freon-12, \(\mathrm{CCl_2F_2}\), with a sample mass of \(0.242\ \mathrm{g}\).
Use atomic masses \(\mathrm{C}=12,\ \mathrm{H}=1,\ \mathrm{I}=127,\ \mathrm{Cl}=35.5,\ \mathrm{F}=19\).
An investigator must compare the total amounts of iodine atoms in P and chlorine atoms in Q, and correctly identify the compounds' historical applications. Count atoms incorporated in the compounds, not free halogen atoms.
Which statement is correct?
ⓐ. P contains \(0.00300\ \mathrm{mol}\) iodine atoms and was used as an antiseptic; Q contains \(0.00400\ \mathrm{mol}\) chlorine atoms and was used as a refrigerant
ⓑ. P contains \(0.00100\ \mathrm{mol}\) iodine atoms and was used as a refrigerant; Q contains \(0.00200\ \mathrm{mol}\) chlorine atoms and was used as an antiseptic
ⓒ. P contains \(0.00300\ \mathrm{mol}\) iodine atoms and was used as a refrigerant; Q contains \(0.00400\ \mathrm{mol}\) chlorine atoms and was used as an insecticide
ⓓ. P contains \(0.00400\ \mathrm{mol}\) iodine atoms and was used as an antiseptic; Q contains \(0.00300\ \mathrm{mol}\) chlorine atoms and was used as a refrigerant
Correct Answer: P contains \(0.00300\ \mathrm{mol}\) iodine atoms and was used as an antiseptic; Q contains \(0.00400\ \mathrm{mol}\) chlorine atoms and was used as a refrigerant
Explanation: \(\textbf{Distinguish the two molecular identities:}\)
Iodoform is triiodomethane, so each molecule contains one carbon atom, one hydrogen atom and three iodine atoms.
Freon-12 is dichlorodifluoromethane, containing one carbon atom, two chlorine atoms and two fluorine atoms.
The number of moles of a particular type of atom need not equal the number of moles of molecules.
\(\textbf{Calculate the amount of iodoform:}\)
The molar mass of iodoform is:
\[
M(\mathrm{CHI_3})=12+1+3(127)=394\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Thus:
\[
n(\mathrm{CHI_3})=\frac{0.394\ \mathrm{g}}{394\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}}
\]
\[
n(\mathrm{CHI_3})=0.00100\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
Each mole of iodoform contains three moles of iodine atoms.
\[
n(\mathrm{I\ atoms})=3(0.00100)=0.00300\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the amount of Freon-12:}\)
Its molar mass is:
\[
M(\mathrm{CCl_2F_2})=12+2(35.5)+2(19)=121\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}
\]
Therefore:
\[
n(\mathrm{CCl_2F_2})=\frac{0.242\ \mathrm{g}}{121\ \mathrm{g\,mol^{-1}}}
\]
\[
n(\mathrm{CCl_2F_2})=0.00200\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
Each molecule contains two chlorine atoms, giving:
\[
n(\mathrm{Cl\ atoms})=2(0.00200)=0.00400\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Relate structure to historical use:}\)
Iodoform is a yellow crystalline organoiodine compound historically associated with antiseptic applications.
Freon-12 belongs to the chlorofluorocarbon refrigerants and was also used as an aerosol propellant.
Its chemical stability in ordinary use does not imply environmental harmlessness; sufficiently energetic ultraviolet light can release chlorine-containing radicals that participate in stratospheric ozone destruction.
The historical use of iodoform is distinct from both the properties and environmental action of a chlorofluorocarbon.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
P contains \(0.00300\ \mathrm{mol}\) of iodine atoms, whereas Q contains \(0.00400\ \mathrm{mol}\) of chlorine atoms.
The corresponding historical applications are antiseptic use for P and refrigeration for Q.
466. 4-Bromoaniline is used to prepare 4-bromobenzoic acid without replacing the bromine atom originally attached to the benzene ring.
A chemist proposes the following sequence:
P: Diazotisation of the amino group at \(273–278\ \mathrm{K}\).
Q: Treatment of the diazonium salt with cuprous cyanide.
R: Complete hydrolysis of the resulting nitrile.
A second chemist proposes directly treating bromobenzene with alcoholic KCN as an ordinary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) substitution.
Which assessment is most appropriate?
ⓐ. Diazonium cyanation followed by nitrile hydrolysis is suitable; direct KCN displacement at unactivated bromobenzene is not
ⓑ. The second strategy is more suitable because bromobenzene has an aromatic \(sp^2\) carbon that permits easier backside attack than an alkyl bromide
ⓒ. The first sequence gives benzoic acid without bromine because cuprous cyanide necessarily replaces every halogen attached to the ring
ⓓ. Neither strategy can introduce a carboxyl group because an aromatic nitrile cannot undergo hydrolysis
Correct Answer: Diazonium cyanation followed by nitrile hydrolysis is suitable; direct KCN displacement at unactivated bromobenzene is not
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the required carbon connectivity:}\)
The target is 4-bromobenzoic acid.
Its carboxyl group and bromine atom must occupy para positions on the benzene ring.
The starting 4-bromoaniline already contains the required aromatic bromine at the correct position relative to the amino group.
\(\textbf{Convert the amino group into a leaving group:}\)
Diazotisation converts the aromatic amino group into a diazonium group:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4NH_2
\xrightarrow[\ 273-278\,K\ ]{NaNO_2/HCl}
4\!-\!BrC_6H_4N_2^+Cl^-}
\]
The original aromatic carbon–bromine bond remains intact.
\(\textbf{Introduce the nitrile carbon:}\)
Under appropriate Sandmeyer conditions, cuprous cyanide replaces the diazonium group by cyanide:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4N_2^+
\xrightarrow{CuCN}
4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CN+N_2}
\]
The product is 4-bromobenzonitrile.
The nitrile carbon is a newly introduced carbon atom bonded directly to the aromatic ring.
\(\textbf{Convert the nitrile into a carboxyl group:}\)
Suitable complete hydrolysis of the nitrile, followed by the required work-up, gives:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CN
\xrightarrow{H_2O/H^+,\ \Delta}
4\!-\!BrC_6H_4COOH}
\]
The final product is 4-bromobenzoic acid.
The carboxyl carbon is the carbon originally introduced through cyanide.
\(\textbf{Evaluate direct KCN treatment of bromobenzene:}\)
In bromobenzene, bromine is bonded directly to an aromatic \(sp^2\)-hybridised carbon.
This bond resists ordinary saturated-carbon \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) displacement.
Unactivated bromobenzene also lacks the nitro-group activation needed for the familiar aromatic addition–elimination mechanism.
Consequently, the second chemist's proposed ordinary KCN displacement is unsuitable.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the two cyanide-introduction pathways:}\)
Carbon-linked cyanide readily substitutes at suitable saturated alkyl-halide centres.
For the aromatic synthesis here, the cyanide group is instead introduced through displacement of an aromatic diazonium group.
The same carbon-containing substituent is installed by a different mechanism.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
A successful synthesis requires placing the new carbon atom at the intended aromatic position without relying on an unfavourable ordinary aryl-halide substitution.
The diazonium-to-nitrile route followed by hydrolysis accomplishes this transformation.
467. Three isomeric alkyl bromides are compared under identical concentrations and suitable reaction conditions:
| Compound | Structure | Approximate boiling point (°C) |
| P | \(\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH_2CH_2Br}\) | 102 |
| Q | \(\mathrm{CH_3CH(Br)CH_2CH_3}\) | 91 |
| R | \(\mathrm{(CH_3)_3CBr}\) | 73 |
Experiment I compares their tendencies towards carbocation-forming solvolysis in a strongly ionising solvent.
Experiment II compares their tendencies towards direct backside substitution with the same strong nucleophile under suitable \(S_\mathrm{N}2\)-favouring conditions.
Which conclusion is correct?
ⓐ. P has the lowest boiling point and the greatest ordinary solvolysis tendency, while R is most favourable for backside displacement
ⓑ. Q has the lowest boiling point, and its secondary carbon guarantees that it reacts fastest by both mechanisms
ⓒ. R has the lowest boiling point and is favoured for carbocation-forming solvolysis, while P is the least hindered of the three for ordinary backside substitution
ⓓ. R has the highest boiling point because its carbon–bromine bond is attached to a tertiary carbon, while P cannot undergo nucleophilic substitution
Correct Answer: R has the lowest boiling point and is favoured for carbocation-forming solvolysis, while P is the least hindered of the three for ordinary backside substitution
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the common molecular formula:}\)
All three compounds have the formula \(\mathrm{C_4H_9Br}\).
They contain the same number of carbon, hydrogen and bromine atoms.
However, the carbon skeleton and position of the bromine-bearing carbon differ.
\(\textbf{Interpret the boiling-point order:}\)
P is an unbranched primary bromide.
Q is a secondary bromide.
R is a highly branched tertiary bromide.
The supplied boiling points decrease from P to Q to R.
Greater branching generally reduces the effective surface area available for dispersion interactions between comparable molecular isomers.
\(\textbf{Examine carbocation-forming solvolysis:}\)
R can produce a relatively stable tertiary carbocation.
Q would form a less stable secondary carbocation.
P would require ordinary primary-carbocation formation for the corresponding simple ionisation pathway.
Thus, R is favoured for the stipulated carbocation-forming process.
\(\textbf{Examine direct backside substitution:}\)
An \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) reaction requires nucleophilic approach to the carbon bearing bromine.
P has a primary reaction centre and is comparatively accessible.
Q is more sterically hindered.
R is tertiary and strongly resists ordinary backside substitution.
\(\textbf{Connect the two reactivity orders:}\)
The substrate favoured for carbocation formation is not necessarily the substrate favoured for direct backside attack.
The two mechanisms respond differently to carbon substitution level.
\(\textbf{Avoid confusing physical and kinetic measurements:}\)
Boiling point describes a physical phase transition.
Substitution rate depends on the chemical mechanism, substrate and reaction conditions.
A low boiling point does not independently imply either a low or high substitution activation barrier.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Branching lowers the boiling point across the supplied isomers, favours carbocation formation at the tertiary centre and hinders ordinary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) attack.
R has the lowest boiling point and favoured ionisation tendency, while P is most accessible to backside substitution.
468. Bromoethane and ethanol are compared in an experiment involving water.
Sample P contains pure bromoethane.
Sample Q contains pure ethanol.
A third sample is prepared by complete hydrolysis of bromoethane using aqueous hydroxide, followed by removal of the inorganic salts.
Assume identical temperatures and that ethanol is completely miscible with water while bromoethane is only sparingly soluble.
Which statement best explains the observed difference in aqueous behaviour?
ⓐ. Bromoethane is sparingly soluble because its carbon–bromine bond is nonpolar, whereas ethanol is miscible because its carbon–oxygen bond is ionic
ⓑ. Ethanol hydrogen-bonds effectively with water; bromoethane does not. Complete hydrolysis converts bromoethane to ethanol
ⓒ. Bromoethane and ethanol must have identical solubilities because they contain the same number of carbon atoms
ⓓ. The hydrolysis product remains bromoethane because replacing bromine by hydroxide changes only the solvent and not the molecular structure
Correct Answer: Ethanol hydrogen-bonds effectively with water; bromoethane does not. Complete hydrolysis converts bromoethane to ethanol
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the structural difference:}\)
Bromoethane has the structure \(\mathrm{CH_3CH_2Br}\).
Ethanol has the structure \(\mathrm{CH_3CH_2OH}\).
Both contain a two-carbon alkyl group, but their functional groups differ.
\(\textbf{Examine bond polarity in bromoethane:}\)
Bromine is more electronegative than carbon.
Therefore, the carbon–bromine bond is polar covalent.
However, the presence of a polar bond does not guarantee extensive hydrogen bonding with water.
\(\textbf{Account for water's intermolecular structure:}\)
Water molecules interact strongly through hydrogen bonding.
Introducing another substance requires disruption and rearrangement of some of these interactions.
Favourable new solute–water interactions must compensate sufficiently for that change.
\(\textbf{Evaluate bromoethane:}\)
Bromoethane can participate in intermolecular interactions with water.
Nevertheless, it does not possess a hydroxyl group capable of donating an ordinary O–H hydrogen bond.
Its interactions with water do not provide the same extensive hydrogen-bonding network available to ethanol.
This helps explain its limited aqueous solubility.
\(\textbf{Evaluate ethanol:}\)
Ethanol contains an O–H group.
Its oxygen can accept hydrogen bonds, and its hydroxyl hydrogen can participate in hydrogen-bond donation.
The small ethyl group does not prevent favourable mixing with water.
Ethanol is consequently miscible with water.
\(\textbf{Follow the chemical transformation:}\)
Complete substitution of bromoethane by hydroxide gives:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2Br+OH^-
\rightarrow CH_3CH_2OH+Br^-}
\]
After removing inorganic salts, the organic product is ethanol.
Its interaction with water differs from that of the starting haloalkane.
\(\textbf{Distinguish solubility from ionic dissociation:}\)
Bromoethane's limited solubility does not mean that its carbon–bromine bond is nonpolar.
Likewise, ethanol's miscibility does not require complete ionisation of its molecules.
Solubility must be interpreted using the full set of intermolecular interactions.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Changing one functional group can transform the aqueous behaviour of a molecule while preserving its carbon skeleton.
The hydrolysis of bromoethane produces ethanol, whose hydrogen-bonding capability explains its much greater water miscibility.
469. Cinnamyl chloride, \(\mathrm{C_6H_5CH{=}CHCH_2Cl}\), is treated with water under two alternative, experimentally controlled mechanisms.
P: Direct backside substitution occurs exclusively at the carbon originally bearing chlorine.
Q: Chloride first departs to generate a resonance-stabilised allylic carbocation, which is then trapped by water at either of the two resonance-related electrophilic positions.
Assume no elimination, carbon-skeleton rearrangement or secondary reactions.
Which statement correctly distinguishes the possible alcohol products?
ⓐ. P gives cinnamyl alcohol, while Q can additionally give \(\mathrm{C_6H_5CH(OH)CH{=}CH_2}\), which possesses a stereogenic hydroxyl-bearing carbon
ⓑ. P gives only 1-phenylprop-2-en-1-ol, while Q necessarily gives phenylpropan-1-ol through complete hydrogenation
ⓒ. Both pathways must give only cinnamyl alcohol because resonance stabilisation cannot affect the position of nucleophilic capture
ⓓ. P and Q both give phenol because hydroxide always replaces a substituent directly on the benzene ring
Correct Answer: P gives cinnamyl alcohol, while Q can additionally give \(\mathrm{C_6H_5CH(OH)CH{=}CH_2}\), which possesses a stereogenic hydroxyl-bearing carbon
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the starting carbon–chlorine environment:}\)
Cinnamyl chloride contains chlorine attached to a saturated carbon adjacent to a carbon–carbon double bond.
It is therefore an allylic chloride.
Its adjacent double bond is also conjugated with a phenyl group.
\(\textbf{Follow the direct substitution in P:}\)
The stipulated backside substitution replaces chlorine at the original reaction centre:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH{=}CHCH_2Cl+OH^-
\rightarrow C_6H_5CH{=}CHCH_2OH+Cl^-}
\]
The product is cinnamyl alcohol, also called 3-phenylprop-2-en-1-ol.
The original carbon–carbon double-bond position remains unchanged.
\(\textbf{Form the allylic carbocation in Q:}\)
Ionisation gives an allylic cation:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH{=}CHCH_2^+}
\]
Its positive charge can be delocalised through the adjacent pi system.
\(\textbf{Identify the alternative resonance contributor:}\)
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH{=}CHCH_2^+
\leftrightarrow C_6H_5CH^+CH{=}CH_2}
\]
The alternative contributor has positive-charge character at the benzylic carbon.
This position also benefits from the neighbouring aromatic system.
\(\textbf{Determine capture at the original position:}\)
Water attack at the original chloromethyl carbon produces cinnamyl alcohol after deprotonation.
This is the same constitutional alcohol obtained through P.
\(\textbf{Determine capture at the alternative position:}\)
Water can instead attack the benzylic position represented in the second contributor.
The product is:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH(OH)CH{=}CH_2}
\]
It is 1-phenylprop-2-en-1-ol.
\(\textbf{Examine the new alcohol centre:}\)
The hydroxyl-bearing carbon in this second product is attached to hydroxyl, hydrogen, phenyl and vinyl groups.
These four substituents are different.
Therefore, this carbon is stereogenic, and the compound can exist as enantiomers.
\(\textbf{Distinguish resonance from carbon-skeleton rearrangement:}\)
Both possible products retain the same three-carbon chain attached to the aromatic ring.
No carbon–carbon sigma bond migration is required.
The difference arises from the location of nucleophilic capture within the delocalised allylic system.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
A concerted substitution at one carbon can give a single specified connectivity.
An allylic carbocation can permit alternative capture positions and create a product with a different stereochemical possibility.
470. Two para-brominated alkylbenzenes are heated separately with an excess of a suitable strong oxidising reagent, such as alkaline potassium permanganate, followed by acidification.
P: 4-Bromotoluene, \(\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH_3}\).
Q: 1-Bromo-4-tert-butylbenzene, \(\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4C(CH_3)_3}\).
Assume that the aromatic carbon–bromine bond remains intact and that the reaction is restricted to the usual benzylic side-chain oxidation pathway.
Which prediction is correct?
ⓐ. Both compounds give 4-bromobenzoic acid because the presence of any alkyl side chain guarantees complete oxidation
ⓑ. P resists oxidation because its methyl group contains only primary hydrogens, whereas Q gives 4-bromobenzoic acid
ⓒ. Both give bromobenzene because potassium permanganate always removes the alkyl side chain completely
ⓓ. P can give 4-bromobenzoic acid, whereas Q resists the stated benzylic oxidation because its carbon directly attached to the ring has no hydrogen
Correct Answer: P can give 4-bromobenzoic acid, whereas Q resists the stated benzylic oxidation because its carbon directly attached to the ring has no hydrogen
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two aromatic substituents:}\)
Both molecules contain bromine directly attached to a benzene-ring carbon.
They also contain an alkyl group para to bromine.
The distinction lies in the hydrogen environment of the carbon directly attached to the aromatic ring.
\(\textbf{Examine P's benzylic carbon:}\)
The methyl group of 4-bromotoluene contains three hydrogen atoms on the carbon directly attached to the benzene ring.
These are benzylic hydrogens.
Their presence permits the usual strong oxidation of the side chain.
\(\textbf{Predict the oxidation product from P:}\)
Under suitable conditions, the methyl substituent is oxidised to a carboxyl group:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH_3
\xrightarrow[\ H_3O^+\ ]{KMnO_4,\ \Delta}
4\!-\!BrC_6H_4COOH}
\]
The organic product is 4-bromobenzoic acid.
The aromatic bromine atom remains attached to the ring.
\(\textbf{Examine Q's benzylic carbon:}\)
The tert-butyl substituent is attached to the aromatic ring through its central carbon.
That carbon is bonded to the ring and three methyl groups.
It has no directly attached hydrogen.
\(\textbf{Apply the benzylic-hydrogen requirement:}\)
The ordinary oxidation of an alkylbenzene side chain to a benzoic acid derivative requires an appropriate benzylic hydrogen.
Q lacks such a hydrogen.
Therefore, it resists the stipulated conventional benzylic oxidation pathway.
\(\textbf{Distinguish terminal methyl hydrogens from benzylic hydrogens:}\)
Q contains three methyl groups with carbon–hydrogen bonds.
However, those methyl carbons are one additional carbon–carbon bond away from the aromatic ring.
Their hydrogens are not attached to the benzylic carbon.
Counting every hydrogen in the alkyl substituent would therefore give an incorrect prediction.
\(\textbf{Integrate the aromatic carbon–halogen bond:}\)
The existing aromatic carbon–bromine bond is not the intended reaction centre.
Both experiments preserve it under the supplied assumptions.
The observed difference is caused by the side-chain structure rather than by a change in the halogen.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The presence of a benzylic hydrogen, not merely an alkyl substituent, is the key structural requirement for the usual side-chain oxidation.
P gives 4-bromobenzoic acid, whereas Q resists the specified transformation.
471. An idealised photochemical study examines bond cleavage in dichlorodifluoromethane, \(\mathrm{CCl_2F_2}\).
Two monochromatic light sources are used:
P: Wavelength \(300\ \mathrm{nm}\).
Q: Wavelength \(260\ \mathrm{nm}\).
Assume that the molecules absorb the photons and that an individual bond can undergo the specified single-photon homolysis only when photon energy is at least its bond dissociation enthalpy.
Given:
\[
D(\mathrm{C-Cl})=351\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\[
D(\mathrm{C-F})=452\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\[
E_{\mathrm{photon,molar}}=\frac{N_Ahc}{\lambda}
\]
Use \(N_Ahc=1.196\times10^{-1}\ \mathrm{J\,m\,mol^{-1}}\).
Which conclusion is correct under this idealised model?
ⓐ. P supplies enough energy for C–Cl homolysis but not C–F homolysis; Q supplies enough energy for the specified homolysis of either bond type
ⓑ. P supplies enough energy for neither bond, while Q supplies enough only for C–Cl homolysis
ⓒ. P and Q supply identical photon energies because both wavelengths lie in the ultraviolet region
ⓓ. P supplies enough energy for C–F homolysis, while Q cannot cleave C–Cl because its wavelength is shorter
Correct Answer: P supplies enough energy for C–Cl homolysis but not C–F homolysis; Q supplies enough energy for the specified homolysis of either bond type
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the energy–wavelength relation:}\)
Photon energy is inversely proportional to wavelength.
A shorter wavelength corresponds to greater energy per photon.
Therefore, source Q should supply more energy per photon than source P.
\(\textbf{Calculate the energy from source P:}\)
Convert wavelength into metres:
\[
\lambda_P=300\ \mathrm{nm}=300\times10^{-9}\ \mathrm{m}
\]
Apply:
\[
E_P=\frac{N_Ahc}{\lambda_P}
\]
\[
E_P=\frac{1.196\times10^{-1}}{300\times10^{-9}}
\ \mathrm{J\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\[
E_P=3.987\times10^5\ \mathrm{J\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\[
E_P=398.7\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Compare P with both bond thresholds:}\)
\[
351\lt 398.7\lt 452
\]
Thus, P exceeds the supplied C–Cl threshold but not the C–F threshold.
\(\textbf{Calculate the energy from source Q:}\)
\[
\lambda_Q=260\times10^{-9}\ \mathrm{m}
\]
\[
E_Q=\frac{1.196\times10^{-1}}{260\times10^{-9}}
\]
\[
E_Q=4.600\times10^5\ \mathrm{J\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\[
E_Q=460.0\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Compare Q with both bond thresholds:}\)
\[
460.0\gt 452\gt 351
\]
Thus, Q exceeds both specified bond dissociation thresholds.
\(\textbf{Interpret the chemical distinction:}\)
Freon-12 contains carbon–chlorine and carbon–fluorine bonds with different strengths.
Sufficiently energetic radiation can generate radical fragments through homolytic cleavage.
However, the energetic accessibility of a bond-cleavage event does not establish its actual quantum yield or frequency.
\(\textbf{Recognise the photochemical limitation:}\)
The question explicitly assumes appropriate photon absorption and idealised bond-energy thresholds.
Actual molecular photochemistry additionally depends on absorption probabilities, excited-state pathways and competing relaxation processes.
The calculation should therefore not be interpreted as a complete atmospheric photolysis model.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\begin{aligned}
E_P&=398.7\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}\\
E_Q&=460.0\ \mathrm{kJ\,mol^{-1}}
\end{aligned}
\]
Under the stipulated thresholds, P permits C–Cl but not C–F homolysis, while Q permits either.
472. A tertiary alkyl bromide, 2-bromo-2-methylpropane, is allowed to react with water in a polar protic medium. Under one set of conditions, substitution to 2-methylpropan-2-ol is important. On increasing the temperature, formation of 2-methylpropene by elimination becomes more competitive. Which explanation is most appropriate?
ⓐ. Substitution and elimination are both concerted \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) pathways, so no carbocation can form
ⓑ. Both pathways may follow carbocation formation; heating can make E1 relatively more competitive
ⓒ. E1 is impossible for tertiary alkyl halides because they have no beta hydrogen atoms
ⓓ. Heating necessarily converts every substitution reaction into elimination, regardless of solvent and reactants
Correct Answer: Both pathways may follow carbocation formation; heating can make E1 relatively more competitive
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the substrate:}\)
2-Bromo-2-methylpropane is a tertiary alkyl bromide. Ionisation in a suitable polar protic medium can produce the relatively stable tert-butyl carbocation:
\[
\mathrm{(CH_3)_3CBr\rightarrow (CH_3)_3C^++Br^-}
\]
This ionisation is the characteristic first step of a conventional \(S_\mathrm{N}1\) or E1 pathway.
\(\textbf{Follow the substitution branch:}\)
Water can attack the carbocation. Subsequent loss of a proton gives 2-methylpropan-2-ol, a substitution product in which the carbon skeleton remains unchanged.
\(\textbf{Follow the elimination branch:}\)
A solvent or base molecule can instead remove a beta hydrogen from a methyl group adjacent to the positively charged carbon. This gives 2-methylpropene:
\[
\mathrm{(CH_3)_3C^+\rightarrow (CH_3)_2C{=}CH_2+H^+}
\]
The displayed equation summarises the proton-transfer result; an appropriate base accepts the proton.
\(\textbf{Assess the effect of temperature:}\)
Elimination often becomes relatively more competitive at higher temperature, but temperature alone does not guarantee a unique product or completely exclude substitution. Substrate, nucleophile, base and solvent conditions still matter.
\(\textbf{Conclusion:}\)
The correct comparison recognises a common carbocation intermediate and two different product-forming events: nucleophilic attack for substitution and beta-proton removal for elimination.
473. 4-Bromoethylbenzene, \(\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH_2CH_3}\), is used in two independent carbon-chain extension routes.
Route P: Selective benzylic monochlorination using \(\mathrm{Cl_2/h\nu}\), followed by substitution of the benzylic chlorine with alcoholic KCN and complete hydrolysis of the nitrile.
Route Q: Formation of the arylmagnesium bromide from the aromatic carbon–bromine bond using magnesium in dry ether, followed by dry \(\mathrm{CO_2}\) and acidic hydrolysis.
Assume that each route is selective for the stated reaction centre and proceeds without rearrangement or competing reactions.
Which comparison correctly identifies the two acids?
ⓐ. P gives 2-(4-bromophenyl)propanoic acid, whereas Q gives 4-ethylbenzoic acid; each acid contains nine carbon atoms
ⓑ. P gives 4-bromobenzoic acid, whereas Q gives 4-ethylbenzoic acid; each acid contains seven carbon atoms
ⓒ. P gives 2-(4-bromophenyl)propanoic acid, whereas Q gives 4-bromobenzoic acid; each acid contains nine carbon atoms
ⓓ. P gives 4-ethylbenzoic acid, whereas Q gives 2-(4-bromophenyl)propanoic acid; each acid contains eight carbon atoms
Correct Answer: P gives 2-(4-bromophenyl)propanoic acid, whereas Q gives 4-ethylbenzoic acid; each acid contains nine carbon atoms
Explanation: \(\textbf{Distinguish the two original reaction centres:}\)
The starting compound contains bromine directly attached to an aromatic carbon.
Its ethyl side chain contains benzylic carbon–hydrogen bonds that can undergo radical chlorination.
The two routes therefore introduce new functional groups at different positions of the same initial eight-carbon skeleton.
\(\textbf{Route P — Introduce a benzylic leaving group:}\)
Controlled photochemical chlorination replaces one benzylic hydrogen:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH_2CH_3
\xrightarrow{Cl_2/h\nu}
4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH(Cl)CH_3}
\]
The aromatic carbon–bromine bond remains intact under the stipulated conditions.
\(\textbf{Route P — Extend the side chain:}\)
Cyanide substitutes for benzylic chlorine through its carbon end:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH(Cl)CH_3
\xrightarrow{KCN}
4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH(CN)CH_3}
\]
The nitrile carbon is newly introduced and will become the carboxyl carbon after complete hydrolysis:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH(CN)CH_3
\xrightarrow[\ hydrolysis\ ]{H_3O^+}
4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH(COOH)CH_3}
\]
The product is 2-(4-bromophenyl)propanoic acid.
Its nine carbon atoms comprise six aromatic, two original side-chain and one introduced nitrile carbon.
\(\textbf{Route Q — Activate the aromatic C–Br bond:}\)
In the separate starting sample, magnesium insertion gives the arylmagnesium bromide:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH_2CH_3+Mg
\xrightarrow{dry\ ether}
4\!-\!MgBrC_6H_4CH_2CH_3}
\]
Dry carbon dioxide introduces a carboxyl carbon at the original aromatic carbon–magnesium position.
Following acidic hydrolysis, the product is:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!HOOC-C_6H_4CH_2CH_3}
\]
This is 4-ethylbenzoic acid, which also contains nine carbon atoms.
\(\textbf{Compare the carbon connectivity:}\)
Both routes add one carbon atom, but the newly formed carbon–carbon bonds occur at different sites.
P retains aromatic bromine and creates a carboxyl group on the side chain.
Q replaces the aromatic bromine-derived organomagnesium group with a carboxyl group while retaining the ethyl side chain.
Equal carbon counts do not imply identical product connectivity.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
P gives 2-(4-bromophenyl)propanoic acid, while Q gives 4-ethylbenzoic acid.
Their distinction follows from selecting the correct starting carbon–halogen or benzylic reaction centre.
474. Two isomeric tetrabromobutanes undergo complete hydrolysis of all their geminal carbon–bromine groups under conditions favouring the corresponding stable carbonyl compounds.
P: 2,2,3,3-Tetrabromobutane, \(\mathrm{CH_3CBr_2CBr_2CH_3}\).
Q: 1,1,4,4-Tetrabromobutane, \(\mathrm{CHBr_2CH_2CH_2CHBr_2}\).
Assume complete intended conversion without carbon–carbon bond cleavage, oxidation or rearrangement.
Which pair correctly identifies the organic products?
ⓐ. P gives butane-1,4-dial; Q gives butane-2,3-dione
ⓑ. Both give butane-2,3-dione because each starting compound contains four bromine atoms
ⓒ. P gives butane-2,3-dione; Q gives butane-1,4-dial
ⓓ. P gives butane-2-one; Q gives butane-1,4-diol
Correct Answer: P gives butane-2,3-dione; Q gives butane-1,4-dial
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the geminal dihalide units:}\)
A geminal dibromide contains two bromine atoms attached to the same carbon.
Both starting molecules possess two such groups.
However, the positions of the geminal groups within the four-carbon chain are different.
\(\textbf{Recall the hydrolysis consequence:}\)
Suitable complete hydrolysis of a geminal dihalide formally replaces both halogens by hydroxyl groups.
The resulting geminal diol is associated with the corresponding stable carbonyl compound.
Whether an aldehyde or ketone forms depends on the substituents originally attached to that carbon.
\(\textbf{Examine P's two reactive carbons:}\)
P has the structure:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CBr_2CBr_2CH_3}
\]
Both bromine-bearing carbons lie within the carbon chain.
Each is attached to two carbon atoms.
Therefore, each can become a ketone carbonyl carbon.
\(\textbf{Predict P's product:}\)
Complete hydrolysis gives:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3COCOCH_3}
\]
This compound is butane-2,3-dione.
It contains two adjacent ketone groups.
\(\textbf{Examine Q's two reactive carbons:}\)
Q has the structure:
\[
\mathrm{CHBr_2CH_2CH_2CHBr_2}
\]
The two geminal dibromide groups occur at the terminal carbons.
Each terminal carbon carries a hydrogen atom.
Therefore, each forms an aldehyde group after the intended hydrolysis.
\(\textbf{Predict Q's product:}\)
The final structure is:
\[
\mathrm{OHCCH_2CH_2CHO}
\]
This compound is butane-1,4-dial.
Its two aldehyde groups occupy the ends of the carbon chain.
\(\textbf{Check carbon and oxygen placement:}\)
Neither reaction changes the number of carbon atoms.
Each starting molecule produces a compound containing two carbonyl oxygen atoms.
However, the oxygen atoms become attached to different carbon positions, resulting in different functional-group arrangements.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The number of bromine atoms alone cannot determine the carbonyl product.
The locations of the geminal dihalide groups decide whether complete hydrolysis produces a diketone or a dialdehyde.
475. 2-Phenylpropene, \(\mathrm{C_6H_5C(CH_3){=}CH_2}\), is subjected to two separate HBr additions.
P: Ordinary HBr addition in the absence of peroxides.
Q: HBr addition with a suitable peroxide initiator.
The resulting bromides are then compared under two distinct conditions: strongly ionising solvolysis and direct backside substitution with a strong nucleophile.
Assume that the ordinary regioselectivity is obtained in each addition and that no rearrangement occurs in the later substitutions.
Which statement correctly predicts the products and their contrasting substitution tendencies?
ⓐ. P forms a primary benzylic bromide and is therefore favoured for \(S_\mathrm{N}2\), whereas Q forms a tertiary bromide and is favoured for \(S_\mathrm{N}1\)
ⓑ. P forms a tertiary benzylic bromide favoured for carbocation-forming solvolysis, whereas Q forms a primary bromide more accessible to ordinary backside substitution
ⓒ. Both give the same tertiary benzylic bromide because a phenyl group enforces identical regioselectivity in ionic and radical additions
ⓓ. P gives an aryl bromide, while Q gives a vinylic bromide that cannot undergo any saturated-carbon substitution
Correct Answer: P forms a tertiary benzylic bromide favoured for carbocation-forming solvolysis, whereas Q forms a primary bromide more accessible to ordinary backside substitution
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the unsymmetrical alkene:}\)
The starting compound has a terminal double bond adjacent to a carbon bearing phenyl and methyl groups.
Its two alkene carbons are not equivalent.
HBr addition can therefore place bromine at different positions depending on the mechanism.
\(\textbf{Follow the ionic addition in P:}\)
In the absence of peroxides, protonation occurs preferentially in the direction producing a relatively stable carbocation.
Addition of hydrogen to the terminal carbon produces a tertiary benzylic carbocation:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5C^+(CH_3)_2}
\]
This carbocation benefits from both alkyl substitution and benzylic resonance stabilisation.
\(\textbf{Identify P's bromide:}\)
Bromide capture produces:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5C(Br)(CH_3)_2}
\]
The product is 2-bromo-2-phenylpropane.
Its bromine-bearing carbon is tertiary and benzylic.
\(\textbf{Follow the radical addition in Q:}\)
Under suitable peroxide conditions, a bromine radical adds to the terminal alkene carbon.
This generates a more stable tertiary benzylic carbon radical on the neighbouring carbon.
Hydrogen abstraction from HBr subsequently produces:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH(CH_3)CH_2Br}
\]
The product is 1-bromo-2-phenylpropane.
Its bromine-bearing carbon is primary.
\(\textbf{Compare carbocation-forming solvolysis:}\)
P can ionise to a highly stabilised tertiary benzylic carbocation.
Q would require initial formation of a much less favourable ordinary primary carbocation through direct ionisation of its terminal carbon–bromine bond.
Therefore, P is strongly favoured for the stipulated \(S_\mathrm{N}1\)-type comparison.
\(\textbf{Compare backside substitution:}\)
Q contains an accessible primary bromomethyl group.
A strong nucleophile can attack that saturated carbon through an ordinary backside displacement.
P has a crowded tertiary reaction centre and resists \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) substitution.
\(\textbf{Integrate the two mechanistic decisions:}\)
The ionic and radical HBr additions differ because they favour different reactive intermediates.
Those regioselectivities then create bromides with different carbon substitution levels.
Consequently, the later preferred nucleophilic substitution mechanism also changes.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The conditions used to prepare an alkyl bromide can determine its later mechanistic reactivity.
Ordinary HBr addition produces a tertiary benzylic bromide, while peroxide-assisted addition produces a primary bromide.
476. 4-Bromobenzyl bromide, \(\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH_2Br}\), is subjected to two alternative routes.
Route P: Selective benzylic substitution using alcoholic KCN, followed by complete hydrolysis of the resulting nitrile.
Route Q: Selective benzylic hydrolysis to an alcohol, followed by strong oxidation of the benzylic alcohol to a carboxylic acid.
Assume that the aromatic carbon–bromine bond remains intact and that no carbon–carbon bond cleavage or rearrangement occurs.
Which statement correctly identifies the final products and their different carbon counts?
ⓐ. P gives 4-bromobenzoic acid with seven carbons, whereas Q gives 4-bromophenylacetic acid with eight carbons
ⓑ. Both give 4-bromobenzoic acid because introduction of cyanide does not introduce an additional carbon atom
ⓒ. P gives 4-bromophenylacetic acid with eight carbons, whereas Q gives 4-bromobenzoic acid with seven carbons
ⓓ. Both give 4-bromophenylacetic acid because oxidation always introduces one additional carbon atom
Correct Answer: P gives 4-bromophenylacetic acid with eight carbons, whereas Q gives 4-bromobenzoic acid with seven carbons
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the reactive and retained carbon–halogen bonds:}\)
The starting compound contains two bromine atoms.
One is attached directly to an aromatic carbon.
The other is attached to a saturated benzylic methylene carbon.
The question specifies that the aromatic bromine remains attached throughout both routes.
\(\textbf{Follow the cyanide substitution in P:}\)
Carbon-linked cyanide replaces the benzylic bromine:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH_2Br+CN^-
\rightarrow4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH_2CN+Br^-}
\]
The product is 4-bromophenylacetonitrile.
The cyanide group introduces one additional carbon atom.
\(\textbf{Hydrolyse the nitrile:}\)
Complete hydrolysis converts its nitrile carbon into a carboxyl carbon:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH_2CN
\xrightarrow{H_2O/H^+,\ \Delta}
4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH_2COOH}
\]
The product is 4-bromophenylacetic acid.
It contains six ring carbons, one benzylic methylene carbon and one newly introduced carboxyl carbon.
\(\textbf{Count the carbon atoms in P's product:}\)
\[
N_{C,P}=6+1+1
\]
\[
N_{C,P}=8
\]
\(\textbf{Follow the hydrolysis in Q:}\)
The benzylic bromine is replaced directly by hydroxyl:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH_2Br
\rightarrow4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH_2OH}
\]
The product is 4-bromobenzyl alcohol.
It contains the original seven carbon atoms.
\(\textbf{Oxidise the benzylic alcohol:}\)
Strong oxidation converts the benzylic carbon into the carboxyl carbon:
\[
\mathrm{4\!-\!BrC_6H_4CH_2OH
\xrightarrow{[O]}
4\!-\!BrC_6H_4COOH}
\]
The product is 4-bromobenzoic acid.
Its carboxyl group is attached directly to the aromatic ring.
\(\textbf{Count the carbon atoms in Q's product:}\)
\[
N_{C,Q}=6+1
\]
\[
N_{C,Q}=7
\]
\(\textbf{Distinguish carbon introduction from carbon oxidation:}\)
Route P creates a new carbon–carbon bond by introducing the cyanide carbon.
That additional carbon eventually becomes the carboxyl carbon.
Route Q changes the functional group of an already existing benzylic carbon.
It does not introduce an extra carbon atom.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Both routes convert a benzylic carbon–bromine bond into a carboxylic acid-containing product while retaining the aromatic bromine.
However, cyanide incorporation extends the carbon skeleton, whereas oxidation preserves it.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
N_{C,P}=8,\qquad N_{C,Q}=7
\]
477. Two experiments investigate the reaction of bromoethane with hydroxide under conditions where the only reaction is an elementary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) substitution:
\[
\mathrm{C_2H_5Br+OH^-\rightarrow C_2H_5OH+Br^-}
\]
In each experiment, the initial concentrations of bromoethane and hydroxide are equal. Neither reactant is replenished, and both are consumed in a \(1:1\) ratio.
| Experiment | Initial concentration of each reactant | Time for half the initial bromoethane to react |
| P | \(0.100\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\) | \(50.0\ \mathrm{min}\) |
| Q | \(0.200\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\) | \(25.0\ \mathrm{min}\) |
Assume constant temperature, volume and rate constant.
Which pair correctly gives the second-order rate constant and the predicted half-life when the initial concentration of each reactant is \(0.250\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\)?
ⓐ. \(0.100\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}\,min^{-1}}\); \(40.0\ \mathrm{min}\)
ⓑ. \(0.200\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}\,min^{-1}}\); \(20.0\ \mathrm{min}\)
ⓒ. \(0.0200\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}\,min^{-1}}\); \(20.0\ \mathrm{min}\)
ⓓ. \(0.200\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}\,min^{-1}}\); \(40.0\ \mathrm{min}\)
Correct Answer: \(0.200\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}\,min^{-1}}\); \(20.0\ \mathrm{min}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the elementary rate law:}\)
The reaction is specified to follow an \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) mechanism.
Therefore, its rate depends on both bromoethane and hydroxide concentrations:
\[
r=k[\mathrm{C_2H_5Br}][\mathrm{OH^-}]
\]
The two initial concentrations are equal, and the reactants are consumed in equal amounts.
Consequently, their concentrations remain equal throughout each experiment.
\(\textbf{Simplify the rate expression:}\)
Let their common concentration at any instant be \(c\).
Then:
\[
-\frac{dc}{dt}=kc^2
\]
For equal initial reactant concentrations \(c_0\), integration gives:
\[
\frac1c-\frac1{c_0}=kt
\]
\(\textbf{Obtain the half-life relation:}\)
At half-life:
\[
c=\frac{c_0}{2}
\]
Therefore:
\[
\frac{2}{c_0}-\frac1{c_0}=kt_{1/2}
\]
\[
t_{1/2}=\frac1{kc_0}
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the rate constant using P:}\)
\[
k=\frac1{t_{1/2}c_0}
\]
\[
k=\frac1{(50.0)(0.100)}
\]
\[
k=0.200\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}\,min^{-1}}
\]
\(\textbf{Verify with Q:}\)
\[
k=\frac1{(25.0)(0.200)}
\]
\[
k=0.200\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}\,min^{-1}}
\]
The observations are consistent with the same second-order rate constant.
\(\textbf{Predict the changed-concentration half-life:}\)
For \(c_0=0.250\ \mathrm{mol\,L^{-1}}\):
\[
t_{1/2}=\frac1{(0.200)(0.250)}
\]
\[
t_{1/2}=20.0\ \mathrm{min}
\]
\(\textbf{Interpret the kinetic distinction:}\)
This half-life decreases when the common initial concentration increases.
That behaviour differs from an ordinary first-order reaction, whose half-life is independent of initial substrate concentration.
It also differs from pseudo-first-order \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) conditions, where one reactant is maintained in large excess.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{k=0.200\ \mathrm{L\,mol^{-1}\,min^{-1}},\qquad t_{1/2}=20.0\ \mathrm{min}}
\]
478. An isotopically labelled alkyl bromide, \(\mathrm{BrCH_2CH(D)CH_3}\), contains ordinary hydrogen and deuterium on the carbon adjacent to the bromine-bearing carbon.
It undergoes E2 elimination through either of two possible beta-hydrogen-removal events.
Pathway P removes the ordinary hydrogen from the beta carbon.
Pathway Q removes deuterium from that carbon.
Assume that bromide leaves from carbon 1 in both pathways, no isotope exchange occurs, and no other elimination site is available.
Which statement correctly distinguishes the alkene products?
ⓐ. P gives ordinary propene, while Q gives deuterium-labelled propene
ⓑ. Both pathways give ordinary propene because deuterium cannot remain attached to an alkene carbon
ⓒ. P gives \(\mathrm{CH_2{=}C(D)CH_3}\), whereas Q gives \(\mathrm{CH_2{=}CHCH_3}\); the isotope retained in the alkene identifies which beta substituent was removed
ⓓ. Both pathways give \(\mathrm{CH_2{=}C(D)CH_3}\), because E2 elimination removes bromine but cannot remove deuterium
Correct Answer: P gives \(\mathrm{CH_2{=}C(D)CH_3}\), whereas Q gives \(\mathrm{CH_2{=}CHCH_3}\); the isotope retained in the alkene identifies which beta substituent was removed
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the alpha and beta carbons:}\)
The starting bromide has the structure:
\[
\mathrm{BrCH_2CH(D)CH_3}
\]
Carbon 1 is the alpha carbon because it bears bromine.
Carbon 2 is the beta carbon and bears hydrogen, deuterium and a methyl group.
\(\textbf{Apply the E2 mechanism:}\)
In an E2 event, a base removes a beta hydrogen isotope while the leaving group departs.
A carbon–carbon double bond forms between the alpha and beta carbons.
The relevant bonds must achieve suitable antiperiplanar alignment.
\(\textbf{Follow Pathway P:}\)
The base removes ordinary hydrogen from carbon 2.
Deuterium remains bonded to that carbon.
Bromide leaves carbon 1, and the new double bond forms:
\[
\mathrm{BrCH_2CH(D)CH_3
\rightarrow CH_2{=}C(D)CH_3+HBr}
\]
The product is deuterium-labelled propene.
\(\textbf{Follow Pathway Q:}\)
The base instead removes deuterium from carbon 2.
The ordinary hydrogen remains attached to the alkene carbon:
\[
\mathrm{BrCH_2CH(D)CH_3
\rightarrow CH_2{=}CHCH_3+DBr}
\]
The organic product is ordinary propene.
\(\textbf{Track the isotope independently of the carbon skeleton:}\)
Both pathways produce a three-carbon alkene with the double bond between carbons 1 and 2.
The structural distinction is whether deuterium remains in the organic product or leaves in the hydrogen halide.
Neither pathway requires carbon–carbon bond rearrangement.
\(\textbf{Recognise the kinetic qualification:}\)
Carbon–hydrogen and carbon–deuterium bonds can have different rates of cleavage.
However, the problem does not supply kinetic isotope-effect information.
Therefore, the relative amounts of the two alkene products cannot be calculated from the structures alone.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Isotopic labelling can reveal which beta bond was broken during elimination.
The presence or absence of deuterium in the alkene provides information that would be lost if only the constitutional alkene formula were considered.
479. An aromatic compound has the following substitution pattern:
A benzene ring contains fluorine at carbon 1, chlorine at carbon 3 and a nitro group at carbon 4. Fluorine is para to the nitro group. Chlorine is ortho to the nitro group. The two halogens are meta to one another.
The compound is treated with a limited amount of sodium methoxide under conditions favouring activated aromatic addition–elimination substitution.
Assume that both halogen-bearing positions are electronically accessible to the mechanism, that the reaction is under kinetic control, and that the fluorine-bearing position has the faster nucleophilic addition pathway.
Which product is expected to predominate?
ⓐ. 1-Fluoro-3-methoxy-4-nitrobenzene, formed by displacement of aromatic chlorine
ⓑ. 1-Fluoro-3-chloro-4-methoxybenzene, formed by displacement of the nitro group
ⓒ. 1-Methoxy-3-fluoro-4-nitrobenzene, formed by exchange of the positions of the two halogens
ⓓ. 1-Methoxy-3-chloro-4-nitrobenzene, formed by displacement of aromatic fluorine
Correct Answer: 1-Methoxy-3-chloro-4-nitrobenzene, formed by displacement of aromatic fluorine
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the aromatic reaction class:}\)
Both halogens are bonded directly to aromatic carbon atoms.
The reaction is therefore not an ordinary saturated-carbon \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) displacement.
The specified conditions favour nucleophilic aromatic addition followed by elimination.
\(\textbf{Examine the nitro-group activation:}\)
A strongly electron-withdrawing nitro group can stabilise the negatively charged addition intermediate when positioned ortho or para to the leaving halogen.
The relevant resonance stabilisation facilitates nucleophilic attack at an activated aromatic carbon.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the fluorine-bearing position:}\)
Fluorine occupies carbon 1.
The nitro group occupies carbon 4, making it para to fluorine.
Therefore, the fluorine-bearing position is activated for the stipulated nucleophilic aromatic substitution.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the chlorine-bearing position:}\)
Chlorine occupies carbon 3.
The nitro group at carbon 4 is ortho to chlorine.
This position is also electronically activated for an appropriate addition–elimination pathway.
\(\textbf{Identify the additional selectivity condition:}\)
The question explicitly states that the fluorine-bearing position has the faster nucleophilic addition pathway.
Under kinetic control, the faster pathway predominates when reagent availability limits extensive further reaction.
Therefore, methoxide chiefly attacks carbon 1.
\(\textbf{Predict the leaving group:}\)
Methoxide forms a carbon–oxygen bond at carbon 1.
The addition intermediate subsequently eliminates fluoride, restoring aromaticity.
Chlorine remains attached to carbon 3, and the nitro group remains at carbon 4.
\(\textbf{Write the product connectivity:}\)
The intended product has methoxy at carbon 1, chlorine at carbon 3 and nitro at carbon 4.
It is represented as 1-methoxy-3-chloro-4-nitrobenzene using the original ring numbering.
\(\textbf{Avoid an ordinary leaving-group shortcut:}\)
Fluoride is usually a poor leaving group in simple alkyl-halide \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) substitution.
However, appropriately activated aromatic addition–elimination reactions can show a different halogen reactivity order.
It would therefore be incorrect to predict chlorine displacement solely from ordinary alkyl-halide leaving-group trends.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Both the position of the nitro group and the mechanism-specific kinetic evidence are needed.
The stipulated faster attack at aromatic fluorine leads predominantly to the methoxy-substituted product retaining aromatic chlorine.
480. Two separate substitution reactions follow the experimentally established rate laws:
Reaction P: \(r_P=k_P[\mathrm{RX}]\), consistent with an \(S_\mathrm{N}1\) pathway.
Reaction Q: \(r_Q=k_Q[\mathrm{RX}][\mathrm{Nu}]\), consistent with an \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) pathway.
Temperature and the respective rate constants are unchanged. In P, the alkyl-halide concentration is halved while nucleophile concentration is increased fourfold. In Q, the alkyl-halide concentration is doubled while nucleophile concentration is tripled. Which pair correctly gives the resulting rates relative to the initial rates of the same reactions?
ⓐ. P becomes \(2\) times its initial rate; Q becomes \(6\) times its initial rate
ⓑ. P becomes \(\tfrac12\) of its initial rate; Q becomes \(6\) times its initial rate
ⓒ. P becomes \(2\) times its initial rate; Q becomes \(\tfrac23\) of its initial rate
ⓓ. P becomes \(\tfrac18\) of its initial rate; Q becomes \(6\) times its initial rate
Correct Answer: P becomes \(\tfrac12\) of its initial rate; Q becomes \(6\) times its initial rate
Explanation: \(\textbf{Apply the rate law for P:}\)
The stated \(S_\mathrm{N}1\)-type rate law is first order in substrate but independent of nucleophile concentration. Halving the substrate concentration therefore halves the rate:
\[
\frac{r_{P,\mathrm{new}}}{r_{P,\mathrm{old}}}
=\frac{\tfrac12[\mathrm{RX}]}{[\mathrm{RX}]}
=\frac12
\]
Increasing nucleophile concentration fourfold does not alter this ratio because nucleophile concentration is absent from the specified rate law.
\(\textbf{Apply the rate law for Q:}\)
The \(S_\mathrm{N}2\)-type rate law depends on both substrate and nucleophile concentrations. The substrate contributes a factor of two, while the nucleophile contributes a factor of three:
\[
\frac{r_{Q,\mathrm{new}}}{r_{Q,\mathrm{old}}}=2\times3=6
\]
\(\textbf{Compare the independent changes:}\)
The rates of the two different reactions are compared only with their own original values; the problem does not assume that the two rate constants are equal. Applying one universal rate rule to both reactions would therefore give an incorrect result.
\(\textbf{Conclusion:}\)
P becomes half as fast under its stated concentration changes, whereas Q becomes six times as fast. The difference follows directly from the mechanism-specific concentration dependence.
481. An enantiomerically enriched sample of a secondary alkyl bromide undergoes solvolysis through a reversible carbocation-forming process:
\[
\mathrm{RBr\rightleftharpoons R^++Br^-}
\]
The planar carbocation may either recombine with bromide or react with water to form an alcohol.
Assume that:
I. Recombination can occur from either face of the carbocation.
II. Some carbocations recombine before reacting with water.
III. Neither the recovered alkyl bromide nor the alcohol undergoes any subsequent stereochemical change.
Which experimental observation is consistent with this model?
ⓐ. Recovered starting bromide may show reduced enantiomeric purity even when a substantial fraction of it has not been converted into alcohol
ⓑ. The recovered bromide must retain its original enantiomeric purity because optical changes are possible only after hydroxyl substitution
ⓒ. The model necessarily gives an exactly racemic alcohol and completely optically pure recovered bromide
ⓓ. Bromide recombination must form a carbon–carbon double bond rather than regenerate the carbon–bromine bond
Correct Answer: Recovered starting bromide may show reduced enantiomeric purity even when a substantial fraction of it has not been converted into alcohol
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the initial stereochemical information:}\)
The starting alkyl bromide is enantiomerically enriched.
Its reacting carbon therefore has a stereogenic environment.
Before ionisation, the starting sample contains unequal amounts of its two enantiomers.
\(\textbf{Examine the ionisation step:}\)
Cleavage of the carbon–bromine bond produces a carbocation.
The reaction centre becomes approximately planar.
The original tetrahedral stereochemical information at that carbon is no longer fully preserved in the carbocation geometry.
\(\textbf{Identify the two possible fates:}\)
The carbocation can be trapped by water, eventually forming an alcohol.
Alternatively, bromide can recombine with the carbocation to regenerate alkyl bromide.
Both pathways proceed from the same intermediate.
\(\textbf{Follow bromide recombination:}\)
The question permits bromide attack from either face.
Attack from one face regenerates one configuration at the reacting carbon.
Attack from the other face regenerates the opposite configuration.
Therefore, a molecule that returns to the alkyl bromide pool need not possess its original configuration.
\(\textbf{Interpret the recovered substrate:}\)
Recovered bromide can include molecules that never ionised and molecules that ionised before recombining.
These populations may have different stereochemical histories.
The recovered material may therefore exhibit lower enantiomeric purity than the initial sample.
\(\textbf{Distinguish conversion from configurational change:}\)
A molecule can undergo temporary ionisation and recombination without undergoing net constitutional substitution.
Nevertheless, its stereogenic carbon may change configuration during that sequence.
Consequently, a chemical sample can become less enantiomerically enriched without complete conversion into a different functional group.
\(\textbf{Avoid an unsupported numerical claim:}\)
The relative rates of ionisation, recombination and water capture are not provided.
The fraction of recovered bromide that changes configuration therefore cannot be calculated.
Exact racemisation of either product pool is not guaranteed by the stated information.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Reversible carbocation formation can affect the stereochemistry of recovered reactant as well as the substitution product.
Optical purity and net chemical conversion must be evaluated as separate properties.
482. Two sets of para-substituted aromatic halides are compared under different mechanisms.
Series P contains 4-methoxybenzyl chloride and 4-nitrobenzyl chloride, each subjected to ionising conditions favouring formation of a benzylic carbocation.
Series Q contains 4-methoxyfluorobenzene and 4-nitrofluorobenzene, each subjected to methoxide substitution under conditions favouring aromatic addition–elimination where suitable.
Assume comparable conditions within each series and no competing reactions.
Which statement correctly predicts the opposing effects of the methoxy and nitro groups?
ⓐ. The para-nitro group favours both mechanisms because an electron-withdrawing substituent stabilises every possible charged intermediate
ⓑ. The para-methoxy group favours both mechanisms because it is electron donating, regardless of the sign of charge developing in the relevant intermediate
ⓒ. Methoxy-substituted compounds must have identical rates in both series because the methoxy group occupies the same aromatic position
ⓓ. Para-methoxy substitution favours benzylic-carbocation stabilisation in P, while para-nitro substitution favours anionic addition-intermediate stabilisation in Q
Correct Answer: Para-methoxy substitution favours benzylic-carbocation stabilisation in P, while para-nitro substitution favours anionic addition-intermediate stabilisation in Q
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the different reaction centres:}\)
The benzyl chlorides contain chlorine attached to a saturated benzylic carbon.
The fluoroarenes contain fluorine attached directly to an aromatic carbon.
Therefore, the two series do not undergo the same kind of nucleophilic substitution.
\(\textbf{Examine the specified process in Series P:}\)
Ionisation of a benzyl chloride produces a benzylic carbocation.
Positive charge can be delocalised through the aromatic system.
A para substituent can affect the stability of the resulting cation through resonance.
\(\textbf{Determine the effect of methoxy in P:}\)
Methoxy can donate electron density into the aromatic ring by resonance.
When positioned para to the benzylic carbon, it can stabilise positive-charge character in suitable benzylic-carbocation resonance contributors.
This favours the ionisation pathway relative to an otherwise corresponding strongly electron-withdrawing substitution pattern.
\(\textbf{Determine the effect of nitro in P:}\)
Nitro is strongly electron withdrawing.
Its electronic effect does not provide the same favourable stabilisation of a positively charged benzylic resonance system.
Therefore, it is less favourable for the stipulated carbocation-forming tendency.
\(\textbf{Examine Series Q:}\)
Methoxide attacks the aromatic carbon bearing fluorine in an activated addition–elimination pathway.
The addition intermediate has negative-charge character distributed through the aromatic system.
Its stabilisation is electronically different from stabilisation of a benzyl carbocation.
\(\textbf{Determine the effect of nitro in Q:}\)
A para nitro group can stabilise the anionic aromatic addition intermediate through electron withdrawal and resonance.
This electronic activation facilitates the stated nucleophilic aromatic substitution.
\(\textbf{Determine the effect of methoxy in Q:}\)
Methoxy is a resonance electron donor.
It does not provide the strong anionic-intermediate stabilisation supplied by a para nitro group.
Thus, the corresponding methoxyfluorobenzene is less activated for the stipulated aromatic substitution pathway.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The effect of an aromatic substituent depends on which intermediate or transition state the mechanism requires.
Electron donation can favour positive-charge stabilisation, whereas electron withdrawal can favour negative-charge stabilisation.
The qualitative substituent preference therefore reverses between the two series.
483. The following data refer to methyl halides at ordinary pressure:
| Compound | Normal boiling point (°C) | C–X bond enthalpy (kJ mol\(^{-1}\)) |
| \(\mathrm{CH_3Cl}\) | −24 | 351 |
| \(\mathrm{CH_3Br}\) | 4 | 293 |
| \(\mathrm{CH_3I}\) | 42 | 234 |
A student proposes that the methyl halide with the highest boiling point must undergo ordinary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) substitution most slowly, because its molecules are held together most strongly.
All three are instead compared with the same nucleophile in one suitable polar aprotic medium at the same temperature.
Which statement correctly evaluates this prediction?
ⓐ. The prediction is correct because intermolecular dispersion attractions prevent iodide from leaving the reacting carbon
ⓑ. The prediction is correct because a high boiling point directly establishes a strong intramolecular carbon–halogen bond
ⓒ. The prediction is incorrect because iodomethane can have both the highest boiling point and the greatest ordinary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) reactivity of the three
ⓓ. The prediction is incorrect because chloromethane forms a carbocation more readily than iodomethane under the stated \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) conditions
Correct Answer: The prediction is incorrect because iodomethane can have both the highest boiling point and the greatest ordinary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) reactivity of the three
Explanation: \(\textbf{Separate intermolecular and reaction-centre properties:}\)
A boiling point reflects the energy required to separate molecules into the gas phase.
For these methyl halides, increasing size and polarizability strengthen London dispersion attractions, tending to increase the boiling point from chloromethane to iodomethane.
This does not mean that the internal carbon–iodine bond is stronger than the carbon–chlorine bond.
\(\textbf{Use the supplied bond information:}\)
The carbon–halogen bond enthalpy decreases in the order shown:
\[
D(\mathrm{C-Cl})\gt D(\mathrm{C-Br})\gt D(\mathrm{C-I})
\]
Iodide is generally a better leaving group than bromide or chloride in ordinary alkyl-halide substitutions under comparable suitable conditions.
All three substrates are methyl halides and present very little steric obstruction to backside attack.
\(\textbf{Identify the appropriate mechanism:}\)
The stipulated comparison concerns an \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) pathway, not a mechanism requiring a stable free methyl carbocation.
The nucleophile attacks the methyl carbon while the carbon–halogen bond is broken in the same elementary substitution step.
A suitable polar aprotic medium can help an anionic nucleophile remain available for this backside attack.
\(\textbf{Compare the two orderings:}\)
The normal boiling points increase:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3Cl\lt CH_3Br\lt CH_3I}
\]
The ordinary relative ease of displacement under the stipulated conditions can instead follow:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3I\gt CH_3Br\gt CH_3Cl}
\]
The two trends describe different physical and chemical processes.
\(\textbf{Rule out the student's inference:}\)
A high boiling point does not establish a high \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) activation barrier.
Likewise, the lower carbon–iodine bond enthalpy is relevant to leaving-group behaviour but is not by itself a complete quantitative rate calculation.
The provided comparison supports greater substitution reactivity for iodomethane despite its higher boiling point.
Thus, the student's predicted inverse connection between boiling point and substitution ease is unjustified.
484. Propene is treated with chlorine under two distinct sets of conditions.
P: Chlorine in a suitable inert solvent in the dark, favouring ordinary electrophilic addition across the double bond.
Q: Chlorine under controlled radical conditions favouring selective replacement of one allylic hydrogen while retaining the carbon–carbon double bond.
Assume that no further chlorination occurs.
The isolated products are then treated separately with a reagent that reacts selectively with carbon–carbon double bonds.
Which statement correctly identifies the initial products and predicts their behaviour towards the double-bond reagent?
ⓐ. P gives allyl chloride, while Q gives 1,2-dichloropropane; only P reacts with the double-bond reagent
ⓑ. Both give 1,2-dichloropropane because chlorine cannot replace an allylic hydrogen
ⓒ. P gives 1,2-dichloropropane, which is saturated; Q gives allyl chloride, which retains a carbon–carbon double bond
ⓓ. Both give allyl chloride because propene contains an allylic methyl group
Correct Answer: P gives 1,2-dichloropropane, which is saturated; Q gives allyl chloride, which retains a carbon–carbon double bond
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the unsaturated starting substrate:}\)
Propene has the structure:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH{=}CH_2}
\]
It contains a carbon–carbon double bond and a methyl group adjacent to that bond.
The methyl hydrogens are allylic hydrogens.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the reaction conditions in P:}\)
In a suitable inert solvent under dark electrophilic-addition conditions, chlorine adds across the double bond.
One chlorine atom attaches to each original double-bond carbon:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH{=}CH_2+Cl_2
\rightarrow CH_3CHClCH_2Cl}
\]
The product is 1,2-dichloropropane.
\(\textbf{Identify the remaining unsaturation in P:}\)
Addition changes the original carbon–carbon double bond into a single bond.
The product is saturated with respect to carbon–carbon multiple bonds.
It therefore does not undergo the intended additional reagent reaction as an alkene.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the radical conditions in Q:}\)
Under the stipulated allylic radical-substitution conditions, chlorine replaces a hydrogen on the methyl group adjacent to the double bond.
The carbon–carbon double bond remains present:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH{=}CH_2+Cl_2
\xrightarrow{radical\ conditions}
ClCH_2CH{=}CH_2+HCl}
\]
The product is allyl chloride, also called 3-chloroprop-1-ene.
\(\textbf{Identify Q's remaining reaction site:}\)
Allyl chloride contains a carbon–carbon double bond.
Therefore, it can react with a suitable reagent selective for alkene double bonds.
The carbon–chlorine bond and the alkene bond are distinct functional features.
\(\textbf{Compare the two chlorine transformations:}\)
P introduces two chlorine atoms by addition and destroys the double bond.
Q introduces one chlorine atom through substitution while preserving the double bond.
The products differ in both chlorine count and unsaturation.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Reagent identity alone does not determine whether a haloalkane derivative or haloalkene is obtained.
Reaction conditions control addition versus allylic substitution and consequently determine the product's subsequent alkene reactivity.
485. Two secondary alkyl bromides having the same molecular formula, \(\mathrm{C_5H_{11}Br}\), undergo separate reactions with alcoholic KCN:
P: 2-Bromopentane, \(\mathrm{CH_3CH(Br)CH_2CH_2CH_3}\).
Q: 3-Bromopentane, \(\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH(Br)CH_2CH_3}\).
Assume exclusive replacement through the carbon end of cyanide at the original bromine-bearing carbon, without elimination, rearrangement or racemisation of any already existing stereogenic centre.
Which comparison of the nitrile products is correct?
ⓐ. P gives achiral 2-ethylbutanenitrile, whereas Q gives potentially chiral 2-methylpentanenitrile
ⓑ. P gives potentially chiral 2-methylpentanenitrile, whereas Q gives achiral 2-ethylbutanenitrile
ⓒ. P gives achiral 2-methylpentanenitrile, whereas Q gives potentially chiral 2-ethylbutanenitrile
ⓓ. P gives potentially chiral 3-methylpentanenitrile, whereas Q gives achiral 2-ethylbutanenitrile
Correct Answer: P gives potentially chiral 2-methylpentanenitrile, whereas Q gives achiral 2-ethylbutanenitrile
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the bond-forming reagent:}\)
In the specified reaction, the carbon end of cyanide attacks the carbon initially bonded to bromine.
Formation of a new carbon–carbon bond adds the carbon of the cyanide group to the starting carbon skeleton.
Consequently, both nitrile products contain six carbon atoms rather than five.
The position of the original bromine-bearing carbon determines the connectivity of the nitrile.
\(\textbf{Follow the conversion of P:}\)
The intended substitution is:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH(Br)CH_2CH_2CH_3+KCN
\rightarrow CH_3CH(CN)CH_2CH_2CH_3+KBr}
\]
The nitrile carbon must be numbered as carbon 1 in the parent nitrile chain.
The longest chain including that carbon contains five carbon atoms, with a methyl substituent at carbon 2.
Thus, P gives 2-methylpentanenitrile.
\(\textbf{Evaluate chirality of P's product:}\)
Its carbon 2 is attached to hydrogen, methyl, propyl and the nitrile group.
All four groups are different, so carbon 2 is stereogenic.
An enantiomerically enriched starting 2-bromopentane can therefore yield an optically active nitrile under suitable stereospecific conditions.
\(\textbf{Follow the conversion of Q:}\)
For the second isomer:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH(Br)CH_2CH_3+KCN
\rightarrow CH_3CH_2CH(CN)CH_2CH_3+KBr}
\]
The longest chain containing the nitrile carbon has four carbon atoms.
An ethyl substituent remains at carbon 2, giving 2-ethylbutanenitrile.
\(\textbf{Evaluate chirality of Q's product:}\)
The carbon bonded to the nitrile group is attached to two identical ethyl groups.
It cannot be a stereogenic centre, even though the carbon–bromine bond originally belonged to a secondary halide.
\(\textbf{Integrate the two tests:}\)
Identical starting molecular formulas do not require identical carbon connectivities after cyanide substitution.
The nitrile carbon is introduced at different positions, and this also changes the stereochemical possibilities.
P gives potentially chiral 2-methylpentanenitrile; Q gives achiral 2-ethylbutanenitrile.
486. A secondary alkyl bromide undergoes nucleophilic substitution in two solvents at constant temperature.
The following experimentally established facts are supplied:
I. In solvent P, the substrate disappears with a rate proportional to both substrate concentration and nucleophile concentration, and inversion predominates at the reacting stereogenic centre.
II. In solvent Q, the rate is independent of added nucleophile concentration, and both configurations of the substitution product are formed.
III. Solvent P is polar aprotic, while Q is strongly ionising and polar protic.
IV. The substrate and nucleophile are chemically identical in both experiments.
Which interpretation best explains the combined observations?
ⓐ. P is consistent with an \(S_\mathrm{N}1\) mechanism and Q with \(S_\mathrm{N}2\), because polar aprotic solvents necessarily generate free carbocations
ⓑ. Both mechanisms must be identical because changing the solvent cannot alter the preferred substitution pathway
ⓒ. P is consistent with \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) and Q with \(S_\mathrm{N}1\); solvent changes the preferred pathway
ⓓ. Q must involve E2 elimination because obtaining both product configurations excludes substitution
Correct Answer: P is consistent with \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) and Q with \(S_\mathrm{N}1\); solvent changes the preferred pathway
Explanation: \(\textbf{Interpret the kinetics in P:}\)
The observed rate in P depends on both substrate and nucleophile concentrations.
This is characteristic of an elementary bimolecular substitution.
The corresponding rate expression is:
\[
r_P=k_P[\mathrm{RX}][\mathrm{Nu}]
\]
\(\textbf{Interpret the stereochemistry in P:}\)
The predominance of inversion supports backside nucleophilic attack.
A concerted displacement can change the configuration at a stereogenic reaction centre.
These kinetic and stereochemical observations together support \(S_\mathrm{N}2\).
\(\textbf{Evaluate the polar aprotic environment:}\)
Suitable polar aprotic solvents can stabilise ions without strongly hydrogen-bond solvating many anionic nucleophiles.
This can increase the effectiveness of a nucleophile in direct backside attack.
The observed mechanism is therefore compatible with the stated solvent.
\(\textbf{Interpret the kinetics in Q:}\)
In Q, the measured rate does not depend on added nucleophile concentration.
This is compatible with rate-determining carbon–bromine bond ionisation:
\[
r_Q=k_Q[\mathrm{RX}]
\]
Such behaviour is characteristic of the usual \(S_\mathrm{N}1\) pathway.
\(\textbf{Interpret the product configurations in Q:}\)
A carbocation intermediate is approximately planar.
Nucleophilic capture can occur from either face.
Formation of products with both configurations is therefore consistent with \(S_\mathrm{N}1\).
Exact racemisation is not required because ion pairing and solvent effects can influence facial attack.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the polar protic environment:}\)
A strongly ionising polar protic solvent can stabilise developing ions and support carbocation formation under suitable conditions.
The solvent may therefore favour ionisation relative to direct backside displacement.
\(\textbf{Integrate the observations:}\)
The substrate and nucleophile remain chemically identical.
Nevertheless, their relative reaction pathways can change because the solvent affects nucleophile solvation, ionisation and transition-state stabilisation.
The kinetic and stereochemical evidence must be considered together.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Mechanism selection is not a permanent property of a molecular formula.
The same substrate can exhibit different substitution behaviour when the reaction environment changes.
487. An unknown secondary alkyl bromide X has the molecular formula \(\mathrm{C_5H_{11}Br}\).
Its carbon skeleton is known to be unbranched.
Two experiments are performed:
P: Hydrolysis gives an alcohol whose hydroxyl-bearing carbon is stereogenic.
Q: Dehydrohalogenation gives two constitutional alkenes, one of which can exhibit E/Z isomerism, while the other cannot.
Assume no rearrangement and that all possible beta-elimination directions are accessible.
Which structure is consistent with both observations?
ⓐ. 1-Bromopentane
ⓑ. 3-Bromopentane
ⓒ. 2-Bromopentane
ⓓ. 1-Bromo-2-methylbutane
Correct Answer: 2-Bromopentane
Explanation: \(\textbf{Apply the molecular-formula constraint:}\)
X contains five carbon atoms and one bromine atom.
The question specifies an unbranched carbon skeleton.
Therefore, branched structural isomers are excluded.
\(\textbf{Apply the secondary-carbon constraint:}\)
The bromine-bearing carbon must be attached to two carbon atoms.
1-Bromopentane is a primary alkyl bromide and does not meet this condition.
The relevant unbranched secondary possibilities are 2-bromopentane and 3-bromopentane.
\(\textbf{Examine hydrolysis of 2-bromopentane:}\)
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH(Br)CH_2CH_2CH_3
\rightarrow CH_3CH(OH)CH_2CH_2CH_3}
\]
The product is pentan-2-ol.
Its hydroxyl-bearing carbon is attached to hydroxyl, hydrogen, methyl and n-propyl groups.
These four substituents are different.
Therefore, it is stereogenic.
\(\textbf{Examine hydrolysis of 3-bromopentane:}\)
Hydrolysis gives pentan-3-ol:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH(OH)CH_2CH_3}
\]
The hydroxyl-bearing carbon is attached to two identical ethyl groups.
It is therefore not stereogenic.
Thus, observation P favours 2-bromopentane.
\(\textbf{Apply the elimination constraint:}\)
2-Bromopentane contains beta-hydrogens on both sides of the bromine-bearing carbon.
Elimination towards the terminal carbon gives pent-1-ene.
Elimination towards the internal side gives pent-2-ene.
These are two distinct constitutional alkenes.
\(\textbf{Examine alkene stereoisomerism:}\)
Pent-1-ene has a terminal double-bond carbon bearing two hydrogen atoms.
It cannot exhibit E/Z isomerism.
Pent-2-ene has two different substituents on each double-bond carbon.
It can exist as E and Z isomers.
\(\textbf{Test the alternative secondary isomer:}\)
3-Bromopentane is symmetrical about the central bromine-bearing carbon.
Elimination towards either adjacent carbon gives pent-2-ene after appropriate numbering.
It therefore gives only one constitutional alkene.
This contradicts observation Q.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Hydrolysis identifies whether the reaction centre becomes stereogenic.
Elimination independently tests the equivalence of the two beta positions.
Both observations establish 2-bromopentane as X.
488. Two structurally related compounds are investigated:
P: \(\mathrm{C_6H_5CH_2Cl}\), benzyl chloride.
Q: \(\mathrm{C_6H_5CHCl_2}\), benzal chloride.
Each is hydrolysed completely under conditions favouring replacement of the available benzylic carbon–chlorine bonds.
The products are subsequently subjected to suitable mild oxidation conditions.
Assume no aromatic-ring substitution or carbon–carbon bond cleavage.
Which statement correctly identifies the products immediately after hydrolysis and the effect of the subsequent oxidation?
ⓐ. P gives benzaldehyde and Q gives benzyl alcohol; oxidation converts both into benzene
ⓑ. P hydrolyses to benzyl alcohol and Q to benzaldehyde; mild oxidation can convert P's alcohol into Q's aldehyde
ⓒ. Both give benzyl alcohol because the extra chlorine atom in Q is removed without altering the organic functional group
ⓓ. P gives benzoic acid and Q gives phenol; subsequent oxidation leaves both unchanged
Correct Answer: P hydrolyses to benzyl alcohol and Q to benzaldehyde; mild oxidation can convert P's alcohol into Q's aldehyde
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the benzylic carbon–halogen arrangements:}\)
Benzyl chloride contains one chlorine atom bonded to a benzylic methylene carbon.
Benzal chloride contains two chlorine atoms attached to the same benzylic carbon.
These are a monohalide and a geminal dihalide, respectively.
\(\textbf{Hydrolyse P:}\)
Replacement of the carbon–chlorine bond introduces hydroxyl:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH_2Cl+OH^-
\rightarrow C_6H_5CH_2OH+Cl^-}
\]
The organic product is benzyl alcohol.
It contains a primary alcohol group attached to the benzylic carbon.
\(\textbf{Hydrolyse Q:}\)
Complete hydrolysis of both chlorine atoms formally gives a geminal diol:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CHCl_2
\rightarrow C_6H_5CH(OH)_2}
\]
The corresponding stable carbonyl compound is benzaldehyde:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CHO}
\]
Thus, Q produces an aldehyde under the stipulated hydrolysis.
\(\textbf{Apply mild oxidation to P's product:}\)
Benzyl alcohol is a primary alcohol.
Under suitable controlled oxidation conditions, it can be converted into benzaldehyde:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH_2OH
\xrightarrow{[O]}
C_6H_5CHO}
\]
The benzylic carbon changes from the alcohol oxidation state to the aldehyde oxidation state.
\(\textbf{Evaluate Q's product:}\)
Q has already produced benzaldehyde after complete hydrolysis.
It does not need a separate primary-alcohol oxidation to reach that structure.
Any further transformation would depend on the oxidising conditions, which the question specifies to be mild and controlled.
\(\textbf{Compare the two pathways:}\)
P initially produces an alcohol and requires oxidation to reach the aldehyde.
Q produces the aldehyde through hydrolysis of a geminal dichloride.
Both routes can therefore converge on benzaldehyde, but their initial functional-group transformations differ.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
One benzylic chlorine substitution leads to an alcohol, while hydrolysis of two geminal chlorine atoms leads to a carbonyl compound.
The number and arrangement of carbon–halogen bonds determine the immediate hydrolysis product.
489. A region stops using DDT after its historical insecticidal application. Several months later, residues are still detected in soil and sediments, and DDT is found in the fatty tissues of predators feeding in the contaminated area. Which conclusion best explains these observations?
ⓐ. Stopping new applications necessarily removes all existing DDT immediately because it is water-soluble
ⓑ. The residue proves that predators manufacture DDT naturally even without any environmental source
ⓒ. Persistent DDT residues may continue to enter food chains after applications cease, and lipid affinity can favour retention in organisms
ⓓ. DDT residues can persist only as chlorine radicals in the stratosphere, not in soil or organisms
Correct Answer: Persistent DDT residues may continue to enter food chains after applications cease, and lipid affinity can favour retention in organisms
Explanation: \(\textbf{Distinguish stopping use from removing residues:}\)
A ban or halt in new applications prevents additional deliberate releases, but it does not instantly destroy pesticide molecules already present in soil, sediments or biological tissues. The continued presence of DDT is consistent with its environmental persistence.
\(\textbf{Connect persistence with chemical behaviour:}\)
DDT is a relatively stable organochlorine insecticide. Its limited water solubility and high affinity for lipid-rich material promote retention in organisms and can slow its removal from contaminated ecosystems.
\(\textbf{Follow the continuing exposure pathway:}\)
Existing residues can remain available for uptake by organisms even after application has stopped. Prey may carry DDT into predators through feeding relationships, and concentrations may rise at successive trophic levels when biomagnification occurs.
\(\textbf{Distinguish this pathway from CFC chemistry:}\)
DDT's characteristic long-term concern is persistence and biological accumulation, not the chlorine-radical ozone-depletion pathway associated with some chlorofluorocarbon refrigerants. The observations do not require new DDT synthesis within predators.
\(\textbf{Conclusion:}\)
Environmental controls on future use are valuable, but they do not automatically eliminate previously released persistent chemicals. The continuing exposure is explained by existing DDT residues and their food-chain transfer.
490. A chemist compares two preparations of iodobenzene from aromatic starting materials.
Route P: Direct iodination of benzene using molecular iodine in the presence of a suitable oxidising agent.
Route Q: Diazotisation of aniline using sodium nitrite and hydrochloric acid at \(273–278\ \mathrm{K}\), followed by treatment of the diazonium salt with potassium iodide.
Consider the following statements.
Statement I: Direct aromatic iodination is reversible, and an oxidising agent can help by removing the hydrogen iodide formed during substitution.
Statement II: Replacement of a benzene diazonium group by iodine requires cuprous iodide as an indispensable reagent.
Statement III: Both routes can produce iodobenzene, but the iodine-incorporation mechanisms are different.
Statement IV: Replacing the amino group through its diazonium derivative avoids attempting ordinary backside substitution at an aromatic carbon–nitrogen bond.
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. I, II and III only
ⓑ. II and IV only
ⓒ. I, III and IV only
ⓓ. I, II, III and IV
Correct Answer: I, III and IV only
Explanation: \(\textbf{Examine direct aromatic iodination:}\)
Benzene can undergo electrophilic aromatic substitution with iodine under suitable conditions.
However, iodination is reversible.
The hydrogen iodide formed can interfere with obtaining a favourable net conversion.
An oxidising agent such as nitric acid or periodic acid can oxidise the hydrogen iodide and assist iodination.
Therefore, Statement I is correct.
\(\textbf{Identify the role of aniline in Route Q:}\)
Aniline contains an amino group directly attached to an aromatic carbon.
Diazotisation converts this amino group into a diazonium group under suitably cold acidic conditions.
The diazonium intermediate provides a route for replacement of the original amino substituent.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the proposed cuprous-iodide requirement:}\)
Aromatic diazonium salts can be converted into aryl iodides using potassium iodide.
Unlike the corresponding Sandmeyer preparations of aryl chlorides and bromides, introduction of iodine by this method does not require cuprous halide.
Therefore, Statement II is incorrect.
\(\textbf{Compare the overall products:}\)
Direct iodination introduces iodine by electrophilic substitution of an aromatic hydrogen.
Diazonium conversion replaces an existing nitrogen-containing substituent with iodine.
Both routes can yield:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5I}
\]
Nevertheless, their reaction sequences and underlying substitution pathways differ.
Statement III is correct.
\(\textbf{Examine the aromatic bond-breaking misconception:}\)
An ordinary saturated-carbon \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) mechanism is unsuitable for direct replacement at an aromatic \(sp^2\)-hybridised reaction centre.
The diazonium route uses the special leaving-group behaviour of an aromatic diazonium salt.
It does not require ordinary backside displacement of the original amino group.
Statement IV is correct.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The appropriate preparation method depends on both the aromatic starting material and the substitution mechanism.
Statements I, III and IV correctly distinguish direct iodination from diazonium-based iodide introduction.
491. A chemist prepares an alkyl chloride from propan-1-ol using a mixture of two chlorinating reagents.
In one reaction vessel, \(0.0800\ \mathrm{mol}\) propan-1-ol is converted quantitatively using thionyl chloride:
\[
\mathrm{ROH+SOCl_2\rightarrow RCl+SO_2+HCl}
\]
In a second vessel, \(0.120\ \mathrm{mol}\) propan-1-ol is converted quantitatively using phosphorus pentachloride:
\[
\mathrm{ROH+PCl_5\rightarrow RCl+POCl_3+HCl}
\]
The gaseous products from the two vessels are collected together.
Assume that all the hydrogen chloride and sulphur dioxide escape into the combined gas collection system, whereas phosphoryl chloride does not contribute to the collected gases.
What is the mole ratio of collected \(\mathrm{SO_2}\) to collected \(\mathrm{HCl}\), and how much propyl chloride is formed in total?
ⓐ. \(2:5\) and \(0.200\ \mathrm{mol}\)
ⓑ. \(2:3\) and \(0.200\ \mathrm{mol}\)
ⓒ. \(2:5\) and \(0.0800\ \mathrm{mol}\)
ⓓ. \(1:1\) and \(0.120\ \mathrm{mol}\)
Correct Answer: \(2:5\) and \(0.200\ \mathrm{mol}\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the common organic transformation:}\)
Both reagents replace the hydroxyl group of propan-1-ol with chlorine.
Consequently, both vessels produce 1-chloropropane.
However, their inorganic by-products differ, allowing the two reagent contributions to be distinguished.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the thionyl-chloride vessel:}\)
The balanced reaction is:
\[
\mathrm{ROH+SOCl_2\rightarrow RCl+SO_2+HCl}
\]
One mole of alcohol produces one mole each of alkyl chloride, sulphur dioxide and hydrogen chloride.
Therefore:
\[
n_1(\mathrm{RCl})=0.0800\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\[
n_1(\mathrm{SO_2})=0.0800\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\[
n_1(\mathrm{HCl})=0.0800\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Evaluate the phosphorus-pentachloride vessel:}\)
The second reaction is:
\[
\mathrm{ROH+PCl_5\rightarrow RCl+POCl_3+HCl}
\]
Each mole of alcohol produces one mole of alkyl chloride and one mole of hydrogen chloride.
No sulphur dioxide is produced.
Therefore:
\[
n_2(\mathrm{RCl})=0.120\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\[
n_2(\mathrm{HCl})=0.120\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Combine the collected gas amounts:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm{total}}(\mathrm{SO_2})=0.0800\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{total}}(\mathrm{HCl})=0.0800+0.120
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{total}}(\mathrm{HCl})=0.200\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Calculate the gaseous mole ratio:}\)
\[
\mathrm{SO_2:HCl}=0.0800:0.200
\]
\[
\mathrm{SO_2:HCl}=2:5
\]
\(\textbf{Determine the total organic product:}\)
\[
n_{\mathrm{total}}(\mathrm{RCl})=0.0800+0.120
\]
\[
n_{\mathrm{total}}(\mathrm{RCl})=0.200\ \mathrm{mol}
\]
\(\textbf{Connect by-products to reagent selection:}\)
Thionyl chloride is frequently preferred for preparing relatively pure alkyl chlorides because its sulphur dioxide and hydrogen chloride by-products are gaseous.
The phosphorus-pentachloride reaction also produces phosphoryl chloride, which creates a different separation situation.
The distinction is chemical, not merely a difference in chlorine content.
\(\textbf{Final answer:}\)
\[
\boxed{n(\mathrm{SO_2}):n(\mathrm{HCl})=2:5,\qquad n(\mathrm{1\!-\!chloropropane})=0.200\ \mathrm{mol}}
\]
492. A historical chloroform sample is stored with a small amount of ethanol.
For this question, suppose some chloroform nevertheless undergoes oxidation to phosgene:
\[
\mathrm{2CHCl_3+O_2\rightarrow2COCl_2+2HCl}
\]
The phosgene then reacts completely with the available ethanol according to:
\[
\mathrm{COCl_2+2C_2H_5OH\rightarrow (C_2H_5O)_2CO+2HCl}
\]
Assume that ethanol does not otherwise affect the oxidation step and that no further reactions occur.
Which interpretation correctly identifies the chemical role of ethanol and the remaining hazard?
ⓐ. Ethanol converts phosgene into diethyl carbonate but also generates HCl; phosgene removal does not imply hazard removal
ⓑ. Ethanol reduces phosgene to methane and prevents formation of hydrogen chloride in either stage
ⓒ. Ethanol converts phosgene into iodoform, explaining why chloroform was historically used as an antiseptic
ⓓ. Ethanol prevents oxygen from reacting with chloroform because its hydroxyl group consumes all ultraviolet radiation
Correct Answer: Ethanol converts phosgene into diethyl carbonate but also generates HCl; phosgene removal does not imply hazard removal
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the storage-related reaction:}\)
Chloroform can slowly undergo oxidation in the presence of air and light.
The resulting carbonyl chloride, also called phosgene, is extremely poisonous.
Hydrogen chloride is another product of the stipulated oxidation.
\(\textbf{Examine ethanol's specified role:}\)
The second equation shows ethanol reacting with phosgene after phosgene has formed.
Two ethanol molecules replace the chlorine-containing groups of one phosgene molecule.
The resulting organic product is diethyl carbonate.
\(\textbf{Distinguish trapping from prevention:}\)
Consumption of phosgene after its formation is not chemically identical to preventing chloroform oxidation.
The question explicitly states that oxidation still occurs.
Therefore, disappearance of detectable phosgene cannot be used to conclude that the preceding oxidation was absent.
\(\textbf{Track hydrogen chloride production:}\)
The oxidation reaction produces hydrogen chloride.
The subsequent reaction of phosgene with ethanol produces additional hydrogen chloride.
Thus, the specified trapping process does not remove every hazardous reaction product.
\(\textbf{Identify the proper storage principle:}\)
Protection from light and atmospheric oxygen addresses the conditions responsible for hazardous chloroform oxidation.
The storage precaution is distinct from a chemical process that consumes phosgene after it has formed.
\(\textbf{Interpret the broader safety limitation:}\)
Chloroform itself has significant toxicity even when phosgene formation is minimised.
A reagent or storage additive must not be assumed to make an otherwise hazardous solvent harmless.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The complete reaction sequence must be considered rather than tracking only one toxic intermediate.
Ethanol can trap the stipulated phosgene product as diethyl carbonate, while hydrogen chloride remains a possible hazard.
493. In a simplified model of stratospheric chemistry, a chlorine radical can follow either of two pathways.
Pathway P:
\[
\mathrm{Cl^\bullet+O_3\rightarrow ClO^\bullet+O_2}
\]
\[
\mathrm{ClO^\bullet+O\rightarrow Cl^\bullet+O_2}
\]
Pathway Q:
\[
\mathrm{Cl^\bullet+CH_4\rightarrow HCl+CH_3^\bullet}
\]
For this comparison, assume that the HCl formed in Q remains a temporary reservoir of chlorine and does not release a chlorine radical during the observation period. Which statement is correct?
ⓐ. P consumes chlorine permanently; Q regenerates chlorine because it produces a methyl radical
ⓑ. Both pathways immediately regenerate a chlorine radical and therefore destroy ozone equally
ⓒ. P regenerates active chlorine; Q temporarily removes it from this ozone-destruction cycle as HCl
ⓓ. Q converts methane directly into ozone and therefore increases the atmospheric ozone concentration
Correct Answer: P regenerates active chlorine; Q temporarily removes it from this ozone-destruction cycle as HCl
Explanation: \(\textbf{Analyse pathway P:}\)
The chlorine radical first reacts with ozone, producing chlorine monoxide and oxygen. The chlorine monoxide radical subsequently reacts with atomic oxygen to regenerate the original chlorine radical. Chlorine can therefore catalyse further ozone depletion instead of being consumed after a single reaction.
\(\textbf{Analyse pathway Q:}\)
A chlorine radical abstracts hydrogen from methane and forms HCl along with a methyl radical. In the stated observation period, chlorine remains in HCl instead of re-entering the specified catalytic ozone-destruction cycle. A methyl radical is not the same as a regenerated chlorine radical.
\(\textbf{Avoid an absolute conclusion:}\)
HCl is a chlorine reservoir species, not a guarantee that chlorine can never become reactive again. Actual stratospheric processes can transform reservoir compounds under suitable conditions. The supplied assumption limits the conclusion to the observation period.
\(\textbf{Compare the outcomes:}\)
P maintains catalytically active chlorine, whereas Q temporarily removes it from the simplified cycle. This distinction explains why the fate of chlorine after CFC photolysis matters for ozone depletion.
494. A student shakes water containing a small quantity of dissolved molecular iodine with chloroform.
The following information is provided:
P: Chloroform has density \(1.49\ \mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}\), while water has density \(1.00\ \mathrm{g\,mL^{-1}}\).
Q: Chloroform and water form separate liquid layers under the experimental conditions.
R: Molecular iodine preferentially dissolves in chloroform and produces a violet-coloured organic solution.
S: No reagent capable of converting molecular iodine into iodoform is present.
After the layers separate, the student claims that the violet lower layer must contain newly synthesised iodoform.
Which assessment is correct?
ⓐ. The claim is correct because every iodine-containing solution contains triiodomethane
ⓑ. The claim is correct because chloroform necessarily undergoes iodine substitution when shaken with water
ⓒ. The claim is incorrect because the violet layer is the upper aqueous layer and contains only iodide ions
ⓓ. The claim is incorrect because the lower chloroform layer can contain physically dissolved molecular iodine without formation of iodoform
Correct Answer: The claim is incorrect because the lower chloroform layer can contain physically dissolved molecular iodine without formation of iodoform
Explanation: \(\textbf{Determine the relative layer positions:}\)
Chloroform is denser than water according to the supplied data.
When the two liquids form separate layers, the denser liquid occupies the lower layer.
Therefore, chloroform is the lower liquid phase.
\(\textbf{Identify the observed colour source:}\)
The question specifies that dissolved molecular iodine produces a violet-coloured chloroform solution.
The violet colour is therefore consistent with iodine partitioning into the organic phase.
It does not independently establish the formation of a new covalent organic compound.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the three chemical identities:}\)
Molecular iodine has the formula \(\mathrm{I_2}\).
Chloroform is \(\mathrm{CHCl_3}\).
Iodoform is \(\mathrm{CHI_3}\).
These are distinct substances with different molecular structures.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the student's chemical inference:}\)
Dissolving iodine in chloroform need not involve cleavage of a carbon–chlorine bond.
It also need not involve formation of three new carbon–iodine bonds.
The supplied conditions provide no basis for claiming that chloroform has been converted into iodoform.
\(\textbf{Consider the appearance of iodoform:}\)
Iodoform is characteristically a yellow crystalline solid.
Its formation in a suitable reaction is not established merely by observing a violet organic liquid layer.
The observations here are more directly explained by physical distribution of iodine between two solvents.
\(\textbf{Connect the observation to chloroform's use:}\)
Chloroform has historically been used as a solvent for iodine and various organic substances.
Such solvent behaviour depends on intermolecular interactions and does not require a chemical substitution reaction.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Layer position, colour and chemical identity provide different kinds of information.
The dense lower chloroform layer may contain dissolved molecular iodine, but those observations do not demonstrate synthesis of iodoform.
495. Ethylbenzene and styrene are subjected to an analytical comparison.
P: Ethylbenzene, \(\mathrm{C_6H_5CH_2CH_3}\).
Q: Styrene, \(\mathrm{C_6H_5CH{=}CH_2}\).
A student proposes that both compounds should undergo exactly the same benzylic hydrogen-substitution reaction because each contains a carbon atom directly attached to a benzene ring and bearing hydrogen.
The compounds are also separately tested with bromine in an inert solvent under dark conditions favouring alkene addition.
Which statement correctly evaluates the proposal and the bromine test?
ⓐ. Both compounds have identical benzylic carbon–hydrogen environments, and neither reacts through ordinary dark bromine addition
ⓑ. P has saturated benzylic C–H bonds; Q has a vinylic ring-adjacent C–H bond and undergoes bromine addition across C=C
ⓒ. P undergoes bromine addition because it contains an aromatic ring, whereas Q cannot react because its side-chain carbon is \(sp^2\)-hybridised
ⓓ. Q contains a primary benzylic chloride even before any halogenating reagent is added, whereas P is an aryl chloride
Correct Answer: P has saturated benzylic C–H bonds; Q has a vinylic ring-adjacent C–H bond and undergoes bromine addition across C=C
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the side-chain bonding in P:}\)
Ethylbenzene contains the group:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH_2CH_3}
\]
The carbon directly attached to the aromatic ring is saturated.
It bears two hydrogen atoms.
These are benzylic hydrogens.
\(\textbf{Connect P with radical substitution:}\)
Abstraction of a benzylic hydrogen can produce a benzylic radical.
The radical is stabilised through resonance involving the aromatic ring.
Therefore, ethylbenzene is suitable for controlled benzylic radical halogenation under appropriate conditions.
\(\textbf{Identify the bonding in Q:}\)
Styrene has the structure:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH{=}CH_2}
\]
The carbon directly attached to the aromatic ring participates in a carbon–carbon double bond.
Its hydrogen is attached to a vinylic \(sp^2\)-hybridised carbon.
It is not a hydrogen on a saturated benzylic methylene group.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the student's generalisation:}\)
Attachment of a carbon atom to an aromatic ring is not sufficient to establish identical hydrogen environments.
The hybridisation and adjacent bond arrangement must also be considered.
Consequently, ordinary benzylic hydrogen-substitution reasoning for ethylbenzene cannot be transferred unchanged to styrene.
\(\textbf{Predict the dark bromine test for P:}\)
Ethylbenzene has no isolated side-chain carbon–carbon double bond.
Under the stipulated conditions excluding photochemical substitution and aromatic electrophilic bromination, it does not undergo the intended alkene-addition reaction.
\(\textbf{Predict the dark bromine test for Q:}\)
Styrene contains a side-chain double bond.
Bromine can add across it:
\[
\mathrm{C_6H_5CH{=}CH_2+Br_2
\rightarrow C_6H_5CHBrCH_2Br}
\]
The product is a vicinal dibromide.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Ethylbenzene and styrene both contain a phenyl group, but the carbon directly attached to the ring has different bonding in each molecule.
Identifying saturated benzylic hydrogens separately from vinylic hydrogens explains their different behaviour under the specified conditions.
496. 1-Bromo-2-chloroethane, \(\mathrm{BrCH_2CH_2Cl}\), is treated with a suitable strong base under conditions favouring E2 elimination rather than nucleophilic substitution.
The substrate can eliminate either HBr or HCl, depending on which halogen departs.
Assume that both pathways possess accessible anti-periplanar conformations and that, for this controlled comparison, bromide departure is kinetically favoured over chloride departure.
Which statement correctly identifies the two possible organic products and the expected principal product?
ⓐ. HBr elimination gives vinyl chloride, \(\mathrm{CH_2{=}CHCl}\), while HCl elimination gives vinyl bromide, \(\mathrm{CH_2{=}CHBr}\); vinyl chloride is expected to predominate
ⓑ. HBr elimination gives vinyl bromide, while HCl elimination gives vinyl chloride; vinyl bromide is expected to predominate
ⓒ. Either elimination gives ethyne because both carbon–halogen bonds are necessarily broken in a single E2 step
ⓓ. Both pathways give 1,2-dihaloethene because the two halogens remain attached to the double-bond carbons
Correct Answer: HBr elimination gives vinyl chloride, \(\mathrm{CH_2{=}CHCl}\), while HCl elimination gives vinyl bromide, \(\mathrm{CH_2{=}CHBr}\); vinyl chloride is expected to predominate
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the two halogen-bearing carbons:}\)
The starting compound has bromine on one terminal carbon and chlorine on the adjacent carbon.
Each carbon also carries hydrogen atoms.
Therefore, an appropriate beta-hydrogen is available regardless of which carbon–halogen bond is selected for elimination.
\(\textbf{Apply the E2 requirement:}\)
An E2 reaction removes a beta-hydrogen while a leaving group departs.
A carbon–carbon double bond forms between the original alpha and beta carbons.
The question explicitly provides suitable antiperiplanar conformations for both alternatives.
\(\textbf{Follow the HBr-elimination pathway:}\)
If bromine leaves, a hydrogen is removed from the neighbouring chlorine-bearing carbon:
\[
\mathrm{BrCH_2CH_2Cl
\xrightarrow{-HBr}
CH_2{=}CHCl}
\]
The product is chloroethene, commonly called vinyl chloride.
Chlorine remains attached to a double-bonded carbon.
\(\textbf{Follow the HCl-elimination pathway:}\)
If chlorine leaves, a hydrogen is removed from the bromine-bearing carbon:
\[
\mathrm{BrCH_2CH_2Cl
\xrightarrow{-HCl}
CH_2{=}CHBr}
\]
The product is bromoethene, commonly called vinyl bromide.
Bromine remains attached to a double-bonded carbon.
\(\textbf{Apply the leaving-group condition:}\)
The question specifies that departure of bromide is kinetically favoured.
Therefore, the HBr-elimination pathway is preferred.
The expected principal alkene is vinyl chloride.
\(\textbf{Distinguish the product bonding environments:}\)
The starting compound contains two halogens attached to saturated carbon atoms.
Each elimination removes one hydrogen halide and creates one double bond.
The halogen retained in the product becomes directly attached to a vinylic carbon.
\(\textbf{Recognise the limit of the prediction:}\)
The question does not establish an exact ratio of vinyl chloride to vinyl bromide.
The relative amount depends on the competing transition-state barriers.
The stipulated leaving-group preference supports only the qualitative principal-product assignment.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
A mixed vicinal dihalide can form different vinyl halides depending on which carbon–halogen bond participates in elimination.
Tracking the departing halogen and the retained halogen is essential for identifying the product.
497. An experimental study compares the elimination and substitution behaviour of a primary alkyl bromide using isotopic labelling.
Two substrates are prepared:
P: \(\mathrm{BrCH_2CH_2CH_3}\).
Q: \(\mathrm{BrCH_2CD_2CH_3}\), in which both beta hydrogens on carbon 2 are replaced by deuterium.
Each reacts with the same strong base under identical conditions.
The observed initial rates are proportional to both alkyl bromide concentration and base concentration.
However, P reacts \(4.5\) times as fast as Q, and the major organic product in each case is an alkene.
Assume that differences in concentration, solvent and carbon–bromine bond identity have been excluded as explanations.
Which mechanistic inference is best supported?
ⓐ. An exclusive \(S_\mathrm{N}1\) mechanism is established because deuterium accelerates carbocation formation
ⓑ. The identical bimolecular rate-law forms prove an \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) mechanism, regardless of the products and isotope effect
ⓒ. The observations support an E2 pathway involving beta C–H or C–D bond cleavage; bimolecular kinetics alone would not distinguish it from \(S_\mathrm{N}2\)
ⓓ. The slower reaction of Q proves that no carbon–hydrogen or carbon–deuterium bond is involved in the rate-determining process
Correct Answer: The observations support an E2 pathway involving beta C–H or C–D bond cleavage; bimolecular kinetics alone would not distinguish it from \(S_\mathrm{N}2\)
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the shared kinetic observation:}\)
Both substrate-disappearance rates depend on alkyl bromide and base concentrations.
Such bimolecular dependence is compatible with elementary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) substitution.
It is also compatible with elementary E2 elimination.
The rate-law form alone therefore does not uniquely distinguish the mechanisms.
\(\textbf{Locate the isotopic substitution:}\)
In P, the beta carbon adjacent to the bromine-bearing carbon contains ordinary hydrogen atoms.
In Q, those hydrogens are replaced by deuterium.
The alpha carbon and its carbon–bromine bond are otherwise unchanged in the stated comparison.
\(\textbf{Examine an E2 transition state:}\)
An E2 reaction involves simultaneous cleavage of a beta carbon–hydrogen bond and departure of bromide.
A carbon–carbon double bond forms between the adjacent carbons.
Substitution of deuterium at the beta position changes the bond that must be broken during elimination.
\(\textbf{Interpret the isotope effect:}\)
Carbon–deuterium bonds generally exhibit different vibrational zero-point energies from corresponding carbon–hydrogen bonds.
Cleavage of a beta C–D bond during a rate-determining elimination can consequently be slower than cleavage of the corresponding C–H bond.
A substantial primary kinetic isotope effect is therefore consistent with the observed rate difference.
\(\textbf{Use the observed organic product:}\)
The major organic products are alkenes.
This directly supports elimination rather than nucleophilic substitution as the dominant pathway.
The isotope effect provides independent mechanistic evidence that beta-bond cleavage participates in the rate-controlling event.
\(\textbf{Evaluate an ordinary }S_\mathrm{N}2\textbf{ interpretation:}\)
In an elementary \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) event, nucleophile attack occurs at the carbon bearing bromine.
A beta C–H bond is not directly cleaved as part of the concerted substitution event.
Although secondary isotope effects may occur, the stipulated combination of substantial beta isotope sensitivity and alkene production more strongly supports E2.
\(\textbf{Distinguish evidence from absolute proof:}\)
Isotope effects should be interpreted alongside product analysis and kinetics.
The numerical rate ratio alone would not establish every detail of the transition state.
Here, the three independent observations together provide the intended mechanistic discrimination.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Both \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) and E2 reactions can exhibit bimolecular kinetics.
Beta-deuterium labelling adds evidence about bond cleavage, while the alkene product identifies elimination as the dominant transformation.
498. 4-Bromoaniline is used to prepare two different aromatic halides through its diazonium salt.
The amino group is first diazotised using \(\mathrm{NaNO_2/HCl}\) at \(273–278\ \mathrm{K}\).
The resulting diazonium solution is divided into two portions.
P: Treatment with fluoroboric acid, isolation of the corresponding diazonium fluoroborate, followed by controlled heating.
Q: Treatment with copper powder and hydrochloric acid under suitable Gattermann-reaction conditions.
Assume complete intended replacement of the diazonium group, with the original aromatic carbon–bromine bond remaining unchanged.
Which statement correctly identifies the products and distinguishes the two preparation methods?
ⓐ. P gives 1-bromo-4-chlorobenzene by the Balz–Schiemann reaction, whereas Q gives 1-bromo-4-fluorobenzene by the Gattermann reaction
ⓑ. P gives 1,4-dibromobenzene, whereas Q gives 1-bromo-4-fluorobenzene because hydrochloric acid supplies fluorine
ⓒ. Both give 1-bromo-4-chlorobenzene because the chloride counterion of the original diazonium salt determines every subsequent substitution
ⓓ. P gives 1-bromo-4-fluorobenzene by the Balz–Schiemann reaction, whereas Q gives 1-bromo-4-chlorobenzene by the Gattermann reaction
Correct Answer: P gives 1-bromo-4-fluorobenzene by the Balz–Schiemann reaction, whereas Q gives 1-bromo-4-chlorobenzene by the Gattermann reaction
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the starting substitution pattern:}\)
4-Bromoaniline contains an amino group and a bromine atom at para positions on a benzene ring.
Diazotisation converts the amino group into a diazonium group without requiring replacement of the pre-existing aromatic bromine.
The two subsequent reactions replace the diazonium group at the carbon originally bearing nitrogen.
\(\textbf{Follow the fluorination route:}\)
Treatment with fluoroboric acid produces the corresponding arenediazonium fluoroborate.
On controlled heating, this salt decomposes with liberation of nitrogen and formation of an aromatic carbon–fluorine bond.
The reaction is the Balz–Schiemann preparation of aryl fluorides.
The organic product is 1-bromo-4-fluorobenzene.
\(\textbf{Follow the Gattermann route:}\)
An aromatic diazonium group can be replaced by chlorine using hydrochloric acid and copper powder under suitable conditions.
This is the Gattermann method of preparing an aryl chloride from an aromatic diazonium salt.
Since bromine remains at its original ring position, the organic product is 1-bromo-4-chlorobenzene.
\(\textbf{Distinguish Gattermann from Sandmeyer:}\)
The corresponding Sandmeyer chlorination commonly employs cuprous chloride.
Gattermann chlorination uses copper powder with the corresponding halogen acid.
Both methods can introduce aromatic chlorine, but their specified reagent systems are not identical.
\(\textbf{Reject the counterion misconception:}\)
The initial diazonium chloride contains chloride as its counterion.
That does not force every subsequent diazonium replacement to introduce chlorine.
The reagent and reaction conditions used after diazotisation determine the intended substitution.
\(\textbf{Connect the method to aromatic bonding:}\)
Ordinary fluoride substitution at an unactivated aromatic carbon does not proceed by the usual primary-alkyl-halide \(S_\mathrm{N}2\) pathway.
The diazonium fluoroborate route avoids treating aromatic fluorination as a routine Swarts exchange at saturated carbon.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Both routes retain the original para-bromine substituent but introduce different second halogens.
The fluoroborate route gives an aryl fluoride, whereas the copper–hydrochloric acid route gives an aryl chloride.
499. An optically inactive sample of 1-bromopropane is treated separately with two nitrite reagents under conditions giving their characteristic linkage-selective substitution products.
P: Potassium nitrite, \(\mathrm{KNO_2}\).
Q: Silver nitrite, \(\mathrm{AgNO_2}\).
Assume complete intended substitution, no elimination and no competing reaction.
Consider the following statements.
Statement I: The two principal organic products can have the same molecular formula while differing in the atom through which the nitrogen–oxygen-containing group is attached to carbon.
Statement II: P predominantly gives propyl nitrite, \(\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH_2ONO}\), whereas Q predominantly gives 1-nitropropane, \(\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH_2NO_2}\).
Statement III: The products must be identical because both reagents contain one nitrogen and two oxygen atoms per nitrite unit.
Statement IV: The difference illustrates why the bonding character and reagent identity of an ambident nucleophile must be considered when predicting substitution products.
Which combination is correct?
ⓐ. I, II and IV only
ⓑ. I and III only
ⓒ. II, III and IV only
ⓓ. I, II, III and IV
Correct Answer: I, II and IV only
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the ambident nitrite system:}\)
The nitrite group contains both nitrogen and oxygen atoms capable of participating in different bonding arrangements.
It is therefore important to identify which atom becomes attached directly to the alkyl carbon.
The complete molecular formula alone does not establish the connectivity of the substitution product.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the potassium-nitrite reaction:}\)
Potassium nitrite is an ionic nitrite reagent.
Under the specified characteristic conditions, reaction through oxygen predominates:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH_2Br+KNO_2
\rightarrow CH_3CH_2CH_2ONO+KBr}
\]
The organic product is propyl nitrite.
Its alkyl group is attached to oxygen, which is connected to nitrogen.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the silver-nitrite reaction:}\)
Silver nitrite favours the alternative nitrogen-linked substitution product:
\[
\mathrm{CH_3CH_2CH_2Br+AgNO_2
\rightarrow CH_3CH_2CH_2NO_2+AgBr}
\]
The product is 1-nitropropane.
Here, the alkyl carbon is bonded directly to nitrogen.
\(\textbf{Compare the molecular formulas:}\)
Both products contain three carbon atoms, seven hydrogen atoms, one nitrogen atom and two oxygen atoms.
Their common formula is:
\[
\mathrm{C_3H_7NO_2}
\]
However, the atom connectivity differs.
They are linkage isomers rather than identical compounds.
\(\textbf{Evaluate the four statements:}\)
Statement I is correct because equal molecular formulas can represent different attachment patterns.
Statement II correctly identifies the characteristic products of the stipulated reagent systems.
Statement III is incorrect because common elemental composition does not guarantee identical connectivity.
Statement IV is correct because ambident nucleophile reactions require reagent-sensitive product prediction.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
The distinction between alkyl nitrite and nitroalkane formation cannot be resolved by counting atoms alone.
Recognising the nucleophilic attachment site gives statements I, II and IV.
500. Two brominated starting compounds are considered for preparation of organomagnesium reagents:
P: 2-Bromoethan-1-ol, \(\mathrm{BrCH_2CH_2OH}\).
Q: 1-Bromo-2-methoxyethane, \(\mathrm{BrCH_2CH_2OCH_3}\).
Each is separately treated with magnesium in rigorously dry ether, followed by an attempted carboxylation using dry carbon dioxide.
Assume that, if a carbon–magnesium bond forms in P, the hydroxyl proton reacts rapidly with an organomagnesium centre before carbon dioxide is introduced.
In Q, assume ordinary magnesium insertion and carboxylation proceed without competing reactions.
Which assessment is correct?
ⓐ. P cannot provide a persistent ordinary Grignard reagent under the specified conditions because of its acidic hydroxyl proton; Q can give 3-methoxypropanoic acid after carboxylation and hydrolysis
ⓑ. P is more suitable because its free hydroxyl proton increases the amount of active Grignard reagent available for carbon dioxide attack
ⓒ. Both substrates give the same carboxylic acid because the hydroxyl group and methoxy group have identical reactivity towards organomagnesium reagents
ⓓ. Neither substrate can form an organomagnesium reagent because an ether oxygen always destroys carbon–magnesium bonds
Correct Answer: P cannot provide a persistent ordinary Grignard reagent under the specified conditions because of its acidic hydroxyl proton; Q can give 3-methoxypropanoic acid after carboxylation and hydrolysis
Explanation: \(\textbf{Identify the carbon–bromine reaction centres:}\)
Both substrates contain bromine attached to a terminal saturated carbon.
Under suitable anhydrous conditions, magnesium can insert into an appropriate carbon–bromine bond.
However, the other functional group present in each molecule must also be considered.
\(\textbf{Examine the hydroxyl group in P:}\)
P contains an O–H bond.
The hydroxyl proton can behave as an acidic proton towards a strongly basic organomagnesium reagent.
Thus, formation of a carbon–magnesium bond does not guarantee that the organomagnesium species will remain available for carbon dioxide attack.
\(\textbf{Follow the stipulated proton-transfer competition:}\)
The question specifies rapid reaction of the hydroxyl proton with an organomagnesium centre.
A generic reaction is:
\[
\mathrm{RMgBr+R'OH\rightarrow RH+R'OMgBr}
\]
The carbon–magnesium bond is consumed, and an alkoxide-containing magnesium species is formed.
This process prevents accumulation of the intended active Grignard reagent under the stated conditions.
\(\textbf{Examine the functional group in Q:}\)
Q contains a methoxy group rather than a free hydroxyl group.
Its oxygen is part of an ether linkage.
There is no O–H proton available for the corresponding rapid acid–base destruction of the organomagnesium centre.
\(\textbf{Form Q's organomagnesium reagent:}\)
\[
\mathrm{BrCH_2CH_2OCH_3+Mg
\xrightarrow{dry\ ether}
BrMgCH_2CH_2OCH_3}
\]
The reacting carbon remains at the end of the two-carbon fragment.
\(\textbf{Carboxylate and hydrolyse Q:}\)
\[
\mathrm{BrMgCH_2CH_2OCH_3
\xrightarrow[\ H_3O^+\ ]{CO_2}
HOOCCH_2CH_2OCH_3}
\]
The product is 3-methoxypropanoic acid.
The carboxyl carbon comes from carbon dioxide.
\(\textbf{Distinguish an ether from an alcohol:}\)
Both compounds contain oxygen.
Only P contains a free hydroxyl proton.
Therefore, the presence of oxygen itself is not the decisive incompatibility; the availability of an acidic proton is.
\(\textbf{Integrated conclusion:}\)
Anhydrous solvent alone cannot protect a Grignard reagent from reactive groups within the substrate.
The methoxy-substituted bromide is compatible with the stipulated preparation and carboxylation, whereas the unprotected bromohydrin is not.